HomeMy WebLinkAboutBates 11312-11318 - 4-19-17 Airport Land Use Commission MinutesMinutes of Wednesday, April 19, 2017
Minutes of the Regular Meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission held in the (new)
County Board of Supervisors Chambers, County Government Center 1055 Monterey
Street, Room D170, San Luis Obispo, CA, at 01:30 P.M.
HEARINGS ARE ADVERTISED FOR 1:30 P.M. HOWEVER, HEARINGS GENERALLY
PROCEED IN THE ORDER LISTED. THIS TIME IS ONLY AN ESTIMATE AND IS NOT TO BE
CONSIDERED AS TIME GUARANTEED. THE PUBLIC AND APPLICANTS ARE ADVISED
TO ARRIVE EARLY.
ROLL CALL
PRESENT:Erich Schaefer, William Borgsmiller, Michael Cripe, Craig Piper, Chairperson
Roger Oxborrow, and Linda Butler
ABSENT:Allen Settle
PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD
Chairman Oxborrow: opens and closes public comment with no one coming forward.
STAFF UPDATES
Brian Pedrotti, Airports Planner: reviews ALUC appointments. Chairman Roger
Oxborrow was reappointed by the Airports Manager to another term. Commissioner
Cripe's appointment ends on May 1, 2017 and will be reappointed by the Board of
Supervisors.
DISCUSSION
1. County of San Luis Obispo: discussion item for a future proposed subdivision at
property east of Highway 227 near San Luis Obispo Country Club (APN
044-082-035); Chuck Braff, Applicant.
Agent Email
Brian Pedrotti, Airports Planner: provides presentation for discussion.
Commissioner Schaefer: states for the record a point of clarification that this project
is on the west side of Highway 227.
Charles Braff, Applicant: discusses the proposed project.
Commissioner Cripe: questions if the surrounding properties are one-acre lots with
Brian Pedrotti responding.
Airport Land Use Commission https://slocounty.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=57&clip_i...
1 of 7 12/22/2020, 10:17 AM
11312
Commissioner Piper: discusses the concern for the noise and have them complete
the disclosures.
Commissioner Borgsmiller: questions if there is any tool that will help with the noise
complaints.
Matter is fully discussed, Commissioners express comments to the applicant; no
action taken.
2. City/County of San Luis Obispo: discussion item for a future General Plan
Amendment and Specific Plan for the Froom Ranch Area, directly south of the
Irish Hills Plaza (APNs 067-241-030, -031; RRM Design Group, Applicant.
Agent_RRM Letter
Attachment 1: Agent Email
Brian Pedrotti, Airports Planner: presents the proposed property for discussion.
Vic Montgomery, Agent: states he is available for questions.
Commissioner Borgsmiller: states he likes the Cannon map and agrees with using
this map.
Commissioner Cripe: addresses the use of the Cannon map.
Commissioner Piper: in agreement of using the Cannon Map.
Chairman Oxborrow: questions if we update the map then will this project be out of
the commissioner purview with Brian Pedrotti responding.
Matter is fully discussed; no action taken.
HEARINGS:
3. A continued hearing to consider a mandatory referral by the City of San Luis
Obispo (City) for a determination of consistency or inconsistency with the Airport
Land Use Plan (ALUP) for the San Luis Obispo County Regional Airport (Airport)
for proposed amendments to the City’s General Plan, the City Zoning Map, the City
Airport Compatible Open Space (ACOS) Plan, And Vesting Tentative Map to
implement the San Luis Ranch Development. The San Luis Ranch Specific Plan
encompasses approximately 131 acres generally bounded by Madonna Road,
Dalidio Drive, US Highway 101, and the San Luis Obispo City Farm. The Project is
located in ALUP Aviation Safety Areas S-1b and S-2. (Continued from March 29,
2017) City Project Manager: Brian LeVeille
Staff Report
Attachment 2: Modified Site Plan
Attachment 3: City of SLO Letter
Attachment 4: March 29, 2017 Staff Report
Airport Land Use Commission https://slocounty.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=57&clip_i...
2 of 7 12/22/2020, 10:17 AM
11313
March 29, 2017_Attachment 1
March 29, 2017_Attachment 2_rev
March 29, 2017_Attachment 3_rev
March 29, 2017_Attachment 4_rev
March 29, 2017_Attachment 5_rev
March 29, 2017_Attachment 6_rev
March 29, 2017_Attachment 7
March 29, 2017_Attachment 8_rev
March 29, 2017_Attachment 9
March 29, 2017_Attachment 10
March 29, 2017_Attachment 11
March 29, 2017_Attachment 12
Correspondence Received from Craig Kincaid
Correspondence Received from Kristin Flynn
Correspondence Received from Ryan Miller
Brian Pedrotti, Airports Planner: presents proposed project via PowerPoint.
Commissioner Schaefer: questions Condition 10 with Brian Pedrotti responding.
Commissioner Borgsmiller: questions if we can pull up the language from the Avila
Ranch project regarding providing for community outreach with Brian Pedrotti
responding.
Xzandrea Fowler, City of San Luis Obispo: questions if the applicant should present
first with Chairman Oxborrow responding.
Rachel Kovesdi, Agent: presents report via PowerPoint and is available for
questions.
Commissioner Schaefer: requests clarification on the proposed project with Ms.
Kovesdi responding.
Gary Grossman, Owner: thanks staff and his team and discusses the safety of the
proposed project.
Xzandrea Fowler, City of San Luis Obispo: discusses the proposed project.
Airport Land Use Commission https://slocounty.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=57&clip_i...
3 of 7 12/22/2020, 10:17 AM
11314
Doug Davidson, Deputy Director for Development Review, City of San Luis Obispo:
discusses the City's future involvement with the proposed project.
Chairman Oxborrow: discusses past projects and requests clarification on what
entitlements stay with the property. Bill Robeson, County Deputy Director
responding.
Commissioner Schaefer: requests clarification on "project specific" with Bill
Robeson, County Deputy Director responding.
Commissioner Cripe: states the no build zone, the location of the no build zone and
center line are locked in.
Chairman Oxborrow: opens public comment.
Jeff Echles, Executive Director of the Home Builders Associates of the Central
Coast: discusses the proposed project.
Carl Dudley, resident of SLO: discusses the proposed project.
Kevin Huwbert, Senior Loan Officer, Mortgage House, City of SLO: states reasons
to approval of the proposed property.
Tim Williams, Resident of SLO: discusses reasons for approval of the proposed
project.
Mike Manchak, President & CEO, Economic Vitality Corporation: discusses options
of affordable housing and availability of housing.
Steve Delmartini, Resident of SLO: discusses reasons for approval of the proposed
project.
John Spigelski, Resident of SLO: suggests approval of the proposed project.
Rob Davidson, Resident of SLO: speaks in favor of the proposed project.
Chairman Oxborrow: closes public comment.
Commissioner Piper: questions a commercial zone space within the no build zone
and safety features with Ms. Kovesdi responding.
Commissioner Schaefer: discusses Measure J and the viability for this project. The
water supply is adequate.
On motion of Commissioner Schaefer, seconded by Commissioner Butler for a
determination of consistency with the Airport Land Use Plan (ALUP) for the San Luis
Obispo County Regional Airport (Airport) for proposed amendments to the City’s
General Plan, the City Zoning Map, the City Airport Compatible Open Space
(ACOS) Plan, And Vesting Tentative Map to implement the San Luis Ranch
Development with the second recommendations and findings and conditions of
approval is discussed further.
Commissioner Borgsmiller: discusses Measure J and the San Luis Ranch project.
Would like to add the Community Outreach used in the Avila Ranch Project. Modify
Airport Land Use Commission https://slocounty.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=57&clip_i...
4 of 7 12/22/2020, 10:17 AM
11315
the 1200 x 200 condition and suggest parallel lanes in the no build zone.
On motion of Commissioner Schaefer, seconded by Commissioner Butler to amend
as stated adding the Community Outreach plan used in the Avila Ranch Project and
modifying the 1200' x 200' traffic lanes parallel to the parking stalls in the no build
zone is further discussed.
Commissioner Cripe: agrees with other Commissioners that the project is ready for
approval.
Brian Pedrotti, Airports Planner: clarifies the requested additional condition
regarding Avila Ranch Community Outreach. Unable to find that condition in the
Avila Ranch Project conditions, staff suggests creating/crafting a new condition.
Discussion with Commissioner Borgsmiller and staff.
Bill Robeson, County Deputy Director: clarifies the 1200' x 200' parking lanes
parallel to the center line of the runway.
Mike Cannon, Cannon Associates: speaks to creating a new layout for the parking
lanes. Marshall H. representing the owner agrees to the parking lane stipulation.
Thereafter, on motion of Commissioner Erich Schaefer, seconded by
Commissioner Linda Butler and on the following vote:
AYES: Commissioners: Erich Schaefer, Linda Butler, William Borgsmiller,
Michael Cripe, Craig Piper, Chairperson Roger Oxborrow,
NOES: None
ABSENT: Allen Settle
The motion carries on an all yes vote in the absence of Commissioner Settle
for the determination of consistency with the San Luis Obispo County
Regional Airport Land Use Plan (ALUP) and is referred back to the City of San
Luis Obispo regarding for proposed amendments to the City’s General Plan,
the City Zoning Map, the City Airport Compatible Open Space (ACOS) Plan,
And Vesting Tentative Map to implement the San Luis Ranch Development
with the adoption of staff recommendation 2 of the staff report as modified,
and recommended by staff.
4. Continued hearing to consider a request by the County of San Luis Obispo
(County) and the City of San Luis Obispo (City) to the Airport Land Use
Commission (ALUC), for consideration and possible adoption of a draft update
amendment to the San Luis Obispo County Regional Airport Land Use Plan
(ALUP) for the San Luis Obispo County Regional Airport. [Continued from April 17,
2013 - March 29, 2017] County Airports Planner: Brian Pedrotti
Staff Report
Brian Pedrotti, Airports Planner: discusses RS&H working draft, the ALUC
subcommittee has looked at it. Staff recommends that this item is continued to May
24, 2017.
Commissioner Cripe: states sub-committee needs to review a couple of graphics of
the safety zones and comparative airports and safety zones.
Airport Land Use Commission https://slocounty.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=57&clip_i...
5 of 7 12/22/2020, 10:17 AM
11316
Commissioner Borgsmiller: asks when will be this available for ALUC to review with
Brian Pedrotti responding.
Chairman Oxborrow: opens and closes public comment with no one coming
forward.
Thereafter, on motion of Commissioner William Borgsmiller, seconded by
Commissioner Erich Schaefer and on the following vote:
AYES: Commissioners: William Borgsmiller, Erich Schaefer, Michael Cripe,
Craig Piper, Chairperson Roger Oxborrow, Linda Butler
NOES: None
ABSENT: Allen Settle
The motion carries on an all yes vote in the absence of Commissioner Settle
to continue this item to the next Airport Land Use Commission meeting on
May 24, 2017 regarding the consideration of a request by the County of San
Luis Obispo (County) and the City of San Luis Obispo (City) to the Airport
Land Use Commission (ALUC), for consideration and possible adoption of a
draft update amendment to the San Luis Obispo County Regional Airport Land
Use Plan (ALUP) for the San Luis Obispo County Regional Airport as
recommended in staff report memo.
AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION (ALUC) BUSINESS:
5. Airport Advisory Collaborative (AAC) Subcommittee. Applications and
recommendations submitted to the ALUC for appointment consideration.
Attachment 1: Caltrans Coverletter AAC Recommendation
Attachment 2: Application
Brian Pedrotti, Airports Planner: discusses appointment of AAC subcommittee
member John Olejnki from CalTrans.
Chairman Oxborrow: opens and closes public comment with no one coming forward.
Thereafter, on motion of Commissioner Craig Piper, seconded by
Commissioner Erich Schaefer and on the following vote:
AYES: Commissioners: Craig Piper, Erich Schaefer, William Borgsmiller,
Michael Cripe, Chairperson Roger Oxborrow, Linda Butler
NOES: None
ABSENT: Allen Settle
The motion carries on an all yes vote in the absence of Commissioner Settle
to accept the nomination of Caltrans employee John Olejnki to the Airport
Advisory Collaborative (AAC) Subcommittee as recommended.
6. Receive and File: All Correspondence and Exhibits if received at this meeting.
Airport Land Use Commission https://slocounty.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=57&clip_i...
6 of 7 12/22/2020, 10:17 AM
11317
Thereafter, on motion of Commissioner William Borgsmiller, seconded by
Commissioner Craig Piper and on the following vote:
AYES: Commissioners: William Borgsmiller, Craig Piper, Erich Schaefer,
Michael Cripe, Chairperson Roger Oxborrow, Linda Butler
NOES: None
ABSENT: Allen Settle
The motion carries on an all yes vote in the absence of Commissioner Settle
to accept all correspondence and exhibits received for this meeting in the
ALUC record.
ADJOURNMENT:
7. Next Scheduled Meeting: Wednesday May 24, 2017, at 1:30 p.m. in the County
Board of Supervisors Chambers, (new) County Government Center, 1055 Monterey
Street, Room D170, San Luis Obispo, CA. For additional information, please
contact Nicole Retana, Airport Land Use Commission Secretary, at (805)781-5718
or at E-mail address: NRetana@co.slo.ca.us
Thereafter, on motion of Commissioner William Borgsmiller, seconded by
Commissioner Craig Piper and on the following vote:
AYES: Commissioners: William Borgsmiller, Craig Piper, Erich Schaefer,
Michael Cripe, Chairperson Roger Oxborrow, Linda Butler
NOES: None
ABSENT: Allen Settle
The motion carries on an all yes vote in the absence of Commissioner Settle
to adjourn this meeting to the next Airport Land Use Commission meeting on
Wednesday May 24, 2017.
ADJOURNMENT: 3:35 p.m.
Chris Macek, Pro Tem
Airport Land Use Commission
Airport Land Use Commission https://slocounty.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=57&clip_i...
7 of 7 12/22/2020, 10:17 AM
11318