HomeMy WebLinkAbout10/16/2024 cc Rosten (NY Times Article re Trees)
Wilbanks, Megan
From:Emily <emilyrosten@gmail.com>
Sent:Wednesday, October 16, 2024 4:04 AM
To:Wilbanks, Megan; Whipple, Anthony
Subject:NYTimes Gift Article: A Fading Tree, Once Majestic, Had to Come Down. But It Wasn’t
the End.
This message is from an External Source. Use caution when deciding to open attachments, click links, or respond.
Good morning Megan,
I think tree committee members might enjoy this article.
Explore this gift article from The New York Times. You can read it for free without a subscription.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/16/climate/sugar-maple-tree-
pennsylvania.html?unlocked_article_code=1.Sk4.AYb9.2FWs90yVpPpd&smid=nytcore-ios-
share&referringSource=articleShare
????
????
?????
Emily
1
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/16/climate/sugar-maple-tree-
pennsylvania.html
Listen to this article · 6:44 min Learn more
By Daryln Brewer Hoffstot Photographs by Kristian Thacker
Dar yln Brewer Hoffstot lives on a farm in western Pennsylvania.
Oct. 16, 2024
When you live a long time with trees, they become a part of you.
So it pained me to take down the old sugar maple, my arboreal cathedral, one
rafter at a time, her demise not from flames but an underground blaze of fungus.
Small honey-colored mushrooms fruiting at her base were “the giveaway,” said the
forester.
The tree was old when we moved to the farm 36 years ago, about the age of this
farmhouse we figured, 160 years. I know she was here as far back as the 1940s
because we have a photo of her in her younger days, much smaller and not quite
ruling over the side yard as she did in her later years.
In her old age, she reached about 90 feet high. And she was a tree with a
personality. Not straight and narrow, but quirky, with a trunk that had split into
four and branches that splayed this way and that, coping with aging as best she
could. I felt privileged to have lived under her canopy for many years.
But lately she’s been battered by torrential rains, and then drought. Summers are
hotter, winters aren’t as cold. She’s had little snow cover to insulate her roots.
Climate change probably made her more susceptible to the fungus, armillaria, the
forester said.
And she’s not the only tree stressed on the farm. Ash trees have been decimated by
the emerald ash borer. Native dogwoods are dying of anthracnose. Hemlocks are
being attacked by the hemlock woolly adelgid and spicebush and sassafras are
A beloved sugar maple slowly succumbed to disease. Today, it lives on in a new form.
suffering from laurel wilt, spread by the nonnative ambrosia beetle. Woods that
were once woods are becoming fields again.
We watched the old maple die slowly. She’s not doing well, my husband and I said
to each other.
Then, in one season, her entire left side started coming down. Limbs crashed onto
the springhouse below, chunks of bark everywhere. Anthills appeared at her base.
Vegetation that had lodged high in her crevices looked less vigorous to me.
Even the birds were leaving. I saw no Baltimore oriole nest high in her branches as
I had the year before, nor did I find on the ground the glossy white and elliptical
egg of a mourning dove. Perhaps the birds knew that securing a nest to those
branches was no longer safe.
The sugar maple in 2022; photographs of the tree taken in 1942, top, and 1952; the tree’s bark; and its
stump.
Still, I hoped we could save her. Prune the dead limbs. Trim back. A little longer, I
begged. I knew I was too attached to her. My children had grown up beside her.
Animals of all sorts scampered about her trunk. Black bears often ambled by. At
night from the sleeping porch, I watched the moon circle east to west above her.
She was more than just a tree, she was a village.
And what, I wondered, had she witnessed in her long life? Horse and buggy,
farmers who lived in log houses with corn cob daubing, a barn raising, cold winters
with piles of snow, many more birds, more insects, lots of bats (which are almost
gone from the farm now). Darker skies, brighter stars, years with no airplane noise
and then Flight 93 hijacked overhead. She’d watched the pond being dug, the house
modernized, the land altered, by us, to divert new floodwaters.
Like the wrinkles on my face, her gnarly roots were a record of years gone by, of
lives lived, the blessed and the painful.
But I could fool myself no longer. It had become too dangerous to walk underneath
her or mow the grass. My husband and another fellow strung ropes to her
branches. I could feel it in my limbs. I didn’t want to look. They used pole pruners
and chain saws: dangerous, noisy work. They were experienced, but not on this
scale. We had to call in a professional with a bucket truck, more people and more
powerful chain saws. But he was so busy dealing with dead and diseased trees in
our small town that he said he’d drop her, but not clean up the mess.
She was down.
That couldn’t be the end, though. I remembered the suggestions of many readers of
my original New York Times essay who urged me to turn the old maple into tables,
shelves, lumber, guitars or bowls. I took their advice.
Mr. Snyder on the writer’s farm. His T-shirt reads, “Turn it, don’t burn it.”
“Turn it, don’t burn it,” says Corey Snyder’s business card. I’d met Snyder, a wood
turner, years ago at our farmer’s market, had bought beautiful bowls from him as
wedding gifts. I asked if he could do the same with our tree. He said he’d come look
at the wood. Maple is often a light wood, sometimes almost white, he said, which
many people don’t like. But he was willing to see how the grain turned out.
His chain saw struck up another chorus. More piles of sawdust accumulated on the
grass. This time, I put my nose to the newly cut grain and soaked in its sweet smell.
We placed heavy chunks of the tree into a tractor bucket, then loaded them onto his
trailer. He took them back to his shop. He’d let me know if the wood was worth
using.
A couple months later, Snyder presented me with three beautiful, honey-colored
bowls: one for our son, one for our daughter, and one for us. Each has different
characteristics. One has a “bark inclusion,” a dark brown mushroom-shaped mark
where a branch had been trimmed or damaged.
Another has a wave pattern resulting from a Y (a crotch, Snyder called it) where
two branches met and the tree’s growth pattern changed. One has light streaks of
green because of mineral deposits. They are different shapes, sizes and
thicknesses. I asked him how he chose what form the bowls should take. “I let the
piece of wood dictate,” he said.
The old maple had spoken.
She still had not revealed her age, though. I had hoped I could count her rings, but
she was so scuffed up with a kaleidoscope of chain saw marks that it was
impossible to do so.
Cutting the tree into smaller pieces; maplewood bowls, one with a bark inclusion, made by Mr. Snyder;
the grain of one of the bowls; sections of tree ready to be carted away.
Now, instead of gazing up at the tree, I can hold her in my hands. The bowls are
silky smooth, not rough like her bark, light-colored, not dark, small, not stately. But
they are the old maple in a second life, albeit a different form. Some of her will stay
here, where she put down deep roots, but other parts will venture out into a wider
world because Snyder said he liked working with the wood so much he wants to cut
more.
Pretty soon only the stump will remain. I console myself further that, over time,
the stump will become another little ecosystem unto itself. Bacteria will decompose
the wood, ants and beetles will move in, and then perhaps pileated woodpeckers,
which feed on them. Salamanders may shelter there, snakes hibernate, and
chipmunks hide acorns in her crevices. Fungi, moss and lichen will grow and
nutrients will return to the soil.
Maybe, someday, a seedling will sprout.
Yet when I walk out to the side yard, I still see her standing, her long, elegant
branches reaching skyward. It is autumn now and there is no longer that colorful
array of red, yellow and orange leaves blanketing the ground beneath her. And last
spring, I strained to hear the dawn chorus.
That glorious sound is not as close to the house as it once was, not as vibrant. It
emanates from branches farther away, from trees closer to the forest. The birds
that once called the old maple home have had to move on, to sing elsewhere. So
must I.
Daryln Brewer Hoffstot’s collection of essays, “A Farm Life: Observations From
Fields and Forests,” was published by Stackpole Books.