Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout09/22/1986 Item 1 - Consideration of recommendations by the Mobilehome Rent Review BoardF ----I !a oLsaaispo - Mgttap O¢TE: i� PrTIW nber ZZ, t9g 0 Conalderation of recommendations by the Robllehome Rent i Based ,��� Review Board CAO MHVOAMN: Review and concur with recommendations of and pate to Print leer 8.4nta to the Kf bllehONe Parkthe a Rent S aant nti Review Regvlettoev. ;Chapter 5.44 gGOgC] The Coancll has directed the Nobilehoma Rent Review Board adalnlatcative And procedural provtalona of the wo611ehome Rent Prevent atlon Ordinance. (chapter 5.44O PLOP to 1'evlew the Prevent the Council with a complete ) The board had In tended is bualnene Prevented completion Dockage of resoeeendatlone, Chuaash, Creakaide and Silver Clt cha work including rent but other forward a partial list y ob'lehome parks. The Boarddecidedfrom of Pour Items for Councll'e review, Two ssltr '*sues not addreeaed et this time rill ba considered b Board et a later dote. They are: 1.) TAe concept of -safe harbor" (allowing Parke to be Y the 30ne term leases exempt If a certain percentage of residents are on from t and 2.) �vecancy Qecontrot" {stamp qng recant recommendationaoo) TAe Board will contluct D0 11co haarin¢a and *Oaten n tAena sue for Countil'a consideration. forward Pod a Dertod of nearly two years non, the Board has held and Band J ated over amendments to the existing trainanc e. In 0 i 984 and Januar , bInp hearings Increasingy ardor the sherd recommended and the Council roves[ of the Board membership mablp from three to five. The approved approved ¢ recommendation mmentling the rra le:arzce to delete certain restrictions on eligibility for board mem °Yertl also Eerehip. The Couicll he being °eked So approve four ertiltlonal amendments to the artll^once. Those amentlment* ere: 1. add the term 'In we t n in Section 5.44.070, G . The card Celt by Adding this language, c ar ty Por both the owner end the Occurred. toThiecommendation ass a unan LoOw Owner and Occurred at resident sea relating to this ben tterarfng 9arch a, 1955. There wan not the board and opposition u- Define the term "long-tera leanea^ eta testa with a term one Year and Include in Sactlon 5.44. 030, B.. Mobile Prom rent nebll p:a [lop If ri greater than Park roslden[a Alen long term leases,rka Presently. exempt Presently, the ordinance language define, A 'more than a mooch -to -month' tenancy as a long term lease. The board votetl unan Lou*lY at its of November 20. 1995, to define a tang term lease an Year' tlurntlon. There was IS[t!e disc uaalon on this matter and than ng nc teeter than a Opposition. ¢ r- 'r=1WISOBISPO COUBCll Agenda Report Amendments to MObllehose Bent Stabilization Ordinance Page 2 3. Modify the - lUNRIlcation fee Section 5.44.Ovp 1985. thnal e Board voted vane tmouely to modf( B'. During February of nolglttery, the application fee for revt¢wihe aDpllcente' fee. no matter wkat the size of the park 4r the number reor a nt In The Board as $300; agreed tryst n tee of $IBS plus f1.00 °Daces ln:Olved. appropriate. Thu Board felt that asall p°} space could ba more COPI to and the receaeaded a Da rka were Raving to pay more per size of the park. There atlea mna it and easel tlally Dage d on the was on gore leant tlIs usnion on tAln flex wLtR r Opposition to the sad itica[lon of the owner's applicant I fee. Buying the discussions an the application fee, much of the focus wee centered an the charge for a •recant applicatl on'. Orlglneily, the regulation dtd not directly address aDpllcatlona try Bernal. T<thbony by Park residents. eta stated that 1[ mould not be financially feasible for Host Identical. o ants by .residents , board members and staff concerned a fee Identical to the[ f the owner's (3300. 00) and no to Hal merlon had been akin. Since that it", the Board ha° acted on an application made by a tenants' a°eoclatfon. Agaln, although no formal n[att testa 1t Dan complete au 'Cell^ was taken by the Bppll, fee at g30.00. An ➢Dra In [tCormanding a tenantscan ape lcr time contra tog as nn application by a ten°pt or ep 899oC1IIClan Cnn be as CLC caeca to the owner's application , and although direct and Indirect Cloy Can't ever be fully recovered, a fee of thla amount may reviewrnge frivolous applications being submitted for staff and Bound review. 4. Interpret the•Conaumer Price Index Presently, rents maY be In--- �re0��d language, Section 5. 44. 060, g.2.. 8k of the currant roviding they space rent or •three fmurtba e a Year p(seventy-L Iv, do not exceed the Cast of living Increase (Bureau of Labor Statistics, US National l of however, Price istl<x)•. Thee !e no US National Consumer Price index, however, Mere Ia n US Cities CPI Avernge•. Staff has administratively Interpreted tho CPI measurement tool statisticsgeographically. The nearest Reglonal Center of the Bureau of Labor Includes is oge Angeles. They compute a Southern California Cpl. which lacludea Los Ange lea/Anepate/Long Beach areas. Differences In between the US Cities CPI and the Southern fe"fettle CPI IV or tittle between the androm percentages occurred between the lccompdting'Ye&[CPIa YGTha Over the yenta. ° balance Rea California Index for Other purposes. y has used the Southern Sdi !IS OBISPO NC1L AGENDA REPORT ��ell Agenda Report rdiumu �t Amendments to Nobllehowe Beat page 3lzation Ordfnancc Pogo 3 The Board had vote) unsas quivaly Naroh 2T, 1980, to support the the US area es a suitable CPf computation. no pportcouncil map decide the US Cities Average to he a earn eppraputate gauge of c. A matter considerable amount of testimony "a presented to the Board on this +attar. Significant resident opposition to the LA(Annhel.'Grog eethA margin roe at they "tl Park owners felt that the dirt erenc Lung w marginal that they presented no strong position. -re so ALTERNATIVES The Council Can accept the amend recoendations of the Board and end the Nobllehome Rent Sea 0lmm staff to llzation Regulations In tour areas. 2. no Council can choose not to accept the rate"endetlona of the Board and staff to asend the NoDilehoAs Rent Stabilization Rego latlons In tour areas. 3. The council can choose [o Board or accept some or the re Regulations commendations of the Stabilization the Pour amendments to the Nob}lehoee Rent ion each of 4. The council can continue action with direction to staff and the boarl. PUBLIC PPUBLIC P—TION Nubl The received ehoae Rene Review guard conducted many public hearings and received hours of testimony regarding these amendments, evidence ease Presented for [ha record and 0eabere of the public were encouraged s partlelpa te. EC ch meeting was taped and minutes were taken. [P Council Would like to e e any of these. they are on rile In the Aaslstant to the City Adman at rear I efface. C dFCIIRRPNCE City Attorney'a office notes that the reca"endatieda o[ the Board are within legal Ilelte. FISCAL INPACT There lm no fiscal impact an the Cit.' of San Luis Obispo. STAFF RR� C�—rNVAVOR Accept the reccemendatlons of the Board and pa as to print an 0 dlnance .� "ending the four areas of the Regulations. ORDINANCE No. (1986 SERIES( Es AN ORDINANCE OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BAH LUIS OBISPO AMDIUMG CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE MOBILE RENT STABILIZATION REGULATIONS (CHAPTER 5.44 OF THE S OBISPO MUNICIPAL CODE). BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of San Luis Obispo as foi lows: SECTION 1. SubSOCtlon 5.44.030 IE) of the San Luis Ohio Po Municipal Code is hereby Amended to read as follows: 'E. Tenancies Covered by leaves or contracts which provide for Creater than a year's tenancy, but only for the duration of such lease or Contract' Upon the expiration Of or other termination of any such lease or contract. thD chapter shall loadletely he applicable to the tenancy'; 9EMON 2. Subsection 5.44.060 (B-2) of the San Luis Obispo Mu nlclpai Code is hereby amended to read as follows: '2. An lncreaae over the then existing space rent equal to three -fourths (seventy-five percent) of the Cost of living increase (Bureau of Labor StatlatlC1. U.S. National Consumer Price Index. Los Angeles/Anahelm/Long Cents) for the proceeding twelve month period. SECTION 3. Subsection 5.44.070 IS and C) are hereby amended to reed as follows: J a 0 nrdl.:ance No. 41968 5 rlew( S. M application for a rant increase pursunat to this section shall he accompanied by the payment or a fee of one hundred and twenty-five dollars plus one dollar per space for carer end fifty dollars for tenant applications. The aPVllcatiun aRail opacity, as applicable. the address of the mobile home park, the space number or nusbers for which rent is requested to be Increased, the amount of the requested rent 10... $me or services or rcCilltles reduction or too "as. the proposed effective date of ouch Increase, reduction or charge and the fects supporting the application. The applicant shall produce at the request Of the board any records, receipts, reports or other notes enn that the board say does necessary for the board to sake a determination whether to approve the application. C. The owner shall serve each affected tenant. In writing, either J personally or by ra11, with notice of the rent Increase or change In services ar facilltlam requested and with notice that application for approve of sass is baing filed with the board. Proof of ouch service shall be filed with the board concurrent with the filing of the application. Copies of the application shell be available free of ' charge to any effected tenants requesting same at the business office 1n the affected park. 3ECi ION e. This Ordinance, together with the ayes and noes. shall be published once in full. a, least three (3) days prior to its final passage In the Telegrew-Tribune, a newspaper published and circulated In said C ley, and the same shall :o Into effect at the expiration of thrtty (301 4y. after Its said final panauc. Y 111"OOOC® ABO PA89BO Ta Min by the Caned of the City of Bno hula M2epu at a eeetln held w Che 22ad day of 9apteeber, l988, on Milan of seconded by and on the folioelae roll pit vote: AYBBi =15: AB90ff: XBYcr Ron Wnin AT T: city Clerk Pesele Votes n � ! City Adeleietn tive OE a city At Aaelncsot to the City Adaiaieerative officer [- ( 6 A LEGISLATIVE GRAFTS 1. 5.44.070 Application for rant increase--Fee--Contents—Notion of request — Hearing. C. The caner shall serve each affected tenant, in writing, either personally; ar by Mail, with notice of the rent increase or change I n services or facilities requested and with notice of application for approval of saes is being filed with the board concurrent with the filing of the applicetion. Copies of the apPliw tion shall be available free of charge to any affected tenants requesting sane at the business office In the affected park. 5-44.030 Exemptions i E. Tenancies covered by losses or contracts which provide for sera -then e-oenth-tm-ninth greater than s Yesrls tenant, but only for the dura- tion of said contract. Upon the expiration of or other termination of any such lease or contract, this chapter shall Iwe lately be appli- cable to the tenancy. 3. 5.44.070 Applicoil on for rent increase--Fee--Contents--Notice of request -- Hearing. B. An application for a rent Increase pursuant to this section shall M eceampaniad is the payment of a fee of three-hundred-deftarst one hundred and [went -five dollars lus one dollar r s ace for owner and 1 t dol ors for tenant a i cat ons. The spill cation snail $pail y, as app icable, the adtlrms o the mobilehose park, the space number or numbers for which rent is requested to be in. crossed, the mmunt of the requested rent increase or service or facilities reduction or charge and the facts supporting the appli- cation. The applicant shall produce at the request of the board any records, receipts, reports or other documents that the board may deem necessary for the board to make a determination « ather to approve the application. 4. 5.44.060 Base space rent --Bete rmination--Allowable Increases. An 'acres$* aver the then existing space rent equal to three - fourths (seventy'flve percent) of the cost of living Increase (Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. National COnsaeer Price Index; Los Mileles/Maheim/Lon Beach) for the preceding twelve month parlod. R ' s.ao.l7o—s.4a.olo assignadon, prostitution, or obscene or harmful matter. nor shall the uses of such language be interpreted to kgnhs those types of businesses which from time In time have been regarded "per se" Mora! public nuisaosss (Ord. 925 § I tpart). 1982: prior code § 4815) 5.40.170 Applicability ofprovisions to Adult theaters and adult bookstores. With respect toadult theaters am! adultbook- atnra applying for a licestst and permit under the terms of this chapter the council shall make no determination on such application without first considering a report of the city attorney cnnanning the appropriateness of applying the standards set out in thuelupnc Ifsoadvised by the city atMmry that any or all standards set out in this chapter may not properly be a,plied to theaduit books o m or adult thmitarapplication, thecouncil shall Trotapplysuch standards, fOrd. 967 § L 1993: prior code § 4816) Chapter 5.44 MOBILE HOME PARK RENT STABILIZATION Sections: 5.44.010 Purpose and intent. 5A4420 Definitions. 5.44.030 Exemptions. 5,44.040 Mobile home rent review board —Established — Membership —Terms. 5.44.050 Mobile home rent review bosrd—Pbwers and dudes. 5.d4.060 Base spa" rmt— Dete mutation —Allowable increases. 5.44.070 Application for rent increase — Fee —Contents —Notice of rvquest—Hearing. 5.44.080 Application for rent increase— Conduel of hearing. Qm.t«.oww. ran 134 a 5.44.D90 Applicationforrestincrease— Evalustion—Relevant factors. 5.44.100 Application For rent increase— Hearing—Determidtfoa. 5.44.110 Application for rent Incrnae— Hearing—Appeal. 5.44.120 Rent increases not made in conformity with provisions— TmmCs right to refwe to pay. 5.44.130 Actions brought to recover posession of mobile home space —Retaliatory eviction grounds for denial. 5A4.140 Owner to provide tenants with copy of this chapter. 5A4.010 Purpose and latent. A. There is presently within the city and the surrounding areas a shortage of spaces for the location of mobile homes. Becauseofthis short. age, them is a very low vacancy rate. and rents have been for several yesm and art presently, rising rapidly andcausingconcemamongasub� stantiai number of San Luis Obispo residents. B. Mobile home tenants, forced by the lack of suiubleaimmative housing, have had to Day the rent increases and thereby suficr a further reduction in their standard of living. C. Because of the high cost and imprac- usability of moving mobile homes, the potential for damage resulting therefrom, the require. menu misting to the installation of mobile homes, including permits, landscaping and site preparation, the lack of alternative homesi= for mobile home residents, and the substantial investment of mobile home owners in such homm this council finds and dec arms it neca. nary to protect the owners and occupiers of mobilehomes fmm unreasonable reptincteasa, while at the same time recognizing the need of park owners to raccive a suitable profit on their 0 5.44,020-5A4.030 r� J�� property with metal income sufficient to cover increases; in corta of repaic maintenance, insur. ance, utilities, employee services, additional amenities, and other torts of opmtion, and to receive a fair mum on their property. D. This council finds that the present low vacancy rate and frequent heat inmeasesare par- ticularly hard upon and unfair to residents of mobile home parks within the dry. Large num. bet of than maidersts am senior citizens and others on rued incomm who installed their mobile homes in the city when the present infla. tionary rent incases could not reasonably have been foreseen. E. Howevee this council recognizes that a rent stabilization ordinance must be fair and equitable for all martin Rod must provide appto• priam incentives for mobile home park operators to cautious their parks profitably, as well as to attract additional iavearors for am parks (Ord. 923 § I (part), 1982. prior code § 4800) 5A,U)20 Definitions. For the purpose oflhis chapter. certain words and phrases used herein are defined as follows: A. "Capital improvements" means those improvementsthat materially add to the value of the property and appreciably prolong its useful life or adapt it to new uses, and which may be amortized over the useful life of the improve. menu in accordance with the internal Revenue Code and regulations issued pursuant thereto; provided, that this definition shall be limited to capital improvements either approved by mom than fifty percent of the tenants in the affected parkorcummucted to complywith tbediremion of public agency. B. "Mobile home park" means an area of land which rents spaces for mobile home dwell. Ingumts. C. "Mobile home park owner" or "owner" mom the owner, lessor. corruptor man tgerofa mobile home park. D. "Mobile home park rent review board' or "board" means the mobile home park rent 135 review board established in Section 5.44.040. E. "Mobile home tenant' or"tmaat"mesas any person entitled to occupy a mobile home within a mobile home park pursuant to owner. shipofthe mob0ehomeorumleramntalorlease agreement with the owner ofth mobile home. E "Rehabilitation work" means any renova- tion or repair work completed on or in a mobile home park performed in order to comply with the direction or order of a public agency, or to repairdarnage resulting from fim, earthquake or othercasualty. G. "Space rent" means the consideration, including any seertritydeposim bonuses, benefits or gratuities, demanded or received in connec. don with the use and occupancy of �inobile home space in a mobile home park, or forhous- ing services provided, but exclusive of any amount paid forthe use ofa mobile homedwell. ing unit (Ord. 923 § I (part), 198E prior code § 4901) 5.04930 Exemptions. The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to the following tenanciesin mobile home parks: A. Mobile home park spaces rented for non. residential uses: B. Mobile home parks managed or operated by the United States Government, the state of California, or she county of San Luis Obispo; C Tenancies which do not exceed an occ t- mum, oftwenty days and which do not comem- plate an occupancy of mom than twenty days; D. Tenancies for which any federal or state law or regulation specifically prohibits rent regulation; E. Tenancies covered by leases or contracts .which provide for more thin a month -to -month tenancy, but only for the duration ofsuch lease or contract. Upon the expiration ofor other fermi. nation ofany such lose or contract this chapter shall immediately be applicable m the tenancy; F. Mobile home parks which sell lots for fac- tory -built or manufactured housing, or which provide condominium ownership of such lots, l 7 M 3 3.44.040-5.44.060 0 even iron at mom homes in the development ate rented or leased ouL (Opt. 923 § I (pan). 1982 prior Code § 4902) 5+W.040 Mobile boom mat review boud— Ela2bnabed—Mambership— Temi. A. Them is established a mobile home rent review board tansiuing of three members who, along with their alternates shall be appointed by and serve as the rlea-cam of the mural. B. The council shall appoint three regular members and two altercate members to serve in the absrnm of regular members The city clerk Shan x3eei by lot the alUmte member to so Serve in the absence of ooe regular member. C. The board members and the alternates shell be Panama who am not connected with the rill estate or rental housing industry for their Persons] gain. None ofthe members oraltmutes shall be t U of or have ary fiwnaai interns, (m defined by state law) in any mobile home or mobile home park. The members and aitttnatts Shall file a declaration to this effect with the aty Berk in a form approved by the city attorney. D. Boars membersand altemamna)u6 not be compensated for their services as such, but may receive relmburmmentsazpmvided bythecoun. cn for traveling and other eapeuea incurred while On official duty. E. The terms of hoard members and alter. notes Shan be two years Terms of the Ent three membersand altamatesahail expire on3uae 30, 1984, irrmpective of the date of appoinemenL Terms dolt expire thernner on June 30th of even numbered Years. (Opt. 923 § I (pent, 1982: prior code § 4803) 5.44" Mobile dame rent review board — Powers and duties. Within the limitations provided by law, the board shalll"i" thefalk wingpowen andduda A. To mat from time to time as required by the Council and to utilize the city a Bite, facilities and personnel as needed; 136 C B. TO receive, investigate, hold hearings on, andtaa upon the issues ralatingto mobilchome Park rent stabilization asset forth in thischaptec ar to any dmopeon in, or charges for. services or facilities; C To make or conduct such independent hearings or investigations as may be appropriate to obtain such information on is necemry to Clmyoul iadutie; D. To reader following every teat review heuingaw:i t reponmthecouncilmmeming its activities, holdings, actions4 results of hear- i ngs and aIi other matters Pmincn t to Nis chap- ter which MY be of interest to the council; F. To adopt, promulgate, amend and rcand administtativc rule; as it dams appropriate to cffeCtuam the purposes and policies of this chap. ter. (Opt. 923 § I (tart), 1932, Pr{orcode § 4804) 5.a.060 Ban 'Pam rent—Determbu lon— , -j4a(d . Allowable lneecaes. mi.QY.K"r^ A. The "bxsespare rent"for purpi as orthis chapter.shol be the monthly some rent charged u ofMamh 15. 190Z , B. Exceptuotherwisepmviddinthis che, ter the maximum monthly space rent may be ineressnt no more than once a year by the lesser of the two following amounts: i. Eight percent of the then existing space rent; 2. An increase over the then existing space mat equal to throe-fourths(aeventy-five pea tiro) of the cost of living increase (Bureau of labor Statistics, U.S. National Caasumar Price Index) for the Pmceding twelve-month periled C Calculation of the onoyaar limitation an metal incaeasa at provided in this section shall be from the date the Iut increase became a&c- tivc at the park. D. No owner shall either(1) demand, accept or retain a mat oforrmma monatinexcessofthe maximum rent permitted by this Chapter, or (2) effect a prohibited rent i nerease by a reduction of general park facilities and services. (Ord. 923 § I (part), 1982: prior code § 4805) A/V I U SM.070 Appligtloa for rent increase— Fae—Contents—Noti" of «peat—Ncarb g. A. An ownerwhohasbeco scquircd to mate expenditures or has incurred coma of such amounts that he will be unable to make a just and reasonable mum on his property given the maximum increase permitted by Section 5.44.060. may file with the board an application for a scat irraease for one or mom spare or application to reduce, or charge for, certain sm- vices or facilitim in either event referred to hereinafter as "application"or "application for rent inrnsse." B. An application for a sent increase pur. suant to this section shall beaccompanled by the payment of a fm of thrt hundred doilam The application shall specify, as applicable, the address of the mobile home park, the spare number or or numbers for which rent is requested to be increased, the amount of the requested rent increase or service or fecllitia Mductionorcharges, thepmposedeffemivedate of such increase. reduction or charge and the face supporting the application. The applicant shall produce at the request of the board any records. receipts, reports or other documents that the board maydmm necessary forthe board to makeademinination whVi erto approvmhe application. C. The owner shall serve each affccred ten- ant. either personally. or by mail, with notice of the rent increase or change in services orfaciB- ties requested and with notice that applicwion for approval of same is being Sled with the board. Proof of such sevim shall be filed with the board mncurrtnt with the filing ofthespoil. catian. Copies of the application shell be avail- able free of charge to any affected tenants requesting same at the business office in the affected park. D. The board shall set a hewingon theappii. mition complying with the repuirerecnu of this section no less than ten days and no more than thirty days after receipt of the applimson and proof of servim. The board shall notify the ownerand tenants. in writing, orthe time, place 137 0 5.44.070-5.44.090 and date set for the hearing. No hearing or any port thcroof may be continued beyond thirty days after the initial hearing date, without the owner'sconsent. ifthe board approves an appli- cation as miumted or as modified, the same shall take effatas noticed bytheowna ns weire board mayotherwisedirecr. (Ord.923 § 1(part), 1982: prior code § 4806) 5.44.080 APplicationforrentimavase— Conduct of hearing. A. Ali review hearings conducted by the board shall becoaducted is aaoidanm with the Ralph M. Brawn Act, wSection 54950aseq. of the Califomia Government Code. B. All interested parties to a hearing may have assistance from an attorney or such other person an; may be designated by the parties in presenting evidence or in selling forth by argu- menttheir position. Ali witnesses shall beswom in and all testimony shall be under penalty of perjury. C. In the event that either the owns or the Imant(s) should fail to appear at the hearing at the specified time and place. the board maybm and review such evidence as may be pr ac.:ed and make such decisions as if all parties had been present. D. Applicant and affected tenants may offer any testimony, documents, written declarations or other relevant cvidenm. E. Formal rules of evidence shall net apply. F. Minutes shall be taken at all review hear- ings, (Ord. 923 § I (part), 1932: prior code § 4807) 5.44.090 Application for not increara— E.aluation—R<lenot factors. In evaluating the application the board may consider. along with all other factors it considers relevant changes in costs to the aw :er attribut- able to increases or decreases in master land and/orfacilities lease rent, utility mm, property razm insurance. advertising. variable mortgage interest rates. employm costs. normal repair and maintenance. and other considerations. including, but not limited to. rehabilitation ma iw.o t+o /W 101 5A4.100-5.44.140 work, capital improvements, upgrading and addition of amenities or services, net operating income, and the level efrent necessary to permi t a just and reasonable return on the owners property.fOrd.92311(pa L 1982: priorcode§ 4809) 5.N.100 Application for rent In<rease- 2fearWg—Determination. A. The bond "I make a final decision no laterthan twentydays after theconcluson ofits hearing. The board's decision shall be based on the preponderance ofthe evidence submitted at the hearing. The decision shall be based on find- ings. All parties to the hearing shall be advised by mail of the bond's decision and findings B. Pursuant to its hadinSL the board may: 1. Permit the requested rent increase to become effective, in whole or in part: or 2. Deny the requested min increase, or 3. Permit or deny, in whole or in part. requested reductions. of or charges for. facilities or services. C. Any decision of the board shall be final unless, within fifteen days after mailing of the derision and findings the owner or any armed tenant appeals the decision m the council. (Ord. 923 § 1(pan). 1982: prior code § 4809) SA4.II0 Application for rent ncrease— ftearfng—Appeal. A. Any appeal from a decision of board shall be filed with the city clerk The date for consideration of the appal shall be set by the city clerk no less than ten days nor more than thirtydays after the expiration date for filing of an appeaL Notice of the date, time and nlace shall be given by lhecity clerk to the owner and III affected tenants. R. At the time sn for consideration of the appeal the council shall mviewand consider the record ofthe board hearing and thedeeision and Ending of the board. AOer review and consid- eration the council may either (1) determine that a further hewing shall be heW. to be con. ducted before the council no later than the next 138 regular meeting, or ratify and adopt the dmi- tied and findings of the board. Ifa further bear. ing is conducted, the council may upon conclusion of that hearin& and in no event more than thirty days thereafter. modify or reverse the decision of the board, and shall make finding in support themor.(Ord. 92311(pan), 1982: prior code 4810) SA4.120 Rent inveasea not nude is conformity with provisions— 'Raaat's right to "fuse to pay. A tenant may refuse m pay any increase in rent not trade in conformity with this chapter. Such refusal to pay shall be a defense in any anion brought to recover possession ofa mobile home space: or to collect the mat increase (Ord. 923 § 1(pan). 1982: prior code § 4811) 5.44.130 Actions brought to recover possession of mobut home space —Retaliatory eviction grounds for denial. Notwithstanding Section 5.44.120, in any action brought to recover possession ofa mobile home space, the court may consider as grounds for denial any violation of any provision of this chapter. Further, the determination that the action wasbrought in retaliation for the exercise of any rightsronfimred by this chapter shall be grounds for denial. (Ord. 923 § 1 (pan), 1982: prior code § 4812) 5.44.140 Owner to provide tenants with copy of this chapter. Any tenant offered a lease or contract which if accepted and fully executed would be exempt from the provisions of this chapter (Section 5.44.030E) shall at the time of the offer also be provided with a copy ofthis chapter.(Ord. 923§ I (part). 1982: prior code § 4313) C HA