Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-01-2015 Item 14 - Action for Civility Report Recommendations Meeting Date: 12/1/2015 FROM: Chris Staley, Police Captain Prepared By: Christine Wallace, Neighborhood Outreach Manager SUBJECT: ACTION FOR CITY CIVILITY REPORT RECOMMENDATIONS RECOMMENDATION 1. Approve implementation strategies for the City led Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility recommendations; and 2. Make no changes to the City membership of the Student Community Liaison Committee. DISCUSSION Background On May 19, 2015 Council received the Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Report and provided direction to staff to return with implementation strategies for the recommendations detailed in the report. In addition, staff was asked to provide a recommendation to the City Council on the make-up of City representatives on the Student Community Liaison Committee. Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Recommendations The Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Report was presented to Council on May 19, 2015 (Attachment A.) The report is a comprehensive and highly detailed document which was prepared after a two year research process. A wide variety of recommendations were established in the report, with each recommendation matched to the agency/institution that would be responsible for further exploration and action identification. The following are the recommendations for which the City of San Luis Obispo was identified as the lead agency followed by the staff recommended action. Notably, several of the following recommendations have already been addressed in recent Council actions. Objective 1 – Define short-term actions to enhance the quality of life 1. Investigate establishing a Student Neighborhood Assistance Program (SNAP) Ride- Along program and promote current Police Ride-Along program. Action: The San Luis Obispo Police Department Ride-Along program is available to residents of the city and may be scheduled once per year. It is not currently advertised on the City website but consideration is being made for including information in the FAQs section of the Police Department web content. The SNAP program, staffed by part-time temporary employees of the Police Department, is not staffed or structured to support resident ride-alongs. While SNAP employees receive a great deal of training, it would not be appropriate for them to take responsibility for 14 Packet Pg. 200 residents in a ride-along capacity. 2. Explore the option of creating a noise ordinance in public spaces on streets and sidewalks for gatherings of more than 50 people by issuing citations or other alternative options. Action: Not recommended. Chapter 5.80 of the City’s Municipal Code regulates parades and assemblies within the public right-of-way. The City’s Unruly Gathering Ordinance addresses certain gatherings on private property which “spill-out” and obstruct the public right-of-way. Further regulating the ability to gather within traditional public forums could infringe on the public’s right to assemble and/or free speech rights. The amendments made to the Unruly Gathering Ordinance allow the Police Department the ability to more effectively address gatherings that are causing a significant disturbance to a neighborhood. In addition, Penal Code section 415, commonly referred to a “disturbing the peace” addresses some of the unlawful impacts associated with large gatherings. 3. Consider expanding tools to enforce ordinances for nuisance properties including, but not limited to, “tagging” properties that meet a definition of a public nuisance or unruly gatherings in terms of both property-maintenance concerns and behavior issues. Action: Ongoing proactive enforcement by Code Enforcement and the Neighborhood Services Specialists are addressing chronic and nuisance properties. Behavioral issues are addressed by SLOPD in the enforcement of noise and the newly amended Unruly Gathering ordinances and Cal Poly University Police are enforcing municipal code violations (noise, unruly gathering, open container, public urination) in the neighborhoods up to one mile off campus. The Rental Housing Inspection Program will also help better address properties that are lacking basic safety and habitable conditions. All of these efforts should be fully implemented prior to considering another regulation that requires tagging properties that violate certain provisions of the Municipal Code. If the council wishes to pursue this added regulation staff recommends that it be considered after the first full cycle of the Residential Housing Inspection Program. 4. Evaluate policies so that new development or redevelopment does not unduly impact neighborhoods. Action: Action: In progress. Project plan for implementation of General Plan Program 2.13 (Neighborhood Compatibility) to be presented to Council by end of Fiscal Year 2015-2016. Objective Two – Define stakeholders’ needs and success 5. Evaluate best practices and implement strategies to reduce the number of disruptions from parties and noise in neighborhoods (as referenced in Objective Three) Action: Council amended the Unruly Gathering ordinance in August 2015 to strengthen the ordinance as an enforcement tool. Also in August 2015, Council approved the Memorandum of Understanding between the Police Department and 14 Packet Pg. 201 Cal Poly University Police (“UPD”) Department allowing UPD the ability to enforce municipal code ordinances up to one mile from campus. SLOPD will continue to evaluate other methods that may help reduce disruptions. 6. Develop and implement a rental housing inspection program. Action: A Rental Housing Inspection Program was adopted by City Council May 19, 2015 and the program is currently in development for phased implementation. Phase 1 – Amnesty to assist in legalizing unpermitted work or existing unpermitted dwelling units starting December 1, 2015. Postcards and flyers will sent out to property owners at the end of November 2015. Phase 2 – Registration of rental units begins January 1, 2016. Information mailed out starting last week of December 2015. Registration deadline will be March 15, 2016. Phase 3 – First Inspection is scheduled for April 2016. 7. Implement educational programs to increase the number of student-aged residents who bring in their trashcans on the same day the trash is picked up. Action: In progress. Neighborhood Services Specialists (NSS) participate in “Walk and Talks” educate residents of the Neighborhood Enhancement Ordinance regulations. NSS conducts proactive enforcement, speaking with residents face to face and using informational stickers that are applied directly to waste wheelers that have not been moved from the street. More challenging locations, such as Hathway Alley, have required a more focused approach from Code Enforcement and Utilities with great success. NSS has also begun outreach to residents at Farmers’ Market on Thursday evenings. 8. Continue to implement strategies to address homelessness in San Luis Obispo (particularly in the downtown area). Action: In progress and on-going. SLOPD will continue to work within strongly established community partnerships to provide focused service on identified needs using the Community Action Team (CAT), Downtown Bicycle Officers and patrol services. Engage and collaborated with stakeholders to provide education and awareness opportunities through programs such as the Directed Giving campaign. 9. Implement strategies to reduce traffic issues in neighborhoods. Consider using strategies identified in the Land Use and Circulation Element update to achieve this objective. Action: The City’s Neighborhood Traffic Management (NTM) Program encourages neighborhood residents to work with staff in developing strategies to address identified issues. The objective of the NTM program is to encourage citizens to be directly involved in addressing neighborhood traffic concerns and to provide a process that results in equitable and affordable solutions to the traffic problems in a neighborhood. Neighborhood traffic safety and operational issues on all other streets and intersections fall under the scope of the City’s Annual Traffic Safety and Biennial Traffic Operations Programs. Neighborhood parking issues fall under the scope of the City’s Residential Parking District Program. 14 Packet Pg. 202 Objective Three – Identify university/city best practices 10. Work with the City to generate a neighborhood map of housing rental properties and provide outreach to student renters by funding welcome bags for neighbors to distribute to establish positive interactions. Action: Currently, SLOPD Neighborhood Outreach provides rack cards and door hangers to residents wishing to conduct focused outreach to various properties/residents. In addition, the Police Department and Code Enforcement “Walk and Talks” are the personal contacts and provision of educational materials to thousands of residents at the beginning of the academic year. Neighborhoods, such as Alta Vista, visit properties annually with a welcome letter sharing information and expectations with new residents. Given limited resources and funding, the City is not in a position to complete this objective. Further discussion to determine program viability is recommended. 11. Create a Renter/Rental Housing Inspection Program Action: See #6 under Objective 2. 12. Implement a Party Registration Program. Develop a program to incentivize party registration that provides the opportunity for the San Luis Obispo Police Department to contact the party registrant and offer a 20-minute warning before dispatching S.N.A.P. or a police officer. Action: Research concept for viability. Analysis of a program that could be created with current resource as well as best practices will be conducted – Fall 2016. 13. Develop proactive engagement of law and code enforcement with visits to properties of concern; “Knock and Talk”. Action: Complete. Neighborhood Officer and Neighborhood Services Specialists “Knock and Talks” established in Fall of 2014 and are continuing. Objective Four – Review enforcement best practices 14. City and Cal Poly officials to craft a MOU between the City and University regarding police operational protocol within a one-mile radius of campus. Action: Complete. Council approved the MOU in August 2015. UPD officers were provided training prior to the start of the 2015 academic year and are actively enforcing municipal code violations in the neighborhoods within one mile of campus 15. Partner Cal Poly and Cuesta police officers with San Luis Obispo Neighborhood Officers to coordinate resources and achieve program goals. Action: University Police officers currently partner with SLOPD officers during traditionally busy time periods (start of school, Halloween) as staffing allows. This is 14 Packet Pg. 203 possible wth UPD because the campus is contiguous to the City. The use of C uesta PD officers is not realistic given Cuesta’s lack of proximity to the City and their resources. 16. Implement a keg registration program. Action: Research practicality of keg registration program – present findings to Council in May 2016. 17. Conduct an internal assessment of the San Luis Obispo Police Department staffing to prepare for growth within the city and on the Cal Poly campus to ensure staffing needs match the population. Action: Staffing assessment, primarily patrol and dispatch, is addressed in the Strategic Plan being developed by the Police Department and will be presented to Council in March 2016. 18. Explore the possibility of Cal Poly Police being able to issue City Municipal Administrative Citations. Action: Established per the MOU (#14 above). Objective Five – Engage stakeholders: review current educational & information efforts 19. Create an annual communications plan containing neighborhood wellness messages and a process for communicating the information effectively to maximize resources Action – Communication plan created for Fall/Winter 2015 by a subcommittee consisting of residents, Cuesta Student Government, Cal Poly staff from Orientation, Housing, Greek Life, Administration and ASI, City Code Enforcement and Neighborhood Outreach. The subcommittee will meet every six months to continue with the planning and delivery of neighborhood wellness messaging to ensure effectiveness. Student Community Liaison Committee Established in 1987, the Student Community Liaison Committee (SCLC) serves as a mechanism of communication between Cal Poly, Cuesta College, San Luis Obispo County and the City of San Luis Obispo. The mission of SCLC is to “proactively engage in discussion to promote positive relations, mutual respect and improved quality of life for all citizens of San Luis Obispo.” Per the current SCLC Memorandum of Understanding, the City provides meeting space, two City Council representatives to include the mayor, who is a voting member, and a rotating council member and three voting members: the City Manager, the Police Chief and the Neighborhood Outreach Manager. (Attachment B) SCLC has been an excellent venue for the agencies to share information and work to improve community relationships. In assessment of the City of San Luis Obispo membership, staff recommends that the voting membership of the Mayor, City Manager, Police Chief and Neighborhood Outreach remain unchanged. As there are times when meeting conflicts arise, the 14 Packet Pg. 204 Assistant City Manager, Police Captains and Community Development Director would be asked to attend for coverage and participation. Staff also recommends maintaining the rotating Council Member structure as SCLC provides the opportunity to information sharing and community relationship building. CONCURRENCES The Community Development Department, Public Works, and Finance Department concur with the recommendations for action in this report. FISCAL IMPACT There are no fiscal impacts from the recommendations contained in this report. The Rental Housing Inspection Program was approved in May 2015. Funding for the program was adopted as part of the 2015-2017 Financial Plan. The additional actions recommended in this report will be completed with existing resources. ALTERNATIVE 1. Do not approve recommended actions. Request that staff return with further alternative actions at a later date. Attachments: a - Neighborhood Wellness Report - Final b - SCLC MOU Final 5-16-13 14 Packet Pg. 205 San Luis Obispo Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort FINAL REPORT Spring 2015 - Enhancing the quality of life for all residents - 14.a Packet Pg. 206 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS OVERVIEW ................................................................................................................................................. 3 PROCESS ..................................................................................................................................................... 4 OBJECTIVE ONE: Define short-term actions to enhance the quality of life .............................................. 5 OBJECTIVE TWO: Define stakeholders’ needs and success ....................................................................... 7 OBJECTIVE THREE: Identify university/city best practices ................................................................... 10 OBJECTIVE FOUR: Review enforcement best practices .......................................................................... 17 OBJECTIVE FIVE: Engage stakeholders: review current educational & information efforts .................. 23 OBJECTIVE SIX: Prepare for sustained engagement to achieve desired vision & goal ............................ 25 APPENDIX A: Working Group Membership ........................................................................................... 28 APPENDIX B: Council Agenda Report .................................................................................................... 29 APPENDIX C: Full Survey Report ........................................................................................................... 54 APPENDIX D: Matrix of All Action Items .............................................................................................. 70 APPENDIX E: Post March 7 Recommendations ...................................................................................... 76 APPENDIX F: Maintaining Balanced Neighborhoods Report .................................................................. 79 14.a Packet Pg. 207 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 3 OVERVIEW ith the focus of making San Luis Obispo an even more vibrant community for residents and students to reside in, community representatives, Cal Poly and Cuesta College administrators, students and San Luis Obispo city staff have worked side by side to coordinate their efforts through the Neighborhood Wellness/ Community Civility Effort. The effort was launched in May of 2013 with the support of the San Luis Obispo City Council, Cal Poly President Jeffrey Armstrong, and Cuesta College President/Superintendent Gil Stork. This initiative aimed to discuss the changing culture of neighborhoods in San Luis Obispo resulting from the shifts of owner-occupied households to the increase in rental units, specifically by student-aged individuals. Collectively, the working group has a vision of building “a community in which year-round residents and students actively collaborate to build community and communicate in an environment that fosters mutual respect and understanding.” The unified goal of the working group has been to develop ideas for stakeholder consideration that are intended to “enhance the quality of life for all residents.” The group responded to the six objectives created by the San Luis Obispo City Council with subsequent recommendations, desired outcomes, implementation leads and partners, and timelines for implementation. The objectives are outlined below, and each is addressed thoroughly in this report.  Define short-term actions to enhance the quality of life  Define stakeholders’ needs and success  Identify university/city best practices  Review enforcement best practices  Engage stakeholders: review current educational and information efforts  Prepare for sustained engagement to achieve desired vision and goal W From the recommendations above and active collaboration within the working group, three overall themes emerged:  Increase communications from Cal Poly and Cuesta College  Develop responses through solution-oriented initiatives  Set in motion proactive measures to avoid repeating past mistakes and preventing new problems from occurring 14.a Packet Pg. 208 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 4 PROCESS Beginning work in October of 2013, the Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort working group conducted a thoughtful study of the objectives outlined by the San Luis Obispo City Council and created a process to efficiently move the community into action. Champions were assigned to each objective, and the subsequent 13 meetings, hosted by Cuesta College, were devoted to discussions of the objectives, led by the champions. Champions for the objectives are presented below: Note: Names in parentheses denote past working group members. During the robust discussions for each objective the entire working group offered feedback on the work of the champions and direction on how to proceed. Each group returned to conduct further studies based on the feedback and direction of this group. The champions provided recommendations to the working group in late 2014. Each of the recommendations were discussed and affirmed during the monthly meetings, which focused specifically on one particular objective. It is those recommendations that are presented in this report. OBJECTIVE ONE: Karen Adler, Julie Towery OBJECTIVE TWO: Katie Lichtig, Joi Sullivan (Jason Colombini), Dr. Anthony Gutierrez, Juventino Ortiz OBJECTIVE THREE: Derek Johnson, Stephanie Teaford (Justin Wellner, Betsy Kinsley) OBJECTIVE FOUR: Joe Arteaga, Steve Gesell, George Hughes, Chris Staley, Brenda Trobaugh OBJECTIVE FIVE: Scott Chedester (Charles Scovell), Dr. Anthony Gutierrez, Kimberly Hampton, Joi Sullivan (Jason Colombini), Christine Wallace OBJECTIVE SIX: Dr. Keith Humphrey, Sandee McLaughlin 14.a Packet Pg. 209 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 5 Goal To define short-term actions that could be implemented to enhance the quality of life for all residents, particularly associated in the timeframe around the start of Cal Poly’s fall term. OBJECTIVE ONE: Define short-term actions to enhance the quality of life Champions Karen Adler, Community Julie Towery, Community Background Historically, there has been an increase in calls for service around the neighborhood areas adjacent to Cal Poly coinciding with start of the school year. This objective is set to define what short-term actions could lead to positive long-term effects during that timeframe. Short-term actions are also distributed among all objectives, thus are not exclusive to objective one. Recommendations  Schedule regular neighborhood tours with city council, mayor, neighbors, Cal Poly and Cuesta College leaders, etc.  Investigate establishing Student Neighborhood Auxiliary Patrol (S.N.A.P.) Ride-Along program and promote current Police Ride Along program  Explore the option of creating a noise ordinance in public spaces on streets and sidewalks for gatherings of more than 50 people by issuing citations or other alternative options  Consider expanding tools to enforce ordinances for nuisance properties including, but not limited to, “tagging” properties that meet a definition of a public nuisance or unruly gatherings in terms of both property-maintenance concerns and behavior issues  Evaluate policies so that new development or redevelopment does not unduly impact neighborhoods 14.a Packet Pg. 210 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 6 Actions Desired Outcomes Implementation Leads & Partners Timeline for Implementation Schedule regular neighborhood tours with city council, mayor, neighbors, Cal Poly and Cuesta leaders, etc. Allow neighbors to point out neighborhood issues Cal Poly Ongoing, began Summer of 2014 Investigate establishing S.N.A.P. Ride-Along program and promote current Police Ride Along program Increase the amount of support to assist with complaints and allow officers to do other police work City of San Luis Obispo Fall 2015 Explore the option of creating a noise ordinance in public spaces on streets and sidewalks for gatherings of more than 50 people by issuing citations or other alternative options Decrease number of noise complaints City of San Luis Obispo Spring 2016 Consider expanding tools to enforce ordinances for nuisance properties including, but not limited to, “tagging” properties that meet a definition of a public nuisance or unruly gatherings in terms of both property- maintenance concerns and behavior issues Hold repeat noise violators accountable City of San Luis Obispo Spring 2016 Evaluate policies so that new development or redevelopment does not unduly impact neighborhoods. Decrease properties that allow for high occupancy City of San Luis Obispo Fall 2016 14.a Packet Pg. 211 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 7 OBJECTIVE TWO: Define stakeholders’ needs and success Champions Dr. Anthony Gutierrez, Cuesta College Katie Lichtig, City of San Luis Obispo Juventino Ortiz, Community Joi Sullivan (Jason Colombini), Cal Poly Goal For Cal Poly, Cuesta College and the City of San Luis Obispo to use the results of the community-wide survey to suggest efforts for implementation to address community-defined issues. Background The purpose of this objective is to identify the stakeholders’ needs and suggest solutions so that the outcomes reflect a desired environment for the community. To obtain a comprehensive assessment of the community’s needs and what success looked like, a communitywide survey was mailed in May of 2014. A total of 3, 774 surveys were completed and returned, physically and electronically. Of the completed surveys, 1,706 were from non- student residents, 1,783 were from individuals identifying themselves as either Cal Poly or Cuesta students, and 318 individuals did not associate themselves with any group. The full survey results and discussion is offered in Appendix C. Recommendations The assessment results provided a clearer picture of the stakeholder perceptions, which helped develop potential recommendations, such as:  Evaluate best practices and implement strategies to reduce the number of disruptions from parties and noise in neighborhoods (as referenced in Objective Three)  Develop and implement a rental housing inspection program  Implement a range of strategies to change the relationship and culture between students and non-students in neighborhoods  Explore and implement strategies to address the concentration of bars in the downtown area and related safety issues. Consider using strategies identified in the Land Use and Circulation Element (LUCE) update to achieve this objective  Implement educational programs to increase the number of student-aged residents who bring in their trashcans on the same day the trash is picked up  Implement strategies to reduce traffic issues in neighborhoods. Consider using strategies identified in the Land Use and Circulation Element update to achieve this objective 14.a Packet Pg. 212 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 8  Continue to implement strategies to address homelessness in San Luis Obispo (particularly in the downtown area) Actions Desired Outcomes Implementation Leads & Partners Timeline for Implementation Evaluate best practices and implement strategies to reduce the number of disruptions from parties and noise in neighborhoods (as referenced in Objective Three) Reduce noise disruptions Cal Poly and Cuesta College (programmatic) City of San Luis Obispo (enforcement) Fall 2015 Develop and implement a rental housing inspection program Insure that rental units comply with required minimum health and safety standards City of San Luis Obispo Fall 2016 Implement a range of strategies to change the relationship and culture between students and non-students in neighborhoods (no specific recommendations discerned from the survey results) Improve student and community relationships Cal Poly Associated Student, Inc. (ASI) and Associate Students for Cuesta College (ASCC) Spring 2016 Explore and implement strategies to address the concentration of bars in the downtown area and related safety issues. Consider using strategies identified in the Land Use and Circulation Element update to achieve this objective Address and decrease safety-related issues City of San Luis Obispo Ongoing per LUCE strategies Implement educational programs to increase the number of student-aged residents who bring in their trashcans on the same day the trash is picked up Increase the number of student-age residents to comply with the 24-hour ordinance City of San Luis Obispo Ongoing Continue to implement strategies to address homelessness in San Luis Obispo (particularly in the downtown area) A reduction in the impacts of homelessness on the community City of San Luis Obispo Ongoing 14.a Packet Pg. 213 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 9 Implement strategies to reduce traffic issues in neighborhoods. Consider using strategies identified in the Land Use and Circulation Element update to achieve this objective Reduce traffic-related issues in neighborhoods City of San Luis Obispo Ongoing 14.a Packet Pg. 214 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 10 OBJECTIVE THREE: Identify university/city best practices Champions Derek Johnson, City of San Luis Obispo Stephanie Teaford (Betsy Kinsley, Justin Wellner), Cal Poly Goal To identify best practices that can be undertaken by Cal Poly, in collaboration with the City of San Luis Obispo, to enhance positive interactions between students and permanent residents. Background Universities and colleges across the nation impact the communities in which they exist in both positive and negative ways. The impact of students in residential neighborhoods has prompted higher education institutions to share best practices that can lead to improvements in community relationships and mitigate negative impacts. The objective explored various programs and efforts undertaken by universities and colleges nationwide. The following recommendations could provide a framework for improving relations between student residents and permanent residents of San Luis Obispo. 14.a Packet Pg. 215 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 11 Recommendations To address student rental properties  Create and implement a transition to Off-Campus Living Education Program, to be shared with Cuesta College’s Student Life Office  Include expectations and responsibilities of living in neighborhoods in the City of San Luis Obispo (e.g. local ordinances)  The successful completion of a culminating test will result in a Preferred Renter Certification with potential benefits offered by landlords  Work with the city to generate a neighborhood map of housing rental properties and provide outreach to student renters by funding welcome bags for neighbors to distribute to establish positive interactions (University of Colorado, Boulder)  Create a Renter/Rental Housing Inspection Program. Students and landlords can work together for preferred renter/rental designation o Beautification Program: “Door Decal” or “Golden Arrow” for upkeep of property and meeting standards for appearance and safety o Student Affairs Awards: Awarded yearly to no-complaint housing (LaSalle University) o Preferred rental properties listed with the city o Request the release of judicial information to off campus entities (Plymouth State University) 14.a Packet Pg. 216 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 12 To alleviate nighttime noise and to build compassion and understanding  Develop outreach and marketing efforts toward students (University of Massachusetts, Amherst)  Implement a Party Registration Program. Develop a program to incentivize party registration that provides the opportunity for the San Luis Obispo Police Department to contact the party registrant and offer a 20-minute warning before dispatching S.N.A.P. or a police officer. This provides the students a way to minimize impacts on enforcement resources (University of Colorado, Boulder)  Initiate Dialog Dinners or Block Parties for students and residents to talk about what they like most about their neighborhoods (University of Colorado, Boulder)  Promote the principles of the The Mustang Way in neighborhoods: o Student Neighborhood Liaisons: Block parties/events for networking. (University of Minnesota, Twin Cities & Towson University) o Neighborhood Helping Hands: Volunteerism for neighbor assistance (e.g. fruit picking, ladder needs, barn raising, etc.). Coordinate with campus departments to provide Learn by Doing experiences within neighborhoods for senior projects and other work-related majors such as horticulture, landscape architecture, construction management and others. o Peer-to-peer engagement for neighborhood policing; “Walk this Way Program” (University of Massachusetts, Amherst) 14.a Packet Pg. 217 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 13 To improve collaboration and understanding among students, non-students and city groups, and to increase engagement in problem solving  Continue to engage and communicate collaboratively among students, non-students and city groups. See Student Community Liaison Committee (SCLC), below.  Utilize various on-campus departments and offices that support living off-campus (Off- Campus Student Life; Cuesta College Student Life and Leadership; Student & Community Relations; Office of Neighborhood Life; Student Neighborhood Relations; Neighborhood University Relations and Neighbors; and Student Life and Leadership at Cuesta College) to: o Support all students, non-students, and permanent residents in the communities surrounding Cal Poly o Educate students about university policies and local ordinances o Continue to build and strengthen neighborhood relations by facilitating dialogue o Promote civic citizenship to create a positive quality of life for everyone living in the neighborhoods (Georgetown University) o Specific communications and strategies could include:  A 100 percent response policy for any time, any issue, by enforcing a prompt and meaningful response  The police provide a blueprint that lets students and neighbors know exactly what to expect when a community concern is registered with the university  The policy will establish a standard for reporting an incident (through a university helpline); clear steps that would be taken for follow-up with the student (through an updated sanction chart) and community members; and what data would be collected to create a metric to evaluate student success and outcomes (Georgetown University)  Sustained conflict resolution services such as “SLO Solutions,” a jointly sponsored citywide conflict-resolution program specifically designed to address student-neighbor issues and provide a means for constructive resolution. Since 2004, this program has used the services of Creative Mediation to resolve a variety of community disputes at no cost to those seeking mediation  Sustained SCLC effort. For more than 20 years, Cal Poly’s Associated Students, Inc. (ASI), Associated Students of Cuesta College (ASCC), and the city have served as leaders on the committee. It was established to further student and community communication and develop positive relationships 14.a Packet Pg. 218 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 14  Neighborhood Concerns Phone Line: Neighbors can call in with concerns. Cal Poly and Cuesta College staff can recommend actions and contact students (Colorado University, Boulder)  Quarterly walkabouts and coffee sessions with city residents and representatives from Cal Poly, Cuesta College and the city  One-hour walkabouts will be scheduled, every third month and will take place at various times throughout the neighborhoods surrounding the campus. During these walks they will explore student housing rentals, party atmosphere, traffic impacts and Greek housing  One-hour coffee sessions or “listening sessions” will be scheduled every third month, in the afternoon, at a local venue to discuss such topics as the Cal Poly Master Plan and vision for the future, diversity and inclusivity, students in the community, and year- end accomplishments and challenges  Develop proactive engagement of law and code enforcement with visits to properties of concern; “Knock and Talk” (University of Maryland).  Implement a Joint Letter Program. Police contact with students in off-campus housing who generates letters signed by the university, police and city that outlines expectations. It is sent to the resident and landlord (University of Oregon) o Tagging for repeat offending or problem properties 14.a Packet Pg. 219 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 15 Actions Desired Outcomes Implementation Leads & Partners Timeline for Implementation Create and implement a transition to Off-Campus Living Education Program, to be shared with Cuesta College’s Student Life Office Set expectations and responsibilities for students living in neighborhoods in the City of San Luis Obispo Cal Poly Summer 2015 Work with the city to generate a neighborhood map of housing rental properties and provide outreach to student renters by funding welcome bags for neighbors to distribute to establish positive interactions Establish positive interaction with City Cal Poly ASI , ASCC, City of San Luis Obispo Spring 2016 Create a Renter/Rental Housing Inspection Program Rental properties that meet minimum health and safety standards Cal Poly, City of San Luis Obispo Spring 2016 Develop outreach and marketing efforts toward students Raise awareness of the impacts of noise on neighborhood Cal Poly Spring 2016 Implement a Party Registration Program. Develop a program to incentivize party registration that provides the opportunity for the San Luis Obispo Police Department to contact the party registrant and offer a 20- minute warning before dispatching S.N.A.P. or a police officer Fewer noise citations City of San Luis Obispo Spring 2016 Initiate Dialog Dinners or Block Parties for students and residents to talk about what they like most about their neighborhoods Create positive interactions between students and year- round residents Cal Poly ASI, ASCC Ongoing Promote the principles of the The Mustang Way in neighborhoods Enhance a positive culture of peer-to-peer accountability in neighborhoods Cal Poly ASI Ongoing 14.a Packet Pg. 220 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 16 Continue to engage and communicate collaboratively among students, non-students and city groups Improve collaboration and understanding among students, non- students and city groups SCLC Ongoing Utilize various on-campus departments and offices that support living off-campus to support students, non- students and permanent residents living in neighborhoods. Educate students about university policies and ordinances, strengthen neighborhood relations by facilitating dialogs Cal Poly & Cuesta College Fall 2015 Develop proactive engagement of law and code enforcement with visits to properties of concern; “Knock and Talk”. Positive engagement with law enforcement and decrease repeat offending properties City of San Luis Obispo Ongoing Implement a Joint Letter Program. Police contact with students in off-campus housing generates letter signed by university, police and city that outlines expectations sent to resident and landlord Cal Poly Fall 2015 14.a Packet Pg. 221 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 17 Goal That Cal Poly, Cuesta College and the City of San Luis Obispo police departments consider implementing strategies to address community civility and quality-of-life matters. OBJECTIVE FOUR: Review enforcement best practices Champions Joe Arteaga, Cuesta College Steve Gesell, City of San Luis Obispo George Hughes, Cal Poly Chris Staley, City of San Luis Obispo Brenda Trobaugh, Cal Poly 14.a Packet Pg. 222 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 18 Background In the past several years, both Cal Poly and the City of San Luis Obispo have engaged in numerous programs to address quality of life and community wellness. Both organizations have expanded professional staff dedicated to neighborhood wellness, created and modified ordinances, and implemented new programs to address pubic disorder and nuisance crimes including but not limited to: Amendments to the noise ordinance In 2010 the San Luis Obispo Police Department made recommendations to the city council regarding changes to the existing noise ordinance to improve noise reduction efforts. The modifications included reducing the number of allowable warnings to one every nine months and to hold residential property owners responsible for repeat noise violations. Many landlords have since added language to their lease and rental agreements with penalties levied to their tenants who receive noise violations. These modifications were accepted by city council and noise complaints were significantly reduced by 30 percent for the following year and have been maintained since (see Table 1 below). Table 1: Total noise party violations reported from 2009 to 2014. 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Noise Violations 2584 2238 2013 1644 1672 1729 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 Noise Party Violations 14.a Packet Pg. 223 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 19 Unruly Gathering Ordinance In 2010 the San Luis Obispo Police Department conducted research on Unruly Gathering Ordinances. After extensive research and outreach to the community and Cal Poly, an Unruly Gathering Ordinance was proposed and accepted by the city council. The ordinance was intended to prevent substantial disturbances on private property in a neighborhood. This included unlawful and disruptive behavior by large groups of people. On April 6, 2010, the city council adopted section SLMC 9.13.030 Prohibition of Unruly Gatherings. A violation of the Unruly Gathering Ordinance consists of hosting a gathering on private property that:  Involves 20 people or more; and  Involves unlawful conduct that creates a substantial disturbance in a significant segment of a neighborhood. “Unlawful conduct that results in a substantial disturbance can include such things as excessive noise, public drunkenness, serving alcohol to minors, fighting, urinating in public, crowds overflowing into yards, sidewalks, or streets, or similar unlawful behaviors.” Neighborhood Officer Program The San Luis Obispo Police Department initiated its Neighborhood Officer Program on December 1, 2013. The goal of the Neighborhood Officer Program is to quickly identify community issues, concerns, problems and crime trends that have long-term quality-of-life impacts on a particular neighborhood. The Neighborhood Officer Program allows for officers to coordinate resources to help solve these problems. This model of policing is both a philosophy and an organizational strategy that allows police and community residents to work closely together in new ways to solve problems associated with crime, fear of crime, social disorder and neighborhood decay. Attainable goals of this program include:  Maintain or increase public confidence in the Police Department  Decrease fear of crime  Listen to and address citizen concerns  Bring community resources together to solve problems  Impact specific crime problems  Reduce repetitive calls for service  Educate the public about its Police Department 14.a Packet Pg. 224 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 20 Student Community Success Program In 2013 Cal Poly hired a full-time off-campus student life coordinator to be both proactive and reactive in supporting students and neighborhood residents with neighborhood wellness initiatives. Responsibilities of the position include:  Coordinate the resolution of off-campus conduct with university administration, city government and community members to find solutions for student’s problems or concerns  Assist in mediating and resolving student/community conflicts  Effect change in the social climate and relationships with specific responsibility of working with students and their neighbors within the local community  Implement training sessions, presentations, and educational programs regarding substance abuse, civic and social responsibility One goal of the program is to create a Student Community Success Program with the mission to help students be successful off campus and address community concerns. The program is intended to change and encourage inappropriate behavior through community and student meetings, workshops, leadership panels, and peer-mentoring opportunities. Cal Poly University Police Off-Campus Patrols By authority of the California Penal Code, the University Police Department has legal authority to exercise peace officer powers within a one-mile radius of the exterior boundaries of campus (see Appendix A). In 2014 Cal Poly hired two additional police officers to expand proactive patrols within the neighborhoods directly adjacent to campus. The focus of these patrols has been to proactively discourage and enforce public disorder crimes. Recommendations  City and Cal Poly officials should craft a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) agreement between the city and university regarding police operational protocol  Partner Cal Poly and Cuesta police officers with San Luis Obispo Neighborhood Officers to coordinate resources and achieve program goals 14.a Packet Pg. 225 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 21  City should explore additional proactive educational opportunities with Cal Poly and Cuesta College to change the student culture related to neighborhood wellness  Implement a keg registration program  Conduct an internal assessment of the San Luis Obispo Police Department staffing to prepare for growth within the city and on the Cal Poly campus to ensure staffing needs match the population  Conduct an internal assessment of the University Police Department staffing to meet the growth on the Cal Poly campus  Explore the possibility of Cal Poly Police being able to issue City Municipal Administrative Citations  Location of a university police substation within the new residence hall project to coordinate law enforcement problem-solving efforts 14.a Packet Pg. 226 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 22 Actions Desired Outcomes Implementation Leads & Partners Timeline for Implementation City and Cal Poly officials to craft a Memorandum of Understanding agreement between the city and university regarding police operational protocol within a one- mile radius Allows for coordination of resources to quickly respond to community concerns Cal Poly, City of San Luis Obispo Fall 2015 Partner Cal Poly and Cuesta police officers with San Luis Obispo Neighborhood Officers to coordinate resources and achieve program goals To coordinate resources and obtain program goals City of San Luis Obispo Fall 2015 City should explore additional proactive educational opportunities with Cal Poly and Cuesta College to change the student culture related to neighborhood wellness Change student culture related to neighborhood wellness SCLC Fall 2016, and with each annual report Implement a keg registration program A reduction in underage alcohol use and an accountability mechanism for persons who serve minors City of San Luis Obispo Fall 2016 Conduct an internal assessment of the San Luis Obispo Police Department staffing to prepare for growth within the city and on the Cal Poly campus to ensure staffing needs match the population Meet the needs of the community as population grows City of San Luis Obispo Spring 2016 Conduct an internal assessment of the University Police Department staffing to meet the growth on the Cal Poly campus Meet the needs of Cal Poly as student population grows Cal Poly Spring 2016 Explore the possibility of Cal Poly Police being able to issue City Municipal Administrative Citations To be able to patrol in neighborhoods adjacent to Cal Poly campus Addressed via MOU identified above Location of a university police substation within the new residence hall project to coordinate law enforcement problem-solving efforts Coordinate law enforcement outreach and problem solving efforts Cal Poly Fall 2018 14.a Packet Pg. 227 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 23 Goal To engage stakeholders: review current educational and informational efforts. OBJECTIVE FIVE: Engage stakeholders: review current educational & information efforts Champions Scott Chedester (Charles Scovell), Cuesta College Dr. Anthony Gutierrez, Cuesta College Kimberly Hampton, Cal Poly Joi Sullivan (Jason Colombini), Cal Poly Christine Wallace, City of San Luis Obispo Background This objective examines the methods, content and effectiveness of educational efforts put forward by Cal Poly, Cuesta College, the City of San Luis Obispo, and student resident groups. The inventory of channels of communication was compiled by representatives of Cal Poly, Cuesta College, and the City of San Luis Obispo. Neighborhood wellness meeting attendees, Cal Poly and Cuesta College student focus groups were presented with the inventory. An additional student subcommittee met to discuss the effectiveness of current methods and content. Suggestions for outreach changes made during the presentations based on the content effectiveness are reflected in the recommendations of this report. Recommendations The recommendation is to collaboratively create an annual communications plan containing neighborhood wellness messages and a process for communicating the information effectively to maximize resources. The communication plan should be reassessed annually to evaluate effectiveness and to ensure resources are not duplicated or wasted. Communications plan participants could consist of representatives from Cal Poly, Cuesta College and the city. Suggestions for the Subcommittee  Produce a variety of impactful electronic and print media to educate residents on property maintenance standards, with a specific focus on repeat offenders in neighborhoods 14.a Packet Pg. 228 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 24  Revive the Off-Campus Housing Guide (University of Colorado, Boulder)  Produce video for new Cuesta College students to view as part of the required online orientation on “how to be a good neighbor”  Produce “good neighbor” and Safety Enhancement Zone videos for www.respectslo.com (Linked to Cal Poly websites and campus television stations)  Cal Poly University Housing bulletin boards made available for “good neighbor” and Safety Enhancement Zone messaging  Cuesta College bulletin boards are made available for “good neighbor” and Safety Enhancement Zone messaging.  Create and play radio public service announcements on KCPR  Conduct annual presentations to Block P – Cal Poly Athletics  Develop an information distribution plan with off-campus housing providers and property management; request Safety Enhancement and good neighbor materials be posted  Housing resident assistant training to include off-campus impacts  Create better avenues of communication with Greek Life house owners  Produce Safety Enhancement Zone door hangers  Produce banners and sandwich boards to be displayed in the Cal Poly and Cuesta College university unions about community and neighborhood wellness issues  Produce table tents in Cal Poly University Union and Cuesta College cafeteria  Involve off-campus housing providers (property management companies, housing complex managers) in outreach efforts Actions Desired Outcomes Implementation Leads & Partners Timeline for Implementation Create an annual communications plan containing neighborhood wellness messages and a process for communicating the information effectively to maximize resources Effectively inform the community on matters of neighborhood wellness City of San Luis Obispo Winter 2015 14.a Packet Pg. 229 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 25 Goal The purpose of objective six of the report is to ensure that the plans developed in objectives one through five are implemented, assessed, and folded into the regular operations of the appropriate agency (for ongoing efforts). Additionally, the goal is to sustain regular communications between Cal Poly, Cuesta College, the City of San Luis Obispo, residents and students. OBJECTIVE SIX: Prepare for sustained engagement to achieve desired vision & goal Champions Dr. Keith Humphrey, Cal Poly Sandee McLaughlin, Cuesta College Background Neighborhood wellness issues in San Luis Obispo have historically been fragmented within each agency by implementing its own projects, causing confusion among year-round residents, and limiting the effectiveness of each individual effort. There is a unified desire among all constituencies in San Luis Obispo to see the quality of life improve in neighborhoods, and a structure to coordinate these efforts was missing. For almost three decades, the Student- Community Liaison Committee (SCLC) has brought the students of Cal Poly and Cuesta College together with city officials and residents for communication and discussion. This forum has been valuable to all parties, as any culture change related to neighborhood wellness rests with the students. Recommendations  Re-invest in the Student-Community Liaison Committee  The Student-Community Liaison Committee should assess the effectiveness of each recommendation once they have been implemented  Shift SCLC memberships  Host an annual town hall meeting 14.a Packet Pg. 230 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 26 Actions Desired Outcomes Implementation Leads & Partners Timeline for Implementation Re-invest in the Student- Community Liaison Committee Become the coordinating body responsible for monitoring the recommendations, once adopted by the city council, Cal Poly and Cuesta College SCLC Fall 2015, ongoing The Student-Community Liaison Committee should assess the effectiveness of each recommendation once they have been implemented Recommend the appropriate changes, and produce an annual report on the state of neighborhood wellness in the City of San Luis Obispo SCLC Ongoing Shift SCLC memberships SCLC memberships should be reevaluated to directly involve those individuals (by their position) most directly involved in neighborhood wellness SCLC Spring 2016 Host an annual town hall meeting Present their report to the community, receive feedback and suggestions from the broader San Luis Obispo community SCLC Spring 2016, ongoing 14.a Packet Pg. 231 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 27 14.a Packet Pg. 232 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Neighborhood Wellness/Community Civility Effort, Final Report | San Luis Obispo, CA Page 28 - Enhancing the quality of life for all residents - 14.a Packet Pg. 233 At t a c h m e n t : a - N e i g h b o r h o o d W e l l n e s s R e p o r t - F i n a l ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) 14.b Packet Pg. 234 At t a c h m e n t : b - S C L C M O U F i n a l 5 - 1 6 - 1 3 ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) 14.b Packet Pg. 235 At t a c h m e n t : b - S C L C M O U F i n a l 5 - 1 6 - 1 3 ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) 14.b Packet Pg. 236 At t a c h m e n t : b - S C L C M O U F i n a l 5 - 1 6 - 1 3 ( 1 1 4 8 : A c t i o n f o r C i v i l i t y R e p o r t R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s ) Page intentionally left blank.