HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-28-2022 TC Agenda PacketCity of San Luis Obispo, Agenda, Planning Commission
Agenda
TREE COMMITTEE
Regular Meeting Agenda
Monday, March 28, 2022
The City of San Luis Obispo has returned to in-person meetings. Zoom participation
will not be supported. For those attending in-person, City facilities will be at limited
capacity and masks are strongly recommended.
INSTRUCTIONS FOR PUBLIC COMMENT:
Public Comment prior to the meeting (must be received 3 hours in advance of
the meeting):
Mail - Delivered by the U.S. Postal Service. Address letters to the City
Clerk's Office at 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, California, 93401.
Email - Submit Public Comments via email to
advisorybodies@slocity.org. In the body of your email, please include the
date of the meeting and the item number (if applicable). Emails will not be
read aloud during the meeting.
Voicemail - Call (805) 781-7164 and leave a voicemail. Please state and
spell your name, the agenda item number you are calling about, and leave your
comment. Verbal comments must be limited to 3 minutes. All voicemails will
be forwarded to the members and saved as Agenda Correspondence.
Voicemails will not be played during the meeting.
*All correspondence will be archived and distributed to members, however,
submissions received after the deadline will not be processed until the following day.
Public Comment during the meeting:
Meetings have returned to an in-person format. To provide public
comment during the meeting, you must be present in the Council Hearing
Room. Zoom participation will not be supported. The Council Hearing Room
is in City Hall, 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo.
If you have questions, contact the City Clerk's Office at
cityclerk@slocity.org or (805) 781-7100.
Tree Committee Agenda for March 28, 2022 Page 2
5:30 PM REGULAR MEETING Council Hearing Room
990 Palm Street
San Luis Obispo
CALL TO ORDER: Chair Alan Bate
ROLL CALL : Committee Members Elizabeth Lucas, Emily Rosten, Sadie Weller, Vice
Chair Daniel Canella, and Chair Alan Bate (two vacant seats)
CONSIDERATION OF MINUTES
1.Minutes of the Tree Committee Meeting of February 28, 2022
PUBLIC COMMENT: At this time, people may address the Committee about items not on the
agenda. Comments are limited to three minutes per person. Items raised at this time are generally
referred to staff and, if action by the Committee is necessary, may be scheduled for a future
meeting.
NEW BUSINESS
2.New Business: 1911 & 1823 Johnson Ave. (ARCH-0161-2019, VAR-0499-2019, USE-0500-
2019, EID-0742-2021). Review of the proposed removal of 113 trees and replanting of 120
trees to facilitate the phased expansion of the French Hospital Medical Center campus that
includes the construction of a two-level 5,800-square-foot parking structure with a helistop
that has specific FAA requirements for flight paths, a four-story 89,775-square-foot patient
tower, and associated landscaping. (Cassidy Williams, Contract Planner)
Recommendation: Recommend the Planning Commission find the proposed tree removals
and compensatory planting plan as part of the French Hospital Expansion project consistent
with the Tree Regulations. The Tree Committee may provide recommended considerations or
condition(s) related to the tree removals and compensatory planting.
Tree Committee Agenda for March 28, 2022 Page 3
TREE REMOVAL APPEALS
Any person aggrieved by an act or determination of the authorized approving authority exercising
the authority herein granted shall have the right to appeal the decision of the authorized approving
authority as set forth in Section 12.24.180 of the City of San Luis Obispo Municipal Code. Appeals
received by the City Clerk within ten calendar days from the date of determination or act shall
cause the director to withhold tree removal permits and any permits for construction or demolition
actively relying on the subject tree removal until the appeal is heard and a decision is reached.
3.572 E. Foothill Blvd. Review an appeal of the City Arborist’s decision to deny removal of two
(2)Canary Island Pine trees (pinus canariensis).
4.3204 Flora St. Review an appeal of the City Arborist’s decision to deny removal of one (1)
Southern Magnolia tree (magnolia grandiflora).
COMMENT AND DISCUSSION
5.Arborists Report:
•Operations Update: Tree Inventory, WCA, Pruning, and Watering
ADJOURNMENT
The next Regular Meeting of the Tree Committee will be held on Monday, April 25 , 2022
at 5:30 p.m. in the Council Hearing Room at City Hall, 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo.
Please note that, with the return of in -person meetings, Zoom participation will no longer be
supported.
The City of San Luis Obispo wishes to make all of its public meetings accessible to the
public. Upon request, this agenda will be made available in appropriate alternative formats to
persons with disabilities. Any person with a disability who requires a modification or
accommodation in order to participate in a meeting should direct such request to the City Corp
Yard Office at (805) 781-7220 at least 48 hours before the meeting, if possible.
Telecommunications Device for the Deaf (805) 781-7410.
Meeting audio recordings can be found at the following web address:
http://opengov.slocity.org/WebLink/Browse.aspx?id=61087&dbid=0&repo=CityClerk
Minutes – Tree Committee Regular Meeting of February 28, 2022 Page 1
Minutes
TREE COMMITTEE
Monday, February 28, 2022
Regular Meeting of the Tree Committee
CALL TO ORDER
A Regular Meeting of the San Luis Obispo Tree Committee was called to order on Monday,
February 28, 2022 at 5:30 p.m. via teleconference, by Chair Alan Bate.
ROLL CALL
Present: Committee Members Elizabeth Lucas, Emily Rosten, Sadie Mae Weller, Vice
Chair Daniel Canella, and Chair Alan Bate (two vacant seats)
Absent: None
Staff: Anthony Whipple, Acting City Arborist and Teresa Purrington, City Clerk
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
1.Consideration of the Minutes of the Tree Committee Meeting of January 24, 2022
ACTION: UPON MOTION OF VICE CHAIR CANELLA SECONDED BY COMMITTEE
MEMBER ROSTEN, CARRIED 5-0-0 (with two vacant seats), the Tree Committee approved
the Minutes of January 24, 2022.
PUBLIC COMMENT ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS
None
--End of Public Comment--
NEW BUSINESS
2.New Business: 3490 Empresa Drive (ARCH-0516-2021). Review the proposed removal of 10
trees and replanting of 14 trees. Tree removals are proposed to facilitate a n office/warehouse
development consisting of 16,741 square feet of commercial space, with associated parking
and onsite landscaping. (Kyle Bell, Associate Planner)
Recommendation: Recommend the Planning Commission find the proposed tree removals and
compensatory planting plan as part of the 3490 Empresa Drive Development Project consistent
with the Tree Regulations. The Tree Committee may provide recommended considerations or
condition(s) related to the tree removals and compensatory planting.
Item 1
Packet Page 1
Minutes – Tree Committee Regular Meeting of February 28, 2022 Page 2
Associate Planner Kyle Bell provided a presentation and responded to questions from the
Committee.
PUBLIC COMMENT
None
--End of Public Comment--
The Applicant, Chris Hoover, provided an overview of the project and responded to questions
from the Committee.
ACTION: UPON MOTION OF VICE CHAIR CANELLA, SECONDED BY COMMITTEE
MEMBER LUCAS, CARRIED 4-1 (Chair Bate voting no, two vacant seats), the Tree
Committee recommends the Planning Commission approve the application for tree removal
with the requirement that at least 50% of the required replacement trees be native species
planted in 36-inch boxes, and the remainder planted in 15-inch boxes.
TREE REMOVAL APPEALS
3. 3150 Rockview Pl. Review an appeal of the City Arborist’s decision to approve removal of one
(1) Sweet Gum tree (liquidambar styraciflua).
Acting City Arborist Anthony Whipple provided a report on this decision.
PUBLIC COMMENT
None
--End of Public Comment--
ACTION: UPON MOTION OF VICE CHAIR CANELLA, SECONDED BY COMMITTEE
MEMBER ROSTEN, CARRIED 4-1 (Chair Bate voting No and two vacant seats), the Tree
Committee denied the appeal and uphold the City Arborist’s decision to approve the removal
of the tree.
4. 384 Santa Maria Ave. Review an appeal of the City Arborist’s decision to deny removal of one
(1) Eucalyptus tree (eucalyptus polyanthemos).
Acting City Arborist Anthony Whipple provided a report on this decision.
PUBLIC COMMENT
None
--End of Public Comment--
The Appellant, Leslie O’Connor, provided an overview of the appeal.
Item 1
Packet Page 2
Minutes – Tree Committee Regular Meeting of February 28, 2022 Page 3
ACTION: UPON MOTION OF COMMITTEE MEMBER LUCAS, SECONDED BY
COMMITTEE MEMBER ROSTEN, CARRIED 3 – 2 (with Member Weller and Chair Bate
voting No and two vacant seats), the Tree Committee approved the appeal for removal with a
three to one replacement with 24-inch box trees from the City’s Authorized Tree list.
5. 861 Pepper St. Review an appeal of the City Arborist’s decision to deny removal of one (1)
Aleppo pine tree (pinus halepensis).
Member Weller recused herself from this item as she lives within 500 feet of the property.
Acting City Arborist Anthony Whipple provided a report on this decision.
PUBLIC COMMENT
None
--End of Public Comment--
The Appellant, Patricia Kohlen, provided an overview of the appeal.
ACTION: UPON MOTION OF CHAIR BATE, SECONDED BY VICE CHAIR CANELLA,
CARRIED 4-0-1 (With Member Weller recused and two vacant seats), the Tree Committee
denied the appeal and uphold the City Arborist’s decision to deny removal.
6. 1010 E. Foothill Blvd. Continued review of an appeal of the City Arborist’s decision to deny
removal of one (1) Comphor tree (Cinnamomum camphora).
Acting City Arborist Anthony Whipple provided a report on this decision.
PUBLIC COMMENT
None
--End of Public Comment--
The Appellant, Bob Hill, provided an overview of the appeal.
ACTION: UPON MOTION OF VICE CHAIR CANELLA, SECONDED BY COMMITTEE
MEMBER LUCAS CARRIED 5-0 (with two vacant seats), the Tree Committee approved the
appeal with the replanting plan submitted with the additional condition that two of the trees be
a larger species (24-inch box with a minimum mature height of 20 feet.)
COMMENT AND DISCUSSION
7. Arborists Report:
• Operations update: WCA Inventory, Stump grinding and Planting.
Item 1
Packet Page 3
Minutes – Tree Committee Regular Meeting of February 28, 2022 Page 4
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 7:16 p.m. The next Regular Meeting of the Tree Committee will
be held on Monday, March 28 , 2022 at 5:30 p.m . in the Council Hearing Room at City Hall,
990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo .
APPROVED BY THE TREE COMMITTEE: XX/XX/2022
Item 1
Packet Page 4
TREE COMMITTEE AGENDA REPORT
SUBJECT: Review of the proposed removal of 113 trees and replanting of 120 trees to facilitate the phased
expansion of the French Hospital Medical Center campus that includes the construction of a two-level
5,800-square-foot parking structure with a helistop that has specific FAA requirements for flight paths, a
four-story 89,775-square-foot patient tower, and associated landscaping.
PROJECT ADDRESS: 1911 & 1823 Johnson Ave. BY: Cassidy Williams, Contract Planner
Phone Number: (805) 539-2867
Email: cassidy.williams@swca.com
FILE NUMBER: ARCH-0161-2019; FROM: Anthony Whipple, City Arborist
USE-0500-2019; VAR-0499-2019; &
ER # 0742-2021
RECOMMENDATION: Recommend the Planning Commission find the proposed tree removals and
compensatory planting plan as part of the French Hospital Expansion project consistent with the Tree
Regulations. The Tree Committee may provide recommended considerations or condition(s) related to
the tree removals and compensatory planting.
SITE DATA
Applicant Dignity Health Corporation
Representative Ariana Melendez, SDG Architects
Zoning Office (O)
General Plan Office
Site Area 18 acres
Environmental
Status
An Initial Study (IS) has been prepared
in accordance with the California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) to
evaluate the potential environmental
effects of the proposed project. A
proposed Mitigated Negative
Declaration (MND) has been drafted
and is being circulated for public
review.
Meeting Date: March 28, 2022
Item Number: 2
Figure 1: Subject Property
Packet Page 5
ARCH-0161-2019; USE-0500-2019; VAR-0499-2019; & ER # 0742-2021
Page 2
SUMMARY
The project consists of the phased expansion of the French Hospital Medical Center campus, including the
construction of a two-level 5,800-square-foot parking structure with a helistop that has specific FAA
requirements for flight paths, a four-story 89,775-square-foot patient tower, and associated landscaping. The
project proposes to remove 113 existing trees and replace with 120 trees (see Attachment 1).
An Initial Study (IS) has been prepared in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act
(CEQA) to evaluate the potential environmental effects of the proposed project. A proposed Mitigated
Negative Declaration (MND) is being circulated for public review.
1.0 COMMITTEE PURVIEW
The Tree Committee’s role is to review the project and provide a recommendation to the Planning
Commission regarding consistency with the policies and standards set forth in San Luis Obispo Municipal
Code (SLOMC) Section 12.24 (Tree Regulations).
2.0 PROJECT INFORMATION
The proposed project consists of the phased expansion of French Hospital Medical Center campus including
the construction of a two-level, 234-space parking structure with 5,800 square feet of future lab and storage
space, and a 2,000-square-foot helistop (Phase 1), and a four-story 89,775-square-foot patient tower, a
1,800-square-foot generator yard, and various related site improvements (Phase 2). The project would
require removal of landscaped trees currently located within the proposed footprint of the patient tower,
parking deck, generator yard, and realigned site driveway. In addition, a number of tall trees within the
immediate project vicinity would need to be trimmed to meet Federal Aviation Association (FAA) standards
to accommodate the flightpath of helicopters using the proposed helistop. Overall, the project would result
in the removal of 113 trees and the trimming of eight eucalyptus trees (see Figure 2).
Trees proposed for full removal include one manna gum (Eucalyptus viminalis), one red flowering gum
(Eucalyptus ficifolia), five California pepper (Schinus molle), one jacaranda (Jacaranda mimosifolia), three
ash (Fraxinus ssp.), one coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia), 12 camphor (Cinnamomum camphora), 12
Brisbane box (Lophostemon confertus), 26 London plane (Platanus hispanica), seven purple leaf plum
(Prunus cerasifera), and eight southern blue gum (Eucalyptus globulus). Trees that would be cut to the
ground include four silver dollar eucalyptus (Eucalyptus cinerea), 20 coast live oak, and four mimosa
(Albizia julibrissin). Trees that would be pruned would include two California pepper, and six southern blue
gum.
Packet Page 6
ARCH-0161-2019; USE-0500-2019; VAR-0499-2019; & ER # 0742-2021
Page 3
Figure 2: Tree Impact Map
Packet Page 7
ARCH-0161-2019; USE-0500-2019; VAR-0499-2019; & ER # 0742-2021
Page 4
Two Arborist Reports were prepared by the same arborist to evaluate the proposed removal of the blue gum
eucalyptus trees due to their potential to conflict with the proposed helicopter flight path located north and
west of the French Hospital Medical Center parking lot near the modular office on-site (Attachment 4,
Attachment 7). The arborist concluded that the trees are in poor health and recommended they be removed
to meet FAA requirements.
An Arborist Report was prepared to evaluate the trees located within the footprint of the proposed patient
tower (Attachment 9). The arborist concluded that these trees are generally in good health and the project
would trigger the need for their removal based on their location within the direct footprint of the patient
tower or its appurtenances (utilities, walkways, reconfigured parking areas, etc.).
An Arborist Report was prepared to evaluate the trees located within the footprint of the parking structure
(Attachment 10). The arborist concluded that trees in this area ranged from healthy to poor and most occur
within the direct footprint of the proposed parking structure or its appurtenances (walkways, utilities, etc.).
Parking areas outside of the structure are proposed for modifications and repaving that would affect trees as
well. Existing oaks beyond the construction footprint would be protected and maintained.
An Arborist Report was prepared to evaluate trees located within the footprint of the reconfigured parking
lot (Attachment 11). The arborist concluded that trees in this area ranged from healthy to poor and the project
would trigger the need for their removal based on their location within areas proposed to be repaved and
reconfigured, including construction of new walkways.
The project includes a landscaping planting plan that includes screening trees, parking lot trees, pedestrian
plaza trees, shrubs, vines, perennials, and groundcover plantings. The planting plan includes planting of new
ornamental trees adjacent to the patient tower and around the garden areas. Parking lot shading would be
maximized with the new tree plantings and areas around the on-site Open Space Easement would include
planted native oak trees. Overall, the proposed planting plan would include the planting of 53 trees of species
native to California and 67 trees of non-native species, for a total of 120 trees (see Attachment 1 and
Attachment 6). Proposed tree plantings would mostly be 24-inch box in size with the Coast Live Oak,
Golenrain Tree, and Chinese Pistache trees species being 15 gallon in size. The proposed irrigation system
would be designed for maximum water efficiency and include an automatic timer, backflow prevention
device, and low gallonage heads for turf and large ground cover areas. A drip-type system would be used
where appropriate. Trees would be irrigated on separate bubbler systems.
3.0 TREE REGULATIONS
The City’s Tree Ordinance (Municipal Code Chapter 12.24) was adopted in April of 2010 (Ordinance 1544)
recently updated in 2019 with the purpose of establishing a comprehensive program for installing,
maintaining, and preserving trees within the city. This chapter establishes policies, regulations, and
specifications necessary to govern installation, maintenance, removal, and preservation of trees to beautify
the city; to purify the air; to provide shade and wind protection; to add environmental and economic value;
and to preserve trees with historic or unusual value.
Criteria for Construction-Related Tree Removal Recommendation. Recommendations and determinations
of the tree committee regarding any tree removal requests shall be based on the following criteria:
Packet Page 8
ARCH-0161-2019; USE-0500-2019; VAR-0499-2019; & ER # 0742-2021
Page 5
• Size of Trees. Proposed trees to be removed range between 3- and 72-inches diameter at breast
height (dbh). Most trees have a dbh between 6 and 18 inches.
• Location of Trees on Private Property. The project would require removal of landscaped trees
currently located within the proposed footprint of the patient tower, parking deck, generator yard,
and realigned site driveway. In addition, a number of tall trees within the immediate project vicinity
would need to be trimmed to meet FAA standards to accommodate the flightpath of helicopters
using the proposed helistop. Some of the proposed eucalyptus tree trimming that would be necessary
to meet FAA standards to accommodate the flightpath of helicopters using the proposed helistop
would be located on privately-owned parcels adjacent to the hospital property. If access to off-site
trees is not secured, an alternative has been developed that would include installation of light
obstruction poles instead of tree trimming in accordance with FAA requirements.
• Species of Tree. Trees proposed for full removal include manna gum (1), red flowering gum (1),
California pepper (5), jacaranda (1), ash (3), coast live oak (1), camphor (12), Brisbane box (12),
London plane (26), purple leaf plum (7), and southern blue gum (8). Trees that would be cut to the
ground include silver dollar eucalyptus (4), coast live oak (20), and mimosa (4). Trees that would
be pruned would include California pepper (2), and southern blue gum (6) (see Figure 1 and
Attachment 12). In addition, a total of eight southern blue gum trees located within the approved
helicopter flight path(s) would be trimmed per FAA requirements.
• Forestry Best Practice. The project would replace trees that are removed with trees that are suitable
for the site. Replanting of trees would increase the number of native trees within the project site.
Additionally, Mitigated Negative Declaration Mitigation Measure BIO-10 requires in-kind
plantings for every native tree proposed for removal and establishment of success criteria for
replanted trees, including a monitoring and reporting schedule over a 5-year period to ensure the
success of native tree plantings.
• Public Right-of-Way Obstruction or Displacement. No street trees are proposed for removal.
• Compliance Regarding Compensatory Plantings. The applicant is proposing to provide
compensatory plantings in accordance with the City’s Tree Ordinance Standards for tree removal.
Mitigated Negative Declaration Mitigation Measure BIO-10 would ensure in-kind replacement
plantings for every native tree proposed for removal at a 1:1 ratio for on-site plantings and 2:1 ratio
for off-site plantings as applicable.
• Heritage Trees. None of the trees proposed for removal have been designated as Heritage Trees.
4.0 ATTACHMENTS
1. Landscape Plan – Sheets L101 to L104, Oasis Landscape Architecture and Planning, June 25,
2020
2. Flightpath Obstructions, Studio Design Group Architects, Inc., July 6, 2020
3. Long Term Tree Removal/Replacement Plan, Oasis Landscape Architecture and Planning,
September 8, 2020
4. Arborist Report – French Hospital rear parking area, north and west of parking, near modular
area, Greenvale Tree Company, October 28, 2020
Packet Page 9
ARCH-0161-2019; USE-0500-2019; VAR-0499-2019; & ER # 0742-2021
Page 6
5. Arborist Report – French Hospital area beyond chain link fence southwest side of property
beyond rear parking, Greenvale Tree Company, October 28, 2020
6. Tree Removals and Replacements Comparison Table, March 30, 2021
7. Arborist Assessment of Trees – FAA Transitional Air Space North, Greenvale Tree Company,
January 17, 2022
8. Arborist Assessment of Trees – FAA Transitional Air Space South, Greenvale Tree Company,
January 17, 2022
9. Arborist Assessment of Trees – Proposed Patient Tower, Greenvale Tree Company, January 17,
2022
10. Arborist Assessment of Trees – Proposed Parking Structure, Greenvale Tree Company, January
17, 2022
11. Arborist Assessment of Trees – Proposed Reconfigured Parking Lot, Greenvale Tree Company,
January 17, 2022
12. Tree Inventory, Removal and Modification Plan, Oasis Landscape Architecture and Planning,
January 20, 2022
Packet Page 10
#$$%#% $ '&!##&&!##!# !!# !!#!# !!!#!#!!#!#! $ $ $ !# !# !# !# !!!!! $%#&$%#&%%%$%#&%#&%%%&#%&#%&#%&#- () # $(% )!- () # "' #.%)-- () # $%!# !) *) $#%+ ! $#- ()- ()- () () # # '('( '( ( #)#) )!!- ()- ()- ()- ( # # # '( '( #) #) #) !!!$%$%#$%#$%(%(%(%(%("("("("#)#)#)$%#$%#$%#$%#(%(%("("("("#)#)#)#)!# ! $!% %% (## # !# !# !# %%#'() %$!#(% "%'$+"#)('$*#"$ ' +,.!.$*)#'() %$!#(% "%'$+"#)('$*#"$ %' # !$)%!#)'(!# ! $!% %% (#'' +!$*')#%) #)'$%$(( )!
!# ! $!# #!$%# ! *(( )!
## ###############% #% # # #% #% #% # #% % % % %%#%% % #% #% % # (%# $#'% $%% %)742>=24?CD0;;0=3B20?4?;0=2>=2DAA4=CF8C7C74?;0=C8=60=38AA860C8>=2>=BCAD2C8>=3>2D<4=CB?;0=8=BC0;;0C8>=A4;0C43B?4285820C8>=B0=3=>C4B@D0;8584BC78B?A>942C0B>=4F78274<1A024BC745>;;>F8=62DAA4=CF0C4A2>=B4AE0C8>=C427=>;>6H0=3<4C7>3>;>684B
*C8;8I0C8>=>5BC0C4>5C740AC8AA860C8>=2>=CA>;;4AB0;;>F8=65>A?A428B8>=8=2A4<4=C0;F0C4AB2743D;8=68=0;;7H3A>I>=4B *B4>53A8?CH?40=3>A<82A>B?A0HBHBC4<B>=;H =C46A0C43?;0=C34B86=%;0=C?0;4CC4B70E4144=5>A<43C>A45;42C?0A0;;4;F0C4A8=6A4@D8A4<4=CBF8C78=40277H3A>I>=46A>D?
%;0=CB8=BC0;;43F8C7<>8BCDA4A4C4=C8E4B>8;0<4=3<4=CB4=01;8=6BCA>=6A>>C0=3?;0=C6A>FC7F8C7C74DB4>5;4BBF0C4A J44?<D;278=6>50;;?;0=C10B8=B0=3?;0=C8=60A40B8=7818C8=64E0?>A0C8>=*B4>5;>FF0C4ADB4?;0=CBE4A6A44=0=334283D>DB?;0=CB<>BCA4@D8A8=6;>FF0C4ADB470E4144=B?4285820;;HB4;42C430=3DB43A4;0C8E4C>C745D=2C8>=BC74HF8;;?A>E834)74?A>?4A?;024<4=C>5?;0=C8=6BF8;;>554A?0BB8E4B>;0A0224BBF8=3345;42C8>=0=3B2A44=8=6C7A>D67>DCC74B40B>=B)74?;0=C8=634B86=2><?;8<4=CBC74B8C4LB0A278C42CDA4F8C7A4B?42CC>B20;4C4GCDA4B0=32>;>A !% %$
%;0=C<0C4A80;F0B27>B4=5>A8CB2><?0C018;8CHF8C7C74<02A><82A>2;8<0C822>=38C8>=B>5C74A468>=0=3B8C4C>;4A0=24>5F8=3C>;4A0=24>53A>D67C2>=38C8>=B;>=64E8CHB2A44=8=620?018;8C84B0=3>E4A0;;0CCA02C8E4=4BB AA860C8>=BHBC4<B70;;1434B86=435>A<0G8<D<F0C4A4558284=2H0=3B70;;8=2;D340=0DC><0C822>=CA>;;4A102:5;>F?A4E4=C8>=34E8240=3;>F60;;>=0647403B5>ACDA50=3;0A646A>D=32>E4A0A40B3A8?CH?4BHBC4<B70;;14DB43F74A40??A>?A80C4)A44BB70;;148AA860C43>=B4?0A0C41D11;4ABHBC4<B %;0=C<0C4A80;@D0=C8C84B=0AA0C8E4B?4285820C8>=BB8C434C08;B0=3<0C4A80;3458=8C8>=BF8;;1434C4A<8=430=3=>C43>=C742>=BCAD2C8>=3A0F8=6B
><?;4C4CA44?A>C42C8>==>C4BF8;;14?A>E8343>=C74>=BCAD2C8>=>2D<4=CB!# ! $#'() %$! % $%$# %#$ *(" '$'% # #!*'!
J$-" % #*(#' #( (#'. (!#% #
J$-!
" #$! '# !$'($*) '#" #$!
J$-"!# %%#$ $!'*)' %# *!) $!#' #)'
!"
% () ##( ( #(% ()
!!
%.'*(!!'.#K'$'L'$'%'
J$-"
'*)*(K"' #L"' #()',''.)'
J$-!$#&$' $!# $!" '$() (M*)K '!$'()'L' '(( !"# "'$!! (K()'*'()'L.! !. !" !$'$%)!*"'*'*"K #(%*'%!!L' # !$,' !!## #$"() +#!."$$ !!
(!!$# --$# #( (K'(L% # (!!$# !" ".' ! $'# ! $'# ,-".')! !" % $'" *")#-K ' 'L#,/!#!-- !! % ))$(%$'*")#* $! *"K( !+'( #L $ * * !"%!*" $*' *!)%%!*" $ !! ' % $!% ( # K +#(L% # # ,) $'# !!
# & '#$%'$(" ' ' L($%'$("
!!
'$("' #*($ #! (K%'$()')L)' ! # '$("'.
!!($!!. )'$% .!!*()'! #!*!!(
!! )' !$(%'"*" (" #$ (()' (" #
!",*$!(,)'*(!(( ) $#($!#(%(% ( ( * )$ !% #) . '' ) $#,)'#($%!#)(% (+!$%.) *# +'( ).$! $'# $$%') +-)#( $#! $'# %')"#)$,)''($*'( $%!($ '#%!#)!!' .(! (# #-$%!#)') # ($#
)$
(!($#!!' #'!))$'(') # $
'%'(#)() "$()!!' .'(!) $#(#') # $
#$)(%!#)() )*() "$()!!' (('(*!)$ # !#)%$!!#$$'#$'$#))$* (& $ ! $(!
J
L # # !#(%'"$!#-%#( $#'$*#%'$%$( %! ) $#(%')(*" ))! !"#$ Attachment #1Item 2Packet Page 11
) %
# #%+ # )+ *!''' +!$*') # #%+ # )%()' #%!/' %()' #'"%, ) #' !(
'#() '(, ) #' !()''%!#)'(#$)*(#,+' '#('# # )'(#$)*(#$)*(
# ).%
#$)*(
- () # "*!) %*'%$()' !
#,)'%!#) # ).%
- () # )'()$'" #
#$)*(
' &).
)$)!(%(%'$+
)!)$%().!'$((,!
- () # !#(%)$'" #
L)!! '#('#)'!! (, ) +' '#+ #(!# !# !# !# !# ! $ $ $ $ !# !# !# !# # $$$$%$%#&$%#&$%#&$%#&$$$$%&#%&#%&#%&#%&!# ! $!% %% (((((# #% #%#% %#####
!# # '# $!! (!
J L!# ! $! % $%$# %#$% #*(#' #( (#'. (!#% #
J$-!
" #$! '# !$'($*) '#" #$!
J$-"&*'*( ' $! $()! +$
!!!# %%#$ $!'*)' %# *!) $!#' #)'
!"
% () ##( ( #(% ()
!!
%.'*(!!'.#K'$'L'$'%'
J$-"
!$%# ! *%#$'*)*(K"' #L"' #()',''.)'
J$-! '%!")*" %#("%!
J$-"! '()'$" # '%".')!
J$-!$#&$' $!# $# $/#) $((%( # '$$%, !! !" '$() (M*)K '!$'()'L' '(( !"#$'.! #K)$'.//!'L '((%!" !! #!!)("# K+' )L+' )!-! !. !"# *(%*" !'% # !! "'$!! (K()'*'()'L.! !. !" # % $ *+' ' $)%$ ' !!
!*#'$#K(' (*#()L$#*( !!
!$'$%)!*"'*'*"K #(%*'%!!L' # !$,' !!## #$"() +#!."$$ !!
(!!$# --$# #( (K'(L% # (!!$# !" ".' ! $'# ! $'# ,-".')! !" % $'" *")#-K ' 'L#,/!#!-- !! % ))$(%$'*")#* $! *"K( !+'( #L $ * * !"%!*" $*' *!)%%!*" $ !! '$(K!$,''%)L!$,''%)'$( !"' % $!% ( # K +#(L% # # ,) $'# !!
# & '#$%'$(" ' ' L($%'$("
!!
'$("' #*($ #! (K%'$()')L)' ! # '$("'.
!!($!!. )'$% .!!*()'! #!*!!(
!! )' !$(%'"*" (" #$ (()' (" #
!",*$!(,)'*(!(( ) $#($!#(%(% ( ( * )$ !% #) . '' ) $#,)'#($%!#)(% (+!$%.) *# +'( ).$! $'# $$%') +-)#( $#! $'# %')"#)$,)''($*'( $%!($ '#%!#)!!' .(! (# #-$%!#)') # ($#
)$
(!($#!!' #'!))$'(') # $
'%'(#)() "$()!!' .'(!) $#(#') # $
#$)(%!#)() )*() "$()!!' (('(*!)$ # !#)%$!!#$$'#$'$#))$* (& $ ! $ !"#$%&'() "#$%! !!!!!$%#$%#%#$%#$%# ! ! ! * * * *((((#!#!#!#!#!' "' "' "' " "#)#)#)#)( ( ( ( ( )!) !)!
Attachment #1Item 2Packet Page 12
) %
# #$#')%+ # $') +%+'()() # ' (!$#) #' '*!) # ,)')*'
)'*#)$"(!#(%%$)().%# ).%)!() # ).%- () # "*!) %*'%$()' !#,)'%!#) # ).%
' &).
)$)!(%(%'$+
)!)$%().!'$((,!
J)!!$#')(),!!
%()' #'"%, ) #' !(
'#() '(!# !!# !!# !!# !!# !!# !!!# $!# $%#&%&#%&#%&#%&#%&#%&#%!# ! $!% %% (#
(!
J
L
- () # $%!# !) *) $#%+ ! $#Attachment #1Item 2Packet Page 13
Attachment #1Item 2Packet Page 14
7/6/20FHMC Parking Structure 3.8.vwxFLIGHTPATH OBSTRUCTIONSFRENCH HOSPITAL MEDICAL CENTER04080275280276277278279281281281275280273274276
277278279281
26265280261262263264266277278279281282283283283255260265270256257258259261262263264266267268269271272273XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX380.91CANOPY1008369.161009369.24CANOPY1010CANOPY1027372.47CANOPY1028372.65CANOPY1029370.28CANOPY1041386.37CANOPY1043388.49CANOPY1044382.42CANOPY381.91CANOPY1007CANOPY369.24379.76372.47CANOPY372.65CANOPY370.28CANOPY386.37CANOPY1042380.06CANOPY388.49CANOPY382.42CANOPY1045381.91CANOPY1044365.64CANOPY10" TREE10" TREE14" TREE12" TREE10" TREE10" TREE10" TREE8" TREE8" TREE6" OAK TREE8" TREE8" TREE6" TREE4" TREE2" TREE8" TREE8" TREE4" TREE8" OAK TREE6" OAK TREE3-4" TREES6" OAK TREE4" OAK TREE2" OAK TREE4-2" TREE3-4" TREE18" TREE4" TREE8" TREERAILBOLLARDBOLLARD3" OAK TREE4" TREE6" TREE6" TREE4" TREE4" TREED.I.TOP TREE365.7910491N52°58'00"E 166.00N37°02'00"W 199.60N36°22'09"W 230.0551.03N53°05'00"E
N52°58'00"E 289.60
N 52°58'00" E
50.74
D=64°37'22"R=20.00L=22.56D=178°12'04"R=50.00L=155.5113.1548.6063.95213.45 D=64°37'22"R=20.00L=22.56D=178°12'04"R=50.00L=155.5113.15275280276277278279281281281275280273274276
277278279281
26265280261262263264266277278279281282283283283255260265270256257258259261262263264266267268269271272273XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX380.91CANOPY1008369.161009369.24CANOPY1010CANOPY1027372.47CANOPY1028372.65CANOPY1029370.28CANOPY1041386.37CANOPY1043388.49CANOPY1044382.42CANOPY381.91CANOPY1007CANOPY369.24379.76372.47CANOPY372.65CANOPY370.28CANOPY386.37CANOPY1042380.06CANOPY388.49CANOPY382.42CANOPY1045381.91CANOPY1044365.64CANOPY10" TREE10" TREE14" TREE12" TREE10" TREE10" TREE10" TREE8" TREE8" TREE6" OAK TREE8" TREE8" TREE6" TREE4" TREE2" TREE8" TREE8" TREE4" TREE8" OAK TREE6" OAK TREE3-4" TREES6" OAK TREE4" OAK TREE2" OAK TREE4-2" TREE3-4" TREE18" TREE4" TREE8" TREERAILBOLLARDBOLLARD3" OAK TREE4" TREE6" TREE6" TREE4" TREE4" TREED.I.TOP TREE365.791049127502762772782792812812827552802273327427622
2777278827992811 2800277278882792811282283328328310" TREE0" TREEREE4" TREE4" TREEREEEEEE6" TREEEEE6" TREEE4"4 TREEEEE4" TREEEEED.I.N36°22'09"W222222222200WWNNNNNN33666°""WWW2820011 230223022222223300.055N52°58'00"E
EEEE 2
E6366.951313.15.1527272755500282282000000000272727666666662727277777777272727888882727279992828281112828281112828281001111222752755575527572722275275275575275272280228028022282828288080808000282828808027327327333344444474444444447474747444747427427427422227427422222727774742227277474427627627666276276222727272727676767666666622727276767666
277277277222772772727277777727277727827827888888787878787878222782727272787878272787827927927999272727222272992812812812828288811282881 22280280222888880800028022802802228880022227727277277222222777777777777222772772772777222272777777777722227272787878888222727782722277878787788222222222722227777778882279279777799992792792792222279922227779799992281281888881128128128122888122228228222288828228228228222228822228328322222888383332832832832222883328322832832222832833832822832832828838328328328283283283283333328328328283310"11010""10"10"10"1 TREETREETREE0"10"10"1011010101 TREETREETREETREETREETREEEEEEEEEEEETREEE4"44"4"4444"444 TREETREETREETTTT4"""44"4"""444444444"444 TRTRETREREERTREEREERERTRRTREEEEEEEEEEERETRTREEEEEE6"66"6"666666666666 TRETREETREEEEE66 REEREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE66 E666"6"6"6 TREETTREETREETTETTE4444"44"4"444444444 TREETREETREEREEEEEREEE4"4"4" TREETREETREEEEEEEEDDD.I.I.I...273XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXE8"8 TREE8" TREE273273273222727737333273273273227733XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXEEEREEREEEE888888888"8"8"88 TREETREETREE8"8"8"TREEETREETREEEEXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX88 TRTREERRRAILLBOLLARDOOBBBBOBLLARDLLBBD=178D=178R=50R=50L=15L=15XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX8"8"8"888TTTTTTTTTTTTRETRETRETTTRTEEREEREEREREREREEEEREEREERRREEREERERREREERAILRAILRAILLLBOBOLBOLOBBLOLOLBOLBOLLLARDLOLLARDOLLARDLLOLOLLOLBOLOLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBOOOBOBOBBBOBOBOBOBOBOOOOOOOBBLOBOLBOLOOOOBOBOBOBOBBOBOBBBBBBBBBBOBOBOOOOOOOBOBOLLOLLOLLOLLOLLLLARDLOLLARDOLLARDOLLLOLLOLBOBEEE2"OAKREREEEREEREETREREREEREREREREREREREREEEEEEEEEEKXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX222"2X TREE3.45.45 XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX222222222222XXXXX2"2"2"XX222222XXXX22XXX TRETREETREE88888888888" TR1181818"8"8"118"8"1818 TTRTRRETRETRTRTTRTRTRTTTTRETRETRTRETTRTTTRTRTRTRTTRETRTR4-2" TREEEE3-4" TREEREEE44444-4-2"4-2"4-2"4-24-4 TREETREETREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE33-3-33-3-3-43-4"3-4"3-4"3-43-43- TTTRTRTTTRTRTREETREETREEETRTREREEREEEEEEEEREREREREEEEEEREREREREREEREEREEREEREEREERRERERE78°12'04"78°12'04"5050.00.00155155.51.51114" T12111 TREE101 TR289.6066666
21321333333333
111114"114"14"11 TTTT11111112"12"12"1111121TREETREETREETTTT0"10"10"1010101101TRTRETREREE101 TREE101TREE88 TREE8" TR6"6 OEETREEREE10"10"10"11TREETREETREETR10"10"10"10001TREETREETREETTTT8"8"8"888TREETREETREE8"88"8"888 TRETRETRE6"66"6"6666666666"6"66"666 OAOAOA5XXREEOAKTREEK8" TREEE88 TTREERRT555XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXEETREEREEAKOAKOAKTREEKTREETREEKKK8"8"8"888888888888 TREEETREETREEEEEEEE888888888""8"8"8"88888"8TTRTRTTTTTTRTTRTTTTTTRTRRTRTRRRTRTRETRERRTRTTRRERERREEEERREEREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERRREREREREREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERRRERERETRRRTR51.035'00"EEEEN53°053333333333333 005555555555
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXEEE2626526226222632326222644526662552256XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX380330.91991CANOPYANCCOOPYCANOPY10100CANOPYAO10272372.47CANOPYCN1028880372.65.CANOPYOOC102937077.28CANOPYCNAC104333388888.49CANOPYON104443823.42CANOPYNANAC3813.91CANOPYC1007773797.763333.4.4.C333333.6.....YC037037078.28.28Y10422380.06CANOPYNYY8838838889.49.49YY333.4..10451811911C""EEXXE8" OAKATREERXX6" OAKOTREERREK4" OAN52°58'00"ENNNNNNNN088885500EEEEENNNNNNNN55NNNN55555225°222 552°8°0888888800000000'''''0000000000000000000000000000 E00000EE5555 16611.000000N37°02'00"W0000000°°°7°77333NNNNNWW 199999999999.606.660060.6606000000NN 52°58'00"52°58
0
0
EE
500.74..7777444
001044365.64CANOPY22626262626262626262626262626262262626262222226526526526656555526552652652226262652656565656565656565555222626262656565656555561261261266662226262626262626262626262626222262622622226226222626622222622622222626262263326326322626263263363262262626226263632626262663333262262262262262262262264626426446565665626662662662662666666262626666255255255222222222225222225555555555555256622562566656565656565655552525252225625625665656552525252522222222522522222222XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXEEXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX3838383333333383803803338080808080808088080808080803333338080808080.999.9.999999919111111111111999991111CCCCCCCCCACACACAANANAAAACANNANOANOOONONONONONNOONOPNOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPYYYOPYOPYPYYYYYYYYYYANANACCCONONONPPOPOPOPYYYYYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPY1010100100010101010001011010001010CACACACACAANOCANOCANOCACAOPYOYYNOPYNOPYNOOOOYYYYYYYYCACANOOYYYYY1102102101002022202702702710101020227333333333337773777772722727222227.47.474.47.47.47.47CACACACACACAYNOPYNOPYNYYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYNYYYYYYYYYYYYYCAANYYP1028102810281010101088028028882880280280202008881111101082802802013373737373737333333333372272722273............665656565656565.6.CANOCANOOONNNNCANOCANOCANOCANOOOOOOOOOOOOONONNNNONONNNNNNNYYOPYPYOYYOPYOPYOPYOPYYYYYOOONN102910291029933370370370370777.2...28.28.28.28CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCAAANANANANANANANANANANYNOPYNOPYYYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYANCNAAACA1110431043333343434343043430404111043104310433333343433343430404101038383838888888888888888888888888999999.49.49.49.49999999999999CCCCANOCANOCCCCCANOCANOCANOCANOCCANOPCANOPOPOPOPOPPYYPYYYYPPOPOONOCC104410441044444444443823338238233333823823823823333333333333333333333333333333333333.42.42.42.42.42.424442CANCANANANCANCANCANCANNYYNOPYNOPYNYYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYNYN381381333813813813813333333331331.91.911.91.91.91.9199..CCCANOCANOCCCANOCANOCANOCANOCCYYPYPYYYPPPYPYPYPYYYPPCCYPO1111111110010010011010100000000000000000000000000007007000000000000070707070707707077777707077777777111010101010000000000000000070707070707077373793797937979379379773797.76.76.76767676767763773737772222222222372222222222222373737377777372372372372372372372333333337272727777222222237372222222222222222333333727222237373737373737373737373747774747777777747474747.47.47.47.47.47.47.47CCCCCCCCCCCCCANCCCCACACCOOOOCANNNOOOOPPYYCOPYOPYOPOPNNNONNNOOOOOOOOOPPPPPYPYPYPYYYYYYYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCCCCCCCCACACACACACACAANANANANANANANNNNNNNNNONNNNNNPPPPPPPPYPYPYPYPYPYPYYYYYYYYNONONONONONONOOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPYOPOPOPOPOPOPPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYCACACACACACACACACACACACCCACAANANNNNONOOPPPYPYYYCNONOOPOPOPOPPYPYPYPYYYAAANANYY37222372372222222222373737373737373737373737373737373737333333322222222222223723723723723723723723723723723722222222222222227272727272727272727272727272222722727272727373737373737373737373366655555656555555665.......555555555556.65.65.6565.65.6565666666566656565656565656565656555555555555555555656565655555656565656565655555555666565656555.6...CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCACCCACACCCCANOOANONOOOPYPYPYOPONONNNNNANAACCANCANCANCANCANCANCANNNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANAAAAAAACACACACACACACACACACACACACACACACCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCANOPYCANOCANOCANOYOPPCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYYYYYYYYYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPPPPPPPOPOPOPYOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOOOOOOOONONONOONONONONONONONONNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNANNNNNNNANACACAOOOOOOOOOOOOOONONONONONNNNNNNNNNNNPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYYPYYPYPYPPOPOPOPOPOPOPOONOONONONNNNNNNANANANANAAOOOOOONONONONNNNNANANANANANAACACACACACACACCCCC3700000037037033333703703703703703703703703703703707707070707070707070707070707077770707070002888888.28.28.2...28282828.28.28.28.28.28.28.28CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCANOPYAANOPYANOPYACCCCCCCCACACCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCACACACACACACAYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCCCCCCCCCCCAACANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCACACACACACACACACACACACACACAANAANAAAACACACACACACACACANANANANANANANCCCACAAACCCCCCCACACACCACCCACACANCANCCCACACACACCCACA111010421042424204204204040404000420420421142042040403338383838333803803800000003838080.06.06.06CCCANCANNCACACCCANOPYYYCANOPYCANOPYYYOPYOPYOPOPYYNOANCACACYOPYOPYY333333338833333338338838838838838838838888888888838838888883888888388388388388388388388383838388383888888888888888888388388383833.....................4444944..4.49.49.49.49.49.49.49999999949494949494949.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.......494944494949494.49494949494949994949.4.44CANOCANOCANOPYPPOPYPYPPOPPYOOCCCCCCOPYOPYOPYOPYOOCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYPNONONONONONONOANANANANANANANCACACACACACACACACCCCCCCCCCCCCCANOCANOCANOCANOCANCANCANCANCANCANCANPPPOOOOOOOONONOANANCANCACACCC3822382382333322222222238238238238238238238238238238238222222238238238238238238238282828282828282828282828282823838383838383838383333333333333333333333333333333282828282828238838383838383833333333333334224242222222222222222222.42.42.42.42.42.42.4222222224242424242424242424242424242424242424242424242424244444444444444422242424242424242424242422242424242424242424444422CCCCCCCCCCCCCACCCACACCCCNOPYNNNOPYNOPYNNYANCCNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYNNNNCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYONNANANANANANANANCACACAACAAACACACACACACACACCCCCCCCCCCCCCCACACACACACACACACACACACYYYYYYYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYYYYYYYYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYOPYOPYOPOPOPYOPOPNYYPYPYOPOPNONONONONANANANCACACACACCCCCCCCCC04510451045111111551138133813813338138138138133338181111111111111338181818138138138138138138138111111118181818181818181383813813813813813813838383838383833333333333338138138138138138138138138138138133333333333333111181181813838138383333919191111119191111111111111111.91.91.91.91.91.91.911111111911111119...91919191.91.91.91.91.91.91.911191191919191.9.9CCCCCCCCCCCCCANOPYCCANOPYANOPYCCYYCCCANOPYANOPYANOPYANOPYCCCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCANOPYCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCYPYPYPYPYPYPYPYYYYYYYYPYYYYYYYPYPPPPPPNNANANANANCACACACACCYYPYYOPYOPYOPOPCCCC104410441044365365365.64.64.64CANOPYCANOPYCANOPYNO444"4"4"""""""4""TTTRTRTTTTTTRRRTREERXXXXTREETREEEEEEXXXXREEREEXXXXRRXXXXETTTTTRTRTRREREEEEEEEEEEEXXXXXXXEEXXEXXREEEEEEEEEEXXXXXXXXXEEEEXXXXXXXXRXXXXXXXXXXXXXE8""8"8""""""""OAAA OAOAOOOOAOAOAOAAAKOAKOAKAAAKAKAKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKOOOAOAAAAAAAKAKKKKKKTTTTTTTTTREEEETREETREETRERREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEXXXXETTTTTRRREEEEEEEEEEE KKKTKKK6"6"6" OOOOOOOOOOOOOAKOAKOAKAKOAKOAOAOOOOKOOOOOTTKTRTRTTTRTTRTRTRKTTTTRTTTTTRTTTREETREETREEETTRTRTRREKKKK3-4"4443 TREESS6" OAKTREEEEEEEEEK4"4"444"444444"4"4"44444"4OAK OAKOAKOKKKKKOTTTTTRTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTRETRETRETREETRTRTRTRTRTRTRRERETREETRETTRTTTRTRREEEEEEEEEKKTKKKKK2XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX2XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX2" XXXXXXXXXXX2 1R2
11111TRTRTEEE5555R2
1111111TRTRTEEE5555RRRERERRRERERRRERXEXXXXXXXXXEREEREE88888888888RETRETREXXXXXXXXXXROETREREAOAKOA78785050151Y0P97006022
5
OOPYOPY370000PPPPPP7777779797777..7.7333333337037037037037037037070770NNNNONONONONOPNOPNOPNOPNOPNOPNOPA"OAKAKAKKKKKK KK"""OOOOOOOAOAOOOA-4REEEEE00000000
12281281282828287748T"T2272722274274222722227222778782222227TTT"""TT"
3 272XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXE272227227222222XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX777777777777777777777727727272727272772727272727272727272727272727272727272727272727272727272727272E26552700026126222263264266267726826927127XX1041138686.37CANOPCY6386386887.37.37CC6" TREEE4""" TREEREREE484888884844446626526526566656565656565555565656555222702702272707070700027027027022727070026122261261222262222262226226222262262626266262626222262262262226262626262622226322632632226226266363322626636363264226426422222266226626626226726722267267676726726726722676726826826822692692692222271271271222727PPYY27272772222272727XXXXXXXXXX104104110414141414114141413838383888888888666868686868677.37.37.37.37CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCANOPCANOPOPOPCANOPCANOCANOPCANOOPOPOPOPCCAPYYYYYYPPPP222PPP22YYYY277277777YYYYY27277722233333333333338633333383838383838383838383838383838383838383838888888838638638638638638638638638638638638638638383838868.373.3..3...7333737333737373733333.37.37.37.37.37.37.3733333333733733377377CANNNCANCANNNNOP2NOPYNOP2272727NNYY2727272727272727272727CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCANCANCANCANNCANOCANOCANOCANOCANOCANOCANONONONONONONONOOPOPOPOPOPOPOPCCYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOP27272727272727NOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPYNOPY72727727277277277277277NONOOPOPOPYPYOPYPYOPPPP272222722222222227272727272727272727272727272777777777777777776"6"6"6 TTTTTTTTTTTRTRTRTRRRRRERERERREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEETTTTTTRRRREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE44444444444"4"4"4""444""""""" TTTRTRTTTTTTTTTTTRTRTRTRTRTREERRTREETREERRREREREETTTTRTRTRTRTRRREREETTTRTRTRTTRREEEETREETREERRTRTRTREEETRTRTREE2721E272272414177777777777777777Y2Y27222277Y2Y72727777777777777227772727272727272727272727272727272EEE272E27227277777777777777777777772727227772727277272727272727272727272727272727272727272EEE2721E2722721177777777777777777772722277227772727272727272727272727272727272EEE2602577258825922XXXXXXXXXXX10080X369X.16661009111369.24CANOOPYCCAANNOPPYC3369369.2.24.24..3OAKOATRRKTOP TREER365.799910491148888.6000060666666D=64°37'22"D=64°37'22"777777777777272722DDDDD=D===6666664333334°34°3°°2222222222222222222"2"22"2"22233333333 R=20R=20000000RRRRRRRRR=R======222202020202000000R=2R2.00.000000000000000000000000000000000000000L=22L=2222222222222222222222222222EEEEEEEEL=L=.56.566666666665555555656565656666565656565656666555526022602602222222622626266060606022226262660602222572577577575752525252525222222257257257757575252525222222258258885858585825252222225825825885825825252529925925922222225255959992592592592225255959XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX0XXXXXXXXX000XXXXXXXXXXX6XXXXXXXXXXXX66XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX111001000800800000000010010101010101010100X000000080080001010101010101888008008888808080808080808080808888800808008080080800888880808080808008000000XXXXXX3633636936936363636663636336366996969696966693636363636XXXXXXX6666666XXXXXXXXXXXXX.16.16.166666666660900000910091009000000000000101010101199999090909099999101111100010119900900911010000000900909090999999990909090911000009090999999939333693693693694.2..24.24.24.24....ANOPYOOCACCCCACACCCCCCCCCANCANCACACAAAANANANANANANCCANOACANOCANONOCACAANANANANANANANANANANANANANAAAANNNNANONONONONONONNNNNNNNOOOCCACAANANANANNONONANANANANANANAAAONONONONANNNONOOOONOOONOPNOPOOOOOOOOOOPOOPOPYOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPPYPPOPYOPYPPPPOPOPYYYOOONONONONONOONOOOOOOOPOPYOPPCACXX3699936936999993693693693693693693693693693693692422442242422224444.24.24.24.242222.24.24.24.24.24.24.2422222222222.2......2222.2.23333333333333333333333333"3""3333OOOOOOAKOAKOAKOOOOAOAOAKKKKKKKKTKKKOOOOOAOATTRTRTRRTRKTKTOPTOPTOPTRETRETREEEEEREEREEREREREREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEREREEE365365365799.79.7979799997910491104911049111111XXXXXXX1XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX111XXX4"4 TREEEEXXXXXXXXXXXX44444444"4444 TRETRERREREREREEEEEREREEEXXXXXXX44144X1XXXX44141XXXX44141261R4866161TTRTRTRRTRTRTRTR44441414141414141111411346.00'353.05'346.00'346.00'351.62'353.87'347.58'338.08'Attachment #2Item 2Packet Page 15
Page 1 of 1
Long Term Tree Removal/Replacement Plan
Upon close review of the tree removal plan prepared for French Hospital Tower project,
we have the following long-range plan for the replacement of more suitable trees for the
site. Please refer to the landscape plans L101-104.
The trees shown to be removed are currently in the locations where the new Tower
Building and Parking Structure are to be built. Most of the trees are ornamental trees with
many of them being Eucalyptus. There are a few small previously planted oak trees
required to be removed as it was unavoidable do to the parking lot realignment required.
Per our count the same about of trees that are now being removed will be replaced with
new trees and all the trees adjacent to the open space will be native oak trees. There will
be new ornamental trees adjacent to the Tower Building and around the garden areas as
they are more appropriate for those locations. As for the long-range tree plan for the
entire site, the parking lot shading will be maximized with the new tree plantings and the
areas around the designated open space will have all native oaks which is more
compatible with the intended use of that area.
Michael Cripe, ASLA
Principal
michael@oasisassoc.com
www.OASISASSOC.com
Attachment #3 Item 2
Packet Page 16
GREENVALE TREE COMPANY
October 28, 2020
Arborist Report
For: Ariana Melendez
Studio Design Group Architects, Inc.
Site: French Hospital rear parking area, north and west of parking, near modular area.
Plant ID Eucalyptus globulus (Blue Gum Eucalyptus)
Task Removal for proposed FAA requirements.
Definition: Transitional Surface – An area not directly below a flight path that allows for
clearance on either side.
Observations These are general observations. Individual trees may have some variance from
these observations.
Canopy – leaf color is good to poor. Some trees have foliage that is discolored
and even yellowed. Some trees have considerable defoliation and dieback. Trees
closer to the creek appear much more vibrant and vigorous. Leaves are being
eaten by Tortoise Beetle.
Branches – The trees furthest west (and close to modular) appear to have
considerable dieback with some main limbs dead or dying. Limbs on these trees
(in general for the area) are very tangled and dense. Most trees have some poor
attachments and some narrow-angled branches. Narrow angled branches tend to
have included bark.
Trunks/stems – Nearly all these trees are multi-stem, having very narrow stem
angles with included bark. Stems have a tendency to lean away from one another
and have the weight and leverage of the canopy off center of balance.
Conclusion The FAA has concluded that these trees exceed height limits for medivac
helicopters taking off from the hospital. These trees are in the flight path proposed
for the FAA.
Attachment #4 Item 2
Packet Page 17
Trees are in poor health overall and in the western area near the modular unit, it
appears as if there is a pathogen at work. Most, if not all, trees have been affected
by the prolonged drought.
Recommendations
Remove all trees in this area (per plan) to meet FAA requirements.
See photos below for more information
Sincerely
Chris Stier,
ISA Certified Arborist, #WE9262-A
*diagnosis was made with observation, history and sound arboricultural and horticultural knowledge. It is always
possible that other, or different problems exist that may contribute to the d ecline and death of plants. Further
evaluation may be warranted if the steps above do not work. Pathology tests and other lab analysis are available.
Attachment #4 Item 2
Packet Page 18
Plan calls for removal of these trees that are in the “transitional surface” of the flight path. These trees are to close to the proposed
path.
Modular
Direction of flight path departure
Attachment #4 Item 2
Packet Page 19
These are most of the trees that would need removal. The helicopters would have a low
trajectory of takeoff close to these trees within the “transitional surface” area.
Attachment #4 Item 2
Packet Page 20
Trees are close together and branches are a tangle. Proximity between the trees has caused stems
and branches to grow outward causing leans and off centered weight.
Attachment #4 Item 2
Packet Page 21
Multi stemmed trunks with narrow angles and included bark have a greater potential to fail in
wind events.
Attachment #4 Item 2
Packet Page 22
Tree #302 has considerable dieback and the trees around this one has more dieback than a
healthy tree should. It is likely a pathogen has caused a root or crown rot in this area.
Attachment #4 Item 2
Packet Page 23
Trees are tall enough that flight safety is at risk during departure when trajectories are low. To
meet the required FAA “transitional surface” regulation these need to be removed.
Attachment #4 Item 2
Packet Page 24
GREENVALE TREE COMPANY
October 28, 2020
Arborist Report
For: Ariana Melendez
Studio Design Group Architects, Inc.
Site: French Hospital area beyond chain link fence southwest side of property beyond rear parking.
Plant ID Eucalyptus globulus (Blue Gum Eucalyptus)
Task Removal and reducing per FAA requirements.
Definition: Transitional Surface – An area not directly below a flight path that allows for clearance on either
side.
Observations These are general observations. Individual trees may have some variance from these
observations.
Canopy – leaf color is good with no noted yellowing or fading. Tortoise Beetle has been feeding
on lower leaves but likely not upper leaves as they are too high for habitat. Trees lower on the
slope have canopies that are very high (top one-third to one-fourth of trunk).
Branches – Some of the trees have longer branches subject to leveraged conditions. The trees on
the top of the slope tend to have more branches and certainly lower branches. Branches of the
upper trees are intertwined between trees and stems. Some branches on all trees have narrow
crotches and included bark. Some stubs noted from prior branch breaks though these appear to be
few.
Trunks/stems – Trees can be single trunked and very balanced to multi-trunked with stems and
weight leaning outward. The trees that are multi-trunked have very narrow angles between trunks
and some of these have included bark. Trees at the top of the slope in general are not quite as tall
as trees downslope. Heights of trees exceed 100 feet on most trees.
Conclusion The FAA has concluded that these trees are exceeding height limits for medivac helicopters
landing at the hospital. These trees are in the “transitional surface” near the flight path proposed
for the FAA. The lower trees likely can be reduced to accommodate the height limitations. The
trees nearest the parking lot cannot be reduced as there are no lower limbs to reduce to and the
cuts would be so large that they would not close before decay and likely infection sets in.
Attachment #5 Item 2
Packet Page 25
Recommendations
Remove trees 389, 391 and 392 as these trees cannot be reduced without stubbing off stems.
Reduce trees 337, 338, 348, 356, 359, 360, 363, 364 and 365. Reducing by 25 to 35 feet should
allow compliance for FAA requirement. These trees should be reduced to an existing, well
attached branch. Final determination will be made by the climber and site arborist. It may be that
a few trees have no good branches to reduce to. If this scenario occurs, then a removal may be in
order as this would be the best arboricultural practice.
The trees that are reduced will need regular pruning maintenance to keep them at the required
FAA height. Removal of smaller wood is always the best arboricultural practice. Management
should be prepared to have these trees trimmed at least every three years.
See drawing photos below for more information
Sincerely
Chris Stier,
ISA Certified Arborist, #WE9262-A
*diagnosis was made with observation, history and sound arboricultural and horticultural knowledge. It is always possible tha t other,
or different problems exist that may contribute to the decline and death of plants. Further evaluation may be warranted if the steps
above do not work. Pathology tests and other lab analysis are available.
Attachment #5 Item 2
Packet Page 26
This (blue arrow) is the proposed flight path of incoming medivac helicopters. The trees in pink
will need to be removed as they cannot be pruned to accommodate FAA “transitional surface”
requirements. The trees in yellow will be reduced to accommodate the FAA requirements.
Regular maintenance will need to be performed to maintain the requirements.
Attachment #5 Item 2
Packet Page 27
This simple drawing illustrates the problem. On the
lower trees we can reduce the tree to a branch (proper
arboriculture practice). On the upper trees we have no
branches to reduce the height to. Leaving a stub will
cause multiple problems and likely lead to the decline
of the tree or, if it gets growth, it would be very weak
and eventually fail, possibly striking cars or people. In
this case we need to remove the trees nearest the
parking and reduce trees downslope
FAA required tree height
Attachment #5 Item 2
Packet Page 28
We are looking at trees 389, 391 and 392 here in this picture. They are the trees closest to the flight path and
within “transitional surface” zone. These need to be removed.
Attachment #5 Item 2
Packet Page 29
This is tree # 391. It’s very close to the parking and at the top of the slope. This tree exceeds the limit allowed
for the FAA “transitional surface”. Note the trees downhill. Those trees can be reduced because they are further
away and lower by being downhill.
Attachment #5 Item 2
Packet Page 30
This is tree #392 and a good example of why three trees need removal. There is no place that the tree can be
reduced to and meet the FAA requirements. Arrow is at approximate level of compliance.
Attachment #5 Item 2
Packet Page 31
The tree with the arrow is #360. This is a tree down slope that will need to be reduced by about 25 feet.
Somewhere near the arrow is where this tree will be reduced. There are many branches to choose from to select
a good place to make the cut.
Attachment #5 Item 2
Packet Page 32
This photo will give the viewer an idea of the slope’s steepness. This slope also makes the lower trees closer to
the FAA requirements while the upper trees (from the perspective of the slope) are taller and would need to be
cut much lower, actually stubbing the trees instead of lowering to a branch.
Attachment #5 Item 2
Packet Page 33
Tree Removals CA. Native Non-Native Total
Tree Replacements
Project CA. Native Non-Native Total
Patient Tower 9 45 54
Parking Deck 24 13 37
Chapel 0 1 1
Driveway Improvements 0 8 8
Screening Trees*20 0 20
Total tree additions:53 67 120
*Screening trees along Iris Street properties, pending agreement with neighbor.
Per "Tree Inventory, Removal, and
Modification Plan", dated 3/30/21 28 90 118
Attachment #6 Item 2
Packet Page 34
Modular Offices
Attachment #7 Item 2
Packet Page 35
Arborist Assessment of Trees
Date: January 17, 2022
Site: FAA Transitional Air Space North
Tree Number/Species: #13 (8 trees) Eucalyptus globulus
Observed – Very tall Blue Gum Eucalyptus. Canopy is healthy, not particularly thick, and new growth is noted.
Noted some dieback in certain trees. Branches range from well-placed and well attached to some narrow angles
and poor attachments. Trunks/stems are mostly straight. Trees have not been maintained. These trees are within
the FAA transitional surface zone for exiting helicopters.
Reason for removal – Trees are close to the air space needed for medivac helicopter flights. The FAA considers
this area as Transitional Surface: “Transitional Surface – An area not directly below a flight path that allows for
clearance on either side.” Tall trees such as these falls into the category as being a clearance issue. Without
removal of the trees, medivac flights at the hospital will not be permitted. Trimming these trees lower is not
possible as there are no branches to trim down to and still meet the FAA requirements (i.e., trees would be
stubbed).
Near by Coast Live Oak trees will remain as they are not a clearance issue. Removal of these Blue Gum’s may
actually help the oaks as they will have more light, room and less competition for water and nutrients.
Chris Stier
ISA Certified Arborist WE9262-A
*Assessment was made with observation, history and sound arboricultural and horticultural knowledge. It is always possible that
other, or different problems exist that may contribute to the destabilization, decline and death of trees. Further evaluation may be
warranted if the steps above do not work. Construction activities can seriously disrupt roots and soils and lead to long term
problems that may directly or indirectly cause a tree to decline and die.
Attachment #7 Item 2
Packet Page 36
This is the group of 8 trees that need removal for Transitional Surface requirements from FAA.
Attachment #7 Item 2
Packet Page 37
Fence Line
Attachment #8 Item 2
Packet Page 38
Arborist Assessment of Trees
Date: January 17, 2022
Site: FAA Transitional Air Space South
Tree Number/Species: 19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27 Eucalyptus globulus
Observed – Very tall Blue Gum Eucalyptus. Canopy is healthy, not particularly thick, and new growth is noted.
Most of the canopy is on the upper third of the trunk. Height-of-canopy-to-trunk ratio makes these trees
leveraged. Branches range from well-placed and well attached to some narrow angles and poor attachments.
Trunks/stems are mostly straight (except for 27). Trees have not been maintained. These trees are particularly
close to the current parking area except for 27 which has a distinct lean (in neighbor’s property).
Reason for removal – Trees are close to the air space needed for medivac helicopter flights. The FAA considers
this area as Transitional Surface: “Transitional Surface – An area not directly below a flight path that allows for
clearance on either side.” Tall trees such as these fall into the category as being a clearance issue. Without
removal of the trees, medivac flights at the hospital will not be permitted. Trimming these trees lower is not
possible as there are no branches to trim down to and still meet the FAA requirements (i.e., trees would be
stubbed).
All trees marked with T will be trimmed for height clearance allowance under FFA guidelines for height.
Chris Stier
ISA Certified Arborist WE9262-A
*Assessment was made with observation, history and sound arboricultural and horticultural knowledge. It is always possible that
other, or different problems exist that may contribute to the destabilization, decline and death of trees. Further evaluation may be
warranted if the steps above do not work. Construction activities can seriously disrupt roots and soils and lead to long term
problems that may directly or indirectly cause a tree to decline and die.
Attachment #8 Item 2
Packet Page 39
This is the group of 6 trees that need removal for Transitional Surface requirements from FAA. Tree 27 leans
and is down in the property below creek.
Attachment #8 Item 2
Packet Page 40
Attachment #9 Item 2
Packet Page 41
Date: January 17, 2022
Arborist Assessment of Trees
Site: Proposed Patient Tower
Tree Number/Species: 1 Eucalyptus viminalis
2 Corymbia ficifolia
3 Schinus molle
4 Jacaranda mimosifolia
5 Fraxinus spp.
6 Fraxinus spp.
7 Quercus agrifolia
10 Platnus X acerfolia
11 Prunus cerasifera
14 Eucalyptus polyanthemos
17 Albizia Julibrissin
19 Schinus molle
Observed –
#1 – (1 tree) Manna Gum – Healthy tree. Large tree. Close to existing building. Top of slope
with lots of room for roots.
#2 – (1 tree) Red Flowering Gum – Large broadly spreading tree. Very healthy. Lots of room for
roots.
#3 - (5) – California Pepper – Smaller trees, fairly young. Trees are yellowed and somewhat thin.
Vary in height.
#4 - (1) – Jacaranda – Tree is on the top of the slop Sprawling tree. Tree branches are nearly
touching the building. Tree is dormant.
#5 – (1) – Ash – not found
#6 – (2) – Ash – The largest of the two has narrow stem angles with included bark. Smaller tree
has a somewhat thinner canopy. They are close to the top of the slope with lots of room for roots.
#7 – (1) – Coast Live Oak – Tree is in good health with good color and growth. Larger tree. Very
broad canopy that is well balanced.
#10 – (2) – London Plane – These trees are planted by the stairwell. One is in a narrow planter
and the other is near 4 electrical vaults. Roots can be a problem. Trees are dormant.
Attachment #9 Item 2
Packet Page 42
#11 – (7) – Purple Leaf Plum – Vary in size. Some are planted in very narrow planters where
roots can be a problem. Most of these trees have narrow crotch angles, included bark and
crowded branches. I noted cankering on some of the limbs. I also noted some that have
sunburned trunks. Some have surface roots. At least one has symptoms of borers.
#14 – (4) – Silver Doller Eucalyptus – All planted in parking planters. Large trees. Overall good
canopy color and vigor. One of these trees has a large gall at the base.
#17 – (1) – Mimosa – Sprawling canopy. Surface rooting tree. Tree is dormant.
# 19 – (1) – California Pepper – Large tree. In good health with good color and vigor. Large
planter with room for roots.
#16 – (1) – Coast live Oak – (mislabeled as California Pepper #19, on plan) – tree is close to the
two Silver Doller Eucalyptus (#14) In current parking planter. Healthy tree. Good growth.
Reason for removal – All of these trees are in the direct footprint of the proposed patient tower or
its appurtenances (utilities, walkways, reconfigured parking lot etc.).
Chris Stier
ISA Certified Arborist WE9262-A
*Assessment was made with observation, history and sound arboricultural and horticultural knowledge. It is
always possible that other, or different problems exist that may contribute to the destabilization, decline and
death of trees. Further evaluation may be warranted if the steps above do not work. Construction activities can
seriously disrupt roots and soils and lead to long term problems that may directly or indirectly cause a tree to
decline and die.
Attachment #9 Item 2
Packet Page 43
This is a London Plane tree. The close proximity to the electrical vaults will eventually be a
maintenance problem. This tree and all those in this section are directly in the way of the
building or its appurtenances.
Attachment #9 Item 2
Packet Page 44
Attachment #10 Item 2
Packet Page 45
Arborist Assessment of Trees
Date: January 17, 2022
Site: Proposed Parking Structure
Tree Number/Species: 8 Cinnamomum camphora
9 Tristania conferta
10 Platenus X acerfolia
15, 16 Quercus agrifolia
Observed –
#8 – (11 trees) Camphor – Trees have a somewhat thin canopy overall. Those that are in the narrowest planters
have more discoloration and thinner canopies. Roots have filled the smaller planters (root bound) and soil is
very compacted. Poorly drained soil. Trees in some areas are cracking curbs and lifting pavements.
#9 – (5) Brisbane Box – Canopy health and vigor range from healthy to poor. These are planted in very narrow
planters, and all are root bound. Soil is compacted and drains poorly. Trees are very tall and have been skirted
up high. Roots are breaking curbs, cracking and lifting walks and lifting pavement. Trees have outgrown the
planters.
#10 – (22) – London Plane – Trees are dormant so health can not be fully assessed. Planted in extremely small
planters they are all root bound. Soil is compacted and poorly drained. I di note some cankers on smaller
branches and twigs. Trimming has been excessive and they are skirted up high. Trees likely will decline due to
poor rooting conditions (small planters).
#15 (9) #16 (4) – Coast Live Oak – The smaller trees (#15) are mostly healthy the larger trees (#16) that are in
larger planters are much healthier than those in small planters. Planters are somewhat compacted and may not
drain well. Larger planters are okay but not great.
Reason for removal – Most of these trees are in the direct foot print of the proposed parking garage or its
appurtenances (walkways, utilities etc.). Parking areas outside of the structure is slated for modifications and
repave that will affect trees as well. Existing oaks beyond the construction will be protected and maintained.
Chris Stier
ISA Certified Arborist WE9262-A
*Assessment was made with observation, history and sound arboricultural and horticultural knowledge. It is always possible that
other, or different problems exist that may contribute to the destabilization, decline and death of trees. Further evaluation may be
warranted if the steps above do not work. Construction activities can seriously disrupt roots and soils and lead to long term
problems that may directly or indirectly cause a tree to decline and die.
Attachment #10 Item 2
Packet Page 46
This Brisbane Box is a good example of narrow planters which are now root bound and poorly drained The tree
has outgrown its space. Note how the curb was removed to accommodate the trunk. Also note how the sidewalk
had to be planed to correct lifting. The Brisbane Box and London Plane trees all are like this.
Attachment #10 Item 2
Packet Page 47
Attachment #10 Item 2
Packet Page 48
Attachment #11 Item 2
Packet Page 49
Date: January 17, 2022
Site: Proposed Reconfigured Parking Lot
Tree Number/Species: 8 Cinnamomum camphora
9 Tristania conferta
10 Platenus X acerfolia
17 Albizia julibrissin
15, 16 Quercus agrifolia
Observed –
#8 – (1 tree) Camphor – Somewhat of a thin canopy. The planter this is in is larger than most and
tree seems well rooted. Soil is not as compacted as some of the planters.
#9 – (7) Brisbane Box – Canopy health and vigor range from healthy to poor. These are planted
in a very narrow planter, and all are root bound. Soil is compacted and drains poorly. Roots are
breaking curbs, cracking and lifting walks and lifting pavement. Trees have outgrown the
planters.
#10 – (2) – London Plane – Trees are dormant so health cannot be fully assessed. Planted in
extremely small planters they are all root bound. Soil is compacted and poorly drained. I did note
some cankers on smaller branches and twigs. Trimming has been excessive, and they are skirted
up high. Trees likely will decline due to poor rooting conditions (small planters).
#15 (3) #16 (3) – Coast Live Oak – The smaller trees (#15) are healthy the larger trees (#16) that
are in larger planters are much healthier than those in small planters. Planters seem less
compacted than most on site. Drainage seems good.
#17 – (3) – Mimosa – Trees are medium size. Roots are somewhat surface with larger ones seen
above grade. Planters are small (about 6 foot) for such and aggressive rooting tree. Soil is
compacted and will not drain well. Since trees are dormant I could not assess the trees health.
Reason for removal – This parking is to be redone and reconfigured. Some new
structures/utilities are to be installed as well as walkways.
Chris Stier
ISA Certified Arborist WE9262-A
*Assessment was made with observation, history and sound arboricultural and horticultural knowledge. It is
always possible that other, or different problems exist that may contribute to the destabilization, decline and
death of trees. Further evaluation may be warranted if the steps above do not work. Construction activities can
seriously disrupt roots and soils and lead to long term problems that may directly or indirectly cause a tree to
decline and die.
Attachment #11 Item 2
Packet Page 50
This is a very narrow planter for the Brisbane Box. They have outgrown both the root zone and
the trunk (nearly encompasses width of planter). Note on the sidewalk the number of places that
planning was done to fix uneven/lifted walks. Pavement is also breaking due to roots.
Attachment #11 Item 2
Packet Page 51
Attachment #12 Item 2Packet Page 52
Packet Page 53
Tree Removal Inspection / Permit
TO: Applicant: Brazil Heights LLC
FROM: Anthony Whipple, Acting City Arborist/Urban Forest Supervisor
SUBJECT: Removal Application SR#12342
On February 9th, 2022, I inspected 4 trees at 572 E Foothill in response to tree removal application
SR#12432. The removal of the mentioned application was submitted based on:
San Luis Obispo Municipal Code 12.24.090 (f) 1
Upon inspection of the trees, I approve the Monterey Pine on the west frontage and the Eucalyptus
due to swollen and displaced hardscape. I Denied the removal of the 2 canary Island pines on the
east frontage due to lack of findings. I am also requesting the removal of an old Eucalyptus stump
located in the center of the complex and replanting with a 24-inch box tree listed below.
Replanting two 36-inch box trees on the Foothill frontage and one 24-inch box tree in the complex
off our city master tree list within 45 days of removal with a photo taken after trees are planted
and mailed to Urban Forest Services 25 Prado RD. San Luis Obispo CA 93401 or emailed to City
Arborist awhipple@slocity.org is a condition of this approval.
NOTE: All trees replanted shall be maintained until fully established as a condition of their
approved tree removal.
Thank you,
Anthony Whipple, Acting City Arborist/Urban Forest Supervisor
(805) 781-7021
Public Works - Urban Forestry
25 Prado Road, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3218
805.781.7220
slocity.org
Item 3
Packet Page 54
Item 3
Packet Page 55
Item 3
Packet Page 56
/
( / $&-"/ !)!&%)/)/&,*"!% /!%/ *!&%/ %%'* m & /* /!+.)/,%!!'#/&
// / /
/ / /
//
//
/
/
2ZZK\F\fm 1AkA`Emf]m7KGFm]am;a]^F`fjm=FCfK]\m
4 %%' * . mlA
3m
,Kfjm+`B]aKefm :]m+^^FAPm
>aFFm1FAQfJmA\Em1AkA`Em 8KfKIAfK]\m ,Kfjm+aB]`Kefm >aFFm,]ZZKffFFm
=FCgM]\m5 %%' * .RSm
8K\]am 9K\LefF`KAPm-FiFQ]^ZF\fm;F`ZLfm`FZ]iAPmG]am ,Kfjm+`B]aKefm ,]ZZh\Kfjm
aFeKEF\fKAQm]`mADDFee]cmC]\ef`hCfK]\m]\mA\m<!m]`m -FiFQ]^ZF\fm-LaFCf]`m
<%mP]f m=FCfK]\mT %%' * / "m
,`LfF`KAmH]`m-KeC`FfK]\Adm;F`ZLfem,]\ef`hCfK]\m?`FFm ,]ZZh\Mfjm ;QA\\K\Im ,]ZZKeeL]\m
<FZ]iAPm=FCfN]\mU#%%' * 0V&
$m -FiFQ]^ZF\fm-LaFCf]`m ,Lgjm,]h\CKQm
8AO]am-FiFQ]^ZF\fm>F\fAfKiFm>`ACfm9A_m ,]ZZh\Kfjm ,Lfjm ,]h\CMQm
,]\EMfM]\AWm@eFm ;FbZMfm =FCfM]\m6 %%' * 'XYm -FiFQ]^[F\fm-KaFCf]am
&S?5b?qGW<Ri>?q5q<E?<PqAX`q
35RXWDqlHeEq<XU[R?e?>q5[[SG<5eHXWqq>X<iU?We5fHXW
q
+`??q(?UXk5Rq5[[SG<5eHXWbqU5nq9?q bi9VGee?>qHWq[?`bXWq5eqq&`5>Xq(X5>q5eq eE?q Genbq
X`[X`5eHXWq,5`>qHWq) $qX`qU5HR?>qeXq
#-23)!3 (3 .#,3 #,*)3
. &# 3)+$, + (3)+ ,-3 +0# ,3
3+ )3 ) 3
(3.#,3 #,*)33 3
&i`bi5WfqeXq)5Wq!iHbq $9Gb[Xq#iWG<H[5Sq X>?qq5Wnq [?`bXWq5DD`G?k?>q9nq5Wq5<eqX`q
>?e?`UGW5eGXWqXAqeE?q5ieEX`Gp?>q5[[aXkIWDq5ieEX`Genq?m?`<HbHWDqeE?q5ieEX`HenqE?`?HWqD`5We?>q
bE5RRqE5k?qeE?q`HDEeqeXq5[[?5RqeE?q>?<HbGXWqXAqeE?q5ieEX`Hp?>q5[[`XkHWDq5ieEX`Henq
[[?5SbqUibeq9?q`?<?Hk?>q9nqeE?q<Henq<S?`PqlHeEHWqe?Wq<5S?W>5`q>5nbqA`XVqeE?q>5e?qXAq
>?e?`UHW5eHXWqXaq5<eqbE5SSq<5ib?qeE?q>J`?<eX`qfXqlIeEEXR>qe`??q`?UXk5Rq[?`VGebq5W>q5Wnq
[?aUHebqC`q<XWbe`i<eGXWqX`q>?UXRHeHXWq5<eGkHenq`?SnGWDqXWqeE?qbi9O?<eqea??q`?VXk5Rq iWeHSqeE?q
5[[?5RqKbqE?5`>q5W>q5q>?<HbHXWqHbq `?5<E?>q
+E?qA??qeXq5\]?5SqeXqeE?q+`??q XUVHee??qGbq %() m
+EHbqe`??q`?UXk5Rq5[[SH<5eGXWqUibeq9?qbHDW?>q9nqeE?q[aX[?`enqXlW?`qX`q5Wq ieEX`Ip?>q
D?Weq 3 % + 3.( +3* ( &-23)!3 .+23-" -3 &&3-" 3! -,3,- - 31#-"#(3-"#,3-+ 3
+ ')/ &3 **&# -#)(3 + 3-+. 3 ( 3
[[RG<5Webq)HDW5ei`?
5e?q--./-q0q
'T@6c@qU6P@q=F@=Qq^6o7:T@qgXqgF@q LhqYBq*8Wq "jMdq%;Nb_Zq
3 E?<Pq123q4q
Item 3
Packet Page 57
Item 3
Packet Page 58
Item 3
Packet Page 59
Item 3
Packet Page 60
Item 3
Packet Page 61
Item 3
Packet Page 62
Item 3
Packet Page 63
Item 3
Packet Page 64
Item 3
Packet Page 65
Item 3
Packet Page 66
Item 3
Packet Page 67
Item 3
Packet Page 68
Item 3
Packet Page 69
Item 3
Packet Page 70
Item 3
Packet Page 71
Item 3
Packet Page 72
Item 3
Packet Page 73
Item 3Packet Page 74
Item 3
Packet Page 75
Item 3
Packet Page 76
Tree Removal Inspection Report/ Permit
TO: Timothy Gilligan
FROM: Anthony Whipple, Acting City Arborist/Urban Forest Supervisor
SUBJECT: Removal Application SR#12374
On Date: February 16th, 2022, I inspected 1 tree at address 3204 Flora in response to tree removal
application SR#12374. The removal of the mentioned application was submitted based on:
San Luis Obispo Municipal Code 12.24.090 (E) 1
c.The tree’s roots are causing severe damage to public or private property, and removing the tree
is the only feasible way to eliminate the damage;
d.The tree is affected by structural defects and/or deficiencies that will limit lifespan;
e.The tree is densely clustered amongst other trees and the requested tree removal promotes
good arboricultural practice;
Upon inspection of the southern magnolia (Magnolia Grandiflora), I could not find significant
structural damage and or appropriate criteria for removal authorized by the City of San Luis Obispo
Municipal Code, Title 12, Tree Regulations, and I denied the removal application.
Appeals must be file with the City Clerk’s Office Municipal Code 12.24.180
Thank you,
Anthony Whipple, Acting City Arborist/Urban Forest Supervisor
(805) 781-7021 awhipple@slocity.org
Public Works - Urban Forestry
25 Prado Road, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3218
805.781.7220
slocity.org
Item 4
Packet Page 77
Item 4
Packet Page 78
Item 4
Packet Page 79
Item 4
Packet Page 80
Item 4Packet Page 81
Item 4
Packet Page 82
Item 4
Packet Page 83
Item 4
Packet Page 84
Item 4
Packet Page 85
Item 4
Packet Page 86
Item 4
Packet Page 87
Item 4
Packet Page 88
Item 4
Packet Page 89