Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout06-17-2013 c12 johnson ave housing project ir contract amendmentcounctI âqenòâ Repopt Meeting Date June 77,2013 tem Nuhber C12 FROM: Prepared By: CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO Derek Johnson, Community Development Director Pam Ricci, Senior Planner SUBJECT:..SECOND AMENDMENT" TO AGREEMENT WITH RINCON CONSULTANTS, INC. REGARDING THE JOHNSON AVENUE HOUSING PROJECT ErR (ER s6-08) RECOMMENDATION Approve a "Second Amendment" to the existing agreement with Rincon Consultants, Inc. to prepare the Environmental Impact Report (EIR) in the amount of $16,350. DISCUSSION The applicant, San Luis Coastal Unified School District, has submitted project plans to develop 88 residential units in seven separate buildings on a 4.36-acre site on 1642 Johnson Avenue. On February 7, 2072, the City Council approved the workscope for EIR consultant services in connection with the project and authorized staff to send out Request for Proposal (RFP) documents to qualified consulting f,rrms. Part of the Council's action was to authorize the City Manager to award the EIR contract to a qualified consulting firm, contingent upon the developer depositing with the City the amount of the contract plus a 30Yo administrative fee. After a review of eight submitted proposals and interviews of the top three firms, Rincon Consultants, Inc. was selected to prepare the requested EIR. On April 18,2012, the School District deposited $115,617 to cover Rincon Consultants, Inc. costs for the consultant selices to prepare the EIR ($88,936), plus a 30Yo administrative fee ($26,681), with the administration of the consultant contract overseen by the Community Development Department, in conjunction with the Finance Department. 'Work on the Administrative Draft EIR began after the deposit of funds and final execution of the contract. Prior to the Draft EIR being released in February of 2013 for public review and comment, the School District suggested and the City concurred to put the EIR on hold and conduct a separate and more focused access and circulation study of the existing High School and surrounding street system. The intent is to identify any physical or operational changes that may improve current traffrc issues around the High School. The cost for the focused study was $24,589 which was paid by the applicant and processed as a "First Amendment" to the EIR contract with Rincon Consultants Inc. through a City Manager report approved on April I0,2013. The School District recently announced that regular bus service to the high school would be terminated starting with the next school term. Since this change in conditions was not known at the time that the original project description was developed to constitute baseline conditions, the impact of the termination of bus service on trip generation needs to be evaluated. The discussion of c12-1 Johnson Avenue Housing Project EIR Contract Amendment #2 Page 2 mitigation measures will be coordinated with the access and circulation study authorized with the "First Amendment" to the EIR contract. The total cost associated with the additional analysis as a "Second Amendment" to the EIR contract with Rincon Consultants Inc. is $16,350. Additional workscope items for EIRs routinely arise due to changes in conditions or input from public hearings. To maximize efficiency and continuity, contract amendments are handled by the same consultant originally selected to prepare the EIR, rather than going out for a competitive bid. Since the EIR contract was awarded to Rincon Consultants, Inc., the work items included in this additional analysis would be handled by them and ultimately incorporated into the EIR for which they have the special expertise and background to prepare. According to the purchasing policy contained in the Financial Management Manual on Page 255-2, the cumulative amount of amendments that the City Manager can authorize for consultant services is $25,000.00. Since the first contract amendment was already authorized by the City Manager on April 10, 2013 for $24,589, the additional $16,350 requested as part of this second amendment must be approved by the City Council. FISCAL IMPACT There would be no fiscal impact to the City since the developer would be funding the consultant costs. ALTERNATIVES Approve the additional analysis identified in the scope of work for the contract amendment, but direct staff to prepare it. If Rincon Consultants is not authorized to proceed with the additional analysis, City staff would be required to prepare it. City staff does not typically prepare EIRs because of the workload demands and expertise required beyond typical project processing commitments. Additional staff costs to handle this work would likely exceed the consultant costs. 2. Continue consideration of the contract amendment. The California Environmental Quality Act contains timelines for completion and certification of EIRs (Section 15108). Continuation would further delay the completion of the release of the Draft EIR that is eagerly anticipated by the City, applicant and surrounding neighborhood that have been actively involved in the review of the project. The project site is a desirable location for infill housing and was specifically identified as an appropriate site for residential development in the adopted Housing Element of the General Plan. ATTACHMENTS EIR Services Authorization Second Amendment to Agreement and original Consultant Agreement with attachments T:\Council Agenda Reports\21L 3\201 i-06-1 TVohnson Avenue Housing Project EIR Contract Amendment 2 (Johnson-Ricci)\ECAR Johnson Ayenue 1 1. 2. Housing Project EIR Contract Amendnent,docx c12-2 cúy ot sân Lurs ontspo envrRonmentâL R€vt€w s€pvtces authoptzÀtton PROJECT TITLE: Johnson Avenue Housing Project EIR (Specification No. 91146) APPLICANT: San Luis Coastal Unified School District APPLICANT ADDRESS: 1642 Johnson Avenue, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Develop the property with a residential project consisting of 88 units in seven separate buildings on 4.36-acre site (ER 56-08). PROCESSING FEES lSecond dment to EIR Aqreementl: 1. Consultant Fee (Firm:Rincon Consultants, lnc.) (Revenue Account 600-2472) $16,350 I 2. Administration Fee (30% of Consultant Fee) (Revenue Account 1 00-45480) 3. Report Reproduction Fee/Advertising Fee (Revenue Account 1 00-45480) $0 $o $o4. Other Fees (Specify: 5. Total Fees.$ 16.350 Authorization and Assurances The cost to the applicant for consultant services (as stated in line 5 above) is based on the total cost included in the consultant's proposal for preparation of the analysis of the termination of regular bus service for the high school in conjunction with the focused circulation study of the high school and the Johnson Avenue Housing Project ElR, as detailed in Exhibit "A". Date Derek Johnson, Community Development Director As applicant for this project, I hereby accept the fees for the additional Environmental lmpact Repoft (ElR) study and agree to deposit with the City of San Luis Obispo Community Development Department, the amount shown on line 5 above. Upon receipt of this sum, the Community Development Director is authorized to employ a qualified consultant to complete the study. C.M. Florence, representative for San Luis Coastal Unified School District Date c12-3 SECOND AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT This Second Amendment to Agreement is entered into this day of June, 2013, by and between the CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO, a municipal corporation, hereinafter referred to as "City", and RINCON CONSULTANTS, lNC., hereafter referred to as "Consultant." WITNESSETH WHEREAS, on April 19,2012, the parties entered into an Agreement concerning the preparation of an Environmental lmpact Repoft (ElR) per Specification No. 91146; and WHEREAS, the City and the project applicant concluded that additional analysis is needed to evaluate the impacts of the termination of regular high school bus service as part of the overall EIR contract; and WHEREAS, the City and Consultant seek to modify certain provisions of the Agreement between them. NOW, THEREFORE, City and Consultant mutually agree as follows: 1. Section 3 (City's Obligations) of the Agreement is modified to acknowledge preparation of an analysis of the termination of regular high school bus service and associated modifications to the Draft EIR (City File No. 56-08). 2. The Scope of Work (Exhibit A) to the Agreement is modified to provide for payment in an amount not to exceed $16,350 for work performed by the consultant from the effective date of this Second Amendment to Agreement through the completion of the EIR contract, as shown on the attached Exhibit B. 3. This Second Amendment to Agreement shall be effective June 18,2013. 4. All other terms and conditions of the Agreement remain unchanged. lN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this instrument to be executed the day and year first above written. CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO CONSULTANT By Michael Codron, Asst. City Manager Stephen Svete, Vice President Rincon Consultants, lnc. ATTEST:APPROVED AS TO FORM: Maeve Kennedy Grimes, City Clerk J. Christine Dietrick, City Attorney c12-4 ß THIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into in the City of San Luis Obispo on this by and between the CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO, a municipal corporation, hereinafter referred to as City, and RINCON CONSULTANTS, INC., hereinafter referred to as Consultant. WITNESSETH: V/HEREAS, on February 13, 2012, the City requested proposals for the preparation of an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) per Specification No. 91146. WHEREAS, pursuant to said request for proposals, Consultant submitted a proposal that was accepted by City for said EIR services. NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of their mutual promises, obligations and covenants hereinafter contained, the parties hereto agree as follows: l. TERM. The term of this Agreement shall be from the date this Agreement is made and entered, as first written above, until acceptance or completion ofsaid EIR services. 2' INCORPORATION BY REFERENCE. City Specification No. 91146 (Exhibit A) and Consultant's Proposal dated March 14, 2012 (Exhibit B), are hereby incorporated in and made a part of this Agreement. 3. CITYTS OBLIGATIONS. For providing EIR services as specified in this Agreement, City agrees to cooperate with Consultant in the completion of the work described in Exhibit B (Consultant's Proposal) attached hereto and incorporated by reference. City will pay, and Consultant shall receive, payments in accordance with Exhibit C (Compensation Schedule), attached hereto and incorporated by reference. 4. CONSULTANT'S OBLIGATIONS, For and in consideration of the payments and agreements hereinbefore mentioned to be made and performed by City, Consultant agrees with City to provide all specified services as described in Exhibit B (Consultant's Proposal) attached hereto and incorporated into this Agreement by reference. Consultant may not amend the Scope of Work, either to modify provisions or to add or delete provisions, without the prior written consent of the City's pioject Manager, c12-5 ( ,-- Consultant Agreement Page2 5' AMENDMENTS. Any amendment, modification or variation from the terms of this Agreement shall be in writing and shall be effective only upon approval by the Community Development Director of the City. 6. COMPLETE AGREEMENT. This written Agreement, including all writings specifically incorporated herein by reference, shall constitute the complete agreement between the parties hereto. No oral agreement, understanding, or representation not reduced to writing and specifically incorporated herein shall be of any force or effect, nor shall any such oral agreement, understanding, or representation be binding upon the parties hereto. 7. NOTICE. A1l written notices to the parties hereto shall be sent by United States mail, postage prepaid byregistered or ce¡tified mail addressed as follows: , City Pam Ricci, Project Manager Community Development Departrnent City of San Luis Obispo 919 Palm Street San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 Consultant Stephen Svete, Vice President Rincon Consultants, Inc. 180 N. Ashwood Avenue Ventura, CA 93003 8. AUTHORITY TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT. Both City and Consultant do covenant that each individual executing this agreement on behalf of each party is a person duly authorized and empowered to execute Agreements for such party. IN V/ITNESS 'WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this instrument to be executed the day and year fust above w¡itten. ATTEST: CITY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO, A Municipal Corporation Sheryll Clerk Katie Manager APPROVED AS TO CONSUL Õ By Dietrick, City Attorney Svete, c12-6 fttlt0fl Rincon Consultants, lnc. 1530 Monterey Street, Suite D San Luis 0bispo, California 93401 so5 547 0900 FAX 547 0901 inf o@rinconconsultants.com www. rinconconsultants,com May 20,2013 Job No, 12-69280 Pam Ricci, Senior Planner City of San Luis Obispo Community Development Department 990 Palm Street San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 SUBJECT: Johnson Avenue Housing EIR Request for Fee Authorization for Additional Tasks Dear Ms. Ricci The purpose of this letter is to request authorization of additional fees for environmental review services that exceed those included in the April 20, 2012 contract scope of work for Johnson Avenue Housing ElR, as amended. With this revised scope of work, Rincon Consultants will oversee preparation of a revised traffic analysis to be prepared by Kittelson and Associates, lnc. (KAl) to address the discontinuation of bus service to San Luis Obispo High School beginning in fall 2013. Rincon Consultants will also update other analysis in the EIR for consistency with the revised traffic study. Revrsed Scope of Work tor Additional laslrs Task 1. Revise EIR Traffic Study and lmpact Analysis, KAI will revise the EIR Traffic Study to include an evaluation of a new "Near-term" scenario that addresses the discontinuation of bus service to San Luis Obispo High School in the ¡¡ear 2014. KAI willcoordinate with City staff to determine how many new schooltrips would be created in this scenario, as well as other trips from nearby development projects anticipated to be operational in this timeframe. These additional trips will be added to the existing traffic counts to identify the near-term scenario baseline. KAI will apply estimates of the project's trip generation levels and the directional distribution of the project's traffic from the Administrative Draft EIR Traffic Analysis to evaluate near-term plus project conditions. KAI will determine the AM and PM peak hour levels of service for the study intersections and roadway facilities. Project impacts and mitigation measures for the near-term scenario will be identified. The discussion of mitigation measures will be coordinated with the Access and Circulation Plan. KAI will also revise the Traffic Study cumulative baseline and cumulative plus pro¡ect scenario analyses to address the additional trips that would result from discontinuation of bus service to the high school. KAI will determine the AM and PM peak hour levels of service for the study intersections and roadway facilities for these scenarios. As with the near-term scenario, project impacts and mitigation measures for the cumulative scenario will be identified, and the discussion of mitigation measures will be coordinated with the Access and Circulation Plan. The Draft Revised Traffic Study will be submitted to City staff for review and comment, and a Final Revised Traffic Study will be prepared. Rincon Consultants will incorporate the Final Revised Traffic Study into the EIR Transportation and Circulation impact section. Environmental Scientists Planners ,"ß1,L7'= City of San Luis Obispo Johnson Avenue Housing EIR Page 2 Task 2. Revise EIR Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Noise, and Alternatives Analyses. Based on the Revised Traffic Study, Rincon Consultants will update the EIR Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Noise and Alternatives analyses. This will include updating the CalEEMod criteria air pollutant emissions modeling and greenhouse gas emissions operational modeling for the project, as well as the operational noise modeling for receptors along study area roadway segments. The EIR impact analyses and mitigation measures will be verified and/or modified as necessary to reflect the updated traffic analysis. ln addition, the traffic, air quality, greenhouse gas emissions, and noise impact discussions in the Alternatives section will be updated to reflect the revised traffic information. Proiect Manaqement. Rincon will oversee completion of the Revised Traffic Study, including subconsultant management and invoicing. This scope of work includes Rincon attendance at one additional project meeting Schedule The Draft Revised Traffic Study will be submitted within two weeks after written authorization to proceed and verification and consensus of the total number of added vehicle trips and their distribution. The Final Revised Traffic Study will be submitted within ten days from receipt of a single non-conflicting set of comments. The revised Administrative Draft EIR will be submitted within two weeks of completion of the Final Revised Traffic Study. Fee Estimate As shown on the attached spreadsheet, we are estimating fees in the amount of $'16,350 to complete this revised scope of work. These fees will be billed on a time and materials basis and in accordance with the terms of our existing contract with the City. Thank you for your consideration of this request to provide additional environmental consulting services for this project. Please call Richard Daulton directly if you have any questions or need any additional information. Sincerely, RINCON CONSULTANTS, INC. Principal Stephen Svete, Al P, LEED AP Vice President EnvironmentaÌ Scientists Planners " " Gtr?8. " City of San Luis Obispo Johnson Avenue Housing EIR Cosf Eslimafe City of San Luis Obispo Johnson Avenue Housing EIR Page 3 Revised 5/20/20 13 Environmental Scientists Planners Rincon Consultants Tasks (Base Fee)Cost R¡ncon Låbor Hours Sr Prircipal $210/hour Prol MSr $170ih¡ Assl Prcj Mgr $105/hd¡ Asw $90/hour Graphics $85/hour C lsicãl 555/hour BASE FEE 1. Prcjecl lnítiation 1 '1 KickoflVeeling and Dab Collecton/úerifcaüon 1 2 No[ce ofPreparaüon '1 3 Smping Meeting 2 Adn¡nislralive Drafl EIR 2 1 DratProþctDescriplion and EIR Ouüine 2 2 Developmnl of Project AlÞrnaüves 2 3 Adminisfalive DrafrElR Analysis 22l ExecutiveSumry 2 2 2 lnüoducton, Project Descripbon, and Environmnbl Seüing 2 2 3 Environmnhllmpact and i\¡itgaton l\¡easures a Aeslhel¡s (Rincon Labor OnM b Greenhouse Gas Emlslons c Noise d. Transpotlal¡on/ÍraÍf¡c (R¡ncon Labor )nly) Transpodalion/Traftic (Rincon Conling Release J anuary 201 3) e Effecls Found Nol lo Be Sign¡frcanl 234 AlÞrnalives(4) 2 3 5 Oher CEQA-Required Secdons Reviæd lmpact Analysis b Address Revised Tralic St¡dy (May 2013) 2 4 DraflMilìgaiìon l\.4onibring and Reporüng Program 2 5 Screencheck DratElR (New Task, Conling Release January 2013) 3. Drâft EIR Prcparation and Publicalion 4 FinalElRPrcparat¡on 4 1 Response b Comrenb/Administalive FinalElR 4 2 Finall\,1iügalion [.rlonibring and Reporling Program 4 3 Publ¡caüon ofhe F¡nal EIR 5. Preparc CEQA F¡nd¡ngs and Statenenl ol Oveniding Consideratíons 6. Staff Meelíngs (4) 7. Publ¡c Heailngs (4) P rojecl M an agemenuj oodin alio n Projecl Managenenl (Addilional, Aptil 2013) Proied Manaoemenl lAddil¡onel Mev ?0131 $1,685 $3,120 $3,370 $2,045 $1,310 $2,180 $3,300 $435 $5,930 $615 $2,785 $3,200 $970 $275 $1,21 0 $1,525 $740 $670 $1,135 $3,555 $380 $1,170 $2,965 $1,470 $3,670 $'1,780 $775 $'1.285 7 12 16 29 31 20 10 22 31 4 6 31 ¿o 10 5 I 't5 7 31 3 13 24 I 2 10 1 ,| 1 2 2 1 2 4 2 4 1 6 1 6 4 1 1 1 1 2 2 1 6 4 2 4 2 4 4 I I I I 16 I 2 12 l8 4 6 2 2 6 2 4 4 2 2 4 4 1 2 1 3 4 2 1 4 1 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 Slhinhl I abor lBase Fecì s53 550 461 15 106 153 118 45 34 Add¡t¡onal Costs (Base Fee) Bob Carr - Aesüìelic Sbdy and Two Visual Simulalions Kilelson & Associabs, lnc - Trafrc SUdy & Associabs, lnc - High SchoolAæss and Circulalion Pian I Project lniü?ûon and Dah Collecton 2 Exisling and Fuure Condilions 3 Ev¿luabPoÞnliallmprovemnb 4 DrafrAæess and C¡rculaton Plan 5 Final Aæess and Circulaüon Plan 6 Two TeamMeelings Subbhl & Asciaþs, lnc - Additionâl Analysis br Bus Seruiæ lssue (May 2013) (5 cop¡es ADEIR, 35 æpÌes DEIR, 35 copies..lLnal qß) & Adrinisfative & Admnisfalive (Addilional, Conüng Release January 2013) & Adminishatìve (Addilional, April 2013) Kiüelson & AssociaÞs, lnc - Additional Analysis (Contng Release January 2013) and [.rliscellaneous Expenses 173 $263 $3,360 $1,484 $2,754 $6,608 $6,000 $21,755 $1,756 $5,526 $3,321 $22,399 $7,730 Subbbl Addifonal Cosb lBase Fee)$98.728 TOTAL LABOR +ADDITIONAL COSTS $129,879 PREVIOUS TOTAL $r13,526 ADDITIONAL FEES MAY 2013 Opt¡onal Tasks $r6,350 Cost Rinæn Allendance: Each Add¡l¡onal Meelina or Heatinq $1.000/e¿ E " ß1,2-9, . RINCON CONSULTANTS, INC. Standard Fee Schedule for Environmental, Biological, and Planning Services Rincon Consultants' fee schedule is based on the time that is charged to projects by our professionals and support staff. Direct costs associated with completing a project are also billed to the project as outlined under Reimbursable Expenses below. The following sets forth the billing rates for our personnel. Professional and Technical Personnel Principal II/ Program Manager Rate $ 210/hour $ 180/hour $ 95lhour $ 8S/hour $ 60lhour Principal I / Pr o gr am / Project Manager Senior Supervising Environmental Scientist/Planner/Biologist II $ 155/hour Supervising Environmental Scientist/Planner/Biologist I......... $ 145/hour Senior Environmental Scientist/ Planner/ Biologist II $ 135/hour $ 120/hourSenior Environmental Scientist/ Planner/ Biologist I......... Environmental Scientist /Planner/Biologist III................ .......... $ 105/hour Environmental Scientist/ Planner/ Biologist II Environmental Field 4ide............ ....... $ S5/hour Environmental Scientist / Plarner / Biolo gist I.. ......... Environmental Technician Senior GIS Specialist GIS Specialist/CAD Specialist... Graphic Designer Clerical/ Administrative Professional. ............. Production Technician. Technical Editor.......... $ 105/hour $ 8S/hour fi 75/hour $ 85/hour $ 65lhour $ 65lhour Expert witness services consisting of depositions and in-court testimony are charged at a rate of fi295/hour. Photocop]¡ing and Printing Photocopies will be charged at a rate of $0.08/copy for single-sided copies and $0.16 for double-sided copies. Colored copies will be charged at a rate of $1.00/copy for single-sided and fi2.00/ copy for double-sided or 11"x17" copies. Oversized maps or display graphics will be charged at a rate of $8.00/square foot. Reimbursable Expenses Expenses associated with completing a project are termed Reimbursable Expenses. These expenses do not include the hourly billing rates described above. Reimbursable expenses include, but are not limited to, the following: 7. Direct costs associøted with the ü.ecution of ø project are billed at cost plus 75% to couer Generøl ønd Administrøtiae seruices. Direct costs include, but øre not limited to, laboratory ønd drilling seraices chørges, subcontrøctor seraices, authorized traael expenses, permit charges andfilingfees, printing ønd grøphic charges, møilings and postage, perþ rental other than coaeredby the aboue charges, etc. es (including PDAs, cell phones, phone, fax, and elec processing, etc.) øre billed øt 3% of totøI labor. 2. Vehicle use in company-ownedaehicles willbebilled ø cle use and $735 per day for 4-IND off-road aehicle use, plus For transportation in employee-cruned automobiles, a rate will be billed at cost plus 1.5%. April2013 E nv i r o n m e ntal S c i e n tis t s P I a n n e r s E n c in, öìZ-lO RINCON CONSULTANTS, INC. Equipment Schedule for Environmental, Biological, and Planning Services Bailer $zs Day Brass Sample Sleeves $ro Each DC Pulge $ss Duy Disposable Bailer $20 Each Flame Ionization Detector $ 2oo Duy Four Gas Monitor $ 120 Duy Hand Auger Sarnpler $ss Duy Level C Health and Safety $oo Person per day Oil-Water Interface Probe $as Doy Photo-Ionization Detector $ 120 Duy Soil Vapor Extraction Monitoring Equipment $ r¿o Day Water Level Indicator $es Duy Water Resources Dissolved Oxygen Meter $+s Day Refractolleter (salinity)$so Duy Sterilized San-rple Jar $s Each Temp-pH-Conductivity Meter $so Duy Turbiclity Meter $go Duy Biological Field Equipment $e0 Duy Infrared Sensor Digital Camera $50 Day Field Equipment Package, amphibian survey (digital camera, GPS, thermorneter, clecon chlorine, waders, float tube, hand net)$ 150 Duy Fielcl Equipment Package, construction monitoring (digital camera, GPS, thern'rometer, binoculars, field computer, safety equipment)$ss Duy Field Equipment Package, standard (digital camera, GPS, thermorneter, binoculars, and botanic collecting equipment)$+s Duy Field Equipment Package, remote (digital camera, GPS, thermometer, binoculars, field computer and mifi, Delorme Satellite Beacon, 24-I].o:ur SafeW Phone) $ 125 Duy Laser Rangefinder/ Altitude $ro Duy Mammal trap,latge / small $f .SO / $O.SO Each per trap cycle Minnow trap $ss Each per job Net hand / large seine $ rol$so Day Pettersson Bat Ultrasound Detector/ Recording Equipment $ 150 Iob Pit-fall Trap $ S Each per trap cycle Scent Station $zo Station Spotlight $s Day Trimble@ GPS (subrneter accuracy)$ rso Job Spotting Scope $ 150 Job Multi-Services Field Equipment Anemorneter $s Day Con'rputer Field Equipment $¿s Day GPS unif standard field $ro Day Offroad 4x4 Mule $zs Day Sound Level Meter Duy$so April2013 E nvir o nm e ntal Scientists Planners Ensineers- c12-11 Page i ntentiona I ly left blank. c12-12