HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation form - Reviewer-2Reviewer Name: REDACTED
Scoring Criteria
Maximum
Points
White
Nelson Vavrinek
Glenn
Burdette Badawi LSL Moss Levy
1 - Understanding of the work required by the City 25 25 25 25 25 25 20
2 - Quality, clarity and responsiveness of the proposal 20 18 16 10 18 18 5
3 - Demonstrated competence and profesional qualifications
necessary 10 10 10 5 10 10 5
4 - Recent experience in successfully performing similar
services 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
5 - References 20
6 - Background and related experience of the specific
individuals assigned 20 18 18 18 18 20 15
7 - Proposed approach in completing the work 15 15 15 13 15 15 10
8 - Proposed compensation 15 10 13 7 15 11 9
9 - Adherence to form 25 20 24 24 25 24 20
Total Scores - written proposals 160 126 131 112 136 133 94
68-72 59-64 73-81 59-62 64-73 68-78
4 3 5 1 2 6
Reviewer comments:
Moss Levy - 668 hours. Low visual quality. Modern? Pass with deficiencies - documentation deficiencies
LSL - 519 hours. Minor typos. Good visual quality - indication of nice looking end product
Badawi - local exp Guadalupe, Port SL Harbor Dist. No schedule of hours
GB - 436 hours. Low visual quality. Pass w/deficiencies - CPE
VTD - good viual quality - minor formatting/typos. Similar engagements - huge list. Do they really know what is similar to SLO if this is the list they provide?
501 hours
WNDE - good use of technology. 535 hours