Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout10/16/2007, STUDY SESSION 1 - SUCCESSION PLANNING: PREPARING THE NEXT GENERATION 1 councit MceingD.m o j1 acEnaa nepont CITY OF SAN LUIS OBI S PO FROM: Shelly Stanwyck, ACAO Monica Irons, Human Resources Director Prepared By: April Richardson, Administrative Assistant Rachael Hendricks, Human Resources Analyst SUBJECT: SUCCESSION PLANNING: PREPARING THE NEXT GENERATION CAO RECOMMENDATION Receive a report and presentation on the topic of succession planning and endorse the efforts underway to create a more formal program for the City. REPORT IN BRIEF One of the most significant issues facing cities and other public and private organizations is a shrinking pool of talent from which to draw the next generation of the workforce. Therefore, as recognized by Council and staff, succession planning is an important undertaking for our organization. Although the community and Council share a vision of San Luis Obispo as a unique and special place, unfortunately, when it comes to workforce demographics we are just like other communities in facing an upcoming crisis in the supply of sufficiently skilled and talented employees. With this Study Session, the City is embarking on its journey toward developing a more formal Succession Planning program. The kick-off of this organization wide effort begins with the Council Study Session followed the next day by a training session with the managers and a succession planning committee. At both, nationally known expert on this topic, Frank Benest, City Manager of Palo Alto, is serving as the featured speaker. The expected short-term outcome from these efforts is to bring greater structure and strategy to our program. The longer-term efforts include creation of a plan which when executed will result in an organization that is prepared to continue to provide excellent service because it has the workforce to do so. DISCUSSION Introduction The City, along with other public agencies and businesses, is at a critical juncture in the continued development of one of its most important resources — its employees. Just as the community and Council plan for the community's future through the General Plan and specific s51 - I i Succession Planning: Preparing the Next Generation Page 2 plans for infrastructure, the City must plan for its operational future by further developing its workforce. Who is the Next Generation? The next generation refers generally to the talent pool of potential employees who are available to fill future organizational needs. The next generation is not age specific. Presently four distinct generations (Baby Boomers, Generation X, Generation Y, and the Millenials) comprise the workforce. It is critical to understand the values of each in order to effectively manage and leverage their talents. Preparing the next generation involves developing skills of existing employees, increasing efficiencies, using contingent workforces, re-engaging retirees, offering more flexible work schedules, and creating opportunities for students and younger workers. What is Succession Planning? Succession Planning is more than simply having a plan to replace positions that become vacant; it is an ongoing process of identifying, assessing, and developing talent to ensure employee continuity. Although this may sound easy, organizations across the world are struggling with this crisis. Succession planning ensures that an organization will anticipate the future needs of its customers, the required skill sets of employees, and have the ability to attract and retain those skilled employees to fulfill customers' needs. The process of establishing systematic succession planning is the equivalent of making a long-term culture change. For example, in an organization where decision-makers have been accustomed to filling one vacancy at a time, a succession plan requires broader and more strategic thinking. Most experts agree it is important to move sequentially through four phases to effectively develop and implement a succession plan. Those four phases are: 1. Assessment. Develop a comprehensive understanding of an organization's demographics and resources with a commitment to address identified "shortages." Positions where "successors" will be needed and the competencies necessary to fill those positions are identified. Current human resources programs and practices should be evaluated to ensure that they can be implemented with the succession plan. 2. Development of a Plan. Establish succession planning objectives and resources, create a communication plan, formalize the succession planning selection process, and define measures of plan success. 3. Implementation. The organization's succession plan is implemented (this may occur over time and/or in phases). 4. Monitoring and Revision. Using the plan's measures of success, evaluate plan programs using mechanisms, which include feedback. If necessary adjust programs based on evaluation results. Why this? Why now? Professionals in both the public and private sector agree that workforce succession planning is critical to public and private entities during the next two decades. The majority of the workforce Ss I - a i Succession Planning: Preparing the Next Generation Page 3 will be of retirement age in the next 20 years. Adding to this challenge is the fact that the population to replace these Baby Boomers is much reduced. I. Demographic Crisis Local government is potentially facing a demographic crisis in management leadership. As 80 million Baby Boomers (those born between 1946 and 1964) retire throughout the U.S., there are only 50 million Gen Xers (1965-1977) available to fill these positions. As a result�a significant gap in workforce supply is emerging. This is especially problematic in the public sector where there is a higher level of older employees than in private industry. Nationwide, over 46% of local government employees are 45 years or older. This is compared with the private sector, where just 31.2% are 45 years and older. Some have concluded that the government sector is at the forefront of this trend (The Mejorando Group, Succession Planning Proposal). While the issues below do not necessarily apply to the City (at least presently), the literature often identifies organizational challenges such as: a. The perceived lack of rewards for increasingly difficult jobs. Jobs are becoming increasingly complex, and for some the compensation and benefits are not perceived to be adequate exchange for the level of difficulty. b. Differing values. When surveyed, Generation X and Y employees often identify a desire for a balanced lifestyle. Many state a perception that those "above them" are often "consumed by work and do not have time for family and other pursuits". In analyzing length of employment trends, many members of the workforce from Generations X and Y follow a pattern of shorter-term employment - for an average of only two to three years. c. The lack of time for local government to grow their talent. As public sector agencies have responded to shrinking financial resources by functioning with fewer employees there have been fewer opportunities to cross train employees due to time constraints. Many junior workers have been unable to gain the experiences necessary to qualify for upper management positions now being vacated by Baby Boomers. d. Shift in attraction to Public Service. For many just entering the workforce, government is not listed as the "employer of choice". Unfortunately, many governmental jobs are incorrectly viewed as not being"exciting" or technology based. 2. SL Demographics The City conducted a workforce analysis(Attachment 1) and invited consultant Patrick Ibarra of the Mejoranda Group to discuss succession planning with the management team in 2006. We found that the City's demographics mirror those of many other public sector agencies. The City regular employee pool as of July 2007 consists of approximately 350 members. The demographics of the employee group and the urgency for action are exemplified in the following statistics all based on age: a. 69 employees are currently eligible for retirement. SSI - 3 Succession Planning: Preparing the Next Generation Page 4 b. 68 additional employees will be eligible to retire in the next 5 years. c. 6 of the 12 current Department Heads are either presently eligible for retirement or will be within the next five years. As of July 2007, 24% of the City's 350 full time employees are eligible for retirement. Another 15% will be of retirement age in the next 5 years. The attached organizational charts (Attachment 2) depict expected vacancies due to retirements during the next five years. Some of the more sobering statistics are found in the Fire Department, which is expecting almost complete turnover of its senior management, three Battalion Chiefs, during the next two years. The Utilities and Public Works Departments both have over 50% of departmental workers eligible for retirement in the next five years. As follow up to the Mejoranda Group's workshop, the Department Head Team discussed the demographics and identified three main concerns: 1) a shrinking pool from which to draw applicants; 2) the loss of institutional knowledge; and 3) the City's ability to prepare its existing employees for the"next level" within the City. 3. Some Recent Examples of Recruitment and Retention Challenges at the City. In recent years, the City has experienced difficulty replacing workers in a wide variety of positions. In general, the numbers of applicants for most positions are significantly lower than they were ten years ago. Many City positions require pre-employment skills testing or certifications that may deter applicants who lack those pre-requisites. Following are three recent examples of specific situations in which recruitment and retention has been particularly difficult: a. Supervising Civil Engineer. This position is responsible for the engineering development review process. The most recent incumbent resigned in August 2005 to accept a job in the private sector for an increased salary. Staff immediately recruited and was only able to develop a small eligibility list. An offer to the only strong candidate from the list was declined. In July 2006, the City re-hired the departed employee, who resigned again only a few months later to accept a higher paying job at another local City. Staff went through yet another recruitment, and made yet another offer, which was declined because of insufficient salary. Today, the position remains unfilled. b. Water Treatment Plant Operator. The City has recruited seven times in five years for Water Treatment Plant Operators. In March 2007, three offers were made and only one candidate accepted. c. Lateral Police Officers. The City uses an `open until filled" approach in recruiting `'lateral" police officers, due to heavy statewide competition for experienced officers. When positions are open, the City, on average, conducts interviews quarterly as a result of its receiving only about one application per month, which is very low. Significantly, statewide, agencies are anticipated to need 68,000 police officers between 2002 and 2012. In response, many California agencies now even advertise on billboards and by using bumper stickers. Succession Planning: Preparing the Next Generation Page 5 Current Programs and Practices The City has many established programs and practices which support succession planning — it just hasn't labeled them as such. As a Succession Plan is developed for the organization some of these programs will need modification, and will need to be more strategically interwoven into a formal plan. 1. Outreach to Potential Employees Human Resources has been working with other departments to improve recruitment material with the intent of better marketing the City to potential employees by using a more-a personal touch, e.g., targeted letters to potential employees who have required certificates. The City also has an excellent relationship with local high schools and Administration (increasingly accompanied by staff from other departments) regularly visits high school classes to present careers in local government. By reaching out to high school students, the City is promoting public service and putting a personal face on local government. 2. Volunteers and Interns The City makes good use of volunteers and interns. The City's Water Reclamation Facility has used volunteers for several years in the laboratory, eventually training individuals to be eligible to become Laboratory Analysts. Internships are regularly offered in Administration, Community Development, Public Works, Utilities, and Human Resources for Cuesta and Cal Poly students and have resulted in several instances where the City has "grown its own" employees. 3. Employment Opportunity Program The Employment Opportunity Program (EOP) is a City created program. It allows City employees to apply for full-time opportunities internally before the general public. During the past two years, more than 29 employees have changed positions as a result of the EOP. This program was showcased in the International City Management Association's (ICMA) book, Local Governments Preparing for the Next Generation — Successful Case Studies (Attachment 3). 4. Retention of Institutional Knowledge Continuity and longevity in public service often result in high service levels and an accumulation of invaluable institutional knowledge. When long-term employees leave for other employers, they typically provide two to four weeks notice, making knowledge transfer difficult. Many departments are asking upcoming retirees to document as much institutional knowledge as possible prior to leaving the City. This involves detailed "desk manuals", "lessons learned", and contact information. S. Mentoring Program The City developed a formal internal mentoring program in 1999 and a handful of employees initially participated, all resulting in job advancement within the City. However, today, informal mentoring is more prevalent with several employees being selected for new roles in the City after being informally mentored. This program should be reviewed to ensure the City retains what is working on an informal level, while at the same time accomplishing the objectives of the more formal program that is accessible and far-reaching. Succession Planning: Preparing the Next Generation Page 6 6. Use of Retirees During the past few years, the City has made an effort to keep retirees engaged through part-time work, fill-in for temporary absences, or work on short-term projects. This has been an effective way to supplement the City's full-time workforce with retirees needing little training and possessing expertise and, in several cases, institutional knowledge. Two current examples include retired Senior Analyst, Sue Baasch, who continues to work on special projects for the Utilities and Human Resources Departments. Another example is Les Evans, a former City Manager who is "helping out" the Public Works Department in the area of engineering development review. 7.Education and Training a. Educational Reimbursement. The City's educational assistance program reimburses up to $1,200 per year for job related courses at accredited institutions. In the last two years, 16 employees have participated in the program for a total reimbursement of$11,004. b. New Professional Development Classes. The City of San Luis Obispo Professional Association for City Employees (PACE) has recently partnered with Cuesta College to offer professional development courses such as Communication, Decision Making, Management and Supervision, and Teambuilding. Since the introduction of these classes a mere six months ago, 59 employees have completed these classes to rave reviews. c. On-going Training. The California Joint Powers Insurance Authority (CJPIA) offers a wide variety of high-quality training. Courses in safety, communications, and supervision are regularly offered onsite to City employees. The CJPIA also offers specific "academies" in leadership, human resources management, public works, and parks and recreation that provide a foundation for employees seeking advancement in those fields or looking to broaden their knowledge base. d. ICMA Teleconferences and Discussion. The City participates in the ICMA Next Generation teleconference trainings. Topics covered range from leadership to advances in information technology to advancing or reinvigorating one's career in local government. Post panel discussions facilitated by Department Heads are aimed at encouraging cross-departmental discussions and sharing best practices. Next Steps As described above, the City has a wide variety of programs and practices in place that are a part of succession planning and has much to work with as its efforts mature and develop more structure. During the Study Session, Mr. Benest, will place the City's present efforts in a larger context and discuss programs that have been effective in his City and in organizations that are further down the road than ours. Following this Study Session, Administration, in partnership with the Human Resources Department will initiate an organization wide effort to prepare the next generation of the City's workforce. A Succession Planning Committee has been formed to provide insight and input by employees "from all walks of City life" (Attachment 4) and together with managers, Mr. Benest SSI - 0 Succession Planning: Preparing the Next Generation Page 7 will be conducting a training session on October 17`h. As programs are developed, implemented, and updated, committee members will provide feedback on their effectiveness. Thus far, five priorities have emerged from initial work and discussions on succession planning: 1) creation of a communication program; 2) creation of an employee university; 3) marketing the City as an "employer of choice"; 4) identifying career ladders, and 5) programs to develop competencies. Examples of the kinds of initiatives that may emerge under these areas include: 1. Communication Program. A web-based application that allows employees to view all training and succession planning opportunities is expected to be identified as a need. The City of Santa Barbara is using "off the self technology"to accomplish this objective and is likely to be a model. 2. Employee University Human Resources is currently researching an Employee University and it is likely all training opportunities will be presented to employees under this umbrella. Again, it will be web-based, promoted through the communications program's outreach efforts, and will include on-line registration opportunities. 3. Marketing the City as an Employer of Choice Enhanced marketing efforts can highlight innovative aspects of working for the City. Areas like conservation, wellness, and quality of life can be better promoted. 4. Career Ladders Positions where there is a natural progression through similar job classifications from entry level to senior management may be identified. 5. Competency Development The combination of knowledge, skills, abilities, and attitudes needed to be successful in a job are called "competencies". By better identifying job competencies employees and the City can tailor training programs to benefit employees and further develop their competencies in preparation for their next position. Conclusion The City is at a critical juncture in its future staffing ability. Without a formalized plan for retention and recruitment, the City risks the loss of institutional knowledge, the ability to develop core competencies for key positions, and the ability to effectively recruit and develop talent. Succession Planning: Preparing the Next Generation is an effort to address these and other related issues. The goal of the program is to keep the City vital and viable in a competitive job market. Upon creation of a formal plan, anticipated in nine to 12 months, staff will return to Council to provide an update and acquire further direction as appropriate. SS Succession Planning: Preparing the Next Generation Page 8 FISCAL IMPACT The Human Resources Department has a budget of$25,000 for succession planning efforts in the 2007-09 financial plan. This amount will be sufficient to begin to address the immediate priorities identified above. Added funds may be needed in the future. ATTACHMENTS 1. Workforce Analysis 2. Departmental Organization Charts with Retirement Eligibility Based on Age 3. Local Governments Preparing for the Next Generation — Successful Case Studies (San Luis Obispo) 4. Succession Planning Committee G:\Projects & Programs\Succession Planning\Next Gen CAR 10-07 SS l-� ATTACHMENT 1 _ J co co CD N F d` N LO O O ti 0 co' CO O ti N O r M co t O M 00 1` w �t J in r NLO c in O ti O O r V � � L _ O w 1` N LA y� N h CO ti IrmL 0 O Irmo M O J E a aE 0 L co cf) m v v a H aM o ATTACHMENT 2 Organizational Chart Key The following organizational charts illustrate employees that are currently or will become eligible to retire in the next five years based on age. While this does not necessarily mean the employees will retire, the charts illustrate the challenge that virtually all departments face in the coming years. The possible retirees are indicated by the following: 55 - i o .g ATTACHMENT 2 cn W Z HM o NOO U � crW a . ' ac o � 3 � ori 0 0 LLI Q � 2 Z LU F Z G p0 V c o N Q 00 ® o 0 LU mG H En ao a � 0U _j LU O 0IL) > 8 Q. LU aornl0 O NV CA O v � "Q SS1 - I ��'� ATTAMIENT 2 N w o E .y � a o a e Z w ® a: .� LL O W Z > e N Cl) �' o o, Z oo wz m _ a cl � � a U ' c � _ a O CL ; cn L � O � v v� �- i A.TTACHMEWr 2 a p,j w = c Z oZC N +0 ® O 'c a v O u O O � � C= V v� SSI - 13 ATTACHMENT 2 C � � � ._ CA ME CA as Y LU Ix J U IMMMM � U O — > � O ._ CA Cc — *MdN ccO � � a VCA a , SSI - 14 P.TTACHMENT 2 ° 00 t C ° V M a o m C z W 2 CL Z ® W N J a W 0 IM w � •' ° i 0 m d W W O o a G p C U) C G V cm CL U o N ca 'N ca Z g C G a ) ° O :3 L -, Lca 0 cc 0 yr C o C o r N W N W a � � c o a a � 5Sf - IS ATTACHPPEMT 2 � e o 0 c ® O O O y y Z C ' 8 V Na Ana W c1 cE- Z O OC O Z Z CM= IM= I,— cm Jilt c �, c �, c .• c .• LU c � � / � • O N O y O y O y VZ as as as Qa O � O cam. — O � ca _ (a_ �6 CL o a • 02 o y QN QQ Qa i� ss i-d o i Ki IRCHFUNT 2 c m m c m c m mcc CU . o x G Of mca ca z cc Z ca O7 Q C • W I1 U- LL W Li 0 . ` 5� O O 0 m Q a. C mrrvia) N N m m C . m W O ' C C m c O1 C 07 � ) m ( Cm cc m C CV � W WLL LU .!LL:: LU .!LL= LL W L 0 Li O Q CD C LL , ® O e m m m m o C C C m C �� C O) O e •�•�F • •�� a •� • •�� Q W W jy W LL W LL W j � r N co � --- cn Q o C C C C O O O 222SSS o ca co cz co \"W a 05 } ATTACHL!ENT 2 a , • LU c Z D a U w O • mC Ir O Z V CQ C D O m � NN O • � a O � U v� SS1 -f�5 /I L J O N pj� �p a'y •i C d E N E y 'h 1ACHMEN f 2 N '— 0 O d O N aCiVN aN dy m = L L N .. .. « O O i y N R l�6 E E W 0) N i /0 cc l0 i C C E .OI z CD � o U 0 91 0 C. m � om aU) a (n Uro U4) C ¢ HN Y Y C I a CD �o = L � C �Cc C O Y tO W L N R d m d m d L J J ® C C_ N d V W 3 E Q C > Q N Q M L C d 9 LLINV ® S = It U as W = 0 0 I ow y p L C O L i 0 U 7 Y `n L w li11 litC W > E N = W L R L R O d O O O L CL O mV C. am �1 N L Q W .0 0 0 E y � t0 — . G' ca i V CLL d O 0 m0:5 as a� V u� W O N E y r 00 '> R _R V i d Gd V U. 0 = a` y n1v�L .6N T d L L L Y L L d d d d F • W ~ eO000000 Y L V V 0 E E 000 7 C C W Q EV c E a a c W _a a a ' Y x Y Y • d d d d C) UUV 'L* V Q o o c o V V o V E CL ® 0000 0L L L L L L L L L L L L 000000 0000000000000 O CL o V V V O GN 000 a � cm CD v � Gl N 1000000000000 .0-0 V01 0 u 0 0 00J Vd 0 0 0 SSS= C i N ATTA0NmE.Rp 2 � N Q LL cL L O 0 � N d C C r C C C C � 3 �o — we ai LU ®^, 0 � c ~ a w w W N d c ¢ Q1 F aci ® Lc L —_ O� O O Cf d = = o t _ �ca *E � c c w rn o� .� N V W W a � a O e • CL " y VY/ L ° L L L Y � . c m � dE Cyd Oo '- 0 LU V •v o = = ae - - - d d d W d 16 d Y Y w i X Yp � � 0 0 X33 a d a U'n V cTIL _ L - - W C NQ O O • F . 0 CD L L L L Y Y Y Y Ol Vd 3 t 0 0 0 0 0 0 W ZL Q ,O 0 W •L a � v Q� ay ayLU O L H IM0 LU L L - U CL `o c N 0 W W W !L U ssi -ai P-71 TA lif-i!-r,T 2 C C R O o. 0 U C m l�4 Y • Q i r d M0) O > a 3 y d Q Gcc Co L d d C a1 E R � o IL M 0Gi A 0) E 0`1 aR v a °' 0 o .a - G 0O w CL C13 �� e — �' Q ) a s . . ca �C M m v 00 085 U w CL m p U V :3w R ® a > d . R m .> _ m � L 01 � N 0 o � rn CCL Un •= t7 v� to (n v) E c7 c7 c7 � 0 G d CC C R W 330 — o � LL <� a v � SS 1 L - ' P T,TACFME T 2 O L O N N C N N y 7 W 7 W C. C p C 3 C U L L Y Y Y Y d .,�. Q L LC W ed W !0 W W J c c c c� aaaa Y N co CL� d D Y • C V L L Y IL CL CL 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 W C� N c d W Y • LL L L L L L L Mp/ Y M w W W W W W W W W L L L L L L L L d d W G! d d d d as C. a c. aaa L 00000000 Co Y c c w dd N O V V V V • M •p. ..p. V 40 . C . W W W W W 3 y L p m d G1 d 01 G> O1 m d t1 y fn (/1 !C C. C. C. C. C. � V C. 0000000 N N N N N YYYYY GC 'aVN J CD 0 C 0 z 7 = 7 N N N N N UUUU o = OGC E M tm y N M aT C N O C 1 L Q ^ • • • Y Y Y Y Y d C N d Yp• c c c c cc to c. c6 c. a c. as c o 0 0 00000 fA � U � • o c - - W W U N s , V U 1 -� 3 ATTACHMENT 3 ' 15 ' • n , PROGRAM DESCRIPTION In an effort to enhance employment opportunities for current City employees who desire to move from one position to another, and to provide department heads with a list of current employees interested in employment opportunities within their departments, the Employee Opportunity Program was developed. This policy replaces the old opening. Employees interested in After a review of the qualified "Employee Transfer Policy."The applying for the position must applications, the department head old policy covered transfer submit an application within five and the Director of Human opportunities for General Unit working days of the notification Resources will determine if an employees only and involved to the Department of Human outside recruitment or an in- filling out"Job Interest Cards." Resources.Due to time house promotional is appropriate. The new Employment constraints, no application will be If the final decision is to conduct Opportunity Program is for all accepted after the five day an outside recruitment,those regular, non-probationary,and notification period. qualified City applicants will be temporary City employees.The Human Resources staff will then included in the recruitment Program is designed to give review the applications to process.All employees who have current employees a window of determine if the employees meet applied for the position will be z the minimum qualifications as opportunity to apply for and notified of the status of their Z possibly transfer or promote into listed on the current job application and the recruitment Z another classification when there process within five working days Z description. If an employee fails to is a vacancy prior to the start of of the recruitment decision. Q an outsiderecruitment.This meet the minimum qualifications, . J their application will be removed �P �' 'ROGRAM.SUCCESSES CL process does not apply to - J department head recruitments. from the process.Applications Between une 2005 and October Z may also be rejected by the 2006,the.City filled forty-two out 0 When a department submits a Director of Human Resources of 111 positions,-approximately 38 N request for a regular position,an pursuant to the Personnel Rules percent,through the Employee Ln e-mail is sent to all employees and Regulations.The department Lu Opportunity Program. LJ (with department secretaries head will be notified of the City u responsible for providing a hard employees who meet the copy to those not connected to e- minimum qualifications. mail) informing them of the 83 ATTACHFAEN, SUCCESSION PLANNING city of San Luis Obispo / Employment Opportunity Program JURISDICTION INFORMATION Population:44,439 Total Full-Time Employees:348 Total Operating Budget:$59.2 million LESSONS LEARNED This program saved the City PROGRAM'S LEAD CONTACT significant recruitment costs and provides an equitable process for MonicaIrons, advancement from within.The Director of Human program has also proven to work Resources very effectively,and as we address (805)781-7252 ' succession planning in the organization,this process will be minoloney@slocity.org key. TOTAL PROGRAM BUDGET Z This program has limited costs, _ requiring only staff time to Z interview associates,and reduces Z the cost of advertising and recruiting for open City positions. 0— Z Z O N N W U V _ N Ss I -,as 84 'ATTACHMENT A Succession Planning Committee 1 Department Employee Position Title Administration April Richardson Administrative Assistant III LAttorney Christine Dietrick Assistant City Attorney Clerk Elaina Cano Administrative Assistant III Community Development Lindsey Stephenson Permit Technician I Brian Leveille Associate Planner I Kim Murry Deputy'Director Community Development Finance Miguel Guardado Information Technology Technician II April Kraft_ Accounting Assistant_I !Fire re —`� Molly Brown Fire Inspector II Mike King Fire Captain _ Jason Pratt Firefighter _ Human Resources Rachael Hendricks Human Resources Analyst l 'Parks and Recreation Doug Carscaden Ranger Services Administrator Marti Reynolds Supervising Administrative Assistant Police Robert Cudworth Police Officer Jennifer Murphy Field Service Technician Sean Gillham Police Officer Chris Staley Police Lieutenant ,Public Works Jake Hudson Engineer III Gary Keavney Streets Maintenance Supervisor Brian Lindsey _ Maintenance Worker III Utilities Kathe Bishop Senior Administrative Analyst Aaron Floyd Laboratory Analyst 5�1- �