Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutBatch 091 Hicks, Bailey From:Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Friday, October 19, 2018 2:32 PM To:Hill, Robert Cc:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Coming Back Around... Robert/Chris  No worries and I’m glad that you are leaning to launch in 2020 rather than wait for another year or two. I’ll wait on  setting anything in motion at my end until I know, with a reasonable degree of certainty, that you plan to recommend  joining MBCP to your governing Boards.    Best    Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        From: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, October 19, 2018 2:06 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>; Read,  Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Coming Back Around...    Hi Tom, We really appreciate your thoughtful, gracious, and very patient consideration of us. Thank you. As you might expect, we will be having serious internal discussions right away. More very soon… Best regards, Bob Robert Hill Interim Deputy Director City Administration 2 Office of Sustainability 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E rhill@slocity.org T 805.781.7211 slocity.org  From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, October 19, 2018 10:52 AM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>; Read, Chris  <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Coming Back Around...    Hi Shawn/Robert/Chris  Attached is MBCP Implementation plan for your reference. I want to add few observations to Shawn’s recollection of our  conversation  1‐ The legality of one JPA formed for the purpose of becoming a CCA joining another CCA may not work for 2  reasons; 1) Rule 23 that permits the formation of CCA allows municipalities and counties with defined boarders  to form or become part of a CCA. I don’t believe that extends to a JPA and even if it does; 2) MBCP’s JPA allows  members to terminate their membership provided that they take responsibility of decisions made on their  behalf prior to their withdrawal. I think that would be very difficult to enforce if the member is a JPA rather than  a city or a county.  2‐ The costly proposition of customer outreach, notifications and enrollment will be difficult to do if it’s done in the  name of another JPA, especially if that entity (in this case CCCE) has no responsibility to the SLO/Morro Bay  customers. Furthermore, our members in Santa Cruz and San Benito may demand the same treatment, sending  our marketing effort down the rabbit hole  3‐ I’m not advocating that SLO/Morro Bay abandon the CCCE brand, in fact I do like the name and in a few years, If  I would advocate for a change in name, CCCE would be an ideal one. I’m, however, suggesting that SLO hold on  to the name and redirect their mission to implementing energy efficiency and other programs that we are not  likely to begin promoting until we can get funding from the CEC, CPUC or other sources.  Finally, and to be blunt, if you guys want in, then be “ALL IN”, but if identity and local control is of paramount  importance to you, then bite the bullet, raise the funds and do your own thing.  And that’s my two cents    Best         Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2018 6:27 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>; Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> Subject: Coming Back Around...   3   Tom,   On behalf of Bob Hill and Chris Read who are leading the CCA effort down in San Luis Obispo, I want to thank  you for your time and graciousness on the phone this afternoon… and your willingness to entertain (yet  again!) the idea of expanding MBCP’s membership to include SLO communities.  By way of this email, I am  sharing MBCP’s JPA Agreement with Chris and Bob and outlining some of the terms and next steps that we  discussed.  Bob and Chris will follow up with you directly once they’ve had the chance to review the JPA  Agreement and discuss internally.     DRAFT Terms:   Membership: Central Coast Community Energy (CCCE) as a new JPA serving SLO County communities would  join MBCP as a full voting member  Governance: CCCE would have one seat on the MBCP Ops and Policy Boards to start; additional seats  allocated as per the population thresholds described in the JPA Agreement  Cost to Join: None, other than CCCE (or its member cities) will cover initial legal costs for JPA review and  technical consultant costs to prepare the amended Implementation Plan  Branding/Identity: In concept, Tom is fine with CCCE retaining its name and brand identity at the local level;  will need to check with PG&E on bill labeling. MBCP may also choose to change its name to reflect a broader  service territory (final approach TBD).  Revenues and Expenditures: Revenues and expenditures will remain under the purview of MBCP and its  Board; no separate accounting  Rate Setting/Power Options: CCCE will become part of MBCP’s existing rate design, pricing structure and  power product options   Programs: MBCP’s programs will be offered within the SLO service territory as they are throughout MBCP’s  existing territory; opportunities for local power procurement will be available on the same basis as other  MBCP members (generally through RFPs)  CAC: CCCE may appoint a community member to MBCP’s CAC; MBCP will not support a separate CAC for CCCE Staffing: Will be provided by existing MBCP staff; in the future, would consider hiring a local staff person to  liaison with HQ in Monterey    Action Items:   Greg Stapanicich to affirm legality of a JPA joining another JPA   Greg and city attorneys to review MBCP’s JPA Agreement to flag questions or issues  Tom to send word version of MBCP’s Implementation Plan so TEA can update/amend (if given the green light) Tom to handle internal load analysis related to CCCE expansion  11/7 ‐ 1st CCCE Board meeting to provide direction on whether to pursue membership in MBCP; if yes…  11/14 – MBCP Ops Board meets; provide recommendation to approve (or not) CCCE’s membership  12/5 – MBCP Policy Board meets; approve CCCE as new member and adopt the amended Implementation  Plan (assuming its ready)    2019: Program integration and enrollment for early 2020 launch    I think that covers it for now.  Tom, please add/amend if I missed anything.  Thanks all, S‐     Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org 4   5 Hicks, Bailey From:Hill, Robert Sent:Friday, October 19, 2018 2:06 PM To:Tom Habashi;shawn marshall;Read, Chris Subject:RE: Coming Back Around... Hi Tom, We really appreciate your thoughtful, gracious, and very patient consideration of us. Thank you. As you might expect, we will be having serious internal discussions right away. More very soon… Best regards, Bob Robert Hill Interim Deputy Director City Administration Office of Sustainability 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E rhill@slocity.org T 805.781.7211 slocity.org  From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, October 19, 2018 10:52 AM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>; Read, Chris  <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Coming Back Around...    Hi Shawn/Robert/Chris  Attached is MBCP Implementation plan for your reference. I want to add few observations to Shawn’s recollection of our  conversation  1‐ The legality of one JPA formed for the purpose of becoming a CCA joining another CCA may not work for 2  reasons; 1) Rule 23 that permits the formation of CCA allows municipalities and counties with defined boarders  to form or become part of a CCA. I don’t believe that extends to a JPA and even if it does; 2) MBCP’s JPA allows  members to terminate their membership provided that they take responsibility of decisions made on their  behalf prior to their withdrawal. I think that would be very difficult to enforce if the member is a JPA rather than  a city or a county.  2‐ The costly proposition of customer outreach, notifications and enrollment will be difficult to do if it’s done in the  name of another JPA, especially if that entity (in this case CCCE) has no responsibility to the SLO/Morro Bay  6 customers. Furthermore, our members in Santa Cruz and San Benito may demand the same treatment, sending  our marketing effort down the rabbit hole  3‐ I’m not advocating that SLO/Morro Bay abandon the CCCE brand, in fact I do like the name and in a few years, If  I would advocate for a change in name, CCCE would be an ideal one. I’m, however, suggesting that SLO hold on  to the name and redirect their mission to implementing energy efficiency and other programs that we are not  likely to begin promoting until we can get funding from the CEC, CPUC or other sources.  Finally, and to be blunt, if you guys want in, then be “ALL IN”, but if identity and local control is of paramount  importance to you, then bite the bullet, raise the funds and do your own thing.  And that’s my two cents    Best         Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2018 6:27 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>; Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> Subject: Coming Back Around...     Tom,   On behalf of Bob Hill and Chris Read who are leading the CCA effort down in San Luis Obispo, I want to thank  you for your time and graciousness on the phone this afternoon… and your willingness to entertain (yet  again!) the idea of expanding MBCP’s membership to include SLO communities.  By way of this email, I am  sharing MBCP’s JPA Agreement with Chris and Bob and outlining some of the terms and next steps that we  discussed.  Bob and Chris will follow up with you directly once they’ve had the chance to review the JPA  Agreement and discuss internally.     DRAFT Terms:   Membership: Central Coast Community Energy (CCCE) as a new JPA serving SLO County communities would  join MBCP as a full voting member  Governance: CCCE would have one seat on the MBCP Ops and Policy Boards to start; additional seats  allocated as per the population thresholds described in the JPA Agreement  Cost to Join: None, other than CCCE (or its member cities) will cover initial legal costs for JPA review and  technical consultant costs to prepare the amended Implementation Plan  Branding/Identity: In concept, Tom is fine with CCCE retaining its name and brand identity at the local level;  will need to check with PG&E on bill labeling. MBCP may also choose to change its name to reflect a broader  service territory (final approach TBD).  Revenues and Expenditures: Revenues and expenditures will remain under the purview of MBCP and its  Board; no separate accounting  7 Rate Setting/Power Options: CCCE will become part of MBCP’s existing rate design, pricing structure and  power product options   Programs: MBCP’s programs will be offered within the SLO service territory as they are throughout MBCP’s  existing territory; opportunities for local power procurement will be available on the same basis as other  MBCP members (generally through RFPs)  CAC: CCCE may appoint a community member to MBCP’s CAC; MBCP will not support a separate CAC for CCCE Staffing: Will be provided by existing MBCP staff; in the future, would consider hiring a local staff person to  liaison with HQ in Monterey    Action Items:   Greg Stapanicich to affirm legality of a JPA joining another JPA   Greg and city attorneys to review MBCP’s JPA Agreement to flag questions or issues  Tom to send word version of MBCP’s Implementation Plan so TEA can update/amend (if given the green light) Tom to handle internal load analysis related to CCCE expansion  11/7 ‐ 1st CCCE Board meeting to provide direction on whether to pursue membership in MBCP; if yes…  11/14 – MBCP Ops Board meets; provide recommendation to approve (or not) CCCE’s membership  12/5 – MBCP Policy Board meets; approve CCCE as new member and adopt the amended Implementation  Plan (assuming its ready)    2019: Program integration and enrollment for early 2020 launch    I think that covers it for now.  Tom, please add/amend if I missed anything.  Thanks all, S‐     Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org   8 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Friday, October 19, 2018 1:31 PM To:Gregory W. Stepanicich Cc:Read, Chris;Hill, Robert Subject:Re: Coming Back Around... Actually, MBCP doesn’t have one member/one vote.  It is a voting structure based on population size with  shared seats for communities under 50,000 (or something like that).  Still, I agree that there may need to be  some amendments to MBCP’s JPA – and this is likely something that Tom would require CCCE to pay for…     Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org   From: "Gregory W. Stepanicich" <GStepanicich@rwglaw.com>  Date: Friday, October 19, 2018 at 1:26 PM  To: 'shawn marshall' <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>  Cc: "Read, Chris" <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Coming Back Around...     Tom’s first point is the one that I am concerned about.  There also are operational issues.  The Monterey JPA Agreement  would need to be amended.  Since each member has one vote, this creates a problem for CCCE as it would get just one  vote for two or more cities.      From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Friday, October 19, 2018 1:24 PM  To: Gregory W. Stepanicich <GStepanicich@rwglaw.com>  Cc: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: FW: Coming Back Around...      Hey Greg,   See below for Tom Habashi’s comments on the legal question (in yellow) and if you want to scroll down to  read the recap of the original conversation, please do. Not sure if you concur with Tom’s assessment, but  worth noting his concerns. Cheers, S‐     Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org    9 From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Date: Friday, October 19, 2018 at 10:52 AM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>, Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>, "Read, Chris"  <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Coming Back Around...      Hi Shawn/Robert/Chris  Attached is MBCP Implementation plan for your reference. I want to add few observations to Shawn’s recollection of our  conversation  1‐ The legality of one JPA formed for the purpose of becoming a CCA joining another CCA may not work for 2  reasons; 1) Rule 23 that permits the formation of CCA allows municipalities and counties with defined boarders  to form or become part of a CCA. I don’t believe that extends to a JPA and even if it does; 2) MBCP’s JPA allows  members to terminate their membership provided that they take responsibility of decisions made on their  behalf prior to their withdrawal. I think that would be very difficult to enforce if the member is a JPA rather than  a city or a county.  2‐ The costly proposition of customer outreach, notifications and enrollment will be difficult to do if it’s done in the  name of another JPA, especially if that entity (in this case CCCE) has no responsibility to the SLO/Morro Bay  customers. Furthermore, our members in Santa Cruz and San Benito may demand the same treatment, sending  our marketing effort down the rabbit hole  3‐ I’m not advocating that SLO/Morro Bay abandon the CCCE brand, in fact I do like the name and in a few years, If  I would advocate for a change in name, CCCE would be an ideal one. I’m, however, suggesting that SLO hold on  to the name and redirect their mission to implementing energy efficiency and other programs that we are not  likely to begin promoting until we can get funding from the CEC, CPUC or other sources.  Finally, and to be blunt, if you guys want in, then be “ALL IN”, but if identity and local control is of paramount  importance to you, then bite the bullet, raise the funds and do your own thing.  And that’s my two cents     Best          Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org          From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2018 6:27 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>; Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> Subject: Coming Back Around...      Tom,   On behalf of Bob Hill and Chris Read who are leading the CCA effort down in San Luis Obispo, I want to thank  you for your time and graciousness on the phone this afternoon… and your willingness to entertain (yet  again!) the idea of expanding MBCP’s membership to include SLO communities.  By way of this email, I am  sharing MBCP’s JPA Agreement with Chris and Bob and outlining some of the terms and next steps that we  10 discussed.  Bob and Chris will follow up with you directly once they’ve had the chance to review the JPA  Agreement and discuss internally.      DRAFT Terms:   Membership: Central Coast Community Energy (CCCE) as a new JPA serving SLO County communities would  join MBCP as a full voting member  Governance: CCCE would have one seat on the MBCP Ops and Policy Boards to start; additional seats  allocated as per the population thresholds described in the JPA Agreement  Cost to Join: None, other than CCCE (or its member cities) will cover initial legal costs for JPA review and  technical consultant costs to prepare the amended Implementation Plan  Branding/Identity: In concept, Tom is fine with CCCE retaining its name and brand identity at the local level;  will need to check with PG&E on bill labeling. MBCP may also choose to change its name to reflect a broader  service territory (final approach TBD).  Revenues and Expenditures: Revenues and expenditures will remain under the purview of MBCP and its  Board; no separate accounting  Rate Setting/Power Options: CCCE will become part of MBCP’s existing rate design, pricing structure and  power product options   Programs: MBCP’s programs will be offered within the SLO service territory as they are throughout MBCP’s  existing territory; opportunities for local power procurement will be available on the same basis as other  MBCP members (generally through RFPs)  CAC: CCCE may appoint a community member to MBCP’s CAC; MBCP will not support a separate CAC for CCCE Staffing: Will be provided by existing MBCP staff; in the future, would consider hiring a local staff person to  liaison with HQ in Monterey     Action Items:   Greg Stapanicich to affirm legality of a JPA joining another JPA   Greg and city attorneys to review MBCP’s JPA Agreement to flag questions or issues  Tom to send word version of MBCP’s Implementation Plan so TEA can update/amend (if given the green light) Tom to handle internal load analysis related to CCCE expansion  11/7 ‐ 1st CCCE Board meeting to provide direction on whether to pursue membership in MBCP; if yes…  11/14 – MBCP Ops Board meets; provide recommendation to approve (or not) CCCE’s membership  12/5 – MBCP Policy Board meets; approve CCCE as new member and adopt the amended Implementation  Plan (assuming its ready)     2019: Program integration and enrollment for early 2020 launch     I think that covers it for now.  Tom, please add/amend if I missed anything.  Thanks all, S‐      Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org      Click here to report this email as spam.  11 Hicks, Bailey From:Gregory W. Stepanicich <GStepanicich@rwglaw.com> Sent:Friday, October 19, 2018 1:27 PM To:'shawn marshall' Cc:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Coming Back Around... Tom’s first point is the one that I am concerned about.  There also are operational issues.  The Monterey JPA Agreement  would need to be amended.  Since each member has one vote, this creates a problem for CCCE as it would get just one  vote for two or more cities.     From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Friday, October 19, 2018 1:24 PM  To: Gregory W. Stepanicich <GStepanicich@rwglaw.com>  Cc: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: FW: Coming Back Around...     Hey Greg,   See below for Tom Habashi’s comments on the legal question (in yellow) and if you want to scroll down to  read the recap of the original conversation, please do. Not sure if you concur with Tom’s assessment, but  worth noting his concerns. Cheers, S‐     Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org    From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Date: Friday, October 19, 2018 at 10:52 AM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>, Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>, "Read, Chris"  <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Coming Back Around...      Hi Shawn/Robert/Chris  Attached is MBCP Implementation plan for your reference. I want to add few observations to Shawn’s recollection of our  conversation  1‐ The legality of one JPA formed for the purpose of becoming a CCA joining another CCA may not work for 2  reasons; 1) Rule 23 that permits the formation of CCA allows municipalities and counties with defined boarders  to form or become part of a CCA. I don’t believe that extends to a JPA and even if it does; 2) MBCP’s JPA allows  members to terminate their membership provided that they take responsibility of decisions made on their  behalf prior to their withdrawal. I think that would be very difficult to enforce if the member is a JPA rather than  a city or a county.  2‐ The costly proposition of customer outreach, notifications and enrollment will be difficult to do if it’s done in the  name of another JPA, especially if that entity (in this case CCCE) has no responsibility to the SLO/Morro Bay  12 customers. Furthermore, our members in Santa Cruz and San Benito may demand the same treatment, sending  our marketing effort down the rabbit hole  3‐ I’m not advocating that SLO/Morro Bay abandon the CCCE brand, in fact I do like the name and in a few years, If  I would advocate for a change in name, CCCE would be an ideal one. I’m, however, suggesting that SLO hold on  to the name and redirect their mission to implementing energy efficiency and other programs that we are not  likely to begin promoting until we can get funding from the CEC, CPUC or other sources.  Finally, and to be blunt, if you guys want in, then be “ALL IN”, but if identity and local control is of paramount  importance to you, then bite the bullet, raise the funds and do your own thing.  And that’s my two cents     Best          Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org          From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2018 6:27 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>; Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> Subject: Coming Back Around...      Tom,   On behalf of Bob Hill and Chris Read who are leading the CCA effort down in San Luis Obispo, I want to thank  you for your time and graciousness on the phone this afternoon… and your willingness to entertain (yet  again!) the idea of expanding MBCP’s membership to include SLO communities.  By way of this email, I am  sharing MBCP’s JPA Agreement with Chris and Bob and outlining some of the terms and next steps that we  discussed.  Bob and Chris will follow up with you directly once they’ve had the chance to review the JPA  Agreement and discuss internally.      DRAFT Terms:   Membership: Central Coast Community Energy (CCCE) as a new JPA serving SLO County communities would  join MBCP as a full voting member  Governance: CCCE would have one seat on the MBCP Ops and Policy Boards to start; additional seats  allocated as per the population thresholds described in the JPA Agreement  Cost to Join: None, other than CCCE (or its member cities) will cover initial legal costs for JPA review and  technical consultant costs to prepare the amended Implementation Plan  Branding/Identity: In concept, Tom is fine with CCCE retaining its name and brand identity at the local level;  will need to check with PG&E on bill labeling. MBCP may also choose to change its name to reflect a broader  service territory (final approach TBD).  Revenues and Expenditures: Revenues and expenditures will remain under the purview of MBCP and its  Board; no separate accounting  13 Rate Setting/Power Options: CCCE will become part of MBCP’s existing rate design, pricing structure and  power product options   Programs: MBCP’s programs will be offered within the SLO service territory as they are throughout MBCP’s  existing territory; opportunities for local power procurement will be available on the same basis as other  MBCP members (generally through RFPs)  CAC: CCCE may appoint a community member to MBCP’s CAC; MBCP will not support a separate CAC for CCCE Staffing: Will be provided by existing MBCP staff; in the future, would consider hiring a local staff person to  liaison with HQ in Monterey     Action Items:   Greg Stapanicich to affirm legality of a JPA joining another JPA   Greg and city attorneys to review MBCP’s JPA Agreement to flag questions or issues  Tom to send word version of MBCP’s Implementation Plan so TEA can update/amend (if given the green light) Tom to handle internal load analysis related to CCCE expansion  11/7 ‐ 1st CCCE Board meeting to provide direction on whether to pursue membership in MBCP; if yes…  11/14 – MBCP Ops Board meets; provide recommendation to approve (or not) CCCE’s membership  12/5 – MBCP Policy Board meets; approve CCCE as new member and adopt the amended Implementation  Plan (assuming its ready)     2019: Program integration and enrollment for early 2020 launch     I think that covers it for now.  Tom, please add/amend if I missed anything.  Thanks all, S‐      Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org    Click here to report this email as spam. 14 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Friday, October 19, 2018 1:24 PM To:Gregory W. Stepanicich Cc:Read, Chris Subject:FW: Coming Back Around... Attachments:MBCP Implementation Plan 8.2017.docx Hey Greg,   See below for Tom Habashi’s comments on the legal question (in yellow) and if you want to scroll down to  read the recap of the original conversation, please do. Not sure if you concur with Tom’s assessment, but  worth noting his concerns. Cheers, S‐    Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org   From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Date: Friday, October 19, 2018 at 10:52 AM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>, Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>, "Read, Chris"  <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Coming Back Around...     Hi Shawn/Robert/Chris  Attached is MBCP Implementation plan for your reference. I want to add few observations to Shawn’s recollection of our  conversation  1‐ The legality of one JPA formed for the purpose of becoming a CCA joining another CCA may not work for 2  reasons; 1) Rule 23 that permits the formation of CCA allows municipalities and counties with defined boarders  to form or become part of a CCA. I don’t believe that extends to a JPA and even if it does; 2) MBCP’s JPA allows  members to terminate their membership provided that they take responsibility of decisions made on their  behalf prior to their withdrawal. I think that would be very difficult to enforce if the member is a JPA rather than  a city or a county.  2‐ The costly proposition of customer outreach, notifications and enrollment will be difficult to do if it’s done in the  name of another JPA, especially if that entity (in this case CCCE) has no responsibility to the SLO/Morro Bay  customers. Furthermore, our members in Santa Cruz and San Benito may demand the same treatment, sending  our marketing effort down the rabbit hole  3‐ I’m not advocating that SLO/Morro Bay abandon the CCCE brand, in fact I do like the name and in a few years, If  I would advocate for a change in name, CCCE would be an ideal one. I’m, however, suggesting that SLO hold on  to the name and redirect their mission to implementing energy efficiency and other programs that we are not  likely to begin promoting until we can get funding from the CEC, CPUC or other sources.  Finally, and to be blunt, if you guys want in, then be “ALL IN”, but if identity and local control is of paramount  importance to you, then bite the bullet, raise the funds and do your own thing.  And that’s my two cents     15 Best          Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org          From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2018 6:27 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>; Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> Subject: Coming Back Around...      Tom,   On behalf of Bob Hill and Chris Read who are leading the CCA effort down in San Luis Obispo, I want to thank  you for your time and graciousness on the phone this afternoon… and your willingness to entertain (yet  again!) the idea of expanding MBCP’s membership to include SLO communities.  By way of this email, I am  sharing MBCP’s JPA Agreement with Chris and Bob and outlining some of the terms and next steps that we  discussed.  Bob and Chris will follow up with you directly once they’ve had the chance to review the JPA  Agreement and discuss internally.      DRAFT Terms:   Membership: Central Coast Community Energy (CCCE) as a new JPA serving SLO County communities would  join MBCP as a full voting member  Governance: CCCE would have one seat on the MBCP Ops and Policy Boards to start; additional seats  allocated as per the population thresholds described in the JPA Agreement  Cost to Join: None, other than CCCE (or its member cities) will cover initial legal costs for JPA review and  technical consultant costs to prepare the amended Implementation Plan  Branding/Identity: In concept, Tom is fine with CCCE retaining its name and brand identity at the local level;  will need to check with PG&E on bill labeling. MBCP may also choose to change its name to reflect a broader  service territory (final approach TBD).  Revenues and Expenditures: Revenues and expenditures will remain under the purview of MBCP and its  Board; no separate accounting  Rate Setting/Power Options: CCCE will become part of MBCP’s existing rate design, pricing structure and  power product options   Programs: MBCP’s programs will be offered within the SLO service territory as they are throughout MBCP’s  existing territory; opportunities for local power procurement will be available on the same basis as other  MBCP members (generally through RFPs)  CAC: CCCE may appoint a community member to MBCP’s CAC; MBCP will not support a separate CAC for CCCE Staffing: Will be provided by existing MBCP staff; in the future, would consider hiring a local staff person to  liaison with HQ in Monterey     Action Items:   Greg Stapanicich to affirm legality of a JPA joining another JPA   16 Greg and city attorneys to review MBCP’s JPA Agreement to flag questions or issues  Tom to send word version of MBCP’s Implementation Plan so TEA can update/amend (if given the green light) Tom to handle internal load analysis related to CCCE expansion  11/7 ‐ 1st CCCE Board meeting to provide direction on whether to pursue membership in MBCP; if yes…  11/14 – MBCP Ops Board meets; provide recommendation to approve (or not) CCCE’s membership  12/5 – MBCP Policy Board meets; approve CCCE as new member and adopt the amended Implementation  Plan (assuming its ready)     2019: Program integration and enrollment for early 2020 launch     I think that covers it for now.  Tom, please add/amend if I missed anything.  Thanks all, S‐      Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org    17 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Friday, October 19, 2018 11:15 AM To:Tom Habashi;Hill, Robert;Read, Chris Subject:Re: Coming Back Around... Thanks Tom.  This is helpful additional context now that you’ve had a chance to “sleep on it.” And we fully  understand the “all in” sentiment.  Once we hear back from Greg and the team further assesses the situation,  we’ll be back in touch.  Meanwhile, we are requesting a 30‐day extension on the I‐Plan which could be helpful  in any event.  We will keep you posted. S‐      Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org   From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Date: Friday, October 19, 2018 at 10:52 AM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>, Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>, "Read, Chris"  <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Coming Back Around...     Hi Shawn/Robert/Chris  Attached is MBCP Implementation plan for your reference. I want to add few observations to Shawn’s recollection of our  conversation  1‐ The legality of one JPA formed for the purpose of becoming a CCA joining another CCA may not work for 2  reasons; 1) Rule 23 that permits the formation of CCA allows municipalities and counties with defined boarders  to form or become part of a CCA. I don’t believe that extends to a JPA and even if it does; 2) MBCP’s JPA allows  members to terminate their membership provided that they take responsibility of decisions made on their  behalf prior to their withdrawal. I think that would be very difficult to enforce if the member is a JPA rather than  a city or a county.  2‐ The costly proposition of customer outreach, notifications and enrollment will be difficult to do if it’s done in the  name of another JPA, especially if that entity (in this case CCCE) has no responsibility to the SLO/Morro Bay  customers. Furthermore, our members in Santa Cruz and San Benito may demand the same treatment, sending  our marketing effort down the rabbit hole  3‐ I’m not advocating that SLO/Morro Bay abandon the CCCE brand, in fact I do like the name and in a few years, If  I would advocate for a change in name, CCCE would be an ideal one. I’m, however, suggesting that SLO hold on  to the name and redirect their mission to implementing energy efficiency and other programs that we are not  likely to begin promoting until we can get funding from the CEC, CPUC or other sources.  Finally, and to be blunt, if you guys want in, then be “ALL IN”, but if identity and local control is of paramount  importance to you, then bite the bullet, raise the funds and do your own thing.  And that’s my two cents     Best          18 Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org          From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2018 6:27 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>; Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> Subject: Coming Back Around...      Tom,   On behalf of Bob Hill and Chris Read who are leading the CCA effort down in San Luis Obispo, I want to thank  you for your time and graciousness on the phone this afternoon… and your willingness to entertain (yet  again!) the idea of expanding MBCP’s membership to include SLO communities.  By way of this email, I am  sharing MBCP’s JPA Agreement with Chris and Bob and outlining some of the terms and next steps that we  discussed.  Bob and Chris will follow up with you directly once they’ve had the chance to review the JPA  Agreement and discuss internally.      DRAFT Terms:   Membership: Central Coast Community Energy (CCCE) as a new JPA serving SLO County communities would  join MBCP as a full voting member  Governance: CCCE would have one seat on the MBCP Ops and Policy Boards to start; additional seats  allocated as per the population thresholds described in the JPA Agreement  Cost to Join: None, other than CCCE (or its member cities) will cover initial legal costs for JPA review and  technical consultant costs to prepare the amended Implementation Plan  Branding/Identity: In concept, Tom is fine with CCCE retaining its name and brand identity at the local level;  will need to check with PG&E on bill labeling. MBCP may also choose to change its name to reflect a broader  service territory (final approach TBD).  Revenues and Expenditures: Revenues and expenditures will remain under the purview of MBCP and its  Board; no separate accounting  Rate Setting/Power Options: CCCE will become part of MBCP’s existing rate design, pricing structure and  power product options   Programs: MBCP’s programs will be offered within the SLO service territory as they are throughout MBCP’s  existing territory; opportunities for local power procurement will be available on the same basis as other  MBCP members (generally through RFPs)  CAC: CCCE may appoint a community member to MBCP’s CAC; MBCP will not support a separate CAC for CCCE Staffing: Will be provided by existing MBCP staff; in the future, would consider hiring a local staff person to  liaison with HQ in Monterey     Action Items:   Greg Stapanicich to affirm legality of a JPA joining another JPA   Greg and city attorneys to review MBCP’s JPA Agreement to flag questions or issues  19 Tom to send word version of MBCP’s Implementation Plan so TEA can update/amend (if given the green light) Tom to handle internal load analysis related to CCCE expansion  11/7 ‐ 1st CCCE Board meeting to provide direction on whether to pursue membership in MBCP; if yes…  11/14 – MBCP Ops Board meets; provide recommendation to approve (or not) CCCE’s membership  12/5 – MBCP Policy Board meets; approve CCCE as new member and adopt the amended Implementation  Plan (assuming its ready)     2019: Program integration and enrollment for early 2020 launch     I think that covers it for now.  Tom, please add/amend if I missed anything.  Thanks all, S‐      Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org    20 Hicks, Bailey From:Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Friday, October 19, 2018 10:52 AM To:shawn marshall;Hill, Robert;Read, Chris Subject:RE: Coming Back Around... Attachments:MBCP Implementation Plan 8.2017.docx Hi Shawn/Robert/Chris  Attached is MBCP Implementation plan for your reference. I want to add few observations to Shawn’s recollection of our  conversation  1‐ The legality of one JPA formed for the purpose of becoming a CCA joining another CCA may not work for 2  reasons; 1) Rule 23 that permits the formation of CCA allows municipalities and counties with defined boarders  to form or become part of a CCA. I don’t believe that extends to a JPA and even if it does; 2) MBCP’s JPA allows  members to terminate their membership provided that they take responsibility of decisions made on their  behalf prior to their withdrawal. I think that would be very difficult to enforce if the member is a JPA rather than  a city or a county.  2‐ The costly proposition of customer outreach, notifications and enrollment will be difficult to do if it’s done in the  name of another JPA, especially if that entity (in this case CCCE) has no responsibility to the SLO/Morro Bay  customers. Furthermore, our members in Santa Cruz and San Benito may demand the same treatment, sending  our marketing effort down the rabbit hole  3‐ I’m not advocating that SLO/Morro Bay abandon the CCCE brand, in fact I do like the name and in a few years, If  I would advocate for a change in name, CCCE would be an ideal one. I’m, however, suggesting that SLO hold on  to the name and redirect their mission to implementing energy efficiency and other programs that we are not  likely to begin promoting until we can get funding from the CEC, CPUC or other sources.  Finally, and to be blunt, if you guys want in, then be “ALL IN”, but if identity and local control is of paramount  importance to you, then bite the bullet, raise the funds and do your own thing.  And that’s my two cents    Best         Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2018 6:27 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Robert Hill <rhill@slocity.org>; Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> Subject: Coming Back Around...     Tom,   21 On behalf of Bob Hill and Chris Read who are leading the CCA effort down in San Luis Obispo, I want to thank  you for your time and graciousness on the phone this afternoon… and your willingness to entertain (yet  again!) the idea of expanding MBCP’s membership to include SLO communities.  By way of this email, I am  sharing MBCP’s JPA Agreement with Chris and Bob and outlining some of the terms and next steps that we  discussed.  Bob and Chris will follow up with you directly once they’ve had the chance to review the JPA  Agreement and discuss internally.     DRAFT Terms:   Membership: Central Coast Community Energy (CCCE) as a new JPA serving SLO County communities would  join MBCP as a full voting member  Governance: CCCE would have one seat on the MBCP Ops and Policy Boards to start; additional seats  allocated as per the population thresholds described in the JPA Agreement  Cost to Join: None, other than CCCE (or its member cities) will cover initial legal costs for JPA review and  technical consultant costs to prepare the amended Implementation Plan  Branding/Identity: In concept, Tom is fine with CCCE retaining its name and brand identity at the local level;  will need to check with PG&E on bill labeling. MBCP may also choose to change its name to reflect a broader  service territory (final approach TBD).  Revenues and Expenditures: Revenues and expenditures will remain under the purview of MBCP and its  Board; no separate accounting  Rate Setting/Power Options: CCCE will become part of MBCP’s existing rate design, pricing structure and  power product options   Programs: MBCP’s programs will be offered within the SLO service territory as they are throughout MBCP’s  existing territory; opportunities for local power procurement will be available on the same basis as other  MBCP members (generally through RFPs)  CAC: CCCE may appoint a community member to MBCP’s CAC; MBCP will not support a separate CAC for CCCE Staffing: Will be provided by existing MBCP staff; in the future, would consider hiring a local staff person to  liaison with HQ in Monterey    Action Items:   Greg Stapanicich to affirm legality of a JPA joining another JPA   Greg and city attorneys to review MBCP’s JPA Agreement to flag questions or issues  Tom to send word version of MBCP’s Implementation Plan so TEA can update/amend (if given the green light) Tom to handle internal load analysis related to CCCE expansion  11/7 ‐ 1st CCCE Board meeting to provide direction on whether to pursue membership in MBCP; if yes…  11/14 – MBCP Ops Board meets; provide recommendation to approve (or not) CCCE’s membership  12/5 – MBCP Policy Board meets; approve CCCE as new member and adopt the amended Implementation  Plan (assuming its ready)    2019: Program integration and enrollment for early 2020 launch    I think that covers it for now.  Tom, please add/amend if I missed anything.  Thanks all, S‐     Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org 22   23 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Thursday, October 18, 2018 6:27 PM To:Tom Habashi;Hill, Robert;Read, Chris Subject:Coming Back Around... Attachments:Monterey Bay Community Power JPA Agreement EXECUTED.pdf Tom,   On behalf of Bob Hill and Chris Read who are leading the CCA effort down in San Luis Obispo, I want to thank  you for your time and graciousness on the phone this afternoon… and your willingness to entertain (yet  again!) the idea of expanding MBCP’s membership to include SLO communities.  By way of this email, I am  sharing MBCP’s JPA Agreement with Chris and Bob and outlining some of the terms and next steps that we  discussed.  Bob and Chris will follow up with you directly once they’ve had the chance to review the JPA  Agreement and discuss internally.     DRAFT Terms:   Membership: Central Coast Community Energy (CCCE) as a new JPA serving SLO County communities would  join MBCP as a full voting member  Governance: CCCE would have one seat on the MBCP Ops and Policy Boards to start; additional seats  allocated as per the population thresholds described in the JPA Agreement  Cost to Join: None, other than CCCE (or its member cities) will cover initial legal costs for JPA review and  technical consultant costs to prepare the amended Implementation Plan  Branding/Identity: In concept, Tom is fine with CCCE retaining its name and brand identity at the local level;  will need to check with PG&E on bill labeling. MBCP may also choose to change its name to reflect a broader  service territory (final approach TBD).  Revenues and Expenditures: Revenues and expenditures will remain under the purview of MBCP and its  Board; no separate accounting  Rate Setting/Power Options: CCCE will become part of MBCP’s existing rate design, pricing structure and  power product options   Programs: MBCP’s programs will be offered within the SLO service territory as they are throughout MBCP’s  existing territory; opportunities for local power procurement will be available on the same basis as other  MBCP members (generally through RFPs)  CAC: CCCE may appoint a community member to MBCP’s CAC; MBCP will not support a separate CAC for CCCE Staffing: Will be provided by existing MBCP staff; in the future, would consider hiring a local staff person to  liaison with HQ in Monterey    Action Items:   Greg Stapanicich to affirm legality of a JPA joining another JPA   Greg and city attorneys to review MBCP’s JPA Agreement to flag questions or issues  Tom to send word version of MBCP’s Implementation Plan so TEA can update/amend (if given the green light) Tom to handle internal load analysis related to CCCE expansion  11/7 ‐ 1st CCCE Board meeting to provide direction on whether to pursue membership in MBCP; if yes…  11/14 – MBCP Ops Board meets; provide recommendation to approve (or not) CCCE’s membership  12/5 – MBCP Policy Board meets; approve CCCE as new member and adopt the amended Implementation  Plan (assuming its ready)    24 2019: Program integration and enrollment for early 2020 launch    I think that covers it for now.  Tom, please add/amend if I missed anything.  Thanks all, S‐     Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org   25 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, October 3, 2018 9:01 AM To:Shawn Marshall Subject:FW: PCIA Proceeding Attachments:FINAL Mayors PCIA Letter_9.2.18.docx; MBCP Press Release_PCIA_Monterey Bay County Supervisors(1).pdf; SF SJ Oak Mayors Press Release 9-4-18 CPUC Fee Proposal(2).pdf From: Leora Broydo Vestel <leora@cal‐cca.org>   Sent: Friday, September 14, 2018 3:14 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Beth Vaughan <beth@cal‐cca.org>  Subject: Re: PCIA Proceeding    Hi Chris, Forwarding a few letters/press releases that were sent by CalCCA members, as well as a links to recent opinion pieces that make similar points. Opinions: https://cal-cca.org/fair-exit-fee-critical-to-renewable-energy-future/ https://cal-cca.org/why-puc-should-protect-clean-energy-innovation/ CalCCA press releases: https://cal-cca.org/120-elected-officials-urge-cpuc-to-issue-a-fair-and-equitable-pcia-decision/ https://cal-cca.org/calcca-calls-on-commission-to-reject-alternate-pcia-proposal/ You can also look at the comments in the PCIA proceeding, though they are somewhat technical: https://apps.cpuc.ca.gov/apex/f?p=401:57:0::NO 26 Let me know if you need additional materials. Best, Leora Leora Broydo Vestel  Director of Communications  California Community Choice Association  (415) 999-4757    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Sent: Friday, September 14, 2018 11:55 AM  To: Beth Vaughan  Cc: Leora Broydo Vestel  Subject: RE: PCIA Proceeding Hi Leora,    Please let me know when you are able to send the sample letters. We are happy to help in whatever way we can.    Best,    Chris     From: Beth Vaughan <beth@cal‐cca.org>   Sent: Tuesday, September 11, 2018 11:47 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Leora Broydo Vestel <leora@cal‐cca.org>  Subject: RE: PCIA Proceeding     Hi Chris,     It’s never too late. I’m copying in Leora who can send you some sample letters that other jurisdictions have been  sending in to the PUC.  With consideration of the PD and APD delayed until 9/27, there is an argument for staggering  letters thru the next couple of weeks.  Reply comments are due on Thursday and I anticipate that we may see a revised  decision.  If that’s the case, we will be updating letters to reflect our advocacy on the revisions.     Let’s stay in touch over the next few weeks.     Best,     Beth  27    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Tuesday, September 11, 2018 11:34 AM  To: Beth Vaughan <beth@cal‐cca.org>  Subject: PCIA Proceeding     Hi Beth,    I know it is a bit late in the game, but we are still interested in at least sending a letter to the PUC from our Mayor regarding the PCIA. Can you advise on best approach?    Thanks,     Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  28 Hicks, Bailey From:Hilary Staver <hilary.staver@svcleanenergy.org> Sent:Thursday, September 27, 2018 9:42 AM To:kwells@cityoflancasterca.org;jcregar@co.santa- barbara.ca.us;tom.moody@ci.corona.ca.us;kmorris@hermosabch.org;julie.benabente@sanjoseca.gov; msears@cityofdavis.org;spoonhour@wrcog.cog.ca.us;dking@cosb.org;tprill@sanjacintoca.us;kbarrow s@cvag.org;hmartinez@cordobacorp.com;Beth Vaughan;mswan@applevalley.org;Hendry, James;Mskolnik@ceo.lacounty.gov;CC Song;Tom Habashi;Joseph F. Wiedman;Katherine Hernandez;aretalla@placer.ca.gov;acampbell@redwoodenergy.org;Neal Reardon;Joseph Moon;Ramirez, Manuel;Dan Griffiths;Shalini Swaroop;Michael Callahan;Nathaniel Malcolm (nmalcolm@mcecleanenergy.org);Jenine Windeshausen;dtibbs@aes4u.com;rengel@redwoodenergy.org;Steve Shupe;CB Hall;leah.goldberg@sanjoseca.gov;kelli.parmley@sanjoseca.gov;Greg Wade;scott.green@sanjoseca.gov;Ty Tosdal;cnajera@encinitasca.gov;cbrown@delmar.ca.us;jason.haber@carlsbadca.gov;MLahsaiezadeh@ ci.oceanside.ca.us;Read, Chris;Hill, Robert;Sheridan Pauker;Tim Lindl Cc:Tom Habashi;Barbara Spoonhour;jgwynn@redwoodenergy.org;Huynh, Leanna;Kofi Antobam;Kathy Schmachtenberger;Erin Maker Subject:Agenda for CalCCA Affiliate Monthly Regulatory Discussion Attachments:CalCCA Affiliate Regulatory Discussion agenda 27Sept18.pdf Good Morning Affiliate Team,    Please find attached the agenda for our September regulatory discussion call. Multiple voting delays have kept Phase 1  of the PCIA proceeding going a month longer than expected, while the two other major proceedings, Integrated  Resource Planning and Resource Adequacy, are both in a state of uncertainty. I look forward to discussing these and  other topics at 10:00 am today.     Best,  Hilary  CalCCA Regulatory Committee Chair  SVCE is committed to protecting customer privacy. Learn more about our privacy policy at:  https://www.svcleanenergy.org/customer‐confidentiality   29 Hicks, Bailey From:Leora Broydo Vestel <leora@cal-cca.org> Sent:Friday, September 14, 2018 3:14 PM To:Read, Chris Cc:Beth Vaughan Subject:Re: PCIA Proceeding Attachments:FINAL Mayors PCIA Letter_9.2.18.docx; MBCP Press Release_PCIA_Monterey Bay County Supervisors(1).pdf; SF SJ Oak Mayors Press Release 9-4-18 CPUC Fee Proposal(2).pdf Hi Chris, Forwarding a few letters/press releases that were sent by CalCCA members, as well as a links to recent opinion pieces that make similar points. Opinions: https://cal-cca.org/fair-exit-fee-critical-to-renewable-energy-future/ https://cal-cca.org/why-puc-should-protect-clean-energy-innovation/ CalCCA press releases: https://cal-cca.org/120-elected-officials-urge-cpuc-to-issue-a-fair-and-equitable-pcia-decision/ https://cal-cca.org/calcca-calls-on-commission-to-reject-alternate-pcia-proposal/ You can also look at the comments in the PCIA proceeding, though they are somewhat technical: https://apps.cpuc.ca.gov/apex/f?p=401:57:0::NO Let me know if you need additional materials. Best, Leora Leora Broydo Vestel  Director of Communications  California Community Choice Association  (415) 999-4757    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Sent: Friday, September 14, 2018 11:55 AM  To: Beth Vaughan  Cc: Leora Broydo Vestel  Subject: RE: PCIA Proceeding Hi Leora,    Please let me know when you are able to send the sample letters. We are happy to help in whatever way we can.  30   Best,    Chris     From: Beth Vaughan <beth@cal‐cca.org>   Sent: Tuesday, September 11, 2018 11:47 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Leora Broydo Vestel <leora@cal‐cca.org>  Subject: RE: PCIA Proceeding     Hi Chris,     It’s never too late. I’m copying in Leora who can send you some sample letters that other jurisdictions have been  sending in to the PUC.  With consideration of the PD and APD delayed until 9/27, there is an argument for staggering  letters thru the next couple of weeks.  Reply comments are due on Thursday and I anticipate that we may see a revised  decision.  If that’s the case, we will be updating letters to reflect our advocacy on the revisions.     Let’s stay in touch over the next few weeks.     Best,     Beth     From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Tuesday, September 11, 2018 11:34 AM  To: Beth Vaughan <beth@cal‐cca.org>  Subject: PCIA Proceeding     Hi Beth,    I know it is a bit late in the game, but we are still interested in at least sending a letter to the PUC from our Mayor regarding the PCIA. Can you advise on best approach?    Thanks,     Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  31 Hicks, Bailey From:eric@slocleanenergy.org on behalf of Eric Veium <eric@carbonfreeslo.org> Sent:Wednesday, September 12, 2018 3:26 PM To:Read, Chris Cc:Mark Bachman Subject:Re: Need SLO contact Fantastic!  That is exactly who we are looking for.    Please connect us.    Thank you Mark!    Best,  Eric    On Wed, Sep 12, 2018 at 12:32 PM, Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> wrote:  Hi Mark,    Great seeing you as well. I will connect you with Eric Veium, the chair of the SLO Climate Coalition Task Force (cc’d). Thanks for reaching out!  Best,    Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org      From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Wednesday, September 12, 2018 12:02 PM  32 To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: FW: Need SLO contact     Hi Chris,     It was great seeing you at the CalCCA conference.      Our head of H.R. is personally connected to a new SLO resident that is an “absolute power house for community  organizing” and wants to support the CCE program launch.  Do you have a lead on community outreach or a member of  the public with whom I could connect her?      Thank you.     Mark     Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org     From: cynjordan@att.net <cynjordan@att.net>   Sent: Wednesday, September 12, 2018 10:26 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: cynjordan@att.net  Subject: Need SLO contact     Hi Mark –  A dear friend – and one of the most energized social activists you’ll ever meet – just moved to SLO county.  She and  many neighbors/customers/etc have been reading about the CCA work going on down there.  She wants to get them all  involved in advocating for it with local gov’t and politicians.  Can you give me the name of a CCA contact that she can  connect with and offer to do some volunteer work for?  Thanks  33 C      From: Beth Trenchard <btrenchard@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Wednesday, September 12, 2018 9:57 AM  To: cynjordan@att.net  Subject: RE: Power to the People!     This is great!       Mark Bachman worked quite a bit with Tom on SLO – I’m sure he would have some good contacts.     B  *     From: cynjordan@att.net <cynjordan@att.net>   Sent: Wednesday, September 12, 2018 7:44 AM  To: Beth Trenchard <btrenchard@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: FW: Power to the People!     Hi –  Pls see below.  Do you remember the office we met at in Felton and the woman who hosted the meeting on Puerto  Rico hurricane assistance?  She recently moved to San Luis Obispo county.  She is an absolute power house for  community organizing and doing “good things” – as you saw.  She just got connected with the CCA movement  there.  She is organizing the locals and wants to connect with the political/gov’t person(s) advocating for CCAs.  I know  that we’ve sent some staffers there to give them a hand.  Can you tell me who that was – or do you know the name of  the SLO advocates?  Thanks  C      From: Lyndia11 <lyndia11@gmail.com>   Sent: Tuesday, September 11, 2018 10:45 PM  34 To: Cynthia Jordan <cynjordan@att.net>  Subject: Re: Power to the People!     Hi Cynthia  I just joined a group that is called next door, for people in my neighborhood… there was a comment about PGE & I  responded with "a group is forming here for our own electric coop"… not knowing much about it and still got a big  response… people want to know where… how…. I am sure I could get 2‐300 people signed up…. can’t wait for the name  to push this along!     Lance in San Juans, bringing our boat parts back…. yesterday was difficult for me… anniversary of Julian’s passing  today… so much grief over what might have been. I put my energy into making & canning salsa and tomatoes to keep  myself busy…      Much Love,   Lyndia         On Sep 11, 2018, at 8:45 PM, cynjordan <cynjordan@att.net> wrote:     Hi  Our CCA has been mentoring SLO as they ramp up. Give me a day or 2 to get you a contact name.  C           Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone     ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Original message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐  From: Lyndia11 <lyndia11@gmail.com>   35 Date: 9/11/18 8:29 AM (GMT‐08:00)   To: Cynthia Jordan <cynjordan@att.net>   Subject: Power to the People!      Good Morning Cynthia   I am hoping you can get me the contact person for the energy program that is budding here in San Luis  Obispo County… wanting it for myself to connect with them and  to pass it along to my neighbors.      Looking forward to meeting your friend….we are now in communication. She is a sweetheart…. offered  to come to the house and feed the feral cat hanging around here while we are in Denver…. I have  others who will do it, but what a gem she is to offer!     Thanks Cynthia,      Lyndia      PS: Did you get a personal trainer? If not, do you want me to make a couple of calls and see if I can find  one that might work?         Lyndia Storey-Leonard  lyndia11@gmail.com  831-250-3103 (Cell)   831-704-7369 (Office)  www.newphoenixrising.com/avatar        36                   Lyndia Storey-Leonard  lyndia11@gmail.com  831-250-3103 (Cell)   831-704-7369 (Office)  www.newphoenixrising.com/avatar                         37 Hicks, Bailey From:Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Monday, September 10, 2018 7:08 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:Re: Cal CCA Hi Chris Sorry I missed you at the conference, it was a little hectic to say the least. Hope is well and on target to get you guys on line in early 2020. Best of luck manuvering through the process, but with TEA guiding the way, you will be fine Get Outlook for Android From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Sent: Monday, September 10, 2018 4:48:42 PM  To: Tom Habashi  Cc: Hill, Robert  Subject: Cal CCA      Hi Tom,    Hope you are well. I was hoping to speak with you at Cal CCA, but you were very busy! Just wanted to say thank you again for all the time and effort you’ve shared with us so far. We are truly grateful and hope to find a way to work together in the future.    Sincerely,     Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  38 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, September 10, 2018 4:49 PM To:tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:Cal CCA Hi Tom, Hope you are well. I was hoping to speak with you at Cal CCA, but you were very busy! Just wanted to say thank you again for all the time and effort you’ve shared with us so far. We are truly grateful and hope to find a way to work together in the future. Sincerely, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  39 Hicks, Bailey From:Hilary Staver <hilary.staver@svcleanenergy.org> Sent:Thursday, August 23, 2018 9:54 AM To:cbrown@delmar.ca.us;jcregar@co.santa- barbara.ca.us;tom.moody@ci.corona.ca.us;kmorris@hermosabch.org;julie.benabente@sanjoseca.gov; msears@cityofdavis.org;spoonhour@wrcog.cog.ca.us;dking@cosb.org;tprill@sanjacintoca.us;kbarrow s@cvag.org;hmartinez@cordobacorp.com;Beth Vaughan;mswan@applevalley.org;Hendry, James;kwells@cityoflancasterca.org;Mskolnik@ceo.lacounty.gov;CC Song;Tom Habashi;Joseph F. Wiedman;Katherine Hernandez;aretalla@placer.ca.gov;acampbell@redwoodenergy.org;Neal Reardon;Joseph Moon;Ramirez, Manuel;Dan Griffiths;Shalini Swaroop;Michael Callahan;Nathaniel Malcolm (nmalcolm@mcecleanenergy.org);Jenine Windeshausen;dtibbs@aes4u.com;rengel@redwoodenergy.org;Steve Shupe;CB Hall;leah.goldberg@sanjoseca.gov;kelli.parmley@sanjoseca.gov;Greg Wade;scott.green@sanjoseca.gov;Ty Tosdal;cnajera@encinitasca.gov;jason.haber@carlsbadca.gov;MLahsaiezadeh@ci.oceanside.ca.us;Rea d, Chris;Hill, Robert;Sheridan Pauker;Tim Lindl Cc:Tom Habashi;Barbara Spoonhour;jgwynn@redwoodenergy.org;Huynh, Leanna;Kofi Antobam;Kathy Schmachtenberger;Erin Maker Subject:CalCCA Affiliate Monthly Regulatory Discussion Agenda Attachments:CalCCA Affiliate Regulatory Discussion agenda 23Aug18.pdf Hello Affiliate Team,    Attached is the agenda for our monthly regulatory discussion call at 10:00 am. It’s been an incredibly busy month, so  we’ve got plenty to go over. I look forward to talking with you.    Best,  Hilary  CalCCA Regulatory Committee Chair    Hilary Staver Manager of Regulatory and Legislative Affairs (408)-721-5301 x1008  SVCleanEnergy.org | Follow us @SVCleanEnergy    SVCE is committed to protecting customer privacy. Learn more about our privacy policy at:  https://www.svcleanenergy.org/customer‐confidentiality   40 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, August 10, 2018 10:50 AM To:Scott Collins;Hill, Robert Subject:RE: CCE Check-In Attachments:2018_8.14 - MB CC CCE Update.pptx; Task Order 2 TEA SLO as of 8-8-2018.DOCX; RMA TEA SLO as of 8-8-2018.DOCX; Task Order 1 TEA SLO as of 8-8-2018.DOCX Hi Scott, Please find the updated PPT and TEA contract files, as discussed. One other note we didn’t discuss… it seems like we are coalescing a bit around a JPA name: Central Coast Community Energy. You should know, there is some discussion over whether SB had it first or not, but I’m feeling that we are going to be ok here. Any thoughts on the name? Thanks! Chris ‐‐‐‐‐Original Appointment‐‐‐‐‐  From: Read, Chris   Sent: Thursday, August 9, 2018 4:01 PM  To: Read, Chris; Scott Collins; Hill, Robert  Subject: CCE Check‐In  When: Friday, August 10, 2018 10:15 AM‐10:45 AM (UTC‐08:00) Pacific Time (US & Canada).  Where: Call Chris at 805‐781‐7151    I. 9/14 Presentation II. JPA Update III. TEA Resource Management Agreement and Task Orders IV. September Council Dates V. Regional Partners 41 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Thursday, August 9, 2018 2:21 PM To:Heather Shepard;Kate Kelly;DeFalco, Cathy;kwells@cityoflancasterca.org;Hale, Barbara;Hyams, Michael;Kirsten Andrews-Schwind;Girish Balachandran;Annie Henderson;Joseph Moon;Howard Chang;Tom Habashi;Peter Berridge;Richard Engel;Mitch Sears;Jim Parks;Cregar, Jennifer;Mitchell, Lori;Struyk, Zachary;Read, Chris;jwindesh@placer.ca.gov;kkale@placerca.gov;Woody Hastings;Ted Bardacke;Tyler Aguirre;Katie Barrows;Barbara Spoonhour;Tyler Masters;Nicole Capretz Cc:Alison Elliott Subject:CCE Updates for LEAN Webinar-- Job openings and open RFPs? Good afternoon colleagues,      Thanks to all who responded to our request for CCE updates for tomorrow’s LEAN webinar.  We have over 200  people registered and we very much appreciate all the current information you share.  One thing I failed to  ask is whether you have open job postings and/or RFPs that you want us to include in our update.  If so,  please let us know by reply email today.     And for those who haven’t yet sent your program highlights and update, there’s still time!  I’m in the office  until 6:00 pm today.     Many thanks.  Stay cool out there... S‐      Shawn E. Marshall   Executive Director  (415) 786-9118 (mobile)  www.LEANenergyus.org   42 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, July 20, 2018 4:06 PM To:Katie Ferber Attachments:18-SLOCITY-CCE Fact Sheet.LEAN Edits.docx     Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org   43 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, July 16, 2018 5:09 PM To:Katie Ferber Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:FW: FAQ document — updated draft attached along with samples Attachments:18-SLOCITY-CCE Fact Sheet.LEAN Edits.docx; MENDO_trifold6_lowerRes.pdf; DAVIS_CCE_flyer_FINAL.pdf Katie, please find our response to the FAQ email, attached. From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Monday, July 16, 2018 2:14 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Re: FAQ document — updated draft attached along with samples  Importance: High    Howdy again,   Attached please find a more fleshed‐out fact sheet/FAQ that I think is closer to what you’re aiming for; let me  know if not.  I’ve also attached a digital flyer and brochure from the City of Davis and Mendocino County  which ‐ similar to what you’re doing ‐  created a webpage and early collateral to provide basic info in advance  of Council go/no‐go votes.  The websites and materials were then updated as the process moved along and  the CCE became “more real.”      There’s some good copy in the Mendocino brochure in particular that Katie may wish to consider. Let me  know if you need anything else on this. We have folks on our team who can help with both content and design if requested.  Cheers, S‐     Shawn Marshall   Director, LEAN Energy US  P.O. Box 961   Mill Valley, CA 94941  (415) 786-9118 (m)  www.LEANenergyus.org     From: "Read, Chris" <cread@slocity.org>  Date: Monday, July 16, 2018 at 8:18 AM  To: Shawn Marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>  Cc: "Hill, Robert" <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: FAQ document — context     Great, thanks Shawn!     44 From: Shawn Marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Monday, July 16, 2018 8:17 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Re: FAQ document — context      Ok great. Finishing up our edits when I get to the office at Noon. S‐  Sent from my iPhone    On Jul 16, 2018, at 8:12 AM, Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> wrote:  I believe the intent is for it to live on the website and to be used as approved text for inserting into a variety of other materials.     From: Shawn Marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Sunday, July 15, 2018 7:07 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Re: FAQ document — context      Hi Chris,   Quick question re: the draft FAQ document from Katie — is that to become a handout or flyer and/or  copy for your website? Having some context for how it will be used will help us suggest additions and  edits. Right now, I’m assuming “all of the above” so we have a fair bit to add.      I’ll send our comments and some digital examples of flyers and “early” brochures to you by 1 pm  on  Monday. Thanks! S‐     Sent from my iPhone    On Jul 13, 2018, at 12:55 PM, Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> wrote:  I’m heading home early today to take care of some appointments, so I’ll be away from email. If anything urgent comes up, feel free to call my cell. Thanks, thanks, and thanks again for everything you do!    Best,    Chris Read Sustainability Manager <image001.png> City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  45 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Monday, July 16, 2018 2:14 PM To:Read, Chris Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:Re: FAQ document — updated draft attached along with samples Attachments:18-SLOCITY-CCE Fact Sheet.LEAN Edits.docx; MENDO_trifold6_lowerRes.pdf; DAVIS_CCE_flyer_FINAL.pdf Howdy again,   Attached please find a more fleshed‐out fact sheet/FAQ that I think is closer to what you’re aiming for; let me  know if not.  I’ve also attached a digital flyer and brochure from the City of Davis and Mendocino County  which ‐ similar to what you’re doing ‐  created a webpage and early collateral to provide basic info in advance  of Council go/no‐go votes.  The websites and materials were then updated as the process moved along and  the CCE became “more real.”      There’s some good copy in the Mendocino brochure in particular that Katie may wish to consider. Let me  know if you need anything else on this. We have folks on our team who can help with both content and design  if requested.  Cheers, S‐     Shawn Marshall   Director, LEAN Energy US  P.O. Box 961   Mill Valley, CA 94941  (415) 786-9118 (m)  www.LEANenergyus.org     From: "Read, Chris" <cread@slocity.org>  Date: Monday, July 16, 2018 at 8:18 AM  To: Shawn Marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>  Cc: "Hill, Robert" <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: FAQ document — context     Great, thanks Shawn!     From: Shawn Marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Monday, July 16, 2018 8:17 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Re: FAQ document — context      Ok great. Finishing up our edits when I get to the office at Noon. S‐  Sent from my iPhone  46   On Jul 16, 2018, at 8:12 AM, Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> wrote:  I believe the intent is for it to live on the website and to be used as approved text for inserting into a variety of other materials.     From: Shawn Marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Sunday, July 15, 2018 7:07 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Re: FAQ document — context      Hi Chris,   Quick question re: the draft FAQ document from Katie — is that to become a handout or flyer and/or  copy for your website? Having some context for how it will be used will help us suggest additions and  edits. Right now, I’m assuming “all of the above” so we have a fair bit to add.      I’ll send our comments and some digital examples of flyers and “early” brochures to you by 1 pm  on  Monday. Thanks! S‐     Sent from my iPhone    On Jul 13, 2018, at 12:55 PM, Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> wrote:  I’m heading home early today to take care of some appointments, so I’ll be away from email. If anything urgent comes up, feel free to call my cell. Thanks, thanks, and thanks again for everything you do!    Best,    Chris Read Sustainability Manager <image001.png> City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  47 Hicks, Bailey From:Hilary Staver <hilary.staver@svcleanenergy.org> Sent:Thursday, June 28, 2018 8:47 AM To:Shalini Swaroop;jcregar@co.santa- barbara.ca.us;tom.moody@ci.corona.ca.us;kmorris@hermosabch.org;julie.benabente@sanjoseca.gov; msears@cityofdavis.org;spoonhour@wrcog.cog.ca.us;dking@cosb.org;tprill@sanjacintoca.us;kbarrow s@cvag.org;hmartinez@cordobacorp.com;Beth Vaughan;mswan@applevalley.org;Hendry, James;kwells@cityoflancasterca.org;Mskolnik@ceo.lacounty.gov;CC Song;Tom Habashi;Joseph F. Wiedman;Katherine Hernandez;aretalla@placer.ca.gov;acampbell@redwoodenergy.org;Neal Reardon;Joseph Moon;Ramirez, Manuel;Dan Griffiths;Michael Callahan;Nathaniel Malcolm (nmalcolm@mcecleanenergy.org);Jenine Windeshausen;rengel@redwoodenergy.org;Steve Shupe;CB Hall;leah.goldberg@sanjoseca.gov;kelli.parmley@sanjoseca.gov;Greg Wade;scott.green@sanjoseca.gov;Ty Tosdal;cnajera@encinitasca.gov;cbrown@delmar.ca.us;jason.haber@carlsbadca.gov;MLahsaiezadeh@ ci.oceanside.ca.us;Read, Chris;Hill, Robert Cc:Huynh, Leanna;Barbara Spoonhour;jgwynn@redwoodenergy.org;Kofi Antobam Subject:Agenda for June CalCCA Affiliate Monthly Regulatory Discussion Attachments:CalCCA Affiliate Regulatory Discussion agenda 28Jun18.pdf Hello Affiliate Team,    Attached is the agenda for our monthly regulatory discussion call at 10:00 am today. It’s been a busy month; I look  forward to talking.    Best,  Hilary     Hilary Staver Manager of Regulatory and Legislative Affairs (408)-721-5301 x1008  SVCleanEnergy.org | Follow us @SVCleanEnergy    SVCE is committed to protecting customer privacy. Learn more about our privacy policy at:  https://www.svcleanenergy.org/customer‐confidentiality   48 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Tuesday, June 26, 2018 5:10 PM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:SLO CCE Dear Mr. Bachman, Thank you for MBCP’s proposal and interview for technical and energy services. We sincerely appreciate the time, interest, and creativity spent bidding on the project. However, pending successful contract negotiations, the review committee has made a decision to select another team at this time. The selection was enormously challenging for the review team. All the finalists were extremely well qualified and everyone offered interesting approaches to our nascent CCE program. We’ll be available to debrief on specifics in the next week or so. Additionally, thank you for the substantial and continued dialogue about CCE in San Luis Obispo for the last two years. We are sincerely appreciative and hope to find ways to work together to achieve our shared carbon free future. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  49 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Monday, June 25, 2018 3:37 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:FW: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions Is this something you want me to check with Tom about before our call?     Shawn Marshall   Director, LEAN Energy US  P.O. Box 961   Mill Valley, CA 94941  (415) 786-9118 (m)  www.LEANenergyus.org     From: Deb Emerson <demerson@sonomacleanpower.org>  Date: Monday, June 25, 2018 at 2:37 PM  To: "Read, Chris" <cread@slocity.org>, "Hill, Robert" <rhill@slocity.org>, shawn marshall  <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>, Eric Veium <eveium@calpoly.edu>, Scott Collins  <scollins@morrobayca.gov>  Subject: RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    I’m attaching the recent decision about the minimum bond of $147,000.  MBCP made it clear they would not post it,  however, it’s unfortunate they’re under the impression that it’s not necessary to post.  The answer that was provided  was how the bond was handled prior to this May 31st decision.  You will need to take that cost into consideration.     http://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/Published/G000/M215/K726/215726275.PDF        Deb Emerson | Sonoma Clean Power  Director of Power Services  www.SonomaCleanPower.org  Direct: (707) 978-3469 | Cell: (410) 615-0904  Customer Service: 1 (855) 202-2139     Find us on social media: Facebook | Twitter | Linkedin    This electronic message transmission (email) contains information from SCPA that may be confidential or privileged. The information is intended to be solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom this email is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, be aware that any disclosure, copying, distribution, or use of the contents of this information is prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please immediately notify us by telephone ([sender’s phone #]) or by electronic mail ([sender’s email]), and confirm that you have deleted the email and any copies. Thank you     From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Monday, June 25, 2018 12:09 PM  To: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>; shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>; Eric Veium  50 <eveium@calpoly.edu>; Deb Emerson <demerson@sonomacleanpower.org>; Scott Collins <scollins@morrobayca.gov> Subject: FW: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions         From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 25, 2018 9:56 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions     Hi Chris,     Attached is MBCP’s written response to your follow up questions.  The second attachment is the resumes for the  procurement team.  Finally, our response to your first question on procurement risk refers to our Risk Management  Policy, so we have also attached the Risk Management Policy for your team to review.     Please let me know if there is any clarification or additional materials our team can provide.     Best,  Mark     Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org     From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 7:23 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions     Hi Mark,    Thank you again for interviewing with us yesterday. The team has several follow up questions. Please provide written responses to the questions by noon on Monday, June 25.     Additional Questions:   Please clarify approach to and level of financial hedging to mitigate procurement risk   Please provide specifics with regard to costs if program expands to new communities   Please clarify range of services/staff that would be included in $50k monthly fee   Please clarify the process for billing validation (method of checks and balance on PGE data) when MBCP switches over to Rate Ready billing system   Please confirm that the minimum security bond will net out to $0. If it doesn’t, will MBCP cover the financial security bond which could be approximately $147,000 for new CCAs?    Please clarify SLO project lead and members of procurement team (including resumes of procurement team)    Thank you again. If you have any questions for us, please don’t hesitate to reach out.     Best,    51 Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  52 Hicks, Bailey From:Deb Emerson <demerson@sonomacleanpower.org> Sent:Monday, June 25, 2018 2:37 PM To:Read, Chris;Hill, Robert;shawn marshall;Eric Veium;Scott Collins Subject:RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions I’m attaching the recent decision about the minimum bond of $147,000.  MBCP made it clear they would not post it,  however, it’s unfortunate they’re under the impression that it’s not necessary to post.  The answer that was provided  was how the bond was handled prior to this May 31st decision.  You will need to take that cost into consideration.    http://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/Published/G000/M215/K726/215726275.PDF      Deb Emerson | Sonoma Clean Power  Director of Power Services  www.SonomaCleanPower.org  Direct: (707) 978-3469 | Cell: (410) 615-0904 Customer Service: 1 (855) 202-2139   Find us on social media: Facebook | Twitter | Linkedin This electronic message transmission (email) contains information from SCPA that may be confidential or privileged. The information is intended to be solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom this email is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, be aware that any disclosure, copying, distribution, or use of the contents of this information is prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please immediately notify us by telephone ([sender’s phone #]) or by electronic mail ([sender’s email]), and confirm that you have deleted the email and any copies. Thank you   From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Monday, June 25, 2018 12:09 PM  To: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>; shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>; Eric Veium  <eveium@calpoly.edu>; Deb Emerson <demerson@sonomacleanpower.org>; Scott Collins <scollins@morrobayca.gov> Subject: FW: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 25, 2018 9:56 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Chris,    Attached is MBCP’s written response to your follow up questions.  The second attachment is the resumes for the  procurement team.  Finally, our response to your first question on procurement risk refers to our Risk Management  Policy, so we have also attached the Risk Management Policy for your team to review.    Please let me know if there is any clarification or additional materials our team can provide.    Best,  Mark  53   Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 7:23 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Mark, Thank you again for interviewing with us yesterday. The team has several follow up questions. Please provide written responses to the questions by noon on Monday, June 25. Additional Questions:  Please clarify approach to and level of financial hedging to mitigate procurement risk  Please provide specifics with regard to costs if program expands to new communities  Please clarify range of services/staff that would be included in $50k monthly fee  Please clarify the process for billing validation (method of checks and balance on PGE data) when MBCP switches over to Rate Ready billing system  Please confirm that the minimum security bond will net out to $0. If it doesn’t, will MBCP cover the financial security bond which could be approximately $147,000 for new CCAs?  Please clarify SLO project lead and members of procurement team (including resumes of procurement team) Thank you again. If you have any questions for us, please don’t hesitate to reach out. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  54 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 25, 2018 1:59 PM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions Thank you, Mark. We’ll be in touch. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org Chris From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 25, 2018 9:56 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Chris,    Attached is MBCP’s written response to your follow up questions.  The second attachment is the resumes for the  procurement team.  Finally, our response to your first question on procurement risk refers to our Risk Management  Policy, so we have also attached the Risk Management Policy for your team to review.    Please let me know if there is any clarification or additional materials our team can provide.    Best,  Mark    Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 7:23 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  55 Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Mark, Thank you again for interviewing with us yesterday. The team has several follow up questions. Please provide written responses to the questions by noon on Monday, June 25. Additional Questions:  Please clarify approach to and level of financial hedging to mitigate procurement risk  Please provide specifics with regard to costs if program expands to new communities  Please clarify range of services/staff that would be included in $50k monthly fee  Please clarify the process for billing validation (method of checks and balance on PGE data) when MBCP switches over to Rate Ready billing system  Please confirm that the minimum security bond will net out to $0. If it doesn’t, will MBCP cover the financial security bond which could be approximately $147,000 for new CCAs?  Please clarify SLO project lead and members of procurement team (including resumes of procurement team) Thank you again. If you have any questions for us, please don’t hesitate to reach out. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  56 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 25, 2018 1:59 PM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions Thank you, Mark. We’ll be in touch. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org Chris From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 25, 2018 9:56 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Chris,    Attached is MBCP’s written response to your follow up questions.  The second attachment is the resumes for the  procurement team.  Finally, our response to your first question on procurement risk refers to our Risk Management  Policy, so we have also attached the Risk Management Policy for your team to review.    Please let me know if there is any clarification or additional materials our team can provide.    Best,  Mark    Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 7:23 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  57 Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Mark, Thank you again for interviewing with us yesterday. The team has several follow up questions. Please provide written responses to the questions by noon on Monday, June 25. Additional Questions:  Please clarify approach to and level of financial hedging to mitigate procurement risk  Please provide specifics with regard to costs if program expands to new communities  Please clarify range of services/staff that would be included in $50k monthly fee  Please clarify the process for billing validation (method of checks and balance on PGE data) when MBCP switches over to Rate Ready billing system  Please confirm that the minimum security bond will net out to $0. If it doesn’t, will MBCP cover the financial security bond which could be approximately $147,000 for new CCAs?  Please clarify SLO project lead and members of procurement team (including resumes of procurement team) Thank you again. If you have any questions for us, please don’t hesitate to reach out. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  58 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 25, 2018 12:09 PM To:Hill, Robert;shawn marshall;Eric Veium;Deb Emerson;Scott Collins Subject:FW: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions Attachments:SLO CCE Follow Up Questions-MBCP Response.pdf; MBCP Power Supply-Resumes.pdf; MBCP Energy Risk Mangement Policy.pdf From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 25, 2018 9:56 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Chris,    Attached is MBCP’s written response to your follow up questions.  The second attachment is the resumes for the  procurement team.  Finally, our response to your first question on procurement risk refers to our Risk Management  Policy, so we have also attached the Risk Management Policy for your team to review.    Please let me know if there is any clarification or additional materials our team can provide.    Best,  Mark    Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 7:23 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Mark, Thank you again for interviewing with us yesterday. The team has several follow up questions. Please provide written responses to the questions by noon on Monday, June 25. Additional Questions:  Please clarify approach to and level of financial hedging to mitigate procurement risk  Please provide specifics with regard to costs if program expands to new communities  Please clarify range of services/staff that would be included in $50k monthly fee  Please clarify the process for billing validation (method of checks and balance on PGE data) when MBCP switches over to Rate Ready billing system 59  Please confirm that the minimum security bond will net out to $0. If it doesn’t, will MBCP cover the financial security bond which could be approximately $147,000 for new CCAs?  Please clarify SLO project lead and members of procurement team (including resumes of procurement team) Thank you again. If you have any questions for us, please don’t hesitate to reach out. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  60 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 25, 2018 12:09 PM To:Hill, Robert;shawn marshall;Eric Veium;Deb Emerson;Scott Collins Subject:FW: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions Attachments:SLO CCE Follow Up Questions-MBCP Response.pdf; MBCP Power Supply-Resumes.pdf; MBCP Energy Risk Mangement Policy.pdf From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 25, 2018 9:56 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Chris,    Attached is MBCP’s written response to your follow up questions.  The second attachment is the resumes for the  procurement team.  Finally, our response to your first question on procurement risk refers to our Risk Management  Policy, so we have also attached the Risk Management Policy for your team to review.    Please let me know if there is any clarification or additional materials our team can provide.    Best,  Mark    Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 7:23 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Mark, Thank you again for interviewing with us yesterday. The team has several follow up questions. Please provide written responses to the questions by noon on Monday, June 25. Additional Questions:  Please clarify approach to and level of financial hedging to mitigate procurement risk  Please provide specifics with regard to costs if program expands to new communities  Please clarify range of services/staff that would be included in $50k monthly fee  Please clarify the process for billing validation (method of checks and balance on PGE data) when MBCP switches over to Rate Ready billing system 61  Please confirm that the minimum security bond will net out to $0. If it doesn’t, will MBCP cover the financial security bond which could be approximately $147,000 for new CCAs?  Please clarify SLO project lead and members of procurement team (including resumes of procurement team) Thank you again. If you have any questions for us, please don’t hesitate to reach out. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  62 Hicks, Bailey From:Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Monday, June 25, 2018 9:56 AM To:Read, Chris Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions Attachments:SLO CCE Follow Up Questions-MBCP Response.pdf; MBCP Power Supply-Resumes.pdf; MBCP Energy Risk Mangement Policy.pdf Hi Chris,    Attached is MBCP’s written response to your follow up questions.  The second attachment is the resumes for the  procurement team.  Finally, our response to your first question on procurement risk refers to our Risk Management  Policy, so we have also attached the Risk Management Policy for your team to review.    Please let me know if there is any clarification or additional materials our team can provide.    Best,  Mark    Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 7:23 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: SLO CCE Follow Up Questions    Hi Mark, Thank you again for interviewing with us yesterday. The team has several follow up questions. Please provide written responses to the questions by noon on Monday, June 25. Additional Questions:  Please clarify approach to and level of financial hedging to mitigate procurement risk  Please provide specifics with regard to costs if program expands to new communities  Please clarify range of services/staff that would be included in $50k monthly fee  Please clarify the process for billing validation (method of checks and balance on PGE data) when MBCP switches over to Rate Ready billing system  Please confirm that the minimum security bond will net out to $0. If it doesn’t, will MBCP cover the financial security bond which could be approximately $147,000 for new CCAs?  Please clarify SLO project lead and members of procurement team (including resumes of procurement team) Thank you again. If you have any questions for us, please don’t hesitate to reach out. Best, 63 Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  64 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, June 20, 2018 7:23 PM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:SLO CCE Follow Up Questions Hi Mark, Thank you again for interviewing with us yesterday. The team has several follow up questions. Please provide written responses to the questions by noon on Monday, June 25. Additional Questions:  Please clarify approach to and level of financial hedging to mitigate procurement risk  Please provide specifics with regard to costs if program expands to new communities  Please clarify range of services/staff that would be included in $50k monthly fee  Please clarify the process for billing validation (method of checks and balance on PGE data) when MBCP switches over to Rate Ready billing system  Please confirm that the minimum security bond will net out to $0. If it doesn’t, will MBCP cover the financial security bond which could be approximately $147,000 for new CCAs?  Please clarify SLO project lead and members of procurement team (including resumes of procurement team) Thank you again. If you have any questions for us, please don’t hesitate to reach out. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  65 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, June 15, 2018 1:49 PM To:Mark Bachman Subject:MBCP - CCE Interview Information Greetings, We look forward to speaking with you on Tuesday, June 19 at 10:00 AM. The 105 minute interview will be organized as follows: 1. Introductions and proposer presentation (10-15 minutes) 2. Standard interview questions (~45 minutes) 3. Discussion and proposal specific questions (~45 minutes) Please note that the interview will be conducted in the main conference room at our Utilities office at 879 Morro Street, San Luis Obispo, 93401. Parking is available at the adjacent parking garage or across the street at 919 Palm. We are still working on finalizing the standard interview questions, so we will only be able to provide general topic areas ahead of the interviews. Proposers can be expected to answer questions related to the following general topics: 1. Your team’s competitive advantage in serving our customers and load. 2. Your team’s approach to and experience with inclusion of clean and renewable power and new technologies for CCAs. 3. Your team’s approach to helping us optimize integration of DER and drive innovation. 4. Your assumptions of and preferred approach to CCE JPA staffing. 5. What you believe to be the most challenging aspects of power planning and procurement for CCAs (current and future) and how you address those challenges. 6. Your team’s recommendations for energy risk management practices and agency reserves. 7. Your team’s approach to local power projects/development. 8. Your team’s approach to ensuring we are a priority given the demands of your existing workload and obligations. We are in the process of compiling proposal specific questions. Due to timing constraints, we will not be able to provide these questions ahead of the interview. In general, they are clarifying in nature. We wish you safe travels. Feel free to email me with any questions. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  66 Hicks, Bailey From:Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Thursday, June 14, 2018 3:28 PM To:Read, Chris Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Great.  Thank you, Chris.    Mark    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2018 12:57 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Mark, We support a streamlined approach to the technical study so long as key issues related to our specific load and customer base, power supply options, ability to be price competitive, and perform better than PG&E on environmental metrics are addressed. Item 16 data for 2016/2017 is available now. All data will be shared (pending NDA signing) once the preferred vendor is identified and contract discussions are underway/complete. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2018 6:36 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    67 A couple questions for you:    1. For the Phase 1 technical study, we are planning a similar (or even leaner) approach as taken in the attachment  by PEA for the County of Santa Barbara.  Can you please review and give us your team’s feedback on that  approach?   This is a more succinct approach than taken for previous Technical Studies.  2. When will the city be able to provide load (Item 16) data?  Do you have historical load data that you can share?    Thank you, Chris.  We are looking forward to the interview next Tuesday.    Best,  Mark        From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:31 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Mark, We do intend to share the standard questions this week. Best, Chris From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:28 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Thank you, Chris.  I will expect your follow up email with more information later this week.  Will we receive the standard  questions ahead of time?    We are looking forward to presenting to your team.      Best,  Mark    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 3:20 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Mr. Bachman,    I am writing to confirm the 10a time on 6/19.     68 As noted in my previous email, I’ll follow up later this week with more information about the interview. Generally, it will  follow a standard format with interviewees providing a 10‐15 minute introductory presentation, followed by a standard  set of questions for all interviewees, and concluding with proposal specific questions and open discussion.     We look forward to speaking with you.    Best,  Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org   From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    Our preferences in order are:    1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. 69 Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  70 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Thursday, June 14, 2018 12:57 PM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Hi Mark, We support a streamlined approach to the technical study so long as key issues related to our specific load and customer base, power supply options, ability to be price competitive, and perform better than PG&E on environmental metrics are addressed. Item 16 data for 2016/2017 is available now. All data will be shared (pending NDA signing) once the preferred vendor is identified and contract discussions are underway/complete. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2018 6:36 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    A couple questions for you:    1. For the Phase 1 technical study, we are planning a similar (or even leaner) approach as taken in the attachment  by PEA for the County of Santa Barbara.  Can you please review and give us your team’s feedback on that  approach?   This is a more succinct approach than taken for previous Technical Studies.  2. When will the city be able to provide load (Item 16) data?  Do you have historical load data that you can share?    Thank you, Chris.  We are looking forward to the interview next Tuesday.    71 Best,  Mark        From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:31 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Mark, We do intend to share the standard questions this week. Best, Chris From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:28 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Thank you, Chris.  I will expect your follow up email with more information later this week.  Will we receive the standard  questions ahead of time?    We are looking forward to presenting to your team.      Best,  Mark    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 3:20 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Mr. Bachman,    I am writing to confirm the 10a time on 6/19.     As noted in my previous email, I’ll follow up later this week with more information about the interview. Generally, it will  follow a standard format with interviewees providing a 10‐15 minute introductory presentation, followed by a standard  set of questions for all interviewees, and concluding with proposal specific questions and open discussion.     We look forward to speaking with you.    Best,  72 Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org   From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    Our preferences in order are:    1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager 73 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  74 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Wednesday, June 13, 2018 1:03 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:Re: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Hey Chris,   My thoughts on response below in red.     Shawn Marshall   Director, LEAN Energy US  P.O. Box 961   Mill Valley, CA 94941  (415) 786-9118 (m)  www.LEANenergyus.org     From: "Read, Chris" <cread@slocity.org>  Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2018 at 12:46 PM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>  Subject: FW: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    FYI    From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2018 6:36 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview     Hi Chris,     A couple questions for you:     1. For the Phase 1 technical study, we are planning a similar (or even leaner) approach as taken in the attachment  by PEA for the County of Santa Barbara.  Can you please review and give us your team’s feedback on that  approach?   This is a more succinct approach than taken for previous Technical Studies. We understand that the  technical studies PEA has authored in the past are extensive and costly. We have no problem with a more  streamlined approach so long as key issues related to our specific load and customer base, power supply  options, ability to be price competitive, and perform better than PG&E on environmental metrics is addressed.    2. When will the city be able to provide load (Item 16) data?  Do you have historical load data that you can share?  Item 16 data for 2016/2017 is available now.  We also have 2015 data if you want to go farther back.  All data  can be shared once the preferred vendor is identified and contract discussions are underway/complete.      Thank you, Chris.  We are looking forward to the interview next Tuesday.     75 Best,  Mark           From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:31 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview     Hi Mark,    We do intend to share the standard questions this week.     Best,    Chris     From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:28 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview     Thank you, Chris.  I will expect your follow up email with more information later this week.  Will we receive the standard  questions ahead of time?     We are looking forward to presenting to your team.       Best,  Mark     From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 3:20 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview     Mr. Bachman,     I am writing to confirm the 10a time on 6/19.      As noted in my previous email, I’ll follow up later this week with more information about the interview. Generally, it will  follow a standard format with interviewees providing a 10‐15 minute introductory presentation, followed by a standard  set of questions for all interviewees, and concluding with proposal specific questions and open discussion.      We look forward to speaking with you.     Best,    76 Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org         From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview     Hi Chris,     Our preferences in order are:     1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm     From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview     Greetings, Mark Bachman,    Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:     10:00a -11:45a   1:00p – 2:45p   3:00p – 4:45p    Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview.    Best,    Chris Read Sustainability Manager 77 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  78 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, June 13, 2018 12:46 PM To:shawn marshall Subject:FW: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Attachments:PEA Final CCA Study Memo_052518.pdf FYI From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2018 6:36 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    A couple questions for you:    1. For the Phase 1 technical study, we are planning a similar (or even leaner) approach as taken in the attachment  by PEA for the County of Santa Barbara.  Can you please review and give us your team’s feedback on that  approach?   This is a more succinct approach than taken for previous Technical Studies.  2. When will the city be able to provide load (Item 16) data?  Do you have historical load data that you can share?    Thank you, Chris.  We are looking forward to the interview next Tuesday.    Best,  Mark        From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:31 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Mark, We do intend to share the standard questions this week. Best, Chris From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:28 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  79 Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Thank you, Chris.  I will expect your follow up email with more information later this week.  Will we receive the standard  questions ahead of time?    We are looking forward to presenting to your team.      Best,  Mark    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 3:20 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Mr. Bachman,    I am writing to confirm the 10a time on 6/19.     As noted in my previous email, I’ll follow up later this week with more information about the interview. Generally, it will  follow a standard format with interviewees providing a 10‐15 minute introductory presentation, followed by a standard  set of questions for all interviewees, and concluding with proposal specific questions and open discussion.     We look forward to speaking with you.    Best,  Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org   From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    Our preferences in order are:  80   1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  81 Hicks, Bailey From:Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Tuesday, June 12, 2018 6:36 PM To:Read, Chris Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Attachments:PEA Final CCA Study Memo_052518.pdf Hi Chris,    A couple questions for you:    1. For the Phase 1 technical study, we are planning a similar (or even leaner) approach as taken in the attachment  by PEA for the County of Santa Barbara.  Can you please review and give us your team’s feedback on that  approach?   This is a more succinct approach than taken for previous Technical Studies.  2. When will the city be able to provide load (Item 16) data?  Do you have historical load data that you can share?    Thank you, Chris.  We are looking forward to the interview next Tuesday.    Best,  Mark        From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:31 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Mark, We do intend to share the standard questions this week. Best, Chris From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:28 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Thank you, Chris.  I will expect your follow up email with more information later this week.  Will we receive the standard  questions ahead of time?    We are looking forward to presenting to your team.      82 Best,  Mark    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 3:20 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Mr. Bachman,    I am writing to confirm the 10a time on 6/19.     As noted in my previous email, I’ll follow up later this week with more information about the interview. Generally, it will  follow a standard format with interviewees providing a 10‐15 minute introductory presentation, followed by a standard  set of questions for all interviewees, and concluding with proposal specific questions and open discussion.     We look forward to speaking with you.    Best,  Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org   From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    Our preferences in order are:    1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  83 Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  84 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Tuesday, June 12, 2018 1:07 PM To:Hill, Robert Subject:FW: Executive Summary - June 6, 2018 - Meeting of MBCP's Policy Board FYI From: Eric Veium <eric@slocleanenergy.org>   Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2018 12:33 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: Fwd: Executive Summary ‐ June 6, 2018 ‐ Meeting of MBCP's Policy Board    See below re: "Super‐JPA" and San LOUIS Obispo.     ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐  From: Monterey Bay Community Power <info@mbcommunitypower.org>  Date: Tue, Jun 12, 2018, 11:16 AM  Subject: Executive Summary ‐ June 6, 2018 ‐ Meeting of MBCP's Policy Board  To: <eric@slocleanenergy.org>    Community Advisory Council Update: As of the April 30 deadline,           85             Executive Summary: Regular Meeting of the Policy Board of Directors Wednesday, June 6, 2018 CEO’s Report  A Super Joint Powers Authority (JPA) made up of several California Community Choice Aggregators (CCAs) is being formed to reduce the cost of long-term electricity contracts with centralized energy procurement.  The cities of San Louis Obispo and Morro Bay are joining together to form their own CCA. Should they approve our proposal – on a cost-plus basis – MBCP will assist with launch and operations.  MBCP has purchased its needed Resource Adequacy (RA), equivalent to 15% more than our predicted power supply 86 needs, as mandated by the California Public Utilities Commission. Since the incumbent electric utility is currently the only supplier, the price was raised substantially above market rate.  MBCP will be matching an expected 15-20% reduction in electricity generation rates by PG&E. MBCP is dedicated to offering rates equal to or lower than PG&E despite the expected decrease.  Enrollment Update: Out of 37,500 non-residential customers, only 176 have chosen to opt-out and remain with the incumbent utility. Out of 235,000 residents, only 445 have chosen to opt-out and remain with the incumbent utility. Time/Location of Regular Meetings of the Policy Board of Directors Resolution adopted unanimously to change board meeting location to MBCP offices at 70 Garden Court in Monterey, and move the meeting time to 10:30 AM instead of 9AM to allow for traveling outside of commuting hours. General Counsel Full Time Employee The replacement of the MBCP general counsel contract position with a full-time employee position for regulatory and legislative support, as well as power procurement contracts, was approved unanimously. Effective Oct. 1, 2018 Community Advisory Council (CAC) Appointed Prior to unanimous approval of the 11 selected CAC members, nearly each board member thanked the 62 applicants, acknowledging the richness of the selection pool, their broad scope of knowledge and expertise, and how fair the selection process was. San Benito County Supervisor Jerry Muenzer encouraged all applicants to remain engaged, “If you weren’t selected, do stay involved. We want the continued engagement with the community.” MBCP’s Beth Trenchard was acknowledged for her hard work throughout the process. The MBCP team is elated with 87 how smooth the process was and honored to have the opportunity to be working with such a tremendous group of qualified CAC members! Progress Update - 15-year Renewable Wind Power Purchase MBCP put out a joint Request for Offers (RFO) and received 87 responses. MBCP is currently in negotiations with the three applicants who were shortlisted. One of the applicants is a wind project in New Mexico, which would generate electricity during different times of day than MBCP’s solar providers, delivering an efficient compliment to MBCP’s existing power mix. MBCP expects to complete negotiations by July or August, 2018.                   CLEAN ENERGY Electricity Generation   SAME SERVICE Electricity Delivery   YOUR CHOICE Greener Electricity at Lower Cost       Monterey Bay Community Power www.mbcommunitypower.org     Connect with us     88 Monterey Bay Community Power | 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940 Unsubscribe eric@slocleanenergy.org Update Profile | About our service provider Sent by info@mbcommunitypower.org in collaboration with Try it free today   89 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Tuesday, June 12, 2018 1:07 PM To:Hill, Robert Subject:FW: Executive Summary - June 6, 2018 - Meeting of MBCP's Policy Board FYI From: Eric Veium <eric@slocleanenergy.org>   Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2018 12:33 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: Fwd: Executive Summary ‐ June 6, 2018 ‐ Meeting of MBCP's Policy Board    See below re: "Super‐JPA" and San LOUIS Obispo.     ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐  From: Monterey Bay Community Power <info@mbcommunitypower.org>  Date: Tue, Jun 12, 2018, 11:16 AM  Subject: Executive Summary ‐ June 6, 2018 ‐ Meeting of MBCP's Policy Board  To: <eric@slocleanenergy.org>    Community Advisory Council Update: As of the April 30 deadline,           90             Executive Summary: Regular Meeting of the Policy Board of Directors Wednesday, June 6, 2018 CEO’s Report  A Super Joint Powers Authority (JPA) made up of several California Community Choice Aggregators (CCAs) is being formed to reduce the cost of long-term electricity contracts with centralized energy procurement.  The cities of San Louis Obispo and Morro Bay are joining together to form their own CCA. Should they approve our proposal – on a cost-plus basis – MBCP will assist with launch and operations.  MBCP has purchased its needed Resource Adequacy (RA), equivalent to 15% more than our predicted power supply 91 needs, as mandated by the California Public Utilities Commission. Since the incumbent electric utility is currently the only supplier, the price was raised substantially above market rate.  MBCP will be matching an expected 15-20% reduction in electricity generation rates by PG&E. MBCP is dedicated to offering rates equal to or lower than PG&E despite the expected decrease.  Enrollment Update: Out of 37,500 non-residential customers, only 176 have chosen to opt-out and remain with the incumbent utility. Out of 235,000 residents, only 445 have chosen to opt-out and remain with the incumbent utility. Time/Location of Regular Meetings of the Policy Board of Directors Resolution adopted unanimously to change board meeting location to MBCP offices at 70 Garden Court in Monterey, and move the meeting time to 10:30 AM instead of 9AM to allow for traveling outside of commuting hours. General Counsel Full Time Employee The replacement of the MBCP general counsel contract position with a full-time employee position for regulatory and legislative support, as well as power procurement contracts, was approved unanimously. Effective Oct. 1, 2018 Community Advisory Council (CAC) Appointed Prior to unanimous approval of the 11 selected CAC members, nearly each board member thanked the 62 applicants, acknowledging the richness of the selection pool, their broad scope of knowledge and expertise, and how fair the selection process was. San Benito County Supervisor Jerry Muenzer encouraged all applicants to remain engaged, “If you weren’t selected, do stay involved. We want the continued engagement with the community.” MBCP’s Beth Trenchard was acknowledged for her hard work throughout the process. The MBCP team is elated with 92 how smooth the process was and honored to have the opportunity to be working with such a tremendous group of qualified CAC members! Progress Update - 15-year Renewable Wind Power Purchase MBCP put out a joint Request for Offers (RFO) and received 87 responses. MBCP is currently in negotiations with the three applicants who were shortlisted. One of the applicants is a wind project in New Mexico, which would generate electricity during different times of day than MBCP’s solar providers, delivering an efficient compliment to MBCP’s existing power mix. MBCP expects to complete negotiations by July or August, 2018.                   CLEAN ENERGY Electricity Generation   SAME SERVICE Electricity Delivery   YOUR CHOICE Greener Electricity at Lower Cost       Monterey Bay Community Power www.mbcommunitypower.org     Connect with us     93 Monterey Bay Community Power | 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940 Unsubscribe eric@slocleanenergy.org Update Profile | About our service provider Sent by info@mbcommunitypower.org in collaboration with Try it free today   94 Hicks, Bailey From:Eric Veium <eric@slocleanenergy.org> Sent:Tuesday, June 12, 2018 12:33 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:Fwd: Executive Summary - June 6, 2018 - Meeting of MBCP's Policy Board See below re: "Super‐JPA" and San LOUIS Obispo.     ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐  From: Monterey Bay Community Power <info@mbcommunitypower.org>  Date: Tue, Jun 12, 2018, 11:16 AM  Subject: Executive Summary ‐ June 6, 2018 ‐ Meeting of MBCP's Policy Board  To: <eric@slocleanenergy.org>              Executive Summary: 95 Regular Meeting of the Policy Board of Directors Wednesday, June 6, 2018 CEO’s Report  A Super Joint Powers Authority (JPA) made up of several California Community Choice Aggregators (CCAs) is being formed to reduce the cost of long-term electricity contracts with centralized energy procurement.  The cities of San Louis Obispo and Morro Bay are joining together to form their own CCA. Should they approve our proposal – on a cost-plus basis – MBCP will assist with launch and operations.  MBCP has purchased its needed Resource Adequacy (RA), equivalent to 15% more than our predicted power supply needs, as mandated by the California Public Utilities Commission. Since the incumbent electric utility is currently the only supplier, the price was raised substantially above market rate.  MBCP will be matching an expected 15-20% reduction in electricity generation rates by PG&E. MBCP is dedicated to offering rates equal to or lower than PG&E despite the expected decrease.  Enrollment Update: Out of 37,500 non-residential customers, only 176 have chosen to opt-out and remain with the incumbent utility. Out of 235,000 residents, only 445 have chosen to opt-out and remain with the incumbent utility. Time/Location of Regular Meetings of the Policy Board of Directors Resolution adopted unanimously to change board meeting location to MBCP offices at 70 Garden Court in Monterey, and move the meeting time to 10:30 AM instead of 9AM to allow for traveling outside of commuting hours. General Counsel Full Time Employee 96 The replacement of the MBCP general counsel contract position with a full-time employee position for regulatory and legislative support, as well as power procurement contracts, was approved unanimously. Effective Oct. 1, 2018 Community Advisory Council (CAC) Appointed Prior to unanimous approval of the 11 selected CAC members, nearly each board member thanked the 62 applicants, acknowledging the richness of the selection pool, their broad scope of knowledge and expertise, and how fair the selection process was. San Benito County Supervisor Jerry Muenzer encouraged all applicants to remain engaged, “If you weren’t selected, do stay involved. We want the continued engagement with the community.” MBCP’s Beth Trenchard was acknowledged for her hard work throughout the process. The MBCP team is elated with how smooth the process was and honored to have the opportunity to be working with such a tremendous group of qualified CAC members! Progress Update - 15-year Renewable Wind Power Purchase MBCP put out a joint Request for Offers (RFO) and received 87 responses. MBCP is currently in negotiations with the three applicants who were shortlisted. One of the applicants is a wind project in New Mexico, which would generate electricity during different times of day than MBCP’s solar providers, delivering an efficient compliment to MBCP’s existing power mix. MBCP expects to complete negotiations by July or August, 2018.           CLEAN ENERGY SAME SERVICE YOUR CHOICE 97 Electricity Generation   Electricity Delivery   Greener Electricity at Lower Cost   Monterey Bay Community Power www.mbcommunitypower.org   Connect with us   Monterey Bay Community Power | 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940 Unsubscribe eric@slocleanenergy.org Update Profile | About our service provider Sent by info@mbcommunitypower.org in collaboration with Try it free today   98 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 11, 2018 4:31 PM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Hi Mark, We do intend to share the standard questions this week. Best, Chris From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:28 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Thank you, Chris.  I will expect your follow up email with more information later this week.  Will we receive the standard  questions ahead of time?    We are looking forward to presenting to your team.      Best,  Mark    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 3:20 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Mr. Bachman,    I am writing to confirm the 10a time on 6/19.     As noted in my previous email, I’ll follow up later this week with more information about the interview. Generally, it will  follow a standard format with interviewees providing a 10‐15 minute introductory presentation, followed by a standard  set of questions for all interviewees, and concluding with proposal specific questions and open discussion.     We look forward to speaking with you.    Best,  Chris Read Sustainability Manager 99 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org   From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    Our preferences in order are:    1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 100 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  101 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 11, 2018 4:31 PM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Hi Mark, We do intend to share the standard questions this week. Best, Chris From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:28 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Thank you, Chris.  I will expect your follow up email with more information later this week.  Will we receive the standard  questions ahead of time?    We are looking forward to presenting to your team.      Best,  Mark    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 3:20 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Mr. Bachman,    I am writing to confirm the 10a time on 6/19.     As noted in my previous email, I’ll follow up later this week with more information about the interview. Generally, it will  follow a standard format with interviewees providing a 10‐15 minute introductory presentation, followed by a standard  set of questions for all interviewees, and concluding with proposal specific questions and open discussion.     We look forward to speaking with you.    Best,  Chris Read Sustainability Manager 102 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org   From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    Our preferences in order are:    1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 103 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  104 Hicks, Bailey From:Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Monday, June 11, 2018 4:28 PM To:Read, Chris Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Thank you, Chris.  I will expect your follow up email with more information later this week.  Will we receive the standard  questions ahead of time?    We are looking forward to presenting to your team.      Best,  Mark    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 3:20 PM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Mr. Bachman,    I am writing to confirm the 10a time on 6/19.     As noted in my previous email, I’ll follow up later this week with more information about the interview. Generally, it will  follow a standard format with interviewees providing a 10‐15 minute introductory presentation, followed by a standard  set of questions for all interviewees, and concluding with proposal specific questions and open discussion.     We look forward to speaking with you.    Best,  Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org   From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM  105 To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    Our preferences in order are:    1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  106 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 11, 2018 3:20 PM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Mr. Bachman,    I am writing to confirm the 10a time on 6/19.     As noted in my previous email, I’ll follow up later this week with more information about the interview. Generally, it will  follow a standard format with interviewees providing a 10‐15 minute introductory presentation, followed by a standard  set of questions for all interviewees, and concluding with proposal specific questions and open discussion.     We look forward to speaking with you.    Best,  Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org   From: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Hi Chris,    Our preferences in order are:    1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  107 Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  108 Hicks, Bailey From:Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa-barbara.ca.us> Sent:Monday, June 11, 2018 10:56 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up Ok. I’ll touch base with you tomorrow pm. Thanks!    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 8:41 AM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    I can check in quickly before 9a this morning. Tomorrow after lunch is more or less open as well. From: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 8:31 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: FW: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    Good morning, Chris. I hope you enjoyed the rest of your whirlwind visit to Sacramento. The tone was certainly different  at this year’s BLES!    I checked in with Tom at MBCP to see if it was still an option to have the northern part of SB County join them as a back  up to forming a new CCA. Please see his response to one of the questions below – can you weigh in on what your  prospects are for joining MBCP vs starting your own? Also, can we chat about what it might look like if our PG&E  territory were to join with you (and southern with CPA)? I have pretty good availability tomorrow and Thursday. Any  open slots for you?    1. Are there other jurisdictions currently interested in joining MBCP? We made a proposal to provide services to  SLO and Morro Bay, potentially a new CCA to be formed by July.    Thanks,  Jen  From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Saturday, June 09, 2018 11:06 AM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    Hi Jennifer  Glad to know that  you guys are back on the CCE formation track. Below are my answers to your questions which I’ll be  happy to elaborate on with you and others, so don’t hesitate to call to schedule a conference call    Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org    109     From: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 4:30 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    Hello Tom,    I hope this email finds you well. Pacific Energy Advisors has completed our new CCE feasibility study (attached), this time  just for Santa Barbara County rather than our tri‐county region with SLO and Ventura. The new study looks promising for  our elected officials to move forward with a CCE program serving all or part of Santa Barbara County, should they choose  to do so. That said, our Board of Supervisors remains interested—likely as a back‐up option—in splitting ourselves in two  and potentially joining MBCP for the PG&E parts of our county and CPA for the SCE parts.     I’ll be taking the new study results to our Board on July 17. To inform my presentation of options, I would appreciate if  you could advise on the below questions related to MBCP’s interest and process in taking us on. Do you have some time  to discuss in the next week or two?    1. Are you/your board potentially still interested in having Northern Santa Barbara County join MBCP? YES  2. What is the current process for joining MBCP? Have the county pass a resolution expressing the County’s desire  to join MBCP. Once our Board approves of including SBC to our JPA, you’re in.  3. Would a new member have any joining fees? If so, can you help us understand how the fees are calculated,  what they would cover, and whether the fees would be paid back through future revenues generated by  customers located in SB County? There is no fee to join. You may need to front $30,000 to pay for amending our  implementation plan. This fee will be refunded to you roughly 90 days after enrolling SBC customers  4. How soon could a new member’s customers begin receiving electricity service from MBCP? More specifically,  would it be possible to submit an updated implementation plan to the CPUC by January 1, 2019 to begin service  for our customers in 2020? Yes and yes provided the decision to join is made no later than July or August at the  latest  5. What would you need from a new member to update MBCP’s implementation plan? A signed resolution  expressing your desire to join which we can draft for you    6. What is the likelihood that potential future new renewable generation projects could be built in Santa Barbara  County? Good, assuming the price is within acceptable premium to MBCP (inclusive of SBC)  7. Can you describe your current power supply portfolio and overall approach (e.g., content, contract length, plans  for local generation, open position)? So far, we have signed 56 confirmations for hedged price energy, indexed  priced renewable (bucket one), indexed priced carbon free resources (large hydro) and RA. These agreements  range in duration from one month (RA) to four years (carbon free). Our open position range from 20% in 2019 to  70% in 2022. In addition, we, along with SVCE, are in negotiations with 3 developers for wind (200 MW) and  solar + storage (300 MW), of which MBCP’s share will be 225 MW, meeting 18% of our customer demand. We  expect these negotiations to conclude in July and the resources to be online by 2021. Finally, the approved  power resource mix for 2018 is 30% eligible renewable (all bucket one) and 100% carbon free. This is likely to  change in favor of eligible resources in future years    8. Are there other jurisdictions currently interested in joining MBCP? We made a proposal to provide services to  SLO and Morro Bay, potentially a new CCA to be formed by July.  9. For the unincorporated parts of Santa Barbara County to join MBCP, we would also need to join/form another  CCA serving the SCE parts of our county. The CPUC has been unwilling to confirm whether they would accept  110 this split‐CCA approach to offer service to 100% of our residential customers, as required by PUC Section  366.2(b). This could present a risk to the CPUC certifying your implementation plan should your plan include  unincorporated Santa Barbara County. Are you/would you anticipate your board would accept this risk?  Obviously we’ll need to do some homework to get the CPUC to take position on this issue. To the extent they  stick to the letter of section 366.2 (b), then SBC has a decision to make, they can have the city of SB join while  we litigate the county split with the CPUC or they can have the entire county become a single CCA and struggle  with the issue of devising different generation rates for the County’s north and south section. Either way, I don’t  see any risk to MBCP      Thank you, as always, for letting me pepper you with questions. Any time    Have a wonderful weekend,  Jen      Jennifer Cregar Co-Division Chief Sustainability Division 805-568-3506 T | 805-560-1091 F jcregar@countyofsb.org   From: Tom Habashi <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 1:20 PM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    No worries, best of luck getting across that finish line, one way or another.     From: Cregar, Jennifer [mailto:jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us]   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 1:16 PM  To: 'Tom Habashi' <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up     Fantastic. Thank you for the always speedy reply!     From: Tom Habashi [mailto:tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org]   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 1:07 PM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up     Hi Jennifer  See answers below. Let me know if you have any additional questions.     From: Cregar, Jennifer [mailto:jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us]   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 11:54 AM  To: 'tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org' <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: 'Chris Read' <cread@co.slo.ca.us>; Jon Griesser <jgriesser@co.slo.ca.us>; Chapjian, George <gchapjian@co.santa‐ barbara.ca.us>  Subject: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up     Hi Tom,     111 We presented to the County of Santa Barbara Board of Supervisors last week on the results of our CCE feasibility study  and options for how to proceed, including the possibility of our North County customers joining MBCE (and LACCE for  our South County customers). Our Board asked us to further study the feasibility of starting our own CCE program, as  well as additional details related to joining MBCE (and LACCE). Can you please respond to the follow‐up questions  below?     1. If Santa Barbara County were to join MBCE, would we have the ability to modify the base electricity product  offered to our customers? Specifically, could we increase the RPS‐eligible renewable energy content above the  planned RPS‐equivalent, say to 50%? Would this incur any additional cost to the County or our customers?  Provided that Santa Barbara join MBCP, all decisions regarding the proper power supply mix, rates, reserve policy, etc.  will be done jointly by the Board of Directors and any decision made by the Board will applicable to all. Regarding  increasing the % of eligible renewable in the mix, it’s very likely that we’ll see the return of SB100 in early 2018, which  will accelerate the 50% eligible renewable in the mix to 50% by 2025. Meanwhile, I believe that during the next 2 years,  the decision to go with 100% carbon free and meeting 100% of the RPS using type 1 renewable is a prudent approach to  maximize the reduction of GHG and to help us accumulate enough reserves and become credit worthy  2. Can you provide some information on MBCE’s plans for investment in new local renewable energy generation,  including timeframe for when MBCE thinks it may be able to contract for new generation and where such  projects might be located, specifically whether such projects might be located in Santa Barbara County or if the  focus is mainly on the original 3 county participants?  We issued an RFO for long term renewables in conjunction with SVCE. The offers are due tomorrow and we’ll evaluate  the results and select few options for negotiation and eventually signing contracts by Jan 2018. These contract will  provide sufficient power to meet roughly 10% of MBCP’s electricity demand. We’re likely to repeat in 12‐18 months  from now. We have no conceived plans for local generation and hopeful that some of the offers will be well priced to  justify keeping the deal local.      3. It doesn’t look like Santa Barbara County will make a decision to join MBCE by the Thanksgiving time period to  be include in your Phase 2 launch in July 2018. If we were to join later in 2018, is your ballpark cost estimate still  $0 up to $25‐50,000 to modify your implementation plan?  Yes.      Many thanks,  Jen       Jennifer Cregar  Project Supervisor  Energy and Sustainability Initiatives  805-568-3506 T | 805-560-1091 F  jcregar@countyofsb.org        112 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 11, 2018 8:41 AM To:Cregar, Jennifer Subject:RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up I can check in quickly before 9a this morning. Tomorrow after lunch is more or less open as well. From: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>   Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 8:31 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: FW: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    Good morning, Chris. I hope you enjoyed the rest of your whirlwind visit to Sacramento. The tone was certainly different  at this year’s BLES!    I checked in with Tom at MBCP to see if it was still an option to have the northern part of SB County join them as a back  up to forming a new CCA. Please see his response to one of the questions below – can you weigh in on what your  prospects are for joining MBCP vs starting your own? Also, can we chat about what it might look like if our PG&E  territory were to join with you (and southern with CPA)? I have pretty good availability tomorrow and Thursday. Any  open slots for you?    1. Are there other jurisdictions currently interested in joining MBCP? We made a proposal to provide services to  SLO and Morro Bay, potentially a new CCA to be formed by July.    Thanks,  Jen  From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Saturday, June 09, 2018 11:06 AM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    Hi Jennifer  Glad to know that  you guys are back on the CCE formation track. Below are my answers to your questions which I’ll be  happy to elaborate on with you and others, so don’t hesitate to call to schedule a conference call    Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        113 From: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 4:30 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    Hello Tom,    I hope this email finds you well. Pacific Energy Advisors has completed our new CCE feasibility study (attached), this time  just for Santa Barbara County rather than our tri‐county region with SLO and Ventura. The new study looks promising for  our elected officials to move forward with a CCE program serving all or part of Santa Barbara County, should they choose  to do so. That said, our Board of Supervisors remains interested—likely as a back‐up option—in splitting ourselves in two  and potentially joining MBCP for the PG&E parts of our county and CPA for the SCE parts.     I’ll be taking the new study results to our Board on July 17. To inform my presentation of options, I would appreciate if  you could advise on the below questions related to MBCP’s interest and process in taking us on. Do you have some time  to discuss in the next week or two?    1. Are you/your board potentially still interested in having Northern Santa Barbara County join MBCP? YES  2. What is the current process for joining MBCP? Have the county pass a resolution expressing the County’s desire  to join MBCP. Once our Board approves of including SBC to our JPA, you’re in.  3. Would a new member have any joining fees? If so, can you help us understand how the fees are calculated,  what they would cover, and whether the fees would be paid back through future revenues generated by  customers located in SB County? There is no fee to join. You may need to front $30,000 to pay for amending our  implementation plan. This fee will be refunded to you roughly 90 days after enrolling SBC customers  4. How soon could a new member’s customers begin receiving electricity service from MBCP? More specifically,  would it be possible to submit an updated implementation plan to the CPUC by January 1, 2019 to begin service  for our customers in 2020? Yes and yes provided the decision to join is made no later than July or August at the  latest  5. What would you need from a new member to update MBCP’s implementation plan? A signed resolution  expressing your desire to join which we can draft for you    6. What is the likelihood that potential future new renewable generation projects could be built in Santa Barbara  County? Good, assuming the price is within acceptable premium to MBCP (inclusive of SBC)  7. Can you describe your current power supply portfolio and overall approach (e.g., content, contract length, plans  for local generation, open position)? So far, we have signed 56 confirmations for hedged price energy, indexed  priced renewable (bucket one), indexed priced carbon free resources (large hydro) and RA. These agreements  range in duration from one month (RA) to four years (carbon free). Our open position range from 20% in 2019 to  70% in 2022. In addition, we, along with SVCE, are in negotiations with 3 developers for wind (200 MW) and  solar + storage (300 MW), of which MBCP’s share will be 225 MW, meeting 18% of our customer demand. We  expect these negotiations to conclude in July and the resources to be online by 2021. Finally, the approved  power resource mix for 2018 is 30% eligible renewable (all bucket one) and 100% carbon free. This is likely to  change in favor of eligible resources in future years    8. Are there other jurisdictions currently interested in joining MBCP? We made a proposal to provide services to  SLO and Morro Bay, potentially a new CCA to be formed by July.  9. For the unincorporated parts of Santa Barbara County to join MBCP, we would also need to join/form another  CCA serving the SCE parts of our county. The CPUC has been unwilling to confirm whether they would accept  this split‐CCA approach to offer service to 100% of our residential customers, as required by PUC Section  366.2(b). This could present a risk to the CPUC certifying your implementation plan should your plan include  unincorporated Santa Barbara County. Are you/would you anticipate your board would accept this risk?  Obviously we’ll need to do some homework to get the CPUC to take position on this issue. To the extent they  stick to the letter of section 366.2 (b), then SBC has a decision to make, they can have the city of SB join while  we litigate the county split with the CPUC or they can have the entire county become a single CCA and struggle  114 with the issue of devising different generation rates for the County’s north and south section. Either way, I don’t  see any risk to MBCP      Thank you, as always, for letting me pepper you with questions. Any time    Have a wonderful weekend,  Jen      Jennifer Cregar Co-Division Chief Sustainability Division 805-568-3506 T | 805-560-1091 F jcregar@countyofsb.org   From: Tom Habashi <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 1:20 PM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    No worries, best of luck getting across that finish line, one way or another.     From: Cregar, Jennifer [mailto:jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us]   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 1:16 PM  To: 'Tom Habashi' <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up     Fantastic. Thank you for the always speedy reply!     From: Tom Habashi [mailto:tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org]   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 1:07 PM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up     Hi Jennifer  See answers below. Let me know if you have any additional questions.     From: Cregar, Jennifer [mailto:jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us]   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 11:54 AM  To: 'tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org' <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: 'Chris Read' <cread@co.slo.ca.us>; Jon Griesser <jgriesser@co.slo.ca.us>; Chapjian, George <gchapjian@co.santa‐ barbara.ca.us>  Subject: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up     Hi Tom,     We presented to the County of Santa Barbara Board of Supervisors last week on the results of our CCE feasibility study  and options for how to proceed, including the possibility of our North County customers joining MBCE (and LACCE for  our South County customers). Our Board asked us to further study the feasibility of starting our own CCE program, as  well as additional details related to joining MBCE (and LACCE). Can you please respond to the follow‐up questions  below?     115 1. If Santa Barbara County were to join MBCE, would we have the ability to modify the base electricity product  offered to our customers? Specifically, could we increase the RPS‐eligible renewable energy content above the  planned RPS‐equivalent, say to 50%? Would this incur any additional cost to the County or our customers?  Provided that Santa Barbara join MBCP, all decisions regarding the proper power supply mix, rates, reserve policy, etc.  will be done jointly by the Board of Directors and any decision made by the Board will applicable to all. Regarding  increasing the % of eligible renewable in the mix, it’s very likely that we’ll see the return of SB100 in early 2018, which  will accelerate the 50% eligible renewable in the mix to 50% by 2025. Meanwhile, I believe that during the next 2 years,  the decision to go with 100% carbon free and meeting 100% of the RPS using type 1 renewable is a prudent approach to  maximize the reduction of GHG and to help us accumulate enough reserves and become credit worthy  2. Can you provide some information on MBCE’s plans for investment in new local renewable energy generation,  including timeframe for when MBCE thinks it may be able to contract for new generation and where such  projects might be located, specifically whether such projects might be located in Santa Barbara County or if the  focus is mainly on the original 3 county participants?  We issued an RFO for long term renewables in conjunction with SVCE. The offers are due tomorrow and we’ll evaluate  the results and select few options for negotiation and eventually signing contracts by Jan 2018. These contract will  provide sufficient power to meet roughly 10% of MBCP’s electricity demand. We’re likely to repeat in 12‐18 months  from now. We have no conceived plans for local generation and hopeful that some of the offers will be well priced to  justify keeping the deal local.      3. It doesn’t look like Santa Barbara County will make a decision to join MBCE by the Thanksgiving time period to  be include in your Phase 2 launch in July 2018. If we were to join later in 2018, is your ballpark cost estimate still  $0 up to $25‐50,000 to modify your implementation plan?  Yes.      Many thanks,  Jen       Jennifer Cregar  Project Supervisor  Energy and Sustainability Initiatives  805-568-3506 T | 805-560-1091 F  jcregar@countyofsb.org        116 Hicks, Bailey From:Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa-barbara.ca.us> Sent:Monday, June 11, 2018 8:31 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:FW: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up Good morning, Chris. I hope you enjoyed the rest of your whirlwind visit to Sacramento. The tone was certainly different  at this year’s BLES!    I checked in with Tom at MBCP to see if it was still an option to have the northern part of SB County join them as a back  up to forming a new CCA. Please see his response to one of the questions below – can you weigh in on what your  prospects are for joining MBCP vs starting your own? Also, can we chat about what it might look like if our PG&E  territory were to join with you (and southern with CPA)? I have pretty good availability tomorrow and Thursday. Any  open slots for you?    1. Are there other jurisdictions currently interested in joining MBCP? We made a proposal to provide services to  SLO and Morro Bay, potentially a new CCA to be formed by July.    Thanks,  Jen  From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Saturday, June 09, 2018 11:06 AM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    Hi Jennifer  Glad to know that  you guys are back on the CCE formation track. Below are my answers to your questions which I’ll be  happy to elaborate on with you and others, so don’t hesitate to call to schedule a conference call    Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557 (cell)  (831) 641‐7215 (direct)  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        From: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 4:30 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    Hello Tom,    117 I hope this email finds you well. Pacific Energy Advisors has completed our new CCE feasibility study (attached), this time  just for Santa Barbara County rather than our tri‐county region with SLO and Ventura. The new study looks promising for  our elected officials to move forward with a CCE program serving all or part of Santa Barbara County, should they choose  to do so. That said, our Board of Supervisors remains interested—likely as a back‐up option—in splitting ourselves in two  and potentially joining MBCP for the PG&E parts of our county and CPA for the SCE parts.     I’ll be taking the new study results to our Board on July 17. To inform my presentation of options, I would appreciate if  you could advise on the below questions related to MBCP’s interest and process in taking us on. Do you have some time  to discuss in the next week or two?    1. Are you/your board potentially still interested in having Northern Santa Barbara County join MBCP? YES  2. What is the current process for joining MBCP? Have the county pass a resolution expressing the County’s desire  to join MBCP. Once our Board approves of including SBC to our JPA, you’re in.  3. Would a new member have any joining fees? If so, can you help us understand how the fees are calculated,  what they would cover, and whether the fees would be paid back through future revenues generated by  customers located in SB County? There is no fee to join. You may need to front $30,000 to pay for amending our  implementation plan. This fee will be refunded to you roughly 90 days after enrolling SBC customers  4. How soon could a new member’s customers begin receiving electricity service from MBCP? More specifically,  would it be possible to submit an updated implementation plan to the CPUC by January 1, 2019 to begin service  for our customers in 2020? Yes and yes provided the decision to join is made no later than July or August at the  latest  5. What would you need from a new member to update MBCP’s implementation plan? A signed resolution  expressing your desire to join which we can draft for you    6. What is the likelihood that potential future new renewable generation projects could be built in Santa Barbara  County? Good, assuming the price is within acceptable premium to MBCP (inclusive of SBC)  7. Can you describe your current power supply portfolio and overall approach (e.g., content, contract length, plans  for local generation, open position)? So far, we have signed 56 confirmations for hedged price energy, indexed  priced renewable (bucket one), indexed priced carbon free resources (large hydro) and RA. These agreements  range in duration from one month (RA) to four years (carbon free). Our open position range from 20% in 2019 to  70% in 2022. In addition, we, along with SVCE, are in negotiations with 3 developers for wind (200 MW) and  solar + storage (300 MW), of which MBCP’s share will be 225 MW, meeting 18% of our customer demand. We  expect these negotiations to conclude in July and the resources to be online by 2021. Finally, the approved  power resource mix for 2018 is 30% eligible renewable (all bucket one) and 100% carbon free. This is likely to  change in favor of eligible resources in future years    8. Are there other jurisdictions currently interested in joining MBCP? We made a proposal to provide services to  SLO and Morro Bay, potentially a new CCA to be formed by July.  9. For the unincorporated parts of Santa Barbara County to join MBCP, we would also need to join/form another  CCA serving the SCE parts of our county. The CPUC has been unwilling to confirm whether they would accept  this split‐CCA approach to offer service to 100% of our residential customers, as required by PUC Section  366.2(b). This could present a risk to the CPUC certifying your implementation plan should your plan include  unincorporated Santa Barbara County. Are you/would you anticipate your board would accept this risk?  Obviously we’ll need to do some homework to get the CPUC to take position on this issue. To the extent they  stick to the letter of section 366.2 (b), then SBC has a decision to make, they can have the city of SB join while  we litigate the county split with the CPUC or they can have the entire county become a single CCA and struggle  with the issue of devising different generation rates for the County’s north and south section. Either way, I don’t  see any risk to MBCP      Thank you, as always, for letting me pepper you with questions. Any time    Have a wonderful weekend,  Jen    118   Jennifer Cregar Co-Division Chief Sustainability Division 805-568-3506 T | 805-560-1091 F jcregar@countyofsb.org   From: Tom Habashi <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 1:20 PM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up    No worries, best of luck getting across that finish line, one way or another.     From: Cregar, Jennifer [mailto:jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us]   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 1:16 PM  To: 'Tom Habashi' <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up     Fantastic. Thank you for the always speedy reply!     From: Tom Habashi [mailto:tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org]   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 1:07 PM  To: Cregar, Jennifer <jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us>  Subject: RE: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up     Hi Jennifer  See answers below. Let me know if you have any additional questions.     From: Cregar, Jennifer [mailto:jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us]   Sent: Thursday, October 12, 2017 11:54 AM  To: 'tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org' <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: 'Chris Read' <cread@co.slo.ca.us>; Jon Griesser <jgriesser@co.slo.ca.us>; Chapjian, George <gchapjian@co.santa‐ barbara.ca.us>  Subject: Santa Barbara County MBCE follow up     Hi Tom,     We presented to the County of Santa Barbara Board of Supervisors last week on the results of our CCE feasibility study  and options for how to proceed, including the possibility of our North County customers joining MBCE (and LACCE for  our South County customers). Our Board asked us to further study the feasibility of starting our own CCE program, as  well as additional details related to joining MBCE (and LACCE). Can you please respond to the follow‐up questions  below?     1. If Santa Barbara County were to join MBCE, would we have the ability to modify the base electricity product  offered to our customers? Specifically, could we increase the RPS‐eligible renewable energy content above the  planned RPS‐equivalent, say to 50%? Would this incur any additional cost to the County or our customers?  Provided that Santa Barbara join MBCP, all decisions regarding the proper power supply mix, rates, reserve policy, etc.  will be done jointly by the Board of Directors and any decision made by the Board will applicable to all. Regarding  increasing the % of eligible renewable in the mix, it’s very likely that we’ll see the return of SB100 in early 2018, which  will accelerate the 50% eligible renewable in the mix to 50% by 2025. Meanwhile, I believe that during the next 2 years,  119 the decision to go with 100% carbon free and meeting 100% of the RPS using type 1 renewable is a prudent approach to  maximize the reduction of GHG and to help us accumulate enough reserves and become credit worthy  2. Can you provide some information on MBCE’s plans for investment in new local renewable energy generation,  including timeframe for when MBCE thinks it may be able to contract for new generation and where such  projects might be located, specifically whether such projects might be located in Santa Barbara County or if the  focus is mainly on the original 3 county participants?  We issued an RFO for long term renewables in conjunction with SVCE. The offers are due tomorrow and we’ll evaluate  the results and select few options for negotiation and eventually signing contracts by Jan 2018. These contract will  provide sufficient power to meet roughly 10% of MBCP’s electricity demand. We’re likely to repeat in 12‐18 months  from now. We have no conceived plans for local generation and hopeful that some of the offers will be well priced to  justify keeping the deal local.      3. It doesn’t look like Santa Barbara County will make a decision to join MBCE by the Thanksgiving time period to  be include in your Phase 2 launch in July 2018. If we were to join later in 2018, is your ballpark cost estimate still  $0 up to $25‐50,000 to modify your implementation plan?  Yes.      Many thanks,  Jen       Jennifer Cregar  Project Supervisor  Energy and Sustainability Initiatives  805-568-3506 T | 805-560-1091 F  jcregar@countyofsb.org        120 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 11, 2018 8:14 AM To:Deb Emerson Subject:RE: SLO/MB CCE Proposals for Review Attachments:MBCP_SLO_Proposal_6.4.18_executed.pdf; SMUD_Proposal_for_San_Luis_Obispo_Community_Choice_Energy.pdf; TEA_SLO_RFP_Response_Final_.pdf No problem, attached. From: Deb Emerson <demerson@sonomacleanpower.org>   Sent: Saturday, June 9, 2018 10:44 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: Re: SLO/MB CCE Proposals for Review    Chris,   If you get this message is there any chance you could reforward the proposals? My iPad isn’t downloading them  although I did see them the first day it was sent. But now when I’m getting ready to fly back it says cannot download.   Deb Emerson | Sonoma Clean Power Director of Power Services www.SonomaCleanPower.org Direct: (707) 978-3469 | Cell: (410) 615-0904 Customer Service: 1 (855) 202-2139   On Jun 8, 2018, at 11:13 PM, Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org> wrote:  CCE Review Team,    Shawn and her team put together a review matrix to help compare pricing/terms and key considerations across the proposals. Hope it helps! Let me know if you have any questions.    Best,    Chris     From: Read, Chris   Sent: Thursday, June 7, 2018 12:20 PM  To: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>; 'shawn marshall' <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>; 'Scott Collins'  <scollins@morrobayca.gov>; 'Deb Emerson' <demerson@sonomacleanpower.org>; 'Eric Veium'  <eric@slocleanenergy.org>  Subject: RE: SLO/MB CCE Proposals for Review  Importance: High     Hi everyone,    After taking a pass at the proposals (and given that there are only 3 submitted), I propose that we invite all 3 teams to interview on the 19th. If that makes sense to everyone else, I’d like to extend interview invitations tomorrow so folks have extra time to make travel arraignments. 121 Please express your disagreement or agreement with this approach by start of business tomorrow. If I don’t hear any objections, I will move forward with invitations tomorrow morning.    For the review team, there are no changes to schedule. I still expect review comments to be submitted to me by 6/12 and everyone is still expected to participate in the 1p conference call on 6/13.     I’m sure you have also noticed that the price proposals came back very different. To help compare apples and oranges, Shawn is putting together a comparison of the costs and what they get us. We should be able to share that with the review team tomorrow afternoon.    Finally, for the interview, I propose that each one be 60 minutes, with a 5 minute vendor presentation, 30 minutes of standard questions (same across all three proposals), and 25 minutes of proposal specific questions. Please provide thoughts on this by the end of the week. Given the importance and complicated nature of the interviews, I’d be open to 90 minute interviews if you all think that is necessary…     Thank you all so much for your help with this. Exciting times!    Best,    Chris Read Sustainability Manager <image001.png> City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org    Chris     From: Read, Chris   Sent: Monday, June 4, 2018 5:45 PM  To: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>; shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>; Scott Collins  <scollins@morrobayca.gov>; 'Deb Emerson' <demerson@sonomacleanpower.org>; 'Eric Veium'  <eric@slocleanenergy.org>  Subject: SLO/MB CCE Proposals for Review     SLO and Morro Bay CCE Review Team,    I am thrilled to be sharing the proposals we received in response to our CCE RFP! Please find the proposals and review/ranking tools attached. As noted in the schedule below, please provide a completed review tool for each proposal back to me on 6/12.     Review schedule:     6/4 – Receive proposals; send proposals and review guide to review team   6/12 – Submit review comments (via email, to me)   6/13 – Conference call to discuss proposals and interview (4-5p, invite coming under separate email. If you would prefer the call be from 1-2, let me know)   6/19 – Interviews   6/22 – Notify selected firm   7/6 – Complete contract review   122  7/9 – Start work    Also, we don’t intend to make these documents public unless there is a specific request to do so. Please do not share outside this group without consulting with me first.     Feel free to reach out with any questions or comments.    Many thanks!    Chris Read Sustainability Manager <image001.png> City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  <SLO‐MB_CCE Bidders Matrix.pdf>  123 Hicks, Bailey From:Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Friday, June 8, 2018 9:42 AM To:Read, Chris Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Hi Chris,    Our preferences in order are:    1. 10:00am‐11:45am  2. 3:00pm‐4:45pm    From: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>   Sent: Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM  To: Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview    Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  124 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  125 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, June 8, 2018 9:05 AM To:Mark Bachman Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:Central Coast CCE Technical and Energy Services Interview Greetings, Mark Bachman, Thank you for submitting a proposal for CCE Technical and Energy Services. We would like to invite your team to an interview at City Hall in San Luis Obispo on June 19, 2018. The following time slots are available:  10:00a -11:45a  1:00p – 2:45p  3:00p – 4:45p Please let us know your top two preferred times. We will reply with confirmation of timing and more detail about the interview. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  126 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Monday, June 4, 2018 5:47 PM To:Hill, Robert;shawn marshall;Scott Collins;Deb Emerson;Eric Veium Subject:SLO/MB CCE Proposals for Review Attachments:SMUD_Proposal_for_San_Luis_Obispo_Community_Choice_Energy.pdf; SLO_RFP_Response_Final_.pdf; SLO-MBCP_Proposal_6.4.18_executed.pdf; CCE_RFP Ranking Tool.docx; CCE_RFP Review Tool.docx SLO and Morro Bay CCE Review Team, I am thrilled to be sharing the proposals we received in response to our CCE RFP! Please find the proposals and review/ranking tools attached. As noted in the schedule below, please provide a completed review tool for each proposal back to me on 6/12. Review schedule:  6/4 – Receive proposals; send proposals and review guide to review team  6/12 – Submit review comments (via email, to me)  6/13 – Conference call to discuss proposals and interview (4-5p, invite coming under separate email. If you would prefer the call be from 1-2, let me know)  6/19 – Interviews  6/22 – Notify selected firm  7/6 – Complete contract review  7/9 – Start work Also, we don’t intend to make these documents public unless there is a specific request to do so. Please do not share outside this group without consulting with me first. Feel free to reach out with any questions or comments. Many thanks! Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  127 Hicks, Bailey From:Colleran, Lorraine Sent:Monday, June 4, 2018 3:56 PM To:Hill, Robert;Read, Chris Subject:RFP proposals Attachments:SMUD_Proposal_for_San_Luis_Obispo_Community_Choice_Energy.pdf; SLO_RFP_Response_Final_.pdf; SLO-MBCP_Proposal_6.4.18_executed.pdf Lorraine Colleran Accounting Assistant III Finance-Purchasing 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E lcolleran@slocity.org T 805.781.7435 slocity.org    128 Hicks, Bailey From:Hilary Staver <hilary.staver@svcleanenergy.org> Sent:Thursday, May 24, 2018 9:57 AM To:jcregar@co.santa- barbara.ca.us;tom.moody@ci.corona.ca.us;kmorris@hermosabch.org;julie.benabente@sanjoseca.gov; msears@cityofdavis.org;spoonhour@wrcog.cog.ca.us;dking@cosb.org;tprill@sanjacintoca.us;kbarrow s@cvag.org;hmartinez@cordobacorp.com;Beth Vaughan;mswan@applevalley.org;Hendry, James;kwells@cityoflancasterca.org;Mskolnik@ceo.lacounty.gov;CC Song;Tom Habashi;Joseph F. Wiedman;Katherine Hernandez;aretalla@placer.ca.gov;acampbell@redwoodenergy.org;Neal Reardon;Joseph Moon;Ramirez, Manuel;Dan Griffiths;Shalini Swaroop;Michael Callahan;Nathaniel Malcolm (nmalcolm@mcecleanenergy.org);Jenine Windeshausen;dtibbs@aes4u.com;rengel@redwoodenergy.org;Steve Shupe;CB Hall;leah.goldberg@sanjoseca.gov;kelli.parmley@sanjoseca.gov;Greg Wade;scott.green@sanjoseca.gov;Ty Tosdal;cnajera@encinitasca.gov;cbrown@delmar.ca.us;jason.haber@carlsbadca.gov;MLahsaiezadeh@ ci.oceanside.ca.us;Read, Chris;Hill, Robert Cc:Barbara Spoonhour;jgwynn@redwoodenergy.org;Huynh, Leanna;Kofi Antobam Subject:Agenda for CalCCA Affiliate Monthly Regulatory Discussion Attachments:CalCCA Affiliate Regulatory Discussion agenda 24May18.pdf Hello Affiliate Team,    I hope this finds everyone well. It’s been a little less than a month since our last call on May 3rd, but that’s just as well  because there’s a lot going on! Attached is the agenda for our call at 10:00 am. We’ll discuss updates in the IRP, CCA  bond methodology, and tree mortality non‐bypassable charge proceedings, as well as this month’s biggest headline, the  Green Book. Talk soon.    Best,  Hilary  CalCCA Regulatory Committee Chair      Hilary Staver Manager of Regulatory and Legislative Affairs (408)-721-5301 x1008  SVCleanEnergy.org | Follow us @SVCleanEnergy    SVCE is committed to protecting customer privacy. Learn more about our privacy policy at:  https://www.svcleanenergy.org/customer‐confidentiality   129 Hicks, Bailey From:Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Wednesday, May 23, 2018 8:18 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: SLO CCE Pre-bid Presentation Hi Chris  We are putting a proposal together for you and Mark Bachman is planning on being at the meeting tomorrow. Looking  forward to working together, one way or another.  Best    Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Wednesday, May 23, 2018 5:41 PM  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: SLO CCE Pre‐bid Presentation    Greetings, For those of you planning on calling in to tomorrow’s pre-bid conference, please find our opening presentation, attached. If you have any technical difficulties calling in, please let me know via email. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  130 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 23, 2018 5:41 PM Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:SLO CCE Pre-bid Presentation Attachments:2018_5.24 - SLO CCE Pre Bid Presentation.pdf Greetings, For those of you planning on calling in to tomorrow’s pre-bid conference, please find our opening presentation, attached. If you have any technical difficulties calling in, please let me know via email. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  131 Hicks, Bailey From:Administrator <postmaster@slocity.org> Sent:Wednesday, May 23, 2018 5:19 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:[Postmaster] Email Delivery Failure This is a delivery failure notification message indicating that an email you addressed to email address :  ‐‐ habashi@mbcommunitypower.org    could not be delivered. The problem appears to be :  ‐‐ Recipient email address is possibly incorrect    Additional information follows :  ‐‐ sorry, no mailbox here by that name. ulc: 46301932229, rcp: 0001. (#5.7.1)    This condition occurred after 1 attempt(s) to deliver over a period of 0 hour(s).    If you sent the email to multiple recipients, you will receive one of these messages for each one which failed delivery,   otherwise they have been sent.      132 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 23, 2018 5:17 PM Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:SLO CCE Pre-bid Presentation Attachments:2018_5.24 - SLO CCE Pre Bid Presentation.pdf Greetings, For those of you planning on calling in to tomorrow’s pre-bid conference, please find our opening presentation, attached. If you have any technical difficulties calling in, please let me know via email. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  133 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 4:55 PM To:shawn marshall Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Looks great, thanks Shawn From: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 2:35 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: Re: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Fantastic!  I know we’ll be talking tomorrow afternoon, but can you verify my current task list? I was driving  when we last spoke so I want to be sure the list below is accurate.  I’ll get cracking on some of this stuff before  our call:     For the Bidder’s Conference/Evaluation Process:   o Brief agenda and slides (will send for tomorrow’s call)  o Reach out to CCA procurement staffer to serve on bid review committee (checking with Sonoma and  Peninsula)  o Develop draft list of finalist interview questions     JPA Agreement  o Prepare Agreement outline and list of “decision points” for discussion w/Morro Bay (will send for  Thursday’s call)  o Prepare initial JPA Agreement for attorney review (post 5/24)    May 24 Meeting with Morro Bay:  o Let’s discuss what materials/slides you’d like to develop     For our Call on Tomorrow at 3:30 pm:   o Final Plans for Bidders Conf and Meeting with Morro Bay  o Bid Evaluation Team (who and dates to hold)  o Updates/load data authorizations from other cities   o Anything needed for community advisory cmte/public info? (CCA info webpage?)       Did I miss anything?  I am traveling down to Riverside tomorrow for a meeting that runs 12‐2 pm so will send  stuff across cob today.       Shawn Marshall   Director, LEAN Energy US  P.O. Box 961   Mill Valley, CA 94941  (415) 786-9118 (m)  www.LEANenergyus.org 134     From: "Read, Chris" <cread@slocity.org>  Date: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 at 6:54 PM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>  Subject: FW: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    FYI… Good news! We’ll catch up on Thursday.     From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List     Hi Lorraine,    Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:    jfuller@teainc.org   swadalawala@teainc.org   Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org   Tasha.Crawford@smud.org   andyw@acespower.com   randy.howard@ncpa.com   kirby@pacificea.com   saleba@eesconsulting.com   mef@mrwassoc.com   habashi@mbcommunitypower.org   Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com   Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com   dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com   dave.dockham@ncpa.com   Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com   nchaset@ebce.org    Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151.    Best,    Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 135 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  136 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 2:35 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:Re: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Fantastic!  I know we’ll be talking tomorrow afternoon, but can you verify my current task list? I was driving  when we last spoke so I want to be sure the list below is accurate.  I’ll get cracking on some of this stuff before  our call:     For the Bidder’s Conference/Evaluation Process:   o Brief agenda and slides (will send for tomorrow’s call)  o Reach out to CCA procurement staffer to serve on bid review committee (checking with Sonoma and  Peninsula)  o Develop draft list of finalist interview questions     JPA Agreement  o Prepare Agreement outline and list of “decision points” for discussion w/Morro Bay (will send for  Thursday’s call)  o Prepare initial JPA Agreement for attorney review (post 5/24)    May 24 Meeting with Morro Bay:  o Let’s discuss what materials/slides you’d like to develop     For our Call on Tomorrow at 3:30 pm:   o Final Plans for Bidders Conf and Meeting with Morro Bay  o Bid Evaluation Team (who and dates to hold)  o Updates/load data authorizations from other cities   o Anything needed for community advisory cmte/public info? (CCA info webpage?)       Did I miss anything?  I am traveling down to Riverside tomorrow for a meeting that runs 12‐2 pm so will send  stuff across cob today.       Shawn Marshall   Director, LEAN Energy US  P.O. Box 961   Mill Valley, CA 94941  (415) 786-9118 (m)  www.LEANenergyus.org     137 From: "Read, Chris" <cread@slocity.org>  Date: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 at 6:54 PM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>  Subject: FW: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    FYI… Good news! We’ll catch up on Thursday.     From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List     Hi Lorraine,    Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:    jfuller@teainc.org   swadalawala@teainc.org   Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org   Tasha.Crawford@smud.org   andyw@acespower.com   randy.howard@ncpa.com   kirby@pacificea.com   saleba@eesconsulting.com   mef@mrwassoc.com   habashi@mbcommunitypower.org   Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com   Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com   dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com   dave.dockham@ncpa.com   Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com   nchaset@ebce.org    Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151.    Best,    Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  138 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:36 PM To:Colleran, Lorraine Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Not to be silly, but since it seems like the system isn’t set up for our type of solicitation, can you put $1? From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:11 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    No I tried From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:10 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Can it be $0? From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:09 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    BidSync wants a dollar amount. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:01 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    This is an unusual solicitation because there is no dollar amount. The costs incurred are deferred until the program is operational, at which point, the revenues from the program will pay the deferred costs. The term of the contract is also open to negotiation. We describe it in the RFP as, “Requested services are to be provided during the Program assessment and implementation/launch period, anticipated to be July 2018 – December 2019, followed by a 36 – 48 month initial Program operating period expected to commence on or about January 1, 2020.” From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:33 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    You will have to give me the dollar amount budgeted for this project. 139 From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:01 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Sorry, in a meeting with limited access to email. I’ll get back to you at 1130. Thanks. From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:00 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List  Importance: High    I need the phone numbers of all the vendors in order to add them to BidSync. You have not returned my call, or e-mail, so I will have to wait for your approval on the ad. Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris 140 From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org 141 Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  142 Hicks, Bailey From:Colleran, Lorraine Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:11 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List No I tried From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:10 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Can it be $0? From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:09 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    BidSync wants a dollar amount. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:01 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    This is an unusual solicitation because there is no dollar amount. The costs incurred are deferred until the program is operational, at which point, the revenues from the program will pay the deferred costs. The term of the contract is also open to negotiation. We describe it in the RFP as, “Requested services are to be provided during the Program assessment and implementation/launch period, anticipated to be July 2018 – December 2019, followed by a 36 – 48 month initial Program operating period expected to commence on or about January 1, 2020.” From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:33 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    You will have to give me the dollar amount budgeted for this project. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:01 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Sorry, in a meeting with limited access to email. I’ll get back to you at 1130. Thanks. 143 From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:00 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List  Importance: High    I need the phone numbers of all the vendors in order to add them to BidSync. You have not returned my call, or e-mail, so I will have to wait for your approval on the ad. Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, 144 Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager 145 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  146 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:10 PM To:Colleran, Lorraine Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Can it be $0? From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:09 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    BidSync wants a dollar amount. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:01 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    This is an unusual solicitation because there is no dollar amount. The costs incurred are deferred until the program is operational, at which point, the revenues from the program will pay the deferred costs. The term of the contract is also open to negotiation. We describe it in the RFP as, “Requested services are to be provided during the Program assessment and implementation/launch period, anticipated to be July 2018 – December 2019, followed by a 36 – 48 month initial Program operating period expected to commence on or about January 1, 2020.” From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:33 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    You will have to give me the dollar amount budgeted for this project. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:01 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Sorry, in a meeting with limited access to email. I’ll get back to you at 1130. Thanks. From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:00 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List  Importance: High    147 I need the phone numbers of all the vendors in order to add them to BidSync. You have not returned my call, or e-mail, so I will have to wait for your approval on the ad. Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List  148   Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  149 Hicks, Bailey From:Colleran, Lorraine Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:10 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Okay I will submit now to trib. Thanks for responding. If someone has questions for me I will be happy to help. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 12:59 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    This looks perfect, thanks Lorraine. Kristen’s name was in the standard RFP template for spec contact, so I assumed it would be you. If it is consistent with our protocol and policies, I have no problem being the contact. Thanks again! From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 9:11 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Please review and correct if needed. I don’t know why people would contact me about your Spec? I put your name down as contact for questions. Thank you, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com 150  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, 151 Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  152 Hicks, Bailey From:Colleran, Lorraine Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:09 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List BidSync wants a dollar amount. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:01 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    This is an unusual solicitation because there is no dollar amount. The costs incurred are deferred until the program is operational, at which point, the revenues from the program will pay the deferred costs. The term of the contract is also open to negotiation. We describe it in the RFP as, “Requested services are to be provided during the Program assessment and implementation/launch period, anticipated to be July 2018 – December 2019, followed by a 36 – 48 month initial Program operating period expected to commence on or about January 1, 2020.” From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:33 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    You will have to give me the dollar amount budgeted for this project. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:01 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Sorry, in a meeting with limited access to email. I’ll get back to you at 1130. Thanks. From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:00 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List  Importance: High    I need the phone numbers of all the vendors in order to add them to BidSync. You have not returned my call, or e-mail, so I will have to wait for your approval on the ad. Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  153 To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, 154 Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  155 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 1:01 PM To:Colleran, Lorraine Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List This is an unusual solicitation because there is no dollar amount. The costs incurred are deferred until the program is operational, at which point, the revenues from the program will pay the deferred costs. The term of the contract is also open to negotiation. We describe it in the RFP as, “Requested services are to be provided during the Program assessment and implementation/launch period, anticipated to be July 2018 – December 2019, followed by a 36 – 48 month initial Program operating period expected to commence on or about January 1, 2020.” From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:33 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    You will have to give me the dollar amount budgeted for this project. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:01 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Sorry, in a meeting with limited access to email. I’ll get back to you at 1130. Thanks. From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:00 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List  Importance: High    I need the phone numbers of all the vendors in order to add them to BidSync. You have not returned my call, or e-mail, so I will have to wait for your approval on the ad. Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org 156  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List  157   Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  158 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 12:59 PM To:Colleran, Lorraine Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List This looks perfect, thanks Lorraine. Kristen’s name was in the standard RFP template for spec contact, so I assumed it would be you. If it is consistent with our protocol and policies, I have no problem being the contact. Thanks again! From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 9:11 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Please review and correct if needed. I don’t know why people would contact me about your Spec? I put your name down as contact for questions. Thank you, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org 159  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com 160  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  161 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 12:59 PM To:Colleran, Lorraine Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List This looks perfect, thanks Lorraine. Kristen’s name was in the standard RFP template for spec contact, so I assumed it would be you. If it is consistent with our protocol and policies, I have no problem being the contact. Thanks again! From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 9:11 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Please review and correct if needed. I don’t know why people would contact me about your Spec? I put your name down as contact for questions. Thank you, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org 162  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com 163  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  164 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 12:56 PM To:Colleran, Lorraine Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Updated to include phone numbers:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org; (425) 453-6305  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org; (425) 453-6305  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org; 916‐732‐5483  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org;  916‐732‐6205   ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com; (317) 344‐7089   The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com; (916) 781‐3636  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com; (916) 781‐3636  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com; (916) 781‐3636  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com; (916) 936‐3300  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com; (425)  889‐2700  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com; (510) 834‐1999   Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org; 831‐641‐7222  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com; 617 224 9900  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com; (858) 678‐0118  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org; 833‐ 699‐3223  165 Hicks, Bailey From:Colleran, Lorraine Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:33 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List You will have to give me the dollar amount budgeted for this project. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:01 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Sorry, in a meeting with limited access to email. I’ll get back to you at 1130. Thanks. From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:00 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List  Importance: High    I need the phone numbers of all the vendors in order to add them to BidSync. You have not returned my call, or e-mail, so I will have to wait for your approval on the ad. Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org 166  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com 167  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  168 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:01 AM To:Colleran, Lorraine Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Sorry, in a meeting with limited access to email. I’ll get back to you at 1130. Thanks. From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:00 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List  Importance: High    I need the phone numbers of all the vendors in order to add them to BidSync. You have not returned my call, or e-mail, so I will have to wait for your approval on the ad. Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris 169 From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org 170 Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  171 Hicks, Bailey From:Colleran, Lorraine Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 11:00 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List I need the phone numbers of all the vendors in order to add them to BidSync. You have not returned my call, or e-mail, so I will have to wait for your approval on the ad. Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. 172 Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager 173 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  174 Hicks, Bailey From:Colleran, Lorraine Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 9:11 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Attachments:ADMIN_Energy_Spec91669.docx Chris, Please review and correct if needed. I don’t know why people would contact me about your Spec? I put your name down as contact for questions. Thank you, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris 175 From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org 176 Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  177 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:39 AM To:Colleran, Lorraine Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Business Name, address, and email contacts:  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; jfuller@teainc.org  The Energy Authority; 405 114th Avenue SE Suite 100, Bellevue, WA 98004; swadalawala@teainc.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Sacramento Municipal Utility District; 6301 S St., Sacramento, CA 95817; Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  ACES Power; 1000 South Highway 80, Benson, AZ 85602; andyw@acespower.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; dave.dockham@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  The Northern California Power Agency; 651 Commerce Drive, Roseville, CA 95678-6411; randy.howard@ncpa.com  Pacific Energy Advisors; 1839 Iron Point Road, Suite 120 Folsom CA 95630; kirby@pacificea.com  EES Consulting; 570 Kirkland Way, Suite 100, Kirkland, WA 98033; saleba@eesconsulting.com  MRW & Associated; 1736 Franklin Street, Suite 700, Oakland, California 94612; mef@mrwassoc.com  Monterey Bay Community Power; 70 Garden Court Suite 300, Monterey, CA 93940; habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  ENERNOC; Two Embarcadero Center, 8th Floor, San Francisco CA, 94111; Mtierney- lloyd@enernoc.com  Pilot Power Group, Inc.; 8910 University Center Lane, Suite 520, San Diego, CA 92122; dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  East Bay Community Energy; 1111 Broadway, 3rd Floor Oakland, CA 94607; nchaset@ebce.org Feel free to give me a call with any questions. Thanks! Chris From: Read, Chris   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 8:23 AM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, thanks! The final RFP is attached and here. I’ll compile business names and addresses and send your way shortly. Best, Chris From: Colleran, Lorraine   Sent: Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    178 Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  179 Hicks, Bailey From:Colleran, Lorraine Sent:Wednesday, May 16, 2018 7:41 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Chris, Great, I will work on the RFP. Do you have a copy (final)? You will have to add the business names and address to your list, so they can be added to BidSync. Thanks, Lorraine From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager 180 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  181 Hicks, Bailey From:Hill, Robert Sent:Tuesday, May 15, 2018 8:06 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:Re: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Damn, fool.  You are on it!    Robert Hill  Natural Resources Manager  City Administration  Natural Resources  990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401‐3249  E rhill@slocity.org  T 805.781.7211  slocity.org   From: Read, Chris  Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:53:56 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine  Cc: Hill, Robert  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List      Hi Lorraine,    Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:    jfuller@teainc.org   swadalawala@teainc.org   Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org   Tasha.Crawford@smud.org   andyw@acespower.com   randy.howard@ncpa.com   kirby@pacificea.com   saleba@eesconsulting.com   mef@mrwassoc.com   habashi@mbcommunitypower.org   Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com   Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com   dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com   dave.dockham@ncpa.com   Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com   nchaset@ebce.org    Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151.    Best,    Chris Read Sustainability Manager 182 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  183 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM To:shawn marshall Subject:FW: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List FYI… Good news! We’ll catch up on Thursday. From: Read, Chris   Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM  To: Colleran, Lorraine <lcolleran@slocity.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List    Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org 184 T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  185 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Tuesday, May 15, 2018 6:54 PM To:Colleran, Lorraine Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:Community Choice Energy RFP & Vendor Short List Hi Lorraine, Good news, our RFP was approved to be released by Council! Please let me know when the RFP is in BidSync and please distribute to the following vendors:  jfuller@teainc.org  swadalawala@teainc.org  Victoria.Zavattero@smud.org  Tasha.Crawford@smud.org  andyw@acespower.com  randy.howard@ncpa.com  kirby@pacificea.com  saleba@eesconsulting.com  mef@mrwassoc.com  habashi@mbcommunitypower.org  Mtierney-lloyd@enernoc.com  Ryan.Adelman@centrica.com  dvermette@pilotpowergroup.com  dave.dockham@ncpa.com  Tony.Zimmer@ncpa.com  nchaset@ebce.org Many thanks, and if you have any questions at all, feel free to give me a call at 805-801-7151. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  186 Hicks, Bailey From:Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Wednesday, May 9, 2018 8:36 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo - RFP for CCE Technical and Energy Services Chris  I’m discussing with my staff the best way to go about drafting an offer. I’ll be in touch after the SLO Council consider the  the RFP.    Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Tuesday, May 8, 2018 9:38 PM  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo ‐ RFP for CCE Technical and Energy Services    Dear Community Choice Energy Technical and Energy Services Vendors: We are writing to inform you that the City of San Luis Obispo’s City Council is scheduled to consider authorizing the release of a Request for Proposals for CCE Technical and Energy Services at its May 15 meeting. The Council Agenda Report for the item (#9) is now available at: http://www.slocity.org/Home/ShowDocument?id=19421. Due to condensed project scheduling that is further described in the draft RFP, the response window for submittals is expected to be three weeks; however, you may review the draft RFP now as an attachment to the Council Agenda Report. Pending the City Council’s approval, the official RFP should be available via Bid Sync no later than May 17. City staff will be conducting an optional pre-proposal conference in City Hall (and available via conference call) on May 24th at 11:00 AM. We look forward to reviewing your proposal. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 187 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  188 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Tuesday, May 8, 2018 9:38 PM Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:City of San Luis Obispo - RFP for CCE Technical and Energy Services Dear Community Choice Energy Technical and Energy Services Vendors: We are writing to inform you that the City of San Luis Obispo’s City Council is scheduled to consider authorizing the release of a Request for Proposals for CCE Technical and Energy Services at its May 15 meeting. The Council Agenda Report for the item (#9) is now available at: http://www.slocity.org/Home/ShowDocument?id=19421. Due to condensed project scheduling that is further described in the draft RFP, the response window for submittals is expected to be three weeks; however, you may review the draft RFP now as an attachment to the Council Agenda Report. Pending the City Council’s approval, the official RFP should be available via Bid Sync no later than May 17. City staff will be conducting an optional pre-proposal conference in City Hall (and available via conference call) on May 24th at 11:00 AM. We look forward to reviewing your proposal. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  189 Hicks, Bailey From:shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org> Sent:Friday, May 4, 2018 2:24 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:Re: San Luis Obispo CCE Perfect.  He knows you are working with us and I assume he’ll think that’s a good thing… ͬͭͮͯ  Glad you guys  are going to connect.  Keep me posted. S‐     Shawn Marshall   Director, LEAN Energy US  P.O. Box 961   Mill Valley, CA 94941  (415) 786-9118 (m)  www.LEANenergyus.org     From: "Read, Chris" <cread@slocity.org>  Date: Friday, May 4, 2018 at 1:26 PM  To: shawn marshall <shawnmarshall@leanenergyus.org>  Subject: FW: San Luis Obispo CCE    Just FYI…    From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, May 4, 2018 12:10 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: San Luis Obispo CCE     Hi Chris  Happy to talk to you about the RFP and the potential for working with you to set up the agency or to do joint  procurement. I’m available on Monday between 8:00 and 9:30 or any time after 3:00     Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org          From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, May 4, 2018 11:25 AM  190 To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: San Luis Obispo CCE     Hi Tom,     As you know, our City Council directed us to pursue our own CCE program, which we are in the process of moving forward on through the release of an RFP for technical and energy services on May 15 (the staff report will be publicly available on May 8).     We have great respect for your work and are interested in finding ways to work together. To that end, we hope you:    1. Consider bidding on the RFP; and/or  2. Keep us in mind for future joint procurement opportunities.    We would love to talk about the RFP over the phone on Monday, if you are available. I am completely free, except between 9 and 10a.     Thank you again, we look forward to speaking with you.    Best,    Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  191 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, May 4, 2018 1:27 PM To:shawn marshall Subject:FW: San Luis Obispo CCE Just FYI… From: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, May 4, 2018 12:10 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: San Luis Obispo CCE    Hi Chris  Happy to talk to you about the RFP and the potential for working with you to set up the agency or to do joint  procurement. I’m available on Monday between 8:00 and 9:30 or any time after 3:00    Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, May 4, 2018 11:25 AM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: San Luis Obispo CCE    Hi Tom, As you know, our City Council directed us to pursue our own CCE program, which we are in the process of moving forward on through the release of an RFP for technical and energy services on May 15 (the staff report will be publicly available on May 8). We have great respect for your work and are interested in finding ways to work together. To that end, we hope you: 1. Consider bidding on the RFP; and/or 2. Keep us in mind for future joint procurement opportunities. We would love to talk about the RFP over the phone on Monday, if you are available. I am completely free, except between 9 and 10a. Thank you again, we look forward to speaking with you. 192 Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  193 Hicks, Bailey From:Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Friday, May 4, 2018 12:10 PM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: San Luis Obispo CCE Hi Chris  Happy to talk to you about the RFP and the potential for working with you to set up the agency or to do joint  procurement. I’m available on Monday between 8:00 and 9:30 or any time after 3:00    Tom Habashi, CEO   (831) 313‐5557  thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org        From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, May 4, 2018 11:25 AM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: San Luis Obispo CCE    Hi Tom, As you know, our City Council directed us to pursue our own CCE program, which we are in the process of moving forward on through the release of an RFP for technical and energy services on May 15 (the staff report will be publicly available on May 8). We have great respect for your work and are interested in finding ways to work together. To that end, we hope you: 1. Consider bidding on the RFP; and/or 2. Keep us in mind for future joint procurement opportunities. We would love to talk about the RFP over the phone on Monday, if you are available. I am completely free, except between 9 and 10a. Thank you again, we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager 194 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  195 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, May 4, 2018 11:25 AM To:Tom Habashi Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:San Luis Obispo CCE Hi Tom, As you know, our City Council directed us to pursue our own CCE program, which we are in the process of moving forward on through the release of an RFP for technical and energy services on May 15 (the staff report will be publicly available on May 8). We have great respect for your work and are interested in finding ways to work together. To that end, we hope you: 1. Consider bidding on the RFP; and/or 2. Keep us in mind for future joint procurement opportunities. We would love to talk about the RFP over the phone on Monday, if you are available. I am completely free, except between 9 and 10a. Thank you again, we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  196 Hicks, Bailey From:Hilary Staver <hilary.staver@svcleanenergy.org> Sent:Thursday, May 3, 2018 11:49 AM To:jason.haber@carlsbadca.gov;Hill, Robert;Joseph F. Wiedman;jcregar@co.santa- barbara.ca.us;tom.moody@ci.corona.ca.us;kmorris@hermosabch.org;julie.benabente@sanjoseca.gov; msears@cityofdavis.org;spoonhour@wrcog.cog.ca.us;dking@cosb.org;tprill@sanjacintoca.us;kbarrow s@cvag.org;hmartinez@cordobacorp.com;Beth Vaughan;mswan@applevalley.org;Hendry, James;kwells@cityoflancasterca.org;Mskolnik@ceo.lacounty.gov;CC Song;Tom Habashi;Katherine Hernandez;aretalla@placer.ca.gov;acampbell@redwoodenergy.org;Neal Reardon;Joseph Moon;Ramirez, Manuel;Dan Griffiths;Shalini Swaroop;Michael Callahan;Nathaniel Malcolm (nmalcolm@mcecleanenergy.org);Jenine Windeshausen;dtibbs@aes4u.com;rengel@redwoodenergy.org;Steve Shupe;CB Hall;leah.goldberg@sanjoseca.gov;kelli.parmley@sanjoseca.gov;Greg Wade;scott.green@sanjoseca.gov;Ty Tosdal;cnajera@encinitasca.gov;cbrown@delmar.ca.us;MLahsaiezadeh@ci.oceanside.ca.us;Read, Chris Cc:Huynh, Leanna;Barbara Spoonhour;jgwynn@redwoodenergy.org;Tom Habashi Subject:RE: CalCCA Affiliate Monthly Regulatory Discussion Hello everyone,    Thanks for a robust discussion this morning. Here is the information on the “Green Book” being released today under  the California Consumer Choice Project (CCCP): http://www.cpuc.ca.gov/customerchoice/     If you scroll through this page, you will find some history on the CCCP, a link to the Green Book itself, and call‐in  information for the webinar scheduled for 1:30‐2:30 pm today.     Best,  Hilary    From: Hilary Staver   Sent: Thursday, May 3, 2018 8:34 AM  To: 'jason.haber@carlsbadca.gov' <jason.haber@carlsbadca.gov>; 'rhill@slocity.org' <rhill@slocity.org>; 'Joseph F.  Wiedman' <jwiedman@peninsulacleanenergy.com>; 'jcregar@co.santa‐barbara.ca.us' <jcregar@co.santa‐ barbara.ca.us>; 'tom.moody@ci.corona.ca.us' <tom.moody@ci.corona.ca.us>; 'kmorris@hermosabch.org'  <kmorris@hermosabch.org>; 'julie.benabente@sanjoseca.gov' <julie.benabente@sanjoseca.gov>;  'msears@cityofdavis.org' <msears@cityofdavis.org>; 'spoonhour@wrcog.cog.ca.us' <spoonhour@wrcog.cog.ca.us>;  'dking@cosb.org' <dking@cosb.org>; 'tprill@sanjacintoca.us' <tprill@sanjacintoca.us>; 'kbarrows@cvag.org'  <kbarrows@cvag.org>; 'hmartinez@cordobacorp.com' <hmartinez@cordobacorp.com>; Beth Vaughan <beth@cal‐ cca.org>; 'mswan@applevalley.org' <mswan@applevalley.org>; Hendry, James <JHendry@sfwater.org>;  kwells@cityoflancasterca.org; Mskolnik@ceo.lacounty.gov; 'CC Song' <csong@mcecleanenergy.org>; Tom Habashi  <tom.habashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; 'Katherine Hernandez' <khernandez@pico‐rivera.org>;  aretalla@placer.ca.gov; acampbell@redwoodenergy.org; 'Neal Reardon' <nreardon@sonomacleanpower.org>; Joseph  Moon <JMoon@applevalley.org>; Ramirez, Manuel <MRamirez@sfwater.org>; 'Dan Griffiths'  <griffiths@braunlegal.com>; Shalini Swaroop <sswaroop@mcecleanenergy.org>; Michael Callahan  <mcallahan@mcecleanenergy.org>; Nathaniel Malcolm (nmalcolm@mcecleanenergy.org)  <nmalcolm@mcecleanenergy.org>; Jenine Windeshausen <JWindesh@placer.ca.gov>; dtibbs@aes4u.com;  rengel@redwoodenergy.org; Steve Shupe <sshupe@sonomacleanpower.org>; 'CB Hall'  <CBHall@sonomacleanpower.org>; 'leah.goldberg@sanjoseca.gov' <leah.goldberg@sanjoseca.gov>;  197 'kelli.parmley@sanjoseca.gov' <kelli.parmley@sanjoseca.gov>; 'Greg Wade' <gwade@cosb.org>;  scott.green@sanjoseca.gov; 'Ty Tosdal' <ty@tosdallaw.com>; 'cnajera@encinitasca.gov' <cnajera@encinitasca.gov>;  'cbrown@delmar.ca.us' <cbrown@delmar.ca.us>; 'MLahsaiezadeh@ci.oceanside.ca.us'  <MLahsaiezadeh@ci.oceanside.ca.us>; 'cread@slocity.org' <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Huynh, Leanna <leanna.huynh@sanjoseca.gov>; Barbara Spoonhour <bspoonhour@wrcog.us>;  jgwynn@redwoodenergy.org; Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: CalCCA Affiliate Monthly Regulatory Discussion    Hello Affiliate Team,    Attached please find the agenda for today’s regulatory discussion call. I look forward to talking with all of you at 10 am.    Best,  Hilary  CalCCA Regulatory Committee Chair    Hilary Staver Manager of Regulatory and Legislative Affairs (408)-721-5301 x1008  SVCleanEnergy.org | Follow us @SVCleanEnergy    SVCE is committed to protecting customer privacy. Learn more about our privacy policy at:  https://www.svcleanenergy.org/customer‐confidentiality   198 Hicks, Bailey From:Hilary Staver <hilary.staver@svcleanenergy.org> Sent:Thursday, May 3, 2018 8:34 AM To:jason.haber@carlsbadca.gov;Hill, Robert;Joseph F. Wiedman;jcregar@co.santa- barbara.ca.us;tom.moody@ci.corona.ca.us;kmorris@hermosabch.org;julie.benabente@sanjoseca.gov; msears@cityofdavis.org;spoonhour@wrcog.cog.ca.us;dking@cosb.org;tprill@sanjacintoca.us;kbarrow s@cvag.org;hmartinez@cordobacorp.com;Beth Vaughan;mswan@applevalley.org;Hendry, James;kwells@cityoflancasterca.org;Mskolnik@ceo.lacounty.gov;CC Song;Tom Habashi;Katherine Hernandez;aretalla@placer.ca.gov;acampbell@redwoodenergy.org;Neal Reardon;Joseph Moon;Ramirez, Manuel;Dan Griffiths;Shalini Swaroop;Michael Callahan;Nathaniel Malcolm (nmalcolm@mcecleanenergy.org);Jenine Windeshausen;dtibbs@aes4u.com;rengel@redwoodenergy.org;Steve Shupe;CB Hall;leah.goldberg@sanjoseca.gov;kelli.parmley@sanjoseca.gov;Greg Wade;scott.green@sanjoseca.gov;Ty Tosdal;cnajera@encinitasca.gov;cbrown@delmar.ca.us;MLahsaiezadeh@ci.oceanside.ca.us;Read, Chris Cc:Huynh, Leanna;Barbara Spoonhour;jgwynn@redwoodenergy.org;Tom Habashi Subject:CalCCA Affiliate Monthly Regulatory Discussion Attachments:CalCCA Affiliate Regulatory Discussion agenda 3May18.pdf Hello Affiliate Team,    Attached please find the agenda for today’s regulatory discussion call. I look forward to talking with all of you at 10 am.    Best,  Hilary  CalCCA Regulatory Committee Chair    Hilary Staver Manager of Regulatory and Legislative Affairs (408)-721-5301 x1008  SVCleanEnergy.org | Follow us @SVCleanEnergy    SVCE is committed to protecting customer privacy. Learn more about our privacy policy at:  https://www.svcleanenergy.org/customer‐confidentiality   199 Hicks, Bailey From:Hall, Abby <Hall.Abby@epa.gov> Sent:Thursday, April 5, 2018 2:08 PM To:Couch, Rachel@SCC;Emma Ross;Tiffany Wise-West;Read, Chris Cc:Dana Brechwald (dbrechwald@bayareametro.gov);Arrietta Chakos (arriettachakos@gmail.com);Mindy Craig Subject:Latest RSVP list Attachments:report-2018-04-04T1745.xlsx And Kris mentioned that more are coming in every couple of days.     Abby    Abby Hall  U.S. Environmental Protection Agency  Office of Sustainable Communities  (415) 972‐3384  Hall.abby@epa.gov      200 Hicks, Bailey From:Couch, Rachel@SCC <Rachel.Couch@scc.ca.gov> Sent:Thursday, March 22, 2018 5:20 PM To:Tiffany Wise-West;Hall, Abby;Read, Chris Subject:RE: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop Hi all,  I agree that Michael McCormick will be better for the context setting and that Becky and Juliette will be great to present  the Compass Tool.   Best,  Rachel   From: Tiffany Wise‐West <TWise‐West@cityofsantacruz.com>   Sent: Thursday, March 22, 2018 12:02 PM  To: Hall, Abby <Hall.Abby@epa.gov>; Chris Reed <cr@stoss.net>; Couch, Rachel@SCC <Rachel.Couch@scc.ca.gov>  Subject: RE: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop    Yes that was my suggestion to Juliette and Becky but it seems they are more interested in just talking about the compass  tool itself and not the context. Michael will be perfect for context.     Tiffany Wise‐West, PE, LEED AP, PhD  Sustainability & Climate Action Manager  809 Center Street | Santa Cruz, CA 95060  Direct: 831.420.5433 | Mobile: 831.345.1328    Like the Climate Action Program on Facebook!        From: Hall, Abby [mailto:Hall.Abby@epa.gov]   Sent: Thursday, March 22, 2018 11:33 AM  To: Tiffany Wise‐West <TWise‐West@cityofsantacruz.com>; Chris Reed <cr@stoss.net>; Couch, Rachel@SCC  <Rachel.Couch@scc.ca.gov>  Subject: RE: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop    I don’t mind to take the call, just wanted to make sure I wasn’t overstepping.   I already invited Michael McCormick to speak to the overview issues. He may not be able to join until noon, so we’d  have to schedule that for the second half of the day.   201 As for Juliette and Becky‐ we should have a short session early in the day to talk about all the different planning  requirements and efforts out there that locals are on the hook for. They can be part of that context setting. Does that  make sense?   Thanks,  Abby    From: Tiffany Wise‐West [mailto:TWise‐West@cityofsantacruz.com]   Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2018 7:06 PM  To: Hall, Abby <Hall.Abby@epa.gov>; Chris Reed <cr@stoss.net>; Couch, Rachel@SCC <Rachel.Couch@scc.ca.gov>  Subject: RE: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop    HI ABBY I can field calls if it's problematic for you until we have leadership in place. Ruth Langridge was on my list to contact. IT would be great to have her involved. Also, how do we want Becky Lundy and Juliette Hart to plug into the conference...as speakers or jsut participants? They suggested Michael McCormick to do the Overview of GP, LHMP, and Other Policy Context which I'd feel more  comfortable with as I don't know the nuances of the policy context and not sure who else does on steering committee.  Michael indicates he is coming. Maybe extend invite soon? Then perhaps Becky and Juliette could talk at the end of the day on their compass tool in development? Waht do you think? Thx. Tiffany Wise-West, PE, LEED AP, PhD City of Santa Cruz Climate Action Program m: 831.345.1328 e: twise-west@cityofsantacruz.com w: www.cityofsantacruz.com/GoSolarSC From: Hall, Abby [Hall.Abby@epa.gov] Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2018 12:45 PM To: Tiffany Wise-West; Chris Reed; Couch, Rachel@SCC Subject: FW: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop Hi Tiffany, Chris, and Rachel,     This is the second email or call I’ve gotten to find out more about the project and the Collaborative in general. I’m okay  with taking this call and filling people in on the workshop, but I wanted to let you know I’m starting to get more inquiries  because Zak cc’ed me on the email blasts yesterday, and folks can’t find any specific contact info on the 4C website  (maybe something to think about for the future).     202 If any of you prefer to field these calls, let me know. Otherwise, I can take the calls, do my best to get them to the  workshop, and then the follow‐up connections can happen on site.      Also, I talked to Ruth Langridge from UC Santa Cruz, who is putting in a grant to the SGC on land use and climate change  on the Central Coast, along with Tamara Wilson from USGS. She’s doing some interesting work and wants to stay  plugged into this project.      All good news!  Abby     Abby Hall  U.S. Environmental Protection Agency  Office of Sustainable Communities  (415) 972‐3384  Hall.abby@epa.gov           From: Mark Bachman [mailto:mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org]   Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2018 12:24 PM  To: Hall, Abby <Hall.Abby@epa.gov>  Subject: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop     Hi Abby, Our CEO, Tom Habashi, has asked me to find out more about the resiliency work of the CCCC to see how we can become more involved. Do you have time for a phone call over the next few days? I would like to learn more about the group and the work you are doing and how MBCP can get engaged.    Best,  Mark  Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org        203             Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org     204 Hicks, Bailey From:Tiffany Wise-West <TWise-West@cityofsantacruz.com> Sent:Thursday, March 22, 2018 12:09 PM To:Hall, Abby;Read, Chris;Couch, Rachel@SCC Subject:RE: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop I talk to Mark very regularly and was the one who sent him the invite. You can send him back to me. They won’t have  surplus $ for some time and it will go through a length appropriation/evaluation process but yes it could be that some  gets prioritized toward climate resilience. But I think it has to have some kind of energy nexus.    Tiffany Wise‐West, PE, LEED AP, PhD  Sustainability & Climate Action Manager  809 Center Street | Santa Cruz, CA 95060  Direct: 831.420.5433 | Mobile: 831.345.1328    Like the Climate Action Program on Facebook!        From: Hall, Abby [mailto:Hall.Abby@epa.gov]   Sent: Thursday, March 22, 2018 12:07 PM  To: Tiffany Wise‐West <TWise‐West@cityofsantacruz.com>; cread@slocity.org; Couch, Rachel@SCC  <Rachel.Couch@scc.ca.gov>  Subject: RE: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop    Hi Tiffany, Chris, and Rachel,  I just had a great call with Mark Bachman at Monterey Bay Community Power. They’re a community choice energy  agency doing some great work in Santa Cruz, San Benito and Monterey Counties. They’re really curious about working  with the Collaborative.  I mentioned some of your challenges with staff and a fiscal agent, and he talked about how flexible they can be with  their surplus revenues, including possibly teaming up to hire staff and work on projects together. It sounds like they’re  interested in engaging on replicable models for creating resilient energy systems, which is a big topic but lots of  potential overlap.   He’s checking to see who from MBCP can come to the workshop, but I suggested he talk to someone on the Steering  Committee in advance, in case there are some real collaborations we could think about in advance, then follow‐up on in  person, maybe even on April 25 with the full Steering Committee.   Can I follow up by giving him your names and contact info? Maybe Tiffany and Chris especially with your portfolios that  touch on energy more than Rachel’s?  Thanks,  Abby  205 Abby Hall  U.S. Environmental Protection Agency  Office of Sustainable Communities  (415) 972‐3384  Hall.abby@epa.gov        From: Tiffany Wise‐West [mailto:TWise‐West@cityofsantacruz.com]   Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2018 7:06 PM  To: Hall, Abby <Hall.Abby@epa.gov>; Chris Reed <cr@stoss.net>; Couch, Rachel@SCC <Rachel.Couch@scc.ca.gov>  Subject: RE: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop    HI ABBY I can field calls if it's problematic for you until we have leadership in place. Ruth Langridge was on my list to contact. IT would be great to have her involved. Also, how do we want Becky Lundy and Juliette Hart to plug into the conference...as speakers or jsut participants? They suggested Michael McCormick to do the Overview of GP, LHMP, and Other Policy Context which I'd feel more  comfortable with as I don't know the nuances of the policy context and not sure who else does on steering committee.  Michael indicates he is coming. Maybe extend invite soon? Then perhaps Becky and Juliette could talk at the end of the day on their compass tool in development? Waht do you think? Thx. Tiffany Wise-West, PE, LEED AP, PhD City of Santa Cruz Climate Action Program m: 831.345.1328 e: twise-west@cityofsantacruz.com w: www.cityofsantacruz.com/GoSolarSC From: Hall, Abby [Hall.Abby@epa.gov] Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2018 12:45 PM To: Tiffany Wise-West; Chris Reed; Couch, Rachel@SCC Subject: FW: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop Hi Tiffany, Chris, and Rachel,     This is the second email or call I’ve gotten to find out more about the project and the Collaborative in general. I’m okay  with taking this call and filling people in on the workshop, but I wanted to let you know I’m starting to get more inquiries  because Zak cc’ed me on the email blasts yesterday, and folks can’t find any specific contact info on the 4C website  (maybe something to think about for the future).   206   If any of you prefer to field these calls, let me know. Otherwise, I can take the calls, do my best to get them to the  workshop, and then the follow‐up connections can happen on site.      Also, I talked to Ruth Langridge from UC Santa Cruz, who is putting in a grant to the SGC on land use and climate change  on the Central Coast, along with Tamara Wilson from USGS. She’s doing some interesting work and wants to stay  plugged into this project.      All good news!  Abby     Abby Hall  U.S. Environmental Protection Agency  Office of Sustainable Communities  (415) 972‐3384  Hall.abby@epa.gov           From: Mark Bachman [mailto:mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org]   Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2018 12:24 PM  To: Hall, Abby <Hall.Abby@epa.gov>  Subject: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop     Hi Abby, Our CEO, Tom Habashi, has asked me to find out more about the resiliency work of the CCCC to see how we can become more involved. Do you have time for a phone call over the next few days? I would like to learn more about the group and the work you are doing and how MBCP can get engaged.    Best,  Mark  Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org        207             Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org     208 Hicks, Bailey From:Hall, Abby <Hall.Abby@epa.gov> Sent:Thursday, March 22, 2018 12:07 PM To:Tiffany Wise-West;Read, Chris;Couch, Rachel@SCC Subject:RE: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop Hi Tiffany, Chris, and Rachel,  I just had a great call with Mark Bachman at Monterey Bay Community Power. They’re a community choice energy  agency doing some great work in Santa Cruz, San Benito and Monterey Counties. They’re really curious about working  with the Collaborative.  I mentioned some of your challenges with staff and a fiscal agent, and he talked about how flexible they can be with  their surplus revenues, including possibly teaming up to hire staff and work on projects together. It sounds like they’re  interested in engaging on replicable models for creating resilient energy systems, which is a big topic but lots of  potential overlap.   He’s checking to see who from MBCP can come to the workshop, but I suggested he talk to someone on the Steering  Committee in advance, in case there are some real collaborations we could think about in advance, then follow‐up on in  person, maybe even on April 25 with the full Steering Committee.   Can I follow up by giving him your names and contact info? Maybe Tiffany and Chris especially with your portfolios that  touch on energy more than Rachel’s?  Thanks,  Abby  Abby Hall  U.S. Environmental Protection Agency  Office of Sustainable Communities  (415) 972‐3384  Hall.abby@epa.gov        From: Tiffany Wise‐West [mailto:TWise‐West@cityofsantacruz.com]   Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2018 7:06 PM  To: Hall, Abby <Hall.Abby@epa.gov>; Chris Reed <cr@stoss.net>; Couch, Rachel@SCC <Rachel.Couch@scc.ca.gov>  Subject: RE: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop    HI ABBY I can field calls if it's problematic for you until we have leadership in place. Ruth Langridge was on my list to contact. IT would be great to have her involved. 209 Also, how do we want Becky Lundy and Juliette Hart to plug into the conference...as speakers or jsut participants? They suggested Michael McCormick to do the Overview of GP, LHMP, and Other Policy Context which I'd feel more  comfortable with as I don't know the nuances of the policy context and not sure who else does on steering committee.  Michael indicates he is coming. Maybe extend invite soon? Then perhaps Becky and Juliette could talk at the end of the day on their compass tool in development? Waht do you think? Thx. Tiffany Wise-West, PE, LEED AP, PhD City of Santa Cruz Climate Action Program m: 831.345.1328 e: twise-west@cityofsantacruz.com w: www.cityofsantacruz.com/GoSolarSC From: Hall, Abby [Hall.Abby@epa.gov] Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2018 12:45 PM To: Tiffany Wise-West; Chris Reed; Couch, Rachel@SCC Subject: FW: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop Hi Tiffany, Chris, and Rachel,     This is the second email or call I’ve gotten to find out more about the project and the Collaborative in general. I’m okay  with taking this call and filling people in on the workshop, but I wanted to let you know I’m starting to get more inquiries  because Zak cc’ed me on the email blasts yesterday, and folks can’t find any specific contact info on the 4C website  (maybe something to think about for the future).     If any of you prefer to field these calls, let me know. Otherwise, I can take the calls, do my best to get them to the  workshop, and then the follow‐up connections can happen on site.      Also, I talked to Ruth Langridge from UC Santa Cruz, who is putting in a grant to the SGC on land use and climate change  on the Central Coast, along with Tamara Wilson from USGS. She’s doing some interesting work and wants to stay  plugged into this project.      All good news!  Abby     Abby Hall  U.S. Environmental Protection Agency  Office of Sustainable Communities  (415) 972‐3384  210 Hall.abby@epa.gov           From: Mark Bachman [mailto:mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org]   Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2018 12:24 PM  To: Hall, Abby <Hall.Abby@epa.gov>  Subject: MBCP: CCCC Engagement and Resiliency Workshop     Hi Abby,     Our CEO, Tom Habashi, has asked me to find out more about the resiliency work of the CCCC to see how we can become  more involved.  Do you have time for a phone call over the next few days?  I would like to learn more about the group  and the work you are doing and how MBCP can get engaged.     Best,  Mark  Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org                    Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org     211 Hicks, Bailey From:Mark Bachman <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Tuesday, March 13, 2018 11:53 AM To:Bren Lehr;Tom Habashi;Marc Adato;Read, Chris;Hill, Robert;Meeting Subject:RE: GoToMeeting Invitation - MBCP & SLO to Discuss Creation of CCE Attachments:Revenue Allocations 3.13.18.pptx     Mark Bachman, Strategic Accounts Manager  m:(843) 991‐0308 o:(831) 641‐7207  mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org    ‐‐‐‐‐Original Appointment‐‐‐‐‐  From: Bren Lehr   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:48 AM  To: Bren Lehr; Tom Habashi; Mark Bachman; Marc Adato; Read, Chris; rhill@slocity.org; Meeting  Subject: GoToMeeting Invitation ‐ MBCP & SLO to Discuss Creation of CCE  When: Tuesday, March 13, 2018 11:30 AM‐12:30 PM (UTC‐08:00) Pacific Time (US & Canada).  Where: Phone Number: 1 (571) 317‐3122 / Access Code: 464‐019‐053     MBCP & SLO to Discuss Creation of CCE   Tue, Mar 13, 2018 11:30 AM ‐ 12:30 PM PDT   Please join my meeting from your computer, tablet or smartphone.   https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/464019053   You can also dial in using your phone.   United States: +        Access Code:     First GoToMeeting? Let's do a quick system check: https://link.gotomeeting.com/system‐check   212 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 10:50 AM To:Bren Lehr Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In Perfect, thanks Bren. From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:48 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Chris,    I’m actually sending a GoToMeeting instead. It should come from Meeting@mbcommunitypower.org.     From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:39 AM  To: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Bren, 11:30 works for us. Can you please also include Bob Hill rhill@slocity.org on the invite? Thanks! Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:37 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Can you do 11:30 a.m. on March 13?    213 From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:35 AM  To: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Bren, Unfortunately, we are out of the office on the afternoon of 3/13 at an offsite meeting. Anything else work? Even 30 minutes would be helpful. Thank you very much for your assistance! Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:19 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    I’m struggling to find a date that’s not two weeks out or more. Would you be able to do a call on Tuesday, March 13 at  4pm?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM  To: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager 214 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  madato@mbcommunitypower.org                 Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  215 Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  216 Hicks, Bailey From:Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 10:48 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In Chris,    I’m actually sending a GoToMeeting instead. It should come from Meeting@mbcommunitypower.org.     From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:39 AM  To: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Bren, 11:30 works for us. Can you please also include Bob Hill rhill@slocity.org on the invite? Thanks! Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:37 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Can you do 11:30 a.m. on March 13?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:35 AM  To: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Bren, 217 Unfortunately, we are out of the office on the afternoon of 3/13 at an offsite meeting. Anything else work? Even 30 minutes would be helpful. Thank you very much for your assistance! Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:19 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    I’m struggling to find a date that’s not two weeks out or more. Would you be able to do a call on Tuesday, March 13 at  4pm?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM  To: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org 218 From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  madato@mbcommunitypower.org                 Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. 219 Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  220 Hicks, Bailey From:Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 10:39 AM To:Read, Chris Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In I sure will. I’ll send a request from Tom now.     From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:39 AM  To: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Bren, 11:30 works for us. Can you please also include Bob Hill rhill@slocity.org on the invite? Thanks! Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:37 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Can you do 11:30 a.m. on March 13?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:35 AM  To: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Bren, 221 Unfortunately, we are out of the office on the afternoon of 3/13 at an offsite meeting. Anything else work? Even 30 minutes would be helpful. Thank you very much for your assistance! Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:19 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    I’m struggling to find a date that’s not two weeks out or more. Would you be able to do a call on Tuesday, March 13 at  4pm?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM  To: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org 222 From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  madato@mbcommunitypower.org                 Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. 223 Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  224 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 10:39 AM To:Bren Lehr Cc:Hill, Robert Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In Hi Bren, 11:30 works for us. Can you please also include Bob Hill rhill@slocity.org on the invite? Thanks! Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:37 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Can you do 11:30 a.m. on March 13?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:35 AM  To: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Bren, Unfortunately, we are out of the office on the afternoon of 3/13 at an offsite meeting. Anything else work? Even 30 minutes would be helpful. Thank you very much for your assistance! Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager 225 City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:19 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    I’m struggling to find a date that’s not two weeks out or more. Would you be able to do a call on Tuesday, March 13 at  4pm?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM  To: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  226 <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  madato@mbcommunitypower.org                 Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, 227 Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  228 Hicks, Bailey From:Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 10:37 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In Can you do 11:30 a.m. on March 13?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:35 AM  To: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Bren, Unfortunately, we are out of the office on the afternoon of 3/13 at an offsite meeting. Anything else work? Even 30 minutes would be helpful. Thank you very much for your assistance! Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:19 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    I’m struggling to find a date that’s not two weeks out or more. Would you be able to do a call on Tuesday, March 13 at  4pm?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM  To: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  229 <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  madato@mbcommunitypower.org        230          Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  231 Hicks, Bailey From:Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 10:35 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In I’ll keep looking…stand by…    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:35 AM  To: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Bren, Unfortunately, we are out of the office on the afternoon of 3/13 at an offsite meeting. Anything else work? Even 30 minutes would be helpful. Thank you very much for your assistance! Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:19 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    I’m struggling to find a date that’s not two weeks out or more. Would you be able to do a call on Tuesday, March 13 at  4pm?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM  To: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  232 <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  madato@mbcommunitypower.org        233          Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  234 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 10:35 AM To:Bren Lehr Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In Hi Bren, Unfortunately, we are out of the office on the afternoon of 3/13 at an offsite meeting. Anything else work? Even 30 minutes would be helpful. Thank you very much for your assistance! Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 10:19 AM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    I’m struggling to find a date that’s not two weeks out or more. Would you be able to do a call on Tuesday, March 13 at  4pm?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM  To: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, 235 Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  madato@mbcommunitypower.org                 Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  236 To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  237 Hicks, Bailey From:Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org> Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 10:19 AM To:Read, Chris Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In Hi Chris,    I’m struggling to find a date that’s not two weeks out or more. Would you be able to do a call on Tuesday, March 13 at  4pm?    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM  To: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>; Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    238 She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  madato@mbcommunitypower.org                 Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org 239 T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  240 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM To:Marc Adato Cc:Tom Habashi;Bren Lehr;Mark Bachman;Hill, Robert Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  241 madato@mbcommunitypower.org                 Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org  242 Hicks, Bailey From:Read, Chris Sent:Friday, March 9, 2018 8:43 AM To:Marc Adato Cc:Tom Habashi;Bren Lehr;Mark Bachman;Hill, Robert Subject:RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check-In Great, thank you Marc. We look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org From: Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 5:39 PM  To: Read, Chris <cread@slocity.org>  Cc: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Bren Lehr <blehr@mbcommunitypower.org>; Mark Bachman  <mbachman@mbcommunitypower.org>  Subject: RE: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Chris,    Thank you for reaching out.    Tom has asked Bren to schedule a conference call to include Tom, Mark Bachman and myself.    She will reach out to you with some preferred times for a 30‐60 minute call.    We look forward to circling back, now that we have launched Phase I, to hear what progress you are making in SLO and  how we might assist in your efforts.    Best Regards,  ‐Marc      Marc Adato, Community Outreach & Events Coordinator  m:(831) 234‐4668 o:(831) 641‐7210  243 madato@mbcommunitypower.org                 Local Choice • Clean Energy • Economic Vitality         70 Garden Court, Suite 300         Monterey, CA 93940         mbcommunitypower.org    From: Read, Chris [mailto:cread@slocity.org]   Sent: Thursday, March 8, 2018 3:17 PM  To: Tom Habashi <thabashi@mbcommunitypower.org>; Marc Adato <madato@mbcommunitypower.org>  Cc: Hill, Robert <rhill@slocity.org>  Subject: City of San Luis Obispo / MBCP Check‐In    Hi Tom and Marc, I hope you are well. When we last spoke, I was helping lead the County of San Luis Obispo CCE effort. Since then, I have transitioned to a new role at the City of San Luis Obispo. CCE is a top priority for the City this year. As Marc saw, our Council’s direction in December was to consider creating our own regional CCE, while also learning more about the MBCP option as an alternative approach. Given the length of time since we last spoke, I am hoping to reconnect on a number of issues related to potentially joining MBCP. Let us know if you have some availability in the next several weeks to talk for 30 to 60 minutes, and we will work to accommodate your schedule. Thank you for you time; we look forward to speaking with you. Best, Chris Read Sustainability Manager City Administration 990 Palm Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-3249 E cread@slocity.org T 805.781.7151 slocity.org