Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-14-2020 REOC Agenda PacketCity of San Luis Obispo, Agenda, Planning Commission Agenda REVENUE ENHANCEMENT OVERSIGHT COMMISSION Thursday May 14, 2020 Based on the threat of COVID-19 as reflected in the Proclamations of Emergency issued by both the Governor of the State of California, the San Luis Obispo County Emergency Services Director and the Revenue Enhancement Oversight Committee of the City of San Luis Obispo as well as the Governor’s Executive Order N-29-20 issued on March 17, 2020, relating to the convening of public meetings in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the City of San Luis Obispo will be holding all public meetings via teleconference. There will be no physical location for the Public to view the meeting. Below are instructions on how to view the meeting remotely and how to leave public comment. Additionally, members of the Revenue Enhancement Oversight Committee are allowed to attend the meeting via teleconference and to participate in the meeting to the same extent as if they were present. Using the most rapid means of communication available at this time, members of the public are encouraged to participate in Committee meetings in the following ways: 1. Remote Viewing - Members of the public who wish to watch the meeting can view:  View the Webinar: (recommended for the best viewing quality)  Registration URL: https://attendee.gotowebinar.com/register/710191459809446416  Webinar ID: 307-918-355 2. Public Comment - The Revenue Enhancement Oversight Committee will still be accepting public comment. Public comment can be submitted in the following ways:  Mail or Email Public Comment  Received by 3:00 PM on the day of meeting - Can be submitted via email to advisorybodies@slocity.org or U.S. Mail to City Clerk at 990 Palm St. San Luis Obispo, CA 93401  Emails sent after 3:00 PM and up until public comment is opened on the item – Limited to one page emailed to cityclerk@slocity.org, which will then be read aloud during the public comment period on the item specified.  Verbal Public Comment  Received by 3:00 PM on the day of the meeting - Call (805) 781-7164; state and spell your name, the agenda item number you are calling about and leave your comment. The verbal comments must be limited to 3 minutes. All voicemails will be forwarded to the Council Members and saved as Agenda Correspondence.  During the meeting – Comments can be submitted up until the Public Comment period is opened for the item when joining via the webinar (instructions above). Please type you name and the Item # you would like to speak on in the Questions box. When the Public Comment is opened for the Item you would like to speak on your mic will be unmuted. All comments submitted will be placed into the administrative record of the meeting. Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission Agenda for May 14, 2020 Page 2 Thursday May 14, 2020 5:30 p.m. REGULAR MEETING Teleconference CALL TO ORDER Chair Chris Coates ROLL CALL: Commissioners Jeannette McClure, Vice-Chair Ken Kienow, Michael Multari, and Jim Hamari PUBLIC COMMENT: At this time, people may address the Commission about items not on the agenda. Persons wishing to speak should come forward and state their name and address. Comments are limited to three minutes per person. Items raised at this time are generally referred to staff and, if action by the Commission is necessary, may be scheduled for a future meeting. CONSIDERATION OF MINUTES 1. Draft Minutes of the Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission of April 30, 2020 BUSINESS ITEMS 2. Annual Community Report Review/Annual Citizen Oversight Meeting Recommendation: Review and take public testimony on the FY 2018-19 Local Revenue Measure Annual Community Report and take input from residents and community members on preferences for the use of the revenues generated by the Local Revenue Measure. (Ryan Betz). 3. 2020-21 Supplement Budget Recommendation: Review and recommend to the City Council the proposed use of Local Revenue Measure funds as part of the 2020-21. (Ryan Betz & Matt Horn) COMMENT AND DISCUSSION 4. Staff Updates 5. Commission Communications Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission Agenda for May 14, 2020 Page 3 ADJOURNMENT The next Regular Meeting of the Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission will occur in June with a date to be determined. The City of San Luis Obispo wishes to make all of its public meetings accessible to the public. Upon request, this agenda will be made available in appropriate alternative formats to persons with disabilities. Any person with a disability who requires a modification or accommodation in order to participate in a meeting should direct such request to the City Clerk’s Office at (805) 781-7100 at least 48 hours before the meeting, if possible. Telecommunications Device for the Deaf (805) 781-7107. Meeting audio recordings can be found at the following web address: http://opengov.slocity.org/weblink/1/fol/61028/Row1.aspx DRAFT Minutes – Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission Meeting of April 30, 2020 Page 1 Minutes - DRAFT REVENUE ENHANCEMENT OVERSIGHT COMMISSION Thursday, April 30, 2020 Regular Meeting of the Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission CALL TO ORDER A Regular Meeting of the San Luis Obispo Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission was called to order on Thursday, April 30, 2020 at 5:31 p.m., by Chair Christopher Coates, via teleconference. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners, Jeannette McClure, Michael Multari, Vice Chair Ken Kienow, and Chair Christopher Coates Absent: Three Vacant seats Staff: Greg Hermann Deputy City Manager and Ryan Betz Assistant to the City Manager and City Clerk Teresa Purrington PUBLIC COMMENT ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA None. --End of Public Comment-- APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Consideration of Minutes of the Regular Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission Meeting of December 12, 2019: ACTION: UPON MOTION BY COMMISSIONER MULTARI SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER MCCLURE, CARRIED 4-0-0 (3 POSITIONS VACANT), the Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission approved the Minutes of the Regular Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission Meeting of December 12, 2019, as presented. BUSINESS ITEMS 2. Annual Audit Review Finance Director Brigitte Elke and Accounting Manager Debbie Malicoat provided a PowerPoint presentation and responded to Commissioner inquiries. DRAFT Minutes – Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission Meeting of April 30, 2020 Page 2 Public Comment None --End of Public Comment-- ACTION: UPON MOTION BY COMMITTEE MEMBER MULTARI, SECONDED BY CHAIR COATES, CARRIED 4-0-0 (3 POSITIONS VACANT), to review and accept the audited financial statements contained in the 2018-19 Comprehensive Annual Financial Report for the Local Revenue Measure. 3. Draft 2018-19 Annual Community Report Review Assistant to the City Manager Ryan Betz provided a PowerPoint presentation and responded to Commissioner inquiries. Public Comment None. --End of Public Comment-- ACTION: By consensus, the Commission reviewed and provided feedback on the draft 2018- 19 Annual Community Report and Report in Brief. The Commission requested that a letter be added regarding potential impacts of COVID-19. 4. SLO Forward Update Deputy City Manager Greg Hermann provided a PowerPoint presentation and responded to Commissioner inquiries. COMMENT AND DISCUSSION 5. Staff Updates a. City COVID-19 Response Deputy City Manager Greg Hermann provided a PowerPoint presentation and responded to Commissioner inquiries. 6. Commission Communications None ADJOURNMENT The meeting was adjourned at 7:40 p.m. The next Regular Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission meeting is scheduled for Thursday, May 14, 2020 at 5:30 p.m., via teleconference. DRAFT Minutes – Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission Meeting of April 30, 2020 Page 3 APPROVED BY THE REVENUE ENHANCEMENT OVERSIGHT COMMISSION: XX/XX/2020     Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission March 10, 2016 Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission Agenda Report Meeting Date: 5/14/20 Item Number: 2 FROM: Greg Hermann, Deputy City Manager Prepared By: Ryan Betz, Assistant to the City Manager SUBJECT: FY 2018-19 LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE YEAR ANNUAL COMMUNITY REPORT/ANNUAL CITIZEN OVERSIGHT MEETING RECOMMENDATION 1. Review and take public testimony on the FY 2018-19 Local Revenue Measure Annual Community Report. 2. Take input from residents and community members on preferences for the use of the revenues generated by the Local Revenue Measure. DISCUSSION Background Chapter 3.15 of the Municipal Code (the Essential Services Transactions [Sales] and Use Tax) includes specific citizen oversight and fiscal accountability provisions for the Local Revenue Measure. These provisions require an Annual Community Report: Annual Community Report. A written report shall be reviewed at a public hearing by the Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission, and a summary will be provided annually to every household in the community detailing how much revenue is being generated by the measure and how funds are being spent (MC 3.15.040.E). Annual Citizen Oversight Meeting. The REOC shall hold an annual essential services measure community forum for the purpose of taking input from residents and community members on preferences for the use of the revenues generated by the essential services tax. Chapter 3.15 of the Municipal Code (the Essential Services Transactions [Sales] and Use Tax) includes specific citizen oversight and fiscal accountability provisions for the Local Revenue Measure. These provisions require both an Annual Community Report and an Annual Citizen Oversight Meeting. Annual Community Report The FY 2018-19 Annual Community Report and Annual Report in Brief highlights the revenue and uses of the Local Revenue Measure for fiscal year covering the time from July 2018 to June 2019 – several months before the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic began and the social and economic impacts on the community. The impacts of this emergency will be reflected in the current fiscal year (July 2019 – June 2020) and for years to come. Due to the economic impacts, City revenues, including the Local Revenue Measure, are projected to be significantly lower in FY 2018-19 Local Revenue Measure Annual Community Report Page 2      the current year (FY 2019-20) and for future years. Both of these reports were developed based on feedback from the Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission (REOC) as well as meetings with an ad-hoc subcommittee that was tasked with providing detailed recommendations. The Annual Community Report in Brief (Attachment 1) was included in the City’s utility bills in May along with a letter to community members explaining that the report was prepared prior to the impacts of COVID-19 on the community. The full Annual Community Report (Attachment 2) is available at www.slocity.org/budget and is featured on the homepage of the City’s website. The Annual Community Report highlights information from the Local Revenue Measure Summary Schedule which lists audited expenditures for operating and capital project costs as well as project completion updates. Local Revenue Measure Uses Expenditures are broken into the following categories: 1) Open Space Preservation, 2) Bicycle and Pedestrain Improvements, 3) Traffic Congestion Relief/Safety Improvements, 4) Public Safety, 5) Neighborhood Street Paving, 6) Code Enforcement, 7) Flood Protection, 8) Parks and Recreation/Senior Programs and Facilities, and 9) Other Vital Services and Capital Projects. Actual operating expenditures for FY 2018-19 were approximately $2.1M (26%), and capital expenditures approximately $6M (74%), totaling approximately $8.1M. FY 2018-19 Local Revenue Measure Annual Community Report Page 3      1. Operating Uses ($2.1M) 80 percent of budgeted Local Revenue Measure operating program funds were expended in FY 2018-19. The 20 percent balance remaining was due to salary variances and hiring gaps. The largest use of Local Revenue Measure funding for operating costs was for preservation of essential services, specifically for public safety. Examples of these costs were salaries for four Downtown Patrol Officers and one Sergeant. Other operating expenditures included positions in creek and flood protection, code enforcement and open space protection. 2. Capital Uses ($6M) 74 percent of available Local Revenue Measure capital project funds were expended in FY 2018- 19. Available funds are a combination of what was budgeted in FY 2018-19 and what was carried over from past fiscal years. This is typical of capital improvement projects that usually span over multiple years. Project phases don’t always align with fiscal years, and project schedules are subject to variables that cause delays. Budgeted funds for capital projects carry over year to year until the project is completed. The total amount of local revenue measure carryover for capital projects currently underway in FY 2020-21 is approximately $6M. FY 2018-19 Local Revenue Measure Annual Community Report Page 4      Specific details on which capital projects are carrying a balance are included in Attachment 2. Any funding remaining once projects are completed will be transferred into a Local Revenue Measure Completed Projects account. This funding could be used for other approved Local Revenue Measure projects that end up costing more than what was budgeted (subject to City Manager approval), or be reprogrammed to other capital projects that meet Local Revenue Measure criteria subject to REOC and City Council approval during the next financial plan process. The largest capital expenditures funded by the local revenue measure in FY 2018-19 were for Neighborhood Street Paving, specifically for the Laurel Lane Complete Streets project and the surrounding neighborhoods. Other projects included the acquisition of the Miossi Open Space, storm drain system replacements, park major maintenance/repairs and bicycle/pedestrian improvements. Local Revenue Measure Revenues Audited revenues from the local half-percent sales tax totaled $8.4M in FY 2018-19, representing a 9% increase from the forecasted amount of $7.7M. Due to the economic impacts of the COVID- 19, the revised forecast shows a decrease in revenues of 7% in FY 2019-20. The revenues are projected to not return to the FY 2018-19 amount until FY 2022-23. The Local Revenue Measure has generated over $79.4M to protect and maintain essential services and facilities since its original adoption in 2006. FY 2018-19 Local Revenue Measure Annual Community Report Page 5      FY 2018-19 Budgeted Revenues $7,673,000 FY 2018-19 Year End Revenues (Actuals) $8,428,163 Difference (+/-) $755,163 The revised forecast will be presented to the REOC on May 14th, 2020 and the City Council on June 2, 2020 as part of the FY 2020-21 Supplemental Budget. Staff is recommending no changes to the FY 2020-21 operating budget and several changes to the capital budget based upon the impacts of COVID-19 on the Local Revenue Measure. CONCLUSION Though the goal for uses of the the Local Revenue Measure is a split of 70% for capital expenditures and 30% for operating, audited uses were 74% in capital expenditures and 26% in operating. This was primarily due to the completion of several large capital projects and savings in operating costs. Remaining balances in capital expenditures have been rolled forward to the current budget and will remain assigned to the projects until they are complete. A list of all of the projects budgeted in FY 2018-19 is included in Attachement 2. ATTACHMENTS 1. FY 2018-19 Annual Community Report in Brief 2. FY 2018-19 Local Revenue Measure Annual Community Report WHAT IS THE LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE? ANNUAL COMMUNITY REPORT IN BRIEF Fiscal Year 2018–19 (JULY 2018 - JUNE 2019) 11%PUBLIC SAFETY $928,000 39%NEIGHBORHOOD STREET PAVING (INCLUDES IMPROVEMENTS TO BIKE LANES) $3.2 million 9%PARKS AND RECREATION/ SENIOR PROGRAMS AND FACILITIES $720,000 10%OPEN SPACE PRESERVATION $787,000 15%FLOOD PROTECTION $1.2 million 8%BICYCLE AND PEDESTRIAN IMPROVEMENTS $655,000 2%TRAFFIC CONGESTION RELIEF/SAFETY IMPROVEMENTS $176,000 3%CODE ENFORCEMENT $269,000 3%OTHER VITAL SERVICES AND CAPITAL PROJECTS $202,000 2018–19 Local Revenue Measure funds were used on the following Council-adopted priorities: HOW IS YOUR 1/2 PERCENT SALES TAX SPENT? Open Space The Local Revenue Measure was used to acquire an additional 266 acres of open space east of Cal Poly, on the Miossi Brothers La Cuesta Ranch property, bringing the City’s total open space to over 4,000 acres. The funding was used to leverage additional state grant funding to purchase the land. Public Safety The Local Revenue Measure funded patrol officers and a Sergeant, including the Downtown Metro Bicycle Officers. Downtown patrol has been instrumental in being a visual deterrent and enforcement option in the downtown core to keep residents, businesses and visitors safe. City/County Library Roof Replacement The City-County Public Library required a roof replacement and drainage improvements as part of the second phase of the remodel, major maintenance and ADA compliance project. Flood Protection The Ellen Way storm drain improvement project included the replacement of outdated storm drain pipelines to improve stormwater management and to reduce the potential for flooding. SPENDING HIGHLIGHTS The Local Revenue Measure – also known as Measure G – is a one-half percent local sales tax approved by City voters in November 2006. It protects and maintains essential services and facilities, such as open space preservation, bike lanes and sidewalks, public safety, neighborhood street paving and code enforcement, flood protection, senior programs, and other vital services and capital improvement projects. The Local Revenue Measure is subject to voter extension by March 31, 2023. These community spending priorities help guide the Citizens’ Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission (REOC) when making recommendations to the Council about Local Revenue Measure uses. The Council uses the REOC’s input, and additional public feedback, to prioritize use of the Local Revenue Measure funding as part of the City’s two-year financial planning process. Local one-half-percent sales tax revenue totaled $8.4 million in 2018–19, which added approximately 12 percent to the general fund. The Local Revenue Measure has generated more than $79.4 million since its original adoption in November 2006. REVENUES CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO // For a complete list of 2018–19 Local Revenue Measure uses, view the full report at slocity.org/localrevenue $8.4M Laurel Lane Complete Streets Project More than 180 people cross Laurel Lane every day: school children and parents going to the elementary school and Sinsheimer park, seniors accessing senior living and transit services, and neighbors accessing the Sinsheimer Park Baseball Stadium and the SLO Swim Center. The Laurel Lane Complete Streets and Roadway Maintenance Sealing project included pedestrian, bicyclist and vehicle safety improvements. Roadway maintenance helps decrease vehicle operations costs by fixing potholes and other street repairs. The 2015 Traffic Safety Report identified the intersection of Laurel Lane and Southwood Drive as the highest-ranking intersection for pedestrian collisions on City maintained streets. For every $1 of revenue generated by the Local Revenue Measure, approximately 70¢ is paid by visitors and 30¢ is paid by City residents. (Based on a retail sales analysis completed in Feb. 2020. These figures and overall revenue will change significantly in the current and future fiscal years due to impacts from the COVID-19 emergency on our community) PROJECT HIGHLIGHT Operating Uses ($2.1M) // 26% – Funds positions that provide services Examples of these costs include funding for positions such as police officers and flood control staff. Capital Uses ($6M) // 74% – Funds construction and investment in equipment The largest capital expenditures funded by the Local Revenue Measure in 2018–19 were neighborhood street paving projects (including bike lane improvements), flood protection and open space preservation. Sidewalk Replacement Sidewalk replacements improve accessibility for pedestrians by replacing defective sidewalks with upgrades including curb ramps, tree grates and storm water drainage. Sidewalks on Broad, High, Walker, Marsh and Fredricks Streets were replaced and improved. Pedestrian Crossing With the completion of the project, pedestrian crossings at the intersection increased by 11%, vehicle speeds decreased by 7%, and fatal collision risk decreased by 28%. LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE ANNUAL COMMUNITY REPORT Fiscal Year 2018–19 CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO HOW DID WE SPEND REVENUES? PAGE 5 Read about how Local Revenue Measure funds were spent in 2018–19. LAUREL LANE COMPLETE STREETS PAGE 7 Learn more about our project that included pedestrian, bicyclist and vehicle safety improvements. 1 PROJECT SPOTLIGHT Miossi Open Space The Local Revenue Measure was used to acquire an additional 266 acres of open space east of Cal Poly, on the Miossi Brothers La Cuesta Ranch property, bringing the City’s total open space to over 4,000 acres. The funding was used to leverage additional state grant funding to purchase the land. 2 The Local Revenue Measure – also known as Measure G – is a one-half percent local sales tax approved by City voters in November 2006. It protects and maintains essential services and facilities, such as open space preservation, bike lanes and sidewalks, public safety, neighborhood street paving and code enforcement, flood protection, senior programs, and other vital services and capital improvement projects. The Local Revenue Measure is subject to voter extension in 2023. The Local Revenue Measure is a general-purpose measure and, as such, the proceeds are not restricted to specific purposes. This provides the Council with flexibility to respond to new circumstances and challenges. The voter-approved ballot language provides guidance to use local sales tax revenue to protect and maintain essential services and facilities and identifies examples of services and projects that achieve this objective. These community spending priorities help guide the Citizen’s Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission (REOC) when making recommendations to the Council about Local Revenue Measure uses. The Council uses the REOC’s input, and additional public feedback, to prioritize the use of Local Revenue Measure funding as part of the City’s two-year financial planning process. WHAT IS THE LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE? Open Space Rangers: The Local Revenue Measure funded two Ranger positions which help maintain over 4,000 acres of open space, 55 miles of trails and lead open space hikes with community members. 3 To protect and maintain essential services and facilities – such as open space preservation; bike lanes and sidewalks; public safety; neighborhood street paving and code enforcement; flood protection; senior programs; and other vital services and capital improvement projects – shall the City’s Municipal Code be amended to extend the current one-half percent local sales tax for eight years, with independent annual audits, public goal-setting and budgeting, and a Citizens’ Oversight Commission? LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE BALLOT LANGUAGE (MEASURE G) FISCAL YEAR The railroad district sidewalk, made up of wooden planks, was deteriorated and created a tripping hazard. The old sidewalk was replaced with concrete pavers. 4 The local one-half percent sales tax revenue totaled $8.4 million in 2018-19, which added approximately 12 percent to the general fund. The Local Revenue Measure has generated more than $79.4 million since its original adoption in November 2006. Revenues for 2019-20 and beyond are projected to be significantly lower due to impacts from the COVID-19 emergency. REVENUES The streets maintenance portable message board is used for traffic control to deter vehicles away from roadway work zones. A street maintenance worker position is also funded through the Local Revenue Measure. 0 $2M $4M $6M $8M $10M 2011–12 2012–13 2013–14 FISCAL YEAR 2014–15 2015–16 2016–17 2017–18 2018–19 $6,237,500 $6,493,800 $6,774,365 $7,136,300 $7,178,200 $7,376,500 $7,501,500 $8,428,163 0 $2M $4M $6M $8M $10M 2011–12 2012–13 2013–14 FISCAL YEAR 2014–15 2015–16 2016–17 2017–18 2018–19 $6,237,500 $6,493,800 $6,774,365 $7,136,300 $7,178,200 $7,376,500 $7,501,500 $8,428,163 5USES 2018–19 2018–19 Local Revenue Measure funds were used on the following Council-adopted priorities: 9% PARKS AND RECREATION/ SENIOR PROGRAMS AND FACILITIES $720,000 10% OPEN SPACE PRESERVATION $787,000 15% FLOOD PROTECTION $1.2 million 8% BICYCLE AND PEDESTRIAN IMPROVEMENTS $655,000 2% TRAFFIC CONGESTION RELIEF/SAFETY IMPROVEMENTS $176,000 3% CODE ENFORCEMENT $269,000 3% OTHER VITAL SERVICES AND CAPITAL PROJECTS $202,000 39% NEIGHBORHOOD STREET PAVING (INCLUDES IMPROVEMENTS TO BIKE LANES) $3.2 million 11% PUBLIC SAFETY $928,000 Design work to replace the 100-year old Marsh Street Bridge, located between Osos Street and Santa Rosa Street, has been completed. Construction is set to begin in May 2020 and is expected to be completed in December 2020. The bridge has been deemed structurally deficient and is an important transit corridor for residents, businesses and visitors. 6USES 2018–19 The Local Revenue Measure funded patrol officers and a Sergeant, including the Downtown Metro Bicycle Officers. Downtown patrol has been instrumental in being a visual deterrent and enforcement option in the downtown core to keep residents, businesses and visitors safe. For every $1 of revenue generated by the Local Revenue Measure, approximately 70¢ is paid by visitors and 30¢ is paid by City residents (Based on a retail sales analysis completed in Feb. 2020. These figures and overall revenue will change significantly in the current and future fiscal years due to impacts from the COVID-19 emergency on our community) Operating Uses ($2.1M) // 26% Capital Uses ($6M) // 74% To fund positions that provide services Examples of these costs include funding for positions such as police officers and flood control staff. To fund construction and investment in equipment The largest capital expenditures funded by the Local Revenue Measure in 2018-19 were neighborhood street paving projects (including bike lane improvements), flood protection and open space preservation. Local Revenue Measure uses fall into two categories: operating expenses and capital expenses. 7PROJECT SPOTLIGHT More than 180 people cross Laurel Lane every day: school children and parents going to the elementary school and regional park, seniors accessing senior living and transit services, and neighbors accessing the Sinsheimer Park Baseball Stadium and the SLO Swim Center. The Laurel Lane Complete Streets and Roadway Maintenance Sealing project included pedestrian, bicyclist and vehicle safety improvements. Roadway maintenance helps decrease vehicle operations costs by fixing potholes and other street repairs. The 2015 Traffic Safety Report identified the intersection of Laurel Lane and Southwood Drive as the highest-ranking intersection for pedestrian collisions on City maintained streets. Laurel Lane Complete Streets Project With the completion of the project, pedestrian crossings at the intersection increased by 11%, vehicle speeds decreased by 7%, and fatal collision risk decreased by 28%. 8 The Local Revenue Measure is a critical revenue source for community investment and economic recovery due to the impacts of COVID-19. The City is committed to completing projects that maintain infrastructure and support the delivery of essential services to residents and businesses. PLANNED LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE USES SOUTH BROAD STREET ROAD REHABILITATION COMPLETED AUGUST 2019 MEADOW PARK PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE REPLACEMENT COMPLETED APRIL 2020 MARSH STREET BRIDGE REPLACEMENT DECEMBER 2020 FIRE STATION #1 MAINTENANCE SPRING 2020 ISLAY HILL PARK PLAYGROUND REPLACEMENT AUGUST 2020 TWO NEW STREET LIGHTS IN NEIGHBORHOODS NEAR CAL POLY COMPLETED OCTOBER & NOVEMBER 2019 Maintaining parks and public spaces provides community members an opportunity to enjoy the outdoors, spend time with their families, and stay active. 9 OPERATING PROGRAMS CAPITAL PROJECTS PROJECT TITLE 2018–19 (BUDGET) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) 2018–19 (BUDGET & CARRYOVER*) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) Open Space Protection 551,064 509,886 Open Space Maintenance 131,341 91,392 Laguna Lake Dredging 38,102 33,640 Open Space Wildfire Fuel Reduction 5,000 4,999 Ranger Services (Ranger Staffing: FTE= 2)152,068 147,068 Subtotal 157,068 152,067 720,507 634,918 Sidewalk Replacement 135,943 44,550 Bob Jones Octagon Barn Connection 227,285 184,754 Bob Jones Trail: Prefumo Creek to Oceanaire 216,000 - Railroad District Boardwalk Replacement 5,000 1,165 Railroad Safety Trail: Pepper Street to the Train Station 30,000 27,852 Railroad Safety Trail: Bike Bridge at Phillips Lane 230,840 41,826 Bicycle Transportation Plan Implementation 91,826 90,763 Sidewalk Access Improvements 52,604 - Bicycle Facility Improvements 75,000 592 Safe Routes to School 104,263 58,809 Pedestrian and Bicycle Pathway Maintenance 151,316 14,006 Downtown Renewal 6,000 4,200 Transportation Planning and Engineering (Engineer, Active Transportation Manager: FTE=1.6) 201,675 186,543 Subtotal 201,675 186,543 1,326,076 468,517 OPEN SPACE PRESERVATION BICYCLE AND PEDESTRIAN IMPROVEMENTS CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO // LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE SUMMARY // FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2019 10CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO // LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE SUMMARY // FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2019 OPERATING PROGRAMS CAPITAL PROJECTS Traffic Signs and Striping Maintenance 47,930 21,962 Traffic Safety Report Implementation 111,564 10,880 Transportation Safety and Operations 9,196 530 Neighborhood Traffic Improvements 148,819 23,615 Parking Structure Assessment 8,333 8,333 Signal and Light Maintenance (Technician: FTE=1)112,138 110,398 Subtotal 112,138 110,398 325,842 65,320 TRAFFIC CONGESTION RELIEF / SAFETY IMPROVEMENTS OPERATING PROGRAMS CAPITAL PROJECTS PROJECT TITLE 2018–19 (BUDGET) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) 2018–19 (BUDGET & CARRYOVER) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) Planning and design work was completed for the new Pedestrian Hybrid Beacon (PHB) crossing at the intersection of Foothill Boulevard and Ferrini Road in 2018–19 and installed in December, 2019. This area was identified as the highest safe routes to school improvement priority for Pacheco and Bishop’s Peak Elementary Schools. The PHB, is a traffic control device used to stop road traffic and allow pedestrians and bicyclists to cross safely. 11CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO // LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE SUMMARY // FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2019 Police Dispatch Technology Maintenance 40,826 2,000 Police Station Replacement Study 145,685 27,755 Police Patrol Vehicle Replacements (4) 265,558 366 Fire Vehicle Replacement (Fire Training Pickup, Ambulance Van) 14,867 14,366 Police Station Building Maintenance and Improvements 13,750 8,750 Fire Stations Building Maintenance 154,250 77,781 Police Handheld and Vehicle Radio Replacement 280,000 - South Hills Radio Upgrade 238,455 75,342 Emergency Dispatch Center Maintenance 256,033 5,409 New Street Lights 110,000 48,009 Laurel Lane Streetlight 100,000 91,007 Fire Station 4 Backup Generator 100,877 7,106 PulsePoint CPR Software 8,000 8,000 Patrol Services (Officers, Sergeant: FTE = 4) 928,077 562,311 Subtotal 936,077 570,311 1,720,300 357,892 OPERATING PROGRAMS CAPITAL PROJECTS PROJECT TITLE 2018–19 (BUDGET) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) 2018–19 (BUDGET & CARRYOVER) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) PUBLIC SAFETY The Islay Hills Park Playground will be replaced in August 2020 and includes Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) upgrades from the parking lot to the playground. The new playground will include equipment for all ages, a unique inter-connective climbing course, and a shade feature. The playground is more than 20 years old and replacing the equipment will keep the City in compliance with State regulations. Street Reconstruction and Resurfacing (Laurel Lane and Southwood Street area) 2,466,861 2,464,872 Concrete Streets Repair (Dana, Toro & Palm, Palm & Johnson) 436,661 435,360 Marsh Street Bridge Replacement 725,089 - Streets Maintenance Loader with Skip & Drag Attachment 330,287 130,022 Corporation Yard Maintenance 14,750 13,049 Streets and Sidewalk Maintenance (Maintenance Worker, Project Engineer: FTE = 2) 217,194 191,053 Subtotal 217,194 191,053 3,973,647 3,016,783 12CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO // LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE SUMMARY // FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2019 OPERATING PROGRAMS CAPITAL PROJECTS PROJECT TITLE 2018–19 (BUDGET) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) 2018–19 (BUDGET & CARRYOVER) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) NEIGHBORHOOD STREET PAVING INCLUDES IMPROVEMENTS TO BIKE LANES CODE ENFORCEMENT Building and Safety (Code Enforcement Officer, Neighborhood Services Specialists: FTE = 3) 269,025 269,025 Subtotal 269,025 269,025 - - The City-County Public Library required a roof replacement and drainage improvements as part of the second phase of the remodel, major maintenance and ADA compliance project. 13 Storm Drain System Replacement 431,211 392,839 Ellen Way Storm Drain Improvements 241,500 202,408 Broad and Leff Culvert Repair 10,000 2,387 Creek and Flood Protection (Collection System Personnel: FTE = 6) 652,195 597,222 Subtotal 652,195 597,222 682,711 597,635 CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO // LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE SUMMARY // FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2019 OPERATING PROGRAMS CAPITAL PROJECTS PROJECT TITLE 2018–19 (BUDGET) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) 2018–19 (BUDGET & CARRYOVER) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) FLOOD PROTECTION PARKS AND RECREATION / SENIOR PROGRAMS AND FACILITIES Parks Major Maintenance & Repairs 565,416 134,500 Ludwick Center Gym Lights 15,500 15,610 Swim Center Building Maintenance and Equipment Replacement 79,981 11,006 Jack House Building Maintenance 74,000 2,250 Islay Hill Park Playground Equipment Replacement 80,000 46,139 Sinsheimer Irrigation & Drainage 120,000 - Sinsheimer Stadium Backstop 165,886 165,886 City/County Library Major Maintenance 177,076 145,839 Parks and Recreation Building Maintenance 47,279 15,635 Swim Center Co-generation Plant 85,000 - Parks Maintenance Equipment Replacement 30,000 14,060 Parks Maintenance Walk Behind Mower & Aerator 41,839 41,839 Parks Maintenance Utility Carts With Dump Beds (2) 56,000 55,885 Mission Plaza Restroom Replacements and Enhancements 105,000 30,955 Parks and Landscape Maintenance (Maintenance Worker: FTE = 1) 84,563 40,177 Subtotal 84,563 40,177 1,642,978 679,603 14 Facilities Annual Asset Maintenance Account 58,168 City Hall Chiller Replacement 224,924 201,817 Multisite Energy Management 32,600 Undesignated Capital 114,927 Subtotal - - 430,619 201,817 TOTAL LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE USES 2,629,935 2,116,797 10,822,681 6,049,004 CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO // LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE SUMMARY // FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2019 OPERATING PROGRAMS CAPITAL PROJECTS PROJECT TITLE 2018–19 (BUDGET) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) 2018–19 (BUDGET & CARRYOVER) 2018–19 (ACTUAL) OTHER VITAL SERVICES AND CAPITAL PROJECTS * Budget & Carryover includes unspent funds for planned, but not yet completed projects. Projects may be changed or modified as a part of the City’s response to the COVID-19 emergency. The Ellen Way storm drain improvement project included the replacement of outdated storm drain pipelines to improve stormwater management and to reduce the potential for flooding. 15 Open Space Preservation, Bicycle and Pedestrian Improvements, Traffic Congestion Relief/Safety Improvements, Public Safety, Neighborhood Street Paving, Code Enforcement, Flood Protection, Parks and Recreation/Senior Programs and Facilities, other Vital Services and Capital Projects. PRIORITIES SET BY THE CITY COUNCIL FOR FY 2018–19 INCLUDE: CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO For more information, please visit: www.slocity.org/budget Design: AMF Media Group Photography: Kelly Donohue Photography Owen Main Photography City of San Luis Obispo Sidewalk replacements improve accessibility for pedestrians by replacing defective sidewalks with upgrades including curb ramps, tree grates and storm water drainage. Sidewalks on Broad, High, Walker, Marsh and Fredricks Streets were replaced and improved. Winston Newland Commissioner Chris Coates Chair CITIZENS’ REVENUE ENHANCEMENT OVERSIGHT COMMISSION Volunteer Residents Serve on the Commission The Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission (REOC) reviews, reports, and makes recommendations directly to the City Council regarding the revenue and expenditures of the City’s general purpose, half-percent sales tax. The REOC consists of five members, who must be residents and registered voters of the City. Michael Multari Commissioner Ken Kienow Vice Chair Jeannette McClure Commissioner     Meeting Date: 5/14/20 Item Number: 3 Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission Agenda Report DATE: May 14, 2020 FROM: Greg Hermann, Deputy City Manager Prepared By: Ryan Betz, Assistant to the City Manager Matt Horn, Acting Public Works Director Brian Nelson, Supervising Civil Engineer SUBJECT: PROPOSED FY 2020-21 LOCAL REVENUE MEASURE EXPENDITURES RECOMMENDATION 1. Review and recommend to the City Council the use of Local Revenue Measure funds for the operating and capital expenditures as part of the 2020-21 Supplemental Budget. DISCUSSION Background The Supplemental Budget is the second-year budget of a two-year Financial Plan. Before the beginning of the second year of the two-year cycle, the City Council reviews the progress during the first year, makes adjustments as necessary, and approves appropriations for the second fiscal year. Though the actual revenue received from Local Revenue Measure in FY 2018-19 was above the original budget, the impacts of the COVID-19 emergency on the local economy have been significant. A revised forecast of the revenue from the Local Revenue Measure shows a significant reduction in FY 2019-20, FY 2020-21 and for the foreseeable future. COVID-19 Budget Impacts Prior to March 2020, revenue from the Local Revenue Measure was forecasted to reach $7.8M in FY 2019-20. Due to the impacts of the COVID-19 emergency, the revised revenue projections are $7.3M, a decrease of 7%. The revised revenue projections for FY 2020-21 show a similar trend, with a decrease from the original budget of $8M to $7.2M, a decrease of 9%. Due to the revised projections in revenue from the Local Revenue Measure, staff evaluated the projects currently funded in FY 2019-20 and the projects that were previously identified from FY 2020-21 as part of the 2019-21 Financial Plan. Part of that evaluation included how the capital projects supported delivering essential services to the community as well as identifying a list of projects that could be deferred in order to align with the revised revenue projections. These projects are identified in more detail in the following sections of this report. Staff is not proposing any changes to the operation uses as previously adopted in the 2019-21 Financial Plan. Proposed FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Supplemental Budget Page 2    Role of the Commission The role of the Revenue Enhancement Oversight Commission (REOC) in this process is detailed in section 2.14.040 (E) of the City of San Luis Obispo Municipal Code which states: “E. Budget Recommendations. The REOC shall meet for the purpose of making recommendations to the city council regarding the uses of revenue generated by the essential services measure. The REOC shall take into consideration the input provided by residents and community members during the annual citizen oversight meeting, the purpose of the essential services measure, the major city goals established by the city council, and the amount of revenue available from past fiscal years, and projected to be available during the next fiscal year, in making its budget recommendations to the council.” Construction Cost Escalation Currently, the construction industry is facing unprecedented uncertainty in costs, labor supply, and conditions. Multiple City projects have come in well above engineers’ estimates and have had to be rebid and/or returned to the City Council for further funding allocations. The costs of materials are escalating far more rapidly than indexes can predict and the construction industry is facing a labor shortage. Recently, several capital projects received no bids, which is an unusual occurrence. Global uncertainty in the financial markets and the world in general, due to stock volatility and the COVID-19 pandemic, have created further turmoil in this industry. At the present time, it is uncertain whether the impacts from COVID-19 will increase competition and result in downward pressure on construction costs; however, staff assumes this potential to be low as overall construction has so far not slowed due to the pandemic. As such, costs escalations are also a consideration of capital project prioritization. Capital Project Prioritization Staff identified three overarching goals for continuing projects as identified below, including a prioritization flowchart and categories that assess a Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) project’s ability to strongly deliver improvements to critical health and safety infrastructure, maintenance of essential infrastructure, and support of economic recovery through local construction job opportunities. Staff also evaluated each project’s ability to achieve the 2019-21 Major City Goals, including Housing, Sustainable Transportation, Climate Action, and Downtown Vitality.   Proposed FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Supplemental Budget Page 3    A critical aspect of each of these categories is a commitment to fiscal responsibility, especially with consideration of the current economic uncertainty. The following table provides a concise definition for each category. Prioritization Categories In review of the CIP projects, each project was assessed on its ability to achieve the overarching goals as well as the applicable prioritization categories identified in the prior section. Projects critical for public Criteria Description Critical for Public Health & Safety Critical Infrastructure includes any systems and assets so vital to the City that the incapacity or destruction of these assets would have a debilitating impact on security, fiscal health,public health or safety. Example may include essential roadway connections, bridges, water, wastewater, treatment processes, etc. Essential Maintenance Renovates, repairs, or extends useful life of existing assets where deferal could result in significant cost increases to City. For the purposes of this exercise, this includes projects required by regulatory mandate, or where deferal could result in significant loss in grant funds or other outside funding committments Supports Economic Recovery Projects that would directly contribute to economic recovery. Includes infrastructure projects that would be strong candidates for future ecomonic stimulus, particularly projects likely to generate local employment. Ideally, project could be shovel-ready within 1-2 years. Opportunity for Positive Transformation Projects that provide a positive transformational/disruptive opportunity to align City investments, resources and practices to better support the community's long-term sustainability, health, economic and cultural vitality. Housing Directly supports Housing Major City Goal, with focus on projects that facilitate production of housing supply-- particularly affordable housing. Sustainable Transportation Directly supports Sustainable Transportation Major City Goal, with focus on potential to make progress towards traffic safety (Vision Zero) and Mode Shift objectives, and improve access to lower-cost transportation options. Climate Action Directly supports Climate Action Major City Goal, with focus on potential to support C.A.P. adoption and transition to carbon neutrality. Downtown Vitality Directly supports Downtown Vitality Major City Goal, with focus on potential benefits to economic health, cultural vibrancy, safety and accessibility. Additional consideration for projects with potential City-wide economic and cultural vitality. Definitions for FY2020-21 CIP Project Prioritization FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY: Support for the City's Fiscal Responsibility Major City Goal is an overarching objective embraced with evaluation of each of the other critiria. This includes a continued focus on achieving efficiencies, new ways of doing business, and strategic economic investments for short-term and long-term community vitality Supports Work on the Following: Proposed FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Supplemental Budget Page 4    health and safety, essential maintenance, and work that supports economic recovery are of the highest need to the City and have the ability to reduce future maintenance and replacement costs, or create local economic vibrancy through job preservation and/or creation. Each CIP project was assigned one of the following categories:  Proceed: Construct in FY 2020-21  Proceed: Continue Planning/Design Only  Hold: Shovel Ready for Future Funding/Stimulus – Do Not Defund  Defer: No Further Action this Fiscal Year – Defund  Completed: No Further Action this Fiscal Year – Defund. Projects within the first three categories would not be defunded and are recommended to continue. Projects specific to the “Hold” category present funding flexibility to the City. Should future revenues continue to decline, these projects could be defunded. These projects would be in a “Shovel Ready” status and could proceed if outside funding sources are secured, such as State or Federal stimulus grants. “Hold” projects also could proceed with City funding if future budget forecasts permit. Projects within the Defer category were deemed non-essential and could be defunded to meet budgetary reduction targets. Projects that are completed require no further action, and available remaining balances can be defunded. Budget funds remaining within “Defer” and “Completed” projects are recommended to be returned to the Local Revenue Measure Fund Balance, unless transferred to a new project or projects needing supplemental funding. Completed Local Revenue Measure Funded Capital Project Highlights The following is a list of Local Revenue Measure funded capital projects that have been completed within the first half of the 2019-20 Fiscal Year. Completed 2019-21 Capital Projects Project Status Approx. Construction Budget South Broad Street Pavement Improvements Completed in October $2,270,500 Downtown Renewal – 858 Higuera Sidewalk Completed in May $255,000 Meadow Park Pedestrian Bridge Replacement Completed in April $200,000 Pickleball Courts Completed in September $167,000 Emergency Dispatch Center Maintenance Completed in October $151,000 Swim Center Therapy Pool Maintenance Completed in September $96,000 Fire Station 4 Emergency Backup Generator Completed in September $94,000 City Hall Painting Completed in September $40,000 Fire Station 3 Painting Completed in August $10,000 Total $3,103,500 Proposed FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Supplemental Budget Page 5    Scheduled to be Completed Local Revenue Measure Funded Capital Projects The City has numerous projects forthcoming in the fourth quarter of FY2020 and first quarter of 2021. The largest of the projects is the Marsh Street Bridge Replacement Project, which will replace the structurally obsolete bridge between Santa Rosa and Osos Streets. Work will begin in May and continue for a minimum 9-month construction window in which traffic will be diverted through the downtown area to bypass the replacement work. Other notable projects include South Hills Radio Site Upgrades, which will replace deficient City emergency communication equipment with more advanced and reliable equipment, and Islay Hill Park Playground Equipment Replacements, which will provide all new play equipment and ADA improvements to Islay Hill Park. Project Status Remaining Budget South Hills Radio Site Upgrades Construction begins May $464,094 Marsh Street Bridge Replacement Construction begins May $647,831 Islay Hill Park Playground Equipment Replacement Construction begins May $550,000 City Facilities HVAC Replacements Construction begins May $145,000 Bridge Maintenance Currently in the award phase $85,000 City Hall Fire Department Connection Currently in the award phase $58,000 Fire Station 1 HVAC Replacements Currently out to bid $140,000 Neighborhood Street Paving Currently out to bid $1,262,198 Emerson Park Parking Lot Maintenance Currently out to bid $20,000 Swim Center Bath House Roof Repair Currently in the final design phase $34,700 Total $3,406,823 Proposed Local Revenue Measure Funded Capital Projects for Deferral Project Remaining Budget Parks Maintenance $56,437 Parks Play Surfacing $30,000 Parks Water Stations and Supply Lines $40,000 Sinsheimer Irrigation & Drainage $570,000 Laguna Lake Dredging and Sediment Management $488,897 Bob Jones Calle Joaquin to Oceanaire $216,000 Open Space Acquisition $206,812 Body Slide In Patcher $205,000 Emerson Park Fitness Equipment $100,000 Meadow Park Par Course $20,000 Vista Lago Mini Park Playground $40,000 Meadow Park Pathways Maintenance $123,550 Traffic Safety Implementation $100,000 Meadow Park Irrigation $90,000 Proposed FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Supplemental Budget Page 6    New streetlights $75,000 2015 Traffic Safety Report Improvements $30,000 ADA Transition Plan Implementation $19,663 Elsfor Park Fence $15,000 Police Evidence Storage Building $5,000 Total 2,431,359 Proposed Supplemental/New Project Funding New and Additional Project Funding Budget Description Supplemental – Storm Drain Improvements on Bullock Lane $250,000 Project will replace of storm drain infrastructure on Bullock Lane which is at risk of failure and collapse. Supplemental - Swim Center Bath House Roof $60,000 Project will complete roof repairs due to more extensive damage and costs. New Project - Downtown Cleaning Equipment $150,000 Increases downtown cleanliness to support downtown vitality. New Project - Pedestrian Safety Improvements on Monterey at Buena Vista $30,000 Project to upgrade a pedestrian crossing near Apple Farm is a safety issue and is required by litigation. New Project - Replace City Hall Main Electrical Breaker $30,000 Project will replace an existing electrical disconnect that no longer functions. New Project - Pedestrian Crosswalk Beacon on Ramona $50,000 Project will replace failed hardware with a new system that is easier to maintain, more functional and will improve safety. New Project – Bicycle and Pedestrian Quick Build Projects $140,000 These projects will integrate pedestrian & bicycle improvements during neighborhood street paving. New Project – Vehicle Lift for Fleet Services $78,000 Project will replace the failed in-ground vehicle lifts used to maintain the City fleet vehicles and address safety issues. Supplemental - Neighborhood Traffic Improvements $75,000 Supports construction of a traffic circle improvements on Buchon to reduce vehicle speeds and enhance neighborhood safety Supplemental - Street Reconstruction and Resurfacing $137,000 Supports ADA improvements and pavement reconstruction on Nipomo Street from Buchon to Leff. Street Reconstruction and Resurfacing $(522,048) Project to support construction of the Orcutt/Tank Farm Roundabout. This reducing in LRM funding will be backfilled with SB1 Gas Tax funding. New Project - Orcutt/Tank Farm Roundabout Construction $522,048 Transfer of LRM funding to support construction of the Orcutt/Tank Farm Roundabout. Total $1,000,000 Proposed FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Supplemental Budget Page 7    FY 2020-21 Funding Summary The following table summarizes the total amount of Local Revenue Measure Funded projects recommended to proceed, as well as the total amount recommended for defunding. Within the Local Revenue Measure fund, an additional $1,000,000 is being recommended for new and existing projects. In total, staff is recommending a total amount of $1,631,196 be deferred and returned to the Local Revenue Measure fund balance. A full list of capital projects is provided in Attachment 1. Assessment Category Adopted Budget Actual Cost Remaining Budget Proceed: Construct in FY2020-21 $12,053,856 $4,025,579 $8,028,278 Proceed: Continue Planning/Design Only $1,597,767 $348,211 $1,249,555 Hold: Shovel Ready for Future Funding/Stimulus - Do Not Defund $1,343,706 $323,532 $1,020,174 Proceed Total $10,298,007 Defer: No Further Action this Fiscal Year - Defund $3,106,343 $674,983 $2,431,359 Completed: No Further Action this Fiscal Year - Defund $3,316,316 $3,116,478 $199,837 Defund Total $2,631,196 Additional Project Funding: Budget Transfers $(1,000,000) Remaining Total to Return to Fund Balance $1,631,196 Proposed FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Supplemental Budget Page 8    Chart 1 shows the original FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure uses as adopted in the 2019-21 Financial Plan. 9% 10% 5% 24% 20% 4% 11% 14% 3% FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Uses 1. Open Space Preservation 2. Bicycles and Pedestrian Improvements 3. Traffic Congestion Relief (Safety Improvements) 4. Public Safety 5. Neighborhood Street Paving 6. Code Enforcement 7. Flood Protection 8. Parks and Recreation/Senior Programs and Facilities 9. Other Vital Services and Capital Projects Proposed FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Supplemental Budget Page 9    Chart 2 shows the proposed reallocation of Local Revenue Measure uses for the 2020-21 Supplemental Budget. ATTACHMENT 1. List of Local Revenue Measure Projects 2% 14% 13% 30% 15% 3% 10% 11% 2% FY 2020-21 Local Revenue Measure Uses 1. Open Space Preservation 2. Bicycles and Pedestrian Improvements 3. Traffic Congestion Relief (Safety Improvements) 4. Public Safety 5. Neighborhood Street Paving 6. Code Enforcement 7. Flood Protection 8. Parks and Recreation/Senior Programs and Facilities 9. Other Vital Services and Capital Projects Attachment 1: Proposed FY 2020‐21 Local Revenue Measure Capital Projects      Attachment 1: Proposed FY 2020‐21 Local Revenue Measure Capital Projects      Attachment 1: Proposed FY 2020‐21 Local Revenue Measure Capital Projects   Attachment 1: Proposed FY 2020‐21 Local Revenue Measure Capital Projects    Attachment 1: Proposed FY 2020‐21 Local Revenue Measure Capital Projects