Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout11/16/2010, C5 - RECOMMENDATION TO ADD THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1318 PACIFIC STREET TO THE MASTER LIST OF HISTORIC RE J tl O n V L M-6 71./ /O j acenba nepont C I T Y OF S AN L U IS O B I S P O FROM: John Mandeville, Community Development Directo? Prepared By: Brian Leveille, Associate Planner SUBJECT: RECOMMENDATION TO ADD THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1318 PACIFIC STREET TO THE MASTER LIST OF HISTORIC RESOURCES. RECOMMENDATION: As recommended by the Cultural Heritage Committee (CHC), adopt a resolution adding the property located at 1318 Pacific Street to the Master List of Historic Resources. DISCUSSION Background The property owners of 1318 Pacific Street (Attachment 1, Vicinity Map) have requested f ' that their property be added to `' the Master List of Historic Resources. The property is currently not listed on either the 1 � f Contributing or Master List of Historic Resources. Historic _' s `�� 'y� I, - listing as either a Master List or a Contributing property requires a public hearing before the Cultural Heritage Committee : " (CHC), nomination to the City Figure 1. Front elevation. 1318 Pacific Street Council and Council approval. There are two types of historic resources in San Luis Obispo. Individual buildings that have significant historic or architectural value are called "Master List Properties". These are the most unique and/or important historic resources and merit special recognition and protection. A property may be listed as a Master List property if it meets any of the criteria in Historic Preservation Program Guidelines. The second type of historic resource is the "Contributing Property". A Contributing Property is defined as a structure"built before 1941 that has retained its original architectural style and when C5-1 Council Agenda Report - Master List, 1318 Pacific Street Page 2 November 16, 2010 viewed in the context of its surroundings, contributes to the historic character of the area" (City Council Resolution No. 6424 (1988 Series). While most contributing properties are located within historic districts, the CHC and the City Council have determined they may be located anywhere in the City if they meet the above criteria. If the property is added to the Master List, the applicants will have the ability to apply for a Mills Act Historic Preservation Contract. To qualify for the Mills Act program, the property must be on the Master List of Historic Resources. The applicants have indicated a desire to apply for a Mills Act Contract..The Mills Act request will be a separate application if the property is added to the Master List. The proposed Mills Act contract will require review by the CHC and final approval by the City Council. Site Data Applicants/Property Owners: Thom Brajkovich and Mary Kay Harrington Zoning: O-S (Office with Special Considerations Overlay) General Plan: Office Site Area: 6,520 square feet Site Description: The.lot is developed with the main residence proposed for historic listing, and a driveway leads to parking and a detached single car garage structure at the rear of the property. Historic District: The property is not located within a historic district, but several districts are located nearby, including the Downtown Historic District to the northwest, the Old Town Historic District to the southwest, and the Railroad Historic District to the south. NN \ 106 r �VVd � VV Figure 2. Subject property and vicinity C5-2 Council Agenda Report - Master List, 1318 Pacific Street Page 3 November 16, 2010 Architectural/Historical Background The architectural style of the home at 1318 Pacific Street is Craftsman Bungalow, and exhibits many characteristic features of this style with wide overhangs, projecting gable dormers, decorative brackets, and broad front porches which are deep and dark. The structure has the appearance of a single story but has a high pitched roof to accommodate upstairs bedroom space. This is the characteristic "1-1/2 story". bungalow style. The front elevation has a large gabled dormer with slightly curved eaves and fascias at the edges which are an unusual detail. The other roof eaves on the structure have a similar detail. The raised front porch spans the width of the house and is accented with tapered wood columns and thick curved l- corbels (Attachment 2). , The exterior walls are sided with l x6 redwood siding and windows on the front and side `- elevations are weighted sash-double hung. Windows on the front and rear have uneven sashes with a diamond shaped leaded glass =- pattern which is a characteristic detail on finer `-- examples of craftsman bungalow homes. Figure-3. Curved roof eaves on dormer Previous Owners The first owners of the property were Judge Ralph and Mary Putnam who purchased the property in 1912. In 1927, Leroy and Louisiana Clayton Dart moved into the house and lived there for 63 years until Louisiana's death in 1995 (Attachment 2, Master List request and property history). Leroy Harris Dart and Louisiana married in 1925. Leroy Dart was the . president of Mission Federal Savings Bank. Louisiana Dart was very involved in the community and was dedicated to civic life. Louisiana was Curator of the San Luis Obispo County Historical Museum for nearly 25 years. She also was president of the Monday Club and was the head of the Women's Land Army, a group that helped to harvest local growers' tomato crops since WWII had claimed so much manpower. Louisiana regularly lectured students at Cal Poly and taught in the San Luis Obispo Adult Education Program about local architectural history. Louisiana was President of the San Luis Obispo Historical Society and was a sponsor and regional Vice President of the Conference of California Historical Societies at the University of Pacific. For her lifetime of contributions to the study of local and California History, Louisiana was awarded an honorary degree from the University of Pacific. (Attachment 2 provides more information on Louisiana Dart's contributions and involvement in the Community with newspaper articles, an interview, and her obituary). C5-3 . Council Agenda Report - Master List, 1318 Pacific Street Page 4 November 16, 2010 Advisory Body Recommendation At its September 27, 2010 meeting, the CHC held a public hearing on the property owners' request to add the property to the Master List of Historic Resources. The Committee voted 5-0 to recommend the City Council add the property to the Master List as the historic "Louisiana Dart House" because it meets the following listing criteria in the Historic Preservation Program Guidelines: 1. Architecture - Style. The building is an excellent example of a finer Craftsman style home. The structure has maintained its integrity with no major additions and nearly complete original features on the interior and exterior. The building is somewhat of a rarity in the vicinity considering its scale which is larger than bungalow structures on the block. The building also has purity in its Craftsman style; and has integrity, and eclectic influences. In addition to possessing many Craftsman characteristics, the building also possesses an unusual oriental eclectic influence with flared eaves and a transitional style with high pitched cross gables and vertical design emphasis that is more reminiscent of Victorian-Era architecture. The architectural integrity of the structure is enhanced since it conveys other historical features of the property discussed below. 2. Criteria for Building Evaluations - Architect. William J. Smith was a prominent citizen and very active member of the Masonic Lodge who came to San Luis Obispo in 1890. He built many structures in San Luis Obispo and is best known for his work with Architect Julia Morgan to construct many of the buildings at Hearst Castle. 3. History Person: Louisiana Dart was connected with the structure intimately for at least two generations and was significant to the community locally and regionally with her contributions to the preservation of local history, literary contributions, involvement in civic life, and efforts toward education of local history through teaching in classrooms, books which she authored, and a local radio program (Attachment 2, profile of Lousiana Clayton Dart). Effects of Historic Listing Once properties are added to the Master List, they are eligible to receive and display a historic plaque and to participate in the Mills Act Historic Preservation Program. Exterior site and building changes are possible, provided that such changes promote the structure's original architectural style and character. Significant site and architectural changes are referred to the CHC to determine whether the changes are consistent with City standards and to meet CEQA requirements. C5-4 Council Agenda Report - Master List, 1318 Pacific Street Page 5 November 16, 2010 FISCAL IMPACT Adding the property to the Master List will have no fiscal impact on the City. ALTERNATIVES 1. Continue the item for additional analysis or research. 2. Deny the request to add the property located at 1318 Pacific Street to the Master List of Historic Resources and designate it as a Contributing historic property instead. ATTACHMENTS 1. Vicinity Map 2. Master List request and property history 3. CHC Meeting Minutes, September 27, 2010 4. Draft Council Resolution G:1CD-PLAMBLevei111CHC, Master ListlCouncil Do&CHC 76-10(1318 Pacific) Council.doc C5-5 �w Attachment 2 July 8, 2010 Dan Carpenter/Chair Cultural Heritage Committee c/o Kim Murray, Community Development Department City of San Luis Obispo 770 Palm Street San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 Louisiana Clayton Dart Residence Master List Request Dear Dan, My wife, Mary Kay Harrington, and I are submitting the attached application requesting Master List designation for our residence at 1318 Pacific Street(the Louisiana Clayton Dart House), as well as requesting approval to enter into a Mills Act agreement with the City of San Luis Obispo to protect the property. We have provided attachments which highlight Mrs. Dart's statewide, county, community, and historical achievements, as well as noting the home's architectural importance—built in 1912-a fine example of the Arts and Crafts movement. Please let me know if you would like further information: 541-9486 (office) or 544-4657 home. Sincerely, Thomas ovich C5-7 -' Attachment 2 I Attachments:' 1. Louisiana Clayton Dart + 2. Newspaper articles 3. Oral History Interview(1975) 4. Preface to the Second Printing of_Discovering San Luis Obispo_ 5. Dart's article about Myron Angel, the "Father of Cal Poly" 6. Dart's Obituary 7. Architectural analysis of 1318 Pacific 8. William J. Smith, Builder 9. William J. Smith Obituary 10.Vicinity map 11.Neighborhood pictures i 12. Work completed&proposed improvements 13. Original permits 1912 & 1933 14. Proposed Improvements 15. Ownership History 16. Chain of Title Guarantee C5-8 Attachment 2 Louisiana Clayton Dart house-1318 Pacific Louisiana Clayton Dart(1902-1995) still evokes responses from long-time San Luis Obispo County residents. They remember her southern charm, her large hats, her stories, her front porch, and her complete obsession with local history. Mrs. Dart's impressive resume reads unlike anyone else who has followed her trail since her death: apart from being a wife and mother to three children, she was also a community educator,and linguist, an historian, an author, a master gardener, an amateur f geologist, a radio host, and an author. As a curator of the San Luis Obispo County Historical Museum for almost 25 years, she held the flame of culture and community. Married in 1925 to Leroy Harris Dart, President of Mission Federal Savings Bank, the "kindest man"she ever met, she was skillful in using her position as his wife to promote civic causes as well as highlighting the part local history played in the community. P They moved into 1318 Pacific Street in 1927 and lived in the house.for 63 years until her death in 1995. Her devotion to civic life was legendary. In 1926, she joined the Monday Club (a women's association) and was President from 1942-1943. In that year, she was appointed head of the Women's Land Army helping to harvest local growers' tomato crops since WWII had claimed most of the manpower. She founded the San Luis Obispo Community . Concert Association and was President for twenty years. She also helped introduce foreign films to San Luis Obispo. Named Curator of the San Luis Obispo County Historical Museum in the mid-1950's, she served enthusiastically for nearly twenty-five years. Many remember taking their children to the Museum to hear Mrs. Dart's trill-voiced explanations of objects in the"Victorian Parlor." Her mission was to educate and preserve. She readied the Dallidet Adobe for public viewing and taught local history for a.number of years through the San Luis Obispo Adult Education Program. In addition, Cal Poly regularly asked her to lecture students about local architectural history. She served as President of the San Luis Obispo Historical Society and was a sponsor and regional Vice President of the Conference of California Historical Societies at the University of Pacific. They awarded her an honorary degree for her outstanding contributions to the study of local and California History. C5-9 Attachment 2 Her speaking and writing life were also prolific. The local radio program from 1967- 1978, called"Moments of History,"was written and narrated by her—and presented from a bungalow at the Motel Inn until 1970. In 1978 some of the radio transcripts were published in Vignettes of History (96 pages) by Mission Federal Savings. The thirty-four sections of the book begin respectfully nodding to 15,000 years of history by discussing the Chumash and Salinan Indians, the early European explorers (Carillo, Vizcaino, Portola), and then local characters (Ah Louis, James Cass, John Wilson). The book ranges from lively discussion about the churches, native flowers,the Gold Rush, local architecture, to the nine peaks marching to Morro Bay. Her other literary contributions were two books: What's in a Name? and Early Christmases in San Luis Obispo. 1 Mrs. Dart was not just an observer of state and local life, she was also a participant. In addition, she wrote anIntroduction to the Centennial Re-Edition of Myron Angel's 1883 1 History of San Luis Obispo County, for which she compiled a fifteen-page index (at a time before computers). She also established the route of a walking tour through San Luis Obispo. She was a master publicist, sending out press releases like some now send emails, announcing events and publicizing dedications.-Assisted by the San Luis Obispo Historical Society(and Mrs. Dart)a number of State Historical Landmarks came into being: the San Luis Obispo Mission,the San Miguel Mission, the Santa Margarita Asistencia, the Estrella Church(near Paso Robles), the Dallidet Adobe, the Sebastian Whaling Store(San Simeon), Ah Louis Store, and Morro Rock. The State Historical Monument chosen was Hearst San Simeon. As Mrs. Dart wrote in Vignettes of History, "What a diversity in landmarks-2 Missions, an Asistencia, a simple adobe pioneer Protestant church, an adobe house,2 stores, a mighty rock,and a castle." (p. 49) Mrs. Dart somehow managed to be the person to name the volcanic Peaks, beginning with a peak near the airport and ending with.Morro Rock in the Pacific Ocean: Islay, San Luis Mountain, Bishop's Peak, Chumash Peak, Cerro Romauldo, Hollister Peak, Cabrillo,Black Hill,Morro Rock. Her interest in local architecture is evident from the many photos in her book, Vignettes of History(see attachments). Her love of the old homes and her disappointment because of unfortunate changes are evident as her captions prove: "The Michael Righetti residence at 1314 Palm Street was built in 1887. It says so on the chimney on the side of the house. Elaborate Victorian detail enhances the house and its windows are outlined with panes of colored glass. But a two story apartment has been built in front of the house on the left hand side cutting off the view." (p.56) C5-10 1 I • '�� W {C 4 M. is NRh'S4 C 5'1 S NY.C1 R �'h^ N .x �llb-.jf•S � ,j.1�v.Lc Y, ;V•IR NyS; 1� yS'�i..r`iiy 4°A`` 'rc�r3 J 'ly" 'j - �n r ''3•s T, rr a4` _0101-4I41y vf{'�fT -0,•('" i{�r`4 'SN }. t cr,..01. r , •'i�' -tnf4� i �t- `t K 5 1. rrg,k 5 "X .`..r�v„ .y,• nr ...aru Y� ,+� �Y t-S s I r4 � �S �1Hr �Yyl. crt.Y' n �. � Cyg "'- ,v i '!e h3:1, -1'!+,3 s.h�t +."i'„•..,1+{'E,'�* ! 7.. r�r»eet-r> w+ a>•U x'1r �tJ'-]'F'" �""��k A^�'t s }L.� '3�1f 1xF,+,A.}r�'��-r. 'v Y �p9 A f� ,p'X a 'JS t y� f' f 4�,� M'ev`S r i < Il° 1` `4 S�\+tl� ''}r�3•-"�JK'YAr .C"Xei3yY` 7s{2 F�C',yFJ t '. kfjf l H„y. yyn 1t y fi5.- ? k a ➢ : rt {• ' Y .fb'�.� "� d.^z R ^sP4 ' Su."�lhF�°,'l',y,.if'•+['fir.t�r;.yesj°ka r y ` + , "a. L N � X?> 7isi.o qr , 7k 2 i ♦ ac s .s •.-,R p,ri.n-4 .'*fi^'.c •...+n+ r 4- 'r_p v x r•o ,{ �•.: 4 i s +y li 3 °ldi•,1 �r� ♦ �r 4*S,4 ..�a sy e I. y.YWpa' ° < 5 , et LI i X c<i kyr ;4 K .- ` eu Yw�.. aR.` �_„_ �.1' ',h+.TR✓ii.y4 b'w AJ`S'"a�.Afa'a� .�a`+Cst +,�}}+'b t'9YC- ems t 5 r Jar 9 WINNER a .T st (tLrv, Cp a '1T`�' y--+`' •-� r. � Y ��' � x-. i rrF Jf L'+ "� Y'��L. �'"�.1'�i�fb a'A{I..?j(� � _..i :.-->- � �J ��i r� f{ tr[�i*,T`3•ri ct�x F� ��T 1...... ... t t ,� .:•.of q c '+7JtiA :� - � r � _..¢ t ,r ti x w rs u -�.S + i . y\}j • Lr vM..t c b' t c wn +.- .1' � jr1 ;) xt Ii r��� IT 'C-.— I"...i i 5 lR�R � .-•,r- "r•Ca•�-�'" 1�„ ->11ji�. �:y I ♦ \ Ir':^Jia'1 1� ` r�5. � Y�t"'� _� r i! l ' l !� r x79 �_. b � ilt � � -� t ]4� ;: !j[`• Ynr q- � _ � t•, J .'. 1 1 Yi�a a .in "' .y l_r S 1 \ , } C .. +�,,:.� L �. l � f f.)��,�,bi}c 1y 1 b (i D{ t r -'_^'_'^y�,+�t♦ ,r. fi,B`v� vif_d..�e�r }� ' r 6x4.5 >}Y h' .>•- ': -- "=_S.*R-t'r,4Jc,H"�.'b�EL''4,6�'11'�-Ss{Yx t"."��`'r''��' i�'�c' °`� "fit.,-�..^ ^��{�"� r���.'3rRa'a1.=..3u.2'� .E 19x•r..�'+7p§y � �_`�,r�F'c1��n�L4 _.�'! Y t Photo by Janice Peters \ \ STORYTELLER:The late Louisiana Clayton Dart sitting on her front porch dufingthe summer of 1994. Those `cozy chats' with'Louisiana By Janke Peters VIEWPOINT tion their salary.one of Mr.Dart's One of the fust friends I made after VIEWPOINT customers was a madam gam one of _ ♦ .that pleasure houses on the west altle' moving ro the Canal Coast seven r 'c, W town.and our da3•a i'too Cheek 6e' ago was Imtmiana Clayton _ Lkadtsahedforherbotmced. Part. '- - ' Mn Dart caged Loulsiana flour the She lived nort dour to the mw office ''-yank,and tald her m pm on a Sunday whets I work and was often slttlngoa Idoubt that she am-discadeda and wait for him to pick her up . gat path when l went out for book in her Ufa, as.Gin, Deed •c4jnfbao w.Qo dIdo bofvcoed,_aftd much.One day I complimented her on =in== bookshelves, lined the tgova to the emOt dhe huge loquat tree in her front yard, stags and were std in every :MhgppJDgt�tryapleBgsUtehottaca blustered. Mho aha Invited me to join bar for a evadable nook and=Vof one :.v,Uf.DarYparked the mr in fount of I . �hphaad�ly he mid hooks&r alt the :the hoose awned by his mummer and j + Aa soon as aha discovered I'd jun fasbicmed he and objets d'art(an old- a�IpWslana to wait in the� Masan Brom Lm Angeles to Maim fashiaated Pkram.paLa�,but comthe bad- a !Bay, she enthusiastically began to Plsasly aPPtvpelate) end there was a gy�w cohim m he knocked as herloveofthe Cedhaltauskby xa'Ytogowltheevya��yyy��.,' •':,, '� :-iffirdlraad saw him shake.his head me her unity stories abourthe"'There wait a'.teal�dod"altaaz.out, '.•yjy)�;to was invited Inside While he FM chased Poam.the Renzi Castle.wap ,wajmd'm the patch, the mailman I Louisiana was, hands down, the 'home,anextiWalte dressing tabbnbnx srlbedbnhis mute, best story teller roe ever known.Her collection, sevmai aculptms pietas, >„”A flar delivering the ma he ex- Metalled descriptions and her in¢edi Paintings by local artists. « Raetings with IaWsla m as •ble vocabulary draw you into the antlqua china,and a beautiful grand he walked past the car.It was than - dairy she was team&se completely .piano, covered with photographs of thd Leubdana rediyy the purpose of ,that I tetafe vivid mental pictures barftmlly and several ofLaWsionam her Damm In the as.Ila hmhaod sunwoman.My tabonthereapetlem . .a young favorite photo- ,hal waand it to be abund®fly dear I Thee were celebrity stories,about graph of her was hung by the flint ,that the only business he was trana- (Igoaa 2dRmo wdd,Andres.Segovia door, a saMy foaused:partait of a ,joining at thin estoallshmmt was both and Adele Angers SL John,to rival. lovely blond,girl.aleady possessed of yt1i,{tat•andk�lBmae.Thae:wodldbe ;any I hndgom my days InHonywood. obvious gran and confidence. ..oatgerandlesdibaf)artmrewol r My favorite was about the night she Bvm in her trema.Louisiana was a f�o gossip ral times, I was naggernvited to ;and Ler toddler eon.Leroy.Jeers add young woman who knew and spoke .hatch at Loummna'e house when her ,that William Randolph Hearst was her own mind.She told me about a Hi q n,In tovor.�Thae going to ate at the iaal theater for a. beafa'wha'invited her to vbit Marro •' d be,alx woman altogether.'of :Ptivah Illi sneaurog atffi the regu-. Rock with hint At that tjme,people .various ages and 6attgiv®ds,gath- ebow.They wafted in the lobby were allowed to climb to the tap ofthe ..aed around the table in the dinln6 ,=M Heaat.Marian Davin and then• Rock to pleleandadoy the view. . m=Itw®awm[erAdrvom,wlMa 1gmst.scaess Loretta Young,arrived. Tame war,some rustic same soaps �e window m am wan which Lo Islam described In exquisite gery;y into the cock.used with ease that fealln6 that you..wee ,4wma that aftm trouser ocanal both :by the small herd,M gate that,. aBtlog In the ?don that women wan, nt„tbinB mnsldemd. aousidaed the Rock home.Louisiana;;IIu sd.just outside?won rather dazing at the time.Herat paid g�aly,started the climb,but It wasn't Omverssidon at these gatherings �a tem uisL-aa andherso,. h she reslind thatliar shoe ranged gem mrtent averts to politics d,was lDav heavily on Hearst . shat was out the appropriate mmtand aoQ�c�sraa..and always Included and, to in upright Bm attire fartvck climbing. klotoflavghnt._®cilywhmym'd. Loretto.Young swooped down ou 'She mid hedone Got theyshould go dflanLsfana'e flimda�. Lacy and gushed to Louisiana about �the top. ebe veral goods a appeared;,',,Tal tie spent j sitting ttinggan me what a beautiful child "she" wo. Despite the gouda mistake, Iautw and-she wa t,fthtmod by„their,e]. t parch with LVubdan%'adoying was atBl srytto land of Laretia obvious intent to pass her un the bar yard Med with flowers and vines I=I= na raw nae.The young man casualty allowed to nm rent, a haven for I mvftad Louisiana to my home for instructed her to Batten herself butterflies. dimer ane ermm[with airy permm. �atust the rod so the gam could IaWs�tanadwaas pardcularly fad of and the asked m to Ptd her up an The walla made Iter tae top,where her•Mndxan.She vea�very protea gift ctive of o[ hour Orly n that she could give us Iaumlana admitted that the view aas. ft,and allowed as a trim it for her our awe paaooil historical aur of ��and they,made it bark down Dace,with definite limitations an San Wit Obispo.(It wasn't until her to level gmua,1n ane plea,but that MM ofglmming allowed,. fimartl that I learned she'd created was thetr first and last date.Not by A few days before the passed away the Onocal the history ou Morro)Bay, she the young man's choice, but as last June,I risked her In and made a redid the names o the "Seem Laulah„a-said,"I was not about to .bouquet f urn an the Bowers In her recited peaks as es passed them add ontlnue seeing someone who cousin-• ,yard,including a small branch from expers"pened peaks nebadrometobestow sed rod climbing with a herd of the ilawertagja�aada,to take to her the oMcW names an two of then,to godwas�t��' �yds, ��hffih��p�pyytoo bavve beautiful ma core center.She aderma preset.their being named after Los imm eventually met and married at .babelovedhmne. Angeles areapoBttal figures. bank dark,Leroy Dart Together they LotsLsima's home is empty now;ber On another ocaslm,we lunched at moved into the rambling bungalow- treasures are gena,divided among her the Motel Into and I heard about its style house Louisiana lived in will family. heydayas the that oficnal"motel." her death But as I pass by her house an my A visit to the Monday flab was Moet ImPortank Mr.Dat had all lunch hour.I so ptetu a her sitting . accompanied by atatiO about the the Were an louts there an her net porch enjoying bar bbudi idinas also the architect,alb for mW,Hearst time e��from a gentleman;as. garden,and I find myself longing for Castle.who illustrated by an experience early injust one coma cozy chat coria my jkr{{yy favorite stories, though,were. their marriage. lovelyfdend,Loulsmm. I.ou(sfana'e anectlotes whom her own Back in the IM,bank collets were fife.kat heaan her marriage,end her held accountable for all cheeks may . beloved home. Her house was a ataepted II a deck b mangy. Not:Mum Be and lad the virtual treasure chest efconectiom. �to}hB mllermelDler C5-12 atom the mummer air Eemtbmae It d(y'apfmmfrtgcorrunjsslonns. v � 1 w: d P j fw I1 k MYRON ANGEL Courtesy of California Polytechnic State University One of the names which should be known by every published in 1908 by Tribune Print. In 1910 his book,La citizen of San Luis Obispo is that of Myron Angel, but PiedraPintada;thePainiedRockofCalifornia,aLegend, suangely enough it is recognized by only a few. His was published by the Grafton Publishing Company in contributions to the city were legion from 1883 until his Los Angeles. This very remarkable book gives photos of death in 1911. His famous book, The History of San Luis some of the paintings to be found on that huge horseshoe- Obispo County, has become a collector's item, lol these shaped rock. This is most fortunate as vandals have ,any gears, and is called the bible of local historians. spoiled the paintings and not one of them is left.Only the Angel included a page and a half about his early life and echo remains and the rock is famous for that. :Middle years, until coming to San Luis Obispo, in this Angel kept up his writing to the very last. He died on aaok (see pages 276-278). The biographical sketch came June 27, 1911. The story of his death was carried by the from History of Journalism in Nevada,published in 1881. Tribune with a mourning band of black around the We. then, will write only of his years in our fair city from article. It seems worthwhile to include here his obituary, !881 to 1911. with its old fashioned dignity. When hecame here in1881hewas fifty-four years of age. DIED. ANGEL—In this city, June 27, 1911, After working on his local history he turned to the Myron Angel, beloved husband of Caroline F. newspaper world,bought the Tribune in 1883 and was its Angel; a native of Oneonta, New York, aged 83 editor. In 1886 he sold the Tribune, bought the Daily years,6 months,26 days.Funeral services Thurs- Republic and became its editor. day, June 29, 1911, at the family residence, No. He was married twice.His first wife,Charlotte Paddock 714 Buchon Street at 10:30 o'clock, A.M. Inter- Livingston, died in 1886. In 1889 he married Carrie G. ment in IOOF cemetery. Flagler of Fallsburg, New York. Relatives and friends are invited to attend.(San A public spirited citizen who stood for the finest things Francisco,Los Angeles and Eastern papers please in the community,he was a"Fifty Dollar Life Member"of copy.) the original City Library in 1894.He was a fine speaker,in Myron Angel is buried in the old section of the Odd constant demand,and spoke at a library reception in 1897. Fellows Cemetery in San Luis Obispo, and an angel is When the harbor at Port San Luis was in its embryo stages, etched on his tombstone. .angel was a loyal supporter. Perhaps his greatest con- This writer has tried to get the city to name a street for tribtttion to the city (and now reaching state and inter- him, but to use his whole name,Myron Angel.Perhaps it national proportions) was his great endeavor to found will come to pass someday.His home is still standing and California Polytechnic. He is called "The Father of Cal is Number Seven on the Path of History. Poll. The school has grown from high school level, in 1901. to junior college and college,and is now California Polytechnic State University. Myron Angel would be Louisiana Clayton Dart C5-13 de-ertedh proud. F,rn:natelt for Dosterity.Aneel wrote an eariv hook on `oomm0 "b754S �$'g 68c 9m?E,° g y �Q s s a era g p �i vSa7e �sod� 8 g zg �,� � 1,111-1108111� �m 9 9. 4T$larS °Sm{r' q _ qyL. �° m Is. �g�nE v a � a s m� os 3z s9.:°° o m g g � Ia e• S� Lr,� �. _y�r a 65 l $��°IS,' cSm�g9Er�ig aNiLC .� �� � a Soc� R6e '.000� M mFfinsSg�c6P � aa�a ;g1S$z x $585 ad d E6tlC plo1C n m ''EE C 6 m s M 1 og m• >'B' �_�oyTi.�BIP m.�nS � '�p8r gq5�� ILO 5i� j m sns�°, till {ggp�a8 fie. wogeA ° esoEd��� � �I" In dR mF m ggs£ 66<m ° ...�a 6 5G a i! C1 15, 11 MI i�a.g ma�mmza �ogr—$8$ a °as d m vm1a� a s CKsCD Era m Fie 6� es� s; y�m5 ���1�°.- •m $ eaC�' :, '- °' � I v ��w �Pe 'm G�°63 Qge mCg � �p`aa, q� QQ�s¢ �I nE o S@o Sg �b u 0g 'L2 m } g5p� td®op�$g < SR� g OWN - sKF R— =5 I �11 le X0'"5 g gig q g 8 S m -6. S'p r�w gg �� � H' T; ' ?;; .:�i1i -�•, ,• '. +�I it C Fi C •P'' qct. ^s. .1 ' CC 1 y its m 0 I agovan _m nom{ e c e - � m 6 - s mS C5-14 Attachment Louisiana Clayton Dart, Oral History Interview May 7, 1975 When we bought this house,it had two bedrooms, and upstairs...they had left this large place in case anyone ever wanted to build a second story. . And we did. We put three bedrooms, a hall,and a bath upstairs. Daring the war,the young brides of the soldiers that were at Camp San Luis Obispo came and would walk the streets in the day[time] looking at any house that,had two stories. In that davit was not unusual at all to have ten people ring the bell and say, "Would you rent me a room?" My answer always was, "No, I have three children and I've never rented rooms. We don't rent rooms." Finally the USO rang me up one day—[the Army was]sending out a " great group of soldiers and from here they were to go up to Marysville and from there they were [to be]sent to the theatre of war and various places). There were girls who had come to be with their husbands and there was no place for them to be together. There were some places where[these girls] would rent the stairs at night—in the big hotels that have the big stairs just to the wife. It was a dollar a night,just to he on the stairs. Rhe hotel]would furnish a blanket. It was either that,or they'd walk the streets. There were people who rented the davenports in their living rooms. I knew several people who[did this]for$5 a night. The girls would sleep on the davenports so they would have a place to stay. [The authorities]would tell them not to come,but they came anyhow. Finally,the USO called[me]up and said,"Mrs.Dart,we know you have five bedrooms,and you use the three upstairs,and the two downstairs are not in use, and if you don't do something for this poor girl who has come to be with her husband,we will send around[that]you are not a patriotic American" I said,"But we don't rent rooms." She said,"Well,I'm sending you a very lovely petson." In a little while,the doorbell rang,and this charming young woman with a Southern accent said,"Mrs.Dart, I believe." And then,"I'm from Dothan,Alabama, and isn't this a charming home!" And then,"May I step in and see the living room?" You know about letting one foot in the door,and of course,before she left, I had rented the front bedroom to her. They werecharming,delightful people. We had them to dinner every night,and Sunday we had a very nice dinner for them. I had bathed and dressed the children,and they came down. We were all seated around the table. And this [woman]looked around and she said,"Don't ourchildren look lovely tonight?"She was a real diplomat. Anyhow, after all that,until the end of the war,we rented those two [downstairs] rooms. i C5-15 RootsWeb: CADATA-L [CADATA] Ca-San Luis Obispo Co. History(Introductory Int) Page 1 of Attachment 2 Book Title: Discovering San Luis Obispo PREFACE TO THE SECOND PRINTING Since the publication of the first limited edition of Discovering San Luis Obispo County there has been a demand for another printing. This has been accomplished. This edition is substantially like the first except that the text has been ttt changed slightly to accommodate new information and eliminate inevitable errors. Many of the sketches have been redone to improve the graphics without, it is } hoped, the sacrifice of the charm of the original sketches. J` Mrs. Louisiana Clayton Dart reexamined the text for errors historical and otherwise. As mentioned before, this work would not be possible without her wealth of information and generosity. Carleton M. Winslow, Jr. San Luis Obispo 1972 1 C5-16 nup://Iistsearches.rootsweb.com/th/read/CADATA/2006-11/1164336452 5/7/2010 OBITUARIES, KVt dy-11 Mildred Howard "What's In A Name"and"Early Christmases in San l Luis Obispo." Mildred..Howard, 84. of Southern California, She is survived by three children,Leroy Harris Dan ... { formerly of Arroyo Grande,died Tuesday,June 13, , Jr. of Seattle, Clayton Stuart Dan.of San Francisco 1 1995,ata Pasadena convalescent hospital. ' and L'ifuisiana Dart Knox of Chico;six grandchildren, use, br A graveside service will be held at 3 p.rrL Friday at Stephen Harris Dart and Elizabeth Anne Dan,both of , Arroyo Grande Cemetery.The Rev.Bob Ainsworth of Seattle, Arthur Jackson Scheinuk III of Denver, BOSTON (AP) — Wome New Life Community Church of.the Nazarene in Edward Barker Scheinuk of Now Orleans. Anna estrogen for several-years Pismo Beach will officiate. Scheinuk Farrell of San Diego and Melissa Louisiana Mrs. Howard was born June 6, 1913, in Tyrone, Scheinuk of Rome,Italy:three great-grandchildren;a- pause appear to raise their r Mo.A longtime resident of Arroyo Grande,she lived nephew; and various great-nieces and great•neph-' 'cancer by nearly half,a stud, 1 in Southern California for the past three years. ews. Older women once took ; fShe is survived by her son,Larry Howard and his She was preceded in death by her husband,Leroy only a few years to ease the wife, Pranee, of Tujunga; and two sisters. Helen Harris Dan,in 1959. and other symptoms of men Zdana and her husband,Joe,of Arroyo Grande and Contributions in her memory may be made to the the new study confirms this Myrtle Halfhill of Pon Hueneme. Salvation Army or to a charity of one's choice. But Many doctors now k She was preceded in death by her husband,Rennie Arrangements are by Lady Family-Sutcliffe Menu• on hormones for many yea W.Howard,on Jan,3.1991. ary in San Luis Obispo. life;because of estrogen's de Arrangements are by Marshall•Spoo Sunset Funer• aIC hapel in Grover Beach. Lorraine Travis ability to ward off heart.1 _ - fractures. The latest resear Louisiana Dart Lorraine "Babe"Travis.92, of Pismo Beach died such lengthy use may do Tuesday, June 13, 1495, at an'Arroyo Grande than good for some women. Louisiana Marjorie Clayton Dan, 93, of San Luis hospital. "It clearly raises the neer 1 Obispo died Tuesday,June,13, 1995,at a San Luis A family memorial service will be held at 3 p.m. der the risk and benefit if Obisposare facility. Friday at her daughter's home,located al 311 Hance A funeral service will be held at 10 a.m.Friday at St. in Pismo Beach. going Louse hormones for Stephen's Episcopal Church in San Luis Obispo.The Mrs.Travis was born June), 1903,in Damming, five years, said Dr. Grahar Rev.James Carrington will officiate.Burial will follow N.M.She moved to Pismo Beach 15 years age and .of Brigham and Women's at Lady Family-Sutcliffe Cemetery in San Luis Obispo. was considered a loving mother,grandmother and Boston,the study's principal Mrs.—Dan vras—bora—March-2L,902,_.in-lew_9:eat• randmother. Some earlier studies havt 1 Orleans, La.,to Gilbert 0.and Mary A.Clayton. In SFetssurvived y_1 reesons, o nnGrovanazziand links between .estrogen c 1919 she moved to Atascadero,where her lifelong his wife,Roberta,of Long Beach,Wallace Wood of cancer, others have noL interest in local as well as California history,nature Sand Point,and Wayne Wood and his wife,Judy,of and the preservation of natural beauty,and commu• Washington;two daughters,Beverly Brown and her niry 1925.nd culturalemarried Lerowasy Harrissparked. husband, Waller, of Venice, and Lorre Wood of �tudye �� In 1925,she married Leroy Harris Dart and moved Pismo Beach; 14 grandchildren; arta 19 great• gT+ to San Luis Obispo.In 1926,she joined the Mohday grandchildren. o 1 Club andsurved as as president from 1942.43. Contributions may be made to the American 1 'During her tenure as president,she-was appointed Cancer Society, 767•A Foothill Blvd.,-San Lu head of the Women's Land Army by General Bull,a Obispo,CA 93405. is imaleS e '® group of local women who helped harvest the Arrangements are by Lady Family Mortuary in +�`+ t 'tomato crops of local growers in the absence of Arroyo Grande. NEW YORK (AP)-_ Th manpower during World War II.She then served as W i i l i a m Kelley i I ey DDT might promote abnor i county president of the California Federation of Women's pubs. development of the testes a She was a founding member of the San Luis William Glenwood Kelley,66,of Atascadero died study suggests.. Obispo Community Concert Association and served Wednesday,June 14,1995,at his residence. DDT or similar-behaving as the group's president for 20 years. She was A memorial service will be held at 11 a.m.Saturday may also help explain a rise it instrumental in introducing foreign films to San Luis at SL William's Catholic Church in Atascadero. cancer and a possible fait Obispo.In 1954.55,she wrote for'The Reporter,"a Cremation will be followed by burial at Los Osos speml production over the pa weekly newspaper published in San Luis Obispo. Valley Memorial Park. or so, said William Kelce, r While her children attended grammar school,she Mr. Kelley was born June 23, 1928, id San Luis biologist for the Environmen served as Fremont Schoors PTA president. In the Obispo. Upon graduation from high school, he UonAgency, mid•'50s, she was named curator of the San Luis enlisted in the U.S.Navy and served from 1947.52. . DDT is among a group of Obispo County Historical Museum and served in that From 1952.56,he served with the U.S.Air Force in minht mimicking chemicals in t position for 14W,years.She helped ready the Dallidet China,Japan and Korea.He was employed with Wil- t•that have been S Adobe for public viewing.She taught local history for Mar Disposal in Atascadero,retiring earlier this year. gi several years through the San.Luis Obispo Adult He was a member of the Air Force Sergeants culprits for increases in abnor Education program and regularly guest lectured on Association. In retirement, he enjoyed trips tothe penis and testes and the architectural history at Cal Pops School of Architec- Laughlin, Nev. He will be remembered as a loving testicular cancer and sperm ec lure. husband,father and grandfather. The new study was done in She served as president of the San Luis Obispo - Mr.Kelley is survived by his wife of 39 years,Lcetta , and rats. Researchers found County Historical Society and was a sponsor and Faye Kelley of Atascadero;four sons,William,Patrick doses of the main substance regional vice president of the conference of Cafifor- and Joe Kelley,all of Atescadero,and Donald Kelley by the natural breakdown nia Historical Societies at the University of the Pacific. of Monique; four daughters, Ramona Fuer of _ She was awarded an honorary degree from the Alascadero,Maureen Flores of Paso Robles,Kathy University of the Pacific for her outstanding contribu• Riley of Bowling Green,Ohio,and Angela Kelley of lions to the study of local and California history. Dongola,fit;and nine grandchildren. For more than 11 years, Mrs. Dart had a weekly Contributions may be made to the Hospice of San radio program called"Moments of History,"which Luis Obispo County Inc., 1431 Higuera St.,San Luis she wrote and narrated..ln 1978,some of the radio Obispo,CA 93401. scripts were published as'Vignettes of History'by Arrangements are by Los Osos Valley Mortuary in Mission Federal Savings. She went on to write Los Osos. .�. .. • �f0 e4eeninfman`f-- 1 The Louisiana Clayton Dart House 1318 Pacific Street Construction completed. June 17, 1912 Contractor: William J. Smith Architect: William J. Smith Original Owners: Judge and Mary L. Putnam Style, Design, and Context The Dart House is a classic example of a Craftsman/Bungalow style home true to the period (1905 to 1930). The style derived its name from The Craftsman magazine produced under the direction of the famous architect and designer, Gustav Stickley. Stickely's "mission"was to try to teach average Americans good design,thus the term "Mission Style." Some notable architects of the time were the California architectural firm of the Greene brothers and William Morris with the Arts and Crafts movement in England,whose influences inspired high-styled Craftsman Bungalows. The builder/architect was William J. Smith who died in San Luis Obispo in 1932.He built a number of the finer homes in the city. He was selected by William Randolph ` Hearst as the contractor to construct many of the buildings on his San Simeon estate, La Cuesta Encantada_ See attached obituary for story and street view of house below. ti Front and side of house e5-18 Attachment 2 l 1 Craftsman Bungalows and houses are characterized by the use of natural materials and colors. "A Bungalow is natural enough to blend into any landscape, yet with great attention to craftsmanship and detail. "A house reduced to its simplest form," Stickely + wrote. Two story houses or 1 %z story Bungalows typically have low roofs and wide overhangs, as well as projecting-gable dormers with decorative brackets and sometimes j balconies. The broad front porches are deep and dark,providing.shade from the Califomia sun. The porches often had tapered columns and thick masonry or wood piers and sided with clapboard or wood shingles that are naturally weathered or stained a rich dark brown. Like Prairie-style entrances, the front doors often have simple geometric designs with small squares or tall glass side by side, often leaded. The windows on finer houses had leaded and stained glass designs that were repeated throughout the house. The Dart house has many of the typical features described above. The main shape of the f house is a square with a steep gable roof allowing the second story to be used as living j space. The house appears as a single story but has three bedrooms and a bathroom upstairs. This was referred to as a story and a half in those days. The street front has a large, gabled, dormer window with curved eaves and brackets on the fascias and eaves } that are also subtly curved at the edges. The rear has a dormer with a shed-like roof that was added in 1933 when the Darts' converted the upstairs. The street front greets visitors with a raised wood porch that spans the width of the house. The porch is accented with tapered wood columns,thick curved corbels,and splayed capitals. These columns rest on a flat board cap that is 18" wide (all one piece)and spans the entire width of the porch. The cap is on top of the solid half wall 32"high with clapboard wood siding that mirrors the rest of the house. The bottom of the siding is tapered 10 degrees on all sides of the house just below the window sills that makes the house feel more grounded and gives it a horizontal accentuated line. i The exterior walls are sided with rabbeted, beveled 1 x 6 redwood siding with mitered corners. The windows are all weighted-sash double hung except for the small casement windows in the kitchen and one side of the living room. Also, in the breakfast area of the kitchen, there is a large, multi-planed floor to ceiling wood-fixed window. The windows in the front and rear have a 1/3:2/3 uneven sashes and diamond-shaped leaded glass in the top sections. This diamond-shaped, leaded glass pattern extends to the south and west side of the house. A rear deck and wood trellis has been added by the present owner to accentuate the style. The house has had no additions and is on the same footprint as it was in 1912..The kitchen has been renovated by the current owner and a bathroom and laundry room added where there was a screened porch in the rear. 2C5-19 _} Ti, f porch view The interior of the house has retained much of its original character because the Dart family resided in the house the majority of its life—over 60 years. The height of the interior walls is 9 '/z feet. The living and dining rooms are fitted with a rich,stained f birch-wood panel wainscoting that carries up the walls 8 feet ending with a plate-rack shelf and a ledge. This paneling is trimmed with original red fir that has been finished in a reddish-brown stain and varnished.All the windows are matched and have never been painted. After researching the period's interior designs,the current owner has added matching tapered columns which separate the living from the dining room,where a pocket door originally stood. The new columns mirror the design of the front porch columns with the corbels rounded to reflect the home's character. The columns land on a flat bar with a leaded-glass hutch on one side,and a bar and bookcase on the other. The ceiling of the living and dining rooms have the same rich,boxed, red-fir beams in a grid pattern trimmed out with crown molding that matches the plate rack. The kitchen is new but retains the character of the interior with craftsman-style cabinets and a gridded ceiling that mirror that of the living area. The colors are mild:pastels with lighter tones that contrast well with the dark wood of the living and dining rooms. The floors in the kitchen are durable stone. The rest of the downstairs has the original wood floors with white oak in the living areas and red fir in the two downstairs bedrooms. The upstairs was remodeled in 1933 by the Darts after needing more space for the children. There are three bedrooms,the smallest being in the front dormer. This is the loveliest room as the morning and south facing light floods it with warmth. A rear dormer It5-20 �J Attachment 2 was added then to accommodate a bathroom in for the upstairs bedrooms. Future plans include matching the rear dormer with the front as to make it more like the style of the 1 period. At the moment it has a shed roof. The house sits well on the site and is landscaped with many flowers to accentuate the Arts and Crafts style. Concrete walkways have been added, as well as a concrete and stone driveway,leading to the original garage in the rear that recently has been rebuilt to fit with the style of the house. The front parkway has two trees, an old Jacaranda and a Chinese Pistache. The Dart Craftsman Bungalow stands out almost 100 years after it was built, a finely 1 built home whose inhabitant of over sixty years left her legacy to our city, county, and state. Y Porch and Planters � •M w Rear of House (!5-21 Attachment 2 Mr. William I Smith, Building Contractor A native of Pennsylvania, Mr. Smith came to San Luis Obispo in 1890 at the age of 32 and soon became one of the area's most prolific builders. He operated his construction business,from the home he shared with his wife, Harriet, at 1206 Buchon Street. He was a proninent citizen who was very active as a member of the local Masonic Lodge. Perhaps his most significant accom- plishment was to work closely with Arclitect Julia Morgan to construct many of the buildings at 1 William Randolph Hearst's San Simeon Estate (Hearst Castle). 1 He died in San Luis Obispo on March 21st, 1932. j f L C5-22 sf'.ctGfiflt; Ut piatitren huS th [[ sk V icira s egsrg '+ V� — t le to Mach us and desttvs thej �'_tlierThpt , 11U4nnpet we bore for each(( ' ZF Thu flits , Whet i�Jti '�tr .H „,, the lifit't+'LlfiY #1@ ,�� .` , 7ttr - 4il1YAd!'d�_ 8 + YZ}g" tieltS +lit(IchuiAlltiYlt1 �tPiiitiE }((SCS, F Sfi �te frurn LS:tnnL:t.rr crYnfirmed tglilt LKr �lzuushbt li�fkt�d nt1 til�l`�e. b rwt>Ei`� til �kg.lr �ttr. ti '' u by dins U.11'(1113-1. t s Ment to lt;,[aE.k 14412ug1,'liflttto.� W j84t'�i 2+uu24TR1 efh; Hanxibilte,•.. Who hare a roto a a nt ,E ; i ld datJghutr, i j,4 elaitu l a# �a tied xn a1irE5tmaiJ� '9 mat¢sist 'i J:tne, �yure rase•r t Itt'tcriltl ttL the Chfue-nvp�JfittlM' tlttt tttudt' .of tite;gon' New York ulruost yis yearn t �'$ , ? i ttre euinwtss ion Wolutd-haytk v.0pareti; >1$rritl1R $. ilahHM r' Ivy q'c'r'e equally ranted Un the erld(!rlce thttt'.litjatu 1\itri l toTtslltie t7'tll`(tYr, i Were. for wo robtl ;oft`rnlut+ltis i°vlit faltnd 3Mlitfr x1 [.e rrutl :t half Stars ug„ then v� fl �he .,irt t t tt_tnent was stil ttlt re c.#iect li11� :irFrctuk laitit� lu 1lolic"t�uud. �tiyn llarding's e�<L @ �z``v .Lilt tt C'htrntUvI Ritl7 lltiatr3 l;u tl til6�evl�end-$Ctil}C tt patricl:,n lmauty curried bey _t1 .:' ` r, itttn Luau teo #t�id.atl. ;'- x< t Y 1, fVrgu!r--tiny etnlitirtir 9f hiitll, .lost lttslant st'airdont and iat= I..wesidwit, JrlpaaL'ri had xiili6i Eti ttCq` °nt 'it rIuI%kl._:by It crone}'. Bannister gut a fen' , Y u tvitb ciCiiftixl k t:Ggptittltlnil; 811a tFgi oars-.oad t iit6ft prls at first, then fuuurl only (heir tCprF(,µ .ut in eoratr4l of LtiL 71fo s1100mbi ociLvir JI Av\:l �jtl?j\<`a. tutira r;binri<, !'I tc 'c`itutitty 0.VI, ------- 1ti site 1Tati 4# fiGd e Eduloator + Van.- 1Spea1w to Masons Empire to 1>6Cie S L� Ireland Qu Otion t>+lh>rt lyM1 Y !ng Kersey, state salrerinteu- H education, tvrts Ur lie urincl- i .Ldid t GS + ` ker at the alien meeting of IA)NDa . dlarch E4. .(British acl,oduie9 far the Masonic United Press) Tlie rely of J. H. r , Tbgi•sdny evening at 8.15 Thomas to Rre51dent Eamon De `'u- k'ibtfntg.trlbule sv�ii, lktid to b`cottish Ntio niauous were to lera's aunotinceii..inteAtlea 'of a41n1. ntemary of abelavetl pitpez %' w Fl`1wa + Y T �t in a dinner at Mulholland's fishing the ouch of d1legrante.to Bing nes a�tGrttiW ai ttan6#1-1-1. vi�esQrt '�YIlC� t,dF t'�1tfih4 AS p. in., followed by ser- M the -iY,lai6Aic Temple. Georgy and iaithbolding the jrtsli budu�8" Tai4f dl land annulte9..vras.approved geher ob><siln CAS[(T t t ally by the press, today, but'Publlt def len4¢ to is & AAQ , BOUT U1?3 attention gra& atiuoentratQti uiostivi filiution;� i ono, NO ,"Q tm bOtit tm `bGetfi'92abAs uon what will 7ppenex . nres.av t `b aRlnis The Britishgavgrntnent Pe?Pared T&dj)j&tWEir _ t aictoi�g iln `r right to.place the t XO*X W; re in eon � �� f �ei the A P Haas planned li tribtanal to 'hetet mine ayheth�r 'Alt OP- t't•4i _ Mt •sseeic's res tdzaaestion.ar this �a try l Sran>Tltllt (0 �° a e afur in thile for StuJM Rmu-cm late io 5b t�atp�p (t1t �tR �atle , pla �tlt � ��-•i'i�C'f � / t �tnt�.� wW 'y F :�Y.'Y'b'� � t AND 1N -CX Y ,tS�rrjP� t1�`tj1t0 h.1d7'�1 taw the ,T, ,�, i „—'=� �;�`4>?e�•*�,.,�>� +,�. 'i�j, �. {'' t ��• tZre, il ,, t - %�'1lML .+.t�'�rw..9tl-Q.}di[�}C�rY"K'rasar '! •I ;✓t' i 7 �'ttY��i ylJ PUT P��FfUb� z 77J'. �.>•h, � g.L'�'z+t�'��.'2 .Z�.��, .�'�.� �� y. 4 '" 'y't a. , a'+ *� ,�? 'P,Y6`y+c, y ; F'js•r ' ..,• � ..:�•w �. • t q {�� � 'Ft ifY L'` sFYy:: ` • 1 � Itac 318PACIFIC2=0T`O J '% 1 •' 4.5 � I CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO he information contained in this database is intended for informational use only. This information is provided for the convenience of users, GEODATA SERVICES iut does not necessarily constitute precise property ownership or legal descriptions of any property,and should not be relied upon as an 955MORRO STREET 1ficial property record.The City of San Luis Obispo makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of this data;however,the accuracy of this SAN LUIS OBISPO,CA 93401 aterial isnot guaranteed and users assume responsibility for Independent verification of any and all information contained herein prior to se or reliance upon such information for any official purpose.The City San Luis Obispo disclaims any responsibility or liability for l9rec2.A 805 781-7167 r indirect damages resulting from the use of this data. � 4 7/12/2010 16:06 Attachment 2 s�xx: m`T$mw G l+t 00ONNO QZ � 1 �� 1 •.. SL ° / o TORO �h 6.L •Sa' L4 .9t Taro n 60 I55.10 O •1 'aa' i O N ae.es 9. s.as•a �d N� d B4. o s RM.50-37 a N i a 19 a �j ior..lF - A n 9 d f..a y 0:� v O y\Q; �♦ N QN N n C3 0 J v a y z k 3GO.Ir �1 J JOHNSON CF.•./y esssx sr.) AVE. o Op 1 N w Q /JO' O• ---0 I s OD CD r\A N ^s .\PJI V P o• Cro A " 1 •p W� p P�d7715St /O O rn S N© p____ .M.A-551Ta 6@0 l Is � y GTO 19%GT N J 0 •y �m r• \•. , O m o NOWLES TRACT - 1.0 115.2 A 60 130 pno N To ABVD. °` PEPPER ST. Wt. ©A P.M. 7I-55 .�yRO. w (FM+5. roN.vson s7.� o !T ocN'C a .P NyA.O �• PTN. SA PAR. 37 tlw. e1 on sD.r./ut.ro.s/BTz-�o-zD OVi(�1 n1Aa y 872-40-2AM N - m$v 2 U. A fl O 6-25 L Y 9I r z+1-.._ .- �.-� � -rel .-':1S .'•.".d i�,r'NP � i A \ l� krS�N � i�� Attachont Omf 74 aM �§ 4 x Sr e, < FY.� �, •s c f$;.3�w •. � r+t�t'. ��y,4 �, f ' qry.�a. M1 YI T .y YI , H• 1 l salts, 5 Fdya rte' 1 1 tl M li 1 1 1 I All Next door house side of 1318 Pacific IF C5-27 Attachment 2 ' The Louisiana Clayton Dart House 1 1318 Pacific Street i List of Mills Act Improvements Completed since 2005 i 1. New electrical service and wiring 2. New plumbing and fixtures on all bathrooms `• 3. New mechanical and Forced Air Unit 4. New kitchen remodel: cabinets, flooring, plumbing fixtures, counter tops, appliances,windows and doors to match original. S. Add new.half bath 6. Add new laundry room 7. Paint exterior rear and front of house 8. Paint interior of house. Re-finish doors windows and wood paneling to original stain color. Add tapered wood columns and bookcases as room divider. 9. New IPE deck,handrail and stairs in rear. Add hot tub 10. New roofing: 40 yr architectural composition. 11. Rebuild original garage. 12. New walkways and driveway on side of house 13. Rebuilt front steps and tapered columns to match originals Proposed Improvements 1. Paint outside of house traditional craftsman colors 2. Finish backyard pavers and patio 3 Rebuild rear dormer to match front of house dormer 4. Build gate at end of driveway 5. Landscaping in rear yard C5-28 Attachment 2 The Louisiana Clayton Dart House 1318 Pacific Street t } OWNERSHIP HISTORY Resident Years Occupation Judge Ralph W. and Mary Putnam 1912-1923 Superior Court Judge& Wife Leroy and Loiusiana Clayton Dart 1923-1995 Banker and City Historian f Margaritaville Partnership 1995-2000 Attorneys Andrew Moms and Buttery i Susan M. Steele and Richard Oehrle 2000-2003 Real Estate Investors Thomas and Mary Kay Brajkovich 2004-present Architect and Cal Poly Professor 105-29 Attachment 2 jIto Fidelity National Title Insurance Company GUARANTEE NO.: CAFNT0940-0940-0051-0405102360-F. TMC-2010-G6 l i SUBJECT TO THE EXCLUSIONS FROM CO VERAGE, THE LIMITS OFLIABILITYAND THE CONDITIONS AND STIPULATIONS OF THIS GUARANTEE, f } Fidelity National Title Insurance Company y a corporation, herein called the Company, t GUARANTEES f i the Assured named in Schedule A against actual monetary loss or damage not exceeding the liability amount stated in Schedule A, which the Assured shall sustain by reason of arty incorrectness in the assurances set forth in Schedule A. I Fidelity National Title Insurance Company BY r A7TL'ST Countersigned Chain of Title Guarantee C5-30 CLTA Guarantee Form No.6(12/15/95) �) Attachment Guarantee No. CAFNTb940-0940-0051-0405102360-RMC-2010-G6 j SCHEDULE A CHAIN OF TITLE GUARANTEE j Liability: $1,000.00 i Fee: $215.00 1. Name of Assured: Paragon Architects 2. Date of Guarantee: April 9, 2010, 07:30 A.M. The assurances referred to on the face page are: I That,according to those public records which,under the recording laws,impart constructive notice of E matters relating to the lnterest, if any,which was acquired by Thomas G. Brajkovich and Mary Kay Harrington,Trustees of The Harrington Brajkovich Trust, UTD 6/13/03 pursuant to a See Exhibit B in and to the land described as follows: See Exhibit"A"attached hereto and made a part hereof. Only the following matters appear in such records subsequent to April 11, 1872: See Schedule A(continued)attached. This Guarantee does not cover: 1. Taxes, assessments, and matters related thereto. OWn 1 CLTA Fano talo.6( C 5-31 Attachment . 2 Guarantee No. CAFNT0940-0940-0051-0405102360-FNTIC-2010-G6 1 EXHIBIT"A" THE LAND REFERRED TO HEREIN BELOW IS SITUATED IN THE COUNTY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO, STATE OF CALIFORNIA, AND IS DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: Lot 25 in Block 12 of the Central Addition to the City of San Luis Obispo, County of San Luis Obispo, State of California, according to Map thereof surveyed by E.Y. Buchan in 1887 and revised by George Story in May i 1890 recorded July 27, 1894 in Book A, Page 54 of Maps in the office of the County Reoorder of saidCounty. APN: 002-342-010 I I 2 ChalndTitle(dmrmft FC5-32 ' QTA Wl8r2nOa!F"NO.6(6fb19� 2 Guarantee No. CAFNT0940-0940-0051-040Aj6t - 1 SCHEDULE A } CHAIN OF TITLE GUARANTEE ( Liability: $1,000.00 t Fee: $215.00 } 1. Name of Assured: Paragon Architects 2. Date of Guarantee: April 9, 2010, 07:30 A.M. The assurances referred to on the face page are: That,according to those public records which,under the.recording laws,impart constructive notice of matters relating to the Interest, if any,which was acquired by Thomas G. Brajkovich and Mary Kay I Harrington,Trustees of The Harrington Brajkovich Trust, UTD 6/13/03 pursuant to a See Exhibit B in and to the land described as follows: See Exhibit"A"attached hereto and made a part hereof. Only the following matters appear in such records subsequent to April 11, 1872: See Schedule A(continued)attached. This Guarantee does not cover: 1. Taxes, assessments, and matters related thereto. ChM 1 QWaftbW of"MC5-33 - aTA f,Lararrtx Fi7'in ND.6(4/4792) Guarantee No. CAFNT0940-0940-0051-040510 ent 2 1 EXHIBIT"A" THE LAND REFERRED TO HEREIN BELOW IS SITUATED IN THE COUNTY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO, STATE OF CALIFORNIA, AND IS DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: t Lot 25 in Block 12 of the Central Addition to the City of San Luis Obispo, County of San Luis Obispo, State of i California, according to Map thereof surveyed by E.Y. Buchan in 1887 and revised by George Story in May 1890 recorded July 27, 1894 in Book A, Page 54 of Maps in the office of the County Recorder of said County. APN: 002-342-010 i I i . 2 ChWn« `` wantm C5-34 QTA 6lsrarrtx ram No.6(WN9� aa&wnt 2 Guarantee No.CAFNT'0940-094U 0051-0405 1 SCHEDULE A(CONTINUED) I 1. See Instrument recorded in Book D, Page 10 of Deeds. 2. See Instrument recorded in Book A, Page 416 of Patents. J 3. See Instrument recorded in Book F, Page 168 of Deeds. 1 4. See Instrument recorded in Book G, Page 404 of Deeds. 5. See Instrument recorded in Book G, Page 404 of Deeds. 6. See Instrument recorded in Book R, Page 507 of Deeds. 7. See Instrument recorded in Book R, Page 509 of Deeds. S. See Instrument recorded in Book S, Page 473 of Deeds. 9. See Instrument recorded in Book W, Page 262 of Deeds. i I i 10. See.Instrument recorded in Book 7, Page 470 of Deeds. 11. See Instrument recorded in Book 77, Page 225 of Deeds. 12. See Instrument recorded in Book 93, Page 35 of Deeds. i 13. See Instrument recorded in Book 137, Page 286 of Deeds. 14. See Instrument recorded in Book 164, Page 205 of Deeds. 15. See Instrument recorded in Book 169, Page 182 of Deeds. 16. See Instrument recorded in Book 169, Page 182 of Deeds. 3 min of Title Qwarfte CLTA Gwrantft Farm No.6(6/M C5-35 Attachment 2- Schedule A(continued) Guarantee No. CAFNT0940-0940-0051-0405102360-FNTIC-2010-G5 17. See Instrument recorded July 25, 1932, Instrument No. 3750, in Book 125, Page 430, Official Records. } 18. See Instrument recorded February 16, 1933, Instrument No. 642, in Book 133, Page 308, Official Records. i 19. See Instrument recorded November 26, 1952,Instrument No. 15839,in Book 686,Page 325,Offidal Records. 20. See Instrument recorded April 18, 1972,Instrument No.4360,in Book 1818,Page 2,Offidal Records. 1 21. See Instrument recorded February 10, 1995, Instrument No. 1995-006207, Official Records. 22. See Instrument recorded December 19, 1995, Instrument No. 1995-058646, Official Records. F 23. See Instrument recorded September 29, 2000, Instrument No. 2000-056504, Official Records. 24. See Instrument recorded January 21, 2004,Instrument No. 2004004261, Official Records. i 4 aaln ofT@k ro ara Ve CLTA Qwanbw ram No.6(6/4192) C5-36 �, Attachment edule A(continued) Guarantee No. CAFNT0940-0940 0051-0405102360-RMC-2010-G6 Exhibit B A Grant Deed dated April 11, 2008, as follows: 1 Grantor: Thomas Brajkovich and Mary Kay Harrington, husband and wife,as joint tenants f Grantee: Thomas G. Brajkovich and Mary Kay Harrington,Trustees of The Harrington Brajkovick Trust, UTD 6/13/03 Recorded: June 11, 2008, Instrument No. 2008030424, Official Records END OF ITEMS I F t I I 5 CWndMft GuwarfteC5-37 aTA Glaren0lt Form No.6(61M Attachment 2 fG TORO 1 s 00 Iar.N�, •1 o O pc Fo- £/ liar Aa I �l JOHNSON (sw�,Esssx or.) AVE o (r1 i ! ® _ _� s ____ a - _"__� Qdk Y Y M •� r 14 1O JM J r III.2� 00 rr 70 moo Fin p E. � AM ( S o �i CCSB.E PAR.37 M• 2 sea.1%Ft way on." U. P. R. R. a � O \15V t►r •p C5-38 SCHEDUL�l EXCLUSIONS FROM COVERAGE.OF Til a bac tar eat Z I. Except to the extent that specific assurances are provided in Schedule A of this Guarantee,the Company assumes no liability for loss or damage,by reason of the following: (a) Defects, liens,encumbrances,adverse claims or other matters against the title,whether or not shown by the public records. (b) (1)Taxes or assessments of any taxing authority that levies taxes or assessments on real property;or(2)Proceedings by a public agency which may result in taxes or assessments,or notices of such proceedings,whether or not the matters excluded under(1)or(2)are shown by the records of the taxing authority or by the public records. (c) (1)Unpatented mining claims;(2)reservations or exceptions in patents or in Acts authorizing the issuance thereot;(3)water rights,claims or title to water,whether or not the matters excluded under(1),(2)or(3)are shown by the public records. 2. Notwithstandittg any specific assurances which are provided in Schedule A of this Guarantee,the Company assumes no liability for loss or damage by reason of the following: t (a) Defects,liens,encumbrances,adverse claims or other matters affecting the title to any property beyond the lines ofthe land expressly described in the description set forth in Schedule(A),(C)or in Part 2 of this Guarantee,or title to streets,roads,avenues,lanes,ways or waterways to which such land abuts,or the right to maintain therein vaults,tunnels,ramps or any structure or improvements;or any rights or easements therein,unless such property,rights or easements are expressly and specifically set forth in said description. (b) Defects,liens, encumbrances,adverse claims or other matters,whether or not shown by the public records;(1)which are created,suffered, assumed or agreed to by one or more of the Assureds;(2)which result in no loss to the Assured or(3)which do not result in the invalidity or potential invalidity of any judicial or non judicial proceeding which is within the scope and purpose of the assurances provided. (c) The identity of any party shown or referred to in Schedule A. (d) The validity,legal effect or priority of any matter shown or referred to in this Guarantee. GUARANTEE CONDITIONS AND STIPULATIONS t. Definition of Tams. object for reasonable cam)to represent the Assured and shall to the Companypmshum to this Section Shan am be disrlosedto The following terms when used in the Guarantee mean not be liable for and will not pay the fen of any other counsel, others udess,in the reasonable judgment of the Company,it is (a) the "Assured": the parry or patties named as the nor will the Company pay any fees,Costs or expenses incurred necessary in the adoimistration of ate claim. Failure of the Assured in this Garantoe, or on a supplemental writing by an Assured in the defense of those causes of action which Assured to submit for examination under oath,produce other farecrred by tlto may allege matters not covered by this Guarantee. reasonably requested mflouniason or giant permission to seam (b) "land":the land described or refined to in Serle (c) whenever the Company shall have brought an action reasonably nooasmy informedion from third parties as required (A).(C)or in Part 2,and®provemab aBixedtherero which by or interposed a dlefense as permitted by the provisions of ins m the above paragraph, onlless praihih tm by law or naw Constitute r eal property.The term land"does no mchrde Gaaramx,the Company may pmsue any litigation to final gvvnandritaf regulation,shall to oinme siq liability of the my property beyond the lines of the area described or referred determination by a amt of mmpeteutimisdiction and expressly Campmy under this Guarantee to the Assured for tied e. to is Schedule(A).(C)or in Part 2,nor any right,title,iuteres4 reserves the right, m is sole discretion, to appeal from an Q Options to Pal or Otherwise Settle Claims: t estate or easement in abutting mens,roads,avenues,alleys, adverse judgment or oder. Termination of Liability. lines,ways or waterways. (d) len alt cams where this Gummuepermits thecompany to ease of aCleimmilerthis Guarantee,the Company shall (c) "mortgage":mortgage,deed of trust,mut deed,or to prosecute or provide for the dleferue of any action or have the fa mowing additional options: olha�y - proceeding,an Assured span sellae to the Company the rights (a) To Pay orTender Payment oftheAmoam tofllaWiry (d) "public records": reads established ostler state m prosecute or provide for the defense of soy action or or to Purchase the Indebtedmeas. mmrDa at Date of Guarantee for the purpose of imparmrg pmeeedmg,and all appeals therein,and permit the Company to The Company shalt have the option to pay or settle or anmuctive notice of matters relating to reed property to rue,at its option,the name of such Assured for this purpose. compromise for or in the name of the Assmed any claim which purchasers for value and without knowledge. whenever requested by the Company, an Assured, at the Could result in hon to the Assured wbbm the Coverage of tins (e) "date":the effective date. Company's expose,shall give the Company an reasonable aid Guarantee,or to pay the fnit amount of this Guarantee or,ifthis. L Notice of ClaimtobeGivanbyAssured Cleimmt in my action or Proceeding, seeuing evidence. obtammg Guarantee isowed fordwboefitofaholdaCfa era AnAssured shall mtifytheCompanypromptlymwttmgm wimessex,prosecuting of defending doe,ounce orlawfidact tieaholder,die Compmyshall have the option mpurchase die case kwwledge shall come to Be Assured hereunder of any which in the opinion of the Company may be necessary or mdebtodosv secured by said mortgage or aid lien for the claim of tide or unrest which is adverse to the tide to the estate desirable to establish the title to fie estate or interest as stated amount owing thereon,together with any coats,reasonable or interest,as stared herem,and which might cause loss or have,or to establish the nen rights of the Assured.If the m dmaage for which the Company may be liable by virtue of this och were fee and exposes incurred by the p to the claimant Guarantee.If prompt notice shalt set be give tothe Company. Company cooperation, the Company's obligations to produce. aamot�d Y to the time of then all liability of die Company siaD terminate with regard to Assured under the Gumantne shall terminate. Such pmdham,payment or teach of payment of the fun the chaser or martcs for which prompt notice is required; S. Proof of Loss or Damage. amount of the Guarantee span terminate all liability of the provided,however,tont failure to notify the Company shall moo In additim to and after the notices required under Section 2 Company hereunder.In the event other notice of claim has been case prejudice the rights of any Assured under this Guarautee of them Conditions and Stipulations have been provided to the given to the Company by the Assured the Company offers to art=the Company shall be prejudiced by the failure and Poen Company.a proof or damage signed and sworn to by the purchase aid indebtodoess.the owner of such indebtedness only to the extent of the prejodiee. Assured shall be finished to the Company within moely(90) shall transfer and assign said indebtedness,together with any 1 No Duty to Defaced or Prosecute- days saint the Assured shag ascertain the Facts giving rim to the collateral security, to the Company upon payment of the . The Company shalt have no duty to defend or prosecute lass or damage.The proof of loss or damage shall describe toe purchase price. ani' action or prooeedmg to which the Assured is a parry, matters covered by this Guarantee which conatimte the basis of Upon the exaeim by the Company of the option provided aoNddistanding the natrae of any allegation to such action or loss or damage and shall state,to the extern possible,the basis for in Paragraph(a)the Cbmpaay�s obligation to*a Assured proceeding of calculating the amount ofthe loss or damage.if the Company under this Guarantee for the Claimed loss or damaage,other am l Company's Option to Defend or Prosecute Actions; is prejudiced by the failure of the Assured to provide the to make the payment required in that paragraph,shall uwftin e, Duty of Assured Claimant to Cooperate. required proof of loss or damage,the Companys obligation to including my obligation to continue the defense or prosecution Even though the Company has no duty to defend or such assured under the Guarantee shall terminate.In addition, of any litigation for which the Camay has mend ed its prosecute as act forth in Paragraph 3 above•. the Assured may reasombly be requited to submit to options order paragraph 4, and the Goatamx shall be (a) The Company shalt have the right,at its We option examioatim under oath by any authorized representative ofthe surrendered to the Company for emanation; and cost,to institute and prosecute any&pian or kroae&a& Company and shall produce for examination,inspection and (b) To Pay or Otherwise Settle with Parties Other Than interpose a defense,as Iimitad in(b),or to do any other as Copying, at such reasonable lona and places as may be the Assured or with tie Assmed Claimant which in its opinion may be necessary or desirable to establish designated by any authorized representative of the company,all To pay or otherwise settle with otha parties for orm the the tille to the estate or interest as stated herein,or to establish records, books, kdgers, checks, Cortespondenne and risme of an Assured Claimant any claim insured ageing under 0e Em rights of the Assured,or to prevent or reduce loss or memoranda,whether bearing a date before or after Date of this Guarantee,together demgetotbcAssmed.The with m3'Cosh ming which fee and C�Y�Y�myapprapriete Guarantee,which reasonably pertain to the lea or damage. expenses intoned by the Assured Claimant whidh cone action®da the terms of this Guarantee,whetter or not it shag Further,if requested by any authorized representative of the autheaizedby the Company tip to the time ofpgmtu and which be liable hereunder,and shall not thereby concede Whiny or Company.the Assured shall grant as permission,in wrift for the Company is obligated to pay. waive any provision of this Guarantee.If the Company shall any atnherized representative of the Company to erne, U the exercise the Pco by Companyoblige on to am Assured adtim its rights undo this paragraph,$Shan do m dltigeatly. respect and spy all records, books, ledgers. checks, Cor len Paragraph(b)We Compmye obligator to the Assured (b) Iftte Company Clear to exercise its options as stated correspondence and memoranda in the custody or control of a under this Guarantee for the claimed loss or damage,other than in Paragraph 4(a)the Company shall have the right to select third party,which reasonably pertain to the loss or damage.All to make the payment required in that paragraph,shall terminate, counsel of its choice(subject to the right of such Assured to information designated as confidential by the Assured provided including any obligation to centime the defeam or prosecution (� Clam of Title C &� 9 CLTA Guarantee Form No.6(9/12/08) of any litigation for which the Company bas exercis, )9. Redaction of Liability or Termination of liability. '�_._, the A u tad=nL 2 optima under Paragraph 4. AD payments under this Guarantee,except payments made arbitrated at the option of either the Company or the Assured. T. Determination and Extent of Liability. for costs,ancimeys'fees and expenses pmsumt to Paragraph 4 AD arbitrable matters when the amount ofliati>bty a in taass of _ This Gurrimance is a contract of lademnity against actual shall reduce the among of liability pro tanto. monetary loss or damage sustained or immured by the Assured 10. Payment of Lona. Company shall be arbitrated duly when agreed ct by both the. claimant who has suffered loss or damage by mason of reliance a No a sh lbs The Rules i n offiect at Dam of r () payment shall be made without producing this Guarantee ahaD be binding upon the patties.The award may tWm the assn races set forth in this Guaanme and only to the Guarantee for endorsement ofthe payment unless the Guarantee include atmrneys'fees only tithe laws of the state in which the exrcor herein described,and subject to the Exclusions From has been lost or destroyed, in which case proof of loss or land is located p=int a wort to award attorneys'fees to a Coverage of This Guarantee. destruction shall be famished to the��*om ofthe The liability of the Company ander this Guarantee to the .���s)may Judgment enter upon the ours h rendered is the @) When liability and the extent of loss or damage bis Arbitrator(s)may be catered in any conn having jurisdiction Assured shall not exceed the least of been definitely fixed in accordance with these Conditions and thereof (a) the amamat of liability stared in ScheduleA or in Stipulations, the loss or damage shall be payable within The law of the sitmofthe land shaD Put es. m m abitiatiaa @) the amount of the d �fY(30)� under the Title htsurena Arbitration Ruled. mmaE principal indebtedness 11. Subrogation Upon Payment or Settlement A copy of fire Rules may be obtained from the Company secured by the mortgage of an Assured mortgages,as limited or Whenever the Company stall have settled and paid a claim upm request. { provided under Section 6 of time Condition end StipufaCmcs or under this Gumantm an right of subrogation shall vat in the 13. liabllity Limited to This Guarantee;Guarantee Fatlre as reduced under Section 9 of these Conditions and Stipulations, Company unaffected by say act of the Assured claimant Contract. atria time the loss or damage assured against by this Guarantx The Company shall be subrogated to and be entitled to all (a) This Guarantee together with all endmmmeats,Bary, oecors,together with interest thereon;or rights and remedies which the Assured would have had against attached hereto by the Company is the entire Guarantee and (c) the difference between the value of the estate or any person or property in respect to the claim had this Guarantee contract between the Assured and the Compaq.In int Wert mg inaeres covered hereby as stead herein and the voice of the not been hewed.(requested by the Company.the Assured shall any provision of data Guamme, this Guarantee shall be estate m intei,sr subject to any defect lien or encumbrance transfer to the Company all rights.aad remedies against any construed as a whole. assured against by this Guarantee. person m property eeoearmy in order to perfect this right of (b) Any claim of loss m damage whether m not based on 1 L uritatim of Liability. subrogation. The Assumed shall paw the Company to rue, negligence,manyaetionaasatingsuchebim,shall berarticted (a) If the Company establishes the We.or removes the compromise or settle io the name of the Assured and to use the to this Grumman. alleged defect,lien or encumbrance.or cures any other matter came of the Assured in any transaction or litigation involving (c) No timendmant of or endorsement to this Guamm: assured against by this Guaranty in a reasonably diligent these ti mama by any method,including 14ation and the completion If apapay�omrent account of a claw does not �m made exceptbya writing dent,carloa hewn m atmdcd Of any appals thenefront it shall have filly performed its loss of.the Assured We ful ated to an hereto signed Assistant a the President a Via Pg office the i Obligations with respect to that matrerand shall not be liable fm Compal shall i e�subrogamd m:ail Secretary, an roft Secretary, m validating officer m j my loss or damage caused rights and remedies of the Assured after the Assured shall have 14. Notices, ei,Wier S the Company. @) In the event of �� recovered its principal,interest,and ants of collection. 10. Nothxs,Wiese Scot any litigation by me Company or with 12. Arbitration All ratios required to be give.the Company and any the Company's comsat,the Company shall have no liability for Uden prohibited by applicable law,either the Company or statement in writing required to be famished the Company shall loss Or damage maul there his ben a final determination by a the Assured may demand arbitration pursuant to the Title include the number of This Guarantee and shall be addressed to CMM of competent jurisdiction,and disposition of all appeals Insurance Arbitration Rules of the America.Land fide the Company or I therefiom,adverse to the title,as steed herein. Association.Arbitrable matters may include,but am nut limited (c) The Company shall not be liable for loss mdamage to to.any controversy or claim between the Company and the Fid my Assured for liability volmhnly,assumed the Assured n Assured cillo 4SO23 Tide Insurance Compaq NUHDSany elaimofsuit withomWeprior written wnsentofthe of the yin afar PA.HmuftF Company m wmection with its iisuaua m the breach of JaclumvDle,FL 32232.5023 i ComPany. a Guarantee provision or other obligation.AD arbitrable mantas Atm: Claims Department Chain ofride U CLTA Guarantee Form No.6(9/1,2/08) ^ SAN LUIS OBISPO Attachment 3 CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMITTEE MINUTES September 27, 2010 The meeting convened at 5:30 p.m. in the Council Hearing Room at City Hall, 990 Palm Street. ROLL CALL: Present: Committee Members Barbara Breska, Enrica Costello, Hemalata Dandekar, Buzz Kalkowski, and Chairperson Dan Carpenter Absent: Committee Member Katy Davis and Vice-Chair Jeff Oliveira Staff: Senior Planner Phil Dunsmore, Deputy Community Development Director Kim Murry, Associate Planner Brian Leveille, Assistant Planner James David, and Recording Secretary Janet Miller PUBLIC COMMENT: Dorothy Graves, San Luis Obispo, spoke against the changes to 535 Islay, known as the Sandercock House. Mrs. Graves felt that the Master List and Mills Act designations were no longer appropriate. Staff will provide an update on changes made since the May review. There were no further comments from the public. MINUTES: Minutes of July 26, 1010, were approved as submitted. ACCEPTANCE OF AGENDA: The agenda was accepted as presented. CONSENT: 1. 50 Hiquera Street. CHC 93-10; Review of a street widening project in front of 50 Higuera Street, the Historical Cal Trans Building; C-R-MU zone; City of San Luis Obispo— Public Works Dept., applicant. (Phil Dunsmore) Phil Dunsmore, Senior Planner, presented the staff report, recommending to determine the proposed widening of Higuera will not change the context of the Master List Historic property and to forward this recommendation to the State Historic Preservation Office based on findings and subject to conditions which he outlined. On motion by Committee Member Kalkowski, seconded by Committee Member Breska to determine the proposed widening of Hiquera will not change the context of the Master List Historic property and to forward this recommendation to the State Historic Preservation Office. AYES: Committee Members Breska, Costello, Dandekar, Kalkowski, and Carpenter NOES: None C5-41 AttachmentCHC Minutes September 27, 2010 Page 2 RECUSED: None ABSENT: Committee Members Davis and Oliveira The motion passed on a 5:0 vote. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: 2. 1352 Pacific Street. CHC 19-10; Request to add a residential property to the Master List of Historic Resources; R-2 zone, Matt and Sara Ritter, applicants. (James David) James David, Assistant Planner, presented the staff report, recommending the Committee approve a resolution recommending the City Council add the property located at 1352 Pacific Street to the Contributing Properties List of Historic Resources, based on findings and subject to conditions which he outlined. Matt Ritter, applicant, spoke in support of adding the property to the Master List. Mr. Ritter discussed the historical nature of the site. Betsy Bertrando, applicant representative, discussed how the project met all of the criteria for Master List designation. Committee Member Breska questioned the length of time the Kellys lived in the house. Mrs. Bertrando replied that Charles Kelly had lived there for 20 years before he died, and his wife continued to live there an additional 10 years. Committee Member Costello questioned if there were many affordable housing projects during this era. Mrs. Bertrando replied that there were not and that this house was special and controversial at that time. PUBLIC COMMENTS: Eric Meyer, San Luis Obispo, spoke in support of the Master List designation because it was the first of its kind. There were no further comments made from the public. COMMITTEE COMMENTS: Committee Member Kalkowski suggested the Committee look at the home in its historic context. He disagreed with the staff conclusion and felt Pedder Plan affordable homes were a significant event in San Luis Obispo history. Committee Member Kalkowski also felt Charles Kelly made significant contributions to the community by bringing electricity to the Central Coast. He supported Master List designation for the property with a plaque describing Kelly's contribution. Committee Member Breska agreed with Committee Member Kalkowski's comments. She noted the importance of the building and the people involved. C5-42 Attachment CHC Minutes 1� September 27, 2010 J Page 3 Committee Member Dandekar agreed with staff and did not support a Master List designation because it is not architecturally significant. She noted that the recently- constructed unit behind the Pedder Home significantly detracts from the historic context. Committee Member Dandekar noted Charles Kelly's history is not compelling. Committee Member Costello supported the Master List designation because of the event, construction of attractive postwar affordable houses, and the person associated with the house. There were no further comments made from the Committee. On motion by Committee Member Kalkowski, seconded by Committee Member Breska, to adopt a resolution recommending the City Council add 1352 Pacific Street as a Master List Property with conditions that a plaque is installed that identifies the historic significance of Charles Kelly's work and the Master Listing is for the front house only. AYES: Committee Members Breska, Costello, Davis, Kalkowski, and Carpenter NOES: Committee Member Dandekar RECUSED: None ABSENT: Committee Members Davis and Oliveira The motion passed on a 4:1 vote. 3. 1318 Pacific Street. CHC 76-10; Request to add a residential property to the Master List of Historic Resources; O-S zone; Thom Brajkovich, applicant. (Brian Leveille) Brian Leveille, Associate Planner, presented the staff report, recommending the Committee adopt a resolution recommending the City Council add the property located at 1318 Pacific Street to the Master List of Historic Resources, based on findings and subject to conditions which he outlined. Thom Brajkovich, applicant, spoke in support of the project. Mr. Brajkovich noted that the architecture and people involved supported the Master List designation. Mary Kay Harrington, applicant, spoke in support of the project. Ms. Harrington discussed the history of Louisiana Clayton Dart. PUBLIC COMMENTS: Eric Meyer, San Luis Obispo, spoke in support of the Master List designation. Mr. Meyer noted that the home was a great example of properties that warrant the Master List of Historic Resources. There were no further comments made from the public. COMMITTEE COMMENTS: C5-43 CHC Minutes Attachment 3 September 27,2010 Page 4 Committee Member Dandekar supported the Master List designation. Committee Member Breska thanked the applicants for bringing the property to the Committee's attention. Committee Member Breska supported the Master List designation. Committee Member Kalkowski supported the Master List designation. There were no further comments made from the Committee. On motion by Committee Member Breska, seconded by Committee Member Dandekar, adopt a resolution recommending the City Council add the property located at 1318 Pacific Street to the Master List of Historic Resources, based on findings contained in the draft resolution. AYES: Committee Members Breska, Costello, Dandekar, Kalkowski, and Carpenter NOES: None RECUSED: None ABSENT: Committee Members Davis and Oliveira The motion passed on a 5:0 vote. 4. 375 Chorro Street. CHC 21-09; Determination of continued eligibility for the Master List of Historic Resources (Anholm House) and Mills Act contract; R-1 zone; Michael Mulvihill, applicant. (Brian Leveille) Committee Member Breska recused herself from this item. Brian Leveille, Associate Planner, presented the staff report, recommending to find the Anholm House continues to meet the eligibility criteria for the Master List of Historic Resources and should remain under a Mills Act contract with the City, based on findings of consistency with prior project approvals. Committee Member Kalkowski requested clarification of the importance of the historical criteria for the Anholm house. Staff responded with the detail provided in the initial reports and included in attachments. Committee Member Costello requested the percentage of the structure that represents the original versus the percentage of newer additions. Staff referred the question to the applicant representative Greg Wynn. Committee Member Dandekar requested clarification from Staff on parameters the Committee can review. Staff noted that the Committee can decide if the changes that were made from prior project approvals are significant enough that the property no longer qualifies for the Master List of Historic Resources. C5-44 CHC Minutes ,J Attachment 3 September 27,2010 Page 5 Greg Wynn, applicant representative, spoke in support of maintaining Master List status. Mr. Wynn discussed that the restoration was in line with the initial project approval. Mr. Wynn noted the care and respect put into the project. Ryk Kluver, applicant representative, discussed the restoration and reconstruction process. Mr. Kluver noted that approximately 15% of the original materials could be put back into the restoration. PUBLIC COMMENTS: Bob Vessley, San Luis Obispo, discussed that the project needed to maintain most of its historical integrity and authenticity to remain a listed historic resource. Dean Miller, San Luis Obispo, spoke against keeping the house on the Master List. Mr. Miller stated that the project was a reconstruction, not a renovation. He stated that the project deviated significantly from the original and he does not support Mills Act for the site. Chuck Crotser, San Luis Obispo, spoke in support of the staff recommendation. Anne Hodges, San Luis Obispo, did not support the property's continued historic designation. Ms. Hodges noted that the house is representative of poor Committee decisions on historical designation. Ms. Hodges noted that the house has changed 90% from the original and does not deserve a Mills Act contract. Michael Mulvihill, property owner, spoke in support of the project. Mr. Mulvihill defended the original designation given to his property and reminded the committee that he fulfilled his obligations to complete the project consistent with approved plans. There were no further comments made from the public. COMMITTEE COMMENTS: Committee Member Kalkowski commented on the beauty of the home. He did not support eligibility for the City's Master List. Committee Member Dandekar commented that the historical nature of the person living at the residence was important and the owners had met the conditions of the approved plans and Mills Act contract. She supported the Master List designation. Committee Member Costello noted the dedication of the work the owners had put into the home. Committee Member Costello noted that although she did not agree with prior project approvals, the scope of review was whether the applicants complied with previous project approvals. Committee Member Costello questioned if there had been any area of the contract broken. Staff noted that the discussion for tonight was to address that topic specifically, C5-45 CHC Minutes September 27, 2010 Attachment 3 Page 6 and staff responded that the applicants did finish the project consistent with the Mills Act contract and prior project approvals. Committee Member Kalkowski noted that there should have been better communication with the applicants as this was a demolition rather than a restoration. There were no further comments made from the Committee. On motion by Committee Member Dandekar, seconded by Committee Member Costello, recommending to find the Anholm House continues to meet the eligibility criteria for the Master List of Historic Resources and should remain under a Mills .Act contract with the City. AYES: Committee Members Costello, Dandekar, and Carpenter NOES: Committee Member Kalkowski RECUSED: Committee Member Breska ABSENT: Committee Members Davis and Oliveira The motion passed on a 3:1 vote. COMMUNICATIONS: 5. Staff a. Agenda Forecast—Staff b. Palm-Nipomo Parking Structure Ad Hoc Committee Appointment — 2 volunteers. Committee Member Breska agreed to be on the committee. The second position is still to be determined. 6. Commission ADJOURNMENT: The meeting was adjourned at 9:05 p.m. Respectfully submitted by, Janet Miller Recording Secretary Approved by the Cultural Heritage Committee on _October 25, 2010_. Ryan Betz Supervising Administrative Assistant C5-46 Attachment 4 RESOLUTION NO. (2010 Series) A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO ADDING THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1318 PACIFIC STREET TO THE MASTER LIST OF HISTORIC RESOURCES,CHC 76-10 WHEREAS, applicants Thom Brajkovich and Mary Kay Harrington, on July 15, 2010, submitted an application to add their property to the Master List of Historic Resources; and WHEREAS, the Cultural Heritage Committee of the City of San Luis Obispo at a public hearing held in the Council Meeting Room of City Hall, 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, California, on September 27, 2010, recommended the Council add the property located at 1318 Pacific Street to the Master List of Historic Resources; and WHEREAS, the City Council conducted a public hearing on November 16, 2010, for the purpose of considering adding the property located at 116 Chorro Street to the Master List of Historic Resources (CHC 76-10); and WHEREAS, the City Council has duly considered all evidence, including the testimony of the applicants, interested parties, the records of the Cultural Heritage Committee hearing, and the evaluation and recommendations by staff, presented at said hearing. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of San Luis Obispo as follows: SECTION 1. Findings. The Council makes the following findings of consistency with Historic Preservation Program Guidelines eligibility criteria for Master List Historic Resources: 1. The house is eligible for the Master List of Historic Resources because it meets Historic Preservation Guidelines Historic Significance criteria for Architectural Criteria— Style. The house is an excellent example of the Craftsman style with eclectic influences; has integrity; purity of style; and,effectively conveys the historical value of the property. 2. The house is eligible for the Master List of Historic Resources because it meets Historic Preservation Guidelines Historic Significance criteria for Criteria for Building Evaluations— Architect. The building was designed and built by a prominent architect and builder in the local area. 3. The house is eligible for the Master List of Historic Resources because it meets Historic Preservation Guidelines Historic Significance criteria for History — Person. Louisiana Clayton Dart was a significant local figure who made important contributions to the community as a preservationist,educator, and leader of local organizations. SECTION 2. Action. The Council of the City of San Luis Obispo does hereby add the property located at 1318 Pacific Street to the Master List of Historic Resources as the historic "Louisiana Clayton Dart House". C5-47 Resolution No. [ ] Attachment 4 Page 2 SECTION 3. Environmental Determination. The City Council has determined that the above actions do not constitute a project, as defined by Section 15378 of the California Environmental Quality Act and are exempt from environmental review. Upon motion of seconded by , and on the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: The foregoing Resolution was adopted this day of 2010. Mayor David F. Romero ATTEST: Elaina Cano, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: Z"-�I ae" hristine Dietrick, City Attorney C5-48