HomeMy WebLinkAbout01/16/1990, COMM.1 - POSSIBLE RECONSIDERATION OF COUNCIL DETERMINATION NOT TO ALLOW REMOVAL OF TWO MONTEREY PINE TREES A p MEETING DATE:
jll CIly Of San DAIS OBISO Jan. 16, 1990
P
COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT ITEM NUMB
FROM:
David F. Romero
Public Works Director
SUBJECT:
Possible Reconsideration of Council Determination Not to
Allow Removal of two Monterey Pine Trees at Chumash Village
Mobile Home Park, 3057 South Higuera Street
CAO RECOMMENDATION:
Consider a Request by Councilmember Roalman to Rehear the
Request to Remove the Two Pine Trees.
BACKGROUND:
At its meeting of September 19, 1989 the City Council considered
an appeal to the Tree Committee decision and staff recommendation
which would have allowed the removal of two Monterey pine trees
in Chumash Village. The Council upheld the appeal and denied the
removal of the trees. Since that time the Council has received a
letter from Richard M. Reppert, Chumash Board of Directors
President dated November 21, 1989 stating that the pine trees are
damaging private sewer lines. As such, Councilmember Roalman
would like to reconsider this item, and is asking Council to
refer this matter to staff for a scheduled public hearing.
Attachments:
1 - Staff report of 9/19/89
2 - Map
3 - Letter from Mr. Reppert
p:chumash
by
Coo. � - �
MEETING DATE.
City Of S 1 LUIS OBISpO Sept. 19, 1989
i COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT ITEM NUMBER
FROM:
David F. Romero Lane Wilsoj�`'Prepared by: Jack Brazeal
Public Works Director Parks & Buzldings Mgr. City Arborist
SUBJECT: .
Appeal of the San Luis Obispo Tree Committee'sdecision to allow
removal of -two Monterey Pine trees at Space#87, Chumash Village,
3057 South Higuera Street
CAO RECOMMENDATION:
Adopt resolution denying appeal of Donald Berry and support the Tree
Committee's decision to allow removal of the two Monterey Pine
trees at Space#87, Chumash Village, 3057 South Higuera Street,
California
BACKGROUND:
The Chumash Village Homeowners Association Inc. submitted an
application to the San Luis Obispo Tree Committee to remove three
Pine trees, one Canary Island Pine and two Monterey Pines on July 3,
1989 at Space #87, 3057 South Higuera Street, San Luis Obispo,
California (Exhibits A-1, A-2 and B) . Jack Brazeal reviewed the
request, visited the site and decided that the matter should be
decided on by the Tree Committee. (There ara h oo trees bo .t 1An
in diamQterand ahnut 15 f0Q1 tall Plant d in a three foot planting
strip .20 feet 19nW .
The Tree Committee reviewed the trees on site and at the August 14,
1989 meeting approved the removal of the two Monterey Pines and
required the retention of the Canary Island Pine (Exhibit C) .
Justification for the removals was that the Monterey_ Pines were
causing severe root damage to the parking lot; and, if the roots were
cut to.prevent this damage from reoccuring, the tree would become a
potential hazard to adjacent mobile homes. The Canary Island Pine
was causing no damage and is to be retained. On August 29, 1989,
Donald Berry appealed the decision (Exhibit D) .
Recommendation
Deny the appeal of Donald Berry and support the Tree Committee's
decision to allow removal of the two Monterey Pines and retention of
the Canary Island. Pine at Chumash Village, 3057 South' Higuera Street,
Space #87, San Luis Obispo, California.
Attachments: Resolution (to be delivered under separate cover)
Exhibit A-1 & A-2 - Maps
Exhibit B - Tree Removal. Application
Exhibit C - Minutes of Tree Committee, 8-14-89
Exhibit D - Appeal
b/agd-tcdecision
i
W .
LU
v. _,� ,�+^�+ �� " +'�-) �-�����`'�" I�=-�.<-+•{�'+- amu--..
I lava lava .ara , a� /A/1�$H DRIVE
• " " ` �-. . I L �--C1�-rte•-`�-.F��r� -.
�'
1 cwwE -
,..aL1`Mrr .•
it
ala �r.ACMJ`L � •i I �f � ��,�
LIJAFA 'Wee
r vS f 1
+l
" cUYAMAMJ • •'sr •,a,� �artwF ,
�1 = �L.�. � � ' ' I •ws fir_ ,•
I
V
EXHIBIT A-1
AAAI
VICINITY MAP TRACT 1476
C-S-S 1� ,•-
? I
C-S-S ' -
C—S—S
L "
s• _
a
,fir.-
a
C-S
i•�$i
XX
?Y4:i?:�:•:•:�:•:•i:<�ii�i:•:�ii:�:S>�ii::�::j�:ti;i'?;:;:•:r:tir+:'r`>::}::;:;:::i:``}>�:'::::
y
ON
:i>r:+S:tiC:::titin:•)''• y
v.ii::Y :f•isi'r}i':i?gift>`�?'r?�
ii:iCt�:4i:•>:?v:t•rr:•r:ti?ti•rnY?:<•r:.i�.; :.:::
!
{ t ;;..;
k
• V t -
a F YF+`: �'•': ?F'`rr:•.�:•:::..:::::::•:::::::.�:.�::::::. .iii::
OS-10
ii:v :•:.�R•:Gi�:tiirrii:4r:v i'7:': is
i T :a............:...:1
••
i is■
3 r •
O , u R I
O-5•std r a��, H J �. Q �' • O f
�-
w
C-S-S,� �Ju CZ
"� j'11"! }` ,tis i07 Q&,^, c
ej
EXHIBIT A-2
T_
HOMEChumash ' - VillageP.AK
I
I
City Council
City Hall
990 Palm St .
San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 November 21 , 1989
Gentlemen-
The Chumash .Village - Homeowner 's Association
respectfully request permission to remove two trees
on our property. Due to an ongoing sewer line blockage
problem we feel that this is imperative. The Association,
however, will see to it that these trees are replaced
. with others in a more suitable location.
Please be kind enough to include this item on
the next Agenda and inform us of the date of the meeting.
Respectfully yours ,
RECEIVED
NOV 2 71989
CITY CLERK Richard M: Reppert, President
SAN LUIS OBISPO,CA BOARD OF DIRECTORS
CHUMASH VILLAGE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC .
_ ;,y�WO �sL
J
. r Y/./'.cUnCl .
r! , Ao
'��N N.tiy
.. .I VCI,,rk-ori(.
X
/t P1 onl
i:✓ �. 'ROGER
3057 South Higuera Street / San Luis Obispo, California 93401 / (805) 543-4272