The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About05/02/2006, C3 - REQUEST TO REMOVE A PROPERTY AT 969 MONTEREY STREET FROM THE MASTER LIST OF HISTORIC RESOURCES (ARC council j ac,Enaa REpom e CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO FROM: John Mandeville, Community Development Direc�? Prepared By: Whitney McIlvaine, Contract Planner SUBJECT: REQUEST TO REMOVE A PROPERTY AT 969 MONTEREY STREET FROM THE MASTER LIST OF HISTORIC RESOURCES (ARC 166-02) CAO RECOMMENDATION Adopt a resolution removing the property at 969 Monterey Street from the Master List of Historic Resources, as recommended by the Cultural Heritage Committee. DISCUSSION A new building is now under construction at 969 Monterey Street that replaces the historic Loobliner building, a property that has been included on the City's Master List of Historic Resources. Properties are added to the Master List by resolution of the City Council after considering the recommendations of the Cultural Heritage Committee (CHC). In this case, the historic resource was an un-reinforced masonry building. It was approved for demolition in August of 2004, based on structural re-evaluation after the San Simeon earthquake, which occurred in December, 2003. The new fagade will contain many of the elements of the historic building's original architecture. However, as a totally new structure, it no longer meets the eligibility standards for historic listing. Therefore, at a meeting on November 28, 2005, the CHC recommended that the City Council remove the property from the Master List. Data.Summa" Address: 969 Monterey Street Property Owners: Steve and Rosalyn Carroll Zoning: C-C-H; Central Commercial with the Historic Preservation overlay zone General Plan: General Retail ALTERNATIVES 1. Continue with direction. Retaining the building on the Master List of Historic Resources would not be consistent with the City's Historical Preservation Program Guidelines. � n Removal of 969 Monterey St.from the Master List Page 2 ATTACHMENTS 1. Vicinity map .2. Notice of CHC action 3. Photo of the original Loobliner building 4. Photos of the building before demolition 5. Drawing of the approved fagade for the new building at 969 Monterey 6. Draft resolution YWCGARC166-02 LoobGner..... c3 - z- PF-H O-H - 0 Attachment 1 i R-4 PF-H (' PF-H P�,tr Q C-C-H C-C C-C-H C-C-H °s C-C-H kyt� �f C-C O� C-C- C-C-H ��GJ C-C-H C-C C-C 0 C-C- �P�y� C-C -C- C-C O VICINITY MAP ARC 166-02 N A 969 Monterey IIIIIIIII [I I� I Cityo san l�,s ®��s�pos 990 Patin Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 December 2, 2005 Attachment 2 Steve & Rosalyn Carroll 2653 Victoria Avenue San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 SUBJECT: CHC/ARC 166-02: 969 Monterey Street Request to remove a property from the Master List of Historic Properties Dear Mr. and Ms. Carroll: The Cultural Heritage Committee, at its meeting of November 28, 2005, recommended that the City Council remove the property from the Master List of Historic Resources with the added recommendation that the applicant for the property's redevelopment provide a historic plaque which would commemorate the former Loobliner Building, based on the following findings: 1. The Committee had previously determined the property no longer met the eligibility standards for historic listing and consequently, that it was not historically significant; and 2. The former Loobliner Building, for which the property was designated historic, has been demolished. The decision of the CHC is a recommendation to the City Council and, therefore, is not final. This matter will be scheduled for a public hearing before the City Council in the near future. You will be notified of the hearing date. If you have questions, please contact.Pam Ricci at(805) 781-7168. Sincerely, cc: Pierre Rademaker Design 738 Higuera Street, Suite F SLO, CA 93401 Michael Dra Deputy Community Development Director Leslie Naman Long Range Planning 2656 SW Vista Avenue Portland, OR 97201 cc: County of SLO Assessor's Office OThe City of San Luis Obispo is committed to include the disabled in all of its services,programs and activities. / �� Telecommunications Device for the beif(805)781-7410. Attachment 3 �I l ��y �. o Elul ►r Moo p m a , ONO folk r o w took o .. �.,► -All 33 "�. C� 4 i w i� II d 's C. -a�,,., 2♦ t a 1— n. 1 Ma. '4�l�va.o-• . ■ rrrrr.rrrrr�.rr r.rr rr rrr rrrirrrr rrrirrrrrr j I'I'I'I'I'1'1'I'I'1'I'I'I'PI'1'I'PI'I'I'1'I'I'1'I'1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 I .I I ■ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!111!1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111II111111111111111111 ❑I� IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII .111111111111111111 111111111111111111111111 Illlllllllllllllllllllllllllllr!� _'_ i 1111111,1,111111111111111111111111111,1,41,Ir!'" 11111111111111111141111111111111111111111111111h1d,lila .1111111111111111 � uiiii ■ 111,41 LLLLLLLLIJ,LLI .,�� IIIIIIIIIILI,Li dJ,I,LLLLLLLI,L-f;<7� 'f111111111111111 I 1 uuu �� 111 i �� 1111111II �I ,1111111 111111 �` ■ 111'1` _ � � '1111111111'I'I � � � 1111111111111 uuml � 111111 IIIIIIIIIIIIIII '1111111111111 IIII ® ® � 111111111111111 11111 I I ---- '�— ■ 11'1'11 'I'I'I'I'I'1'I'I'I'I'I'I'�[�� 1111111111111'I'll.l'I'I'I'I'I'I'I'I'I'I'I'IT�j I IIIIIIIIIIIIIII - ■ 1111111j11111111111111111111111111111I'114', i111111111111111111h'111111111111111111111111111'14'I'Ih' 11111111111111111 IIIIIIIII1111111111111I111IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIllj.1111111111111111I1111H I11111111111I111I1111111�1111111111111114j1111111111111111111 •�I�I 41i1i1i4lililildiilili�iliililii4i1i1ili1iliiililyyili ■ 11111111111I1111111111111II'1111111'11111111111j�I111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111'11,x,,111111111111111111 ig r-..�' ■ III I I1111111111I:SRI `11111111111111111x1,111111111111111111111111111.LLLLj 41111111111111111 �o�„y I l.li� LLLI I L1.1.1�1.1.1.�'� � 11 I I I I 1 I G LLLLLLLLLLLLI=O ,11 1 1 1 1 1 1 man ■ VIII 41111111'jlil 11111111111111 ■ Irr rl ! � � ,�I� �r11111d!9p!II� �I� � 1111111111111 '11191'! 111111 ,� II, --�`.1 1•:i..I IIIIQ� ,111111 � I INM 4'111'111111.. A'� �, ` 'Ihhllyllh 111111 1111111 lot 11 1111111115'I I j1� 111111111111i1pju�„!'I'I i I IlII! jl'I!I!i`— j (IIIIIIIIIIIIIII i11111I111'I'I�!!IIIil41ii,1 1 1 1 1 1111 ,1 I I I I I I I I i 11111111111111111j1j1j111111111111111111111,�!j•i, I'I I,I! V I I I i,I,11.1-,�I I I I I �I ' '�� ! 1111111111111111I11111111111111111111!IpIPl11;!i.IP1111L!ii!ii!j'111111111111111VI1�Illo!jauLL111111111111111j111111111111111111 �I�,�ifi.i ■ �IRill li�l�llli!I'I I'll!1111!!Illllllljl�illlj!fill!i�ij�i!��il�!�lili!111111!1111111;i;1!11! !11111!11111IlIlIlIlI11111I11111111 i II�IIlii11,Y11111111111111111„Ili' I'I'11111i'i'�1'i1111111111j11'I'I ii1i11111111111 I'14111111�1111'!I��I!111111111111111111 _ 1 - I ■� 1144 LI1�11111111111111,1i1111�111.1.1•!/ \�\i�ll,l' ,11!1 1111111 illllllll I � �I�1 111:•a ..11.1111.:11.1 L.C�, / III•.,14L':.!:r141d,1 V I I 111, 1 i. IIII 1111 immu, rl�jll�' '1. Ilrlr�.. (/I��`\1',111 f1 „111.1.1.11 j 11111111111111 umu, \ ■ r �� ",. i. r-T '� IIIIIIII Mile” �il 111'1' �i�� . d/i 'lil�l11h41 ■��.r.�I ,1111111 ul I'1 :I'll;alll�l 'il��l�1 ■� 111111111111 i Irl,!6LIJ'I—� III 11 I I 1 111111' ��;. _ ,..n/� � \I► urn.. —,L7 �� j1111111111111 um- -,�� . -ilii:.iljljl�PljljljljijijijPi�”.mT!I�II�Illiiiili�y�:!i�!i,mrnrr.c..iry l�l.:r� 1111111111111111 I � ;111'1'1'1'1{111!1"III 1 i�I�liljlll�l�llild!it 11'1!11 I'I Illl�l il:�!ili'!'Ii1,11111L.11��11,1'''!��III11111111IIIIII IIII\L'"I!1!1!l�liliilili1111111i1ro!lliliI!! j!11!1!' !:%x1!I!Illjlilll�!111111i11111ilillCrli�!:,i'�!illlililllllllllll NJ o . Attachment 6 Draft Resolution - - --- RESOLUTION NO. (2006 Series) A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO REMOVING THE PROPERTY AT 969 MONTEREY STREET FROM THE MASTER LIST OF HISTORIC RESOURCES (ARC 166-02) WHEREAS on December 16, 2002, the Architectural Review Commission granted final approval to a proposed third floor addition and extensive remodel of the building at 969 Monterey Street; and WHEREAS on June 28, 2004, the Cultural Heritage reviewed and approved modifications to the previously approved project, including the full demolition of the existing un- reinforced masonry building at 969 Monterey Street in light of a structural evaluation following the December, 2003 San Simeon earthquake, subject to photographic and historic documentation and archaeological monitoring of the demolition; and WHEREAS on February 2, 2005, the Chief Building Official issued a demolition permit; and WHEREAS on November 28, 2005, the Cultural Heritage Committee recommended that the City Council remove the property at 969 Monterey Street from the Master List of Historic Resources: BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of San Luis Obispo as follows: SECTION 1. Findings. That this Council, after consideration of the Cultural Heritage Committee's recommendation to remove the property at 969 Monterey Street from the Master List of Historic resources, public testimony, staff recommendations and reports thereon, finds that: a. The property at 969 Monterey Street no longer meets the eligibility standards for historic listing, and consequently, is not historically significant. b. The former Loobliner Building, for which the property was designated historic, has been demolished. SECTION 2. Action. The Historical Preservation Program Guidelines are hereby amended to delete the address "969 Monterey" from the Master List of.Historic Resources as shown in Exhibit A. Attachment 6 Resolution No. (2006 Series) Page 2 On motion of seconded by , and on the following roll call vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: The foregoing resolution was passed and adopted this 2nd day of May 2006. Mayor David F. Romero ATTEST: City Clerk Audrey Hooper APPROVED: City rney Jonathan Lowell WM/RESO/de-listing 969 Monterey... Exhibit A MASTER LIST OF HISTORIC RESOURCES 1145 Marsh 0060-04R 1160 Marsh 0126-03C 1167 Marsh 0061-05R 1305 Marsh 0062-05R 1266 Mill 0063-04R Mill Street 1306 Mill 0064-04R Mill Street 1330 Mill 0065-05R Mill Street 1424 Mill 006605R 1460 Mill 0067-04R 642 Monterey 0068-03R Downtown 664 Monterey 0069-04R Downtown 696 Monterey 0128-030 Downtown 747 Monterey 0070-030 Downtown 848 Monterey 0129-05C Downtown 849 Monterey 0130-03C Downtown . 868-70 Monterey 0131-03C Downtown 951-65 Monterey 0132-05C Downtown 962 Monterey 0133-05C Downtown • 960 MmAer 0194 ASC Oe m—tewm 978-98 Monterey 0135-03C Downtown 1035 Monterey 0136-03C Downtown 1815 Monterey 0137-03C 2223 Monterey 0138-03C 1406 Morro 0071-04R Old Town 1624 Morro 0072-04R Old Town 1636 Morro 0073-04R Old Town 1642 Morro 0074-04R. Old Town 991 Nipomo 0139-06C Downtown 1015 Nipomo 0140-05C Downtown 1204 Nipomo 0075-05R 1344'Nipomo 0141-030 Old Town 1407 Nipomo 0076-04R Old Town 1428 Nipomo 6077-05R Old Town 1446 Nipomo 0078-05R, Old Town 890 Osos 0079-04R Downtown 976 Osos (980 Osos) 0142-040 Downtown 1301 Osos 0143-030 1443 Osos 0080-03R Old Town 1706 Osos 0081-05R Old Town 1716 Osos 0082-04R Old Town 1815 Osos 0144-05C Old Town 863 Pacific 0145-04C 1106 Pacific 0146-03C 1185 Pacific :00W-030 800 Palm 0147-03C Downtown 1144 Palm 0084-03R *SerialNumber. 0000- 0 0 X Sequential National Register Bating Type of Strnoture Number 1=Already placed on the National Register R=Residential 2=Determined eligible for the National Register C= Commercial S=Eligible for the National Register O=Other A /v 4=Potentially eH&le for the.National Register 5=Not eligible for the National Register but significant at a local level