HomeMy WebLinkAboutConsultant Evaluation Form - 2001070 South Broad_Kimley HornSouth Broad Street Corridor Planning & Demonstration Project
SPECIFICATION NO. 2001070
July 2026
CONSULTANT EVALUATION FORM
Reviewer Name:
Noah Maidrand
Consultant: Kimley Horn
Category Notes Points (from 0
to 10)
Responsiveness &
Understanding (40%)
Complete proposal.
All required forms included.
Clear and concise proposal
layout.
Demonstrates thorough
understanding project.
- Previous work done on broad street planning lays good
foundation for design work
- Contract exceptions
- Nothing outside of the box in terms of project approach.
Mostly a reiteration of what was in the RFP
- Performance monitoring framework to measure success
- Not concise
- Not impressed with community outreach phase of proposal.
Only 1 virtual meetings, no in person?
7
Previous Project
Experience (20%)
Experience of firm.
Resumes of staff.
Other projects, including grant
projects, are referenced and
applicable.
- City of Sunnyvale
o Grant funded
o Outreach and engagement
o Eliminated parking for buffered bike lanes
- City of Oakland
o Incorporated quick bid elements
o New ped/bike crossings
- City of SLO
o Traffic analysis and concept design
- Los Gatos
o Quick build class IV bike lanes
o Alternatives analysis
- In general, extensive project experience
- Previous experience on broad street planning effort seems
to put them ahead
9
Proposed Timeframe and
Schedule (20%)
Reasonable schedule proposed
and all elements of RFP included
- Final PSE by June 2027
- Meets outline in RFP
8
Proposed Project Cost
(20%)
Proposal includes hourly rates
Proposal indicates work will be
completed under estimate of
$210,000
- Optional add alts go over $210k
- Travel costs
7
Point Total