Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 4a. 1130 Orcutt Rd (ARCH-0529-2023) ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMISSION AGENDA REPORT SUBJECT: REVIEW OF A NEW 16-UNIT MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT, ADU, AND ASSOCIATED SITE DEVELOPMENTS WITH A REQUEST TO ALLOW FOR AN ADU GREATER THAN 1,000 SQUARE FEET AND THE REMOVAL OF 17 TREES FILE NUMBER: ARCH-0529-2023 BY: Cassidy Bewley, Contract Planner Phone Number: (805) 539-2867 PROJECT ADDRESS: 1130 Orcutt Road Email: cassidy.bewley@swca.com APPLICANT: Nathan Love FROM: Rachel Cohen, Senior Planner REPRESENTATIVE: Will Ruoff, 4Creeks, Inc. RECOMMENDATION Review the proposed project in terms of its consistency with the Community Design Guidelines and provide recommendations to the Community Development Director. 1.0 PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND SETTING Nathan Love (Applicant) has applied for a Moderate Development Review (ARCH-0529- 2023) to allow for the demolition of an existing 4,000-square-foot building and construction of a multi-family residential development consisting of eight one-bedroom units and eight two-bedroom units and a detached three-bedroom, 1,200-square-foot accessory dwelling unit (ADU) on a 0.675-acre parcel (Assessor Parcel Number [APN] 004-962-031) located in the Medium-High Density Residential (R-3) zone (project). The project includes a request for an exception to allow for development of an ADU greater than 1,000 square feet in size and to allow for four compact off-street parking spaces. To offset the compact parking spaces, the project includes eight additional guest bicycle parking spaces beyond what would otherwise be required by City Zoning Regulations. The multi-family residential units would be accommodated within six, two-story duplex buildings and the proposed ADU would be two stories tall as well (see Table 1). Each one-bedroom unit would be between 717 square feet and 763 square feet in size and all one-bedroom units would be accommodated within two buildings, four units each. Each two-story unit would be between 1,476 square feet and 1,556 square feet in size and all two-bedroom units would be accommodated within four buildings, two units each. The project also includes a request to modify an existing drainage easement on-site (see Attachment A, Project Plans, for more information). Meeting Date: 5/6/2024 Item Number: 4a Time Estimate: 25 Minutes Page 9 of 67 Item 4a ARCH-0529-2023 (1130 Orcutt Road) Architectural Review Commission Report – May 6, 2024 Table 1. Summary of proposed residential uses. Residential Housing Type Unit Size Number of Units Proposed Configuration Maximum Height Multi-Family Residential 1- bedroom unit 717 sf – 763 sf 8 Two buildings, four units each 20 feet, 11 inches Multi-Family Residential 2- bedroom unit 1,476 sf – 1,556 sf 8 Four buildings, two units each 29 feet Accessory Dwelling Unit 1,200 sf 1 One detached building 26 feet, 9 inches Total 17 Units 7 Buildings Demolition activities would include demolition and removal of the existing 4,000 -square- foot Montessori school and daycare center, an outdoor barbeque, a shed, fencing, and existing parking lot. The existing water well and meter located adjacent to the southern boundary of the project site would be capped and abandoned. The existing trash enclosure would also be removed. The project would include site improvements including installation on -site water lines, installation of a backflow preventer per City standards, installation of new water meters, installation of sewer service lines within the site and a new connection to existing City wastewater infrastructure. Underground electrical service would be installed throughout the project site and connect to a new transformer to be installed on a concrete pad in the northeast corner of the project site by Pacific Gas & Electric. The project would include on-site amenities including construction of a new trash enclosure with a steel canopy, a parking lot, and landscaping. The proposed trash enclosure would be located within a 6 - foot-tall concrete masonry unit (CMU) wall with a 4-foot-tall steel canopy, totaling 10 feet in height above natural grade. The project would retain the existing vehicle access driveway from Fernwood Drive and would add a pedestrian access walkway to the site from the project frontage facing Orcutt Road. The project would include 22 vehicle parking spaces. There are currently 16 trees located within the project site, as well as four street trees located within the right-of-way along the project frontage adjacent to Fernwood Drive. An arborist report was prepared to assess the health, construction impacts, and feasibility of tree retention and/or protection within the project site. Based on the proposed building plan, the arborist report concluded there was no way to adequately protect the existing trees on-site. Accordingly, the report recommended 17 trees to be removed to accommodate construction of the project, with retention of three existing street trees. The project includes a proposed landscaping plan that includes planting 17 trees on -site. General Location: The project is located at 1130 Orcutt Road, on a 0.675-acre parcel (29,410 square feet) (Assessor Parcel Number [APN] 004-962-031). The site is primarily accessed from an existing driveway off of Fernwood Drive (Figure 1). Page 10 of 67 Item 4a ARCH-0529-2023 (1130 Orcutt Road) Architectural Review Commission Report – May 6, 2024 General Plan Land Use Designation: Medium-High Density Residential Zoning Designation: Medium-High Density Residential (R-3) Surrounding Zoning Designations and Uses: East: Fernwood Drive, (R-1) Single Family Residences West: (R-3) Multi-family Residences North: (R-3) Multi-family Residences South: Orcutt Road, (R-2) Mobile home park 2.0 PROPOSED DESIGN Architecture: Contemporary Prairie style1 Design details: Buildings have refined finishes such as stone paneling and prairie style architecture, and careful consideration was placed into the massing and separation of each of the buildings to allow for additional light to enter each unit and provide elevation relief and rhythm. Materials: Stucco and ceramic panel cladding with fiber cement shiplap siding, metal railing, vinyl windows and sliding doors, composite roof shingles Colors: Natural color palettes consisting of grays, beiges, whites, bronze, and green are proposed. 1 Prairie style architecture is generally defined as an architectural style that emphasizes horizontal elements of development rather than vertical elements, low-profile rooflines, open floor plans, and incorporation of natural elements of design with minimalist aspects of design. Figure 1: Subject Property Location Page 11 of 67 Item 4a ARCH-0529-2023 (1130 Orcutt Road) Architectural Review Commission Report – May 6, 2024 3.0 PROJECT STATISTICS Staff have evaluated the project for consistency with relevant development standards of the Zoning Regulations and have summarized its compliance in Tables 2 and 3 below. As noted above, two exceptions from development standards are requested as part of this application, including a request for an exception to allow for development of an ADU Figure 3: Rendering of Proposed Project from Orcutt Road View Figure 2: Rendering of Proposed Project from the Interior / Back Page 12 of 67 Item 4a ARCH-0529-2023 (1130 Orcutt Road) Architectural Review Commission Report – May 6, 2024 greater than 1,000 square feet in size and to allow for four compact off -street parking spaces. Table 2. Project Compliance with the Zoning Regulations Development Standards Site Details Proposed Allowed/Required* R-3 Zone Development Standards Minimum Setbacks Front Corner Lot - Street Side Interior Side Rear Parking Spaces 10 feet 10 feet See Table 4 7 feet 20 feet 10 feet 10 feet See Table 4 7 feet 20 feet Maximum Building Height 29 feet 35 Feet Maximum Lot Coverage 33.85% 60% Minimum Lot Area 29,346 square feet 5,000 square feet Maximum Density 13.28 13.47 Affordable Housing On-site (1 low-income unit) On-site (1 low-income unit) or in-lieu fee Parking and Loading Standards Total Number of Vehicle Spaces Standard Vehicle Spaces Guest Vehicle Spaces ADA-Compliant EV Ready EV Capable 18 14 4 2 3 11 18 14 4 1 3 11 Bicycle Spaces Short-term Long-term 12 34 4 34 Motorcycle Parking 2 0 Tree Removal Replacement Plantings 17 trees removed; 17 trees to be replanted on-site 1:1 replacement planting ratio Environmental Status Categorically exempt from environmental review under CEQA Guidelines section 15332 (Class 32, Infill Development Projects) *2022 Zoning Regulations Page 13 of 67 Item 4a ARCH-0529-2023 (1130 Orcutt Road) Architectural Review Commission Report – May 6, 2024 Table 3. Building Interior Tiered Side Setbacks Building Type First Floor Height First Floor Proposed Interior Side Setback First Floor Required Interior Side Setback Second Floor Height Second Floor Proposed Interior Side Setback Second Floor Required Side Setback 1 Bedroom Unit Building 10 feet 2 inches 5 feet 5 feet 20 feet 11 inches 8 feet 7 feet ADU 10 feet 2 inches 7 feet 5 feet 22 feet 6 inches 7 feet 7 feet 4.0 FOCUS OF REVIEW The ARC’s role is to 1) review the proposed project in terms of consistency with the Community Design Guidelines (CDG) and applicable City Standards, and 2) provide comments and recommendations to the Director concerning the proposed project design, focusing on building architecture and site layout. 5.0 COMMUNITY DESIGN GUIDELINES / DISCUSSION ITEMS Staff have evaluated the project for consistency with relevant standards and guidelines of the CDG, including Chapter 5 (Residential Project Design) and Chapter 6 (Site Planning and Other Design Details). Overall, the proposed project appears to be generally consistent with the CDG. Staff have identified three discussion items for the ARC related to the project’s consistency with the CDG in Table 4, below. Table 4. CDG Consistency Discussion Items Highlighted Sections Discussion Items Chapter 5 – Residential Project Design 5.2(F). Exterior finish materials should be durable and require low maintenance. The use of combined materials can provide visual interest and texture; however, all sides of each multi-family structure should have a carefully designed and detailed façade facing the street, and use bland, featureless stucco or other simple materials on the other exterior building walls. Each residential structure should look like the same building from all sides. As shown in Figure 2, the proposed project design would have well-designed facades facing Orcutt Road including stone paneling and balconies, building facades facing Fernwood Drive would also have these design features. Walls facing the interior of the site include plain, painted stucco and shiplap siding, but no stone paneling. The ARC should discuss whether the proposed combination of materials provides sufficient visual interest and texture on all elevations of the residences. 5.4(A). Site planning for a multi-family or clustered housing project should create a pleasant, comfortable, safe, and distinct place for residents, without the project “turning its back” on the surrounding neighborhood. Higher Proposed ground floor units would have balconies that face the project frontages along Orcutt Road and Fernwood Drive and unit entrances that face towards the parking area. The project includes two pedestrian paths that would lead from the interior of Page 14 of 67 Item 4a ARCH-0529-2023 (1130 Orcutt Road) Architectural Review Commission Report – May 6, 2024 Highlighted Sections Discussion Items density projects should be designed either with ground floor units having individual sidewalk entrances, or as courtyard projects with at least one significant pedestrian entrance from the street sidewalk. the site to the existing sidewalks along Orcutt Road and Fernwood Drive. However, based on the conceptual rendering of the project as viewed from Orcutt Road, these entrances appear narrow and are located between the two-story buildings. The ARC should discuss whether the proposed locations of the front entrances and pedestri an entrances to the project are consistent with this standard. Chapter 6 – Site Planning and Other Design Details 6.1(D.1). All mechanical equipment should be concealed from view of public streets, and neighboring properties, and should be insulated as necessary to prevent noise generated by the equipment from being audible off the property. The project includes a new transformer to be located at ground level within the 10-foot setback from Fernwood Drive. Based on project site plans, there would be little to no visual screening of this equipment from viewers traveling along Fernwood Drive. The ARC should discuss whether the proposed transformer should have additional screening. 6.0 ACTION ALTERNATIVES 6.1 Recommend findings of consistency with the Community Design Guidelines. An action recommending approval of the application based on consistency with the Community Design Guidelines will be forwarded to the Director for final action. This action may include recommendations for conditions to address consistency with the Community Design Guidelines. 6.2 Continue the project to a hearing date certain, or uncertain. An action continuing the application should include direction to the applicant and staff on pertinent issues. 6.3 Recommend findings of inconsistency with the Community Design Guidelines. An action recommending denial of the application should include findings that cite the basis for denial and should reference inconsistency with the General Plan, Community Design Guidelines, Zoning Regulations, or other policy documents. 7.0 ATTACHMENTS A - Project Plans (ARCH-0529-2023) B - Project Elevation (ARCH-0529-2023) Page 15 of 67 Page 16 of 67 ˂˅ʶˈˇˇ ˀˈʿˇʼʠʹʴˀʼʿˌ ʷʸˉʸʿ˂˃ˀʸˁˇ ˇ˛˜˦ˣ˥ˢ˝˘˖˧˜ˡ˩ˢ˟˩˘˦˧˛˘˗˘˩˘˟ˢˣˠ˘ˡ˧ˢ˙ ˠ˨˟˧˜ʠ˙˔ˠ˜˟ˬ˛ˢ˨˦˜ˡ˚ˢˡʤʤʦʣ˂˥˖˨˧˧˅ˢ˔˗ʡˇ˛˘˦˜˧˘ ˦˜˧˦˜ˡ˔˅ʠʦ˭ˢˡ˘˔ˡ˗˜˦ʡʩʪʧ˔˖˥˘˦ʟ˪˛˜˖˛˔˟˟ˢ˪˦˙ˢ˥ ˔˛ˢ˨˦˜ˡ˚˗˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬˢ˙ʤʦʡʧʪ˨ˡ˜˧˦ʡˇ˛˘˜ˡ˜˧˜˔˟ ˗˘˩˘˟ˢˣˠ˘ˡ˧˪˜˟˟˖ˢˡ˦˜˦˧ˢ˙˗˘ˠˢ˟˜˦˛˜ˡ˚˔ˡ˘˫˜˦˧˜ˡ˚ ʧʟʣʣʣ˦ˤ˙˧˕˨˜˟˗˜ˡ˚˔ˡ˗˥˘ʠ˚˥˔˗˜ˡ˚˧˛˘ˣ˥ˢˣ˘˥˧ˬ˔˦ ˪˘˟˟˔˦˥˘ʠ˗˘˦˜˚ˡ˜ˡ˚˧˛˘˘˫˜˦˧˜ˡ˚ˣ˔˥˞˜ˡ˚˟ˢ˧ʡˇ˛˘ ˢ˩˘˥˔˟˟˗˘˩˘˟ˢˣˠ˘ˡ˧˪˜˟˟˖ˢˡ˦˜˦˧ˢ˙ʛʫʜˢˡ˘ ˕˘˗˥ˢˢˠ˨ˡ˜˧˦ʟʛʫʜ˧˪ˢ˕˘˗˥ˢˢˠ˨ˡ˜˧˦˔˦˪˘˟˟˔˦ ʛʤʜʴʷˈ˨ˡ˜˧ʡ˂ˡ˘ˢ˙˧˛˘ˢˡ˘˕˘˗˥ˢˢˠ˨ˡ˜˧˦˪˜˟˟˕˘˔ ˗˘˗˜˖˔˧˘˗˟ˢ˪˜ˡ˖ˢˠ˘˨ˡ˜˧ʡˇˢ˔˖˖ˢˠˣ˟˜˦˛˧˛˜˦ʟ˔ˡ ˘˫˜˦˧˜ˡ˚˗˥˔˜ˡ˔˚˘˘˔˦˘ˠ˘ˡ˧˪˜˟˟ˡ˘˘˗˧ˢ˕˘ ˠˢ˗˜Ѓ˘˗˧ˢ˔˖˖ˢˠˠˢ˗˔˧˘˧˛˘ˡ˘˪˗˘˩˘˟ˢˣˠ˘ˡ˧ʡ ˇ˛˥ˢ˨˚˛˧˛˜˦˔ˣˣ˟˜˖˔˧˜ˢˡ˪˘˔˥˘˥˘ˤ˨˘˦˧˜ˡ˚˔ˡ ˘˫˖˘ˣ˧˜ˢˡ˙ˢ˥˧˛˘˦˜˭˘ˢ˙˧˛˘ʴʷˈ˧ˢ˕˘˔˧ʤʟʥʣʣ ˦ˤ˨˔˥˘˙˘˘˧˔˦˪˘˟˟˔˦˙ˢ˥ʛʧʜ˖ˢˠˣ˔˖˧ˢ˙˙ʠ˦˧˥˘˘˧ ˣ˔˥˞˜ˡ˚˦ˣ˔˖˘˦ʡˇˢˢ˙˙˦˘˧˧˛˘˖ˢˠˣ˔˖˧˦ˣ˔˖˘˦˪˘ ˛˔˩˘ˣ˥ˢ˩˜˗˘˗ʛʫʜ˔˗˗˜˧˜ˢˡ˔˟˚˨˘˦˧˕˜˖ˬ˖˟˘ˣ˔˥˞˜ˡ˚ ˦ˣ˔˖˘˦ʡ ˆˈ ˅ ˉ ʸ ˌ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ˆ ˇ ˅ ˈ ʶ ˇ ˈ ˅ ʴ ʿ  ʼ  ʶ ʼ ˉ ʼ ʿ  ʼ  ˈ ˇ ʼ ʿ ʼ ˇ ʼ ʸ ˆ  ʼ  ˃ ʿ ʴ ˁ ˁ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ʴ ˅ ʶ ʻ ʼ ˇ ʸ ʶˇ ˈ ˅ ʸ Page 17 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ ˢˡ˟ˬʟ˗ˢˡˢ˧˦˖˔˟˘˗˥˔˪˜ˡ˚˦ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˆˈ ˅ ˉ ʸ ˌ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ˆ ˇ ˅ ˈ ʶ ˇ ˈ ˅ ʴ ʿ  ʼ  ˈ ˇ ʼ ʿ ʼ ˇ ʼ ʸ ˆ  ʼ  ʶ ʼ ˉ ʼ ʿ  ʼ  ˃ ʿ ʴ ˁ ˁ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ʴ ˅ ʶ ʻ ʼ ˇ ʸ ʶˇ ˈ ˅ ʸ ˃˥ˢ˝˘˖˧ʴ˗˗˥˘˦˦ʭʤʤʦʣ˂˥˖˨˧˧˅ˢ˔˗ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ ʴ˃ˁʭʣʣʧʠʬʩʥʠʣʦʤ ˍˢˡ˜ˡ˚ʭ˅ʠʦʛ˅˘˦˜˗˘ˡ˧˜˔˟ˀ˨˟˧˜ʠʹ˔ˠ˜˟ˬʜ ʶˢˡ˦˧˥˨˖˧˜ˢˡ˧ˬˣ˘ˉʵ ˁ˨ˠ˕˘˥ˢ˙˦˧ˢ˥˜˘˦ʥ ˂˖˖˨ˣ˔ˡ˖ˬ˅ʠʥʛʹˢ˨˥ˣ˟˘˫ʜʟ˅ʠʦʛʷ˨ˣ˟˘˫ʜ  ʿˢ˧ˆ˜˭˘ʭʡʩʪʧ˔˖˥˘˦ʛʥʬʟʦʧʩ˦ˤ˙˧ʜ ˀ˔˫ʡʷ˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬʭʥʣ˨ˡ˜˧˦ˣ˘˥˔˖˥˘ ˀ˔˫ʡʷ˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬʴ˟˟ˢ˪˘˗ʭ   ʤʦʡʧʪ˗˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬ˨ˡ˜˧˦ ʷ˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬ˃˥ˢˣˢ˦˘˗ʭ   ʤʦʡʥʫ˗˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬˈˡ˜˧˦ ˀ˔˫ʡʿˢ˧ʶˢ˩˘˥˔˚˘ʭʩʣʘ ʿˢ˧ʶˢ˩˘˥˔˚˘˃˥ˢˣˢ˦˘˗ʭʬʟʬʨʨ˦ˤ˙˧ʛʦʦʡʫʨʘʜ ʴ˟˟ˢ˪˔˕˟˘ʻ˘˜˚˛˧ʭʦʨϠ ˀ˔˫ʻ˘˜˚˛˧˃˥ˢˣˢ˦˘˗ʭʥʬϠ ʹ˥ˢˡ˧ˆ˘˧˕˔˖˞ʭʤʣϠ ʶˢ˥ˡ˘˥ʿˢ˧ˆ˜˗˘ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ˆ˘˧˕˔˖˞ʭ   ʤʣϠ ʼˡ˧˘˥˜ˢ˥ˆ˜˗˘ˆ˘˧˕˔˖˞ʭ   ʨϠʛ˧˜˘˥˘˗ʜ ˅˘˔˥ˆ˘˧˕˔˖˞ʭʨϠʛ˧˜˘˥˘˗ʜ ˆˣ˥˜ˡ˞˟˘˥˦˅˘ˤ˨˜˥˘˗   ˬ˘˦ ˆˣ˥˜ˡ˞˟˘˥˦˃˥ˢˣˢ˦˘˗   ˬ˘˦ʮ ˁʹ˃ʴʤʦ˅ˢˡʹˢ˨˥ˣ˟˘˫ʵ˟˗˚˦ʡʙˁʹ˃ʴʤʦʷˢˡʷ˨ˣ˟˘˫ʵ˟˗˚˦ʡ ˈˡ˜˧˦˃˥ˢˣˢ˦˘˗ ʛʫʜʤ˕˘˗˥ˢˢˠ˨ˡ˜˧˦ʭ  ʴˣˣ˥ˢ˫˜ˠ˔˧˘˟ˬʪʨʣ˦ˤʡ˙˧ʡʰ  ʡʩʩ˗˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬ˨ˡ˜˧ ʛʫʜʥ˕˘˗˥ˢˢˠ˨ˡ˜˧˦ʭ  ʴˣˣ˥ˢ˫˜ˠ˔˧˘˟ˬʤʟʨʣʣ˦ˤʡ˙˧ʡʰ  ʤ˗˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬ˨ˡ˜˧ ʛʤʜʦ˕˘˗˥ˢˢˠʴʡʷʡˈʡ˨ˡ˜˧ʭ ʴˣˣ˥ˢ˫˜ˠ˔˧˘˟ˬʤʟʥʣʣ˦ˤʡ˙˧ʡʰ  ʣ˗˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬ˨ˡ˜˧ ʤʦʡʥʫ˗˘ˡ˦˜˧ˬ˨ˡ˜˧˦ ˇˢ˧˔˟˅˘ˠˢ˩˘˗˦ˤ˙˧ʭʧʟʣʣʣ˦ˤ˙˧ ˇˢ˧˔˟ˁ˘˪ʷ˘˩˘˟ˢˣˠ˘ˡ˧˦ˤʡ˙˧ʡʭ   ʤʬʟʥʣʣ˦ˤʡ˙˧ʡ ˃˔˥˞˜ˡ˚   ˅˘ˤ˨˜˥˘˗   ˃˥ˢ˩˜˗˘˗ ˆ˧˔˟˟˦ʭʤʫʤʫʛʤʧˆ˧˔ˡ˗˔˥˗ʟʧʶˢˠˣ˔˖˧ʜ ʺ˨˘˦˧˃˔˥˞˜ˡ˚ˆ˧˔˟˟˦ʭ  ʧʧʛʧˆ˧˔ˡ˗˔˥˗ʜ ʴʷʴ˃˔˥˞˜ˡ˚ˆ˧˔˟˟˦ʭ  ʤʤ ʸ˟˘˖˧˥˜˖ˉ˘˛˜˖˟˘˃˔˥˞˜ˡ˚  ˅˘ˤ˨˜˥˘˗   ˃˥ˢ˩˜˗˘˗ ˆ˧˔˟˟˦ʭ   ʦʸˉ˅˘˔˗ˬ   ʦʸˉ˅˘˔˗ˬʛʤʴʷʴʸˉ˅˘˔˗ˬʜ ʤʤʸˉʶ˔ˣ˔˕˟˘ʛʨʣʘʸˉʶ˔ˣ˔˕˟˘ʜ ʤʤʸˉʶ˔ˣ˔˕˟˘ ʴ˅ʶʻʼˇʸʶˇˈ˅ʴʿ ʴʤʡʣ ʷ˘ˠˢˆ˜˧˘˃˟˔ˡ ʴʤʡʤ ˆ˜˧˘˃˟˔ˡ ʴʤʡʥ ʿ˔ˡ˗˦˖˔ˣ˘ˆ˜˧˘˃˟˔ˡ ʴʥʡʣ ʤʵ˘˗˥ˢˢˠˈˡ˜˧ʹ˟ˢˢ˥˃˟˔ˡ˦ ʴʥʡʤ ʤʵ˘˗˥ˢˢˠˈˡ˜˧ʸ˫˧˘˥˜ˢ˥ʸ˟˘˩˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ʴʦʡʣ ʥʵ˘˗˥ˢˢˠˈˡ˜˧ʹ˟ˢˢ˥˃˟˔ˡ˦ ʴʦʡʤ ʥʵ˘˗˥ˢˢˠˈˡ˜˧ʸ˫˧˘˥˜ˢ˥ʸ˟˘˩˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ʴʧʡʣ ʴʷˈʹ˟ˢˢ˥˃˟˔ˡ˦ ʴʧʡʤ ʴʷˈʸ˫˧˘˥˜ˢ˥ʸ˟˘˩˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ʴʨʡʣ ʶˢ˟ˢ˥˦˔ˡ˗ˀ˔˧˘˥˜˔˟˦ ˂˪ˡ˘˥ʭ ˁ˔˧˛˔ˡʿˢ˩˘ʸˠ˔˜˟ʭ  ˡ˔˧˛˔ˡ˟ˢ˩˘ʪʥʳ˚ˠ˔˜˟ʡ˖ˢˠ ʤʪʧʣʿ˘˘ʴˡˡʶ˧˃˛ˢˡ˘ʭ  ʫʣʨʡʦʧʨʡʩʬʤʪ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ ʴ˥˖˛˜˧˘˖˧ʭ ˊ˜˟˟˅˨ˢ˙˙ʸˠ˔˜˟ʭ  ˪˜˟˟˥ʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧   ˃˛ˢˡ˘ʭ  ʫʣʨʡʥʦʨʡʨʦʦʦ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ ʶ˜˩˜˟ʸˡ˚˜ˡ˘˘˥ʭ ʻ˜˩˘ʸˡ˚˜ˡ˘˘˥˜ˡ˚   ʶˢˡ˧˔˖˧ʭ ʷ˔ˡ˃˔˥˞˘˥ʠʾ˜ˡ˚ ʪʣʨʹ˜˘˥ˢʿˡʟˆ˨˜˧˘ʤʣ   ʸˠ˔˜˟ʭ  ˗˔ˡʳ˛˜˩˘˘ˡ˚˜ˡ˘˘˥˜ˡ˚ʡ˨˦ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ   ˃˛ˢˡ˘ʭ  ʫʣʨʡʨʨʣʡʫʨʧʩ ˃˅˂ʽʸʶˇʼˁʹ˂˅ˀʴˇʼ˂ˁ ˃˅˂ʽʸʶˇʷʼ˅ʸʶˇ˂˅ˌ ˆʻʸʸˇʼˁʷʸˋ ˉʼʶʼˁʼˇˌˀʴ˃ 1 ʴʺʸˁʶʼʸˆʴˁʷˈˇʼʿʼˇʼʸˆ ʶ˜˧ˬˢ˙ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʠʶˢˠˠ˨ˡ˜˧ˬʷ˘˩˘˟ˢˣˠ˘ˡ˧ ʷ˘ˣ˔˥˧ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˃˛ˢˡ˘ʭʛʫʣʨʜʪʫʤʠʪʤʫʣ ʬʤʬ˃˔˟ˠˆ˧˥˘˘˧ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ   ʶ˜˧ˬˢ˙ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʠʵ˨˜˟˗˜ˡ˚ʷ˘ˣ˔˥˧ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˃˛ˢˡ˘ʭʛʫʣʨʜʪʫʤʠʪʤʫʣ ʬʤʬ˃˔˟ˠˆ˧˥˘˘˧ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ ʶ˜˧ˬˢ˙ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʠ˃˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ʷ˘ˣ˔˥˧ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˃˛ˢˡ˘ʭʛʫʣʨʜʪʫʤʠʪʤʫʣ ʬʤʬ˃˔˟ˠˆ˧˥˘˘˧ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ ʶ˜˧ˬˢ˙ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʠ˃˨˕˟˜˖ˊˢ˥˞˦ʷ˘ˣ˔˥˧ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˃˛ˢˡ˘ʭʛʫʣʨʜʪʫʤʠʪʤʫʣ ʬʤʬ˃˔˟ˠˆ˧˥˘˘˧ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ ʶ˜˧ˬˢ˙ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʠʹ˜˥˘ʷ˘ˣ˔˥˧ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˃˛ˢˡ˘ʭʛʫʣʨʜʪʫʤʠʪʦʫʣ ʥʤʩʣˆ˔ˡ˧˔ʵ˔˥˕˔˥˔ʴ˩˘ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ ˃ʺʙʸ ˃˛ˢˡ˘ʭʛʫʣʣʜʪʦʨʠʣʣʣʣ ʧʣʩʻ˜˚˨˘˥˔ˆ˧ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴʬʦʧʣʤ ʴʩʡʣ ʹ˥ˢˡ˧˅˘ˡ˗˘˥˜ˡ˚ ʴʩʡʤ ʼˡ˧˘˥˜ˢ˥ʢʵ˔˖˞˅˘ˡ˗˘˥˜ˡ˚ ʶʼˉʼʿ ʶʤʡʣ ˇ˜˧˟˘ˆ˛˘˘˧ ʶʤʡʤ ˁˢ˧˘˦ˆ˛˘˘˧ ʶʥʡʣ ʺ˥˔˗˜ˡ˚˔ˡ˗ʷ˥˔˜ˡ˔˚˘˃˟˔ˡ ʶʥʡʤ ʺ˥˔˗˜ˡ˚˔ˡ˗ʷ˥˔˜ˡ˔˚˘ˆ˜˧˘ˆ˘˖˧˜ˢˡ˦ ʶʦʡʣ ʸ˥ˢ˦˜ˢˡʶˢˡ˧˥ˢ˟˃˟˔ˡ ʶʦʡʤ ʸ˥ˢ˦˜ˢˡʶˢˡ˧˥ˢ˟ʷ˘˧˔˜˟˦ ʶʧʡʣ ˈ˧˜˟˜˧ˬ˃˟˔ˡ ʶʨʡʣ ʶˢˡ˦˧˥˨˖˧˜ˢˡʷ˘˧˔˜˟˦ Page 18 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ ˢˡ˟ˬʟ˗ˢˡˢ˧˦˖˔˟˘˗˥˔˪˜ˡ˚˦ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˆˈ ˅ ˉ ʸ ˌ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ˆ ˇ ˅ ˈ ʶ ˇ ˈ ˅ ʴ ʿ  ʼ  ˈ ˇ ʼ ʿ ʼ ˇ ʼ ʸ ˆ  ʼ  ʶ ʼ ˉ ʼ ʿ  ʼ  ˃ ʿ ʴ ˁ ˁ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ʴ ˅ ʶ ʻ ʼ ˇ ʸ ʶˇ ˈ ˅ ʸ ʛˁ˂ˇʼˁˆʶ˂˃ʸʜ ʴʤʡʣʷʸˀ˂ˆʼˇʸ˃ʿʴˁ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤϣʰʦʣϠʠʣϣ ʧʟʣʣʣ˦ˤ˙˧ ˁ Page 19 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ ˢˡ˟ˬʟ˗ˢˡˢ˧˦˖˔˟˘˗˥˔˪˜ˡ˚˦ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˆˈ ˅ ˉ ʸ ˌ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ˆ ˇ ˅ ˈ ʶ ˇ ˈ ˅ ʴ ʿ  ʼ  ˈ ˇ ʼ ʿ ʼ ˇ ʼ ʸ ˆ  ʼ  ʶ ʼ ˉ ʼ ʿ  ʼ  ˃ ʿ ʴ ˁ ˁ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ʴ ˅ ʶ ʻ ʼ ˇ ʸ ʶˇ ˈ ˅ ʸ ʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆ ʴ˃ˁʭʣʣʧʠʬʩʥʠʣʦʤ ʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆ ʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆ ʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆ ʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆ ʛˁ˂ˇʼˁˆʶ˂˃ʸʜ ʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆ ʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆ ʥˆˇ˂˅ʼʸˆ ʴʤʡʤˆʼˇʸ˃ʿʴˁ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤϣʰʦʣϠʠʣϣ ˁ ʤ ˇ˅ʴˆʻʸˁʶʿ˂ˆˈ˅ʸ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤʢʫϣʰʤϠʠʣϣ Page 20 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ ˢˡ˟ˬʟ˗ˢˡˢ˧˦˖˔˟˘˗˥˔˪˜ˡ˚˦ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˆˈ ˅ ˉ ʸ ˌ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ˆ ˇ ˅ ˈ ʶ ˇ ˈ ˅ ʴ ʿ  ʼ  ˈ ˇ ʼ ʿ ʼ ˇ ʼ ʸ ˆ  ʼ  ʶ ʼ ˉ ʼ ʿ  ʼ  ˃ ʿ ʴ ˁ ˁ ʼ ˁ ʺ  ʼ  ʴ ˅ ʶ ʻ ʼ ˇ ʸ ʶˇ ˈ ˅ ʸ ʴʤʡʥʿʴˁʷˆʶʴ˃ʸˆʼˇʸ˃ʿʴˁ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤϣʰʦʣϠʠʣϣ ˁ Estimated Total Water Use Enter Values in Blue Cells Tan Cells Show Results Plant Water Use Type Plant Factor Hydrozone Plant Water Use Type (s) (low, medium, high) Plant Factor (PF) Hydrozone Area (HA) (ft2) Without SLA Enter Irrigation Efficiency (IE)(PF x HA (ft2))/IE 1,984 388 HA Area 7,055 2,371 SLA 0 0 Total LA 7,055 Results: MAWA= 105,372 ETo x 0.62 x [((PF x HA)/IE) + SLA]ETWU= 64,395 86 0 Very Low 0 - 0.1 Low 0.1 - 0.3 Medium 0.3 - 0.6 High 0.6 - 1.0 Zone 1 Low 0.25 6,427 0.81 Zone 2 Medium 0.50 628 0.81 Zone 3 Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9 Zone 10 Zone 11 Zone 12 Zone 13 Zone 14 Gallons HCF (Hundred Cubic Feet) per year Acre-feet per year ETWU complies with MAWA Maximum Applied Water Allowance Calculations Enter Value in Blue Cells Tan Cells Show Results San Luis Obispo Type of Project ET 43.80 ET 628 6427 0 Total Landscape Area 7,055 ft Results: (ETo) x (0.62) x [(ETAF x LA) + (1.0 - ETAF) x SLA] 105,372 141 0.32 Residential o of City from MWELO data o (inches/year) 2) 2) 2) 2 Overhead Landscape Area (ft Drip Landscape Area (ft SLA (ft Gallons per year HCF (Hundred Cubic Feet) per year Acre-feet per year Page 21 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ˢˡ˟ˬ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠʴʥʡʣʤʵʸʷ˅˂˂ˀˈˁʼˇʹʿ˂˂˅˃ʿʴˁˆ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤʢʫϣʰʤϠʠʣϣ ʥ ˆʸʶ˂ˁʷʹʿ˂˂˅˃ʿʴˁʤ ʹʼ˅ˆˇʹʿ˂˂˅˃ʿʴˁ ʧʣ˦ˤ˙˧ ˈˁʼˇʵ ʪʦʧ˦ˤ˙˧ ˈˁʼˇʴ ʪʩʦ˦ˤ˙˧ ˈˁʼˇʶ ʪʤʪ˦ˤ˙˧ ˈˁʼˇʷ ʪʤʫ˦ˤ˙˧ ʴ˗˔ˣ˧˔˕˟˘ˈˡ˜˧ ʧʨ˦ˤ˙˧ʧʤ˦ˤ˙˧ ʧʤ˦ˤ˙˧ Page 22 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ˢˡ˟ˬ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠʴʥʡʤʤʵʸʷ˅˂˂ˀˈˁʼˇʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅ʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁˆ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤʢʫϣʰʤϠʠʣϣ ʧ ˁ˂˅ˇʻʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁʦ ˊʸˆˇʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁ ʥ ˆ˂ˈˇʻʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁʤ ʸʴˆˇʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁ ʹʴʶʴʷʸʴ˅ʸʴʭ   ʩʪʤˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʦʬʡʨˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺ˃ʸ˅ʶʸˁˇʴʺʸʭ ʩʘ ʹʼ˅ʸˆʸ˃ʸ˅ʴˇʼ˂ˁʷʼˆˇʴˁʶʸʭ  ʪϠʠʣϣ ʴʿʿ˂ˊʴʵʿʸ˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʥʨʘ ʹʴʶʴʷʸʴ˅ʸʴʭ   ʩʫʨˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʪʨʡʨˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺ˃ʸ˅ʶʸˁˇʴʺʸʭ ʤʤʘ ʹʼ˅ʸˆʸ˃ʸ˅ʴˇʼ˂ˁʷʼˆˇʴˁʶʸʭ  ʪϠʠʣϣ ʴʿʿ˂ˊʴʵʿʸ˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʥʨʘ Page 23 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ˢˡ˟ˬ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠʴʦʡʣʥʵʸʷ˅˂˂ˀˈˁʼˇʹʿ˂˂˅˃ʿʴˁˆ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤʢʫϣʰʤϠʠʣϣ ʥ ˆʸʶ˂ˁʷʹʿ˂˂˅˃ʿʴˁʤ ʹʼ˅ˆˇʹʿ˂˂˅˃ʿʴˁ ˈˁʼˇʴ ʪʣʩ˦ˤ˙˧ ˈˁʼˇʵ ʪʧʥ˦ˤ˙˧ ˈˁʼˇʴ ʪʪʣ˦ˤ˙˧ ˈˁʼˇʵ ʫʤʧ˦ˤ˙˧ ʬʪ˦ˤ˙˧ʧʥ˦ˤ˙˧ Page 24 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ˢˡ˟ˬ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ʦ ʹ˅˂ˁˇʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁ ʤ ʵʴʶʾʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁ ʴʦʡʤʥʵʸʷ˅˂˂ˀˈˁʼˇʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅ʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁˆ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤʢʫϣʰʤϠʠʣϣ ʧ ˅ʼʺʻˇʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁ ʥ ʿʸʹˇʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁ ʹʴʶʴʷʸʴ˅ʸʴʭ   ʫʤʫˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʫʩˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺ˃ʸ˅ʶʸˁˇʴʺʸʭ ʤʤʘ ʹʼ˅ʸˆʸ˃ʸ˅ʴˇʼ˂ˁʷʼˆˇʴˁʶʸʭ  ʪϠʠʣϣ ʴʿʿ˂ˊʴʵʿʸ˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʥʨʘ ʹʴʶʴʷʸʴ˅ʸʴʭ   ʪʪʬˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʩʥˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺ˃ʸ˅ʶʸˁˇʴʺʸʭ ʫʘ ʹʼ˅ʸˆʸ˃ʸ˅ʴˇʼ˂ˁʷʼˆˇʴˁʶʸʭ  ʪϠʠʪϣˀʼˁʡ ʴʿʿ˂ˊʴʵʿʸ˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʥʨʘ Page 25 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ˢˡ˟ˬ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠʴʧʡʣʴʷˈʹʿ˂˂˅˃ʿʴˁˆ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤʢʫϣʰʤϠʠʣϣ ʥ ˆʸʶ˂ˁʷʹʿ˂˂˅˃ʿʴˁʤ ʹʼ˅ˆˇʹʿ˂˂˅˃ʿʴˁ ˈˁʼˇʴ ʪʥʨ˦ˤ˙˧ˈˁʼˇʴ ʧʪʧ˦ˤ˙˧ ʨʬ˦ˤ˙˧ Page 26 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ˢˡ˟ˬ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠʴʧʡʤʴʷˈʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅ʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁˆ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤʢʫϣʰʤϠʠʣϣ ʧ ˊʸˆˇʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁʦ ˁ˂˅ˇʻʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁ ʥ ʸʴˆˇʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁʤ ˆ˂ˈˇʻʸʿʸˉʴˇʼ˂ˁ ʹʴʶʴʷʸʴ˅ʸʴʭ   ʨʦʣˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʥʫˆ˄ʡʹˇʡ ʸˋˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺ˃ʸ˅ʶʸˁˇʴʺʸʭ ʨʘ ʹʼ˅ʸˆʸ˃ʸ˅ʴˇʼ˂ˁʷʼˆˇʴˁʶʸʭ  ʫϠʠʤϣ ʴʿʿ˂ˊʴʵʿʸ˂˃ʸˁʼˁʺʴ˅ʸʴʭ  ʥʨʘ Page 27 of 67 ˆʸˇˁ˂ˇʹ˂˅ʶ˂ˁˆˇ˅ˈʶˇʼ˂ˁ ʹˢ˥ˣ˟˔ˡˡ˜ˡ˚ˣ˨˥ˣˢ˦˘˦ˢˡ˟ˬ ʩʣʨˆ˔ˡ˧˔˅ˢ˦˔ˆ˧˥˘˘˧ʟ ˆ˔ˡʿ˨˜˦˂˕˜˦ˣˢʟʶʴ ʫʣʨʡʬʣʧʡʧʦʬʧ ˜ˡ˙ˢʳʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠ ˪˪˪ʡʧʠ˖˥˘˘˞˦ʡ˖ˢˠʴʨʡʣʶ˂ʿ˂˅ˆʴˁʷˀʴˇʸ˅ʼʴʿˆ ˆʶʴʿʸʭʤʢʫϣʰʤϠʠʣϣ ˃ʤʭˆˇˈʶʶ˂ˀʥʭʶʸ˅ʴˀʼʶ˃ʴˁʸʿ ʶʿʴʷʷʼˁʺ ˀʦʭʹʼʵʸ˅ʶʸˀʸˁˇ ˆʻʼ˃ʿʴ˃ˆʼʷʼˁʺ ˀʤʭʶ˂ˀ˃˂ˆʼˇʸ˅˂˂ʹ ˆʻʼˁʺʿʸˆ ˃ʥʭˀʸˇʴʿ˅ʴʼʿ ˀʤʭʶ˂ˀ˃˂ˆʼˇʸ˅˂˂ʹ ˆʻʼˁʺʿʸˆ ˃ʤʭˆˇˈʶʶ˂ ˀʦʭʹʼʵʸ˅ʶʸˀʸˁˇ ˆʻʼ˃ʿʴ˃ˆʼʷʼˁʺ ˃ʤ ˃ʴʼˁˇʸʷˆˇˈʶʶ˂ ˆˀ˂˂ˇʻʹʼˁʼˆʻ ʿʴʻʴʵ˅ʴ Ϣʿʴ˅ʼʴˇʠʫʥʤʿʛʨʪʜϣ ˃ʥ ˃ʴʼˁˇʸʷˀʸˇʴʿ ˆʻʸ˅ˊʼˁʠˊʼʿʿʼʴˀˆ Ϣˆˊʪʣʩʬʠʼ˅˂ˁ˂˅ʸϣ ˀʤ ʶ˂ˀ˃˂ˆʼˇʸ˅˂˂ʹˆʻʼˁʺʿʸˆ ˂ˊʸˁˆʶ˂˅ˁʼˁʺ ʵ˅˂ˊˁʢʷʴ˅ʾʵ˅˂ˊˁ ˀʨ ʶˀˈʵʴˆʸ ˂˅ʶ˂ʵʿ˂ʶʾ ˀʥ ʶʸ˅ʴˀʼʶ˃ʴˁʸʿʶʿʴʷʷʼˁʺ ʶʿʴʷʷʼˁʺʶ˂˅˃ʶʸ˅ʴˀʼʶʨ Ϣ˅ʸˆʼʴˆʾʣʥϣ ʿʸʺʸˁʷ ˀʩ ˉʼˁˌʿˊʼˁʷ˂ˊ ˀʼʿʺʴ˅ʷ Ϣˇ˅ʼˁˆʼʶˆʸ˅ʼʸˆʠʵ˅˂ˁˍʸϣ ˀʪ ˉʼˁˌʿʷ˂ˈʵʿʸˆˊʼˁʺʷ˂˂˅ˆ ˀʼʿʺʴ˅ʷ Ϣˇˈˆʶʴˁˌˆʸ˅ʼʸˆʠʵ˅˂ˁˍʸϣ ˀʩʭˉʼˁˌʿˊʼˁʷ˂ˊ ˃ʥʭʷʸʶʾʹʴʶʼʴ ˃ʥʭ˅˂˂ʹʹʴʶʼʴ ˃ʥʭ˅˂˂ʹʹʴʶʼʴ ˀʨʭʶˀˈʵʴˆʸ ˃ʥʭ˅˂˂ʹʹʴʶʼʴ ˀʤʭʶ˂ˀ˃˂ˆʼˇʸ˅˂˂ʹ ˆʻʼˁʺʿʸˆ ˀʩʭˉʼˁˌʿˊʼˁʷ˂ˊ ˀʪʭˉʼˁˌʿˆʿʼʷʼˁʺ ʷ˂˂˅ ˃ʥʭ˅˂˂ʹʹʴʶʼʴ ˆ˂ʿʼʷˊ˂˂ʷʷ˂˂˅ ˀʦ ʹʼʵʸ˅ʶʸˀʸˁˇˆʻʼ˃ʿʴ˃ˆʼʷʼˁʺ ʽʴˀʸˆʻʴ˅ʷʼʸ Ϣʷ˅ʸʴˀʶ˂ʿʿʸʶˇʼ˂ˁʠʺ˅ʸʸˁʴˆʻϣ ˀʧ ˆˀ˂˂ˇʻˇ˅ʼˀ ʽʴˀʸˆʻʴ˅ʷʼʸ Ϣʷ˅ʸʴˀʶ˂ʿʿʸʶˇʼ˂ˁʠʴʿˈˀʼˁˈˀϣ ˀʤʭʶ˂ˀ˃˂ˆʼˇʸ˅˂˂ʹ ˆʻʼˁʺʿʸˆ ˀʧʭˆˀ˂˂ˇʻˇ˅ʼˀ Page 28 of 67 ʴʩʡʣʹ˅˂ˁˇ˅ʸˁʷʸ˅ʼˁʺ ˁ˂ˇˇ˂ˆʶʴʿʸ Page 29 of 67 ʴʩʡʤʼˁˇʸ˅ʼ˂˅ʢʵʴʶʾ˅ʸˁʷʸ˅ʼˁʺ ˁ˂ˇˇ˂ˆʶʴʿʸ Page 30 of 67 ENGINEERINGH I V E 705 FIERO LANE, SUITE 10 SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA 93401 WWW.HIVEENGINEERING.US dan@hiveengineering.us 805-550-8546 JO B T I T L E SH E E T T I T L E ORCUTT MULTI-FAMILY DEVELOPMENT 1130 ORCUTT ROAD, SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA 93401 SHEET DESCRIPTIONSHEET NO. SHEET DESCRIPTION PROJECT CONSULTANTS C1.0 TITLE SHEET C1.1 NOTE SHEET C2.0 GRADING AND DRAINAGE PLAN C2.1 GRADING AND DRAINAGE - SITE SECTIONS C3.0 EROSION CONTROL PLAN C3.1 EROSION CONTROL DETAILS C4.0 UTILITY PLAN C5.0 CONSTRUCTION DETAILS PROJECT DATA VICINITY MAP LEGEND ENGINEERS DECLARATION SHEETS EXISTING PROPOSED ABBREVIATIONS GOVERNING CODES SCOPE OF WORK PRE-CONSTRUCTION SEPARATE PERMITS REQUIRED SPECIAL INSPECTIONS EARTHWORK ESTIMATES GRADING INFORMATION REPORTS REQUIRED CITY OF SLO NOTES Page 31 of 67 ENGINEERINGH I V E 705 FIERO LANE, SUITE 10 SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA 93401 WWW.HIVEENGINEERING.US dan@hiveengineering.us 805-550-8546 JO B T I T L E SH E E T T I T L E “” GRADING NOTES “” “ ” GENERAL NOTES OBSERVATION AND TESTING CONSTRUCTION AIR QUALITY DEMOLITION Page 32 of 67                         ENGINEERINGH I V E 705 FIERO LANE, SUITE 10 SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA 93401 WWW.HIVEENGINEERING.US dan@hiveengineering.us 805-550-8546 JO B T I T L E SH E E T T I T L E CONSTRUCTION NOTES  STORMWATER COMPLIANCE SUMMARY IMPERVIOUS AREA CALC Page 33 of 67                SF FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR F R F R FR FR FR FRFRFRFRFR ENGINEERINGH I V E 705 FIERO LANE, SUITE 10 SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA 93401 WWW.HIVEENGINEERING.US dan@hiveengineering.us 805-550-8546 JO B T I T L E SH E E T T I T L E        Page 34 of 67                SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSF FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR FR F R FR FR FR FR FR FRFRFRFRFRFRFRFRFRFRFRFR FR SFSFSSSFSFSF SF SFSFSFSSSFSFSFSFSSSFSSSSSS SFS SF SFS SF SFSFFSFF SFFSFSFFSSSFFSFFSFFFSFSSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFSFFSFSFSFSFSFSSFSFSFSSFSFSFSFSFSFSF FRRRRR FRFRFF FRRRRRRRFR FRRFRFRRFRFR FRRRRRRRRRRRRRRFR FR FRFRFF FRF FRRRRRRRRRRRRRFRFFRR FRF FRFFR FRFRF FRFR FR FR F R F R FFF RR FF FR FRRR FRFR FRF FRFR FRFRRRRFRRFRFRRFFFRFRFRFFRFRFRFRFRFRFRFRFRR SFSSFSFSFSFSFSSFSF SFSFFSFFSFSFSSSSFSSFF SFSF SFSF SFFSFS SFFSF SFSFSFSFFSFSFSFFFSSFSFFSFSFFF SSFSFSFSFSFFFFSSFFFFFF FFFFFFFFFFFFSFSSFSSFSFSFFSFSFFSFSFSFSFFSFSFFSFSFSFSFFSFSFSSFSFFSF FRFRFRFR FRFRFRFRRRRFRRR FRFRFR FRFFRFRFRFR FRFFFR FRFR FR FRFR FR FRFR FRFRRRRRFR FRRFRFRRFRFRRRRR FRFRRFRRFFRFRFRFRF FRFRRFRRFFRRRRRFRFR FFRRFRFFRFRFRFRFRFFFFFFFFRFFRFRFFR FRFRFRFFFFFFRFRFRFRFFFR FRFRFRRRFRFRFFFR FRFRFRRFFRFRFFRRRRRRFFFRFRRRRR FRFRFRRFFF FRFFRFRFFR FRFRFRFRFRFRFRFRFRRRRRRFRFRFRF FRFR FFFFFFF ENGINEERINGH I V E 705 FIERO LANE, SUITE 10 SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA 93401 WWW.HIVEENGINEERING.US dan@hiveengineering.us 805-550-8546 JO B T I T L E SH E E T T I T L E EROSION CONTROL GENERAL NOTES SF EROSION CONTROL NOTES SF FR Page 35 of 67 ENGINEERINGH I V E 705 FIERO LANE, SUITE 10 SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA 93401 WWW.HIVEENGINEERING.US dan@hiveengineering.us 805-550-8546 JO B T I T L E SH E E T T I T L E Page 36 of 67                    W W W W W W W W      W W W W W W W  W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W WWW W WWWWWW   W W S S S S S S S S W S S  W W W  S S S S S S S S SSS SSS S S S S S S S S S S W ENGINEERINGH I V E 705 FIERO LANE, SUITE 10 SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA 93401 WWW.HIVEENGINEERING.US dan@hiveengineering.us 805-550-8546 JO B T I T L E SH E E T T I T L E  UTILITY NOTES CONSTRUCTION NOTES Page 37 of 67 ENGINEERINGH I V E 705 FIERO LANE, SUITE 10 SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA 93401 WWW.HIVEENGINEERING.US dan@hiveengineering.us 805-550-8546 JO B T I T L E SH E E T T I T L E                           Page 38 of 67 SET NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION For planning purposes only 605 Santa Rosa Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 805.904.4394 info@4-creeks.com www.4-creeks.com A5.1STREET ELEVATIONS SCALE: 1/16” = 1’-0” 1 SOUTH ELEVATION 2 EAST ELEVATION SO U T H P L ( F R O N T ) NO R T H P L ( B A C K ) ORCUTT ROAD (E) SIDEWALK 10'-0"DUPLEX UNIT DUPLEX UNIT SITE ACCESS EXISTING DRIVE APPROACH LOCATION SO U SO U SO U SO U SO U SO UOUOU SO U SO U SO U SO UOU SO U SO U SO U SO U SO U SO U SO U SO U SO U SO U SO UOU SO U SO U SO U SO U SO U SO UOUOUUUU SO UOU SO U U SO U SO U SO U SO UOOSOSOOSOOSOOOSOSOOSOOOOSSSSS HTHTHTHTHTHTHTHTHTHTHTHTHTHTHHTHTHHTHHTHTHTHTHTHTHTHTHHTHTHTHHTHTHTHTHHHTHHHHTHTHTHTTTTTTTTTT PL PL PL PL PL PL LPLPL PLPLPLPL PLPLPL PL L PLL LPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLLPLPLPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F RFR (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F R (F(F(FF(FF(F(F(FF(F(F(F((((((((((((((((( ON T OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO ) NT ) NO R NO R NO R NO R NO R NO RORR NO R RRRRR NO R NO R NO R NO R R NO R RR NO R RR NO R NO R RRR NO R NO R NO R NO R NO R NO R NO R R NO R RR NONONONONONONONNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN THTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT WE S T P L ( S I D E ) EA S T P L ( S I D E ) 7'-0"ADU UNIT SITE STAIRS DUPLEX UNIT DUPLEX UNIT DUPLEX UNIT (E) SIDEWALK FERNWOOD DRIVE WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE SES WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S SES WE S WE S WE S S WE S WE S S WE S WE S WE S WE S WE S SS WEWEWEWEWWWWWWWW T PTPPTPTPTPTPP T P T P T P T P T P T P P T P T PTPTP T P T PTPTP T P P T P PTPTP T P T P P T P P T P T P T P PPTPPPPPPPTPPPP T P T TT L( L (L(( L ( L ( L ( ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( (L( L ( L ( L ( L ( L (L( L ( ( L ( L ( (L(( L ( ( ( L ( L (L(( L (L( L LLLL SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI DID SI D SI D D SI D SI D SI D SI D D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SISISISISISIISISSSSSSSSSSSSSS E EA S EA S EA SASAS EA S EA SAS EA S EA S SS EA S EA S SSSSSSSAS EA S SASAS EA S SAS EA S SASSASS EA S SSAS EA S SSASASSSASSSSSASSASSSSASSASSS EA S SSSSSS EA S EA S EA SAAAAAAAAEAEE TP T P T P T P T P T P T P PPTPPPPPPPP T P PPP T P PP T PTP T P PPPTPTPPPPPPTPP T P PPTPPP T P PPTPPPPP TT TTTTTT L ( L ( (( L (L( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( L ( ( L ( L ( ( L ( ( L (L(( L (L( L ( L ( L ( L ( ((L( L (L( L ( L ( (( L ( ( L ( ( L ( L ( ((L((L((( L ( L (L(L(( L (L(((L(L((((((( L ( LL LL L LLL LLLLL SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D D SI DID SI D SI D SI D SI D SI DID SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI DID SI D SI D SI D SI DIDID SI D SI DID SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D DID SI DID SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D SI D D SI D SI D SI D D SI D DISISIISIISIISISIIIISSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS E)E)E)E))E)E))E))E)))E)E)E)E))E)E)))E)E))E)E)E)))E))E))E)E)))E)E)))E)E)E)))E)E)E)E)E)E)E)))E)E))))E)E)E)E))E)E))E))E)E)))EEEEEEEEEEEEEEE Page 39 of 67 Page 40 of 67 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 1 1 REVIEW OF A NEW 16-UNIT MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT, ADU, AND ASSOCIATED SITE DEVELOPMENTS WITH A REQUEST TO ALLOW FOR AN ADU GREATER THAN 1,000 SQUARE FEET AND THE REMOVAL OF 17 TREES. Applicant: Nathan Love Representative: Will Ruoff, 4Creeks, Inc. ARCH-029-2023 (1130 Orcutt Road) Multi-Family Residential Development May 6, 2024 2 ARC Focus of Review Review the proposed multi-family development project in terms of its consistency with the Community Design Guidelines (CDG) Provide recommendations to the Community Development Director. 1 2 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 2 3 Project Location General Location: 1130 Orcutt Road Access: Fernwood Drive General Plan Land Use Designation: Medium-High Density Residential Zoning Designation:R-3 4 Project Description Development of a 16-unit multi-family residential development and an ADU Demolition of an existing 4,000 square foot school and childcare facility Removal of 17 trees Maximum HeightConfigurationNumber of Units Unit Size (sf) Residential Housing Type 20 feet, 11 inches Two buildings, four units each8717 – 763 Multi-Family Residential 1-bedroom unit 29 feetFour buildings, two units each81,476 – 1,556 Multi-Family Residential 2-bedroom unit 26 feet, 9 inches One detached building11,200Accessory Dwelling Unit 7 Buildings17 UnitsTotal 3 4 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 3 5 Project Design Architecture: Contemporary Prairie style Design details: Buildings have refined finishes such as stone paneling and prairie style architecture, and careful consideration was placed into the massing and separation of each of the buildings to allow for additional light to enter each unit and provide elevation relief and rhythm.. 6 Project Design: Colors and Materials Materials: Stucco and ceramic panel cladding with fiber cement shiplap siding, metal railing, vinyl windows and sliding doors, composite roof shingles Colors: Natural color palettes consisting of grays, beiges, whites, bronze, and green are proposed. 5 6 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 4 7 Project Design: Site Plan 8 Project Design: Landscape Plan 7 8 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 5 9 East Street-view Elevation (Orcutt Rd) 10 South Street-view Elevation (Fernwood Dr.) 9 10 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 6 11 Design Discussion The project is not seeking any design exceptions, but is requesting: an ADU greater than 1,000 square feet; four compact parking spaces; and modification of the location of an existing on-site drainage easement •Apart from these requests, the project is consistent with relevant development standards of the Zoning Regulations. •The project was evaluated and appears to be generally consistent with the CDG. •Staff have identified three discussion items for the ARC related to the project’s consistency with the CDG and applicable City Standards. 12 Discussion Item #1 – Materials CDG 5.2(F). Exterior finish materials should be durable and require low maintenance. The use of combined materials (such as stucco and wood siding) can provide visual interest and texture; however, all sides of each single-family dwelling or multi-family structure should employ the same materials, design details, and window treatment. No residential structure should have a carefully designed and detailed facade facing the street, and use bland, featureless stucco or other simple materials on the other exterior building walls. Each residential structure should look like the same building from all sides. The proposed project design would have well-designed facades facing Orcutt Road including stone paneling and balconies, and based on building elevations, building facades facing Fernwood Drive would also have these design features. Walls facing the interior of the site include plain, painted stucco and shiplap siding. The ARC should discuss whether the proposed combination of materials provides sufficient visual interest and texture on all elevations of the residences in compliance with the CDG. 11 12 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 7 13 Building Elevations 14 Discussion Item #2 – Pedestrian Entrances CDG 5.4(A). Site planning for a multi-family or clustered housing project should create a pleasant, comfortable, safe, and distinct place for residents, without the project “turning its back” on the surrounding neighborhood. Higher density projects should be designed either with ground floor units having individual sidewalk entrances, or as courtyard projects with at least one significant pedestrian entrance from the street sidewalk. Proposed ground floor units would have balconies that face the project frontages along Orcutt Road and Fernwood Drive. The project includes two pedestrian paths that would lead from the interior of the site to the existing sidewalks along Orcutt Road and Fernwood Drive. The ARC should discuss whether the proposed locations of the front entrances and pedestrian entrances are consistent with the CDG. 13 14 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 8 15 Conceptual Renderings View from Orcutt Road 16 Discussion Item #3 – Mechanical Equipment CDG 6.1(D.1). All mechanical equipment should be concealed from view of public streets, and neighboring properties, and should be insulated as necessary to prevent noise generated by the equipment from being audible off the property. The project includes a new transformer to be located at ground level within the 10-foot setback from Fernwood Drive. Based on project site plans, there would be little to no visual screening of this equipment from viewers traveling along Fernwood Drive. The ARC should discuss whether the proposed transformer should have additional screening from view of public streets to be compliant with the CDG. 15 16 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 9 17 Transformer Location and Screening 18 ARC Actions Recommend findings of consistency with the Community Design Guidelines and applicable City Standards. An action recommending approval of the application based on consistency will be forwarded to the Community Development Director for final action. This action may include recommendations for conditions to address consistency with the Community Design Guidelines or other applicable City Standards. Continue the project to a hearing date certain, or uncertain. An action continuing the application should include direction to the applicant and staff on pertinent issues. Recommend denial the project. An action recommending denial of the application should include findings that cite the basis for denial and should reference inconsistency with the General Plan, Community Design Guidelines, Zoning Regulations or other policy documents. 17 18 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 10 19 Project Design: Conceptual Renderings View from Orcutt Road 20 Project Design: Conceptual Renderings View from Fernwood Drive access driveway 19 20 5/6/2024 Item 4a ‐ Staff Presentation 11 21 Demolition and Tree Removal Plan 21