HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-14-2014 ac - johnsonph1MEMORANDUM
City of San Luis Obispo- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
DATE: January 13, 2014
TO: Mayor & Council
VIA: Katie Lichtig, City Manager
FROM: Derek Johnson, Community Development Director
SUBJECT: Land Use and Circulation Element Update – Task Force Motions with Meeting
Dates
The Task Force took action both through consensus and through motions as they reviewed and
edited the draft Land Use and Circulation Elements. The Council requested Task Force votes be
provided for context as the Council considers the draft elements. The attached document
updates the agenda correspondence previously provided with dates the motions were made
(highlighted after each item) so that minutes from the respective Task Force meeting may be
referenced where desired.
Please contact Kim Murry at kmurry@slocity.org with any questions.
Received
January 13, 2014
SLO City Clerk
Agenda
Correspondence
Date: 1/7, 1/14, 1/28
Item: PH1
LUCE Task Force Motions
2
Table of Contents
Task Force Motions – Land Use Element .............................................3
Introduction and Goals ............................................................................................................................. 3
Land Use Designations .............................................................................................................................. 5
Chapter 1 – Growth Management............................................................................................................ 7
Chapter 2 – Conservation and Development of Residential Neighborhoods .......................................... 7
Chapter 3 – Commercial & Industrial Development Policies ................................................................... 9
Chapter 4 – Downtown ........................................................................................................................... 11
Chapter 5 – Public & Cultural Facilities................................................................................................... 13
Chapter 6 – Resource Protection ............................................................................................................ 14
Chapter 7 – Airport Area ........................................................................................................................ 15
Chapter 8 – Special Focus Areas ............................................................................................................. 16
Chapter 9 - Sustainability ........................................................................................................................ 20
Chapter 10 – Healthy Community .......................................................................................................... 21
Task Force Motions – Circulation Element ........................................ 22
Chapter 1: Introduction, Goals and Objectives ...................................................................................... 22
Chapter 2 – Traffic Reduction ................................................................................................................. 23
Chapter 3 – Transit Service ..................................................................................................................... 26
Chapter 4 – Bicycle Transportation ........................................................................................................ 27
Chapter 5 - Walking ................................................................................................................................ 28
Chapter 6 – Multi-modal Circulation (replaces Chapter 8, Traffic Flow) ................................................ 28
Chapter 7 (Chapter 6 in TF version) – Traffic Management ................................................................... 29
Chapter 8 (Chapter 7 in TF version) – Neighborhood Traffic Management ........................................... 30
Chapter 9 – Street Network Changes ..................................................................................................... 30
Chapter 10 – Truck Transportation ........................................................................................................ 31
Chapter 11 – Air Transportation ............................................................................................................. 31
The Task Force made no changes to this section. .................................................................................. 31
Chapter 12 – Rail Transportation ........................................................................................................... 31
Chapter 13– Parking Management ......................................................................................................... 32
Chapter 14 – Neighborhood Parking Management ............................................................................... 32
The Task Force approved this section as proposed. ............................................................................... 32
Chapter 15– Scenic Roadways ................................................................................................................ 32
Chapter 16– Circ. Element Implementation ........................................................................................... 32
LUCE Task Force Motions
3
Task Force Motions – Land Use Element
September 18, 2013 – December 10, 2013
Introduction and Goals
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Richardson, to approve the LUE
Introduction and Goals as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Rossi
DATE: 12-5-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Richardson, to approve the
following existing wording for the last paragraph of the Introduction: “Policies in the Land
Use Element and the General Plan Land Use Diagram are designed to be consistent and
complementary with all other General Plan elements.”
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Rossi
DATE: 12-5-2013
The motion passed on a 11:2 vote.
Community Values
On motion by Member Juhnke, and seconded by Member Quaglino, to send this section
back to staff for rewriting including presenting the information in bullet points without
including conclusions.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Rossi
DATE: 12-5-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
Member Brown proposed this new goal: “These policies and programs shall serve as a
blueprint, guiding the City and its various entities in priority setting and resource allocation. It is
LUCE Task Force Motions
4
understood that the availability of financial resources can and will affect the timing of
implementation, but shall not change the goals and intent.”
On motion by Member Brown, and seconded by Member Whitney, to adopt this new goal
as part of the LUE update and place it as the second point under Approach to Planning in
the Introduction for Community’s Goals.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Rossi
DATE: 12-5-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
City Form – San Luis Obispo should:
Goetz suggested: “Create compact mixed use neighborhoods that locate housing, jobs,
recreation and other daily needs in close proximity to each other.” Member Rademaker added
“maintain existing and….”
On motion by Member Goetz, and seconded by Member Crotser, to insert this language in
the City Form section.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, and Richardson
NOES: Task Force Members Rowley, Saunders and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Rossi
DATE: 12-5-2013
The motion passed on a 10:3 vote.
On motion by Member Crotser, seconded by Member Rademaker, to add a new bullet to
Community’s Goals, Environment about encouraging energy efficiency and practices in the
City’s urban design.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Rossi
DATE: 12-5-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
On motion by Member Brown, and seconded by Member Bremer, to approve the
remainder of the section as amended and with the direction given to staff.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force member Rowley
RECUSED: None
LUCE Task Force Motions
5
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Rossi
DATE: 12-5-2013
The motion passed on a 12:1 vote.
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Brown, to approve the
following sections of the Introduction to the Land Use Element in the December 10, 2013,
Transmittal Memorandum as amended: Public Participation, Background to the 1994 Land
Use Element, Background to the 2014 Land Use Element, Community Values, Preamble to
the Land Use Element and San Luis Obispo’s Vision.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
Land Use Designations
Figure 1: County Land Use Designations Map (p.4) and Land Use Designations Outside the LUCE
Planning Sub-area (pp. 34-36)
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Rademaker, to eliminate any
reference to density for this county open space land.
AYES: Task Force Members Crotser, Juhnke, Rademaker, and Rossi
NOES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Meyer, Quaglino, Richardson,
Saunders, and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Multari
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion failed on a 4:9 vote.
On motion by Member Juhnke, and seconded by Member Brown to define a maximum
density for each area, indicate that there is a presumption of no housing in open space, and
place UOS after UAG in the chart on pages 34-36 of the December 10, 2013, Transmittal
Memo.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Multari
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
LUCE Task Force Motions
6
On motion by Member Brown, and seconded by Member Quaglino, to approve as
presented the County Land Use Designations Map (p.4 of the Transmittal) and Land Use
Designations Outside the LUCE Planning Sub-area (pp. 34-36 of the Transmittal) with the
amendments made in the prior motion.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Multari
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
On a motion by Task Force Member Brown, seconded by Member Bremer, to support the
organization of land use designations into a table format as shown in the draft Land Use
Element.
AYES: Committee Members Meyer, Rademaker, Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke,
Multari, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Dandekar, Rossi, and Quaglino
DATE: 11-6-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
On motion by Task Force Member Juhnke, seconded by Member Crotser to support the
density increase in Medium High Density Residential from 18 du/acre to 20 du/acre.
AYES: Committee Members Meyer, Rademaker, Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke,
Multari, Richardson, Saunders, Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Dandekar, Rossi, and Quaglino
ABSTAIN: Task Force member Rowley
DATE: 11-6-2013
The motion passed on a 11:0 vote with one abstention.
On a motion by Task Force Member Rademaker, seconded by Membe r Whitney to not
support minimum densities for Medium and High Density Residential land use designations.
AYES: Committee Members Meyer, Rademaker, Bremer, Brown, Goetz, Juhnke, Multari,
Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, Whitney
NOES: Committee Member Crotser
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Dandekar, Rossi, and Quaglino
DATE: 11-6-2013
The motion passed on a 11:1 vote
LUCE Task Force Motions
7
Chapter 1 – Growth Management
On a motion by Task Force Member Meyer, seconded by Member Bremer to delete Policy
1.4 (Jobs-Housing Relationship).
AYES: Committee Members Meyer, Rademaker, Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke,
Multari, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Dandekar, Rossi, and Quaglino
DATE: 11-6-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
On a motion by Task Force Member Brown, seconded by Member Goetz to approve the
Growth Management Chapter with revisions and direction as noted.
AYES: Committee Members Meyer, Rademaker, Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke,
Multari, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Dandekar, Rossi, and Quaglino
DATE: 11-6-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
Chapter 2 – Conservation and Development of Residential
Neighborhoods
On a motion by Task Force Member Crotser, seconded by Member Brown to revise the
introduction to read: The City shall preserve, protect, and enhance the City’s neighborhoods
and strive to preserve and enhance their identity and promote a higher quality of life within
each neighborhood.
AYES: Committee Members Rowley, Meyer, Saunders, Crotser, Richardson, and Bremer
NOES: Committee Members Dandekar and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Brown, Rossi, Goetz, Quaglino, Multari, Rademaker, and Juhnke
DATE: 11-7-2013
The motion passed on a 6:2 vote.
On a motion by Task Force Member Crotser, seconded by Member Rowley to put in
additional language to describe housing types, replace “vibrant” with “quality” and remove
next to last bullet on page 1-52 that refers to network of facilities.
AYES: Committee Members Crotser, Rowley, and Saunders
NOES: Committee Members Bremer, Dandekar, Richardson, Whitney, and Meyer
LUCE Task Force Motions
8
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Brown, Rossi, Goetz, Quaglino, Multari, Rademaker, and Juhnke
DATE: 11-7-2013
The motion fails on a 3:5 vote.
On a motion by Task Force Member Dandekar, seconded by Member Bremer to put in
additional language to describe housing types and replace “vibrant” with “quality” but to
retain the bullet item referring to interconnectedness.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Richardson, Whitney, and Meyer.
NOES: Committee Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT:Committee Members Brown, Rossi, Goetz, Quaglino, Multari, Rademaker, and Juhnke.
DATE: 11-7-2013
The motion passes on a 6:2 vote.
On a motion by Task Force Member Crotser, seconded by Member Bremer to endorse
Policy 2.2.1 language as proposed in draft element.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Richardson, Whitney, and Meyer
NOES: Committee Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT:Committee Members Brown, Rossi, Goetz, Quaglino, Multari, Rademaker, and Juhnke
DATE: 11-7-2013
The motion passes on a 6:2 vote.
On a motion by Task Force Member Crotser, seconded by Member Richardson to endorse
Policy 2.2.9 language as proposed in draft element with revisions to subsection I and E and
correction to citation in subsection H as discussed.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Richardson, and Meyer
NOES: Committee Members Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Brown, Rossi, Goetz, Quaglino, Multari, Rademaker, and Juhnke
DATE: 11-7-2013
The motion passes on a 5:3 vote.
On motion by Committee Member Richardson, seconded by Committee Member Crotser to
support the new policy 2.4.2 with a minor revision to remove the word “significantly” on
line two of the policy.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Meyer, and Richardson
NOES: Committee Member Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Brown, Rossi, Goetz, Quaglino, Multari, Rademaker, and Juhnke.
DATE: 11-7-2013
The motion passed on a 5:3 vote
LUCE Task Force Motions
9
On motion by Committee Member Richardson, seconded by Committee Member Crotser to
support the new policy 2.4.2 with a minor revision to remove the word “significantly” on
line two of the policy.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Meyer, and Richardson
NOES: Committee Member Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Brown, Rossi, Goetz, Quaglino, Multari, Rademaker, and Juhnke
DATE: 11-7-2013
The motion passed on a 5:3 vote.
On motion by Committee Member Richardson, seconded by Committee Member Crotser to
support the Policy 2.5.2 as proposed in the legislative draft.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Meyer, Richardson, and Whitney
NOES: Committee Member Rowley
RECUSED: None
ABSTAIN: Committee Member Saunders
ABSENT: Committee Members Brown, Rossi, Goetz, Quaglino, Multari, Rademaker, and Juhnke
DATE: 11-7-2013
The motion passed on a 6:1 vote (Saunders abstained).
On motion by Committee Member Dandekar, seconded by Committee Member Crotser to
approve the Residential Neighborhood chapter with changes as noted throughout the Task
Force discussion.
AYES: Committee Members Rowley, Meyer, Saunders, Crotser, Richardson, Dandekar,
Whitney, and Bremer
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Brown, Rossi, Goetz, Quaglino, Multari, Rademaker, and Juhnke
DATE: 11-7-2013
The motion passed on a 8:0 vote
Chapter 3 – Commercial & Industrial Development Policies
On motion by Member Rossi, seconded by Member Quaglino, to develop a program to
allow visitor-serving uses in office zones adjacent to commercial properties in the
Downtown and Monterey Street.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Multari, Quaglino, Rossi,
Rowley, Saunders, Whitney, and Meyer
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Juhnke, Rademaker, and Richardson
DATE: 11-14-2013
LUCE Task Force Motions
10
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
On motion by Member Whitney, seconded by Member Brown, to remove the reference to
“sea cruises” in 3.9.8.D.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Goetz, Meyer, Multari, Rowley, Saunders, and
Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Crotser, Dandekar, Quaglino, and Rossi
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Juhnke, Rademaker, and Richardson
DATE: 11-14-2013
The motion passed on an 8:4 vote.
On motion by Member Rossi, seconded by Member Bremer, to approve the Commercial
and Industrial Development section of the Land Use Element with the modifications agreed
to above.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Juhnke, Rademaker, and Richardson
DATE: 11-14-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Quaglino, to approve all of
the Commercial & Industrial Development changes, except CI 4, listed on page 19 of the
Transmittal Memorandum for this meeting.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Crotser, to approve CI 4 as
presented on page 19 of the Transmittal Memorandum for this meeting.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rossi, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on an 11:2 vote.
LUCE Task Force Motions
11
Chapter 4 – Downtown
On motion by Member Multari, seconded by Member Crotser, to use language in 4.1 that
states, “Entertainment facilities such as nightclubs and theaters shall only be in the
Downtown.”
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Meyer, Multari, Rowley, Saunders,
and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Dandekar and Quaglino
ABSTAINED: Task Force Member Rossi
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Juhnke, Rademaker, and Richardson
DATE: 11-14-2013
The motion passed on a 9:2 vote.
On motion by Member Crotser, seconded by Member Quaglino, to delete the fourth bullet
point in 4.3 and have staff reformulate the sunlight guidelines, motion also to include
direction regarding word changes of “well-lit” and “interesting.”
AYES: Task Force Members Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 11-20-2013
The motion passed on an 11:2 vote.
On motion by Member Crotser, seconded by Member Juhnke, to approve the following
wording for 4.11: “Downtown development nearby publicly-owned gathering places shall
respect views of the hills. In other locations Downtown, views will be provided parallel to
the street right-of-way, at intersections where building separation naturally makes more
views available, and at upper-level viewing decks.”
AYES: Task Force Members Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Multari, Quaglino, Rademaker, and
Richardson
NOES: Task Force Members Meyer, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 11-20-2013
The motion passed on a 8:5 vote.
On motion by Member Goetz, seconded by Member Juhnke, to add a bullet point to 4.14.4
about proximity of housing to convenient transit connections.
AYES: Task Force Members Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Rademaker,
Richardson, and Rossi,
NOES: Task Force Members Quaglino, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
LUCE Task Force Motions
12
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 11-20-2013
The motion passed on a 9:4 vote.
On motion by Member Rossi, seconded by Member Multari, to make two changes to the
first paragraph of 4.14.4 Building Height: 1) replace “set back” with “step back”, 2) replace
“60 feet” with “50 feet”, 3) remove “vertical” from the first sentence, and 4) replace “shall
not obstruct” with “shall respect” in the second sentence.
AYES: Task Force Members, Goetz, Juhnke, Multari, Quaglino, Rademaker , Richardson, and
Rossi
NOES: Task Force Members Brown, Crotser, Meyer, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 11-20-2013
The motion passed on a 7:6 vote.
On motion by Member Rademaker, seconded by Member Juhnke, to approve the Programs
section with the above noted changes.
AYES: Task Force Members Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 11-20-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
On motion by Member Juhnke, and seconded by Member Rademaker, to put a period after
“late night drinking establishments” and delete the list of criteria in DT 7.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, and Saunders
NOES: Task Force Member Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on a 12:1 vote.
On motion by Member Quaglino, and seconded by Member Crotser, to replace “shall
consider” with “shall” in DT 8.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rossi, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
LUCE Task Force Motions
13
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on a 11:2 vote.
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Brown, to approve the
remaining items in the Downtown section of the Transmittal Memorandum for this meeting
as presented with the exception of replacing “over” with “rather than” in DT 2.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
On motion by Member Multari, and seconded by Member Rademaker, to approve the
Safety-related Policies and Programs section on pages 3-4 of the Transmittal Memorandum
for this meeting with these changes: 1) the Crime Prevention Through Environmental
Design program to read as suggested above, 2) the order of the bullets in the same program
be changed so that “Visibility into entry and access points on non-residential buildings” be
the first bullet, 3) that the next program will read “The City, working with the Downtown
Association, businesses, landlords and residents will develop emergency callboxes at
strategic locations in the Downtown” and 4) adding a program that states “The City,
working with the Downtown Association, Downtown businesses, and residents shall
develop a program to encourage lighted storefronts and street frontages throughout the
night.”
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
Chapter 5 – Public & Cultural Facilities
On motion by Member Juhnke, and seconded by Member Crotser, to change the wording of
5.8 to read “The City shall continue to encourage inclusion of public art in all projects as
appropriate.”
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
LUCE Task Force Motions
14
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Brown, to approve the
policies and programs in the Public and Cultural Facilities chapter as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
Chapter 6 – Resource Protection
On motion by Member Juhnke, and second by Member Brown, to approve 6.3.1.1 Madonna
Inn Area as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Multari
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
On motion by Member Quaglino, and seconded by Member Brown, to approve 6.2.7.J and
6.2.7.K as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: Task Force Member Multari
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
On motion by Member Brown, and seconded by Member Bremer, to approve the Resource
Protection chapter as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar, Richardson, and Rossi
LUCE Task Force Motions
15
DATE: 11-25-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
On motion by Member Crotser, seconded by Member Quaglino to replace the words
“previously developed” with “urbanized” in the first paragraph and to delete A-D in the
existing policy.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on an 11:2 vote.
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Bremer, to approve Resource
Protection programs as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
Chapter 7 – Airport Area
On motion by Member Multari, and seconded by Member Juhnke, to refer proposed
updates to policies 7.1. and 7.2, and the two added policies to the Council with the
statement as follows: The Task Force supports the City Council’s efforts to have fact base d
consideration of noise and safety zones and recommends the Council consider the
proposed airport policies and their legal ramifications.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: Task Force Member Richardson
ABSENT: Task Force Member Crotser
DATE: 12-4-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
On motion by Member Multari, and seconded by Member Brown, to include the County
Airport Land Use Plan program with the previous four policies discussed earlier for
consideration at the City Council level.
LUCE Task Force Motions
16
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: Task Force Member Richardson
ABSENT: Task Force Member Crotser
DATE: 12-4-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
On motion by Member Juhnke, and seconded by Member Rossi, to approve the rest of the
airport chapter as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: Task Force Member Richardson
ABSENT: Task Force Member Crotser
DATE: 12-4-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
Chapter 8 – Special Focus Areas
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Brown, to approve the
language about the CalFire/Cal Poly property, North side of Foothill (Bishop Knoll), and the
Alrita properties as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Crotser
DATE: 12-4-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
8.2.1 Foothill Boulevard/Santa Rosa Area
On motion by Member Juhnke, and seconded by Member Richardson, to approve the
section as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Member Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Crotser
DATE: 12-4-2013
The motion passed on a 13:1 vote.
LUCE Task Force Motions
17
Mid-Higuera, Madonna Inn Area, Sunset Drive-in Theatre Area, Pacific Beach Site, Calle Joaquin
Auto Sales Area, LOVR Creekside Area, Broad Street at Tank Farm Road Site
On motion by Task Force Member Rossi, and seconded by Task Force Member Quaglino, to
approve the above sections as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Crotser
DATE: 12-4-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
Interim Open Space zoning
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Richardson, to endorse the
approach to replace the Interim Open Space zoning with policy direction as part of Special
Focus areas for all the properties except the Alrita property and the property on the north
side of Foothill.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on an 11:2 vote.
Introduction
On motion by Member Juhnke, and seconded by Member Crotser, to approve the Special
Focus Areas introduction section as amended to include the addition of “environmental site
constraints” to A, and to split the last paragraph on page 1-123 into two with the second
paragraph beginning, “The additional special planning areas…”.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: Task Force Member Richardson
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on a 10:2 vote.
Margarita Area Specific Plan
On motion by Member Multari, and seconded by Member Crotser, to revise the MASP
section to state, “The City shall consider the Margarita Area Specific Plan as potentially
appropriate for additional residential development.”
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
LUCE Task Force Motions
18
NOES: None
RECUSED: Task Force Member Richardson
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
DALIDIO Chart
On motion by Member Multari, and seconded by Member Bremer, to change the chart to
allow 500 maximum units for housing, leave the commercial at 200,000 sq. ft. maximum,
change office to office/high tech, remove maximum acreage for parks, allow visitor serving
up to 150 rooms, change bullets to letters, change community serving to neighborhood
commercial, and provide clarifying language regarding Prado Road infrastructure .
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
DALIDIO
On motion by Member Multari, and seconded by Member Whitney, that offsite mitigations
for the 50% open space not be allowed.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion failed on a 4:9 vote.
DALIDIO Chart
On motion by Member Juhnke, and seconded by Member Richardson, to add a footnote to
the chart stating that in appropriate circumstances it may be acceptable to substitute not
more than ten percent of required open space off -site.
AYES: Task Force Members Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Quaglino, and Richardson
NOES: Task Force Members Bremer, Dandekar, Meyer, Multari, Rademaker, Rowley, Saunders,
and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion failed on a 5:8 vote.
LUCE Task Force Motions
19
DALIDIO Chart
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Crotser, to add a footnote to
the chart stating that in appropriate circumstances it may be acceptable to substitute not
more than a small portion of on-site open space for offsite open space.
AYES: Task Force Members Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Quaglino, Rademaker, and Richardson
NOES: Task Force Members Bremer, Dandekar, Meyer, Multari, Rowley, Saunders, and
Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion failed on a 6:7 vote.
UPPER MONTEREY
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Whitney, to approve
recommended wording changes for 8.2.2 and include safety to the list of items to be
addressed in a master plan, and inclusion of residents in adjoining areas as well as business
and property owners in developing the master plan for the area .
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
UPPER MONTEREY
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Juhnke, to include evaluation of
Ordinance 1130 as part of the master plan and design guideline development.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown and Rossi
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
Madonna on LOVR
On motion by Member Multari, and seconded by Member Juhnke, to delete the
percentages for 8.1.5 except the 50% for open space/agriculture and assign the designation
CN/CR.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Member Rowley
RECUSED: None
LUCE Task Force Motions
20
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown, Rossi and Saunders
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on a 11:1 vote.
Avila Ranch
On motion by Member Multari, and seconded by Member Junke to add a bullet point to
indicate provision of a neighborhood park, to modify the Airport Area Specific Plan to either
exclude the area or designate it as a special planning area with the AASP, to remove the
percentages, make this area plan consistent with others by providing for a minimum 50%
for open space/agricultural but include an asterisk noting that up to one-third may be
provided offsite or through in lieu fees consistent with the Airport Specific Plan, open space
requirement can be reduced to 30% if RHNA housing affordability levels are met on -site,
shorten the first bullet point with a period after “affordability levels,” add “open space” on
the first line of the third bullet.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: Task Force Member Richardson
ABSENT: Task Force Members Brown, Rossi, Rowley and Saunders
DATE: 11-26-2013
The motion passed on a 11:0 vote.
Chapter 9 - Sustainability
On motion by Member Brown, and seconded by Member Quaglino, to approve this section
as amended, with the exception of the preamble and 9.6.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Crotser
DATE: 12-4-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
On motion by Member Brown, and seconded by Member Bremer, to approve adoption of
the preamble and 9.6 as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Member Rowley
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Crotser
DATE: 12-4-2013
LUCE Task Force Motions
21
The motion passed on a 13:1 vote.
Chapter 10 – Healthy Community
On motion by Member Meyer, and seconded by Member Brown, to approve the Healthy
Community chapter including a new clean air policy and a program to develop a resource
guide to facilitate design that promotes healthy and active lifestyles.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Member Rowley
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Rossi
DATE: 12-5-2013
The motion passed on a 12:1 vote.
On motion by Member Brown, and seconded by Member Rademaker, to approve the
Review and Amendment and Implementation sections as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Rossi
DATE: 12-5-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
LUCE Task Force Motions
22
Task Force Motions – Circulation Element
September 18, 2013 – December 10, 2013
Chapter 1: Introduction, Goals and Objectives
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Crotser, to approve the
following new goal in the Circulation Element: Introduction, Goals, and Objectives:
“Support the development and maintenance of a circulation system that balances the needs
of all circulation modes.”
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Multari
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Rademaker, to approve
modification of the modal share splits to be 50% for vehicles, 10% for public transit, 20% for
bicycles and 20% for walking, car pools and other forms; and also to direct staff to provide
more data to the Planning Commission.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Meyer, Quaglino, Rademaker,
Richardson, and Rossi
NOES: Task Force Members Dandekar, Juhnke, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Multari
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 9:5 vote.
Members Juhnke and Saunders stated that their no vote is based on frustration about not
having the data to back up the modal splits. Member Saunders stated that she regretted not
having the opportunity to vote just on the bicycle share.
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Bremer, to approve Figure 1
Modal Split Objectives as presented except for the changes to the modal split approved in
the last motion.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Meyer, Quaglino, Rademaker, and
Rossi
NOES: Task Force Members Dandekar, Juhnke, Richardson, Rowley, and Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Multari
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 8:5 vote.
LUCE Task Force Motions
23
Chapter 2 – Traffic Reduction
On motion by Committee Member Juhnke, seconded by Committee Member Rowley, to not
delete the first sentence in the Introduction on page 2-12.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyers, Multari,
Quaglino, Richardson, Rademaker, Rowley, Saunders, and
Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSTAIN: Committee Member Rossi
ABSENT: Committee Member Crotser
DATE: 9-18-2013
The motion passed on a 13-0 vote.
On motion by Committee Member Multari, seconded by Committee Member Brown, to
accept the recommended changes in wording for 2.0.1 Multi-level Programs.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyers, Multari,
Quaglino, Richardson, Rademaker, Rossi, and Whitney
NOES: Committee Members Rowley and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Member Crotser
DATE: 9-18-2013
The motion passed on a 12-2 vote.
On motion by Committee Member Rowley, seconded by Committee Member Brown, to
support the recommended changes but to remove the wording “when appropriate” from
2.0.2 Flexible Work Schedules.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Brown, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyers, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: Committee Members Dandekar, Richardson, and Rossi
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Member Crotser
DATE: 9-18-2013
The motion passed on an 11-3 vote.
On motion by Committee Member Multari, seconded by Committee Member Brown to
amend the draft language to “The City shall encourage employers within the city limits to
work with the County to encourage employers outside the City limits to participate in trip -
reduction programs, including commuter benefit options to reduce the amount of
commuters who drive alone in their vehicles.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyers,
Multari, Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and
Whitney
LUCE Task Force Motions
24
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSTAIN: Committee Member Rossi
ABSENT: Committee Member Crotser
DATE: 9-18-2013
The motion passed on a 13-0 vote (Rossi abstained; Crotser absent).
On motion by Committee Member Rademaker, seconded by Committee Member Juhnke, to
accept the proposed wording for 2.0.4 Downtown Congestion with the addition of the
language “establish and” prior to the word “promote.”
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyers,
Multari, Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and
Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Member Crotser
DATE: 9-18-2013
The motion passed on a 14-0 vote (Crotser absent).
On motion by Committee Member Juhnke, seconded by Committee Member Bremer, to
use the following language in 2.1.1: “The City shall participate and cooperate with county
agency efforts in establishing countywide trip-reduction programs.”
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Multari, Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, and Saunders
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSTAIN: Committee Members Rossi and Whitney
ABSENT: Committee Member Crotser
DATE: 9-18-2013
The motion passed on a 12-0 vote (Rossi and Whitney abstained; Crotser absent).
On motion by Committee Member Rowley, seconded by Committee Member Rademaker,
to accept the recommended deletion to the wording of 2.1.2 Average Vehicle Ridership.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyers, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney.
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSTAIN: Committee Members Brown and Rossi
ABSENT: Committee Member Crotser
DATE: 9-18-2013
The motion passed on a 12-0 vote (Brown and Rossi abstained; Crotser absent).
LUCE Task Force Motions
25
On motion by Committee Member Quaglino, seconded by Committee Member Brown, to
approve recommended changes for 2.1.3 Trip Reduction.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Brown, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyers,
Multari, Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and
Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSTAIN: Committee Member Rossi
ABSENT: Committee Member Crotser
DATE: 9-18-2013
The motion passed on a 13-0 vote (Rossi abstained; Crotser absent).
On motion by Committee Member Multari, seconded by Committee Member Richardson,
to approve the following wording for 2.1.4 City Trip Reduction: Th e City shall maintain and,
where cost effective, improve its trip-reduction plan for City employees.
AYES: Committee Members Bremer, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyers, Multari,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, and Saunders
NOES: Committee Member Whitney
RECUSED: None
ABSTAIN: Committee Member Brown
ABSENT: Committee Member Crotser
DATE: 9-18-2013
The motion passed on a 12-1 vote (Brown abstained; Crotser absent).
On motion by Comm. Member Saunders, seconded by Comm. Member Rademaker, to
retain the references to air quality in 2.0.5 with original language.
AYES: Task Force Members Brown, Rademaker, Rowley, Saunders, Whitney
NOES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Multari,
Quaglino, Richardson, Rossi, and Meyer
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 10-30-2013
The motion failed on a 5:10 vote.
On motion by Member Juhnke to recommend language for 2.0.5 as follows: The City will
support programs that reduce traffic congestion and maintain air quality. If air quality
degrades below legal standards, or level of service (LOS) standards are exceeded, the City
will pursue more stringent measures to achieve its transportation goals.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Multari, Quaglino, Richardson, Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, and Whitney
NOES: Task Force Member Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 10-30-2013
LUCE Task Force Motions
26
The motion passed on a 14:1 vote.
Chapter 3 – Transit Service
On motion by Task Force Member Brown, and seconded by Task Force Member Quaglino,
to support the Transit Services section revisions as discussed with the exception of Program
3.1.3.
AYES: Members Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino, Rademaker,
Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Members Bremer, Juhnke, and Rossi
DATE: 10-2-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
On motion by Task Force Member Brown, and seconded by Task Force Member Crotser, to
support Program 3.1.3 as written.
AYES: Members Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino, Rademaker,
Richardson, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: Member Rowley
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Members Bremer, Juhnke, and Rossi
DATE: 10-2-2013
The motion passed on an 11:1 vote.
On motion by Member Brown, seconded by Member Rademaker, to approve 3.0.6 as
presented (with correction of letter assignments A-D under 3.0.6).
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Multari, Quaglino, Richardson, Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 10-30-2013
The motion passed on a 15:0 vote.
LUCE Task Force Motions
27
Chapter 4 – Bicycle Transportation
On motion by Task Force Member Quaglino, and seconded by Task Force Member Brown,
to support the Bicycle Transportation policies revisions as discussed.
AYES: Committee Members Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, Richardson, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Committee Members Bremer, Juhnke, and Rossi
DATE: 10-2-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
Task Force members revised Policy 4.0.3 in light of the discussions and agreed to add language
to 4.0.3: The City shall collaborate with SLO County to coordinate planning and development of
county bikeways to support a regional bike network and identify and acquire additional rights of
way as they become available.
On motion by Task Force Member Quaglino, and seconded by Task Force Member
Rademaker, to approve the programs discussed and agreed upon in 4.1 and the revised
policy 4.0.3.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Multari, Quaglino, Rowley,
Saunders, Whitney, Rademaker, and Meyer
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar, Richardson, and Rossi
DATE: 10-16-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
On motion Member Rossi, seconded by Member Brown, to recommend deletion of 4.0.7
and the addition of the new program and the two new policies listed above.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Multari, Quaglino, Richardson, Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 10-30-2013
The motion passed on a 15:0 vote.
LUCE Task Force Motions
28
Chapter 5 - Walking
On motion by Member Juhnke, and seconded by Member Bremer, to approve the policies
and programs in Section 5 as discussed and agreed upon.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Multari, Quaglino, Rowley,
Saunders, Whitney, Rademaker, and Meyer
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar, Richardson, and Rossi
DATE: 10-16-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
As allowed by the American with Disabilities Act, the City shall consider existing
neighborhood character, including topography, street design, existing density, and
connectivity when identifying and prioritizing the installation of sidewalks .
On motion by Member Saunders, seconded by Member Brown to use Member Multari’s
language listed above for this new policy.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Multari, Quaglino, Richardson, Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 10-30-2013
The motion passed on a 15:0 vote.
Chapter 6 – Multi-modal Circulation (replaces Chapter 8, Traffic Flow)
On motion by Member Rowley, seconded by Member Juhnke, to change the minimum LOS
standard for bicycles from C to D and add this word “shall” before “maintain level of service
minimums” in Policy 6.0.B.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Multari, Quaglino,
Richardson, Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders and Whitney
NOES: Brown and Meyer
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 10-30-2013
The motion passed on a 13:2 vote.
On motion by Member Rademaker, seconded by Member Crotser, to approve the footnote
language as amended for Table 6.0.1 as follows:
LUCE Task Force Motions
29
Exceptions to minimum pedestrian LOS objectives & standards may apply when it is
determined that sidewalks are not consistent with neighborhood character, including
topography, street design, and existing density.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Richardson, Rademaker, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 10-30-2013
The motion passed on a 15:0 vote.
On motion by Member Juhnke, seconded by Member Crotser, to approve the Multimodal
Priorities section as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Richardson, Rademaker, Rowley, Saunders and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Member Rossi
DATE: 10-30-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
Chapter 7 (Chapter 6 in TF version) – Traffic Management
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Rademaker, to remove “desired”
where it appears in the Circulation Element description table.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Rossi, to approve the Description
and Standards for Figure 2 with the following changes: retain the sentences struck out in
Note 1, add wording to indicate that the traffic counts are done when schools are in
session, correct the end of the last sentence in Note 1 to read “up to 15%,” delete “desired”
in the Circulation Element table, and define the street segments of Broad Street.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
LUCE Task Force Motions
30
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
Chapter 8 (Chapter 7 in TF version) – Neighborhood Traffic Management
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Brown, to approve section 7 as
amended and with those sections referenced that will return for further discussion at a
future meeting.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rowley, Saunders, Rademaker, Rossi, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 10-17-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
Policy 8.1.2
On motion by Member Richardson, and seconded by Member Dandekar, to delete the new
policy and replace it with the first sentence of the old language: “The City will undertake
measures to control traffic in residential areas where traffic speeds or volumes exceed
standards set by policy 5.2.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Dandekar, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Quaglino, Rademaker, Richardson, Rossi, Rowley, Saunders, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: None
DATE: 12-10-2013
The motion passed on a 14:0 vote.
Chapter 9 – Street Network Changes
On motion by Member Brown, and seconded by Member Rowley, to approve Section 9
as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer,
Multari, Quaglino, Rowley, Saunders, Rademaker, Rossi, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 10-17-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
LUCE Task Force Motions
31
Chapter 10 – Truck Transportation (Policies are numbered 9 in TF-LUCE
draft)
On motion by Member Brown, and seconded by Member Rowley, to approve Section 9 as
amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz , Juhnke, Meyer, Multari,
Quaglino, Rowley, Saunders, Rademaker, Rossi, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 10-17-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
Chapter 11 – Air Transportation
The Task Force made no changes to this section.
Chapter 12 – Rail Transportation
On motion by Member Quaglino, and seconded by Member Crotser, to approve the Rail
Transportation section as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Multari, Quaglino,
Saunders, Whitney, Rademaker, and Meyer
NOES: Task Force Member Rowley
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar, Richardson, and Rossi
DATE: 10-16-2013
The motion passed on an 11:1 vote.
Member Rowley stated she voted no because she does not believe the intent of the word
“support” in 10.0.2 is clear.
LUCE Task Force Motions
32
Chapter 13– Parking Management
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Brown, to approve the
Parking Management section as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Multari, Quaglino, Rowley,
Saunders, Whitney, Rademaker, and Meyer
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar, Richardson, and Rossi
DATE: 10-16-2013
The motion passed on a 12:0 vote.
Chapter 14 – Neighborhood Parking Management
The Task Force approved this section as proposed.
Chapter 15– Scenic Roadways
On motion by Member Rademaker, and seconded by Member Crotser, to approve the
Scenic Roadways as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rowley, Saunders, Rademaker, Rossi, and Whitney
NOES: None
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 10-17-2013
The motion passed on a 13:0 vote.
Chapter 16– Circ. Element Implementation
On motion by Member Crotser, and seconded by Member Brown, to approve the
Circulation Element Implementation and Management section as amended.
AYES: Task Force Members Bremer, Brown, Crotser, Goetz, Juhnke, Meyer, Multari, Quaglino,
Rademaker, and Rossi
NOES: Task Force Members Rowley, Whitney, and Saunders
RECUSED: None
ABSENT: Task Force Members Dandekar and Richardson
DATE: 10-17-2013
The motion passed on a 10:3 vote.