HomeMy WebLinkAboutFINAL - Consultant Evaluation Form - 2001070 South Broad - RICKSouth Broad Street Corridor Planning & Demonstration Project
SPECIFICATION NO. 2001070
July 2026
CONSULTANT EVALUATION FORM
Reviewer Name:
Meghan Kolin
Consultant: RICK Engineering Company
Category Notes Points (from 0
to 10)
Responsiveness &
Understanding (40%)
Complete proposal.
All required forms included.
Clear and concise proposal
layout.
Demonstrates thorough
understanding project.
- All required forms included
- Proposal is well organized and concise
- Thorough understanding of the project – all tasks are included with
detailed descriptions of relevant deliverables and work to be
completed
- Aside from missing timeline, proposal is complete
9
Previous Project
Experience (20%)
Experience of firm.
Resumes of staff.
Other projects, including grant
projects, are referenced and
applicable.
- Previous project experience is relevant and referenced, including
grant projects (includes 1 SS4A grant project in this section)
- Staff experience also applicable—includes 3 SS4A grant projects
across multiple staff members
- Redundancy within both companies in transportation planning, civil
design, and community engagement teams
10
Proposed Timeframe and
Schedule (20%)
Reasonable schedule proposed
and all elements of RFP included
- Schedule to be proposed at kickoff meeting, but no timeframe
included with proposal
- Phasing included
5
Proposed Project Cost
(20%)
Proposal includes hourly rates
Proposal indicates work will be
completed under estimate of
$210,000
- Hourly rates included for both RICK Engineering and Kittelson
- Standard services listed
- Under $210,000 excluding optional tasks
10
Point Total
34