The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About02/13/2001, 2 - FINAL EIR, ANNEXATION, & PREZONING FOR THE DALIDIO PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2005 DALIDIO DR. (CITY FILE NOS.: ER, ANNX, R 57-98) Council 2-6 -011 j ac En ba Repout h=Numbw CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO FROM: Ron Whisenand,Development Review Manager By: Pam Ricci,Associate Planner fl?, SUBJECT: FINAL EIR, ANNEXATION, & PREZONING FOR THE DALIDIO PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2005 DALIDIO DR. (CITY FILE NOS.: ER, ANNX, R 57-98) CAO RECOMMENDATION: As recommended by the Planning Commission on July 12, 2000, that the City Council take the following actions on the project: 1. Adopt a Resolution (Attachment 1) certifying the Final EIR including the mitigation monitoring program, based on findings, including a finding of overriding considerations relative to traffic/circulation, air quality, aesthetics, and loss of agricultural land. 2. Adopt a "Resolution of Application" (Attachment 2) requesting that the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCo) take proceedings for the 92.9-acre Commercial Annexation,based on findings. 3. Introduce an Ordinance (Attachment 3) to print approving the Prezoning of 52.9 acres of property to C-R-S, Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning; and 40 acres as C/OS40, Conservation/Open Space with a 40-acre minimum parcel size, based on findings. DISCUSSION Situation The project being considered at this time is the commercial annexation of 92.9 acres of the Dalidio property,bounded on its east side by Highway US 101, and located immediately southwest of the SLO Promenade. Approval of this annexation will allow for the City's Architectural Review Commission and Planning Commission to ultimately review more specific plans for the development of the approximately 515,000 square-foot regional shopping center known as the San Luis Marketplace, which is planned for the site. This agenda item is both a hearing to consider the adequacy of the Administrative Final EIR in terms of its compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and a hearing to consider other project entitlements including annexation and prezoning. An Addenda and Errata/Comments and Responses Report was distributed to the Council, which incorporates clarifications and corrections to the revised Draft EIR, as well as all comment letters and responses. This report is basically the same document that was distributed to the Planning Commission last summer with a few minor amendments that the Commission directed to be 2-1 Council Agenda Report- _audio Property Annexation (ER,A.L,_4X, R 57-98) Page 2 made at their July 12, 2000 public hearing on the project. The revised Draft EIR and the Addenda and Errata/Responses to Comments report collectively comprise the Administrative Final EIR for the Dalidio Annexation Project. After certification, the two reports will be edited together, along with any other modifications made by the Council, into a Final EIR. Planning Commission's Action On July 12, 2000, the Planning Commission considered the same project entitlements that the Council is now considering (see Attachment 7 - Planning Commission follow-up letter dated July 18, 2000.). The Commission made three separate motions, but ultimately a majority of the Commissioners supported recommendations to the City Council to certify the EIR (4-3 vote), annex the Commercial Annexation Area (7-0 vote), and prezone the property C-R-S, Retail Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning, and C/OS, Conservation Open Space with a 40-acre minimum (4-3 vote) Much of the initial Commission discussion on the item centered on the size of the Commercial Annexation Area and the relative proportions of retail versus open space areas, and the basis for making findings of overriding considerations. 25 people spoke during the public hearing. Those in support of the project pointed out that: • the proposed uses were consistent with the adopted Land Use Map designations for the site; • there were economic benefits to the City; • the interchange would provide a needed cross-town connection; • the project provides the City with land use control and open space—neither of which can be guaranteed if the property remains in the County; and • the City needed to provide more shopping opportunities within its own limits. Speakers against the project noted a variety of concerns with the proposal including: • chain stores on the periphery of the City may hurt the success of downtown; • big boxes do not add to City charm and character; • too much retail is currently being proposed throughout the City; • alternative circulation solutions to the Prado road interchange exist; and • the validity of making the needed findings of overriding considerations. A previous hearing on the project was held before the Planning Commission on April 26, 2000. More detail on the history of the project is included in the attached Planning Commission report prepared for the July 12,2000 meeting(Attachment 9). Annexation Mix of Land Uses Because of CalTrans radius and grading requirements related to the design of the proposed Prado Road interchange, the amount of area dedicated to freeway/streets shown on the applicant's latest annexation area map has increased from 8.1 acres to 12.9 acres. Therefore, the total size of the commercial annexation area has increased from 88.1 acres to 92.9 acres. The Council staff report consistently uses this revised acreage total. The proposed mix of land uses is still the same as 2-2 Council Agenda Report—,oalidio Property Annexation (ER,Ai .X, R 57-98) Page 3 shown at the Planning Commission hearing,which is 40 acres of Retail Commercial and 40 acres of Open Space. Land Use Element (LUE) Policy 1.13.5 E., Open Space, sets the standards for open space dedication for the Dalidio area as approximately one half of the annexation land area. A majority of the Planning Commission determined that the applicant's proposal showing equivalent proportions of the annexation land area dedicated for retail development and open space as being consistent with this policy. However, some members of the Commission disagreed and felt that the streets portion of the land area should be considered as developed land, not open space. This opinion argues that there is actually 52.9 acres of developed land (the retail area plus streets) and only 40 acres of open space,which is not an even 500/o/50%split. The Draft Council Ordinance for the prezoning of the annexation has included the 12.9 acres of freeway/streets as part of the C-R-S zoning. The Planning Commission Resolution No. 5294-00 noted a remainder acreage dedicated for streets and highway interchange improvements,but did not specifically include this acreage in either proposed zoning category. While the 12.9 acres will eventually be dedicated to CalTrans for improvements associated with the development of the highway interchange, and to the City for streets, the area for annexation purposes needs to be prezoned. Therefore, staff felt that the C-R-S zoning made the most sense, given its location immediately adjacent to the areas proposed for retail development. Although, a portion of the 12.9 acres also abuts the open space area, it seems overly complicated to further divide this area between the two zoning categories. Since a majority of the Planning Commission accepted the applicant's acreage totals for the different land uses as being consistent with LUE Policy 1.13.5 E., staff has not further altered the Draft Council Ordinance for the prezoning acreage totals beyond what was described above. The City Council, if they vote to support the annexation and prezoning, could further modify the acreages if they feel, like a minority of the Commission did, that it would be more consistent with LUE Policy 1.13.5 E. A precise 500/o/50% split of the total area would be 46.4 acres. Another way to look at the 92.9-acre site's land use acreage totals would be to increase the open space area to 46.4 acres, decrease the commercial area to 33.6 acres, and leave the freeway/streets total as 12.9 acres (see Table I below). It should be noted that the language in LUE Policy 1.13.5 E specifically says"approximately one-half', rather than literally calling for exactly even acreage totals. Table I Mix of Land Uses Open Space Retail Freeway/Streets TOTAL Commercial Applicant's 40 acres 40 acres 12.9 acres 92.9 acres Pro osal Alternative 46.4 acres 33.6 acres 12.9 acres 92.9 acres Approach 2-3 Council Agenda Report -oalidio Property Annexation (ER,Ai-.,,X, R 57-98) Page 4 LUE Policy 1.8.2,Prime Agricultural Land The underlying soils of the commercial annexation area are considered prime agricultural land. The site's resources and current farming operations are discussed in detail in Section 4.6, Agricultural Resources,of the Revised Draft EIR. The previous section of this report discussed how LUE Policy 1.13.5 E.requires that approximately 50%of annexed areas in this Dalidio area need to be dedicated as open space with development. Another LUE policy, 1.8.2,Prime Agricultural Land, also applies to the project because of its prime agricultural land designation. This policy says that prime agriculture land may be developed if the development contributes to preservation of agricultural land in the Urban Reserve by one or more of several methods. In the case of the two policies and the Dalidio property, the two policies reinforce one another. Since the proposed open space land is also prime agricultural land, the agricultural and open space policies may be implemented with the same dedication. EIR Findings The Administrative Final EIR concludes that the project would result in significant and unavoidable Class I environmental impacts in the issue areas of air quality, agricultural resources, aesthetics, and traffic/circulation. Therefore, the Council is required to adopt a statement of overriding considerations if it approves the project as submitted. A detailed discussion of these issues areas is included in the corresponding sections of the EIR and a summary is provided in the attached Planning Commission report. The format of the findings was developed based on past Council actions to adopt EIRs with overriding considerations for other projects. The Planning Commission modified the findings from what appears in the attached Commission report. The version recommended by the Commission is reflected in the attached draft resolution to approve the EIR, and also appears in the attached Planning Commission Resolution No. 5294-00. Summary The applicant is seeking Council approval of an annexation and prezoning, consistent with the site's existing land use designations shown on the City's LUE map. The project was subject to detailed environmental analysis through the Environmental Impact Report (EIR) process. Several actions by the Council are now required. 1. The Council must determine whether the EIR adequately addresses potential environmental impacts and complies with the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). If the Council finds that the document has accurately evaluated potential project impacts,then the Council should certify the EIR. It is important to note that the EIR is not a project entitlement, but rather an important background resource or tool for the Council to use in assessing potential environmental impacts. As such, certification of the EIR as recommended by the CAO, does not mean that the Council has to support the project being requested. A great deal of staff, 2-4 Council Agenda Report- Jalidio Property Annexation (ER,A—_4X9 R 57-98) Page 5 consultant, Planning Commission and public time has gone into the careful preparation and review of the EIR. The advantage of Council certification of the EIR, even if the project is ultimately rejected, is that the information contained in the document can be legitimately used as a data source and cited in the analyses of future projects. 2. The Council must decide whether the project site should be annexed and allowed to develop with the uses proposed. LAFCo will ultimately act on the annexation if the Council takes an action to support annexation. A lot line adjustment must be approved in the County reflecting a lot line consistent with the proposed annexation boundary for LAFCo processing of the annexation to proceed. 3. The Council must determine the appropriate zoning categories for the annexation area. The CAO recommendation reflects that of the Planning Commission, which is that 52.9 acres of the property be prezoned C-R-S, Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning, and 40 acres prezoned as C/OS-40, Conservation/Open Space. FISCAL IMPACT The adoption of the recommendations will have no immediate fiscal impact. However, as outlined in a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) previously adopted by the City Council, the commercial project itself is expected to provide substantial added revenue to the City. According to the MOU, a portion if these new revenues might be used to help fund the needed interchange. Detailed provisions related to revenues and possible reimbursement for interchange costs would be outlined in a Development Agreement, to be negotiated when the project receives all of its necessary Planning approvals. While the MOU is not before the Council at this time, it is available for review in the Council Reading File. ALTERNATIVES 1. Adopt the Resolution, included as Attachment 4, denying the annexation and prezoning requests, based on findings citing inconsistency with Policy LUE 1.13.2 of the City's General Plan (annexation as a growth management tool). This would be the option for the Council to follow if they believed that the underlying land uses of the site as reflected on the existing LUE map are correct, but that the proposed timing for annexation and development is premature given market conditions and current development levels. 2. Adopt the Resolution, included as Attachment 5, denying the annexation and prezoning requests, based on findings that the land use categories for the site reflected on the existing LUE map are no longer appropriate, and directing staff to study land use options for the property and return to the Council at a later date with a report analyzing those options. 3. Continue the project with direction to the staff and applicant if the Council desires further information or analysis to render a decision, or if there is an interest in exploring other land use alternatives with the applicant. 2-5 Council Agenda Report- Aidio Property Annexation (ER, Ai .A, R57-98) Page 6 Attachments: Attachment 1: Resolution certifying the Final EIR Attachment 2: Resolution of Application to LAFCo (Annexation) Attachment 3: Ordinance approving the Prezoning Attachment 4: Resolution denying the project (wrong timing) Attachment 5: Resolution denying the project (wrong land use designations) Attachment 6: Mitigation Monitoring Program Attachment 7: Planning Commission follow-up letter&Resolution No. 529400 Attachment 8: 7-12-00 Planning Commission Minutes Attachment 9: 7-12-00 Planning Commission Staff Report and attachments Council reading File: Approved MOU Revised Draft EIR & Addenda & Errata/ Comments & Responses Report (also distributed to Council) L:Dalidio\CC report 2-6 Attachment 1 Page 1 of 3 RESOLUTION NO. (2001 Series) A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO CERTIFYING THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT(EIR)FOR THE DALIDIO COMMERCIAL ANNEXATION PROJECT LOCATED AT 2005 DALIDIO DRIVE (ER 57-98) WHEREAS, public hearings on this EIR were held before the Planning Commission on August 25, 1999,April 26, 2000,and July 12, 2000,and the City Council on February 6,2001; and WHEREAS, the EIR was considered by the City Council after extensive review by City staff and other agencies, and with the comments of the Planning Commission and concerned public; and WHEREAS, the potential environmental impacts of the project have been evaluated in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act and the City's Environmental Guidelines. BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council as follows: SECTION 1. Environmental Determination. The City Council hereby certifies that the Final Environmental Impact Report for the Dalidio Commercial Annexation Project adequately identifies the project's potentially significant impacts, alternatives to the proposed action, and recommended mitigation measures. SECTION 2. Findings. 1. The Final EIR was prepared in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA) and was considered by the City prior to any approvals of the project. 2. The Final EIR reflects the independent judgment of the City. 3. For each significant effect identified in the EIR under the categories of Geology, Drainage and Water Quality, Noise, Biological Resources, Cultural Resources, and Land Use, the approved mitigation measures contained in the EIR will avoid or substantially lessen the identified adverse environmental impacts of the project to a level of insignificance and have been incorporated into the project. 4. The significant effects identified in the Air Quality, Agricultural Resources, Aesthetics 2-7 Attachment 1 Page 2 of 3 Resolution No. (2001 Series) Page 2 and Traffic/Circulation sections of the EIR will not be fully mitigated to a degree of insignificance with the incorporation of all of the identified mitigation measures included in the EIR. However, the Planning Commission finds that the adverse environmental effects are acceptable and makes a statement of overriding considerations for those significant and unavoidable environmental impacts because: a. Mitigation strategies help to reduce project emissions to the degree feasible and ultimately put the air basin in closer compliance with established State and federal standards. b. The development of the site with a commercial shopping center will significantly affect the character of the site through the alteration of viewsheds from US 101, Madonna Road, and Los Osos Valley Road. However, mitigation measures that require screening landscaping, detailed design review of the bridge for the highway interchange by the Architectural Review Commission (ARC), and ARC approval of lighting, fenestration and other elements of project design, will help lessen the severity of the impacts on viewsheds. c. Traffic and circulation impacts could be reduced to less than significant under the Existing Baseline Plus Project Scenario with the implementation of mitigation measures identified in the EIR. It is with cumulative development under 10 Year Plus Project Conditions and Buildout Plus Project Conditions that the weaving sections of proposed auxiliary lanes, and the Los Osos Valley Road southbound onramp will experience Level of Service below established thresholds. d. For the reasons set forth below, the economic, social, and other considerations of the project outweigh the unavoidable impacts identified above in the findings. First, the annexation will enable the City to achieve its General Plan goals. Second, the annexation will allow for the future development of the site, which will enhance the City's tax base, create more jobs, provide for diverse shopping opportunities for residents of the City, improve City traffic circulation, and create permanent open space. Third, the annexation will ensure that the property is developed in the City. e. The data to support these overriding factors are found in the following sections of the record including: 1.) the Environmental Impact Report, specifically Sections 4.3, 4.6, 4.7 & 4.10; 2.) letters submitted by the public contained in the project files; 3.) public testimony provided at this and previous project hearings; and 4.) the applicant's presentation. 2-8 Attachment 1 Page 3 of 3 Resolution No. (2001 Series) Page 3 f. The Mitigation Monitoring Program has been reviewed and approved by the City Council in conjunction with the certification of the Final EIR. On motion of seconded by and on the following roll call vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: the foregoing resolution was passed and adopted this day of ,2001. Mayor Allen Settle ATTEST: City Clerk Lee Price APPROVED AS TO FORM: i If i I Atto 41ey iff rgensen 1ADalidioUR Res. 2-9 Attachment 2 Page 1 of 6 RESOLUTION NO. (2001 Series) A RESOLUTION OF RECOMMENDATION BY THE SAN LUIS OBISPO CITY COUNCIL REQUESTING THAT THE LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSION APPROVE THE DALIDIO COMMERICAL ANNEXATION (ER,ANNX,R 57-98; 2005 DALIDIO DRIVE) WHEREAS, the Planning Commission on July 12, 2000, and the City Council on February 6, 2001, have held public hearings on the proposed Dalidio Commercial Annexation; and WHEREAS, the City Council on February 6, 2001, by Resolution No. (2001 Series), certified an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the proposed annexation, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines Section 15090; and . WHEREAS, on recommendation of the Planning Commission and as a result its deliberations, the Council has approved the amendment of the Zoning Map by prezoning 52.9 acres of the property for the annexation known as the Dalidio Commercial Annexation to C-R-S, Retail- Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning, and 40 acres as C/OS-40, Conservation/Open Space with a 40-acre minimum parcel size, as shown on the attached Exhibit A; and WHEREAS, City Council approval is a prerequisite for the San Luis Obispo County Local Agency Formation Commission to initiate formal annexation proceedings; WHEREAS, the territory proposed to be annexed is uninhabited, and a description of the boundaries of the territory is set forth in Section 2; and WHEREAS,this proposal is consistent with the sphere of influence of the affected city. THEREFORE,BE IT RESOLVED by the San Luis Obispo City Council as follows: 2-10 Attachment 2 Page 2 of 6 Resolution No. (2001 Series) Page 2 SECTION 1.Findings. 1. The annexation is appropriate since it is within the City's Urban Reserve Boundary, and the site is contiguous to the City. 2. The annexation of the site is a logical addition to the City due to its location in relation to existing urban development. 3. The adopted LUE anticipates the development of the site consistent with project plans and proposed zoning categories. SECTION 2. Annexation Area Described. The Annexation consists of approximately 92.9 acres of the Dalidio property, bounded on its east side by Highway US 101, and located immediately southwest of the SLO Promenade, in the City of San Luis Obispo, County of San Luis Obispo, being a part of Assessor's Parcel Number 067-121-022, as shown on the attached map,Exhibit B, and legally described in the attached Exhibit C. SECTION 3. Council Recommendation. The City Council recommends that the Local Agency Formation Commission of San Luis Obispo County approve the proposed annexation subject to property owner compliance with city requirements regarding environmental mitigation and public improvements as described in the project's EIR, in accordance with California Government Code Section 56844 et. SeMc. SECTION 4. Implementation. The City Clerk shall forward a copy of this resolution, prezoning action, EIR, and all pertinent supporting documents to the Local Agency Formation Commission. NOW,THEREFORE, this Resolution of Application is hereby adopted and approved by the City Council of the City of San Luis Obispo. On motion of seconded by and on the following roll call vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: 2-11 Attachment 2 Page.3 Of`6 Resolution No. (2001 Series) Page 3 the foregoing.resolution was-passed and adopted thus.. day of ,2001.. Mayor Allen Settle ATTEST: City Clerk Lee Price APPROVED AS To FORM: i i Itto ey iff rgensen 1ADalidioWnnex Res 2-g2 �4o Page 4 of 6 r- IJ \ .p / !'/1� •,. \ \ y�_��,,,��Wp- Rao VAN.700 RET • t r — L .r 45 S '')� .ter/ � m1, .. _��.`- �'`• . -'.e._•`. -___:•_i,,-s. � % 9• � ! 39.25 ACRES r'I•. `1 f .I= 1 ,M� /46 ZONE:( C R 4 VI I ,111 i i I; � •'I ''� r ^I 1�! ,�,f;� 1 � 1 I�, �•1 .a1 ri {ZONE: C/OS-40 9P2 A4(.'RES I r 4LL ({MRE 1 I' HIGHWAY .INTERCHANGE) :Y 1/ r j ' a O O 1 /P I Y BOUNDARY DATA NOTE: NET USES OF PARCEL 1 AS FOLLOWS uNE BEARING DIST CONSERVATION OPEN SPACE: 40.00 ACRES Lt x357{'511 at.as' RETAIL COMMERCIAL 40.00 ACRES L2 a NO'so'24� 15{.15'E 116. Or nod{'x{ 1v ROADS FREEWAY AND PRADO 12.88 ACRES u < 4 NIT04'26'E 12&2W � x1279'30'E tot.u' 6 N15T'40'E 100.07 g L7 N131S'orw 71.55 rApyp{R p LB N4252*03T 145.26 a 0{0 9 S2779'40'W 91' � :•am /n MIBIT A ~o c SITE ASSCIAT_S 10 N7M'591W 79.24 ..a ... . I PROPOSED ZONING DESIGNATIONS 11 s6e76.0219 37.94' •1••, •+ SLD MARKETPLACE AND N 12 S7275.00E 32.75' 'Y •,;,•,�,B_'e,a 13 S3'W'"-W 37.96 g , DEVELOPMENT PLAN 14 N10.12023-E 71.50' _<j f' T� „,,,e„ar.s.v om n l .o.me.s an OF SAN LUIS OBISPO. CALIFORNIA /"� 15. N16Z613E 76.74' a p0 .w�i mr ti rw wiw.e .0 xrtRxci n .. L16 NJO'{:SSE 113.92• b �..�ro,oa..r„ma vrar,c.w..cr.ruena. w AM BY D41E G JOB rM. j 17 x63'3:07.9 4&91• VICINITY MAP "`a""r a�a m.r a.�w+ mo Ju 01/ 1 960705.10 c m u.srw.a.rc o wunswu svax wr.m�a. n.,v..n..rw.u u.Z . l cw�.aa..eo•u w.nr<n r¢vcr w. OrEOtED BY 7C.lE 91EET cwr e_.ea.r..a n w[ftwm a m1 nxun.r Cw~ls...cw.Nr r.r..0 n....I=, AGM 1' . 500' 1 OE 3 o Page 5 of 6 � ',�` •.J!'f Vii':\ � -..... • .. \ _-�.,,.- "^ RO,40 I NCH-560 FEET y v r . ell `69; � 'p b' ':as /14 1.17 N -- 39.25 ACRES wIDE DRNA p1AM1F•ESYT 47' PER 1840-OR-27EASEMENT 1u2-OR-370 - + I •• i I' ° 1 � I - /t91TQ9 w'1D•NIDE SEWER /j EASEMENT!PER 3978-CRL544 •�� .: . I I 1.•I : ' /46 rte, a i I �1l I PG&E LUNT. 1 11 Y'•a 1 ^ PER 746-OR-414 LENTERLNE OF TO PARCEL 1 I I I ELL `I r' _ �! PER TOYOR-50iOlT 8Z.✓�E ACRES i (Cx+rm) Atm[) II I rI 51'X410WATERLINE ( ` '•'`. .: m i1 5'MADE PG&E; ', 1EENT PER 695-OR-291 1 a. EASWENT PER f 1 - L:• 2479-132-949' SELL 1 , . 6 ' -7 a i p 0 0 P 1 BOUNDARY DATA oUNE I BEARING I DIST LI I NW34'51'w 41.45• L2 I NJM'11'E 1116.Or a L] I NO'24'24'E 154.15' L4 .NIIM4'2irE 12926' L5 NI 30'E IDI.u' i L6 NMI'40'E IDD-02- N13'150"g L 71. 5 0q�A7 c a N42'52'OSE t45.2B' a R04D e L9 S2772.40-W 2191• J1fP Marmon EXHIBIT B SITE A`'s` a.res L10 N70z 59-W 79.24' E 11 4I F 1 4 ANNEXATION MAP 'm 11 568%'02'w 37. ' 94' r+ •"•:.1: • SLO MARKETPLACE AND 0 12 s3sw� 3z z7s DEVELOPMENT PLAN c L13 S396'u'w 37.96• m L1a x10't2'23'E 71.50• CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO. CALIFORNIA ms maurzm w wnwm n fJ.-oY"....'rzs � 15 N167B'ISE 76.74' tul•c w w;Nu4a1 Q+Irtmwu smaa wo m f� •� s-w N.•-x re011ln o n Iw nwlar w. 0 COGS IP�tOYw.d vm QI[4"6- n 16 N30'tr55'E 1119r b mxcwl oar-1-nrs v[onc rllatcr.rlwnu. 6RANr BT ATE •A1B N6. n N633ro7w .991 VICINITY MAP "`"" °""""°" ° �°"� a' m u nnua•rs o wvesawa ss..¢wnmr¢o .IN 01/ (Qt 980705.10 n w.wt orlu nwr a-•r�r n.o"ma �` ml¢owm rp.u un.ond r®n mA CMEdm By SCALE 91FET m�isnnm'�+asr�m+'m Mss u -rmn ACM I� - 500' 2 m 3 Page 6 of 6 OWNER: THELMA T PEROZZI TRUST DALIDIO FAMILY TRUST CLARA B. DALIDIO TRUST 2706 RODMAN DRIVE LOS OSOS, CA. SITUS: 1035 MADONNA ROAD, SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA. APN: 067-121-022 COAL 00- 0226 THAT PORTION OF LOT 64 OF THE SUBDIVISIONS OF THE RANCHO CANADA DE LOS OSOS AND LA LAGUNA, IN THE COUNTY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO. STATE OF CALIFORNIA, ACCORDING TO MAP FILED FOR RECORD IN BOOK A. PAGES 83 AND 84 OF MAPS, IN THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER OF SAID COUNTY, AND THAT PORTION OF LOTS L, M AND N OF THE RESUBDIVISIONS OF LOTS 58, 61, 62, 63, 64, AND 65 AS PER J. T. STRATTON'S SURVEY AND MAP OF THE SUBDIVISIONS OF THE RANCHOS CANADA DE LOS OSOS AND LA LAGUNA, IN THE COUNTY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO, STATE OF CALIFORNIA ACCORDING TO MAP FILED FOR RECORD JANUARY 30, 1875 IN BOOK A, PAGE 161 OF MAPS, IN THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER OF SAID COUNTY z a m r ti 0 s N O O ' Q I n O yU_ 6 �Z< J g llc E)4{IBIT C AS5*C1a.Tas .,..... I LEGAL DESCRIPTION •""°'• SL0 MARKETPLACE AND 8 - DEVELOPMENT PLAN *m oocuuc.r ais Yay.wm 01 Cw ,, A%' CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO. CALIFORNIA % 1i.1 N ui wirwin Y wor[ssw,Ynx¢uq m swu x..w a.iamn o u r.e aoaY.Y.. Yurrui road ry ror.+n om m0ml¢• DB.W BY D.iE JOB N0. cow[nmi oat wrY wn m[anc wertr.nwna.. u m u MmY.cw�rs norr'svau i�mn�a nr�'imuun JN 01 I 980705.10 B.M110M1 OM[,Mq G Y.1 9 9 T Y. m rarva.aai wed u u Wm ,iron wm, * O CGIED By WALE 91EET ctirir<.ra.ru¢o Bawl r nrs mr. ,� tl.pTN1O.0[I,41 r0 1Y[4 IpY6 Yp(apTW1 AGM 3 � Attachment 3 Page 1 of 3 ORDINANCE NO. (2001 SERIES) AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO AMENDING THE ZONING REGULATIONS MAP TO DESIGNATE 52.9 ACRES AS C-R-S, RETAIL-COMMERCIAL,WITH THE SPECIAL CONSIDERATION OVERLAY, AND 2) 40 ACRES OF THE SITE AS C/OS-40, CONSERVATION OPEN SPACE WITH A 40-ACRE MINIMUM PARCEL SIZE, CONTINGENT UPON FINAL APPROVAL OF ANNEXATION OF THE SITE AT 2005 DALEMO DR. (R 57-98) WHEREAS, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on July 12, 2000, and recommended approval of amendments to the Zoning Regulations map; and WHEREAS, the City Council conducted a public hearing on February 6, 2001, and has considered testimony of other interested parties, the records of the Planning Commission hearing and action, and the evaluation and recommendation of staff; and WHEREAS, the City Council finds that map amendments are consistent with the General Plan Land Use Element (LUE) map and text, and the City Council finds that the map amendments are consistent with the purposes of the Zoning Regulations and other applicable City ordinances; and WHEREAS, the City Council has certified the Final Environmental Impact Report, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines Section 15090. BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of San Luis Obispo as follows: SECTION 1. The City council finds and determines that the project's Final Environmental Impact Report adequately addresses the potential significant environmental impacts of the proposed Zoning map amendments, and reflects the independent judgment of the City Council. The Council through the certification of the Final Environmental Impact Report incorporates the mitigation measures listed in Exhibit D into the project (see Attachment 6—Mitigation Monitoring Program). SECTION 2. The Zoning map amendment (prezoning) R 57-98, designating 52.9 acres of the property as C-R-S, Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning, and 40 acres as C/OS-40, Conservation/Open Space with a 40-acre minimum parcel size, as shown on the attached Exhibit A, is hereby approved, based on the following findings: Findings. 1. The proposed "S" overlay zoning will document the special considerations for the Commercial-Retail portion of the site (C-R-S) which are: drainage, flooding protection, urban/agricultural buffers, roadway improvements and design, pedestrian linkages with other commercial developments and nearby residential areas, loading area design, compliance with energy conservation requirements, creek and open space protection, site lighting and preservation of scenic vistas. 2-16 Ordinance No. k,4001Series) Attachment 3 Page 2 Page 2 of 3 2. The required Planning Commission use permit for development of the commercial area of the site will serve as a master use permit that fulfills the intention of LUE Policy 1.13.3, Required Plans, which calls for the master planning of proposed annexation areas so that the City has an adopted plan showing the project layout, physical development plan, required open space protection, and provision of streets and utilities. SECTION 3. A summary of this ordinance, together with the names of the Council Members voting for and against, shall be published at least five (5) days prior to its final passage, in the Telegram-Tribune, a newspaper published and circulated in this City. This ordinance shall go into effect upon final approval of annexation of the site by the Local Agency Formation Commission. INTRODUCED AND PASSED TO PRINT by the Council of the City of San Luis Obispo at a meeting held on the 6th day of February 2001, on motion of seconded by , and on the following roll call vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: Mayor Allen Settle ATTEST: City Clerk Lee Price APPROVED AS TO FORM: *itto ey ff J gensen 1A1Dalidio\R 57-98(Ord) 2-17 Page 3 of 3 ...,.\ 1• 0 m m • r ' �, ... Y I ...• . � YA04Wq 10 T�'II r /14 w -t -F 39.25 ACRES j .1. r rl , r{ ,' B/48I ZONEr T-S 1 j 51, I1 ZONE: C/OS-40 92 (FUTURE - L HIGHWAY 1 { ,INTERCHANGE' e i 8 O O 1 1 i BOUNDARY DATA NOTE: NET USES OF PARCEL 1 AS FOLLOWS S 6EA91Nc DISTCONSERVATION OPEN SPACE: 40.00 ACRES 1 N35'34'stw 41.45' RETAIL COMMERCIAL 40.00 ACRES z NeSo•n� ns.o7• No'24'24 E 154.15' ROADS (FREEWAY AND PRADO) 12.88 ACRES C< t N1194'28'E 12826' `j N1239.30'E 101.44' i N751'40'E 100.02' S 7 N1315'08w 71.35' a 114py�t c 8 N423 03-E 145.28• NOap 52 'bw 2191' SITE A Sa$ lPQ�1 EM181T A 10 N707Ys9w 79.2e 4.0,.[141 I PROPOSED ZONING DESIGNATIOI 11 sse,s o2 w 37.94 ••• •32.75• SLID MARKETPLACE AND .35 12 812 '0! u $ a r s5ve•t4w 37.96• S� �10, .• .-� DEVELOPMENT PLAN 14 N,o,r 71.50' ry o ,o�.wn�sY CITY OF SAN wls a815Po. CALIFORNIA ,4 Is NI 8'1 76.74' , a 76 N30Y7'55'E 113.92• Y..Y.mYe m4.4Y.uno-.n.solo!¢ mYas eY...n,.rs sense I,o4e,.rurla. Oaa441 BY Oat[ CA JOB N0. z 17 Ne33rorW 4&91' VICINITY MAP °`""' " "'a" �"`°'° e rY u.smd4Y,1 o wor®o...amc.nimu¢Y .W 07MA 1 960705.1 0 n w,Ya m,o r1Y u u.oar r.OY1@ SCa1fT Dann.®rte s va souo.>o om.ar m.0rYrp.osupr,Y ae rL.6 s mmvc 11611 1' . S00' SNI1tt 3 Attachment 4 Page 1 of 3 RESOLUTION NO. (2001 Series) A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO DENYING THE REQUEST FOR ANNEXATION AND PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE ZONING REGULATIONS MAP IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE CONSIDERATION OF THE DALDIO COMMERICAL ANNEXATION PROJECT LOCATED AT 2005 DALIDIO DRIVE (ER, ANNX, R 57-98) WHEREAS, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on July 12, 2000, and recommended approval of annexation and amendments to the zoning map in conjunction with the consideration of the Dalidio Commercial Annexation located at 2005 Dalidio Drive; and WHEREAS, the City Council conducted a public hearing on February 6, 2001, and has considered testimony of the applicant, interested parties, the records of the Planning Commission hearing and action, and the evaluation and recommendation of staff; and WHEREAS, the City Council finds that the annexation and proposed zoning map amendments are inconsistent with the several policies of the General Plan as evaluated in the project's Environmental Impact Report and Planning Commission report; and WHEREAS, the potential environmental impacts of the project have been evaluated in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act and the City's Environmental Guidelines. BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of San Luis Obispo as follows: SECTION 1. Findings. 1. The proposed annexation and prezoning are premature given market conditions and current development levels. Consistent with the goals and policies of the General Plan, specifically Policy LUE 1.13.2, annexations may be used as a growth management tool when such circumstances exist. 2. General Plan Policy LUE 1.11.4, Nonresidential Growth Rate, allows for consideration of establishing limits for the rate for nonresidential development if the 2-19 Attachment 4 Page 2 of 3 City Council Resolution No. (2001 Series) Page 2 increase in such development exceeds 5% for any five-year period. The 2000 Draft General Plan Annual Report indicates that the five-year, exclusion-based growth rate was 5.9%. This growth rate is above the policy threshold and significant enough where limits in nonresidential development may be considered. 3. Nonresidential building area is projected to grow two to three times faster than the number of dwellings built during the next several years, which further contributes to the City's jobs/housing imbalance. SECTION 2. Denial. The annexation and zoning map amendments (prezoning) to designate 52.9 acres of the property as C-R-S, Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning, and 40 acres as C/OS-40, Conservation/Open Space with a 40-acre minimum parcel size, are hereby denied: On motion of , seconded by and on the following roll call vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: The foregoing resolution was passed and adopted this_ day of , 2001. 2-20 Attachment 4 Page 3 of 3 City Council Resolution No: (2001 Series) Page 3 Mayor Allen Settle ATTEST: City Clerk Lee Price APPROVED AS TO FORM: AA4A:AvvJmAAZA^ en- I:\ audio\R 57-98 :(d wrong riming) 2-21 Attachment 5 Page 1 of 3 RESOLUTION NO. (2001 Series) A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO DENYING THE REQUEST FOR ANNEXATION AND PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE ZONING REGULATIONS MAP IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE CONSIDERATION OF THE DALDIO COMMERICAL ANNEXATION PROJECT LOCATED AT 2005 DALIDIO DRIVE (ER, ANNX, R 57-98) WHEREAS; the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on July 12, 2000, and recommended approval of annexation and amendments to the zoning map in conjunction with the consideration of the Dalidio Commercial Annexation located at 2005 Dalidio Drive; and WHEREAS, the City Council conducted a public hearing on February 6, 2001, and has considered testimony of the applicant, interested parties, the records of the Planning Commission hearing and action, and the evaluation and recommendation of staff; and WHEREAS, the City Council finds that the annexation and proposed zoning map amendments are inconsistent with the several policies of the General Plan as evaluated in the project's Environmental Impact Report and Planning Commission report; and WHEREAS, the potential environmental impacts of the project have been evaluated in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act and the City's Environmental Guidelines. BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of San Luis Obispo as follows: SECTION 1. Findin s. 1. The Council finds that the current land use designations shown for the Dalidio property are no longer appropriate given changed conditions in terms of overall retail development Citywide and concerns for the long-term preservation of remaining prime agricultural farmland around the City. 2. The significant effects identified in the Air Quality, Agricultural Resources, Aesthetics and Traffic/Circulation sections of the EIR will not be fully mitigated to a degree of insignificance with the incorporation of all of the identified2gation Attachment 5 City Council Resolution No. (2001 Series) Page 2 of 3 Page 2 measures included in the EIR. The adverse environmental impacts associated with project development may be reduced, or potentially eliminated in some cases, with different land use designations for the property. SECTION 2. Denial. The annexation and zoning map amendments (prezoning) to designate 52.9 acres of the property as C-R-S, Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning, and 40 acres as C/OS-40, Conservation/Open Space with a 40-acre minimum parcel size, are hereby denied, and City staff is directed to study land use options for the property and return to the Council at a later date with a report analyzing those options: On motion of , seconded by and on the following roll call vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: The foregoing resolution was passed and adopted this_ day of , 2001. 2-23 t Attachment 5 Page 3 of 3 City Council Resolution No. QQQI Series) - Page 3 Mayor Allen Settle ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM:. o ey ar rgensenI: alidio Ra.( t6*1a lite) 2=2.4. And hment 6 y a m xhibit D c E Pa l of 43 U � y c m o m � � a U O !� U C d Cl) p:lk Q Z < C e cc m CL a m m m e m o to co� Qa � � o UU c� U U • • Lu co cF 0,0 Wm r .0 O G V) � a o3 C yLL m z c o a V m o E e d m to rm y C 0 o C aLLLLEo � LL (D U O � yCmm CL c 9y2ml- O O C C3 -�C' . OC T= m m 7 dC m mO �ul I wI Z C — cCc I ° ° C _ CZUCmOO c Q 5 E 0 E N° ° y LCL 3: � V Q U.LLLL J W yo a 0>j2I r a � i aci to uu .y 9 O) m m 7 .m. dC Ua to ED y L d m N 'O m m C m 4 > 3 f0 C d y � O m `m a) Y d m r E N C y L m C C y L w C E2m0o o3N X52:2 o 0 o `m '3maE'i c'cic� aci oEmjfAL > a E a > ami m o. m e "� m p °' ° ° c .. c m m a a o � E c 5 = 0 m e °' N c 'v o aw 10 acNaci 'v E YuUtvtr- rn<v m ° mmCD m_ po• CL E C p o f v rp `c L m e m ° N (D mE ~ c and E mm O) 0) to 0 d O E � V N m .� a) C T C N .L.. w C m C C V > cm � acim Nho- ° m ` aN � mcc�i •Otoc � 8 � Y000 v a d a w p — U- n ao v -e m 0 d ° _ N m B y m E Q vo c •- mN cvo 'cmap am N cm > go d 7 m L m a i p w U C ul Y m m O m U7U m m `. O N -O p 7 C C CL L 0 7 L m - > C 9 r y 0) m m U ° m _N U m U C C a u N m A 0 Q m O F a s< O` N O m m E C y m N E y � ° = N = m CLU a) ° � `mm � � a>i ° o aLo0NaEoc Ea �� ' IL ° r . a4) m ai m d ° C7 pL E p m1- a E m c p m m oa=_ m A c o 13 cHa arn$ c1- m 'v a c -C - a_ b U - az O) p C m N N �p y ' A N t N M O L m e - C O _ - N r 0 0 O O a O .D N m m .o U O N M L O U m a�p O cl L m U 0 c� 7 y •) y O.y .0 3 O.L.. $ c > a E •d m O C m a O L O. e) fA E w N C7 7 a s WE T3 CL O y N R c m m faO .Lm.. C E .yL m O O N m c 'e ° 7 C `) E c Q6 t5 OODOO V N m m U L E J Y L y m e m C 3 0) C:0 .O m LU L m s O m y C .e O C U y m '3 C la CJ r m 3 •° m L O m N m m O U N m - fA J -•I C C 0 U m O 'm0 ° y T m O u.. (0 d 2 E e" m m N V w U E YO r L !-' C E J C C z � cmrcmTNE gma ommm LEam m � mammNcn myCmm m C m 7 •7 m G E ° C CL.. T C m m C ` L U y y N N E a L p p p ul r r c o cil � E p t oU m c m m N m ' V = m ° 'i 10 —N" aam L�r �� < «_ o y 3 � o c m U cw come E E o )co m � L ° 4 m = c ami °-o < ClU�iltl C A O m 0 L m E t 'e O d m N '-y m N O).`a c m m ` m a•O I I U o t " c vlv m o •- 0 � T� m E m 1 1 m Im C p m C C N 7 C O W O > C L C < W C c C .2 O p I O O orL F m :.. W 0 ,o Nm m U � = C •c ° -0 m c oro c 4 4 c O 3 O K K IL 0 -j � � ami m a m > 5 E c a w m Lm 0 en:2 > - cm 15 m' � m � to too E cl a0 a z ° ° Cvrncmio � ac) mon 6 0.-C � aE O °7jvM > > a v rn W W o c a C Qa 2 c m LU o o c m am lu c o o � P _E 0 C9 (7 m m N _ m w 7 0 U' N 0)J= 7 r in m a C7 a.- e _ _ 2-45 AttaC ent 6 c 0 Exhibit D o E Page 2 of 43 H .= o m U y V Y O n V o m _ v a c a `0 0 C L) mm m CL m a cu ii CL E o m ❑ ❑ elm orl C-)d' a ❑ W O= w M 13 m N �+ a•- C V 0 3 N m U m O E « ? m D C CL E >? Q� ym � O m m y LA- LL C C .m. y C m m LL O O M . m E Nm O 0 .0 .- � 2ME rmEU— OR m C O O cm y1 3 « � v € t n o c c S c c= 0 1 1 p n'3 c `o 0 - E o 7 � E v LLLL� 'C N j m 'C to j y Q g CL .� .0 a a y .0 a j7zUU C C _m O7 m C N T m T � � Lm.. � L.. p W m 7 'ta m T Od C N C m N C m N L S O y p y 7 7 m U C Q m m . y y m m . = p� C E LU C T m 'C •O C �(pp ..� 'C C mm C L p w `d•, U a1 d U m O L m � > m m N C O > m 00) N C C O c o i `o E c > o E c Q LYom oynEma; QN ? E 'md a urn o• c o $ c o o c o o c o m amu o m a m u u o d o m e ¢ a� � urn< CL 0IM ccEE mm isa m m m CD °a W c o m o o y H e a v > m 10 m E '� u o m C m w o 0 o m o c E R m m 'm0 .y.. U •C O m W O> m a) N U �? L] Y° m o Y mK m p c u 2 0 ° is � ''c t N v .y �'o- m E C. = U L C CL y N 47 C m m N C w m C C > C a[ Q `m i � 3r E O m m ma E a y m E CL ° E `-' mumi1! o w n:o >` a 0 ° m m � t .0 c C 0 � m m N , c. a CL c o 'er E c .0 e m o c 3 m m o v -.az Im m m o N w � r o c « um d m m v c `o Tc yw � - c y m O. O. O c.c ti y mE - r~ Sob oec `° - � o X4) 4) Qa mamNN o c yet o g� 3 Qo o .o' o criQ in m m c � c Nv y 'o c OOZOO CL 0 y C y C m � O � M h y L � 'H v CD'ol r cpp m 43 u a O O a= m 0 m U ' O w. � co {Up t0 O U ' C .O m m 7 E .0 E O C j = . 0 0 'C y L N O N N m E b J J 7 J J E C 3 L U L m y C a1 O'E ;z ` m p U L C L y N N «L• m m C c c J c c a1 C X IM m 7 y y ❑ O O m m C z U t O m m N E u o m 0 0 0 rn O c N O O C ` '0 O ` m C b W h V Ol 7 N L.. m C "4 co c `m Q .0.. O C r c 'C 7 m a) O "' O C b m U L N O - '0 > T C A m m C N C S a1 m aa: m b L C C N m O m C U C V V U U U o Em _ a� r m a� > o m > > � H - m >1r - 0) nz a m m m ui E � a) C- ao nem ? �vH m a` v c0) c Ea o ' 93 Ixw o c ` aCUv d nC E d m m m a, � m c>a�az d O a c m a N d b C aJ CV m M:.. c c m a o oe m '- N � c :° 0 00 �' O � y'Hc .2 � ac � ;C Ol .E a m O m 'j U W W 'O W o d x m > U ❑ � Sm uin (nom C7UN C7aomE (Qc 2 / . . . Attachment g 0 0 Page ao 4 2 E � a k CL _ § G . § \ ■ # § 0C ■ a E § � ■ _ | ■ a C G E W� a ;k r—0 a ° C -E [2 ! ` IL o � e 0 LL R ■ a2 ' ■ §) a 727 �J § � § 0 � m . wIzuz 0 k § % k S-$$§ � a 2 E U)&■ 0Q Z)Mzu0 go $ - Cr .0 /i � � \ 0 ) D a) ■ 2a [ § fk k - � . � \k) kkk ■© CL \2 \ � ■ G 2 ] » � � ■■ e a • 80 - t § 2 I ) ƒ! 7I | E CL Z [ £ 2 § d 2 a- CD « 00 -Q ;- ■ ` | % k _ .9 ` § &, _ /\ dk ) B \ \ °0.{�§§ r CL 0 2q � � . � k �9gea CL k fj � � 27 \ � k §�(2 & & 2 - 02 � . 0 %� .9ik i � f )) j)} M m ■ % @A � o ' n � � § a a2 ■ aa k � 2 � kk � k ) � $ a ■ %%2%0 � � kQkk � [f � /) a AL) KE £ as % ) uw $d ® - G o • ° ok s [ SE §�§ .2CM 06 0 # tM � 0 M 2-17 chment 6 °a a m Page 0 10 E N O = U y C N ° m p CL E 'm c m c n `0 0 ocmmm E00 0 c `—' E DI ❑ c 2 mCL e � a U U L) oU) u0F y 9 m e O S y m ., O! > 0m� m -C C ° C Q C a g q m IC OL m C� yItLLO r2 LL c C c « � m m O O O «i3moo U) 9m2 10= p = '0aEm « 03 -1:1 a Cb O 'CC 3 ° N°a� o >> mH p U Ol N IL I Z U Z O y 1 1 ° C W C N 7 m Q{3L m O F U. g a La C. d Nm G ❑ NU)aaGQ 3mzUU c C Q � Ol N p� _ df V L L C 7 � WC f0 N p Q L C m p 13 L C m > > m m .r m 0 � m m " m oL m my � .L-. .Z`L.. f0 « .�+.L., rm •� �' is -0 C 0 0 .8CD U O m « V Q Qnm� NG lL -p ppo>a E c c 0 E` E « ncL « � .i C0 '0c Hc o cm mo � '� cm cnm . „ aon. 10 CL m m Q y m 0 C m G W 0 O a) O N L C o O• 0 M � 6 i p N p g = y . m Ern >0 L a) ca c m r `0 m ° m E n- 0000 ° > al .0 m N m m L 'O >,=% Cd m :w K m E c — n m a o G � 3 « � yCN me :? m —E o m o E :: N p y c mw 0 ma y my 030 c � � Q N O)� vE coat t � � c � � 'OO v E0 IL c Scow ° o " � EeaU .Gm � mw � oow � m om 0�: « m o mo m N CO Emge " mE8aE ym Ts . = (0)a- c a !c m a0i w t W m 'oa c°i X `o 3 (D 0 rnO � E y m �W o °o a �. 'p �' a N G G m m m .p m 7 •E 09_ O. m o c c c �m0 Eo °IWmAD r- ma•N � c � W m t � aa�aa CL ° �O 0O C y aNi c o 'C m m ¢1 �'o > > 0 « m m m O Ow O O O a) cmi 'py0G a � 0 cm W - c Eao pa 0_ ON C Hym ._.. a 7mxNOl Um m y 'Cf« m m` O JJ 7JJ O C O t -0 m = W q N G .L.. "� 'm m m E m C C C J C C m.. m "' y O a) 4) C a1 b m w. W p U ° L ` O c A m X m m N N U 7 ° N ,° C G ° C_ C 01 e•F 7 G N a1 a1 m i�a7 C m L O 3 C m y m G C N y CD = m a V �.9 C w O� O O m C N 1; y O W O _ H m 7 O C Z C ..+ N CO O ` m a W k W G G C 0 y L O M A C -OD C m m k O Q .°+ O = — M = a1 3 3 ego m '0 7 .y W N a rn o N m -c r N V mc A. o a c W G G G c o N N a' .. m y ° _ E m I UU ° of m � � m m5a"ic° OEaaO � o = $ mCD ❑ Om I � I I I Q c N a> rn m o L° �= m E m L R m o m UaDa.Z a 0 4 c c c m B G e _ = E G E « L p W O m M'n L Ym y p € y i� d u? y m O y a Cf 'W'^^ n y '�C '7 o IL C m O 2 E m t m UJ 0 E ... 2-18 Mfffiac ent 6 w 0 m bit D c 0 E Pae 5 of 43 0 = U CL U E FICI U a o c c u ta O D 1 o aoa p a a mu m N p c2 Mo. mQ U O O1m aCc • U d W N m 7 `0 0u c r _ m N N _ mm �+ m , § U) r C 0 E m o m ` m C m v c ° r = u c � `m'E cr aai E n, r � r ma 03 o y d a2LL ELLo � a 2 c, ammWm 7 nc°) O 0E U) o ONE WE = m c IM ° L)i w yc yv4) E cm021 m •C0 o � �� ami m °y 8 = tmo mymom ma ', � MWy 3 ° � � � E > 8 � o ° °)^ a o c c Her ° ° rn O W I zUz 0 7 0 C N U mCO e 3 n E a) m O V C c O N I I o a` N 0) CL O m o ° 0 ca y m o °� CL d n@ o c H ° a3LLL � . CL cm CL a) ° 0 C N nod C d NL d VJwf OQ 7 7 z U U w to O C 9 O ° E C fa L° c o � � � T �. o E a)i6'Duco i c Rm' O C a) a a1 c C mG - � oDc MD O O N 4y ° 2da AEE c woCS c0 aI Eo Omv CL 2 O � c t Oo •O c oc0 d E m— mp w CD CL 0 ° o c) cra a � m - MD o60amEc � :. ° 'a� ° N mac > a 3 (D 'D n c , o ? o v . n°L c c •x m m m d c � 'X a m m o E c ° c N > Q O o y � 3 m c rn 0) o o ° o o x 3 m w d e 0 m a a W� @dtc Edo ` mrn t ° n10mac) aamCM LWmc0L �30�¢ oI Q at ° nt � m mcmncnc � yn ° cLm ^ U29a ° � E `uNN : o .� > 0 ❑ o m rn m n o m y y .y E o m e E.0 d m o IL o r_ (D � cUaaMx ° = EC7-5 c CL ° M � ° m °d = `mm C O J ` C cc W fA « a) M 0)C a) ` INO � N m a) c E aaj � w „ m > O �= 00 a j a- 0 -CLM dr 0" c � $ c Tt ° �+ O N E m0 ° > m o > V w m o as o c C'J ° v > w ° y � ° o .� v ° x � °cccoYc� U � yc 0c ° aauaiaa CL V CLL `m o .0 c � (DZ'0 ° o2oUW m �� ° QvY ° 0 00000 c � m UpyyoGLL �° Emc :° ~ tom QyyUycm` m '� o)c (Dm� Som > > Sc = j cnmo0Q ° oE °aacia � ° `° 5, m '0 c aE ° � � _�� i0 A Ima S ° () .c ai n t .4 a) d E E a f0 N a N > d N C O t '� N /6 O A m e m m X w .O °-_ a) >, C > a O N G W N c N o 0 m O N a W m m Om N a) c r2 O A N L o C y a) _ U a a) r E 3 C O > C V a) > _ > 10 a y w r C � c Z C Co Q a1 O a) E m f0 a) 0 N «? C d y c c a W M U m a 0 0° Q) p O.0 0 0 Q a0 O E N a3 w V °) a) L C c N -D a) is - o L 0 0 a1 O 4) L N ° � Il N ?+'�'° ?•'�` Q 0 T CD *5 O Q CL G.. y m a) 'y n ° O.= V 0 - n_ O a) of O 0 N 0 n� _a G = rn o �° N N = ° y z c m u m w c_ y w {Ea �j m l O V I I O c Q N c '- O N E N y Q: .N-. a1 c 2 O N - 9 d a) fca .. c > V -7 O O Mir d o g ? =°m .2` c E p IDM a rNii �C m w o m L H wo y N m �, M d) E �•c a _ V d7az a7 0) N M r O V N N N •0 c O 0 c C 7 N r r3 IM OOva) v E .02 D avniw m `m `m 'o, � -0 wv m °° a � tiGH ° 9 # ° 2-t9 ALI ent 6 ° a m Page 6 of 4310 c C- E z o U N C A O °• V o U a c' m O co C 0 � � S w � w a � m m a ��a. 0 0 UQIU. LLQ Cr UW " a U V U ? O D U j V w N 0 '0 E fwum~ o= Z2.6 Wa W n U) c Cr- O C W Q w.2 LL W m �m m a' V -"° � Ltmn c' cr aA = Em o E m m gLL U. U U LLCW o o O o o B � o�WmEpW .oN* mn yy C O . U C 'CC O a co U m m V'dm^ OI O � O O 7 j W N y ° y c c E CL cmLp c = 6 mom- °' m 1 2 C3%% 3 a°+ Q O Q p C L) a W p .°+ 0 x « C C ' _ ! yz 11 0 ° o °7 > � r ycoacm °cofmE o3E ° aIILL m � = c� mo = ac m = �+ `m = y m d m -0 .O 8 O m S a m m V/ d !0 0) O. Ll !O G IL Ina1Moa 77ZUU LD Y Y C CD O rte-. d m T = p 7 G 'EO U- V � C R •O O W cr H = L o > m C 'O c m G m E G � aY LG CD U CL a $ m E c 0 o o d ; v m a m m •0 cEmmy c) y5 c ° E E 0 1° CD v W C W m Ip m a v -0 o OL c = o ._ cIm CL O O Op p,OL o@ a ' m Q- m m C C o +, q C ILL LL w va m m n aC m o t_CD m c y y v E ° a A m y > n � � a ° v t m o E io c m° E 0 c mLm m e CO CL y �uoiz U) E _ 7 n W v O m 4 y N m C: �!_ C Ol'O c 0 O ?. O C cm C C m Qa mm amimo � c` � � Ec coEYWm � 3 EmEy 'E E�� E CD LE ._ W � - o - WE $ oom dNma jL Eam 3 p Hw > c rnU aOo o � � ° d = mow (D IL o M . W W a 3rri mmm a- m c mE U c a- C m d' m LL m 'O c '_ m O. m c p m m O y .0 U :.IL z pI ° _ C E d c m o m m >, C L: y 0 p 0 0 0 C O C = m a a l0 m m m X m O N d U ° U m L'A N � "I C a a 0 0.G :E � c�' c o (D Fz � � lima oU c CL c 'o ami aai oo `o m0 aW 0 mm mem « mw > U 'c ._ cpm v w > . m V . � m o � ° 'a = cmyo �j � E -5CLm rnaa� mea at000W O 0.' m m .r r. m « L �! W m m ` m C O a: 7 7 0 7 7 C .0 W D N °.W = O A r- 0 E O a. C m ui m E Vj w m '- C c 111 N C J J 7 J J 4 C 7 - m m O. m m 0 ° 'O .5 1 O m C m p 0 N 0 zI. Cam+ C C J C C m m6f m ll f0 E J p C C C m 0. C m W= « D 0-C C W y c W W .. >. = m m m W .O C m am U m a ch Wt90 X m Ly p �r. O O w n-0 C. m 0 y = L = m °• 'O c 0 U U �-'r H -0 me g v ovcn > > m EEE L aapmamiE9 .. c my o� o oofoo c � � v W y c� p2 Q 0 m aE - a"i � Sr W CC m a « 0 .0 � . � r.- Z00iocm � m � m � 0QmDCMCO , a �o $ � « uV�c�t� O Ip :: J y C m G -0 'O Q 10 V Y V O W m 'O m O y c E Q O 1 1 5 1 1 D) m ; mmmW « c OG1 LLL Umd - m OOOZ no 1o0 C .p CL E N V EBF O V CLW m m C an -- m C .... 0 C U :: `C +L-. 03oIR L c 3 rn E v o m molt m cc co �^ v, > U c m of rn._ m cM �!1 1_ U a�a z C "' m = V r' a W tF L) CN 7 m C M V a) U w N r c 'el C y E 0 N :v_ Wrn > U103tm ° mpH Ti � mal� + omm > E ::'A c3 Dalc3 So W2 auc s o a� oLOo. rwmUU o (XD _ m w nm 0 O ent 6 H c m Pagc 7 of 43 0 E ° ° J V W C � O B V 0 a Cv c m 0 p CA o �. nSS Z �p O C W d o- m u m L CL m a c— E 0 �$] m Im a OUB U7 aU wmvno o— Z � OZ m m 0 ma E' HLL Ec C N VFX m`p £� C 3 m m C t t m S ° 0 c Q W- m GG C N m �p ILLL � U. 0 Q = r y0Or- CML m • • O O W ..5MO0 Wa ° c o `o a a a Ev Cl) c m mcl) c '0 c o 0 o c o o m = � c� : 2 a � dts m U 0 ?�it�y �e z 5 = p c o= d) UooCcurc 0M 02 : m � o2 0 i C d D m N U D m 0 0 U •0 N E Q LL LL LL J cg • • U U m d !V a d a�U) 7 7 z V V n cco Y O ca ma c m 2 W E o om > m w = m N m m m m z oU CX rn c c w ° m ooa 'c�io — o NfOL aW i 0 Z o o � y E « m Q m d a o N N a 0 Q > l0�C W G a W a a LL C CL C O p N O 0 C Z • • LiO Q CL m m G m �d=mCmaLLo� WwVcm FO ^0Q a cyn va�ymE :3t uovpp3W�_:mco mO7�wo°m GJavC�mNocco 00M m o as c 3 € m e iEof� 2 ~ ofo 9 @am.m: Emm � > � a � po N W � m = W = a. 2 00 00r 0 = Efcc ° o ° vN � ° � m E< a $ V EL (° � > c cm = � ° 2Eam2ILmao .oCa ° om � w Z10 > c 2aw ` M wc0 E CL Im m ; n� o ° = a � � o = c 0 (D0 IL 0 -0Cm0m00QmQ : Gaao0Wd - Omc � U � LV E m a c $ > m02 � Z � 0 o ai 0 o m aW m o C0 � w s a O ° vmm E xmm0c = a) -0m ca � NZ cvmmom , yyEn � m � mocc cN4tu � OOc00) cE >E m — o N m ? a3m c danC =o mm — Eaw - = E a aW m > ° d ° -1-J Da1 � V - cM .0 ° m� Ac.3= � i iMCD2a x d CM a dm A Mw aVa 0 tm .o WE � m ° � °e amm ? m � .= � 0o o10 m Ncm ` � mc �ac � mm � rNtc � D¢ 0 amm - FO 0 v` m ° mr 2 m m - E O m CU0 c Hm a 0 = W V ° o co � ocH .Oc � oc m ? c2m 03GIr K c rnm ° � modco � � � E �a�dz� 2m � 0N «m � N o — O. C0 V = nM CL 0. C 0 0 O O 0Z3mmmqCmQTgm3uoo L °-w (x Og �-31o AnaC ent 6 0 c EN hibit D oPage 8 of 43 z m > to m C N O CL V O a U C 0 o 0 c ?. 0 e °nada a 0c `—' Ea � Q '2 it =m t7 � m U aWvm LU 0 '0 N y* m C 0 O] T ° •� 03 mLL m cp cp tt � moE « 3 0O c "mm « a N C c Q 0 = Er m n pm cmc amLLEm G V C a7L y yLL � 0 LL C 0 K U .� gym„ y C ala 0 • • y �'C m C ca `O aU) m- ` p amc'° o c = m C V O O O) N N z $ 0 p ro c 0) ash E oyzc�� o M ' i ° N a •`) cn a a LL LL LL J g a` T n . caca2 »z O U X) `o c m 93 a E n N > O — L 0 OO G O U w O. n 7 (,) N - C S Y •_ N � O Q Cd O O. ar C a) t0 C a3 N 'O m �. a7 C _ m 3 N a7 N m y C C > 1° E ° ° m NE m c E p Q p O c o � O 0 Q c C n N n m CLC p j Y 'a m N S �' E LL 0 m C M N fC.11 a3 l6 7 .+ Q CL CL nO. O • • C c m 0 M m Q N CL 00 p C a7 a -FuN C 'O ° of O C C C m G n A m m U C N O y N C U �i O N r m a7 t y C >p0 O a a7 O a C m m O O O N L > N 0 y ° N N E Q y 0 0 7 > O m 0) 7 C O.CL m E N m Q N n O1 N ° C fLJ @ 7 C U Q m ►In K 1°0 A n mim c 0 CDI (D t .9rn m aidcO (aaaCDm0mc > E20d) r c3pEaC °i Q m .y `o7Om F' � cm ; cam � � vo0 `° � Fa=9Nm � vof E` m : CL D 'r L x U U C Q.-6 L m y@ d w L O -a C — C C a7 E a G ` mpcm ; iaym 3U mHv ° aa) 5L) mf0 > ° c°) yac) =_ m 0CL CLZ c O C > C I C > aJ O a — - —+' m N 'N d N L V > O E m •° m m L a1 C N O a n O O O ' N m a. . C a7 7 d U O 7 F C m C a1 > T O.y O n n O C aSL d 'L Q) y m 7 m `OLL Y .y C >. 2 TO C '° ~ « C «T. as OCa CL � cL1Oy � yo � � � daayaimc_mioo@ � � c°� ,- � cm °� 0000 .L-. N N C 0 N y a) a) m O L > O Ol T 7 W m 3 L 7 J of 7 O 0C .0 7 L O N U a) a) a7 7 O 07 ` I V y _ D ° C 3 rn y L C E 7 J 7 J J C 0 V = C . I C cm d 0 n m O m m 0 Al f0 3 1 V E 1 m 7 01 m '0 'D = m C E J C C 3 m m m = m m� X CD m N E O O.� 0)— N m f�0 O) f~0 U .� O U y m N i0 N,. A t!J W me g m10vv ° w � = m M " C3 E • ; ° mec - c " myd � .0 W-' OE C O C y y a7 M N z C O C N C w " 0 C 2 U N c 0 " N a V C U O L 0 Z':p i+`Z+ >, �° m c E N � U p m c 'm o 0 oma y m m � mew o o � 2 a) ro m � 3EELmud V � 07m j: E ° > c2aoc ,ma - mem i � c3 i m °� ° m — L7 comao m ° ccc � mc � ._ mc � o � L oP goo 0_ y 0 -° y C O F' O N 3 'C E 3 N N as 2 O' E I = C N .m.. T`. O H C 3 G K K E C w H w `� m d m = O Z L A �" >' rL-. pl C 2 0) ._ N a7 7 _ _ m a v m -_ c_ E va�az IL `� l0 y N y C 0= !�7 •U L d a7 a7 U >i N C C N a7 U c r O N E N vrn � Or =.E '� c t mfai, c3mmmomtm29c '> Nmm > w0 m - 25t- U _ a 2 G 5 ° nM 1G � .� ° nr' '� �' °am civ �' Ev CL m a>> c ent 6 0 y C m Exhibit D o E Page9 of 43 ca o y � r CL E c a O` o c G C _ ° La a0CL ❑ ❑ c «, iL = �� E O O) Q O •- L 01 ❑ Z m a Q 3 'Ol= l0 N (� C a d � Qm° UO a lug ma o� yamw o L) a- vJ a >, m o `03 y '� m co >, oV9a' oE z � � a „czc O alw mmr = CL Q o E c m a = m a y-LL. E m rL c� ` a) 0) NLL mwG IL m y m m ~ o O O y is m C O N 002 W = .O+ m c �mXEj a1Z V O w -0 M p7 C m a a) 1 7 m mZ L O O >. C C w p O y y p 0 IM p V W I Z U o0 oc m d c o > > E o M o `0 � v � Nt,� 'C y = ' 'C N V y 'C N N Q I L LL J CL O N t0 C y 0 a d !� Of d ui U) U) G Q 7 7 Z U U CD m v p m C tet.. r >. V E > a) 0 a� of mo CO CD ° N m > N 7 C L .0 r 3 y = ° C N O CL ° L Q m 0a 0 m m 0 M d a aw 02 2 c M M M = m e M 0 M U 3 f0 = 0 ` c E (Ou -0 N C O U O 'O V a N N m O m Q M MCD = fOL � �0 'om � 3N r 030v > o E 2 Wt5 Eam' > m � CL E m c m 0 8 CL a a) c O N 0 0 C A LL N L M y Y c0.1 a 0 a U Lin 0 x f.l C C m 0 0 C v in C0 = y . C �, OI C R 00 W ya ` N a) (D NEm m _ mm mm 0'= m N >, L a) O 7 N « L c N +0+ m 7 C a) NL v. ~ NIO LO OaU N OF C .,r_d yO Q09mO E p c mymL � m M -0m � � aci CL MLm � c c� � � m E � �oi =o0 a rn ca0 ; � c- acca '5@m = � Xyo > m vyt@E ` c ; oda a Q a1 v .> Z � °1a 0 .0 ^ y 0 . wv) LL � 'v E c m yL d o E `V N y o m r a) ao � E m a m = Ea:: � « C C C 01. a= C p Y M m 0 y C y L V 0 m d = C m f0 > O 01 R C O y aM .� N O y p U d.� IL Z _ ° c � m � o ° m :: E E w a.c ° cw 2 � cv � ea aao ao. 9 r a) N a m° C y L d = Of a E 'y" O N D pL.. N l�0 C w W a n m U m ai Zi IOL " L 00 0 � cmN N � asyaa a o d � vLv ° � = LF m m mw m M o IAX i c y ac 00« 00 rn c m v '� crooF- c '° • LyE .= Ea a) y Eo wm0yN mm > 0m E yo'2y3cpE :~ °'�' mi a� cmc "� o mQ ° � y7 ° C .O G L CL.0U y E r V N m w y 3 = 3 N J 7 J J O = .p O y ` O C y m y C `0 .0 - L O' >. G .yr m = — m C w J G G X 10 w (D c c a? c0) > a) —0 � am m E N m � og ° m c� y 0�-'-1 o°i M w toU)clna CD am am .o 'DE � (j3Ova0i y � a � rooc oq "yc o `m 00000 p c am o = d 0 ai W o = = 0 Q d 0 - �' Q �+ O M w w L W N 0 E 07 a te .- 'O N >.— p O a7 N :_ y �.W '� ?� -p — = W O l0 = O UU �'UU = W y 0CD 'a N O N rid .0, m r- a) m a c D — N ¢ E CL 0 CD 0d' L E 01 y r 1 pp 1 U 1 I c� � U t `� a � = � � �?: c � � mwZa `m � ma INac ` ° A o3C � z (L g y wmmwv E = � 3 oacinow � � aQ Acn _Lmwy ac Ua7aZ Or m a � � � .. al ° � € c 'c_ mZ >.TSM0mw v' yEoo _ 'e � > 3 : = u >,Q�i � om 'm � aic3 � mmaciaH30 ° EH ° 3 O° � WO m3 'FaccEwW EE �: � 0ZE3: 0ZoOcv` � vCLacd1243 AMC iment 6 0 m E)hibit D o E Page 10 of 43 2 m � c m o m � � E V c m a `o c a. 0 m m m ocma a r o mu E0 0 OI p m U 5 Z A a 06 m a 0 LL 0 W y m 9 C V C r Z m 0 m a- m .m . c V >1 U O O m C Q m Y E m 0 m n O U C N Q N rL � m LL p L C N m m LL LL O U- 3 m m m m 0 v m C a C • ` m E O y p O O N SN � ram 0 o C m C G �j � � E m 'CC V G m O C C, Or CO o t 1 7 m T• W � p °' o c cam= `o c � E m c O�zVQ c a c m o E c N ar c L O o y m d y rna O 0) CL Q LLLLJ or a` `ora • . wwfpQ »Z U U m - L.., Ma O - N •N m o m c la y m >• C rL-. m O L 0) 'C m N R d a N a) N O Q C r 7 U 0 O > > C O m m a) C C L O C 3 C � M W .0 ° N o Y y C C fca D O D L CO p m U N 'O C U N m m N L �. E I- j ar L m c E d m � U Nv w 0 E E e Q n n Q c an d o m ami 5 m Q m A m a o a rn E E UU E a EU E m N Y U m m a .+ d c0 at .� m m v a r 00 D � �m ° � o > o a� ° a m m CD m c - 5 c m N o M y N m m m m m m E ray ° 0' car N o � m -0 ac o � ou5 m of c ca E 'X .0 E 3 m m o '- m 0 ,c- m o 0 LO m 0 m m m c o c y o 0 0 ° a m0 0 E oo . y ) c yo oy � � . o � wNON am co » 0 a mUa aooID Mmm •' ` �� yom vi AIT c ent 6 0 m Pa 1 of 43 0 � E = � o � > U c c to o a p E V o w U p E m 0 r 3: ama a a a Zu E ¢ O 0 0 0 O c m to CL 0 C U U U U U U `o`2 C Nv_ mto EL§H C ate' O NLL m ZIV C �>1 C'mC O CQ U f.1 !O U f.1 C L L m a I'LL a O ¢0 O 0 LL � CC1 NCaC O a a ZzmER COB mo0 = :° grog_ m- a m o U c .m L O ° N O. ° a) 0 o ° cc i 8 i c 3c0 ° m = ° mc ci a2 coaN c O zUz ° Z N W •°C N 7 C C C 7 C 7 Q LL LL J a y a a y a 0 8 0 8 0 8 0 »zU0 c m d c y c N ° ac 0 :2 Mm E v L � � � ts = $ ate' m do mm m 7 = m C 2 C C C U) m N m 7 m 7 T cm N E m N N M .2 C C C y C N C m Co c m a c c n; L m � m m L m M m 8 ° 8 € cm 0 E o . 3 N ° .. CL c c 3-: N c cm 0 C pUC� N Y C Y CAi m E O C m m C L (p m C m L m E L L C Q o mm o �Y� o •n2 QwE U = 2 U m CL a € C a m c U m E m a m E c m 0 a C ¢ m � O ¢ EcLi � iL88aLL � d iLB2 iL o0 m m N W E � � W Oc OG . L.. m •C C a) y •O" ° j C y 7 L.. 'O N m m m N 0 a) V E7dER m m7 m m Cm —m` N LL pN 'O > C m8E =0 tc m .0 m O - 8m -0 - �- c- �me a W L ' mmU3i Ea ° 2 m Ec - 8¢ OaN ° C m N NLSoo m m .O 4 C 7 >Q cmo � m L ~ vo ) 7o =a m d c6 'o e L N oQa . �azm p U o02mO N C NM W a N m N m m D on O O mmc amNcmy � aowy � cm a > m� a CD a - a.0 NaaB " N 0 ca E m 8 O L = E EEa) m O - 00300 Ade nyE3amE c2 > 0>>Np0 -0mHrnnSQU LEJJ9 2 No C O Qmm dm0 O N C A mm EE OO 1 °t ° m � mNNx L. N ¢ o � , LC .R 0CEd � m 00 i � o oc > Omc o8a L OE c¢ w •a>. LOOm mo 0 E E xmY ° . m o L 2 aic O H~ � m ' mOLNC ° mppOO LV C .. QC C m w E N c •5 m m $ 0 .0 8 3pUzprcC a vto �oz( ° y07 � EOvD 3 SNammm ) Ca . ca0oamai4 ) a� ; ca 45 ent.6 ° n c m Page 2 of 43 0 m E o m U > y C O E w v R a `O o Ll oma o o E CL 0 za Wa' 0M � `o—Zm� N' m0° CL=3tn — c LL IM cV c m° E m ' m m c -E a c LL m ° Q NLL o � a � c cam O O O = 0E to .5m00 N �fA� m= o -E 2 m c m cp •F C c o U C c o o m c O O - 7 cam°=N m •C p3 CL-0 o m 17m10 O yyt,,1 12 U z L 2 O C C 7 r S C C!N-' r C C 42 m O N I I c - y Cc .0 8 m 1 M '— pE -e � O C 0 7 C C O O = O O - W U LL IOL J t $ a` m wm n a 0 o a d w .0 mat U) 20 < 77ZUU N m m N « 0 W t m Q m m C ' .? m e 7 Qm n w m E y 2 in E d c W c v c «m c 'e m m L o 20 Y c o o � 3N cicc � c � cc cpm �' c c o rn _ a 0 � _ m oa c �° m a: SCE m mm mdacin m :° N e Q mm E �.0rn € rn� Ecc m m E m C N C m 'e I L Y6 Cl pd Q O j R , N 0 c m '� O N o C 0 �, M C fJ U e'L C"C. U m L L U m 8 m m C m CL 00 — U O )_ O ; O c�O°mp vy o m W C.s Om O L O C m Om °mO �c7Ot��Cmm°I+ C9'wvGVN ma 02OS e) C e 7 a cWN�m7 �r- uOa m C . O $ w = a> ' f'c mcW oE orc CL 'a mQ mQO � c � omm � E cs Eom m � amrn aLC m m C E pp O O mzO O. m G mCNO E m = m m W ; Cc mfW E N m NC m _ L -0 7 � OO cm Q C e' m o W 0 6 OO O.07�GE m L 0 Q Ern -00 mamaao 0 (0 02 NC s ma CL QE a 8 E- 00300° mC7aE Nm 2mm O V EC mLCL l m M a) C1 ° mM m i m :y 0 0 m m mLC 0 j J Com N m J Cm c0 7a ° mCwC C J C C m 0 0 O Od mmooE N EN m « o mN 7iDd ° mm ma m of > �' mmocE 2dmmm E L2crc m � c .00z p 0) C.) e 3 � n En • a ° � 0 �z ' O c E c ° m wmc m .0m o c 8 °>^ m o o m oC E C DmI ImcvL o • Q IM CL 'o w � a aaNO0 . = 4) E . U) < ;;g E IM 0: r_ � az0 p ^ E o mm a c o w@ -oDE eCl) to m � oVcm0cQUm0) m — opUQtc y ; FU QEai ¢ mo m co • rrh LL LL a 0 46 ArEIC ent 6 H c Page . 3 of 43 c W E H c o T V e VJ CL V E v � e a p 0 0 C of O � g �imd U c� Ee D O D Q ym S m � a U U OU U Sa Wy ma o�0 m � N9 mt`o o�y!aa C `o NLL m m aE m ., t c m cy y a w W m m OF W m 3 3 LLLL � O LL C C C C C R m C a E O O O O O . a m0 `° 9y2 WE Q m m 0$ rC0 CL c- 03 I cm C3 O O G ,M O O a) > y m I 3 g C N C « EO d O O` O I 2 V 0Eo = = = E av c o o o LLLL7 W N n W C • C Q LL a »z3nyac. 3m cy7 FJV cn T C m ED W N W C m c > 0 0 7 m L W C m W -0 N C N O. n O O L m .W.. � m YmE W -nrcLm � E � U EN W c o ,c°, E3 � ° � 10a ° as Em cE m a W " m mFcni « mCL a E3 c € c 3D W`m 'O E W E m c v a> n c E O N C O C y N O C m a O O �, m C U n3 U 3 o m Uy y don U e m° m m 0 N _ N m T N L N n r O 0 O W W W Ol N >._ ami 2 O d m m waE � mEy3 �' � omE't � c c > m ocm w apm � E m � onnn •�= y Adm mEa a >im •m = U � yfpO '� ami DmNomo > W mEr- CL % -0E W W ` •oo� ;� W W � Emc ':` m ¢ m W ° mrmnEaavo, aEL 3 � mmm � mcm` `o.'E -mo � wEEErn0 W c3 � c � ` < cmW - a � ca0irS2 o5 � CL a 108EEE8 w E `—' mm � ® _ _ �p E ma O .� �C •O Tm co W W p � 'O .O 0 -0 Ud > = W p a) V 3t � ° 0 = :L. °+ p C O •7 3 - L ._ O. O N m `7 N m = m W C L W >, c m O O _ m m a c a W C J M 'j = t6 fn 3 C N 'O C a ` ` O n-- L ~ W C V d - 6 z e o W -0 CL Rocmam3 WanEtcmaic ° c.aoac. ,�-p m 2 V 0 N > O N 'm o - O. n W W N L T 2 n o . W 0 Nm m F'i m m n m m �i w ' om W W N WL.. • 'v Q) ca ZL $ W c0E d Gamma a o o, 3 ° m = `p V �' X 3 0 � y mH0L) - � v ar2 m -0 mN OOa00 m V aio `� oof3 W ca c ° � - x � HO N tCc W - cod_ woo C 9 .€ w a W •O1 7 a 0 a m y O W y W " C J N C r m W N C .p W 3 J J J 3 J J G c 7 O L E m C N 0 W .y V N N a) n C C L' 3 C . E CL MC C C C J C C co W3. EN L c ° W coN42 W -' E ° 1a EmWr W CWi ° p c m� cmm X m m 7 W .LW-. V t+ W � ,-W_. t 3 W n y .W`• 4) 'a V � � � O U �1 WIZ C C 'L C E d W - C ° N . E W C L N G O CL n m m a m m c � a vcWQuLmacW � - am -0003 Hm W � r - ooWcyc y,�.0 > = a 9 Em dNmDo3 W ,Lm °c .9L = 'o `- ° a Lm - O. ammW W C1V �ttC� 0 Q .` m > C CD W Q N w -. = w O C .W •O C F a W V W W L.. C N W I M I 7 0 Ip C - W m W m L L L p N L of ° m > t" =r N01WL � NC� gEC CNCww N . CF D 00 ° c $ -- Ewi'iaEy y � ENc>i � 'HoEEnti ° � 100oWdp c0ia � az o W � `� 3 m W W = mN `m N � 0 � NTi a70 ani 3 � W Y � nW :E E cm q va NQW � > L LQOc � N'WQ2 NN W cc 0Q� zmoomaa)) " Q Q � !� < Aa => 1- � � aN3nLmaHvvaWyEQU � naaWE24 -37 ent 6 a 0 m Auac Page 4 of 43 c a E y � o � U Q m p o a V O 9 U p c a `0 0 e v ' ff a® d CD 0 � `-' Ea Q g ❑ ❑ c� U U �� ucF Oc Z m Wm 0 ma o � LL c C O W W c m i` �. a� m« r 0 a N N �o a 9a: Y IL y 000a m LL LL m E -00)2 m = 10 Ec10i cCDs c 0 1 O 10 N Z ee C� 1 2 f� O C C 0 yv E � c 0 c Q3LL t W ❑ v ❑ c4 v1 U) Z a 7 7 Z U U _ t ` W .W m •O `1 'O N 'p N > CC v 7 .m.. 7 cc m W N W N o f o `0 E m N U U E � � cc cc c o00 000 v m o ion mti m 0 N i�5 e 0 c 0 E Q « E E N CIO N N O Y C c� iE � E m mm m m m N EL a N d O o m e Lca iLE °c LLE0 c � mo m m 0- E -E c2 m m5 m as ggo E m m m m y ° ° O-co Ee tm mm comm mloui �_ w 0W206 > V b'G e) O e :7 L L Q O m V 0,0 N 3 � _•`'L W a' W E Q. m y c 'E a m m e m r rn c o_> o m CL n-0 m rnm eae H � � g ma_ m o n = � °, dD ' 3o 'c°rc c a SOL 0) EM 0 tmcco m � � ° eo cam « ea EaWY � e ? y v ;g e ° E � a " e e -- yAL N d c o a o ' w rn c 10ne Em eco a� ma o� � mrm aam me o0mIML0 C O y L m co m y c C � ... O L 7 7 N CL D. as v :;.0 e� a CO°o a m e ° m ZU C L CL`co mtN m ma as mda a o . o m e m c e m m m 'm m CO E a t o v c « z L = O O a 00 m (� O r O m O O > 0 0 L Q O +. W O m m 0 '5 W =0 W W d' — c `- oE coom �- � m -� •�- o� mpm "' co �, ¢ N c W 53W " ° c 3 2 �c°. eo ,c°_„ om W ° � C0coQ' 0-CL co co m � mcilo0 Ec ecM 0 �cc 0 m c � mm °° c°_ � eaE a � E °oaa � 3aem� ` moo OL� w ff ooww� Nc � , c � E � � � � "' So � � cEH '� mo5a c� woo c o m c o 'o = 0 o c ° ? o o `c o io � '� 2^y o 07 o f z` 'O � � Q $ ° o m •_ ° �nN m v . cis v co v m § z g m m � o t�c� LC1Ct ' 0 mom. 'L" '� E t '� ym m E •W G OI.0 C V co '� a�. '( E __ W O N m V C aZ W e �° 3 r -r_ a rn �° c my et c o c �° -i Im m �, m - CO m °c � c ¢� c me we EE c cc emcee mmWc'75N ¢ NE 0 IL a ° mit ami ae Elia c � a � ii aLL � •cLL cvog h S N -2 �OD E O O) m O L .2 V � _ O • • • e e • • Z Z C W Z � 0 _3^ l8 ent 6 $ o m Page 5 of 43 c E y O J V m H w. c A o m CL V E V a c m `o c 0 cv � m mtq amaa C `-' E ° CL � a U CCO (5 U U U Wy0-0 u � 0 C amM0 H cv mowv C) 9m`oE >. >, �,c z .. C c c E c C € r L m a o � > > � c� c� > > amS' m 2 LL' G Qt a) E Q or m IA W{L G m m m C m NC m m LEL LEL 3 tu m LEL LL O y Z `m p0 O ° N .0 N 0 " E cmmEv c e 0 0 0 0 o 0 ° 1 t = tai U U C U � pL W'j z 3AB,' 002 002 0, 2 0, 2 $ c 0 qc p c a c a c a c r `o � ,0 0 U)01l »Z V L) O N N •O a) � N .0.. 7 L.. r m 7 C �0 E m m o 3 0 3 0 0 3 0 m M ° E a c . mM c C) $ c w � c mmmmo m o o E c c E c c c ° E -5 a c o a v ° o r°000 $ a `o Sa `o QQ � = 0L) ',mo_ a c C N O :° oEm 0Ey 0E0 B 0) (D m a mym E $ o E0 'o E $ 'om m m o L m c c c 2 m m o a Q O E N m .O W m "D y ,O p E .. L �r. p 0 m 2 0) CD7N N a) 0mm CL afNm C w > c «mm aaD MA �C° 0cnaiLE ) m m G ; N fG C C O 7 0 a1 0)L Z C H m d O >� N_ m m O• m - c Nyy ; p �m m E Z m t ; a m m :N L C L C L 0) U N N C C C 7 m m C C ~ V C W G O 0 7 m m N N C C O m m 7 •p > W p r2 7 O p m O N Y- O E L y O 7 > C C C m L E C m 01 y y p C - r2 Ll fn f>0 p O n 0) m � O j q m v a m L .0 U L 0 `O m d a a N �' y m ° L 0 0 O m N C CL.- 0 _ m 7 �'O �� tp Q m c � C nL N oma co�, mNg0vN o E ° NNL° p 3 ` m mLL 2 m mar Ha m c o m ui Ha � �oL � :? N E E Ea mac o o om a.L.. LNa1 tN OvCn0cmpo ° 8m ° Nm � oO IL c as m00Mc .vE mcy = oEc o ao2o _JN Nm �' m aL=ILZ m o @ n n. c 8 N m 0 c- � Ll = « 10 C m Q > m m m - o o o 0 a cm � 0 0mE >. c � � aYoCDi2aa°icoLc3 0L) 0 0 CL00 o c � - TZ � a > v m m m c c 'to a, ffi mQ N .>_ v - m - aL 00 Nab CL o m E o - m o m My E W o c o c w > � ao c N m o o .0 m N 0°x00 m m N �` m C L N CLa C 0 0 La L V O Cl C ' a m m J9 O N CL a N ° N N O M2 C m C - L O a D c = C O C � c 2 V O N C O d LCO O O m O E O J J 7 3 3 oc gm >- Q � omoL oma -' cov� 2m (aN9o � L > EcHmE ccJcc mm m a W VL � i0m uo U 'c °mpCin ma � mQ�" a � ° � c mLacmm 0c m Mc N O 0 C L 0 -5 , g C , O c to m 6 a 0 c !o " ° N y mal al me g wh 0CaO °m2 W 0 = -0w0 ID 4) cCm .O > mL0 rnacim oowlo`0 C N O N m > �-6 m - ;- Z � y 0 N C m m L > C p Q $ o ( a c0 E9 < m 0 m 0 a) a) .0 N . coo Q m ai �, c n aE m w a y� > - a m 2a[*- c) _ mC 03 -oa) Eam_ m >m M.LmNs m � - mm � L7Z'raci O of C Q E N ° 'O 0 7 O f0 O N d y Y N ° N V p p T N w m m I 10 1 1 W T. ��CmC `-' p > OR I Do m O fn 'O O C 'O O N C ~ G1 N 7 LL C L C.H V 5 c O G LL'K d 5 •W Uvg � o ❑ mLL c i.m m � E 0 L mt DEQ; > ; dZ c L) a �aZ om = 2 $ mo 5 g o E m� -On-ami c d ad �L 30 .E X65 m ° , °�'� _mrnLNo aIM r ' omcoi0a) - vE > @E 'vca m Eo � m � mom . m mR z « 2wl� a) omazmm0N _ maz3 ° 2EEoEmZnoEE n of _ 7 LLLUCent 6 ° n `o mPage 6 of 43 0 E w, o co m U > w C to o m � � Y a j ° W V U *E c m 30 c 0 ama m2 E CL m w m CQ V 0 0 0 o� u cF m N9 m .0 O L'jU)- c LL c U L tD 0 m CQ Z 0 mE CML � LL 8 8 8 8 8 NLLLLL�C O O 0 O O3 m c E O w s W Q w a1 9 C A _ a � Y _ m= y C C N 5 c loa w WyZUZ OCc42 m O C Q wQ m � E O m c > ° 0NEc0D- W 0o! vnLL 2ca � aa o UQa COL 7 m Z U U coN y m 7 C m 7 C m y O m y N O C W N O > m 0 m a m O w O m aCL w m E m m m E N N = o Lm - o u 0 m � ) > 3 c . c y c . c m a o m 3 c 0 .. o � � c � � c 'c o � E � cmic ° m m mmaia' mmaic°� moo LcE 10C cE Q m cymccHmmno va c` m o > mo > m LN mEm UL 0c no o m - o m a o " m OL U cL a cL Q c 3 o ii 0— E wE c2 06 0 S m cm m W `0 ° a rm ` m m to W m Cm7 •O an d ,,,, W 0 lfl N N -p y d C m G c ► m L RoLWmFm � mIHO o c o3_ WN CD amm m m 5O0 -0 CL E am va 2 oon � 0 cca amcam a m 20 - A co Q - 3a0Lmm U E2N m mvo 7EC E � iaCOL za0CLYtma C a o 0 ap°1 U ._o M m . m o daomp aao sC aN W aN NCm30E m >. m o c E as Naa ° Q 0 0 0) E .010m to N m e 0OOa00 m w m c � � t _ oOc mcoaio •°o r>no � m � aa) oa � � N JOmN U d •� C !a n 0 J 7 4c 3 yoc � > 'SmoE ' m oirono ESQ an °a mm E .. ec�cc x m m ai $�° �v m � .cm � d � v0 � °tto mm m � c a) coWW cc oW � Em > ; in° mcE000 NN � c2 � mm � V `o`o�oo c 'C c cv W me ov mg � L car. m N E 'o- aL o �.�. Q _.2 0 mm .0A2 (D W .cN � om moo 00E a) (D c m m (Dto 0 10 :3rc 'm > cON `mami W " ' cYic 'DE im � a VVVUV y 0 to N m y m a`1 m ._ .0 •O °Ue.; O m G1 ._ L 7 U la N L L 0 093 L a.` m m E w c f0 p. m LL ` .O rn m m d C0 `� H m 0 3 0 ac¢ d 0 Z' m C 'a m Co M .0 m m p :? c y ^ •� C C U a a z a Q wo c N a E om m -O .s 0 o vmrn namiamin.cmm W o � o `� 01m `7 '�' n `Tc- Xacio qm m ov m 3wa ° N C CL` Z c� a z o Z 3 z > a zv � 0Lb � � AfF.ac ent 6 0 N o m 'bit D o E Pag 7 of 43 O J o U _ ° r O W Q a U O U c CD U a o O 0 CD 0 ama � ov¢i z � c0 E0 CL mCD m z0 � d O o, Z W m � ¢ UD U wmm•o : o=° m F m 9m 0 � •C .°+ O) T ( O� m �' m = c a Ur0`5E c m 0 E m t c a CQ 'c c > Q`mm DC LL a v z O O c m LL m m m W c = • • O 2mECD a 3rn� ,p, CC m3m o oT = 0cEU E o - c_ o o a= 3 u c c o_ 1 m = D o m = 0 2 O m I W mm M C°1 O > O C 'D y N j y O W I Z U Z 3 � O m .. wm o c O = Om 1 1 4a av c mw 0 CL c� a y o a ° a LLLLLJ . . a mm20 < >>Z U U r c `o = air � Q 0 m a . nL o N 7 a�r cm N 3 d CO C O E a '�-(q� CD C O O (D U N y _ N w 'O �+ = C C O C W W °f C N m m V 'y0 y C O a C n j > v N Q iivU m m n < `m m iLa a E o- m o m c m • • c C m o CD m p 2 O y e N c.r 00 O « L f0 T m C 2 m C N oN cmi � ¢ IE °' ° my tmm > p E � _ m ` C O m O L m E `1 C F- L m 0 CD0 ° m C m C a = L w Y L d N m p Y m 0 U y .0.. m y m = m 3 F 4? w « m N O 7 m a 0 m C � m N E O` O m = a m > .0 y 0 M m N m m 3 L 'O d a C :s a'� m C C ° > 7 Qm, a aE ` vwmmnmt � a = omaO � ccmm '� 3: 0 >. o � o o30A o < m rno � v D m e N . Or Y m m m m � _ 6) c m t E m y-T ° _ � mLor Qc = (aN mac o cm myomE w E��;` `' M ° m `o i 3 N a o °c =° m •v- t c E o m .0 v y � m m ° E lL mt ° cid=ai OI G y C U C O y y L n= G1 N C = ° °1 p C w « = ; m 0 m O O p O O C N O W w & m y m L -0 L E w O m tM ° U 'O N m O a L m m d ,r uCi mCL ° m CL m t cMayomamcmmym = cm � 3myEyL � NZ � - mm o a aaa a m a o ° c0LU t0mmm = rnm � M 'v omN � 0cMto LO OOZOO m m m U c N c m -0 m a cc o N c E v m - c d m m a m 000 m V O OV m CL CL d 'Cmm mm m m m m C C 9 d m V iz E O o y > y a C W Z o a E � m N N m m C m y L m m J J 7 J J c O cc a� ' O M C M m w m - 'O a C = O m N m Y N m E m m = m 3 c C J c c W W coOQ cL _ amrNOm 'C mrm maU t7LLmm WWCWW m W C M _ c y E ° m L O U Y _ m m y L F N C mm MOM X o m 4 aW mU ) c mms m c a � o ° mom = N aTi c 16 16 = c mc ° v � �0tLNa= W ° ma' m = � w00) 0 � °' E $ � o ° . 00 _ = c m C O om =� N m m m mea m c c N C � o e �° ¢ 3 o E o J ° - ` a c m c m Z m y no m umi � m o � c � N ; uy, 2 �v �� TC W •E _m Cl.Q o i. o E .0 CL.2 mmLW c ° `m m m ' m m � '; c N c Lj 1 TUU CL a ' W " Va2v > �' N OL= ~ ° a) CCL L° ° m~ mom amiE cj pp 1pp O C C N CD O O c .� N O m Z w O w N a m N O m m y m r m m 0 .O p 0 0' ;e N a c m u c� a5az C o 0 '0 0 0 � � m 5)c $ m a) m � � m � m m cm > W c c > �� o � om � Op � °t � y�'yoc � mr8 °'cui90 � c �oNuyiEinEm0 Z m m ' L m U w N L 7 ' O '" U m . O m m W m m o E E m m w. ate.. E m o c N N E 0 H m m a N a aL c Paltac ent 6 y 0 o E 'bit D a m cc E P ige 18 of 43 E � U m m m y m � O E v o R U � c m a c cc _O Q « ata Z U a �� Ea mQ D a a OD olm a Or U Z • • 0 `` OcF o= Zm � N 9`CL_ N ILO « O) T rj )IL o C U •O O ° C Q y N m L m O. O J! C OC C QLL Iy 00 rL IL N U O r .�mr Nm m m m C p Q O • • = mE V12 OO O O FF o 0 H� 01 C .5 G _ O V C C c Q U p .0 m m e O C m C py7 I M m m Z w U 7 O U 01 O V m co m 'F�F C O_:.. U W I Z V Z C N m C m a 0 7 C E C 2 C O tl) 1 1 o c ° y m o p p € d 52 Q cg a o � V U.v a` !2 c1 a` .y o a . a .N U)U)a0 7 Z V V w m O ^ m O 9 c m N N mC .0 N C O O N N Q •N j w C m L y N O UfrL n Q: C c ^ m O C O) m O m 0 d o � n pop C « o Q L�mm lEvEa > oi0ma � a CL < 02 CH a o� do 'E o � o ?4 tmEA, c U0. 0Cm m m oar N i m (D o N mLQ W G 00 °7 ma? 1� aYi1Omv � mcC m � r? > m mm mm mom' ao mEZo m ° m c o ° Cym3m cm > 0c � is > NvEr - mam3NpG 3 � gE om °IoLu tna oaomo > mrc $ m � mmm—a0r •cm pmm � p c > dm cm i° Nac °N m 'c c E a �1"� mN f0 �> ; � t dw = ° g `- m2t H � nd c3 > cw m M rn 0 o a L m y o c m m m • p m c w 0 - to G)0) U, � ac SE � 6o orn6) to cm Eam " � v o m IL ° m =rn c o o m m ° m = - = A � a x � a c m E c y r m c y U a = a z m � c � a � 2 � °' °c' `6CE : @ym � v .o `p oy � Ed oonoo r v � ° tc Sinm 3 om : � c Ma) 3c2momE a) CL` oaim °ama o c po � a�im � maE � 'rnn ° = � mE " a m ° ta � � ° p - aaNaa CL O c N m e c m = m p o 3 c a o m > > y m U m v m f0 O O a 0 0 c � maym� V CSaCMo •Z°- i Attac ent 6 H m Exhibit D o M � Page 9 of 43 m U m m W c A o CL rJ E V c m a `o c O2 0 o o e � a p Z C) m 0CL 0 mt� aiIL O LLQ 0 0 mt 'E° m (7 'Co U ZU7 OU a wNmaLu o` o cr _ co r mvma ° Q• N c v o3 mw6 E m -E C Q y U. U m m m a�iLLr0 U U U „m, m C M M O O O O A .m• ` N s � ° = o a € m � � c `oma mec = pEo `om a o � mac°- � a - o m mN ago o = ° � r C ° c rn 3 ° $ 2 o�zu� o 0 E `o c4 y = a E o ° E o M E U3cn J- o °7a � � Ha n a` n `v, ¢ aCc ` y O. NN 2LGQ 7 7 Z U U CD O m r Z+ C w W > m Cm > 9 L COL m `1 O Q C m N fCa C m O C O'.W-. 7 m r E c faw � o y c a 0 �0 m ca a 0 •- W > m W T C C �_ a C C U O N -O '@ ° C O O a 7 ` G O m � or E U a m E a�Qi o m u c o u iu E Q > 0 3 m 2 ° ° S o m m CL 2 > y c a` C c Z a a r CK m W o � mmr o � G M m Q > H o � $ co Q CL=U) 9) CLCL 0 o m o _ c� � c c _ y CL cC ° fq C Y D m m y -° ° O O tS m � O C G a A w C U y 0 z ) m m° f m J - •� != 7 m -_ O m ` y •r C p O m C C V 0 go > 3 n W W .� m C ... 0I a 7 •p U `� m m t° a°3 -O �► 3 0 E o' Y m 0 E m o mNom :? 3 ° acmQMY � o , = � d ° oQ aE Lom -0m a W c m m E c m m m W 'c c y o o c i v am > > m m 0 = 0 � >,p >,ZUU ° H o .. o �o m m -y ° o X3019K marm .- 3 to o w w � E � U � mS � r "? c � mmO1inEmc�°- ma°i tay ARE Ea � ,mc � IL o ° 3m ° > � � v > c .c m > c7 5 = a mE � a . « e m c - a ° m oo rd = oUOm ° ' 'c ' 3 = y o cao 0 CLZ" ° 16 �>- '= tm � xu E ° wo 'Eoyam � acE ;Ua mW ° 3 0 °� 00 c a o :ymm > m � mm ° ° 00mwac ° a� � E L 0 otia °•aoas ZE o M « E ._ 09 d' (1 > v LL � o coca mf� amm o c � � � caLy NO ° oa� m > = � mm3 <nm W `ao aa2 aamaa CL o m m o '� aE yv .O o c c .0 -0U oa U NO •o OY m > OOZOO m V 00 c . mQm W COo � ` a- ooh W + « oma - !- m . m a c mmOmm c c m •C � o o � L c as aD « v ca c m � � � °cam mL 1-0 ` it d to o � y >> y ' c � cW m - c N a J 7JJ C ycm _ 2d ��ca � d° ca M m 'O O Oy _ WC6N ' N ULC � > Lm � L m L.L ry NU°y 0omi omcf Vc0iaR yfUM mWm ? `` m N N C E mm 0 '- W2 ° O C C m t ° Z C Z m M mO m fn EC W ° rny m W O p � � E ° •o c cm ° CL oOL m w ° or m Quio rDcou m m � r mo ' o � y ra a oo- a .rnorO m ` m � Wcm mm omE5a om oc tanaza ° ° c r- yy - 6_ �� cc0jc � oMCtm oC mr0. Q 0 - y � awca mmaf - gm = 4°C2 rnra cmm243i Attac ent 6 °a `o C E3hibit D a S Page 0 of 43 m c m o W Q � CL v E v � r m � o c ao! C V d m mu m 0 Qa �� m � O OUZ luh 0 O = u I- N 9 m W « Cl) >� a U) 1L c C O U *0 m `- m N 7 EE m m c m L co 0ma ° L m � LLLL 'to IL C 0 y C m m CL- 0 wE U) sMOo « y C = m E y c U CCS tU L p CL 02 QC � ypZUZa v OO O U) QQ 11 K > ° n > N ' U 3 LL LL J a W•C Gr (q0 rLGQ > > Z U U O N O C N m m N m U .0 O y m ` L m 0 O m m IV N U y- > �= M? Nm 3: .0a) i 7 O m N c N ' m nC m - 06 W W C. a c0 W y � V O m n N 0 m C W W y C G j 7Q 3mCMCW p n N OO ° L 0 O Eammc NcH 2 . C ` S o m N ?: m E 0CL r- 'D � N : � Npn cm o0 m c a co U W O. C L dY m � L C ._T. L C� C C N m C m > O > C m m ` n N N C (� 7 0 C cc _ r ) O N m N C N G m 7 a m V t L W ° m E ma — iC N 7 (D C_) m m O m NK a lE0 O' N O >. N m fA O L >, W N U mL.+ ° C m ... O O c o ° oma > ?- CL CLQ~ vacimrnma 0) r- ma o EamYS N E c o o � W rn•c ' m — c E N L) E m a o E CL ° o m o `0 = E (D c c cc >0 CL m na3 mr c C m N y N coiaaai Ol C - W .0 y m o E v c = o O ° ° O r 2 W O m O D >,N L O 0 3 m W C N G.— co = ... 07 > 3 W U V 0 0 O O CL r y w � 'Woa0SyyzYy � � rn= Ea ° ymlcac m 'v yo r a0i �po00 o c � Wm > c .CT mE � Wm mo � 3o � c > N 3 aaN.aa CL o 0 3 `-E ip umi N m m m p >.c � c ° y :5 m y yam • v c O° a00 m (� E '° W V O N L n��., W .T. C N m y •> CI m C -0 Cft I W y N 0 N YI p _.0 0 ` W m O W w O >. N m m 0 > m 2 a C N L O.cc 2 t O y IO of m N C J C J J.J W m W pCL mt ° '� Z > a (D GO) � w Ya . � U m a`� N W — y n mycmm aWxi w m 'E m y 0) m = no n ° 0 ° .2 m o °� ° a aci 3 0 — y 'x o or t� y�pH �f C C = C N z ~ N .r N L U C L„ � _ L_ > > m ._ c0 m m N O .� O O C Q C >+ 7 j.L N y U - m O m L N :_. W y 0 m W `` E m 2) N C C ° ��' a0 c N m .0 3v cwt p � wL - m d�pw � E N :pL `o C. W fri _W UU UU m ° M .Q aa° Wo O p mc c ` a N W° oyai cj t C Dc1 o 100a tN o w9C N O a) y d mn c � m =c cav: E 0 'j c 0 3: o _ ocm - 2otd �dz pU gY0to � 2 aO Q � CO ZOL m m OLO p o Im oC0m O � mvQQ� E vE oci io2 2-441 c ent 6 0 0 m Exhibit D o W E Page 1 of 43 N O 0 J m V C � W rn 0 C W O W Q CL o 0 a c m c Z O ❑ ❑ ° o c z U z ❑U z m u or ama c- Ea gIm O Or or � a a a ❑U z Ua Wyman o,e Of O 9m W O c m—N c v c a) m U a m o E C m Im T m f ° yU amirn Errmc p L c� a� C N 7 Q' a� N{L LL r❑ LL c c O Q a C c m N cm Bm A O O O O ccc3o 0 'E "aof c ° r € 0) E c 0 2 ccs 0 0m m omc od Mc«— L 0 fpi .0 a> a ° C C Ol C a) 0.15 8 a I ?z U ZQ (M CD 0 tm mm o 0Cc1tm= 0 0Cco w C C O C N W C -C 0 2 0 7 CO W C L M .- .0 C ❑y I 1 ° 7 CCU 0pp L C N R d N O) a❑ C N m C m C N m Q fff$LLL LL U. J ❑ Ud d N tm • • O_ W Of m CL IL 9 Ol 7nzu0 r � N N Y C (Na Vml N � N N N C a ESL rm = m v ffc � aciumiacim 3 c � a a s > L 2 y c E L m g 000 m CD 03 om tory m � � � c R� O O C .L. N Y y(� Y N Y N m yL, 7 > m C m e C Cl) ~ d C N m 0 C L c m m cr cm L C C p cY.l n 0 m r y L fo Y L C n •0 N O m n m c c "0 .2 m N 3 m o = o N m ° c m rn m c v E -. Q cLi E 2 L > m E � d ami m e E = =° ° m m m omym caacdc°ivi LLE cE � r "a °WL E r- 0 O C O 0 .20 O N Z p d O A C ii nu U m 00 . . U E- N U a3 00 0 c °•O m m C a m m N ar cC m C c r Y O N O y O m O C W 7 m lC N m m v, m m m p m m m 0 a 9 O C r m ti 2 m m > Q L-. E N m m L C O O V m 7 m L N m C 2 l L E W c m W E m a c a a N m G C m m C F O 0 O 0 m y N g N C O �•O N K m E a 'v -0 EEm (D cc` m a) o. mvi.0 circ CL wC CD = �' c m N d �� alu E ccm md 'v — ° ° gym w Q mo mrnmo ALO we ° .- mom � cm E NNM o c � mEa5a~ d . CO LO Ec ° a' :° c � r Ear � � O m m m N 7 IL C m T � m y W � m y >• O mLw CL a z m m 0 � UaaZ c o mcooO1m � maw � � 00m Yom c " Y � aao °aa O C -O O c ° m m o. n U - L E m N N N a V m j m t a s m a a SL o rmn m ' 7 � � m a� — E N0ma � mm `m0.ac OOZOO m (, p - m L N y 'N m N w m m m O C aL m@ 0 .90 m N c rm � oc2 � com °c ICimEwaa)i a0 N � 9N �9 C 9 N L 7 0 7 7 'O m m N .� L O c 0 O >' fn a J J 7 J J C p a d O Q C m 7 d '� m O U .� Tim a 8 U- C c c J C c W H N m V m7 maa Off+ L 00 > c C mNcalM ra m I m y O- C 3 Im N C N m N m >' O 2 y 2 m .y. .r C ` = > y m N C m -0 w > ..C-p ry C p m C° d o C y 0 'O O O 0 0 0 0 c cL m V Cl) m m m 7 m m m ._ c� _ m C c Z' �� E a w � •2 w m o a � c ° m o= m o � � c� LL m �jc�� vci CL aNi � � � 0 O'Ei2 amai FU � 2aO1i Fcm CD r 3oV 3 ODU I I ` E o v .. > 0 3 d ^ r c tOia� az ° o � d a V m ° ` y y o u � c W ° ❑ c ai m p cto a +• nE Nm •5dm � � � N'vc C;+ � yY " c �?ddm �? � E 9 Wrn N a 6 y o o m � O � v O � c m c. o � 0= O m � O1 0 m ow 0. U.0 NO and 0m cc m > « � m CL 2-45 Attachment 6 y 0 m Exhibit D o E Page 22 of 43 o = U m > y m C N C m � Eo u � v a e ro C7 c LL 0 C Z00UZ) ama D Gri aZ mN Ud D � W N m •p o 2 CM N 'a m N0 aS N C U O S m LL m C V m`o E co' c aU) CL O � p N LL LL p ri LL C N C OE la m ° m 0 y � Ap O O N •O v 9 10 C m Olr- la C " OAU C C O y m C =7 ym N y 3w0 ° c N o3zc�z O O 7 •O m 'CO U LL LL J S aNrnw `om LLLL 7 M z U U J C � A Via = 9 m c E ° a 5 m r Cr m mO al c E Q ° c CY Y m $ @a m CL Mg- a M Q m c c m- m m p m r E T C C O O O m O.m O O 6 a0 C O � � N .L.. a) r a1 � � m ma m m m@ p L A M U U C N N m m m a C V 7 a m e m 0H � __rnm a m � u aa) E = ice ;? E Q � fO rami d m3 '^ anis CA om do cam °'goam tu °, °� r Y E E Q a) m N '- m 3 c CL � � Cm L -0mm = Mm w ' Nc -c '° > t Eu� 10A CD t o m � '; 'u m -0 c a c �'.m ° m Cca m E r O C — a L r N N m . O C '- m — C �f0 0 7. A A IL c Mw C M - � o y- o N E �c opt o m m c ° Ua =CLz o m m oa c 'E '� Q) c $ aa) c� m 3r `m °ao an o c cc moCL a3 `oa � a 3E � � Ld m � oma a� mmm as CL ° ° m IMM `o y m c � m _ ova � � m N c OOaOO m U vE mrn� Co IM a y � NL . t om > . mmO _ m N n > ' •O O C N 7'0 U �. Of 3 m m ° M C 7 7 N 7 7 C �. tM N O m N j C C m j L C la V C m -O m J J J J O C 7 y m m .- .0 N N r C C C C M m c > cm N ° c� - CD d 3 aC '« a) �•- mmcmnt c c c 3 w c. z <D -0 U is m c c m (Dram a m m 3 av ° n a : ° `— o � H3cmotmory 0) 0) Nc -2N C1 - - >.c a a o � c c c n °- m - ;mac °, y mY c c c " m (D ci Vt� c) tO o CNmy = = � tEENti"' oi Attachment 6 c Exhibit D o cc E Page 23 of 43 4 O J > U m w. Ct+�0 O W Q CL V 0 V LIC! m C c 0 CC p m m m t a m d 0 z m u E W pl p U c •- m a J) c d O U c� c� m m o ) o a-� c C c �' c c ci9moE p c t w 7 G7 '� N W ° E W m C W � Q vo � y L) ELmma °I ¢ °_'- m LL F3yr ' C 3 m W R 0 mmam2 - m c y A E « E a m m v a) CDa) U C C C O) C p T m C O � 7 C r'=ru H L O O ° m �' OI ?. y C a=FF m a 1 ?z U z « 3 L N N 0 7 0 C C C 1"m I 1 0 c 0 m m a) c H 0 01 0 D M t� 3U. 0 0 a) cE p d tea ._ o a.c y W r¢nuLLi�Ca M C N > C m m a 4) a) a N @ C M !4 L 0 C W o `W E m' m mc'1E p CO W rn N m p W Ca) 0 m Z W W a E C ¢ m E o c CM m ' c m > U O] m E C CO U D m C CL fAv a $ pa CO 0.0 m m G a0 rn E ECL c > m Sc d rW ma�iE mm mm ` W W a) cv.1 4 ,°p d ` rnw E c !A o 2 m V W N m L W .m. Lm• '� O1 O 'D C lC 5 = a C Y O m p > W ) W f0 C a M N 7 W y a 0 m K m Q CO m W d 3 0 p •C J W Cr am O CO 00CL ° w 3 m E • U U o ° o c ° m m p w ¢ U c � v c `�° m W W >. >; 0 : E o - 0 W Ea CD IL 0 ai avi a) :5 ; rn'> p C O as � � o CA CL 5 O C 0M o o d t ° p m L m m o ° $ >,M ( c E tea- o.z C 0 m •> O U .> y a C t H .L. .0 N 0 U m r 0 i d 0 0 0 7 0 O C L O 0 � c .W M 7 -0 L V CO O a 0. 0 a s W oay mP Ea cmi � EO ,; oc 0c - a!� 0M4) m� aem O C V ¢ O C m •- - f6 C W C a N N d 7 U p W a m d a m CL V o � EN ; m o0m � EccaEE 'aa) wpcli > c � coi ° o )0000 W to _ m - W c 'o .. 75 C 9 ? y m L d W - ID N W W W a M O O a, 0 47 fCO L -1 J 7 J J - c W W CO : > W .. � aL W «`° m o - WOaam cC� cc W W > -0 E '� 2W U r. N i0 J Z f0 >. W W C W CO X O) m W m E c - / 2 0 V; 7 C C N N d .>+ N - �' 0)C W fA V) W a W U . > W W .. fA�. c = r � E0 c � yO ° CO W ccvU WLR oo � oo O W ` p �_ 0 C 01.0 O W C O W@ >` ` c O 0 m N U V V V U U y W CO- - O C CL a10 p)._ C U p CO a) a .7 ' ¢ V O p` W OI a a W C W 0 0 d O N >- q GSC K R 0 o f V A� � m m p a w c r 'o `o m c Z w Z 3 y t$ - a L) ILM&z CL .. > 7 p C - - W U 2 0 C .. m 060 UO Q.' U U O) W 'Ip a) r �/ W CO O O EW ccE •a� � 0Ep �' m € cuiaCrOMEy rn rn o m W Q Q Cu W v S Q w d n Q N w C U J c°i c°� .a 0. 0 ac� J 0 2A /T �/ CL Atntac ent 6 y CO ; E Khibit D o c E Page 4 of 43 a 0 m � m m y V Y �► c O m p � E !- O m V U � e m a o Z o o c z z a � mr 0 Im F a N � a m O O OUa � U W m Ima cF o = 2 m� 0 ,0 m o w 0 ?3 w C U o Mr- 0 "0 c C U a 0 m o E Y 7 E C Y a EL m m a O � m m af° �i Em (yyj LL C cL LL C C C C m y m to 10 O O O O :? B . WC A 0 (p .y. O O 9w2 m= - E E . c m r o C c 3 0 € 3 `o € o m `o u� ° i jjmc � m ma yyyI� 725 m a yUn iMM CO 9 ~ Q d 0 C C ` C � S C C O ` C O y I' C' G C p M 'O C 0 7 "a C O O ' O 7 'O 0 3 W 0 1.- cc N m 'C N m N 'C N 6 IL LL LL J a CL L O) a a.y Ofd a.y O> a !� Ol 7m Z U U W N M N C c m m c c E m a my C� c '0 >. c o m .� N - N o m a m m 0 n L N U U ` m C J >O m Cc C 7 o ('0 CD oau mo -0 2O1 m U m y C V N m L CC 7 `1 C m O n y C v m m > L V �; O a L O -D m N m C C O 'y «� y N N N C m N C C O m m U OI m m L 0 � 7 fc0 �- m G 0 (A X 3 U o Q o E c y a c m y a c w 20 -e CD a m 7 0 C E U m C IO C C m U a m m e D Mr- 0 a U m m .E D m nnw 2 � Oa .. - a_o m m D m v -&i N 0 a) NcE o > O N N C 06 C. Im- O L 7 m m m m N .0 N m W "I� 0 '� Ma3v vm cm N mrn_ - a� o... a - 72 � mGCCE > 7 m a O L .� m 2 m Y m N j m •O m m m ur lL N 0' C YD N E f0 C Y N R' N E Q a Y c m OCD m -0 m n-'y 'cL : m 04E mac �o "sa ar E a (D 4)CC �a N O'er ^ a m o t � w aa, � E mr 0 0 a' y 3;o qz p - m m 0 j O v 00 C D c N m cm m m c Cm N n C.l m j c c m E d O O L 7 m U m L ' O CL m C 'L m = C m w N m C 0 0 2 -Q U .m-. O N O O C 0 a N M '- C - O N C U 7 U m p�r m CL m N Y 0 CO L m m 2 ED 7 0 0� O O a m C N Q N f/) ° m C o m m 0 7 r .2 8 O) m C m 7 y 7 C -0 U N E E y f0 W W ' a 72nD O C ' m y a v m m � m =.3 m O Q O 72.0 C ` m l0 M 0 C C C 2 d W- CMMWmCOCm � f0 7 mmmmmC ° E mC � WOO a 7272 a O O N Co J m o- c m « 72 0 am n0 a•� U 007200 m VmO� :. _� coamm .yy m � mmt a= m0 m ' mCmCao7M w0ONN C y G � 7 � m L W cc `' m Q 7 ` C a= F E m m cr y m U � J J f0 7 7 C (7pp O V y .0 C' m a 3 Q -0 a L m N 'C m = W C C m O' O C J J X 0) m O m m m C m U m m m O C m fm.1 L m C C C Icc >O O N c U C C m L W to ICO rn W C C U '0 L co m m a 0 Imj U n m 7 C Q mCD- O -0 " N - 7 U 0 ` N 07 Q $ O 72mo > > lao «� � � c � omdO �Oo05No 7 >_ m � � ycc mc 00000 v d c o c3 : N rn - z- 2? a.- m C C O U y Y U) (n E U a y C U .- C m E y tm1 Q O N m U L''- C 0 m '� .0 -0 C C •p 0 L « C L �N m c m N Q LU w 0 C O U m C � O m V I U (I I m Of 7 m .- C C A m N 7 m N .- N 0 '0 O m '- V C O W OL :+ m 7 N m LL a C C m .- m U ; Y r (� O f` C C U D f U O 1 0 0 o c c m c� 3 W O O mom Nv_ - - o m m — o m G 0cr0: 72 0 ie � oa- �a� �� E 'y EN � E o !� > � as c � 2 y � nQ m tm V0.7d2 Y N m m N = N •C C d C O . 7 a) 0 {y N C C C v _rn C7 y 0 y a m C7 � '� C7 =? x m mr o m o a ° m E U C o m y o �C'o 0- 0 � w L m 0 U a a m nJ m Q cg ° m m :3 u w o C ent 6 y 0 m E bit D o E Page 5 of 43 y O J CC m M m O m Q CL V O V C 72 m C Q0 0 coL a Z c `m' E0 Q 0 CL� L) U d 0 W N a t 7 O= ° mvmw rp Om c O) >� C E O y LL 0 C V m O C I w U 'Om p rO C UN U E -E crCE IO O L CL CL m 42rL 7 7 U N 0 rLLL O F- Ow O O F- .R =: m C Ham0O p 9U) ME z i C m Ol U m O m m O C O 1 m 'C V U m N 0 O. C m C f0 m C C ? 2 V Z a4 C a U $ O C m N O ='E ig = O 7 D W I t s C O.d L N C O O y U m C 7 C Cc d y a 4 LL LL LL J Q O O.C C.1 d L O G d N �C • 7 0 z U U In Y y N U N -p .m. m m U L E m N a{p E mm •y L 9 U U U m E 0 0 C -0 m m m- 7 m m N tr m CO f0 3 IO _ Co m O 1C C mU N p L m U y - m R' c m O y > Cl) m N m C a VyE0 0o v � -12 ' � CM m� Q m � C ji m0 E E > m Q mV ' oO EO 0 M LL N O OwV U . O O ON C m m EE 0> r m � � d moL c nm OCI N pmj 0 y 0 - U C - - V C m V w N C C YI m m m m m N E E N 0 C O A L '.' C N 'O m C m G u0 7 > m mH Lcp� am � � a) L) ma) c c'vQ fy¢ m O > C m m t N Of C m C X y m 0 -0 d O, m m C Z`O- m E c m a ai o' y a= 0 m o m y o E m y E ? L o cam?3 tea[ `0 Q c ° 0NCx = a= u 0 :E � 0) -0 mcmivo c `o CL E `-'� yL° o cy ocpimuicmi 'm � y ' om c � o � g � c � OE :° `mv� C Easy' « 0 CL C � � � = Env = � � :° Q °m o ami = r mr aci c E m c°� aSiz O O m U a1 fLJ 3 C O U m m m U O 'v_ ` a N O - OL m E N ,° - O a 0 0 a N m C - C O a C 2 m m O V m y <0 Lm, Oi N C a y 0) - 0 .22 m T CL 2 W c. 0 m > mmmE `�n �' cn —Wmom m-' � Evyic 'DFL- Icor hyo OOZOO m V 3 W` E ; o 3mmnZ5a) cc IUn ° � oU -0v° ama nom' N '> a) w�0 C .O N L E m > > D. y O m L y Z d C O N m CO C L) r O CD ) .L.. 7 pl J J 7 J J C .0. N d m V N E m 'O a V f0 U m p) a c — L K m N C J C C .m m C a C C m 'O ICO U m O N N > C W m N C f0 f0 . l0 Ul y m y fOA c � 2 0M 0Eccam pm � i � cvm ° (n0 � ° m � iNH3 cpm oo.00 C ` O O C N U id m m m C .cc L., d O O C 'O y m `1 C C 0 .0 p Q ° 0 h m a' aaiv CL E o Eo `o E o m ° -o m ) -0 m c C m C ami = rnami = � � �« >` C (� O m �`' O O - y C O U ._ L m cL p 'N U l6 E .U. U 'iu -_ m L U V U U U W m �= LL Lm m m 0 LL N a t a 0 m L O U `I w �1 m m N 0 a C yii c c 1130 o " W _ o .o � aL E °7 A N cat F oyv m •y Ea ar, a.-.:o � e30tra 0 a _ m — a= > a ._ m m m cU E m c�a�az O .y m m C m N d U W r 6 C Q y C F M O lA W W C E m L U W `7 m `7 .� U L L W O L O C .~r m m C m lyil W l0 N (� m - Qq � m � NNQ ¢ m � w ¢ COm3 Q � 3amo :E 2E ¢ `� � 7 ❑ � ent 6 $ `o CPage 6 of 43 0 A E' O £ N = O m U >. e0 c � o m n V U a c m $ p c 0 °aoa �_� m 2 � o v o s � C tea ' U U U Wyo -0E w y 0 EEC O U Mc C Q Cdo c O €0 w m o S IL U tm 4) w N w LL IL C C a m L 00 d m R O O •p aN OC O L �mgmm c `o m'rC V p — o CM Mc� mUou IV ° m 0 tmm • m c U ` OCn mmm ` =mUyN ONr '° Z� i :3 CDm1d Q E o SJ2 CN {LUw a Ha a o e aac� »2—C tm Y N m L y m L m 'O N m C w U w Of 25 C O L L — C C cc O C L E 7 C m Cr m W — w Q .m-• �' C 7 CL � mmc � om . mm ax m m c ° 3 y c m E a p C Otm c m > E p C C G m c o, c o� - oc � N � E . m m `c c p E `c c o U g r m U t O m a 7 0 m M 2' f.1 O A C C w U a m U „„a O Q v :; ..C a 0 m. cLwaL E� CO c = IP 0 CmomO amNC o .m0 mIm Nm CD cw = • � wO> EO 0) IM to a � � awipO � to dy ° vNaomc � om � CO Q tv � � mr ym CL CL 160N Ems ; ° E � Eamia p wmC � = Yy rn" 3c�a 10 2 oc � mw � Em � OL om=CL=m=IL o C a o m — C t Ol m O C ° o ° > ` m w a= w C a O C 6 o c L cQ ° ° d c d H a m W o �m � � w ami �a Waa CL O m o � o o � QTc w E "� EQ � � ami 00300 w p '�' W L m O) C m O T b p w m O w w — CO) O L .° w 7 w f0 C m m y o Q L ; j 7 w'S J 7 G C W m O m m N y C j O y Ts � W M E N 4: y N C c J C c mm N wac � w N mww > ?> � � ww � � m ° E N� aulvl x CO m m m - m mL of > > m m `o i ti a�NLa � mm wm � daia�ia � :3D = cEmm o ° roo Qy° o �� m m °� J2 CL m Q o c� c aciv E 3 " � `GL—� TC a c m >. m W EL - T m OL m > > o 2 Ca U UO r p m L a 01 N - L o v m v L m mL W p rnamMcm � O3 Qo •> rn na ° aaCac w Gp SOC - omia Nti o -a t r E vm c3c E c c m m m v ''o my m m E 'm � c m c�a0nz a o Q v m aci - u n L = o 3 c m m E t L p N O q N .L.. v d m ;= V1 O N N ` C N y w w w — w w m gm C > W z � o T rnaa Q w Q vai cco Q m 3 `0 ®H d N d N ��Oha am ac ent 6 0 o m E 'bit D a 0 o Page l of 43 a > r m y C l"0 C E v a c W c a o co 0 C 0 3: � « mm mt� W ofO Z CD m m0. CQ UU U UU U wym . E o_ ° c m r CL c C V U m m O CL O L 0) 0) 0) 0) Q LL LL C C Ow C C 0 m C m m 0 0 CL- E O Ccmm C m C L �' p CL O C C C L n C 0 U W ` V W 0 0 O `0 1 7 m m Z iso ° o a'0 ° E x .3 m R oWzc' 0 0 o. d = m c a - ag 0 aLLLLLL � a` (a CL >ow a a m (na Qa m a -0 AWfoQ nnzUU n O) N C II C 0 ((pp m L W 7 U S 'O06 C y C> •0 coc 1 c > Q Ir W O 0 N O (°G70 •C W W o C m m m m 2 E m 0 > ° w ° ° L 190 C c Q � Ec 3c� '� y u y >, m m U E c, d c W m a E .m m 7 0 0 L Z 0 W C Q m -0 a ° d N 0 Q > m rn E c n� 013 0 2 w >.W (D y > To c m o mm am WO m O W > c '° = ° ° d CD 2 N 'W C W G 73p A Cl) Q Ea a` "� 4 ° m u�ia>» cc 0 W 00 Z (D 06 E E `-' mm2 O O L 0 .°r a w C `y O W y C'y W °; W O) 0) ~ 0 7 m W W O 7 y Y 7 a e c m m � , .- ° m o ° ' 02 00 co `o = m t�a�az 01 O W W c m E W W W C W E O aEL.. L ` ate a3 — O 07 0 0 c a mm CL ECjoow 0 O co = y Wd � c W ;, m m �moo. o. o ° c mEWUoL) '0) 6`O «itm- .2 0) cc ato ) W aamaa CL o W d p ° m3W ma Ea c Xmc � 'o aZ W ° c cm 00 00 m () E � ° am L c o o t yLLI d 5) E v c m W c cm Mo H m0 m C L ° L C j 0) 2 W E `a L N U C C .0.. -O 0) = E m C C W O J J 7 J J oc S0 molrmcE °ow W W C m4) md° ` o. aooa o ccJcc cc m w a 'm vW ccUrnc y2 W o w mm mm X °I m m o 3v 0 C m m G) 'O a) c CL � LaQU > v � Z E Lm. ��tmn�� c c t o EU o � ¢ 3 wy o � W � H W 00 mm` o °woo c � c � � � c ° a°) E mLmt � WWrjO ° W_ � oc � mL o gyo � y Qw O d _ � � = � V1 'yW W " � C � W () O.t C C W � � � 0 U3—•'_ _ 0 LA0 mm vi o,r J yy O. W NN_ I IUUC) Q) 2 Lr _F C 10 7 C a Of `a 0) 'Fn W in Q = 0 0 2 N (c Iy 9 = L j,y,� Gp I G O m m W Y W — y W c d = 01 m '- � " O3Cp'W a ? E@ IT .. E ° mda� a� vEF. _ y � ,G � y � g� caai -mpw ° c�oaz 4 («0 O O. (AU CU — Lw O) °fOf �! nc E OtD 7 0 'y W N a Ol U W W W W 'O W :2 @ .7 ° m cm!n 7 O n m (0 u cc +� m .0 QmCL W0 WJ2 .0 � UUrLWvi wC7 Uw LmcU I � � � 1 6 °o me $ E Page 8 of 43 c N 'C V y � C O a v E 0 YE m 0 ccai. 12 « a ® a c3 Em o 0 comCL Q Cr,y m- 22 N F N•O mL O m a E N LL C .cc C O U'C m G • w 3 C E m C cQ y cv c Em `=° mm f4�. U O a) CLLLL C C m m m N N O Ova 9 - •cam. E -0 CO r2 NIm C m C O U _ F c C O N c7 A m N L tUi n c I Z V Z ° > nm pw 1 1 o `o = 'o o m E m Uvic�F- c"o a.y Im It 8 n »iU.cLL a < ci m N > V c m y cr c c x = o ; = c cy a1 C C y m 'coo .. c m o = v c QH aE _ a m m `� 8 m @ L d m o O' U O m C rn dm Yv ono m a p m N EE co m m d c m c `o o a ° oU-o cm m ° Emo how m > p � u m o v c> o m mm CO v - m cuo = r 6 Ol m c 'O m m e a 'E d cmi a � o m 2 m � o m ° o o E Q m nm0o � '` mcLvm � mcminc c0 °N' �O» m CL 2 c � � � o oi3- = 0 0 o v c"i0) m E 'rn:: g $ � aC y �3o m � e Q W .0 0) ccmic � � m80 CL moms= uc _ > CL m EumYo mC c N m m (D '0 0 c N ° m � c m � a Ea« . .. O - o Nc m � rn H oo- A 0. a so > me o 3 m n5m a ° onN 0 CLZ o Namomm NLwm E � t ;rnmumo CL o 0 ti a m ° � `° �' a c � 62 M wowm > w `o � cEaE3 a4+ maani � o c Wnmt mo EN � mc ,c o � 'wvo0 LIm00 S� Naa n o g E%5 CD — m 0 N . a°i c .. 0 C 0 U m m m W OOaOo m V mm > m6m LLvc co " N0) aci Eomi 'Sya EmCMM N!�ONN MM mm ._ m y = E mLo � 9o0S5 C 'O L O L C N O E U L C O• N T!� U . N J J 7 J J RW m mna`mi �m- mai � oNd « omN .2 cc m3Cc'� u mmJcc x � o > > c0) Oc € - Nmol > 4) gym Edmv � w foca(A m e v o 4) ° oLL 8 c@ m m 4) = 0 an d E m `o a) -0 C 'C � Ummc m � rnc4Lc� n v '-' oy 'Gy 0 0 Qw o 000m � o L > � ° camE � L � maEi � Oome. c yZ'o � �` c a N m « t m � `� ayt 3 ov (D C* c x `° c�UCtt� O m �t m wto m a) cc°; nm c ; m o •m a>i $ m H I I V I I n m o E `o ~ � CC) d) 4D c E - a o 2 w m Q N .� 7 o O OC o c o H@ c � m c d m :: a'� r ywaCD vY m CD- CL O Un.n. IL p '0 7 O m V /0 L l0 7 V C C i > O d � N O = O m va QcmyErnm Q: Q' aci = � oHc > � `�xcmxr = � 3tx� Oma Q no N � S `m O Qb 3a E 'v o m U m m c m N E U m N m m 2-S2 c ent 6 h a m Page 2 9 of 43 0 o a a U � y 0 O n V G m U a, 30 '�+ (c ` m m SIP om CL cZ Ea mQ. 0 �m t7 c w 0a O=Z m OM 0= O O.— m .. C O O mLL EmE O m E N €m m c m E c U cr Q aLL E m O m L m c mLL C O � LL v2= O c � mCmm M E � • e O y 'c S m 0 0 �oJ � m — m c E 10 mZ O Orcm 0)C « o c c «. m °• I O mTo2 .0 o o r E O V 01 w I z 3A0 � > 7v • m c ON I I 0 0 d7m d 2 Old v U33OJ C7H C N co Q LL LL LL J » zUU co C v 4 N m .m-. f0 c a `m z m m y a m c o v L « 3 : E 0 — 0aciwo cmiUm > cc°i � aci � Eo ° o = c mwr m m m ma m_ ° ,= n (D qY may[ m m .o ° O m d rnELE an d a � ° c p 0 E 'er m a) d m `a m $ au E ° m aoe > �e € LQmo. omm E .. _ c Q (D .0 aHtoc >. Etami ° E E23n a m N 0 1C a m n._ $ CD c c m • • aEYm ,. o0 m m p E c m U CD r ~ Y — L m C — O O T Wm m W Y ` m m 0 (Cp D 3 Y_ �Cp L_ O L i G j fm`t a m = m ° O L L a n c7 = J C7 O O N ° m Ow p m 7 Q OL pmt c t 2 c � � dZZ 0 m m � p dU �� 0 O E o „ r E in mU o -- O ov E m E m o m c m c3 m �� ° mami0m � 'a¢ mm � c $ � o ¢ � Lm ¢ o ycn o •= E `2 0L° m o O1'y 2 m U c ? ~ « > Comm m a E a a: 3 0. c � c� ° � OLEE '0 mwc'omen m � cU� � `�° � �c 0 gE Ua�nz c a v opo � M WeaE � � 'oo ) - 0 < 0 a) Gai V c � � o °o0QM m m " uc m � m � oU O wZLa) , Z Edt � m ° .9-9 M.92 m 2 m m m � o v cm N m N ° y p E as aS:a � H . 0 � - L d � m m o 0 o � my � �'� c o > y O m 0°x00 C N 'E N m t O U m 8 N 'O a 10 IA O m m C O m t07 d L m ° y 0 C C N N m 'L" t N J 4 N C N m = J j!A 7 7 '6 ° m O m d E 'C Cin 7 *0 0 F C m E N m 3 ` C w O m. C C J J J m m mm m Y m C m m 4= m O N , O O « N C L 0 0 CL.. a' m C of O :o 0 W N m to N m C •O m C.E C m L .L�. L N m O 0 a .m. m V 12 0 m . !' L1 " m om y N 93 m O ° O O > - m m m m cY « � !� - •mc/) L m 3 m L � O m e t)V 't�tt TC L rm0 (AS < Ov ; EmNyam $ '(D ,�. 2._ Q EOmmami -c ° I IU I I y ° 0 O c � 3 > Oo 3 � � mocmiccc = _ • cm ° -0 - Eeam OQ IOo v 0�c c od c m c ° c m c � � L 0 V F •� c a) rnm 'g OSOza c o r me c w � � a! c� m mU mL m E c c� m c c c l� p O O c ? 0aL�O.Z ow c N- eoma) m 'ca EZ"-eZ ycoa� a 'c1Lm� wc33c M m m 7 a ^ Ol m 0 7 d 7 -0 N L m N Y m Q .r m O v0) Y � � NE � � ._ EW LmnmgmyE �im = " � � ono _ 'a = m 0 = :5 0E ¢ m '- tpvEME •OQ £ O3 � I� H [Yo0 • 3 Attachment 6 00. 0 m Exhibit D c 0 E Page 30 of 43 y E m U LO w c A o m Q a U o U � 'c m 0 cC d mcmi mr °ama c - Ea Ix Q o CrM,� a v Or- LU � * a o= 2W� CX U) CX- IM > z U 9 m o E « 7 E m m c W c Cr E c wm °• ° R N LL LL O rL LL « c c W O O m c NB WO `p mr ° M Td = « m ° C W c � U G C O y O T C :°+ w m .G CL c m m Z 3 c0 O $ CO o �' M o � zU� O 0 7 O 7 U U 3 H 0 m u m LL LL J CL m D1 a N O O. W U!r2 C Q > >z U U O a C C O 9 .0 m c o, >, E c a Cr r9yL= C 0 $ � c w Q 3c ° N M m(D > n o U ' aE E w p f d � ao E C m 0 m 0 U m _ ar op O vi:3 0 O oa - m N m W m c3rz 0O0) M a mo ctq y ° -W� W omom ° .0 y �' N C m O C N O. C e E m 1•C °N 0 o : t > : off : m ~ ° `�° > °Sam E CO J U " a U m CL y ` c m N -p m M C m m O y ~ Z. O 7 O A K CQm CU acrt cvae m C aH E- U C EQo ctc .? m t m : O o m o m � : o o °=a pm ° > y ' ° m Uaa=:aWm z y 1y a) 0 nomO �mma oCD a) o E o � %O m O 'E NaN U aFa C � NQOW CO C a M CL W a - cm m mm came ° mE OOa00a o O 0 v (D s om c °Um eery € Om Ey �umrmEom > = S 'y055 rz r_ LD m 0 M mv �` � rn-Ev y � m E ccot rnEs c� E � c W c m m a) - U0 •ooNao . m ooyN3my � mmv � Nomrntn c _ a� u _ u _ o •e a > z m S y o "6 c � c EmEy mom . W c°; W .0 mm Z :g na yo Q « o f � 3 rn3 CO m o o N m `�° o N ` mem o QD � �,- a CX __ QCO a H rn� v CO m � e o e !� �o vU �Vv m o mrn t m na Ev a o �' c m oL NU o c y o�v mc « _ oo m � mh � a� a m 0 0 0 o m o o h CX y . m m (D o $ caa o mSt � H c _ Hv c � N c � m a ° o no C:L d H u � D ° yF` MUOOdo Ea ` Uo �o z vWrn �� oas Cr. • H N! Q d E U. • • e • • • • 2-94 ent 6 a C m Page 1 of 43 0 E y O O J � N m N t Ip O a v o � v a c m c a `0 0 0c � mm mt� � Im O c2 ma am Q m Oc IL (L. a ocm 0 c1� m m '0mL0 ELE H m C U 'C C v m o w 7 T Wm e m c Q €L .0m a ° LD <.9 � aLL O O '3mca. « cmc (as MO M= cil E € c � c0U m L ° O. ° O. ?7 m m 0 °� 1 zUz 5 *E 0 9 t W C 01 1 1 � O O 7 'O 0 7 " U o1 O 1- 11 m m m IL IL J Im Il m O1 w H1 2 O Q >> z U U O O OC O C c O C O .0 c M m C E ° E .2 0 c m m= w �� c aQcO 1110c_ Ymc` mw aCo c c r c O m O O mm EEac o cm " o Em ° cL 3aOnaE T Om T a m m me cEL0Icm m Em 0 0 r CL 0 0 d' m N a E 0 > C l0 O N .� .0 O 0 .0 C m o A m l0 � m � NN o j C Cu -0 � O � cc �Of 0W007 > 'mwW � oE mr- � crn A � � EE+ �° eaE om mE a o m E a Cc `oa 0 W � > = '; aeEo ayCN.. m '- o c� ' Cz 0 c — o eE � 0 � 3 o = ' v, `9 =' c m 'aim % ' uGm °I Q m � 7 �vm cmao m mco � io � cm E— mmL° o `o wo 013 w Er c G � � o `- G E " e a Ea=t « Y c m c m m �a rn G m E rho 0 0 0 a a y 0 7_ m m IL CD c cctaamim aZi � c = Vie: t3 Cu .G � COmcm oa «oo oc � c � o � ` 0Up � m � = m � t0 � � n CD ca CL 0. S mEmo > ,0c a; O - mN � Eao o, c e ` G m _ amm 7 m � � m C J L �_, 90 a � G N C O m Q.m W O e � O' CL O c � � ca ° m moNV Nzx � � � ° _lei � � Emyc � 0000 V co ° mDac � vtid Omti o � a � c ° mZ COM m mm O ^' w m 7 'c Of N m L vi H X C m G 'l J 7 7 GC. Ud CC N R' e TcJ C � .0 m + W0 �1 O.-0 Oy ITE OG cCJCc x c L 3 m p 'O T U N m -0 E G m IGp S 3 . m r 'G m 0 y m C' m .0 3 W N m N h m r ® N 'O m m ._ N 0 l0 M m m 7 01 7 m U c 7 y m v = y m �- 'O r�'y.r C` g c0 � � mcm am _ c G �° bmyv� m � gmy �, m > > EG � 'o 00000 a° a° _� � m m c E m o v d a� > o ° `c° T ` m o m ° tm aecv°m e c c�iU ,-0c�i CO N a R L V 0 CM m � N t m � C Q.G � � iCf m t C � m m Q ,0 U � I I U I I m ea ac " O N — v0 my c am � - a o1C � S 4 2 � 0) m 1 a� a m o c m .. 10 m N .2 N ° aci ea m ° ' E ' E = y m y o m y E c 5 °o�oKK a o a� m � � a`�i � � a? C� � � a0 a � C y e E n c) aaaz 22 v :2 im O OI N m Di 0L1 Ol m N m ° lO N M Hw H �in � o H � N Nit • • • • • • • 5 Arm hment 6 $ c m Page 32 of 43 c E o o m V c G 0 m � a =E V o V e m o 0 a m CL m Q a m C7 '" a w U) 0-0 C o= m m- m t O 1m >� a N C C O LL c C U m p A m C 0 C ca €t. ma p < m, m rL tc mwmmA 0 *= m E con mo 0 9mgmE A 1OE0.2 ci mL "V CL mh r O O C m W I z V z 0 y 119 `o c ._ t>3yc7 -S a w rn HH2o< »z 0 0 O M OC c O .O m O E ._ O ' spa U a U C r c c c 0 c O o m m U m aL) G m C 0 C a d > 3a a. TEn � m Y nm d EY d CD m G O�� N m m vi.m7 � me 3e0 E m0 mm b b G 0 e .G m Q C6:2 t y e' U 3 co Of o m r +=i• m C u > C e Cr m b a m .O�.- c j y �; C U a. 0 m O m O E P. oam0 E � c0) G 'e= m = m 0M ca 12= me �ooa, 8om .0 Q .p r C m CO t •� l`a y E N C N ` Qj e c 'm b C a c 3 m $ m � � E j °i � me `G° a � o,be = mm � o � � mE � � m E°0N0L Q w 3 o pb b m n� a ° y m °1 m o � T tea : j �b ` � e , °' Em mac a ° r ya c y c °° E m m o a�aEi 'o � c p°� m ' o o m e � , e m m p ' = a s c -- b .e o e o a r, � -ob ,o � c o N c m 3 e m m c o e ° z � u B mCL z cm c a° ; cm a .0 EorybmrGE mR � 3 � aC6 (DI e " me cao•a CL CL aoo o c e -� m m m C m 'e y ° me m y o "' a H oLL c ° t`. ma ea r as m.0a V e o y 3 oa � � 3 E -0 .-tm � Z ° E= m 0 W 3 � o e c cc �To oDa00 c 7 e C '0by Q G b 4 O1 m J { E m m m C C m m m m l m W m Z 0 e J 7 J J mm w me = � o3 £ b ° 3No. my ° woc t � hE � m _ � 3O3m go aa)ic m Eci°' t.QO omt ° y = cmc ca ° V � �° � ? °io m bc3 "0 t/I� mv1M c 0 mn e r m � y " ° -p m p y a Q W 'm r t •N m p m j m m e �i = G o 0 p o ° Q .. o y . Ccc Z� G b N b e c w : o ° .. m � G � � 0 h m m G L� Z _g C c N °� j t m ,y m C C 0 1_I ' 4 V G m t U E e X c"i t m Of p U m ° pa :Bew— ._ E G a m y o ay m ._ p N c c ° m •e I I v I I n� aooa'oam - oc � ya .; � . vm2mo e c g E e E � t >o `b° 'oa m ' o E > a"i m m e W m ._ cz ' ttE m 0 0� ¢ aw EQ� ymmmEn ° H3o'€ > � om = E � oeo, Ec �a�az O m L d m 0 ., m �. r Q•G!. W Im to 02 F = a . 246 IL 0 Attac iment 6 y a m Page 3 of 43 0 .c oU e > H it L a � 0 a V pitl U c a `0 0 C V L N qq CL 0Ens nS nS m m m L � QfL S S S c(m0 O m a CL m N CL a a i Mo m N 'D m N 0 C O O� N LL m L C V C`O E ecm E W 0 C m Etrtoa r2 LL U U U. O O O Omcat0 E M V y � W 0 0 9 y ME R r O f0 m E E € cgCOU 0L7 ° G ° a ° a � m -a to ° z U z Q O c w e c O N I I zn O O 3 'O 0 7 'o O 7D 03 y0t- m m m LL LL LL J a a w rn a 9 rn a N rn » zUv cn `o o `o t� v c -ti c -ti c c o c o c o E o o ' E o o o c0 m wm m C m 0 ,= c p cUN N ZN wp p N 15 C ° C c m .. Q m ` O C m ` ° m ID 3 a m > 3 Q m > 3 n m i tit ent 6 °o 0 m age 4 of 43 0 V E N O m U > . a H t A O l0 Q a ti ° M. U c m c c.0 ° o_c a m m m � md 0 c0 Ea O1 c Q c m (7 a a a oca Mcr m U)'a 0 azo. UmR: 0M ir C O '0m C O wD "mm � m C.Q � L N m O. O L m y 0 LL LL G CML O O O M .. m E ca m O 0 aU) m= �m � Ecmi ccs `oE om o 3c °° m T T G 8 a m 1 7 m is Z � p °0 c °0 y c c ° c pt0 C' c m m m 2 �7 r- O C 0 0 0 O 7 U `i {L LL J d !!r m B y rn O_ O)lOLGQ 7 �z0U O O O C 9 C O C O C O C L LO '� C LO N C O Ec E .4 a OL N CQL aC 'G Gams " C m w U C Nw O O m m U O m m U O m� m 11 �_ � M n cy 'c ° cm 'c ° cm Q m > 3 n m > 3 op, Em oEoEad>. nTao >' CL m t5 oE m..2aE =c aEx m c !" c=i oa omv o� as o yT ? a ° oy may € y 0C� m � c � g > e « ca O V m 0) m e c « m m y N o m � m K m Wa t a m0 ° L c � � .CD — ce .`9e cr n d c cv Lm, a) °� � > E3o'- va c Q y = « JO % .. o � oQ _a ° a z « mem omm « ai Eamw O a N O C L .O Q �. 'C O a c ca E N m L C ` .0. C O a7— A is d CO O N C ~'yr' Vt 'C � y �� O N O N l0 U V 7 N 0 ULL.7O. z G1 O. .0 O) U ' W G O W a ° G •C a m C 0 'O L ID O S 5 �, 0 a:) 0 0 p N a3. y a N V •C m y O y W .0.. C C• m l6 � 0 0- 4)� O) a N _N aCL CL°a m m O c ytt E m d € m CL m yr E � L 5 E (L -5 m m m c E m aO�a- m C1 C a'e c co to '0 rna E o m cQe ` j E_ E c _ E c c c O NO00 °� w o c « m w m U `. � N LL C w m E m C W W m -0 -0 0 2 m O) O m O V m 7 y 7 7 p 9 O m C C N O m O G ' O m C C !_ 'O N 7 C .00 - C !F J J 7 J J c Oi > > m m , M CE > > c � > ccJcc •X A R C .0 .0 IM m m a L'C.. m m: '_ ° w e L �l O d= ° Z ° Ncf) W N m U)N X m y t y .0 N C L y o y c m y « N L N a O C C a C N C D N w w N 0 0 K h m �p C « L O n0+ c � m3mo „ Ow ` dym � m3m EmoWrUvmm -° oo '° � � d $ o m � c c �� yt pb p� mft m ec c c icy « « �L rn� ai ° m m com °= E ma = m m c c > t m o�� m C (D = Eos N � m o •E � Qppc� i i a� s rz c ,v_ a o � y E .� m m E a Ep •C - o ,- .c v �w ` « o c3o ¢ m a 0 t co E e ~ W G O cm tq c a Q Q t0 ' m 0 c ~ m U c m x ~ y U O_M O. z O « v m 0. CL vv m ' '; L° =° m o � � � 3 0, 0 $ $'oL :.. a D 0 c m dv Q O • • � =Ooc) •• • • • HS2 « a • Fd2 4 L ent 6 cx N m Page 35 of 43 0 S O J U m y c O a7 � CL V E U � e m `o 0 c 0 mW W m tea' c2 m °a mQ CW ac d d o o u C _ W F W 7 m a CL=0) c 'CC c C .WC ` 0U o E, S te. Ei c c a ILLL LO C W R W a O O cDaM00 E € cm� o� m 'cC G ° G O a '17amN 3 r0 r C = ° co c ozU wI c 'am y Uz h 0 P O m C t m C N Q �y LL LL J c d H rn a y °' �72UU LO 0 0 0 o c o c o m e a m c a° E ° � E ° m cO C a ami p c n N C M �_ m CC .0 C C O w C C C O a1 O m m V O m m W Q 3 ° c m c O C m z r m CL m a $ 0) m an0) a x � d E 0 a E y � � 2.cc E a N O '•m0 O 0Nm { am NG SO M Om a O g W y m a o 0 o E ai i y = ° o a mo c m � E c O aa) 0 O ? { rn� o G @ G 'y O { E rn� p WOW ° U CX W E m y GO C m W m � °i£ c m o = i° mrc W E 6 n m �O a J L J U O y m e y ° E x O e 0 y m L m c ° > C C mM mamMdam E = CO c � a' a � Qem 5 EE LOL° G W r o Gy � m a a o m m g O E a o m m E m W O 2 m •o m C E my t 0 C .r°o m o f = $d ULL.7dz °i O � 5 � { v c8m � y :oym � � m ? y rnpaimEWmc Oan0 ° �i v d € � � aNrmnyjy3ee � C � y y � 0 oeo r- 'M ma 'am 7z CL m V CO c = E o ~`'� wo {m8oie � �.= o ` 0 , Q- r: OqOOm Q O W O m l�pp �. A m L { , W t o ,d41 — W � L { "' N � C �, W 7 J W 7 7 C .O U m { G U m m J V P O 3 O G O U •G O �a m J 7 J J G c 7 m { ° { �= 'O � m Oly { •O -C .0 e_ O) N 00 pm 6f'O C C CJ c c a7 m R W t y C t v O N C y m r b C d C G m �.' C r m W W c W al X O) m c) W O m C C 7 0 C ° `-' O = m { O O O. j x 0 Ol M WCO� C ` �' �`N m 'CO N S C _ y W m Vj CO) c V q Oi V W y m � W S tW 0 0 0 0 Qw o ' m m w E ao� O ° vc m 3jU ev Q v m 3 (a M civ�t�c) c ° cwW- Eycto a Eccocc � Gy °'t3 � mmaeD 0 W � cy � o � Qppi 100 m e oo ° rEmm y = m " aGiE � � mmmy = EWm 0 omit Qc g W ° � ocm Fats m -o = Ec �iac � -a CL cc actriF- c � c� a � dz oa ac 3c y �_ m y a�i 'oo 3 � � Wj '3 � � 3 m y � 3 � ca12 .0 v m O C O °� m m ° a r c c � � 8ZO: • F > � nE • • • • rev 249 ftt ent 6 ° a C Page 36 of 43 c E O _ m U Q 0 `° a p � O. 'U S m U p c Mi o C 0 C 0 aaoaa c = � a LU 0a c=2 c� m 9m m m >�. o30LLm Tc Uvmo p m > c m .. c � Er � Ema ° . QO U. � � 0 0 Oc a .0cc r m E v H O o $ r � mmEci c ccs `0 € om 40E � c�.4i a .0 ° V (M IM Z 3 ! 0 ° cC ° WC O $W .0 OyZU O 0 7 a 0 7 a 0 7 0 U 3 LL LL J G2 im d m O) iL 2 O] viHfDQ �7ZUU w � O y C O w O O O ' = O) O M W O C C C O. 1 U d N O E : W O r U _ C m O C pC O O Q w. U C E O p U `p d m U O O N O m O Q 0 a N > 3 g O N m C mmOd €E Q cL- E O � CL CcA c m c 8.0C 0 m m o R U z c 0 p C D C c00 G @ W W m m0y O C d �? C > m m mQ O O > h N O .WG m a C m O. 0 C C W > m m 0 C 0 ? O." � W p X 0 .- 7 m > C co m p 0 � G e � 'C.. A o) > J a y m W fi t.. �+ i0 w m E G 'WO G N N O .V WQ p 0 0 C N -0 N D N '�" O m y 3 C `of EW am 00 v •° � `•� y� W ayi i � �° 0v1c > � 4) 'Fu E � 0 `o °o H o o m m$ acct azt o - `o m E c �7 W m E m .7 a c r0 am v $ c 'yy emyEc E � aWLO `-° �' cog cia �az °i ra a 0 o c ^W CX IM m _ d C > c c a C ^ t ^ aL iii .1-1ou ;M W -. 0 c y E a� a umi � c5p` $ � � °aao as y o p o E « W W x ` y O m G t m _ 0 > 02 0 0 0 o c c a c v; 3 W 0 m ^ 0 b m >_ 0 c m E p O BM COBB M O ° �• G c �• C d ai "' G C 0 c W N 06 C . O t M L m J O O a O O m +> . e 3 W ° 3 c� %= (D o m lz m 0 � � y • M w E -0 02000 Wzayt E •rmss Tflrn � a . c -0 ° � cS0p � c 77277 C 9 O) W m 01 C M E �O N G k 0 C .O m 0 m 0 W J J 7 J J C �p r, �C'= p = _ 0I G •O ]+ V cc a W W p W V H _ C O y 'p m a C C J C C X W C M N C C � V W O Q) m It a m 0 O P V N O n (D M� O H U)cow w m D) m O �`� m Co 3 W 4 'O 3 "0 a W 2 a 'O L J C W .° .5 a Q: -6-6 .r Ez a y W W W�� Qa m a o m y y c mfA 0 W a� y 0 p M o �c o 0 Q r O ` G C j C '� co 'WO y Q; Z V cc 0 `2 C M L_, « d a Z � O >� C Z`� Z'z. z c m p W O W O j E W 0 W Q ° W CL y E ._ o 3 oa0 c a Oao t�� vcici a� O1 E moa° 10 °00 o m — a a e`o 2 ca h CO Q pvo ° o � � a '_ o m 0 oP� oc oc -a. 0t ' � � � � v ~ iaciIm $ QM10 �� mo,m~ � cEm � c � Nz �2 vdSaz 'a coCW� o F acwaCoLM 0 cvcw00m • w - QE • • 1 82 QHE cw Attachment 6 $ `o m Page 37 of 43 c m E O J U A y c W o E v o a U c a `o 0 a.r- aa. m W_v m r o sy m . C O 0 O 0 O O Wcr CCL 0 LD. li W W W LLO E N m m m HpN rL m O «9 AW r m E 11 7 E m I m C 3 I m m y L p v W I z V z I 1 CO0 c 0 U)0U.1- >>z U U n M CrtT K c 0 m 0 o E cQ 5 e c m CL c m o ro m G a y T C y y y H p a O r W y a c m 0 a) 06 'O 0 M 0 0 R Mc L a> r to m c i0 ` Iy0 y 7 .L.. 7MM -0 0 tD U W l6 > m 0 O W W N «`. m c W O m O E Q •o C C U y 7 m C L lC d M .�. C ' E •° � f0 C O •` 0 N m c 0 O.CL y W N O Z a) 0 V r T y y�• C .Ci " L 7 W C m O. O ° C 0 7 3 0 m CD G w o E 6 cD O i.y m p a 0 H v j C N 0 N d V O N a0 N E 7«Y 3 a ° n� 'oi� ai m c E ° ~ m r -a = o m � m e ao co� L � m E Uaaaz c o a m L W a rnw- 01 C L 0 C t0 7 � « N N U W E a.•� 0 � m 0 0 7 0 0 C .Z° � � ° i � > � j � aWixxw $ Ndm d M c ac W W 0 vaiq°amm N N W MO � N - N a � aLoCas�Waa y °m � ° � ° E » , 0Uy° CEL OOa00o c 0 CL o Omom � N ? ° M0mo awEd ° E � Ea L ° � o >> >> r- 0 cc cc a a� E _ o � �. c = ° EL � � c °1nH = w2 .0 W- D0 WEc0m •� C .� G O C R �' C C.CM•C y a E U N 0 uU1 0 W IM E 0 W 00 o X 0 0 c o a m E Om E :UV o c m 'E �' nm c �' m - t 0 mo ��0 Q -E m mom my m L) am c0Nv W`O o � cL X20 m � `WWF vU �tit) M a o `° Ho ~ cm@ate adv M r-icU3oEm � o0oo 09 loo r ° .. E 3 oL o - E W c to m m � .. E a.. o�Gtti2 do g o WT� � « m Qmrn eyLEm ' t mWyo Uaaz _ c y ° r c� m Z n U o ° yr W fA m W 3 0 a C y t N M N 0 0. 0 V O y 0 M mmZ .>_ € oom « E � ocy00.� 0leE c6. a 7 M N L D 0 ° > ° 0 C .r W N E F M Qg o W N 0 a n W cn .0 n c� '� 0 2 0 3 0 N 0 - c� U o.._ o.rn 2-51 LLLaC ent 6 ° a • Page :18 of 43 a O m o ca 0 E = o m m (n C m O E v E co o � - V e m n o c 0 0Ca mm mtR ama wa p � Z ,Eva mQ cm C7 � a a a a a LU U) my � �w 0 COF °= Z am 9 m m Y sp c O) >. OS mLL m = C UcO6EE+ � Q € rima O Q� a LL Q� m m m m m O O O O O ai3Wp `o 9yf m = $ E c o V e C o € o € o € o € o >> m m Z � .° 0 o8C o8KM o $ CD o8 � o8 wzt1a 3c.0 mG mS m tmc M OF F O C 4=1 R C W C N m C N O 7 V LL LL J 0_ !� m d m m d !b im d !o Oo d w yvtfpQ >> z U U O O O O C OV 01— C O C O C O C li 16 _ o ° o =° o =° o cm € nCD =c mr- a � m m ° w c• 2 8 _ d V C C � U C O r_ c � cc °° ammmm � mm ` aci Y m Q C m d mOmm C Z O OC 0 Ean Eg0 Eos moo. Ea - E o 0 Q. >L E d oaEm Czme o E Y a E a Y 9Y E E Y m a mm pao m6 _ G 00 CL° >, > 10 mm rn CIL mm oomd33E m 33ocm ° °_rn c o5M c mpmc � E m L O .O O m 0 m E n m C d an d r p m o m o E a> v C0F � � OO C: f!J T7 � c = w moo '> t m 0r- m °'w p Z,c m� m c mcb m j o c y =' o f oii o . m m o a o m c Q ctmm � � m � � CD 0a`) r `mc 'm := � OLEC � c « UU o � ° pm °° a`� c3cm •3 E � 7 cc = ° vm :: n ^ 'w� 0 MCm m Eames ? ° mYQ ° m �'« E ° m ° 8CcmomcLo •° � ° o : a e d- ° ma °o o H d E m c °1 mai `m mSE m U c m o c�araz m o � Gm (V Caw = = 3EE .o o. 00mTi3 moiU cc o °o � oo C ° E � _m6C mcrt CDLm. > r ° Lm. w � a- cL cmc aE W= nm� 0 v c �° o m o o m a- c m m ° m o a s m a a o C o m �emL 'va mm « E Lc mmQ c CL o Ba a n= m O 'c - m m m c o2 U - m N OOZOO V � = umi3 Em � � cmc ° C � omMm � � mom mm woo m = � v • c . coc m L m c > > 00 E C m Y ` C U) ° m N C 7 7 U, :5 7 US m 7 > m C m r m m w C C C J C C x w' ooc� Vm � momw E o � ° E ° v > a � 3 °CL c � m wwMww gm _ C = s , m = -0 -0 = Lm.. 'C-• m C@ N in C C N C d 'O C W m O 0 0 O O C p C 20 '0L 3L n � oowo tp H 2 m .° � v tMc -U; o m cL m „ E Cc 0' C C �,m C O m U m Co Q .m. m m m ~ m C m 0 O O m .`. •i V V U U V m ° o3m0 cv TcoccmTocc ° vcdc0 > 0Cc yr ip1 �•' Ur - vt0 •- c W o O C «m o = c o mm a ` m UY •° R •� C GKK apd _ 2 0 V_mo H m m `-° $ m aoi ani oc aTi 3 E 'm y ow o c c N Va �az O A N m 3 m m 10 L C m 7 pE =La m tLp �O mCL� m Tp 0 M m m O C � .6 m e C r m ° ' U Cm m 2a _642 Qg FOD v m m a F2 . ._ FU . mQ m 02 .. F m FY ac ent 6 °a C EN hibit D o a E Page 9 of 43 y 0 J U � 0 C m O CL v E m U � c a `o p 0 cl CL my a C Z c `m' E0 d a D O m Q D mm CLOr- aCL a Uii0 OU m 0 C� ND m Ltl/ .0+ a—u7 — c LL E Im >� 03 0! E z m ; 'Or _ 0 o mmc „ 0 CL C Q AC 0 1! ' w- CE LL irLL C m O O O al Gc to al VE A E € E Em E � � COU ccs m `o a7 0o u7 `oa77a7c oym � cmm 1 St $ t0,7 m 0 m 0 8 m 0 8 m-0 O U 0) (n W ? ZUZ 7 O C C C C C_ C C N t5 C C C OU) 1 1 O D 0 7 D 0 7 D 0 7 0 7 C 0 O U Tj N 0 r 'C N M •C a7 m 'C N Q 'C N@ a a) Q LL LL IL J g D) Q. N m d T 07 B y rn O a d y 0)0 O m U) fll m O Q »2 U U M O O O �a O C O CO d C O ' O •- 9 fC d m C L m C •0 O a E- w w m C a O O O N c , m o w 7 O w 7 w•N 'O C C Ca •aC CL, � y C l0 VO. m U (q U 0lc 0 = m C C C O C C .0 C m C C 0 10 U C a7 d V 0 aa) 4) 0 ' E N m w w w a ro E = o E .00 � � c Q c° E0" CL Eoao e. ua ym a E m CO)i M am 0 m am 0 uL •o a>7D D c JD m a E Y a E Y E C n O o c 0 0 m m 02 E c m c 4 a oc W N o 0 o a :. m NDa7w 3 m a7 m E o > >O o . No m .00 cE N c L_° m e a7 C O L CM CL— C m N p D 'r .` O 0 C N m m, D 13 Y 0 m 0 E d m OL y W L.. U C U y 3 C t-. iA C C O V C O C T� > C O' CL. d y C m N '3 — m m m '3 v_ 0 to o m o w ° � � 3a rLnmamiAm � vmaciy !7 ami a) 0 � oc r= o E Oma00v � Dr ma3Na o �.mm c u > a r? O N me " is O m nU ai m = N Ua - G. Z C a0 03 � ° v ayiaLio ' a -c0; � mmE0 oEOL 00000 i7 > mm y > UD � m 'Nm — � 3co 3m mm0. w0 O C M N .m. N C W 0 07 �. D m D m 07 m m 0 m a _� d d N 72:5 CL o 0 0`7 m m O7c o 3 m cD > � .` x07 u S m m L' 00x00 m U a E a 'm0 c 4� D � 'S mm a7 > a CO � � E m NmONN K y c 'x N �' U o y D c o N m 3 07 c > ; m E >> co 0 C O L a O •a) y O (D p 0 m C m L N m C 0 c N m m A lea O U D 0 a m O• 9 at L 7 C 7 m L 0 G m V W y m W N X c a3im � M" '5 �—006 a ar � E >oE CML > cm ccQ= ` om `o « LD � Q ° N 0° D Q � y 0 3Ce UOD Uoa z 0 m m LL y aC000G0 Uom N m 0 0 Q V C w' > y N o .. 0 ma ? V m0 $ to` 0voCL 0aI ��UDI tb aUCD!I z U0C mc00X01 i �0) rn CL Ao 0 '00 mZ C G coO An N P m OKO val r ma3im dam � a7 � m `mEQ7aa: � am � m 0 � ro c0 r 0 1-! -02 0) CD J .JOO � r Lm E 3 m . 3 AMTa ent 6 a N mExhibit D o E Pae 0 of 43 N m � h c m o E m U � c `o c � o CL m d d m u E 0 N co C Z m C m Q O c m ULU W m � =u m N 9 m L O EL N . co 0 C V U 9 m F m E tc m C Q a m a m m r2 {L m N IL IL L C _ .m N C m m O ;: �toE v) .m. MO O L� O L V G W I z U z 3 .E0 °y I 1 0 C QLL LL LL -ja >> zucai v CL m avi 3 o 0 c c Ec Q EL o. m U O c . ,E a o ... y C. 00 ;° E o � m mo mm > ae 0 -0 CZ " vv .Lm > CL o m ` Y� m v � moo em � Eg co � m = ^' N = oma > 3 � v3 � a " Eco � eno 'w L oo� m � m ° mo m m V E Lz a ai m y o - Q) a c►° U -g wrc m R CL � � 3 >m dog � yo � 1 m — 3 —o' Ws Q mems Ea Em Acca °.i 'am Wm � c � E ° NN o 0 5 `6 E � Lam 2 em m y m o y m e m -c m Ea3_Y m IL %a y m e= o e �°, = 3 v; oya� cam `° E va =ai tm _ CO ° v E mt n =c tL C � p, 20, m m � 3 � m Q � ti m cc U a 9 CL°_a a mui a� o y 3a e e o0 •`: EO m m m C6 m pOa�O o u 3 � � ¢ E , cti �� L, Cceom t � J--0) ymea'- N NO° yceUtm rE mCa $ mey � ms �a � wa � m � va�iaom m > > N>> m ~ mei? Eck c o o.0 e Cb c °c °CL 0 h � c� L =' � vi-0 co 0 ¢ Mmc mM � c H = Lm yiaE a>> > a>> cOcj X -onvmia � o �' m : m " o -• o m eoyo`o cEmEa cr c c � Z n `e 3 m a E -o .0 E m o m m � m , m o o - c m e c = �m Q « O maa`o C mD m � .0 + ;.' .0 `m m eb � �O m G m m '0�+�.. m W 3—•' ' c p = CO E e : � � m . o. L° o, m ;� �m m o rnoa E m m E m U UU r m oa,mmyame cE � e - neo,= coe `- o . � aw � � v I IU I aE a � � > > Eggc.° Yac° � � � � 3Eeacioo � mmc' = cem3 a o loo o o e E c s o m vb �. m L e m ma o � crca a o m N anp °>' m '� LD 4) 0) o y o� °iE y e w c {` y o m aci `o ca a wJa �az E' m mUQt E o � .0 co c L m Em L m rno m � c0a c m 0 a O 0 • • s • a J 2-%4 Attachment 6 . E 0 Pgmoq 2 . ' E a 0 ] :o Ca - a 0 ) � � .0 u I � 0 § CL0 © CO � � k� .kk M(��% E§I! £ f ( . �I�� r 0E �iz� I LL � k� 0 �-■ .■ \\k� r \ 0 CO $ § _ I �u2� M § - o22LLLE � ■ a -3) B [ -,a« . �:3zuu � % / B Cc 0 - k D CD E 2C . I$ E0 Oe - 07 � C �� § f2 § $ � ;aC ■ a � © a . � � § 2 . \ 2 § kfMM {� § �k �R f5)§ � § & t � § £ � ( - 4 ° 0a ° � E.20 « Ea -a » ` $ 0 tt7e2 « ■ 22 = 72a 0 M a c -0E2 - E2Waa 0IL=zz 0 . ° © � 5 ° - Disk CCLE& C $ § \ i) \ )\ ) \ ) kCL 04 k8Ik8 g v � b ® E6L) E •�2�2 CO7 � � 5 = . � � o § - E w = �]5�] 0 § . f -2 ' & 20E > c ' g § ■ as 0f § 2r § ik >,o � ■2M■2 § f & » § t(DCLO to0 � M £ ] 4 ) .0M — 7 � « k \ : if » ° »■ © a � ° ac ƒ$ i ) § § 9$ bV 4) 0 >. k . ■ � ` � « � % ■ G � t7 � § £ Bgk2IX 2 . a E ° � 6 Cb 09L�9Lz % ( § § � f2G ¢ ee $ ) W ) B F3 CO E � = Ec00 aR M;sMg0100t(D Eo aw 071 2-65 ha ent 6 ° a ` Page 2 of 43 a a 0 cmi E a = o m U C C O m a v o � U . m a p c 0 o c o W mt ICWd m ° E O - 10 cm cmCL � Q U OU U c� m�m w ya L o of s. 0 `-:c c p c '0 y16 m c c ° tea m o E pm rno a� `m Y e o' �_ � �. ELmoo. c y m ° O m .N a) y1LLL i'U LL C mL G $ W C O. O O 0 "0 a $ W c U)smoo 9v)2 W= m 0mcEm 'm = � 0 •Ca) W O 'C �.o d aa) o C° E y �um U m 12 LU Z r N � $ o000 o5U.W LL N J V 0 S C O W 9. W C 0 ':.LD y V W 0 O C �.. O.a g o -ca) o w a cac) Wm Cr y _ CL E O E € y o p C y C C a) W C '> N �a ... p O l0 y O m la E m " c m` ° CW 46 c 5 U 0 O W E CCE y o ornZ Wc oyc am 00 E E E 0mava CL Cm - m 3m Or a, c c � > c y y E c w aci m W o w W o a Yl9L a O c c C C y W at So W m y 3 >, 3Y � C C V N O m p � ° O C .L. > O E a ` > 'FN NL W N y OaU as -cm O. O)C mL.. GY m p m a oxmC ?C SUWJ'. JYrm LmmmW "3vm` aarnu . W ► a9 � ° m cy v U3U3°o Vw0= V'19 ' Q 1 a 7E o c aoa om vr w o � mC - c � � UmaoE-E WG ° 0cc A m W yam c W p oo E p € mammEaa ooa IL Cma° GO F0. cUtsEN Vsa4cm.a,U- a«60 � tO° rn.2 o n - Qi CL c; o Ly w y E Vc O m — ? ay 2 ° W 0 G OU') mF a � a c aa ya3 0. m c c oyE WUW M « Q0L0Q CD � 0 oomm -m >. ywmE pLLc � cy � 3 - ° 7CmdW JJMFE E 015 4) dE. J7 G m er' °O CL 0 W W E W 'O — WW C WW m CW c Cc c C pCL mvC W Jyyna) 0 E ° m WCv)ym(0)Om N N yQ NLECa W c C 00 .0a W . > v � aE > . ar¢ S CM , - ) -L Z-Z.. cOz 3 5 va m'ymrma O a) CL'O W s 0o3 W 3 0e C'` i ao > c '�c Wyc N � cazazc ov mENH � c � mw nvWL. pav = a mEmWQ CL m m m 3a mWw . � Co JaO 2-66 - .. I Attachment 6 a 0c Page 43 of 43 0 � m E' o J U' � A rn w C l�0 O a v o a U a o 0 mt� a m a cE o Q m O m m C7 Or- LU U U W0) m -0 .m w " r o_ Z O m'amCM a U) c C U C O S N LL m C Q C c I V a a m E m ALL. COaa m mm0 mm C CL- OvnaF a0a OIn2 m = S 2m10Ea 0 0 > c = c o CO I c o r 1 6 � a � w � WZ € Iz0 'O .o.. C p l 0 7 � E O 7 ,0�,�++ W I I o `0 M d ym' a 3 9 5 0. v3y0-i a` m a e ww2oa »z U 0 C. Y It O U m N G G 1 O C N C 0 m 'v W g 0 E N N 0 9 Of Q. y m E U r C E NO .� C O C O 2 m ~ C 0 G N m I0 C a+ Q' `03 ami N E am � 9 mU` N �. apOO O -C C O m 0 O' N 0 ` p mm .2 Z: C 0.O E c� V N C 0 O p M L_rn C a d m C m u mrC � Ei � ma0nZ � i 3 � v � � pOm E v m moo— m O � m 0 0 d •- a 9 ,a 0 NCL a 4) C I w 'o � vC Ccnci E�-m0 W m • o o_A m CL Q c m :. m W m � ` vazaz m o mt@ooins2omm 0 00 CL CL CL CL E c 8 3:0 CO EL c AM am= CL o m m c = $ c N 00300 C N m U a m � E � O _ 0 w�0 m m c � 2 on.cN '3WmEa J��' '� o v 2 -az N m t w g O C m m O_- - m N O N CO m C 0 ICO m 0 OI - 0 �p y y 0 f0 " U W y m N O C Z O/ p, 7 mC I0 C C OOOOO C C OI- N N m V Q E Q � a0 ° � '� � mmm VV�UV C m 0 L y C C 2 O p CL a 03 CmZtEa�i COCK e 0 m N c� a0o z O '•' G. Cl m - 7 m N E IG E .2 ` = m I0 U U 6' L O C � f m _linNo _13 ° E 2-67 Attachment 7 ��IIVII�IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII�I I'�IIfIIIIIIIIIII �II Page 1 of 6 II` �� O S �V OBSPC 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 July 18, 2000 SC Properties, LLC 510 South Grand Avenue, Suite 300 Glendora, CA 91741 SUBJECT: ANNX, PD and ER 57-98: 2005 Dalidio Drive Review of a Draft Final EIR and request to annex 88.1 acres of the Dalidio property, and prezone 40 acres Retail-Commercial (C-R) with a possible S (special considerations) or PD (planned development) overlay zone, and prezone 40 acres Conservation/Open Space (C/OS) for permanent open space protection. The remaining 8.1 acres would be dedicated for streets and freeway interchange development. Dear Applicant: The Planning Commission, at its meeting of July 12, 2000, recommended that the City Council certify the EIR, support the Annexation by submitting a "Resolution of Application" to the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCo), approve the prezoning with 40 acres as C-R-S (Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning), 40 acres as C/OS-40 (Conservation/Open Space with a minimum 40- acre parcel size), and the remainder, approximately 8.1 acres, to be used for streets and highway interchange improvements, based on findings and subject to conditions noted in the attached resolution. The action of the Planning Commission is a recommendation to the City Council and, therefore, is not final. This matter has been tentatively scheduled for public hearing before the City Council on September 19, 2000. This date, however, should be verified with the City Clerk's office at (805) 781-7102. If you have any questions, please contact Pam Ricci at (805) 781-7168. Sincerely, i cc: Andrew Merriam j Cannon Associates 364 Pacific Street Ro aid G. Whi nand SLO, CA 93401 Developmen Review Manager Thelma Perozzi cc: SLO County Assessor's Office c/o Ernie Dalidio 2706 Rodman Drive Attachment: Resolution No. 5294-00 Los Osos, CA 93402 L /O The City of San Luis Obispo is committed to include the disabled in all of its services, programs and activf 768 V Telecommunications Device for the Deaf(805) 781-7410. Attachment 7 Page 2 of 6 SAN LUIS OBISPO PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 5294-00 WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of San Luis Obispo did conduct a public hearing in the Council Chamber of City Hall, 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, California, on July 12, 2000, pursuant to a proceeding instituted under application ANNX, PD and ER 57-98, SC Properties, LLC, applicant. ITEM REVIEWED: Review of a Draft Final EIR and request to annex 88.1 acres of the Dalidio property, and prezone 40 acres Retail-Commercial (C-R) with a possible S (special considerations) or PD (planned development) overlay zone, and prezone 40 acres conservation/Open Space (C/OS) for permanent open space protection. The remaining 8.1 acres would be dedicated for streets and freeway interchange development DESCRIPTION: On file in the office of Community Development Department, City Hall. GENERAL LOCATION: 2005 Dalidio Drive WHEREAS, said Commission as a result of its inspections, investigations, and studies made by itself, and in behalf of testimonies offered at said hearing has established existence of the following circumstances recommending certification of the EIR: Findings 1. The Final EIR was prepared in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and was considered by the City prior to any approvals of the project. 2. The Final EIR reflects the independent judgment of the City. 2-69 Attachment 7 Page 3 of 6 Resolution No. 5294-00 Page 2 3. For each significant effect identified in the EIR under the categories of Geology, Drainage and Water Quality, Noise, Biological Resources, Cultural Resources, and Land Use, the approved mitigation measures contained in the EIR will avoid or substantially lessen the identified adverse environmental impacts of the project to a level of insignificance and have been incorporated into the project. 4. The significant effects identified in the Air Quality, Agricultural Resources, Aesthetics and Traffic/Circulation sections of the EIR will not be fully mitigated to a degree of insignificance with the incorporation of all of the identified mitigation measures included in the EIR. However, the Planning Commission finds that the adverse environmental effects are acceptable and makes a statement of overriding considerations for those significant and unavoidable environmental impacts because: a. Mitigation strategies help to reduce project emissions to the degree feasible and ultimately put the air basin in closer compliance with established State and federal standards. b. The development of the site with a commercial shopping center will significantly affect the character of the site through the alteration of viewsheds from US 101, Madonna Road, and Los Osos Valley Road. However, mitigation measures that require screening landscaping, detailed design review of the bridge for the highway interchange by the Architectural Review Commission (ARC), and ARC approval of lighting, fenestration and other elements of project design, will help lessen the severity of the impacts on viewsheds. c. Traffic and circulation impacts could be reduced to less than significant under the Existing Baseline Plus Project Scenario with the implementation of mitigation measures identified in the EIR. It is with cumulative development under 10 Year Plus Project Conditions and Buildout Plus Project Conditions that the weaving sections of proposed auxiliary lanes, and the Los Osos Valley Road southbound onramp will experience Level of Service below established thresholds. d. For the reasons set forth below, the economic, social, and other considerations of the project outweigh the unavoidable impacts identified above in the findings. First, the annexation will enable the City to achieve its General Plan goals. Second, the annexation will allow for the future development of the site, which will enhance the City's tax base, create more jobs, provide for diverse shopping opportunities for residents of the City, improve City traffic circulation, and create permanent open space. Third, the annexation will ensure that the property is developed in the City. 2-70 Attachment 7 Page 4 of 6 Resolution No. 5294-00 Page 3 e. The data to support these overriding factors are found in the following sections of the record including: 1.) the Environmental Impact Report, specifically Sections 4.3, 4.6, 4.7 & 4.10; 2.) letters submitted by the public contained in the project files; 3.) public testimony provided at this and previous project hearings; and 4.) the applicant's presentation. WHEREAS, said Commission as a result of its inspections, investigations, and studies made by itself, and in behalf of testimonies offered at said hearing has established existence of the following circumstances, and recommends to the City Council support for the Annexation, with submittal of a "Resolution of Application" to the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCo), based on the following findings: Findings 1. The annexation is appropriate since it is within the City's Urban Reserve Boundary, and the site is contiguous to the City. 2. The annexation of the site is a logical addition to the City due to its location in relation to existing urban development. 3. The adopted LUE anticipates the development of the site consistent with project plans and proposed zoning categories. WHEREAS, said Commission as a result of its inspections, investigations, and studies made by itself, and in behalf of testimonies offered at said hearing has established existence of the following circumstances, and recommends to the City Council that the Prezoning be approved with 40 acres as C-R-S (Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning, 40 acres as C/OS-40, (Conservation/ Open Space with 40-acre minimum parcel size), and the remainder, approximately 8.1 acres, to be used for streets and highway interchange improvements, based on the following findings: 2-71 Attachment 7 Page 5 of 6 Resolution No. 5294-00 Page 4 Findings 1. The proposed "S" overlay zoning will document the special considerations for the 40-acre Commercial-Retail portion of the site (C-R-S) which are: drainage, flooding protection, urban/agricultural buffers, roadway improvements and design, pedestrian linkages with other commercial developments and nearby residential areas, loading area design, compliance with energy conservation requirements, creek and open space protection, site lighting and preservation of scenic vistas. 2. The required Planning Commission use permit for development of the commercial area of the site will serve as a master use permit that fulfills the intention of LUE Policy 1.13.3, Required Plans, which calls for the master planning of proposed annexation areas so that the City has an adopted plan showing the project layout, physical development plan, required open space protection, and provision of streets . and utilities. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Planning Commission recommend to the City Council, approval of the proposal. The foregoing resolution was approved by the Planning Commission of the City of San Luis Obispo on motion by Commr. Aiken, seconded by Commr. Cooper that the EIR be certified, and on a separate roll call vote: AYES: Commrs. Aiken, Cooper, Ready, and Loh NOES: Commrs. Whittlesey, Peterson and Osborne ABSENT: None NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Planning Commission recommend to the City Council, approval of the proposal. The foregoing resolution was approved by the Planning Commission of the City of San Luis Obispo on motion by Commr. Aiken, seconded by Commr. Loh, that the City Council support the Annexation by submitting of a "Resolution of Application" to the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCo), and on a separate roll call vote: AYES: Commrs. Aiken, Cooper, Whittlesey, Ready, Peterson, Loh and Osborne NOES:. None ABSENT: None 2-72 Attachment 7 Page 6 of 6 Resolution No. 5294-00 Page 5 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Planning Commission recommend to the City Council, approval of the proposal. The foregoing resolution was approved by the Planning Commission of the City of San Luis Obispo on motion by Commr. Aiken, seconded by Commr. Cooper, that the City Council approve prezoning 40 acres as C-R-S (Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning), 40 acres as CIOS-40 (Conservation/Open Space with 40-acre minimum parcel size), and the remainder, approximately 8.1 acres, to be used for streets and highway interchange improvements, and on a separate roll call vote: AYES: Commrs. Aiken, cooper, Ready, and Loh NOES: Commrs. Whittlesey, Peterson and Osborne ABSENT: None Arnold B. Jonas, Secretary Planning Commission Dated: July 12, 2000 2-73 SAN LUIS OBISPO Attachment 8 PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES Page 1 of 13 JULY 12, 2000 CALL TO ORDER/PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: The San Luis Obispo Planning Commission was called to order at 7:06 p.m. on Wednesday, July 12, 2000, in Council Chamber of City Hall, 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, California. ROLL CALL: Present: Commrs. Jim Aiken, Orval Osborne, Mary Whittlesey, Alice Loh, Stephen Peterson, Allan Cooper, and Chairman Paul Ready Absent: None Staff: Recording Secretary Leaha Magee, Community Development Director Arnold Jonas, Development Review Manager Ron Whisenand, Utilities Engineer Dan Gilmore, Deputy Director of Public Works Tim Bochum, Supervising Engineer Jerry Kenny, Principal Transportation Planner Terry Sanville, Economic Development Manager Shelly Stanwick, Associate Planner Pam Ricci, EIR Consultant Steve Svete, and Assistant City Attorney Gil Trujillo. ACCEPTANCE OF THE AGENDA: The agenda was accepted as presented. ACCEPTANCE OF THE MINUTES: The Minutes of May 24, 2000, were accepted as corrected on page 2. PUBLIC COMMENT ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS: There were no non-agenda comments made. PUBLIC HEARINGS: 1. 2005 Dalidio Drive. ANNX, PD and ER 57-98; Review of a Draft Final EIR and request to annex 88.1 acres of the Dalidio property, and prezone 40 acres Retail- Commercial (C-R) with a possible S (special considerations) or PD (planned development) overlay zone, and prezone 40 acres Conservation/Open Space (C/OS) for permanent open space protection. The remaining 8.1 acres would be dedicated for streets and freeway interchange development; SC Properties, LLC, applicant. Commr. Loh reported that she had determined there was no conflict of interest and that she would be able to participate in the discussion of and action on this item. 2-74 Planning Commission Minutes Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page 2 Page 2 of 13 Associate Planner Pam Ricci presented the staff report and recommended that the Planning Commission (1) recommend that the City Council certify the EIR with a finding of overriding consideration relative to traffic/circulation, air quality, aesthetics, and loss of agricultural land, (2) recommend the City Council adopt a Resolution of Intention to annex the property, and (3) recommend the City Council approve the Prezoning. Mr. Svete presented a summary of the Draft Final EIR. Commr. Osborne voiced concerns about area flooding and associated impacts on adjacent properties. Mr. Svete referred Commr. Osborne to Mitigation Measure DW1 B on page 4.2-9 of the revised draft. Commr. Loh noted the Environmental Defense Center's letter mentions threatened California red legged frogs. Mr. Svete stated surveys have identified the seasonal habitat for the frog; this project will not have a direct impact on red-legged frog habitat, except for a future roadway crossing that is not planned at this time. Commr. Peterson expressed concerns about area flooding and asked if there are mitigation measures incorporated that will protect the residential area to the south of the proposed project. Mr. Svete responded that the area to the south has not been identified as a flood- impacted area. Commr. Peterson asked if the traffic section factors into this project the Froom Ranch Project and its potential cumulative traffic impacts. Mr. Svete replied that this information was included in the revised draft. Commr. Cooper referred to Mitigation Measure B10-10) on page 10-3 and suggested the language be revised to reflect: "... interim open space, park or street widening components." He commented that the findings for overriding considerations, page 9 of the staff report, may or may not have paralleled those developed by the Council in 1994, and questioned how mitigation strategies could help to reduce project emissions to the degree feasible. He expressed concerns for the reasoning behind the finding regarding loss of agricultural land. Commr. Cooper had Mr. Svete review the definition of weaving lanes as referred to in Figure 4-10 and 4-11. Commr. Loh voiced concern about not having drawings of the future freeway overpass and questioned if the ARC or Planning Commission would review future plans. 2-75 Planning Commission Minuies Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page 3 Page 3 of 13 Associate Planner Ricci reviewed late-submitted correspondences and a memo submitted by the City's Natural Resource Manager Neil Havlik. Engineer Kenny addressed the drainage analysis related to the proposed development site and the existing residential area. Commr. Peterson questioned if flooding mitigation measures are sufficient to handle the impervious surfaces that will be added with the project. Commr. Osbome noted the City's Land Use and Open Space Elements speak to the protection of half of the land when a conversion of agricultural land to urban uses occurs. This requirement is not being met by this proposal, noting that roads are not open space. Associate Planner Ricci stated the current proposal is 88.1 acres; 40 acres of retail commercial, 40 acres of open space, and an additional 8.1 of roads. Commr. Osborne had staff review the layout and timing of the open space dedications and asked if consideration was given to designating the land open space as agricultural since the City now has agricultural zoning. Manger Whisenand stated when the General Plan originally considered this area, the city only had a Conservation/Open Space designation, but an agriculture prezoning recommendation to the Council would be consistent with the General Plan. Economic Development Manager Shelly Stanwick reported that in 1999, the City Council, Dalido family, and Marketplace Associates entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) outlining the terms of a possible development agreement which specifically assigned land uses the to acreages. Commr. Osborne referred to Land Use Element Policy 1.13.5 and asked if consideration was given to having some increased open space dedication on the Dalido property to compensate for the loss of the McBride property. Manager Whisenand stated the McBride property is a separate piece of land and stands on its own. Commr. Osborne had staff review the findings and statements of overriding consideration for significant environmental impacts identified in the EIR. Assistant City Attorney Trujillo explained the requirements of statements of overriding consideration. Commr. Loh referred to Land Use Element Policy 3.13.3 and noted that there are no plans before the Commission. She felt uncomfortable with division of land related to open space and developable area, and felt that guidelines might be helpful to determine if open space is deducted from the total acreage before roads are planned. She voiced concerns with drainage and felt specific development guidelines were necessary. 2-76 Planning Commission Minutes Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page 4 Page 4 of 13 Commr. Peterson asked when the economic study was conducted and if it addressed development of the Froom and McBride properties. Economic Development Manager Stanwick stated the study was completed in February, 1999, and at that time the Froom project had not proceeded. Commr. Cooper felt the placement of the overriding consideration in staffs recommendations should be reconsidered. The staff report indicates the EIR should be certified and then the Commission would find the adverse environmental effects acceptable. He felt this has nothing to do with EIR certification. Associated Planner Ricci noted the format for findings for certification of the EIR was modeled after previous EIR resolutions of the Council. There were no further comments or questions at this time and the public comment session was opened. PUBLIC COMMENTS: Andrew Merriam of Cannon Associates and representing the landowner, stated that their commitment is to the General Plan, which is reflected in their proposal that shows a 50/50 split in the acreages of developable areas and open spaces. He noted that they are not including the City-required Prado Road extension, which is beyond their control and is a public dedication, nor are they including the freeway interchange. He said they understand that the use permit required because of the proposed "S" designation will be coming back to the Commission. He emphasized the property has been developed consistent with the General Plan; it supplies the open space requirement as a gateway to the city, and meets the requirements of infill and commercial development. Bill Bird, San Luis Marketplace Associates representative, stated the detailed hydrology study was updated as a result of the first EIR. He indicated confidence that drainage concerns would be addressed. He noted that because of the Auto Parkway's needs of the city, there might be some changes and relaxations to the amount of open space dedication for the McBride property. He indicated that the site plan will be presented at another meeting for review. He added that the EIR contemplates the size of the project and the types of tenants that will be accommodated. He stated that the freeway interchange is a $10 million dollar cost and reducing the size of the project just doesn't work. He closed by noting that representatives of Lowe's and Target were available for questions. Commr. Cooper asked if a mall layout redesign could be accommodated to mitigate impacts on the Class I agricultural lands. Mr. Bird stated they are on their fourth architect since project planning began in 1994, and have accepted community input on the design of the project. He added that the desired tenants require a certain amount of parking. He noted that the $10 million dollar freeway interchange will be paid for through sales tax generation. He felt the architects have been aggressive in making the project compact and in keeping it away from the 2-77 Planning Commission Minuto. Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page 5 Page 5 of 13 freeway, thus reducing the impacts of parking. Commr. Osborne asked if it is their intention to go ahead with the Lowe's hardware store, even though Home Depot is going in nearby. Roger Bernstien, Lowe's site development manager, replied yes, and described the differences between Lowe's and Home Depot, noting Lowe's is more upscale. He felt this is a great site and they are anxious to move ahead. Donna Wilson, 1850 Oceanaire Drive, asked about meeting notification requirements. Associate Planner Ricci stated that typically there is a 300-foot notification radius, but for this project an expanded notification was prepared to include all of the houses along the portion of Oceanaire that backs up to the project site. Ms. Wilson expressed a concern with delivery truck access to the site and associated noises since she lives adjacent to the project. Mr. Bemstien stated hours of delivery are typically from 6:00-6:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Commercial trucks are separated from the customers; deliveries will occur behind the buildings that are 1,200 feet from the nearest residence. Ms. Wilson asked if Madonna Road will be improved or widened. She raised a concern with the Mayor's house being in the sphere of influence of this project. Ira Wynn, 3346 Barranca Court, spoke in opposition to the project and stated an environmental impact report is supposed to offer a superior alternative. He felt mail developments on the outskirts of the city work to destroy the downtown, and that chain stores are not locally owned and money will pour out of the city. He felt this is the wrong place for development given the four unmitigatable impacts. He felt this project will destroy the pedestrian ambience of the downtown. Janet Kourakis, 1727 Corralitos, spoke in opposition to the project and expressed safety concerns at the Prado Road interchange because of its adjacency to the Madonna interchange. She felt cross-town interchange users will increase traffic, air quality will be impacted by increased traffic, and the project is too large and is not needed. Shirley Baker, 101 California Boulevard, read a letter (on record in the Planning Department) from San Luis Obispo County Chumash Council in opposition to the project. Betty Shetser, 225 San Luis Drive, spoke in opposition to the project and felt tax revenue is the main justification for the project. She noted that San Luis Obispo has been noted in magazines as having a unique character, and felt that this character is not based on big box stores. Marie Dixon, 1978 Oceanaire Drive, spoke in opposition to the project and noted creek and wildlife behind her home will be replaced with big box development and associated 2-78 Planning Commission Minute . Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page 6 Page 6 of 13 impacts of construction. She commented that she has heard of a plan for a feeder road between Madonna Plaza and the Dalido center, and expressed concern that the road might impact the neighborhood. Cathy Hailey, 1881 Corralitos Avenue, spoke in support of the project and noted there would be great benefits to having more shopping choices. She mentioned that the project has been designed to provide open space, and that the interchange that will allow traffic to move more efficiently through the southern section of the city. She strongly urged the Commission to support the project. She felt the Dalidio family has been working for years in good faith with the City and they should be treated fairly in the process. Brad Bocca, 176 Stenner Street, Apt. E, spoke in opposition to the project and noted the Class I unavoidable impacts. He felt big box stores will negatively impact local retailers and contractors/service suppliers. Bob Hather spoke in support of the project and complimented the applicants on accepting public input during the process. He noted that the overriding circumstances include economic and transportation benefits and convenience of shopping. He urged support of the project. Stan Ryan, 234 Broad Street, felt the project holds enough contradictions that the Commission has the ability to make any decision it chooses. Patricia Wilmore, municipal advocate speaking for the Chamber of Commerce, spoke in favor of the project and asked the Commission to be consistent with the General Plan. She stated that the social, environmental and economic components of the community cannot be ignored, and felt this project is appropriate. Commr. Aiken noted the Commission has not reviewed the 1999 Economic Impact Study and asked for a synopsis of the study. Ms. Wilmore responded that retail expansion in this area is appropriate for the economy of San Luis Obispo, noting that residents find themselves frequently shopping out of town. She added that the economic market in San Luis Obispo can bear this additional development. Cliff Holser, 672 Serrano Drive, spoke to the high quality of life in San Luis Obispo and expressed economic concerns about the cumulative impacts of Froom, Dalido, and Copeland developments on local downtown businesses., Lee Ferraro, 1720 14th Street, Los Osos, spoke in support of the project and supported staffs recommendations of EIR adoption, annexation, and prezoning. Taryn Collins, chair of the local chapter Sierra Club, spoke in opposition to the project. She mentioned that the Sierra Club had concerns including increased traffic, degradation of air quality, and inadequacy of the EIR. She felt that native American cultural resources and the local economy will suffer significant negative impacts, and 2-79 Planning Commission Minutes July 12, 2000 Attachment 8 Page 7 Page 7 of 13 that this project is proposed on a flood plain and flooding and drainage impacts cannot be deferred to future studies. She mentioned that the cumulative impacts of other similar developments have not been adequately studied. She also felt there are sufficient legal grounds to appeal this annexation, and that this project should be rejected. Linda Seely, 1040 San Carlos Drive, spoke in opposition to the project and expressed concern about the project's 515,000 square feet of shopping space. She noted that Froom Ranch was recently approved with 110,000 square feet of shopping area, the Central Coast Plaza is being revamped, and the Copeland development will have over 100,000 square feet of development. She felt this cumulative development constituted excessive growth, and that the beauty of San Luis Obispo does not include big box stores. Cynthia Boche, Buchon Street resident, spoke in opposition to the project because of the significant unavoidable and unmitigatable adverse impacts to air quality, agriculture resources, traffic, and aesthetic. She felt this project is inconsistent with the Land Use Element goals and Sections 1.8.1, 1.8.2, 8.8; Open Space Element Sections 10.2.1, C; sections of the Circulation Element, and Conservation Element policies. She questioned the reliability of the sales figures in the economic study. She felt that this property does belong in the city and would be appropriate for the new Agriculture zone. Christine Mulholland, city resident, spoke in opposition to the project because the EIR has pointed out multiple significant unavoidable impacts. She expressed concem with the Agricultural land loss and commented she felt the statements of overriding consideration were meaningless. Dodie Williams, 438 Woodbridge, spoke in support of the project. She felt the project is consistent with the General Plan, has a generous provision for open space, and provides for needed shopping. She noted this is an in-fill project as opposed to sprawl, and that it makes sense to develop a project amongst urban uses; she questioned whether farming should be continued in an urban area. Commr. Cooper questioned Ms. Williams on the possibility that this project could go ahead in the County. Ms. Williams felt this project could move forward in the County and would probably not include the open and residential provisions and extension of Laguna Lake Park. She added that it would not be a good situation for a development of this nature in the middle of the City's urban area in the County. Brian Rosconi, 27 Branch Street, spoke in support of the project because of the shopping convenience it would provide. Eugene Judd, 665 Leff Street, member of the International Institute of Transportation Engineers, spoke in opposition of the project, displayed overhead exhibits, and commented on the number of trips that would be generated, area circulation and alternatives, and suggested office or industrial rezoning for this land. He urged rejection 2-80 Planning Commission Minutes July 12, 2000 Attachment 8 Page 8 Page 8 of 13 of the rezoning and EIR. Brian Christiansen, 818 Pismo Street, spoke in opposition to the project because of drainage, circulation, liquefaction, groundwater, wetland/mitigation habitat and traffic concerns. He noted that the Prado Road interchange depends on sales tax; which is not an assured source. He felt that this site should be saved. for its open space and agricultural purposes. Richard Ransdorf, 160 Graves Street, reviewed and distributed handouts to the Commission and spoke in opposition to the project. He felt that the General Plan and Land Use Element are not being followed. He noted that although this project consists of 131 acres, only 40 are proposed for open space. Ben Luna, Environmental Defense Center attorney, spoke in opposition to the project. He stated the Dalido project is on a collision course with CEQA, the Endangered Species Act, and California Government Code. He noted that the Fish and Wildlife Service, Department of Fish and Game, and National Marine Fishery Service were not consulted and had no idea this project was moving forward. He questioned why a habitat protection plan has not been developed in relation to the red-legged tree frog or steelhead fish. Mr. Merriam summarized by stating the southern part of the site is dedicated to open space and they fully intend to meet the commitments specified. He added that Caltrans had been consulted and that there is Federal Highway Commission approval for the interchange. He concurred that the findings of overriding consideration should be strengthened. Seeing no further speakers come forward, the public comment session was closed. COMMISSION COMMENTS: Commr. Whittlesey asked what the current County zoning of the land is. Manager Whisenand replied the current zoning is agriculture. Commr. Whittlesey questioned the developability of this Ag-zoned land in the County and asked what would happen if there were no prezoning recommendations made. Manager Whisenand stated in order to have an annexation move forward to LAFCo, a prezone must occur and be a part of the annexation request. Commr. Whittlesey questioned if the EIR could move forward without the prezoning or annexation being successful. Manager Whisenand stated this could occur, but there would be time constraints. Commr. Cooper had staff review examples of statements of overriding considerations. 2-81 Planning Commission Minute.. Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page 9 Page 9 of 13 Commr. Aiken asked for comment from Mr. Merriam regarding what would be sought if this project were not approved and other avenues in the city failed. Mr. Merriam responded that they prefer to be annexed into the City, but if necessary they would proceed with the zone change process in the County. Commr. Peterson stated this land is zoned agriculture in the County and would require a General Plan amendment for a rezone to commercial; this would not be an easily achieved exercise. He added that SOAR is coming down the pipeline and may affect a rezoning as well. Commr. Loh questioned staff on the Froom Ranch prezoning recommendation passed along to Council. Director Jonas responded the portion of Froom Ranch proposed for annexation was entirely C-R and the portion preserved for open space is remaining in the County and is not being annexed but is being restricted to open space. Commr. Aiken moved.to recommend to the City Council that the EIR be certified based upon Findings 1-4 as presented in the staff report with the addition of (1) 4E to reflect that "the economic, social and other considerations of the project outweigh the unavoidable impacts identjfred by the findings. First the annexation will enable the city to achieve its General Plan goals. Second, the annexation will allow for the future: development of the site which will enhance the city's tax base create more lobs provide for diverse shopping opportunities for residents of the city improve the city's traffic circulation and create permanent open space. Third the annexation will ensure that the property is developed in the city," and (2) #41F to reflect: "To support these overriding factors are found in Sections 4.3, 4.6, 4.7. and 4.10 of the EIR. Facts to support this finding are also included in the public testimony and the applicant's presentation and in letters submitted to the Planning Commission this evening " Commission Cooper seconded the motion. Commr. Cooper recommended 4B be deleted from the motion which resulted in the amendments discussed above being reordered as 4D and 4E.. Commr. Aiken accepted the amendment to the motion to delete 4B from the motion which resulted in the amendments discussed above being reordered as 4D and 4E Commr. Peterson felt a situation could occur where a Commr. felt that the EIR is adequate, but does not feel that the overriding considerations outlined are good enough to accept the environmental impacts. He felt further discussion on the economic overriding considerations would be appropriate. Commr. Whittlesey recommended including provision of a shuttle between the Central Coast Plaza/SLO Promenade and this development as a mitigation measure to air quality impacts. 2-82 Planning Commission Minuw� Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page 10 Page 10 of 13 Commr. Aiken amended the motion to reflect on page 4.3-11, under Cumulative Impacts in the Air Quality Section, that the applicant should implement a shuttle service to other commercial developments along Madonna Road. Commr. Cooper accepted the amendment to the motion. Chairman Ready requested page 10.3, Mitigation Bio 1J, be amended to include "or street widening,"as recommend by Commr. Cooper. Commrs. Aiken and Cooper accepted the amendment to the motion. Chairman Ready requested illustrations of weaving lanes be included in the EIR. Commrs. Aiken and Cooper amended the motion to include diagrams of the weaving lanes in the EIR. Commr. Peterson stated that when an EIR lays out several unmitigatable environmental impacts, CEQA requires a statement of overriding considerations to make sure the decision makers have realized the impacts. He felt uncomfortable with reasons to approve this proposal. He noted that the statement that this project would enhance the City's tax base is arguable. He felt that sales tax generated here would be pumped into building the interchange and also detract from our existing hardware stores and lower their sales tax revenue. He did not believe that there could be tourism impacts, and that "potential" for a regional draw is an inadequate rationale for project support. Traffic circulation improvement would not occur because of the traffic this project would generate. He was not convinced. that annexation would ensure that the property is developed in the City, and questions if a rezone would be approved in the County. AYES: Commrs. Aiken, Cooper, Loh, and Chairman Ready NOES: Commrs. Whittlesey, Peterson, and Osbome REFRAIN: None The motion carried 4-3-0. Commr. Aiken moved to recommend to the City Council support for the annexation with submittal of a Resolution of Application to the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCo) based on the three findings as presented in the staff report. Commr. Loh seconded the motion. Commr. Osbome stated that by annexing these 88 acres, the City,will be creating an island of unincorporated County; it his understanding that LAFCo doesn't support this sort of situation. AYES: Commrs. Aiken, Loh, Cooper, Whittlesey, Peterson, Osborne and Ready NOES: None REFRAIN: None The motion carried 7-0-0. 2-83 Planning Commission Minutcs Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page 11 Page 11 of 13 Commr. Whittlesey commented that since circumstances of redevelopment had changed since the General Plan was adopted she moved to recommend to the City Council institution of a General Plan amendment to zone this property for Business Park in anticipation of prezoning this at some future time to Business Park. The motion failed for lack of a second. Commr. Aiken moved to recommend to the City Council that the prezoninq be approved with 40 acres of retail, as C-R-S, Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration Overlay zoning, and the remainder of the site as C/OS-40 Conservation/Open Space with 40-acre minimum parcel size based on the two finding outlined in the staff report. Commr. Cooper seconded the motion Commr. Loh questioned the "the remainder of the site as C/OS-40" part of the motion because the site is 88.1 acres. After discussion, Commr. Aiken clarified the motion by stating the remaining 8.1 acres will be dedicated to the proposed roads, rights of way, and other purpose such as the interchange, public access, and utilities. Commr. Cooper accepted the clarification Commr. Cooper asked for staff comment on Commr. Osborne's suggestion of prezoning this site Agriculture. Manager Whisenand recommended the Conservation/Open Space prezoning, but noted the Agriculture zone would also be suitable. Commr. Aiken preferred C/OS zoning and encouraged continued use as an agriculture property. Commr. Whittlesey was not supportive of the motion and felt the General Plan should be amended. She felt Retail is not appropriate at this site. She added that she would support this annexation with its current operations. Commr. Loh requested Finding 2 be amended to include reference to a physical layout plan of the site. Commr. s Aiken and Cooper accepted the amendment to Finding 2 on page 10 of the staff report to reflect ".. adopted plan showing the project layout and phvsical development plans required open space protection and provision of streets and utilities." Commr. Peterson was not supportive of the motion and felt the project is unhealthy for the city in many ways. He noted that the General Plan contains policies and goals that speak in opposition of this proposal and these opposing policies and goals over power the proposal. He felt internal General Plan inconsistencies may lead to litigation. He thought that development of this site would impact the quality of life in the city; and in light of the public comments received the community does not want this development. He stated that the prime agricultural land should be preserved. Madonna Plaza is half empty and our viewshed and gateway to the city will be compromised; this is bad 2-84 Planning Commission Minutes Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page 12 Page 12 of 13 planning. Between the Froom Ranch project, the redevelopment of the Central Coast Mall, and the Copeland project, there is an excessive amount of retail coming online. Commr. Cooper did not feel development of this site would compete with downtown commercial, noting the downtown has long-term viability. Commr. Loh felt urban development and the freeway have choked this piece of land. She noted that she was sensitive to conserving Class I agriculture soils and natural habitat, but felt that this property is different. She felt shopping choices are needed in the city because many citizens are going out of town to shop. Commr. Osborne felt this project is both consistent and inconsistent with the General Plan. He mentioned that the General Plan supports retention of prime Ag land and signature viewsheds, and says that the City will not increase traffic or air pollution. He added , in spite of the fact that this project will violate the City's goals, the project still can be found to be consistent with the General Plan. He noted his opposition to the plan because of the significant unavoidable impacts and significant viewshed impacts. He felt that farmland was preferable over a parking lot and stated that citizens will experience a lower quality of life with approval of this proposal. He noted half of the 88 acres, which he felt was inconsistent with the General Plan that states that half the land should be dedicated to open space. He suggested changing the requirement for open space to at least be equal to the land that will be paved. Chairman Ready felt there are numerous arguable inconsistencies with respect to the General Plan, but his review supports the requests before the Commission. He is supportive of the motion. AYES: Commrs. Aiken, Cooper, Loh, and Ready NOES: Commrs. Whittlesey, Peterson, and Osbome REFRAIN: None The motion carried 4-3-0. 2. 3165 Broad Street: Request to increase shared and mixed use parking for The Crossroads center from 25% to 30%; C-S-PD zone; Jesse Norris, applicant. Staff reported this item had been withdrawn. COMMENT AND DISCUSSION: 3. Staff: A. Agenda Forecast: Due to the lateness of the evening, this item was not heard. 2-85 Planning Commission Minutes s Attachment 8 July 12, 2000 Page i 3 Page.13 of'13 4. Commission: Due to the lateness of the evening, this item was:not heard. ADJOURNMENT: With no further business before the Commission; the meetingadjourned at 12;11 a.m. to the next regular meeting scheduled for July 26, 2000; at TOO p:m. in Council Chambers. Respectfully submitted, Leaha K. Magee Recording Secretary 1 ImN Attachment 9 Page 1 of 18 CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT ITEM N 1 BY: Pam Ricci, Associate Planner MEETING DATE: July 12, 2000 FROM: Ron Whisenand, Development Review Manager CITY FILE NUMBER: ANNX, R, ER 57-98 EIR STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER: 1999031092 PROJECT ADDRESS: 2005 Dalidio Drive SUBJECT: Review of an Administrative Final EIR and request to annex 88.1 acres of the Dalidio property, and pre-zone 40 acres Retail Commercial (C-R) with a possible S, Special Consideration, or PD, Planned Development, overlay, and pre-zone 40 acres Conservation/Open Space (C/OS) for permanent open space protection. SUMMARY RECOMMENDATION A. Recommend to the City Council that the EIR be certified with a finding of overriding considerations relative to traffic/circulation, air quality, aesthetics, and loss of agricultural land. B. Recommend to the City Council that they adopt a Resolution of Intention to annex the property. C. Recommend to the City Council that the Prezoning be approved. BACKGROUND Situation This agenda item is both a hearing to consider the adequacy of the Administrative Final EIR in terms of its compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and a hearing to consider the various project entitlements. The Planning Commission's action is a recommendation on the EIR and other requested entitlements to the City Council. Previous Review On December 1, 1999, the Planning Commission continued consideration of the Dalidio Annexation project per the applicant's request. The Commission continued consideration of the project to the January 12, 2000 meeting. However, prior to that hearing, staff determined that a revised Draft EIR should be prepared to update the project description and schedule, and to evaluate the secondary impacts of a planned highway interchange in response to criticisms of segmenting EIR issues. In early January 2000,the applicant submitted a revised project proposal indicating that the 131-acre Dalidio Annexation site would be formally divided into two separate 2-8 / ANNX, R, ER 57-98 (Dalin.,Property Annexation) Attachment 9 Page 2 Page 2 of 18 annexations: an 88.1-acre Commercial Annexation, and a 42.9-acre residential Annexation. On April 26,2000,a public hearing was held before the Planning Commission to discuss the revised Draft EIR during the required public review period. At that meeting, testimony from both the Commission and public was taken. A copy of those minutes is included in the Responses to Comments document dated June 2000. A previous hearing was held before the Planning Commission on August 25, 1999 to discuss the original Draft EIR. On June 23, 2000, the Addenda and Errata/Comments and Responses Report was distributed to the Planning Commission, which incorporates clarifications and corrections to the revised Draft EIR, as well as all comment letters and responses. The revised Draft EIR and the Addenda and Errata/Responses to Comments report collectively comprise the Administrative Final EIR for the Dalidio Annexation Project. After certification, the two reports would be edited together, along with any other modifications made by decision makers, into a Final EIR. Data Summary Address: 2005 Dalidio Drive Applicant: San Luis Marketplace Associates, LLC Representative: Canon & Associates; Perkowitz+Ruth architects, Inc. Environmental status: The Administrative Final EIR has been prepared and has been distributed to the Commission. Project action deadline: Legislative actions are not subject to processing deadlines. Project Location The Dalidio Property Annexation EIR area evaluates a site consisting of 131 acres bounded on the east by US 101, and on the west by Madonna Road. The property is located immediately southwest of the Central Coast Mall. The annexation area is outside the city limits, but adjacent to the City of San Luis Obispo and within the City's "urban reserve". The Commercial Annexation Area is located on 88.1 acres, closer to the adjoining Central Coast Mall property and US 101. The proposed Prado Road interchange would have a footprint ranging from about 60 meters (197 feet) from the centerline of the freeway, at the intersection of US 101 and Prado Road, to about 20 meters (66 feet) from the centerline, between Prado Road and Madonna Road, and south of Prado Road. Requested Project Entitlements On April 1, 1998, the Community Development Department received an application from San Luis Obispo Marketplace Associates to prezone and annex a 131-acre piece of property to the City of San Luis Obispo. William and Kevin Bird are the representatives for San Luis Obispo Marketplace Associates, who are proposing the retail component of the project, and Andrew Merriam is the representative for the Dalidio family who own the property. As mentioned earlier, a decision was made in January of 2000 by the applicants to formally divide the total Dalidio Annexation area into two separate annexations. 2-88 ANNK R, ER 57-98 (D*Property Annexation) Attachment 9 Page 3 Page 3 of 18 The specific components of the Commercial Annexation application that is currently up for consideration by the Planning Commission at this hearing include: 1. Retail Commercial. Pre-zone 40 acres of land adjacent to the south of the Central Coast Mall to Retail Commercial and develop the vacant property with new retail commercial uses and restaurants. This new retail center, referred to as the San Luis Marketplace, would contain approximately 515,000 square feet of leasable space, with additional areas allocated to outdoor sales associated with major tenant spaces, including a mixture of larger and smaller retail uses and restaurants. The proposed project would include approximately 2,300 parking spaces in a series of landscaped parking fields mixed throughout the center. 2. Open Space. Pre-zone 40 acres Conservation/Open Space for permanent open space protection. This area is located adjacent to the US 101 freeway and southeast of the Commercial Retail portion of the project. 3. Roadway Dedication. The Commercial Annexation includes 8.1 acres that would be dedicated for freeway and roadway construction throughout the site. 4. Prado Road Interchange. The project would also include the construction of a freeway interchange at Prado Road, the construction of a freeway auxiliary lane on the east side of the freeway, from Prado Road to Madonna Road, the realignment of Elks Lane, and the extension of Prado Road to Madonna Road. The proposed auxiliary lane would be constructed within the existing Caltrans right-of-way. Project History The proposal to annex the Dalidio property to the City of San Luis Obispo has been envisoned by City plans for many years. The Land Use Element (LUE) map for the 1977 plan showed the site as major expansion area with the Interim Conservation/Open Space(C/OS) designation. The Interim C/OS designation implied that the site should be left open until urbanization was appropriate, and that a specific proposal for the area needed to be adopted along with the change to an urban land use designation. In 1994, the City Council adopted a new LUE. After much deliberation and debate, specific land use designations were applied to parts of the Dalidio property as shown in the attached land use plan. This solidified a commitment by the City to eventually allow development of certain parts of the site and permanent open space preservation of others. Since applying to the City for annexation, prezoning, architectural review and environmental review, the project has been discussed by the City Council several times. In accordance with LUE Policy 3.1.3, consultant PCR Kotin prepared an economic study which evaluated the potential sales transfer impacts of the project on the downtown and other retail areas of the City. On April 20, 1999, the Council accepted the report and authorized staff to begin negotiation of a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the applicant. On September 21, 1999, the Council approved the MOU which outlined the principles for some reimbursement of"new" sales tax in order to construct the Prado Road interchange. 2-89 ANNX, R, ER 57-98 (Daftroperty Annexation) Attachment 9 Page 4 Page 4 of 18 EVALUATION The Commission's actions on the various project entitlements are advisory to the City Council. This meeting before the Planning Commission has been set-aside to discuss the legal adequacy of the EIR and to formulate a recommendation to the City Council on requested entitlements. This section of the report is intended to provide the Commission with direction on their role in the review of the project and approaches to making recommendations on the various entitlements. The following paragraphs serve as an outline to the Commission for the order of considering project components. 1. EIR Adequacy The Administrative Final EIR is a compilation of the revised Draft EIR and the Addenda and Errata/Comments and Responses Report. Responses to comments are a written evaluation of comments on the environmental issues received from persons who reviewed the revised Draft EIR. Copies of all the written comments received during the public review period have been incorporated into the Addenda and Errata/Comments and Responses Report, including the minutes of the April 26,2000 Planning Commission meeting. Section 9 of the revised Draft EIR document also includes all of the Responses to Comments prepared for the original Draft EIR. The responses to comments were prepared by the consultant and reviewed by city staff. At this time,the Commission needs to review and consider the information contained in the Administrative Final EIR to determine whether it is complete and in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA); this review process is known in CEQA as certification. The Commission shall make a recommendation to the Council who takes a final action on certification of the EIR.If the document adequately evaluates environmental issues and appropriately responds to comments, then the Commission should recommend to the Council that the Final EIR be certified. The Final EIR must be certified prior to approval of the project analyzed in the EIR. Regardless of the Commission's recommendation on other project entitlements (even if it is to deny them), the Commission could support certification of the EIR. In other words, the Commission can recommend that the EIR be certified even if other project requests are not supported. The City decided to re-circulate the original Draft EIR because of modifications to the project description and changes in the environmental setting since the filing of the original March 1999 Notice of Preparation. The revised Draft EIR includes the following modifications: • An analysis of the environmental consequences associated with construction of the Prado Road interchange; • Applicant-requested revisions to the timing of the annexation of the western and eastern portions of the site; • A revised construction and occupancy schedule; and • Changes to the environmental setting as a result of development that has been approved since the publication of the March 1999 NDP, specifically the Froom Ranch development. 2-90 ANNX, R, ER 57-98 (DWroperty Annexation) Attachment 9. Page 5 Page 5 of 18 Changes to the text of the EIR resulting from comments received during the public review period are highlighted on Page 10-1 to 10-5 of the Addenda and Errata/Commentsand Responses Report. In response to comments from Caltrans, the impact analysis addressing intersection operations under the Existing Baseline Plus Project and Buildout Plus Project scenarios was expanded to include pedestrian minimum times. This expanded analysis supported the conclusion in the revised Draft EIR that impacts to intersection levels of service could be reduced to less than significant with implementation of the required mitigation measures. The most significant change made to the conclusions regarding project impacts was in Section 4.7, Aesthetics,of the revised Draft EIR. As directed by the Planning Commission,Impact AES 1 was modified from a Class II, significant but mitigable impact,to a Class 1, significant and unavoidable impact. The Commission felt that the project would significantly affect the aesthetic character of the site through alteration of viewsheds from US 101,Madonna Road and Los Osos Valley Road. The City has the following options in responding to the conclusions of the EIR: • Disapprove the project because it has significant environmental effects; • Require changes in the project to reduce or avoid a significant environmental effect; • Approve the project despite its significant environmental effects, if the proper findings and statement of overriding considerations are adopted. An agency is not required to select the most environmentally superior alternative. The Administrative Final EIR concludes that the project would result in significant and unavoidable Class I environmental impacts in the issue areas of air quality, agricultural resources, aesthetics, and traffic/circulation. Therefore, the City would be required to adopt a statement of overriding considerations if it were to approve the project as submitted. Air Quality: The County of San Luis Obispo is currently in "non-attainment" for the State standards for ozone and PM10 (fine particulate matter, 10 microns or less in diameter). Increased traffic associated with the project would incrementally increase the pollutants in the air. Projects proposed for development in non-attainment areas should adopt all "reasonably available transportation control measures" to mitigate the impacts associated with new development. This applies to all new projects within the City's urban reserve. Mitigation strategies recommended would reduce emissions associated with the proposed project. However, proposed mitigation measures will not reduce emissions below established SLO APCD thresholds. Agricultural Resources: The proposed development plan shows that 40 acres of the project site would be developed with retail uses, The Marketplace project, and that another 11 acres would ultimately be developed with a residential project. Most of the prime agricultural land that is proposed for development is included in the area occupied by the retail component. The EIR points out that this loss of agricultural land is significant and unavoidable, but also indicates that the loss of this resource was previously evaluated and documented in the EIR for the Land Use Element (LUE) update. In its certification of the LUE EIR on August 23, 1994, the City Council previously adopted a statement of overriding considerations for the loss of prime agricultural soils. An important consideration is that the proposed project is part of that previously identified impact and would not result in any additional significant impact beyond that included in the earlier determination. 2-91 ANNX, R, ER 57-98 (DaftProperty Annexation) Attachment 9 Page 6 Page 6 of 18 Aesthetics: The revised Draft EIR had concluded that the aesthetic impacts of the project were Class II, significant but mitigable. At its April 26, 2000 meeting, the Planning Commission discussed the more subjective nature of aesthetic impacts and the difficulty in establishing meaningful thresholds of significance. Based on this discussion, the Commission took a formal action through a:motion at the 4-26-00 hearing to modify the conclusion of the impact level from Class Il to a Class 1. The Addenda and Errata/Comments and Responses Report reflects the change to the impact level directed by the Planning Commission. Traffic & Circulation: The traffic analysis included in the EIR has been updated to include the development of the Prado Road interchange in the near term (i.e. concurrent with the development of the project). Though construction of the Prado Road Interchange would help alleviate intersection and roadway operation impacts in the near-term, the proposed project, in conjunction with cumulative development throughout the City, would ultimately result in Class I, significant and unavoidable impacts to freeway ramp operations under the Ten Year Plus Project Scenario and The Buildout Plus Project Scenario. These impacts would occur despite the construction of the Prado Road Interchange. 2. Annexation Annexation projects require the review and approval of the San Luis Obispo Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCo). The applicant has applied for LAFCo review. However, LAFCo proceedings would not take place until after the Planning Commission and City Council have indicated their intention to support annexation of the property to the City, and have determined the appropriate zoning for the site to be annexed. The LUE map designates different parts of the total Dalidio site for General Retail, Medium- High Density Residential, Interim Conservation/Open Space and Open Space. Zoning designations, consistent with the LUE map, are discussed in the next section of this report. LAFCo review will resume once the Council acts on the prezoning and agrees to commence tax revenue negotiations. The Council Ordinance approving the prezoning would note that the designated zoning categories for different parts of the site would not go into effect until after LAFCo approval of the annexation. 3. Prezoning As shown in the attached zoning map, the proposed zoning categories for different portions of the Dalidio site are consistent with the underlying land use categories shown on the LUE map. The map shows that for the total Dalidio project area evaluated in the EIR: the 40 acres of retail is proposed as C-R, Retail Commercial; the 11 acres of residential as R-3, Medium-High Density Residential; and the remainder of the site as C/OS-40, Conservation/Open Space. With the applicant's desire to modify the project to divide it into two separate annexations, the proposed zoning categories set aside for retail and open space within the Commercial Annexation area are still consistent with the general plan. LUE Policy 1.13.3, Required Plans, calls for the master planning of proposed annexation areas so that the City has an adopted plan showing the project layout, required open space protection and provision of streets and utilities. To be consistent with this policy the initial study originally prepared by staff and incorporated into the EIR indicates that it may be necessary to amend the 2-92 ANNX, R, ER 57-98 (D*Property Annexation) Attachment 9 Page 7 Page 7 of 18 proposal to include prezoning the various land uses within the property with the Planned Development (PD) overlay. In lieu of a PD overlay, the property could be prezoned to carry the "S", Special Considerations, overlay. The required use permit with an "S" overlay could be conditioned to require certain improvements and to include an adoption of a master development plan. City decision makers may also determine that the submitted architectural review application allows for adequate review of project master planning. Out of the three choices, staff feels that the "S" zoning is the most relevant to this particular site. The site has many development constraints that seem tailor-made for application of the "S" zoning. Through the adoption of the "S" zoning, the specific considerations to be addressed with review of a master use permit can be identified. The purpose of the "S" zone states that the use permit can be conditioned to assure neighborhood compatibility, look at project compliance with physical site constraints and protect scenic and sensitive site areas. The "PD" zoning is not as applicable to the project since the applicant is not seeking relaxation of property development standards. Therefore, documenting now the reasons for the special considerations of the site and having a master use permit return at a later date seems to be a logical processing strategy. Also with the "PD" zoning, the Commission must make specific findings as to the innovative features of the project that are possible with the proposed "PD" zoning that would not be possible with a conventional zoning category. Some of the special considerations of the retail site that staff has identified are: drainage, flooding protection, urban/agricultural buffers, roadway improvements and design, pedestrian linkages with other comtnercial'developments and nearby residential areas, loading area design, compliance with energy conservation requirements, creek and open space protection, site lighting and preservation of scenic vistas. The "S" zoning seems to have some advantages in terms of timing and project review. The applicant has submitted a development plan booklet which calls out proposed land uses, elaborates on the scale of development envisioned in different areas, describes roadway improvements, and details needed utilities. . The EIR also provides an extensive discussion and analysis of the project and its required improvements. However, as is the case with other annexations, the detail of submitted plans is not sufficient to determine precisely how the physical development of the site will address all of the required mitigation measures. Therefore, it is typical that after certification of the EIR and support for annexation by the City Council and LAFCo, that the applicant will develop more precise plans for further decision maker review. With staff's recommendation for the "S" zoning, those future decision makers would be the Planning Commission who would review the use permit, and the Architectural Review Commission who would review plans as they do for all commercial projects within the City. Given the more schematic nature of submitted plans at this time, the "S" overlay has the advantage of having the ability to defer a review of more specific plans to a later date. One problem with the "PD" zoning is that Section 17.50.010 requires that the "PD" rezoning occur simultaneously with approval of a specific project. This requirement is carred out with the approval of a preliminary development plan along with the rezoning request. Staff would caution against this approach since the Commission may wish to see features of building placement, site circulation and parking lot layout more significantly modified once solutions for complying with approved mitigation measures are known. In staff's opinion, support of a "PD" 2-93 ANNX, R, ER 57-98 (Daftroperty Annexation) Attachment 9 Page $ Page 8 of 18 zoning at this time would require a very significant numbers of conditions, including one that the required final development plan be approved by both the Planning Commission and City Council, rather than the typical administrative review by the Community Development Director. 4. Next Steps Since the project review process is complicated and involves several different entitlements, this section of the report is intended to provide a summary of where the project goes after the Commission's review of it. This discussion also assumes that the project is supported at the various steps described in the process. As discussed in this report, the Commission's review of the Final EIR, annexation and Prezoning are recommendations to the City Council on the project. After the Commission has conducted its public hearing and come to a consensus on a recommendation, the project would be considered for City Council review. With the Council's certification, adoption of a "Resolution of Application" to LAFCo regarding the annexation and adoption of a Prezoning Ordinance, the project would be next forwarded to LAFCo for review and approval. Once the Final EIR has been certified, the City would then begin negotiations with the applicants on a development agreement. Prior to LAFCo's approval of the annexation, the City Council would adopt a resolution accepting the negotiated exchange of property tax revenues and annual tax increment. With approval of the annexation by LAFCo, the project, if supported as recommended by staff with the "S", Special Consideration overlay zoning, would need to return to the Planning Commission for review of a master use permit for the retail component known as The Marketplace. The project would also require final review and approval by the Architectural Review Commission of its site and building design, colors and materials, landscaping, lighting, signage and other details. When all of the requisite project entitlements have been approved, then the City Council would approve a development agreement with the applicants. ALTERNATIVES The EIR identifies seven alternatives to the -submitted project including: 1) a no project alternative; 2) continuance of the site in agricultural use; 3) an alternative site project that incorporates the commercial component into a redeveloped Central Coast Mall; 4) development of the commercial component at the drive-in theater site on the east side of Highway 101; 5) a residential/retail alternative; 6) commercial project with a hotel replacing some retail; and 7) same amount of retail floor area, but smaller overall project area footprint. In forwarding a recommendation on the project to the City Council, the Commission may indicate a preference for one of these alternatives over the submitted project. In addition the Commission may: 1. Deny the project, based on findings. Planning Commission action is final unless appealed to the City Council. Since the proposed prezonings included in the Commercial Annexation are consistent with the Land Use Element map of the General Plan, the Commission would need to make very specific findings as to why annexation and development of the site is not appropriate. The 2-94 ANNX, R, ER 57-98 (D%i Property Annexation) Attachment 9 . Page 9 Page 9 of 18 Commission's action should include a recommendation to the Citv Council to amend the Land Use Element designations of the site to different land use categories if it is deemed that the current designations are no longer appropriate. 2. Continue review with direction to the applicant and staff. OTHER DEPARTMENT COMMENTS The comments and recommendations of various City departments are incorporated into the EIR. RECOMMENDATION A. Recommend to the City Council that the EIR be certified, based on the following findings: Findings I. The Final EIR was prepared in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and was considered by the City prior to any approvals of the project. 2. The Final EIR reflects the independent judgment of the City. 3. For each significant effect identified in the EIR under the categories of Geology, Drainage and Water Quality, Noise, Biological Resources, Cultural Resources, and Land Use, the approved mitigation measures contained in the EIR will avoid or substantially lessen the identified adverse environmental impacts of the project to a level of insignificance and have been incorporated into the project. 4. The significant effects identified in the Air Quality, Agricultural Resources, Aesthetics and Traffic/Circulation sections of the EIR will not be fully mitigated to a degree of insignificance with the incorporation of all of the identified mitigation measures included in the EIR. However, the Planning Commission finds that the adverse environmental effects are acceptable and makes a statement of overriding considerations for those significant and unavoidable environmental impacts because: a. Mitigation strategies help to reduce project emissions to the degree feasible and ultimately put the air basin in closer compliance with established State and federal standards. b. The identified loss of agricultural land is significant and unavoidable, but the impact was previously evaluated and documented in the EIR that was done for the LUE update. The City Council has previously adopted a statement of overriding considerations for this impact on August 23, 1994. The proposed project is part of that previously identified impact and would not result in any additional significant impact beyond the earlier determination. c. The development of the site with a commercial shopping center will significantly affect the character of the site through the alteration of viewsheds from US 101, 2-95 ANNX, R, ER 57-98 (DWroperty Annexation) Page 10 � Attachment 9 Page 10 of 18 Madonna Road, and Los Osos Valley Road. However, mitigation measures that require screening landscaping, detailed design review of the bridge for the highway interchange by the Architectural Review Commission (ARC), and ARC approval of lighting, fenestration and other elements of project design, will help lessen the severity of the impacts on viewsheds. d. Traffic and circulation impacts could be reduced to less than significant under the Existing Baseline Plus Project Scenario with the implementation of mitigation measures identified in the EIR. It is with cumulative development under 10 Year Plus Project Conditions and Buildout Plus Project Conditions that the weaving sections of proposed auxiliary lanes, and the Los Osos Valley Road southbound onramp will experience Level of Service below established thresholds. B. Recommend to the City Council support for the Annexation, with submittal of a "Resolution of Application" to the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCo), based on the following findings: Findings 1. The annexation is appropriate since it is within the City's Urban Reserve Boundary, and the site is contiguous to the City on all sides, except for the southwestern property line. 2. The annexation of the site is a logical addition to the City due to its location in relation to existing urban development. 3. The adopted LUE anticipates the development of the site consistent with project plans and proposed zoning categories. C. Recommend to the City Council that the Prezoning be approved with 40 acres of retail as C-R-S, Retail-Commercial with the Special Consideration overlay zoning; and the remainder of the site as C/OS-40, Conservation/Open Space with 40-acre minimum parcel size, based on the following findings: Findings I. The proposed "S" overlay zoning will document the special considerations for the 40- acre Commercial-Retail portion of the site (C-R-S) which are: drainage, flooding protection, urban/agricultural buffers, roadway improvements and design, pedestrian linkages with other commercial developments and nearby residential areas, loading area design, compliance with energy conservation requirements, creek and open space protection, site lighting and preservation of scenic vistas. 2. The required Planning Commission use permit for development of the commercial area of the site will serve as a master use permit that fulfills the intention of LUE Policy 1.13.3, Required Plans, which calls for the master planning of proposed annexation areas so that the City has an adopted plan showing the project layout, required open space protection and provision of streets and utilities. 2-96 -ANNX, R,.ER 57-98(1)%Property Annexation) Attachment-9 Page.11 Page 11 of 18 Attached: Vicinity, land use, rezoning and annexation:maps; Letter from Bill Bird.dated 6-30-00; . Glossary of Acronyms Previously distributed- Revised Draft EIR and the Addenda and Errata/Comments and Responses Report I_dalidio\57,98=2(K r port).doc 2-97 Attachment 9 Dalido Properly Annexation EIR Page 12 of 18 Section 2.0 Proied Description • l I i I I / I • � San Luis Obispo ,o #4 Project Site • T1 FARM ROAD ' �♦ � zn City of San Luis Obispo 'R ' — WAU i MILES ® Subject Property NORTH Site-Specific Location Fi re 2-2 . City of San Luis bispo 2-3 Attachment 9 Dalidio Property Annexation EIR Page 13 Of 18 godinn 2-0 Protect De4Acripfinn _ El YERCADC 1� -_arnanirAa�mnu,<orrra �_ � ^^aa ' !J0 A li D11. is � \ 44, C-3 C-2 C-1 i `\ LnsaM VAttEr Row v Land Use Acres Percentage of Total Area ' A 40.0 30.5% B 11.1 8.5% A C-1 7.0 5.3% B YEDNYfUDIl OER9TVf1Eb70ElIlIAI C-1 IAWMAI/ MPARKEIMEAMN C-2 53.0 40.5% G2 PEIYAI6ROPEN SPAM C-3 92 7.0% C-3 DttERIYWEN SPACE QAM;e EINE) D 10.7 82% ROADS SOURCE: Cannon Associates o s1P aPoo sr•I c w FEET NORTH Proposed Land Use Plan F�g}�re 2_5 W City of San Luis Obispo 2-9 Dalidio Property Annexation EIR Section 2.0 Project Description ttac en Page 14 of 18 EL MERCADO i - ______' _____-----_ -----_ - --- --•-- --• C-R ' „ ; „ C-R c „ e , / R-3-PD 50 �•. C-OS r • �•�r,� i C-OS Potential collector to t Los 0503 Valley Road SOURCE:Cannon Associates e ,oet SCALE w FEET NORTH LEGEND C-R COMMERCIAL RETAIL R-3-PD MEDIUM-HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL PLANNED DEVELOPMENT OVERLAY C-0S CONSERVATION i OPEN SPACE Proposed Zoning Plan Figure r2.10 City of San Luis Obispo 2-100 Attachment 9 [3a ❑ o . Ir COMMERCIAL �! • Fq ;�" job,��"^'!'�' fi EEWAY/STREET o li • COMMERCIAL • ANNEXATION Y,7 RESIDENTIAL 1`. � ANNEXATION ,J J � r- - Commerical Residential Annexation Annexation Commercial 40.0 acres Residential 11.1 acres Scale: 1 inch = 500 feet Open Space 40.0 acres Future Urban 9.2 acres Freeway/ Freeway/ Street Dedication 8.1 acres Street 2.1 acres Dedication Park 7.0 acres Open Space 13.5 acres Dalidio Annexation Areas Total acres 88.1 Total 42.9 acres 2-101 nAttachment 9 O 6[ 199 Page 16 of 18 o 4 e t C a AECEWEQ JUN 3 0 2000 CI I Y Of SM LUIG 08 Sp0 June 27,2000 COMMUN"DEyELOpMENT Chairman Ready and Members of the San Luis Obispo Planning Commission City of San Luis Obispo 990 Palm Street San Luis Obispo,CA 93401-3249 Re: San Luis Obispo Marketplace Dear Chairman Ready and Members: On July 12 you will be reviewing for approval the EIR, zone change and annexation request in response to our application for development of 40 acres of the Dalidio property. This is a project we have been working on since 1994 when the General Plan was updated to provide for this use. Considering the time this project has been under development, including the very time consuming original EIR and the revised EIR,the Economic Impact Study to evidence the Marketplace project would be a positive long run impact on the downtown,the Memorandum of Understanding that determined how a new Prado Road interchange would be funded,and numerous site plan studies including the formation of a citizens committee to provide input to the architect, we request and will greatly appreciate action being taken at the July 12 meeting. The EIR for this project has been previously reviewed by the Planning Commission a number of times. Two times for the public comment meeting and one public hearing last December,when we requested a continuance after learning abut a potential conflict regarding Mayor Settle. Any consideration of a continuance is not appropriate in this case and we look forward to your vote,at the conclusion of the public hearing on July 12. Based on community wide response supporting the need for greater shopping opportunities and the Prado Road interchange, your support of this development would appear justified plus this is a development that is in conformance of the General Plan. Your thoughtful consideration of this request is greatly appreciated. Sincerely, William Bird SAN LUIS OBISPO MARKETPLACE ASSOCIATES LLC•510 SOUTH GRAND AVENUE SUITE 3(2-102 GLENDORA CALIFORNIA 91741•PHONE(626)963-1505 FAX(626)963-5930 GLOASSARY OF ACRONYM,- Attachment 9 . ALUP Airport Land Use Plan Page 17 of 18 APCD Air Pollution Control District APN Assessor's Parcel Number ARC Architectural Review Commission BMP Best Management Practices CAP Clean Air Plan CARB California Air Resources Board CBACT Best Available Control Technology CDFG California Department of Fish and Game CDMG California Division of Mines and Geology CE California Endangered CEQA California Environmental Quality Act CFP California Fully Protected Species CNDDB California Natural Diversity Database CNEL Community Noise Equivalent Level CNG Compressed Natural Gas CNPS California Native Plant Society CO Carbon Monoxide CSC California Species of Special Concern dB Decibels DEIR Draft Environmental Impact Report DPR California Department of Parks and Recreation EIR Environmental Impact Report EPA Environmental Protection Agency ESA Environmental Site Assessment EV Electric Vehicle FAC+ Facultative+ Wetland Species FACW Facultative Wetland FC Federal Candidate FE Federal Endangered FEIR Final Environmental Impact Report FEMA Federal Emergency Management Agency FICON Federal Interagency Committee on Noise FIRM Federal Emergency Management Agency Flood Insurance Rate Map FPE Federal Proposed Endangered FSC Federal Species of Concern GLA Gross Leaseable Area LAFCO Local Agency Formation Commission Ldn Day-Night Average Level Leq Equivalent Noise Level 2-103 LOMR Letter of Map Revision (Federal Emergency Management Agency) Attachment 9 LOVR Los Osos Valley Road Page 18 of 18 LUE General Plan Land Use Element MBTA Migratory Bird Treaty Act MCLS Maximum Contaminant Levels MLD Most Likely Descendent MSL Mean Sea Level NAHC Native American Heritage Commission ND Negative Declaration NMFS National Marine Fisheries Service NOI Notice of Intent NOP Notice of Preparation NOx Nitrogen Oxides NPDES National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System OBL Obligate Wetland Species OS Open Space PCE Tetrachloroethylene PMI0 10 Micron Suspended Particulates PM2.5 2.5 Micron Suspended Particulates ROC Reactive Organic Carbon ROG Reactive Organic Gases SAY Safe Annual Yield (Water Resources) SLO San Luis Obispo SO2 Sulfur Dioxide sox Sulfur Oxides SWPPP Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan SWRCB State Water Resources Control Board UBC Uniform Building Code UCSB University of California,Santa Barbara US101 U.S. Highway 101 USACE U.S. Department of the Army,Corps of Engineers USDA U.S. Department of Agriculture USFWS U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service USGS U.S. Geological Survey VTM Vesting Tentative Tract Map WRF Water Reclamation Facility 2-104